首页 >出版文学> The Spirit of Laws>第41章
  WhiletheStoicslookeduponriches,humangrandeur,grief,disquietudes,andpleasuresasvanity,theywereentirelyemployedinlabouringforthehappinessofmankind,andinexercisingthedutiesofsociety。Itseemsasiftheyregardedthatsacredspirit,whichtheybelievedtodwellwithinthem,asakindoffavourableprovidencewatchfuloverthehumanrace。
  Bornforsociety,theyallbelievedthatitwastheirdestinytolabourforit;withsomuchthelessfatigue,theirrewardswereallwithinthemselves。Happybytheirphilosophyalone,itseemedasifonlythehappinessofotherscouldincreasetheirs。
  11。OfContemplation。Menbeingmadetopreserve,tonourish,toclothethemselves,anddoalltheactionsofsociety,religionoughtnottogivethemtoocontemplativealife。[7]
  TheMahometansbecomespeculativebyhabit;theyprayfivetimesaday,andeachtimetheyareobligedtocastbehindthemeverythingwhichhasanyconcernwiththisworld:thisformsthemforspeculation。Addtothisthatindifferenceforallthingswhichisinspiredbythedoctrineofunalterablefate。
  Ifothercausesbesidestheseconcurtodisengagetheiraffections;forinstance,iftheseverityofthegovernment,ifthelawsconcerningthepropertyofland,givethemaprecariousspirit——allislost。
  ThereligionoftheGaursformerlyrenderedPersiaaflourishingkingdom;itcorrectedthebadeffectsofdespoticpower。ThesameempireisnowdestroyedbytheMahometanreligion。
  12。OfPenances。Penancesoughttobejoinedwiththeideaoflabour,notwiththatofidleness;withtheideaofgood,notwiththatofsupereminence;withtheideaoffrugality,notwiththatofavarice。
  13。OfinexpiableCrimes。Itappearsfroma。passageofthebooksofthepontiffs,quotedbyCicero,[8]thattheyhadamongtheRomansinexpiablecrimes:[9]anditisonthisthatZozymusfoundsthenarrationsopropertoblackenthemotivesofConstantine’sconversion;andJulian,thatbitterrailleryonthisconversioninhisC?sars。
  ThePaganreligionindeed,whichprohibitedonlysomeofthegrossercrimes,andwhichstoppedthehandbutmeddlednotwiththeheart,mighthavecrimesthatwereinexpiable;butareligionwhichbridlesallthepassions;whichisnotmorejealousofactionsthanofthoughtsanddesires;whichholdsusnotbyafewchainsbutbyaninfinitenumberofthreads;which,leavinghumanjusticeaside,establishesanotherkindofjustice;whichissoorderedastoleaduscontinuallyfromrepentancetolove,andfromlovetorepentance;whichputsbetweenthejudgeandthecriminalagreatermediator,betweenthejustandthemediatoragreatjudge——areligionlikethisoughtnottohaveinexpiablecrimes。
  Butwhileitgivesfearandhopetoall,itmakesussufficientlysensiblethatthoughthereisnocrimeinitsownnatureinexpiable,yetawholecriminallifemaybeso;thatitisextremelydangeroustoaffrontmercybynewcrimesandnewexpiations;thatanuneasinessonaccountofancientdebts,fromwhichweareneverentirelyfree,oughttomakeusafraidofcontractingnewones,offillingupthemeasure,andgoingeventothatpointwherepaternalgoodnessislimited。
  14。InwhatMannerReligionhasanInfluenceonCivilLaws。Asbothreligionandthecivillawsoughttohaveapeculiartendencytorendermengoodcitizens,itisevidentthatwhenoneofthesedeviatesfromthisend,thetendencyoftheotheroughttobestrengthened。Thelessseveritythereisinreligion,themorethereoughttobeinthecivillaws。
