Hewhodoesnotgapeafterthefavourofprinces,asafterathinghecannotlivewithout,doesnotmuchconcernhimselfatthecoldnessoftheirreceptionandcountenance,norattheinconstancyoftheirwills。
Hewhodoesnotbroodoverhischildrenorhishonourswithaslavishpropension,ceasesnottolivecommodiouslyenoughaftertheirloss。Hewhodoesgoodprincipallyforhisownsatisfactionwillnotbemuchtroubledtoseemenjudgeofhisactionscontrarytohismerit。A
quarterofanounceofpatiencewillprovidesufficientlyagainstsuchinconveniences。Ifindeaseinthisreceipt,redeemingmyselfinthebeginningasgoodcheapasIcan;andfindthatbythismeansIhaveescapedmuchtroubleandmanydifficulties。WithverylittleadoIstopthefirstsallyofmyemotions,andleavethesubjectthatbeginstobetroublesomebeforeittransportsme。Hewhostopsnotthestartwillneverbeabletostopthecourse;hewhocannotkeepthemoutwillnever,getthemoutwhentheyareoncegotin;andhewhocannotarriveatthebeginningwillneverarriveattheendofall。Norwillhebearthefallwhocannotsustaintheshock:
"Etenimipsaeseimpellunt,ubisemelarationediscessumest;
ipsaquesibiimbecillitasindulget,inaltumqueprovehiturimprudens,necreperitlocumconsistendi。"
["Fortheythrowthemselvesheadlongwhenoncetheylosetheirreason;andinfirmitysofarindulgesitself,andfromwantofprudenceiscarriedoutintodeepwater,norfindsaplacetoshelterit。"——Cicero,Tusc。Quaes。,iv。18。]
Iambetimessensibleofthelittlebreezesthatbegintosingandwhistlewithin,forerunnersofthestorm:
"CeuflaminaprimaCumdeprensafremuntsylvisetcaecavolutantMurmura,venturosnautisprodentiaventos。"
["Asthebreezes,pentinthewoods,firstsendoutdullmurmurs,announcingtheapproachofwindstomariners。"——AEneid,x。97。]
HowoftenhaveIdonemyselfamanifestinjusticetoavoidthehazardofhavingyetaworsedonemebythejudges,afteranageofvexations,dirtyandvilepractices,moreenemiestomynaturethanfireortherack?
"Convenitalitibus,quantumlicet,etnescioanpauloplusetiamquamlicet,abhorrentemesse:estenimnonmodoliberale,paululumnonnunquamdesuojuredecedere,sedinterdumetiamfructuosum。"
["Amanshouldabhorlawsuitsasmuchashemay,andIknownotwhethernotsomethingmore;for’tisnotonlyliberal,butsometimesalsoadvantageous,too,alittletorecedefromone’sright。
——"Cicero,DeOffic。,ii。18。]
Werewewise,weoughttorejoiceandboast,asIonedayheardayounggentlemanofagoodfamilyveryinnocentlydo,thathismotherhadlosthercause,asifithadbeenacough,afever,orsomethingverytroublesometokeep。Eventhefavoursthatfortunemighthavegivenmethroughrelationshiporacquaintancewiththosewhohavesovereignauthorityinthoseaffairs,Ihaveveryconscientiouslyandverycarefullyavoidedemployingthemtotheprejudiceofothers,andofadvancingmypretensionsabovetheirtrueright。Infine,Ihavesomuchprevailedbymyendeavours(andhappilyImaysayit)thatIamtothisdayavirginfromallsuitsinlaw;thoughIhavehadveryfairoffersmademe,andwithveryjusttitle,wouldIhavehearkenedtothem,andavirginfromquarrelstoo。Ihavealmostpassedoveralonglifewithoutanyoffenceofmoment,eitheractiveorpassive,orwithouteverhearingaworsewordthanmyownname:ararefavourofHeaven。
Ourgreatestagitationshaveridiculousspringsandcauses:whatruindidourlastDukeofBurgundyrunintoaboutacartloadofsheepskins!
Andwasnotthegravingofasealthefirstandprincipalcauseofthegreatestcommotionthatthismachineoftheworldeverunderwent?
——[ThecivilwarbetweenMariusandSylla;seePlutarch’sLifeofMarius,c。3。]——forPompeyandCaesarwerebuttheoffsetsandcontinuationofthetwoothers:andIhaveinmytimeseenthewisestheadsinthiskingdomassembledwithgreatceremony,andatthepublicexpense,abouttreatiesandagreements,ofwhichthetruedecision,inthemeantime,absolutelydependedupontheladies’cabinetcouncil,andtheinclinationofsomebitofawoman。
ThepoetsverywellunderstoodthiswhentheyputallGreeceandAsiatofireandswordaboutanapple。Lookwhythatmanhazardshislifeandhonouruponthefortuneofhisrapieranddagger;lethimacquaintyouwiththeoccasionofthequarrel;hecannotdoitwithoutblushing:theoccasionissoidleandfrivolous。
Alittlethingwillengageyouinit;butbeingonceembarked,allthecordsdraw;greatprovisionsarethenrequired,morehardandmoreimportant。Howmucheasierisitnottoenterinthanitistogetout。?