  ThusthereigningreligionofJapanhavingfewdoctrines,andproposingneitherfuturerewardsnorpunishments,thelawstosupplythesedefectshavebeenmadewiththespiritofseverity,andareexecutedwithanextraordinarypunctuality。
  Whenthedoctrineofnecessityisestablishedbyreligion,thepenaltiesofthelawsoughttobemoresevere,andthemagistratemorevigilant;
  totheendthatmenwhowouldotherwisebecomeabandonedmightbedeterminedbythesemotives;butitisquiteotherwisewherereligionhasestablishedthedoctrineofliberty。
  FromtheinactivityofthesoulspringstheMahometandoctrineofpredestination,andfromthisdoctrineofpredestinationspringstheinactivityofthesoul。This,theysay,isinthedecreesofGod;theymustthereforeindulgetheirrepose。Inacaselikethis,themagistrateoughttowakenbythelawsthosewhoarelulledasleepbyreligion。
  Whenreligioncondemnsthingswhichthecivillawsoughttopermit,thereisdangerlestthecivillaws,ontheotherhand,shouldpermitwhatreligionoughttocondemn。Eitheroftheseisaconstantproofofawantoftrueideasofthatharmonyandproportionwhichoughttosubsistbetweenboth。
  ThustheTartarsunderJenghizKhan,[10]amongwhomitwasasinandevenacapitalcrimetoputaknifeinthefire,toleanagainstawhip,tostrikeahorsewithhisbridle,tobreakonebonewithanother,didnotbelieveittobeanysintobreaktheirword,toseizeuponanotherman’sgoods,todoaninjurytoaperson,ortocommitmurder。Inaword,lawswhichrenderthatnecessarywhichisonlyindifferenthavethisinconvenience,thattheymakethosethingsindifferentwhichareabsolutelynecessary。
  ThepeopleofFormosabelieve[11]thatthereisakindofhell,butitistopunishthosewhoatcertainseasonshavenotgonenaked,whohavedressedincalicoandnotinsilk,whohavepresumedtolookforoysters,orwhohaveundertakenanybusinesswithoutconsultingthesongofbirds;whiledrunkennessanddebaucheryarenotregardedascrimes。
  Theybelieveeventhatthedebauchesoftheirchildrenareagreeabletotheirgods。
  Whenreligionabsolvesthemindbyathingmerelyaccidental,itlosesitsgreatestinfluenceonmankind。ThepeopleofIndiabelievethatthewatersoftheGangeshaveasanctifyingvirtue。[12]Thosewhodieonitsbanksareimaginedtobeexemptedfromthetormentsoftheotherlife,andtobeentitledtodwellinaregionfullofdelights;andforthisreasontheashesofthedeadaresentfromthemostdistantplacestobethrownintothisriver。Littlethendoesitsignifywhethertheyhadlivedvirtuouslyornot,sotheybebutthrownintotheGanges。
  Theideaofaplaceofrewardshasanecessaryconnectionwiththeideaoftheabodesofmisery;andwhentheyhopefortheformerwithoutfearingthelatter,thecivillawshavenolongeranyinfluence。Menwhothinkthemselvessureoftherewardsoftheotherlifeareabovethepowerofthelegislator;theylookupondeathwithtoomuchcontempt。
  Howshallthemanberestrainedbylawswhobelievesthatthegreatestpainthemagistratecaninflictwillendinamomenttobeginhishappiness?
  15。HowfalseReligionsaresometimescorrectedbytheCivilLaws。
  Simplicity,superstition,orarespectforantiquityhavesometimesestablishedmysteriesorceremoniesshockingtomodesty:ofthistheworldhasfurnishednumerousexamples。Aristotlesays[13]thatinthiscasethelawpermitsthefathersoffamiliestorepairtothetempletocelebratethesemysteriesfortheirwivesandchildren。Howadmirablethecivillawwhichinspiteofreligionpreservesthemannersuntainted!
  Augustus[14]excludedtheyouthofeithersexfromassistingatanynocturnalceremony,unlessaccompaniedbyamoreagedrelative;andwhenherevivedtheLupercalia,[15]hewouldnotallowtheyoungmentorunnaked。
  16。HowtheLawsofReligioncorrecttheInconveniencesofapoliticalConstitution。Ontheotherhand,religionmaysupportastatewhenthelawsthemselvesareincapableofdoingit。
  Thuswhenakingdomisfrequentlyagitatedbycivilwars,religionmaydomuchbyobligingonepartofthestatetoremainalwaysquiet。AmongtheGreeks,theEleans,aspriestsofApollo,livedalwaysinpeace。InJapan,[16]thecityofMeacoenjoysaconstantpeace,asbeingaholycity。Religionsupportsthisregulation,andthatempire,whichseemstobealoneuponearth,andwhichneitherhasnorwillhaveanydependenceonforeigners,hasalwaysinitsownbosomatradewhichwarcannotruin。
  Inkingdomswherewarsarenotentereduponbyageneralconsent,andwherethelawshavenotpointedoutanymeanseitherofterminatingorpreventingthem,religionestablishestimesofpeace,orcessationfromhostilities,thatthepeoplemaybeabletosowtheircornandperformthoseotherlabourswhichareabsolutelynecessaryforthesubsistenceofthestate。
  EveryyearallhostilityceasesbetweentheArabiantribesforfourmonths:theleastdisturbancewouldthenbeanimpiety。[17]Informertimes,wheneverylordinFrancedeclaredwarorpeace,religiongrantedatruce,whichwastotakeplaceatcertainseasons。
  17。ThesameSubjectcontinued。Whenastatehasmanycausesforhatred,religionoughttoproducemanywaysofreconciliation。TheArabs,apeopleaddictedtorobbery,arefrequentlyguiltyofdoinginjuryandinjustice。Mahometenactedthislaw:[18]"Ifanyoneforgivesthebloodofhisbrother,[19]hemaypursuethemalefactorfordamagesandinterest;buthewhoshallinjurethewicked,afterhavingreceivedsatisfaction,shall,inthedayofjudgment,sufferthemostgrievoustorments。"
  TheGermansinheritedthehatredandenmityoftheirnearrelatives:butthesewerenoteternal。Homicidewasexpiatedbygivingacertainnumberofcattle,andallthefamilyreceivedsatisfaction:athingextremelyuseful,saysTacitus,becauseenmitiesaremostdangerousamongafreepeople。[20]Ibelieve,indeed,thattheirministersofreligion,whowereheldbytheminsomuchcredit,wereconcernedinthesereconciliations。
  AmongtheinhabitantsofMalacca,[21]wherenoformofreconciliationisestablished,hewhohascommittedmurder,certainofbeingassassinatedbytherelativesorfriendsofthedeceased,abandonshimselftofury,andwoundsorkillsallhemeets。
  18。HowtheLawsofReligionhavetheEffectofCivilLaws。ThefirstGreeksweresmallnations,frequentlydispersed,piratesatsea,unjustonland,withoutgovernmentandwithoutlaws。ThemightyactionsofHerculesandTheseusletusseethestateofthatrisingpeople。Whatcouldreligiondomoretoinspirethemwithhorroragainstmurder?Itdeclaredthatthemanwhohadbeenmurderedwasenragedagainsttheassassin,thathewouldpossesshismindwithterrorandtrouble,andobligehimtoyieldtohimtheplaceshehadfrequentedwhenalive。[22]
  Theycouldnottouchthecriminal,norconversewithhim,withoutbeingdefiled:[23]themurdererwastobeexpelledfromthecity,andanexpiationmadeforthecrime。[24]
  19。ThatitisnotsomuchtheTruthorFalsityofaDoctrinewhichrendersitusefulorpernicioustoMenincivilGovernment,astheUseorAbuseofit。Themosttrueandholydoctrinesmaybeattendedwiththeveryworstconsequenceswhentheyarenotconnectedwiththeprinciplesofsociety:andonthecontrary,doctrinesthemostfalsemaybeattendedwithexcellentconsequenceswhencontrivedsoastobeconnectedwiththeseprinciples。
  ThereligionofConfuciusdisownstheimmortalityofthesoul:andthesectofZenodidnotbelieveit。Thesetwosectshavedrawnfromtheirbadprinciplesconsequences,notjustindeed,butmostadmirableastotheirinfluenceonsociety。ThoseofthereligionofTao,andofFoe,[25]believetheimmortalityofthesoul;butfromthissacreddoctrinetheydrawthemostfrightfulconsequences。