Nowweshouldproceedcontrarytothereed,which,atitsfirstspringing,producesalongandstraightshoot,butafterwards,asiftiredandoutofbreath,itrunsintothickandfrequentjointsandknots,assomanypauseswhichdemonstratethatithasnomoreitsfirstvigourandfirmness;’twerebettertobegingentlyandcoldly,andtokeepone’sbreathandvigorouseffortsfortheheightandstressofthebusiness。Weguideaffairsintheirbeginnings,andhavetheminourownpower;butafterwards,whentheyareonceatwork,’tistheythatguideandgovernus,andwearetofollowthem。
YetdoInotmeantosaythatthiscounselhasdischargedmeofalldifficulty,andthatIhavenotoftenhadenoughtodotocurbandrestrainmypassions;theyarenotalwaystobegovernedaccordingtothemeasureofoccasions,andoftenhavetheirentriesverysharpandviolent。Butstillgoodfruitandprofitmaythencebereaped;exceptforthosewhoinwell—doingarenotsatisfiedwithanybenefit,ifreputationbewanting;for,intruth,suchaneffectisnotvaluedbutbyeveryonetohimself;youarebettercontented,butnotmoreesteemed,seeingyoureformedyourselfbeforeyougotintothewhirlofthedance,orthattheprovocativematterwasinsight。Yetnotinthisonly,butinallotherdutiesoflifealso,thewayofthosewhoaimathonourisverydifferentfromthattheyproceedby,whoproposetothemselvesorderandreason。Ifindsomewhorashlyandfuriouslyrushintothelistsandcoolinthecourse。AsPlutarchsays,thatthosewho,throughfalseshame,aresoftandfaciletograntwhateverisdesiredofthem,areafterwardsasfaciletobreaktheirwordandtorecant;sohewhoenterslightlyintoaquarrelisapttogoaslightlyoutofit。Thesamedifficultythatkeepsmefromenteringintoit,would,whenoncehotandengagedinquarrel,incitemetomaintainitwithgreatobstinacyandresolution。’Tisthetyrannyofcustom;whenamanisonceengaged;hemustgothroughwithit,ordie。"Undertakecoolly,"saidBias,"butpursuewithardour。"Forwantofprudence,menfallintowantofcourage,whichisstillmoreintolerable。
Mostaccommodationsofthequarrelsofthesedaysofoursareshamefulandfalse;weonlyseektosaveappearances,andinthemeantimebetrayanddisavowourtrueintentions;wesalveoverthefact。Weknowverywellhowwesaidthething,andinwhatsensewespokeit,andthecompanyknowit,andourfriendswhomwehavewishedtomakesensibleofouradvantage,understanditwellenoughtoo:’tisattheexpenseofourfranknessandofthehonourofourcourage,thatwedisownourthoughts,andseekrefugeinfalsities,tomakemattersup。Wegiveourselvesthelie,toexcusetheliewehavegiventoanother。Youarenottoconsiderifyourwordoractionmayadmitofanotherinterpretation;’tisyourowntrueandsincereinterpretation,yourrealmeaninginwhatyousaidordid,thatyouarethenceforwardtomaintain,whateveritcostyou。Menspeaktoyourvirtueandconscience,whicharenotthingstobeputunderamask;letusleavethesepitifulwaysandexpedientstothejugglersofthelaw。TheexcusesandreparationsthatIseeeverydaymadeandgiventorepairindiscretion,seemtomemorescandalousthantheindiscretionitself。Itwerebettertoaffrontyouradversaryasecondtimethantooffendyourselfbygivinghimsounmanlyasatisfaction。Youhavebravedhiminyourheatandanger,andyouwouldflatterandappeasehiminyourcoolerandbettersense;andbythatmeanslayyourselflowerandathisfeet,whombeforeyoupretendedtoovertop。Idonotfindanythingagentlemancansaysoviciousinhimasunsayingwhathehassaidisinfamous,whentounsayitisauthoritativelyextractedfromhim;
forasmuchasobstinacyismoreexcusableinamanofhonourthanpusillanimity。Passionsareaseasyformetoevade,astheyarehardformetomoderate:
"Exscindunturfaciliusammo,quamtemperantur。"
["Theyaremoreeasilytobeeradicatedthangoverned。"]
HewhocannotattainthenobleStoicalimpassibility,lethimsecurehimselfinthebosomofthispopularstolidityofmine;whattheyperformedbyvirtue,Iinuremyselftodobytemperament。Themiddleregionharboursstormsandtempests;thetwoextremes,ofphilosophersandpeasants,concurintranquillityandhappiness:
"Felix,quipotuitrerumcognoscerecausas,AtquemetusomnesetinexorabilefatumSubjecitpedibus,strepitumqueAcherontisavari!