  Thedoctrineoftheimmortalityofthesoulfalselyunderstoodhas,almostineverypartoftheglobeandineveryage,engagedwomen,slaves,subjects,friends,tomurderthemselves,thattheymightgoandserveintheotherworldtheobjectoftheirrespectorloveinthis。
  ThusitwasintheWestIndies;thusitwasamongtheDanes;[26]thusitisatpresentinJapan,[27]inMacassar,[28]andmanyotherplaces。
  Thesecustomsdonotsodirectlyproceedfromthedoctrineoftheimmortalityofthesoulasfromthatoftheresurrectionofthebody,whencetheyhavedrawnthisconsequence,thatafterdeaththesameindividualwillhavethesamewants,thesamesentiments,thesamepassions。Inthispointofview,thedoctrineoftheimmortalityofthesoulhasaprodigiouseffectonmankind;becausetheideaofonlyasimplechangeofhabitationismorewithinthereachofthehumanunderstanding,andmoreadaptedtoflattertheheart,thantheideaofanewmodification。
  Itisnotenoughforreligiontoestablishadoctrine;itmustalsodirectitsinfluence。ThistheChristianreligionperformsinthemostadmirablemanner,particularlywithregardtothedoctrinesofwhichwehavebeenspeaking。Itmakesushopeforastatewhichistheobjectofourbelief;notforastatewhichwehavealreadyexperiencedorknown:
  thuseveryarticle,eventheresurrectionofthebody,leadsustospiritualideas。
  20。ThesameSubjectcontinued。Thesacredbooks[29]oftheancientPersianssay,"Ifyouwouldbeholyinstructyourchildren,becauseallthegoodactionswhichtheyperformwillbeimputedtoyou。"Theyadvisethemtomarrybetimes,becausechildrenatthedayofjudgmentwillbeasabridge,overwhichthosewhohavenonecannotpass。Thesedoctrineswerefalse,butextremelyuseful。
  21。OftheMetempsychosis。Thedoctrineoftheimmortalityofthesoulisdividedintothreebranches——thatofpureimmortality,thatofasimplechangeofhabitation,andthatofametempsychosis,thatis,thesystemoftheChristians,thatoftheScythians,andthatoftheIndians。Wehavejustbeenspeakingofthefirsttwo,andIshallsayofthelastthatasithasbeenwellorillexplained,ithashadgoodorbadeffects。Asitinspiresmenwithacertainhorroragainstbloodshed,veryfewmurdersarecommittedintheIndies;andthoughtheyseldompunishwithdeath,yettheyenjoyaperfecttranquillity。
  Ontheotherhand,womenburnthemselvesatthedeathoftheirhusbands;
  thusitisonlytheinnocentwhosufferaviolentdeath。
  22。ThatitisdangerousforReligiontoinspireanAversionforThingsinthemselvesindifferent。AkindofhonourestablishedintheIndiesbytheprejudicesofreligionhasmadetheseveraltribesconceiveanaversionagainsteachother。Thishonourisfoundedentirelyonreligion;thesefamilydistinctionsformnocivildistinctions;thereareIndianswhowouldthinkthemselvesdishonouredbyeatingwiththeirking。
  Thesesortsofdistinctionsareconnectedwithacertainaversionforothermen,verydifferentfromthosesentimentswhichnaturallyarisefromdifferenceofrank;whichamonguscomprehendsaloveforinferiors。
  Thelawsofreligionshouldneverinspireanaversiontoanythingbutvice,andabovealltheyshouldneverestrangemanfromaloveandtendernessforhisownspecies。
  TheMahometanandIndianreligionsembraceaninfinitenumberofpeople;
  theIndianshatetheMahometans,becausetheyeatcows;theMahometansdetesttheIndiansbecausetheyeathogs。
  23。OfFestivals。Whenreligionappointsacessationfromlabouritoughttohaveagreaterregardtothenecessitiesofmankindthantothegrandeurofthebeingitdesignstohonour。
  Athenswassubjecttogreatinconveniencesfromtheexcessivenumberofitsfestivals。[30]Thesepowerfulpeople,towhosedecisionallthecitiesofGreececametosubmittheirquarrels,couldnothavetimetodespatchsuchamultiplicityofaffairs。
  WhenConstantineordainedthatthepeopleshouldrestontheSabbath,hemadethisdecreeforthecities,[31]andnotfortheinhabitantsoftheopencountry;hewassensiblethatlabourinthecitieswasuseful,butinthefieldsnecessary。