Fortunatusetille,Deosquinovitagrestes,Panaque,Sylvanumquesenem,Nymphasquesorores!"
["Happyishewhocoulddiscoverthecausesofthings,andplaceunderhisfeetallfearsandinexorablefate,andthesoundofrapaciousAcheron:heisblestwhoknowsthecountrygods,andPan,andoldSylvanus,andthesisternymphs。"——Virgil,Georg。,ii。490。]
Thebirthsofallthingsareweakandtender;andthereforeweshouldhaveoureyesintentonbeginnings;foraswhen,initsinfancy,thedangerisnotperceived,sowhenitisgrownup,theremedyisaslittletobefound。Ihadeverydayencounteredamillionofcrosses,hardertodigestintheprogressofambition,thanithasbeenhardformetocurbthenaturalpropensionthatinclinedmetoit:
"JureperhorruiLathconspicuumtollereverticem。"
["Ieverjustlyfearedtoraisemyheadtoohigh。"
——Horace,Od。,iii。16,18。]
Allpublicactionsaresubjecttouncertainandvariousinterpretations;
fortoomanyheadsjudgeofthem。Somesayofthiscivicemploymentofmine(andIamwillingtosayawordortwoaboutit,notthatitisworthsomuch,buttogiveanaccountofmymannersinsuchthings),thatIhavebehavedmyselfinitasamanwhoistoosupineandofalanguidtemperament;andtheyhavesomecolourforwhattheysay。Iendeavouredtokeepmymindandmythoughtsinrepose;
"Cumsempernatura,tumetiamaetatejamquietus;"
["Asbeingalwaysquietbynature,soalsonowbyage。"
——Cicero,DePetit。Consul。,c。2。]
andiftheysometimeslashoutuponsomerudeandsensibleimpression,’tisintruthwithoutmyadvice。Yetfromthisnaturalheavinessofmine,menoughtnottoconcludeatotalinabilityinme(forwantofcareandwantofsensearetwoverydifferentthings),andmuchlessanyunkindnessoringratitudetowardsthatcorporationwhoemployedtheutmostmeanstheyhadintheirpowertoobligeme,bothbeforetheyknewmeandafter;andtheydidmuchmoreformeinchoosingmeanewthaninconferringthathonouruponmeatfirst。Iwishthemallimaginablegood;andassuredlyhadoccasionbeen,thereisnothingIwouldhavesparedfortheirservice;IdidforthemasIwouldhavedoneformyself。
’Tisagood,warlike,andgenerouspeople,butcapableofobedienceanddiscipline,andofwhomthebestusemaybemade,ifwellguided。Theysayalsothatmyadministrationpassedoverwithoutleavinganymarkortrace。Good!Theymoreoveraccusemycessationinatimewheneverybodyalmostwasconvictedofdoingtoomuch。Iamimpatienttobedoingwheremywillspursmeon;butthisitselfisanenemytoperseverance。Lethimwhowillmakeuseofmeaccordingtomyownway,employmeinaffairswherevigourandlibertyarerequired,whereadirect,short,and,moreover,ahazardousconductarenecessary;Imaydosomething;butifitmustbelong,subtle,laborious,artificialandintricate,hehadbettercallinsomebodyelse。Allimportantofficesarenotnecessarilydifficult:Icamepreparedtodosomewhatrougherwork,hadtherebeengreatoccasion;foritisinmypowertodosomethingmorethanIdo,orthanIlovetodo。Ididnot,tomyknowledge,omitanythingthatmydutyreallyrequired。Ieasilyforgotthoseofficesthatambitionmixeswithdutyandpalliateswithitstitle;thesearetheythat,forthemostpart,filltheeyesandears,andgivementhemostsatisfaction;notthethingbuttheappearancecontentsthem;iftheyhearnonoise,theythinkmensleep。Myhumourisnofriendtotumult;Icouldappeaseacommotionwithoutcommotion,andchastiseadisorderwithoutbeingmyselfdisorderly;ifIstandinneedofangerandinflammation,Iborrowit,andputiton。Mymannersarelanguid,ratherfaintthansharp。Idonotcondemnamagistratewhosleeps,providedthepeopleunderhischargesleepaswellashe:thelawsinthatcasesleeptoo。Formypart,I
commendagliding,staid,andsilentlife:
"Nequesubmissametabjectam,nequeseefferentem;"
["Neithersubjectandabject,norobtrusive。"
——Cicero,DeOffic。,i。34]
myfortunewillhaveitso。Iamdescendedfromafamilythathaslivedwithoutlustreortumult,and,timeoutofmind,particularlyambitiousofacharacterforprobity。
Ourpeoplenowadaysaresobreduptobustleandostentation,thatgoodnature,moderation,equability,constancy,andsuchlikequietandobscurequalities,arenomorethoughtonorregarded。Roughbodiesmakethemselvesfelt;thesmoothareimperceptiblyhandled:sicknessisfelt,healthlittleornotatall;nomorethantheoilsthatfomentus,incomparisonofthepainsforwhichwearefomented。’Tisactingforone’sparticularreputationandprofit,notforthepublicgood,toreferthattobedoneinthepublicsquareswhichonemaydointhecouncilchamber;
andtonoondaywhatmighthavebeendonethenightbefore;andtobejealoustodothathimselfwhichhiscolleaguecandoaswellashe;soweresomesurgeonsofGreecewonttoperformtheiroperationsuponscaffoldsinthesightofthepeople,todrawmorepracticeandprofit。
Theythinkthatgoodrulescannotbeunderstoodbutbythesoundoftrumpet。Ambitionisnotaviceoflittlepeople,norofsuchmodestmeansasours。OnesaidtoAlexander:"Yourfatherwillleaveyouagreatdominion,easyandpacific";thisyouthwasemulousofhisfather’svictoriesandofthejusticeofhisgovernment;hewouldnothaveenjoyedtheempireoftheworldineaseandpeace。Alcibiades,inPlato,hadratherdieyoung,beautiful,rich,noble,andlearned,andallthisinfullexcellence,thantostopshortofsuchcondition;thisdiseaseis,peradventure,excusableinsostrongandsofullasoul。Whenwretchedanddwarfishlittlesoulscajoleanddeceivethemselves,andthinktospreadtheirfameforhavinggivenrightjudgmentinanaffair,ormaintainedthedisciplineoftheguardofagateoftheircity,themoretheythinktoexalttheirheadsthemoretheyshowtheirtails。Thislittlewell—doinghasneitherbodynorlife;itvanishesinthefirstmouth,andgoesnofurtherthanfromonestreettoanother。Talkofitbyallmeanstoyoursonoryourservant,likethatoldfellowwho,havingnootherauditorofhispraisesnorapproverofhisvalour,boastedtohischambermaid,crying,"OPerrete,whatabrave,clevermanhastthouforthymaster!"Attheworst,talkofittoyourself,likeacouncillorofmyacquaintance,who,havingdisgorgedawholecartfuloflawjargonwithgreatheatandasgreatfolly,comingoutofthecouncilchambertomakewater,washeardverycomplacentlytomutterbetwixthisteeth:
"Nonnobis,domine,nonnobis,sednominituodagloriam。"
["Notuntous,OLord,nottous:butuntoThynamebetheglory。"
——Psalmcxiii。I。]
Hewhogetsitofnobodyelse,lethimpayhimselfoutofhisownpurse。
Fameisnotprostitutedatsocheaparate:rareandexemplaryactions,towhichitisdue,wouldnotendurethecompanyofthisprodigiouscrowdofpettydailyperformances。Marblemayexaltyourtitles,asmuchasyouplease,forhavingrepairedarodofwallorcleansedapublicsewer;
butnotmenofsense。Renowndoesnotfollowallgooddeeds,ifnoveltyanddifficultybenotconjoined;nay,somuchasmereesteem,accordingtotheStoics,isnotduetoeveryactionthatproceedsfromvirtue;norwilltheyallowhimbarethankswho,outoftemperance,abstainsfromanoldblear—eyedcrone。ThosewhohaveknowntheadmirablequalitiesofScipioAfricanus,denyhimtheglorythatPanaetiusattributestohim,ofbeingabstinentfromgifts,asaglorynotsomuchhisasthatofhisage。Wehavepleasuressuitabletoourlot;letusnotusurpthoseofgrandeur:ourownaremorenatural,andbysomuchmoresolidandsure,astheyarelower。Ifnotforthatofconscience,yetatleastforambition’ssake,letusrejectambition;letusdisdainthatthirstofhonourandrenown,solowandmendicant,thatitmakesusbegitofallsortsofpeople:
"Quaeestistalausquae:possitemacellopeti?"