  Forthesamereason,inacountrysupportedbycommerce,thenumberoffestivalsoughttoberelativetothisverycommerce。ProtestantandCatholiccountriesaresituatedinsuchamannerthatthereismoreneedoflabourintheformerthaninthelatter;[32]thesuppressionoffestivalsisthereforemoresuitabletoProtestantthantoCatholiccountries。
  Dampierobservesthatthediversionsofdifferentnationsvarygreatly,accordingtotheclimate。[33]Ashotclimatesproduceaquantityofdelicatefruits,thebarbarianseasilyfindnecessaries,andthereforespendmuchtimeindiversions。TheIndiansofcoldercountrieshavenotsomuchleisure,beingobligedtofishandhuntcontinually;hencetheyhavelessmusic,dancingandfestivals。Ifanewreligionshouldbeestablishedamongthesepeople,itoughttohaveregardtothisintheinstitutionoffestivals。
  24。OfthelocalLawsofReligion。Therearemanylocallawsinvariousreligions;andwhenMontezumawithsomuchobstinacyinsistedthatthereligionoftheSpaniardswasgoodfortheircountry,andhisforMexico,hedidnotassertanabsurdity;because,infact,legislatorscouldneverhelphavingaregardtowhatnaturehadestablishedbeforethem。
  TheopinionofthemetempsychosisisadaptedtotheclimateoftheIndies。Anexcessiveheatburnsupallthecountry:[34]theycanbreedbutveryfewcattle;theyarealwaysindangerofwantingthemfortillage;theirblackcattlemultiplybutindifferently;[35]andtheyaresubjecttomanydistempers。Alawofreligionwhichpreservesthemisthereforemoresuitabletothepolicyofthecountry。
  Whilethemeadowsarescorched,riceandpulse,bytheassistanceofwater,arebroughttoperfection;alawofreligionwhichpermitsonlythiskindofnourishmentmustthereforebeextremelyusefultomeninthoseclimates。
  Thefleshofcattleinthatcountryisinsipid36butthemilkandbutterwhichtheyreceivefromthemserveforapartoftheirsubsistence;
  thereforethelawwhichprohibitstheeatingandkillingofcowsisintheIndiesnotunreasonable。
  Athenscontainedaprodigiousmultitudeofpeople,butitsterritorywasbarren。Itwasthereforeareligiousmaximwiththispeoplethatthosewhoofferedsomesmallpresentstothegodshonouredthemmorethanthosewhosacrificedanox。[37]
  25。TheInconvenienceoftransplantingaReligionfromoneCountrytoanother。Itfollowshencethattherearefrequentlymanyinconveniencesattendingthetransplantingareligionfromonecountrytoanyother。
  "Thehog,"saysM。deBoulainvilliers,[38]"mustbeveryscarceinArabia,wheretherearealmostnowoods,andhardlyanythingfitforthenourishmentoftheseanimals;besides,thesaltnessofthewaterandfoodrendersthepeoplemostsusceptibleofcutaneousdisorders。"Thislocallawcouldnotbegoodinothercountries,[39]wherethehogisalmostauniversal,andinsomesortanecessary,nourishment。
  Ishallheremakeareflection。Sanctoriushasobservedthatporktranspiresbutlittle,[40]andthatthiskindofmeatgreatlybindersthetranspirationofotherfood;hehasfoundthatthisdiminutionamountstoathird。[41]Besides,itisknownthatthewantoftranspirationformsorincreasesthedisordersoftheskin。Thefeedingonporkoughtrathertobeprohibitedinclimateswherethepeoplearesubjecttothesedisorders,asinPalestine,Arabia,Egypt,andLibya。
  26。ThesameSubjectcontinued。SirJohnChardinsays[42]thatthereisnotanavigableriverinPersia,excepttheKur,whichisattheextremityoftheempire。TheancientlawoftheGaurswhichprohibitedsailingonriverswasnotthereforeattendedwithanyinconvenienceinthiscountry,thoughitwouldhaveruinedthetradeofanother。
  Frequentbathingsareextremelyusefulinhotclimates。OnthisaccounttheyareordainedintheMahometanlawandintheIndianreligion。IntheIndiesitisamostmeritoriousacttopraytoGodintherunningstream;[43]buthowcouldthesethingsbeperformedinotherclimates?