["Whatpraiseisthatwhichistobegotinthemarket—place(meatmarket?""Cicero,DeFin。,ii。15。]
byabjectmeans,andatwhatcheapratesoever:’tisdishonourtobesohonoured。Letuslearntobenomoregreedy,thanwearecapable,ofglory。Tobepuffedupwitheveryactionthatisinnocentorofuse,isonlyforthosewithwhomsuchthingsareextraordinaryandrare:theywillvalueitasitcoststhem。Themoreagoodeffectmakesanoise,themoredoIabateofitsgoodnessasIsuspectthatitwasmoreperformedforthenoise,thanuponaccountofthegoodness:exposeduponthestall,’tishalfsold。Thoseactionshavemuchmoregraceandlustre,thatslipfromthehandofhimthatdoesthem,negligentlyandwithoutnoise,andthatsomehonestmanthereafterfindsoutandraisesfromtheshade,toproduceittothelightuponitsownaccount,"Mihiquidemlaudabilioravidenturomnia,quaesinevenditatione,etsinepopulotestefiunt,"
["Allthingstrulyseemmorelaudabletomethatareperformedwithoutostentation,andwithoutthetestimonyofthepeople。"
——Cicero,Tusc。Quaes。,ii。26。]
saysthemostostentatiousmanthateverlived。
Ihadbuttoconserveandtocontinue,whicharesilentandinsensibleeffects:innovationisofgreatlustre;but’tisinterdictedinthisage,whenwearepresseduponandhavenothingtodefendourselvesfrombutnovelties。Toforbeardoingisoftenasgenerousastodo;but’tislessinthelight,andthelittlegoodIhaveinmeisofthiskind。Infine,occasionsinthisemploymentofminehavebeenconfederatewithmyhumour,andIheartilythankthemforit。Isthereanywhodesirestobesick,thathemayseehisphysicianatwork?andwouldnotthephysiciandeservetobewhippedwhoshouldwishtheplagueamongstus,thathemightputhisartinpractice?Ihaveneverbeenofthatwickedhumour,andcommonenough,todesirethattroublesanddisordersinthiscityshouldelevateandhonourmygovernment;IhaveeverheartilycontributedallIcouldtotheirtranquillityandease。
Hewhowillnotthankmefortheorder,thesweetandsilentcalmthathasaccompaniedmyadministration,cannot,however,deprivemeofthesharethatbelongstomebytitleofmygoodfortune。AndIamofsuchacomposition,thatIwouldaswillinglybeluckyaswise,andhadratherowemysuccessespurelytothefavourofAlmightyGod,thantoanyoperationofmyown。Ihadsufficientlypublishedtotheworldmyunfitnessforsuchpublicoffices;butIhavesomethinginmeyetworsethanincapacityitself;whichis,thatIamnotmuchdispleasedatit,andthatIdonotmuchgoabouttocureit,consideringthecourseoflifethatIhaveproposedtomyself。
NeitherhaveIsatisfiedmyselfinthisemployment;butIhaveveryneararrivedatwhatIexpectedfrommyownperformance,andhavemuchsurpassedwhatIpromisedthemwithwhomIhadtodo:forIamapttopromisesomethinglessthanwhatIamabletodo,andthanwhatIhopetomakegood。IassuremyselfthatIhaveleftnooffenceorhatredbehindme;toleaveregretordesireformeamongstthem,IatleastknowverywellthatInevermuchaimedatit:
"Menehuicconfideremonstro!
Menesalisplacidivultum,fluctusquequietosIgnorare?"
["ShouldIplaceconfidenceinthismonster?ShouldIbeignorantofthedangersofthatseemingplacidsea,thosenowquietwaves?"
——Virgil,Aeneid,V。849。]
CHAPTERXI
OFCRIPPLES
’TisnowtwoorthreeyearsagothattheymadetheyeartendaysshorterinFrance。——[BytheadoptionoftheGregoriancalendar。]——Howmanychangesmayweexpectshouldfollowthisreformation!itwasreallymovingheavenandearthatonce。Yetnothingforallthatstirsfromitsplacemyneighboursstillfindtheirseasonsofsowingandreaping,theopportunitiesofdoingtheirbusiness,thehurtfulandpropitiousdays,dustatthesametimewheretheyhad,timeoutofmind,assignedthem;
therewasnomoreerrorperceivedinourolduse,thanthereisamendmentfoundinthealteration;sogreatanuncertaintythereisthroughout;sogross,obscure,andobtuseisourperception。’Tissaidthatthisregulationmighthavebeencarriedonwithlessinconvenience,bysubtractingforsomeyears,accordingtotheexampleofAugustus,theBissextile,whichisinsomesortadayofimpedimentandtrouble,tillwehadexactlysatisfiedthisdebt,thewhichitselfisnotdonebythiscorrection,andweyetremainsomedaysinarrear:andyet,bythismeans,suchordermightbetakenforthefuture,arrangingthataftertherevolutionofsuchorsuchanumberofyears,thesupernumerarydaymightbealwaysthrownout,sothatwecouldnot,henceforward,errabovefour—
and—twentyhoursinourcomputation。Wehavenootheraccountoftimebutyears;theworldhasformanyagesmadeuseofthatonly;andyetitisameasurethattothisdaywearenotagreedupon,andonethatwestilldoubtwhatformothernationshavevariouslygiventoit,andwhatwasthetrueuseofit。Whatdoesthissayingofsomemean,thattheheavensingrowingoldbowthemselvesdownnearertowardsus,andputusintoanuncertaintyevenofhoursanddays?andthatwhichPlutarchsaysofthemonths,thatastrologyhadnotinhistimedeterminedastothemotionofthemoon;whatafineconditionareweintokeeprecordsofthingspast。
Iwasjustnowruminating,asIoftendo,whatafreeandrovingthinghumanreasonis。Iordinarilyseethatmen,inthingspropoundedtothem,morewillinglystudytofindoutreasonsthantoascertaintruth:
theyslipoverpresuppositions,butarecuriousinexaminationofconsequences;theyleavethethings,andflytothecauses。Pleasanttalkers!Theknowledgeofcausesonlyconcernshimwhohastheconductofthings;notus,whoaremerelytoundergothem,andwhohaveperfectlyfullandaccomplisheduseofthem,accordingtoourneed,withoutpenetratingintotheoriginalandessence;wineisnonethemorepleasanttohimwhoknowsitsfirstfaculties。Onthecontrary,boththebodyandthesoulinterruptandweakentherighttheyhaveoftheuseoftheworldandofthemselves,bymixingwithittheopinionoflearning;effectsconcernus,butthemeansnotatall。Todetermineandtodistributeappertaintosuperiorityandcommand;asitdoestosubjectiontoaccept。
Letmereprehendourcustom。Theycommonlybeginthus:"Howissuchathingdone?"Whereastheyshouldsay,"。Issuchathingdone?"Ourreasonisabletocreateahundredotherworlds,andtofindoutthebeginningsandcontexture;itneedsneithermatternorfoundation:letitbutrunon,itbuildsaswellintheairasontheearth,andwithinanityaswellaswithmatter:
"Darepondusidoneafumo。"
["Abletogiveweighttosmoke。"——Persius,v。20。]
Ifindthatalmostthroughoutweshouldsay,"thereisnosuchthing,"
andshouldmyselfoftenmakeuseofthisanswer,butIdarenot:fortheycrythatitisanevasionproducedfromignoranceandweaknessofunderstanding;andIamfain,forthemostpart,tojuggleforcompany,andprateoffrivoloussubjectsandtalesthatIbelievenotawordof;
besidesthat,intruth,’tisalittlerudeandquarrelsomeflatlytodenyastatedfact;andfewpeoplebutwillaffirm,especiallyinthingshardtobebelieved,thattheyhaveseenthem,oratleastwillnamewitnesseswhoseauthoritywillstopourmouthsfromcontradiction。Inthisway,weknowthefoundationsandmeansofthingsthatneverwere;andtheworldscufflesaboutathousandquestions,ofwhichboththeProandtheConarefalse。
"Itafinitimasuntfalsaveris,utinpraecipitemlocumnondebeatsesapienscommittere。"
["Falsethingsaresonearthetrue,thatawisemanshouldnottrusthimselfinaprecipitousplace"——Cicero,Acad。,ii。21。]
Truthandliesarefacedalike;theirport,taste,andproceedingsarethesame,andwelookuponthemwiththesameeye。Ifindthatwearenotonlyremissindefendingourselvesfromdeceit,butthatweseekandofferourselvestobegulled;welovetoentangleourselvesinvanity,asathingconformabletoourbeing。
Ihaveseenthebirthofmanymiraclesinmytime;which,althoughtheywereabortive,yethavewenotfailedtoforeseewhattheywouldhavecometo,hadtheylivedtheirfullage。’Tisbutfindingtheendoftheclew,andamanmaywindoffasmuchashewill;andthereisagreaterdistancebetwixtnothingandtheleastthingintheworldthanthereisbetwixtthisandthegreatest。Nowthefirstthatareimbuedwiththisbeginningofnovelty,whentheysetoutwiththeirtale,find,bytheoppositionstheymeetwith,wherethedifficultyofpersuasionlies,andsocaulkupthatplacewithsomefalsepiece;
[Voltairesaysofthispassage,"HewhowouldlearntodoubtshouldreadthiswholechapterofMontaigne,theleastmethodicalofallphilosophers,butthewisestandmostamiable。"
——MelangesHistoriques,xvii。694,ed。ofLefevre。]
besidesthat:
"Insitahominibuslibidoalendideindustriarumores,"
["Menhavinganaturaldesiretonourishreports。"
——Livy,xxviii。24。]
wenaturallymakeaconscienceofrestoringwhathasbeenlentus,withoutsomeusuryandaccessionofourown。Theparticularerrorfirstmakesthepublicerror,andafterwards,inturn,thepublicerrormakestheparticularone;andthusallthisvastfabricgoesformingandpilingitselfupfromhandtohand,sothattheremotestwitnessknowsmoreaboutitthanthosewhowerenearest,andthelastinformedisbetterpersuadedthanthefirst。