  Whenareligionadaptedtotheclimateofonecountryclashestoomuchwiththeclimateofanotheritcannotbethereestablished;andwheneverithasbeenintroducedithasbeenafterwardsdiscarded,itseemstoallhumanappearanceasiftheclimatehadprescribedtheboundsoftheChristianandtheMahometanreligions。
  Itfollowshence,thatitisalmostalwaysproperforareligiontohaveparticulardoctrines,andageneralworship。Inlawsconcerningthepracticeofreligiousworshipthereoughttobebutfewparticulars;forinstance,theyshouldcommandmortificationingeneralandnotacertainkindofmortification。Christianityisfullofgoodsense;abstinenceisofdivineinstitution;butaparticularkindofabstinenceisordainedbyhumanauthorityandthereforemaybechanged。
  ______
  1。ThoughtsontheComet,ContinuationofThoughtsontheComet,ii。
  2。DescriptionofEthiopia,byM。Ponce,Physician。EdifyingLetters,coll。iv,p。290。
  3。SeeDiodorus,i。18。
  4。Dupin,EcclesiasticalLibraryoftheSixthCentury,v。
  5。CollectionofVoyagesthatContributedtotheEstablishmentoftheEastIndiaCompany,iii,partI,p。63。
  6。Prideaux,HistoryoftheJews。
  7。ThisistheinconvenienceofthedoctrineofFoeandLaockium。
  8。DeLeg。,ii。22。
  9。Sacrumcommissum,quodnequeexpiaripotent,impiecommissumest;
  quodexpiaripotentpublicisacerdotesexpianto。
  10。SeetheaccountofJohnDuplanCarpin,senttoTartarybyPopeInnocentIVintheyear1246。
  11。CollectionofVoyagesthatContributedtotheEstablishmentoftheEastIndiaCompany,v,partI,p。192。
  12。EdifyingLetters,coll。xv。
  13。Politics,vii。17。
  14。Suetonius,LifeofAugustus,31。
  15。Ibid。
  16。CollectionofVoyagesthatContributedtotheEstablishmentoftheEastIndiaCompany,iv,partIp。127。
  17。SeePrideaux,lifeofMahomet,p。64。
  18。Koran,i,chapter"OftheCow。"
  19。Onrenouncingthelawofretaliation。
  20。DeMoribusGermanorum,21。
  21。CollectionofVoyagesthatContributedtotheEstablishmentoftheEastIndiaCompany,vii,p。303。SeealsoMemoirsoftheCountdeForbin,andwhathesaysofthepeopleofMacassar。
  22。Plato,Laws,ix。
  23。TragedyofOedipusatColonus。
  24。Plato,Laws,ix。
  25。AChinesephilosopherreasonsthusagainstthedoctrineofFoe:"Itissaidinabookofthatsect,thatthebodyisourdwelling—placeandthesoultheimmortalguestwhichlodgesthere;butifthebodiesofourrelativesareonlyalodging,itisnaturaltoregardthemwiththesamecontemptweshouldfeelforastructureofearthanddirt。Isnotthisendeavouringtotearfromtheheartthevirtueoflovetoone’sownparents?Thisleadsuseventoneglectthecareofthebody,andtorefuseitthecompassionandaffectionsonecessaryforitspreservation;hencethedisciplesofFoekillthemselvesbythousands。"
  ——WorkofanancientChinesephilosopher,intheCollectionofFatherDuHalde,iii,p。52。
  26。SeeTho。Bartholin,AntiquitiesoftheDanes。
  27。AnAccountofJapan,intheCollectionofVoyagesthatContributedtotheEstablishmentoftheEastIndiacompany。
  28。Forbin,Memoirs。
  29。Hyde,ReligionofthePersians。
  30。Xenophon,OntheRepublicofAthens,3,§8。
  31。Leg。3。Cod。deferiis。ThislawwasdoubtlessmadeonlyforthePagans。
  32。TheCatholicsliemoretowardthesouth,andtheProtestantstowardsthenorth。
  33。Dampier,Voyages,ii。
  34。SeeBernier,Travels,ii,p。137。
  35。EdifyingLetters,coll。xii,p。95。
  36。Bernier,Travels,ii,p。137。
  37。Euripides,inAthen?us,ii,p。40。
  38。LifeofMahomet。
  39。AsinChina。
  40。MedicinaStatica,§3,aphor。22。
  41。Ibid。,aphor。23。
  42。TravelsintoPersia,ii。
  43。Bernier,Travels,ii。
  BookXXV。OfLawsinRelationtotheEstablishmentofReligionanditsExternalPolity1。OfReligiousSentiments。Thepiousmanandtheatheistalwaystalkofreligion;theonespeaksofwhatheloves,andtheotherofwhathefears。
  2。OftheMotivesofAttachmenttodifferentReligions。Thedifferentreligionsoftheworlddonotgivetothosewhoprofessthemequalmotivesofattachment;thisdependsgreatlyonthemannerinwhichtheyagreewiththeturnofthoughtandperceptionsofmankind。
  Weareextremelyaddictedtoidolatry,andyethavenogreatinclinationforthereligionofidolaters;wearenotveryfondofspiritualideas,andyetaremostattachedtothosereligionswhichteachustoadoreaspiritualbeing。Thisproceedsfromthesatisfactionwefindinourselvesathavingbeensointelligentastochooseareligionwhichraisesthedeityfromthatbasenessinwhichhehadbeenplacedbyothers。Welookuponidolatryasthereligionofanignorantpeople,andthereligionwhichhasaspiritualbeingforitsobjectasthatofthemostenlightenednations。