’Tisanaturalprogress;forwhoeverbelievesanything,thinksitaworkofcharitytopersuadeanotherintothesameopinion;whichthebettertodo,hewillmakenodifficultyofaddingasmuchofhisowninventionasheconceivesnecessarytohistaletoencountertheresistanceorwantofconceptionhemeetswithinothers。Imyself,whomakeagreatconscienceoflying,andamnotverysolicitousofgivingcreditandauthoritytowhatIsay,yetfindthatintheargumentsIhaveinhand,beingheatedwiththeoppositionofanother,orbytheproperwarmthofmyownnarration,Iswellandpuffupmysubjectbyvoice,motion,vigour,andforceofwords,andmoreover,byextensionandamplification,notwithoutsomeprejudicetothenakedtruth;butIdoitconditionallywithal,thattothefirstwhobringsmetomyself,andwhoasksmetheplainandbaretruth,Ipresentlysurrendermypassion,anddeliverthemattertohimwithoutexaggeration,withoutemphasis,oranypaintingofmyown。Aquickandearnestwayofspeaking,asmineis,isapttorunintohyperbole。Thereisnothingtowhichmencommonlyaremoreinclinedthantomakewayfortheirownopinions;wheretheordinarymeansfailus,weaddcommand,force,fire,andsword。’Tisamisfortunetobeatsuchapass,thatthebesttestoftruthisthemultitudeofbelieversinacrowd,wherethenumberoffoolssomuchexceedsthewise:
"Quasiveroquidquamsittamvalde,quamnilsapere,vulgare。"
["Asifanythingweresocommonasignorance。"
——Cicero,DeDivin。,ii。]
"Sanitatispatrociniumest,insanientiumturba。"
["Themultitudeoffoolsisaprotectiontothewise。"
——St。Augustine,DeCivit。Dei,vi。10。]
’Tishardtoresolveaman’sjudgmentagainstthecommonopinions:thefirstpersuasion,takenfromtheverysubjectitself,possessesthesimple,andfromthemdiffusesitselftothewise,undertheauthorityofthenumberandantiquityofthewitnesses。Formypart,whatIshouldnotbelievefromone,Ishouldnotbelievefromahundredandone:andI
donotjudgeopinionsbyyears。
’Tisnotlongsinceoneofourprinces,inwhomthegouthadspoiledanexcellentnatureandsprightlydisposition,sufferedhimselftobesofarpersuadedwiththereportmadetohimofthemarvellousoperationsofacertainpriestwhobywordsandgesturescuredallsortsofdiseases,astogoalongjourneytoseekhimout,andbytheforceofhismereimagination,forsomehourssopersuadedandlaidhislegsasleep,astoobtainthatservicefromthemtheyhadlongtimeforgotten。Hadfortuneheapedupfiveorsixsuch—likeincidents,ithadbeenenoughtohavebroughtthismiracleintonature。Therewasafterwardsdiscoveredsomuchsimplicityandsolittleartintheauthoroftheseperformances,thathewasthoughttoocontemptibletobepunished,aswouldbethoughtofmostsuchthings,weretheywellexamined:
"Miramurexintervallofallentia。"
["Weadmireafteraninterval(oratadistance)thingsthatdeceive。"——Seneca,Ep。,118,2。]
Sodoesoursightoftenrepresenttousstrangeimagesatadistancethatvanishonapproachingnear:
"Nunquamadliquidumfamaperducitur。"
["Reportisneverfullysubstantiated。"
——QuintusCurtius,ix。2。]
’Tiswonderfulfromhowmanyidlebeginningsandfrivolouscausessuchfamousimpressionscommonly,proceed。Thisitisthatobstructsinformation;forwhilstweseekoutcausesandsolidandweightyends,worthyofsogreataname,welosethetrueones;theyescapeoursightbytheirlittleness。And,intruth,averyprudent,diligent,andsubtleinquisitionisrequiredinsuchsearches,indifferent,andnotprepossessed。Tothisveryhour,allthesemiraclesandstrangeeventshaveconcealedthemselvesfromme:Ihaveneverseengreatermonsterormiracleintheworldthanmyself:onegrowsfamiliarwithallstrangethingsbytimeandcustom,butthemoreIfrequentandthebetterIknowmyself,themoredoesmyowndeformityastonishme,thelessIunderstandmyself。
Theprincipalrightofadvancingandproducingsuchaccidentsisreservedtofortune。Passingthedaybeforeyesterdaythroughavillagetwoleaguesfrommyhouse,Ifoundtheplaceyetwarmwithamiraclethathadlatelyfailedofsuccessthere,wherewithfirsttheneighbourhoodhadbeenseveralmonthsamused;thentheneighbouringprovincesbegantotakeitup,andtorunthitheringreatcompaniesofallsortsofpeople。
Ayoungfellowoftheplacehadonenightinsportcounterfeitedthevoiceofaspiritinhisownhouse,withoutanyotherdesignatpresent,butonlyforsport;butthishavingsucceededwithhimbetterthanheexpected,toextendhisfarcewithmoreactorsheassociatedwithhimastupidsillycountrygirl,andatlasttherewerethreeofthemofthesameageandunderstanding,whofromdomestic,proceededtopublic,preachings,hidingthemselvesunderthealtarofthechurch,neverspeakingbutbynight,andforbiddinganylighttobebrought。Fromwordswhichtendedtotheconversionoftheworld,andthreatsofthedayofjudgment(forthesearesubjectsundertheauthorityandreverenceofwhichimposturemostsecurelylurks),theyproceededtovisionsandgesticulationssosimpleandridiculousthat——nothingcouldhardlybesogrossinthesportsoflittlechildren。Yethadfortuneneversolittlefavouredthedesign,whoknowstowhatheightthisjugglingmighthaveatlastarrived?Thesepoordevilsareatpresentinprison,andarelikeshortlytopayforthecommonfolly;andIknownotwhethersomejudgewillnotalsomakethemsmartforhis。Weseeclearlyintothis,whichisdiscovered;butinmanythingsofthelikenaturethatexceedourknowledge,Iamofopinionthatweoughttosuspendourjudgment,whetherastorejectionorastoreception。
Greatabusesintheworldarebegotten,or,tospeakmoreboldly,alltheabusesoftheworldarebegotten,byourbeingtaughttobeafraidofprofessingourignorance,andthatweareboundtoacceptallthingswearenotabletorefute:wespeakofallthingsbypreceptsanddecisions。
ThestyleatRomewasthateventhatwhichawitnessdeposedtohavingseenwithhisowneyes,andwhatajudgedeterminedwithhismostcertainknowledge,wascouchedinthisformofspeaking:"itseemstome。"Theymakemehatethingsthatarelikely,whentheywouldimposethemuponmeasinfallible。Ilovethesewordswhichmollifyandmoderatethetemerityofourpropositions:"peradventure;insomesort;some;’tissaid,Ithink,"andthelike:andhadIbeensettotrainupchildrenI
hadputthiswayofansweringintotheirmouths,inquiringandnotresolving:"Whatdoesthismean?Iunderstanditnot;itmaybe:isittrue?"sothattheyshouldratherhaveretainedtheformofpupilsatthreescoreyearsoldthantogooutdoctors,astheydo,atten。Whoeverwillbecuredofignorancemustconfessit。
IrisisthedaughterofThaumas;
[Thatis,ofAdmiration。She(Iris,therainbow)isbeautiful,andforthatreason,becauseshehasafacetobeadmired,sheissaidtohavebeenthedaughterofThamus。"
——Cicero,DeNat。Deor。,iii。20。]
admirationisthefoundationofallphilosophy,inquisitiontheprogress,ignorancetheend。Butthereisasortofignorance,strongandgenerous,thatyieldsnothinginhonourandcouragetoknowledge;anignorancewhichtoconceiverequiresnolessknowledgethantoconceiveknowledgeitself。IreadinmyyoungeryearsatrialthatCorras,[AcelebratedCalvinistlawyer,bornatToulouse;1513,andassassinatedthere,4thOctober1572。]
acouncillorofToulouse,printed,ofastrangeincident,oftwomenwhopresentedthemselvestheonefortheother。Iremember(andIhardlyrememberanythingelse)thatheseemedtohaverenderedtheimpostureofhimwhomhejudgedtobeguilty,sowonderfulandsofarexceedingbothourknowledgeandhisown,whowasthejudge,thatIthoughtitaveryboldsentencethatcondemnedhimtobehanged。Letushavesomeformofdecreethatsays,"Thecourtunderstandsnothingofthematter"morefreelyandingenuouslythantheAreopagitesdid,who,findingthemselvesperplexedwithacausetheycouldnotunravel,orderedthepartiestoappearagainafterahundredyears。
Thewitchesofmyneighbourhoodrunthehazardoftheirlivesuponthereportofeverynewauthorwhoseekstogivebodytotheirdreams。ToaccommodatetheexamplesthatHolyWritgivesusofsuchthings,mostcertainandirrefragableexamples,andtotiethemtoourmodernevents,seeingthatweneitherseethecausesnorthemeans,willrequireanothersort—ofwitthanours。It,peradventure,onlyappertainstothatsoleall—potenttestimonytotellus。"Thisis,andthatis,andnotthatother。"Godoughttobebelieved;andcertainlywithverygoodreason;
butnotoneamongstusforallthatwhoisastonishedathisownnarration(andhemustofnecessitybeastonishedifhebenotoutofhiswits),whetherheemployitaboutothermen’saffairsoragainsthimself。
Iamplainandheavy,andsticktothesolidandtheprobable,avoidingthoseancientreproaches:
"Majoremfidemhominesadhibentiis,quaenonintelligunt;
——Cupidinehumaniingeniilibentiusobscuracreduntur。"
["Menaremostapttobelievewhattheyleastunderstand:andfromtheacquisitivenessofthehumanintellect,obscurethingsaremoreeasilycredited。"ThesecondsentenceisfromTacitus,Hist。1。22。]
Iseeverywellthatmengetangry,andthatIamforbiddentodoubtuponpainofexecrableinjuries;anewwayofpersuading!ThankGod,Iamnottobecuffedintobelief。Letthembeangrywiththosewhoaccusetheiropinionoffalsity;Ionlyaccuseitofdifficultyandboldness,andcondemntheoppositeaffirmationequally,ifnotsoimperiously,withthem。Hewhowillestablishthispropositionbyauthorityandhuffingdiscovershisreasontobeveryweak。Foraverbalandscholasticaltercationletthemhaveasmuchappearanceastheircontradictors;
"Videantursane,nonaffirmenturmodo;"