Letamanbutobservewhoareofgreatestauthorityincities,andwhobestdotheirownbusiness;weshallfindthattheyarecommonlymenoftheleastparts:women,children,andmadmenhavehadthefortunetogoverngreatkingdomsequallywellwiththewisestprinces,andThucydidessays,thatthestupidmoreordinarilydoitthanthoseofbetterunderstandings;weattributetheeffectsoftheirgoodfortunetotheirprudence:
"UtquisqueFortunautitur,Itapraecellet;atqueexindesapereillumomnesdicimus;"
["HemakeshiswaywhoknowshowtouseFortune,andthereuponweallcallhimwise。"——Plautus,Pseudol。,ii。3,13。]
whereforeIsayunreservedly,eventsareaverypoortestimonyofourworthandparts。
Now,Iwasuponthispoint,thatthereneedsnomorebuttoseeamanpromotedtodignity;thoughweknewhimbutthreedaysbeforeamanoflittleregard,yetanimageofgrandeurofsufficiencyinsensiblystealsintoouropinion,andwepersuadeourselvesthat,beingaugmentedinreputationandtrain,heisalsoincreasedinmerit;wejudgeofhim,notaccordingtohisworth,butaswedobycounters,accordingtotheprerogativeofhisplace。Ifithappensothathefallagain,andbemixedwiththecommoncrowd,everyoneinquireswithamazementintothecauseofhishavingbeenraisedsohigh。"Isthishe,"saythey,"washenowiserwhenhewasthere?Doprincessatisfythemselveswithsolittle?Truly,wewereingoodhands。"ThisisathingthatIhaveoftenseeninmytime。Nay,eventheverydisguiseofgrandeurrepresentedinourcomediesinsomesortmovesandgullsus。ThatwhichImyselfadoreinkingsisthecrowdoftheiradorers;allreverenceandsubmissionareduetothem,exceptthatoftheunderstanding:myreasonisnotobligedtobowandbend;mykneesare。MelanthiusbeingaskedwhathethoughtofthetragedyofDionysius,"Icouldnotseeit,"saidhe,"itwassocloudedwithlanguage";somostofthosewhojudgeofthediscoursesofgreatmenoughttosay,"Ididnotunderstandhiswords,theyweresocloudedwithgravity,grandeur,andmajesty。"AntisthenesonedaytriedtopersuadetheAthenianstogiveorderthattheirassesmightbeemployedintillingthegroundaswellasthehorseswere;towhichitwasansweredthatthatanimalwasnotdestinedforsuchaservice:"That’sallone,"repliedhe,"youhaveonlytoorderit:forthemostignorantandincapablemenyouemployinthecommandsofyourwarsincontinentlybecomeworthyenough,becauseyouemploythem";towhichthecustomofsomanypeople,whocanonisethekingtheyhavechosenoutoftheirownbody,andarenotcontentonlytohonour,butmustadorethem,comesverynear。ThoseofMexico,aftertheceremoniesoftheirking’scoronationareover,darenomorelookhimintheface;
but,asiftheyhaddeifiedhimbyhisroyalty。Amongsttheoathstheymakehimtaketomaintaintheirreligion,theirlaws,andliberties,tobevaliant,just,andmild,hemoreoverswearstomakethesunrunhiscourseinhiswontedlight,todrainthecloudsatfitseasons,tomakeriversruntheircourse,andtocausetheearthtobearallthingsnecessaryforhispeople。
Idifferfromthiscommonfashion,andammoreapttosuspectthecapacitywhenIseeitaccompaniedwiththatgrandeuroffortuneandpublicapplause;wearetoconsiderofwhatadvantageitistospeakwhenamanpleases,tochoosehissubject,tointerruptorchangeit,withamagisterialauthority;toprotecthimselffromtheoppositionsofothersbyanod,asmile,orsilence,inthepresenceofanassemblythattrembleswithreverenceandrespect。Amanofaprodigiousfortunecomingtogivehisjudgmentuponsomeslightdisputethatwasfoolishlysetonfootathistable,beganinthesewords:"Itcanbenootherbutaliarorafoolthatwillsayotherwisethansoandso。"Pursuethisphilosophicalpointwithadaggerinyourhand。
ThereisanotherobservationIhavemade,fromwhichIdrawgreatadvantage;whichis,thatinconferencesanddisputes,everywordthatseemstobegood,isnotimmediatelytobeaccepted。Mostmenarerichinborrowedsufficiency:amanmaysayagoodthing,giveagoodanswer,citeagoodsentence,withoutatallseeingtheforceofeithertheoneortheother。Thatamanmaynotunderstandallheborrows,mayperhapsbeverifiedinmyself。Amanmustnotalwayspresentlyyield,whattruthorbeautysoevermayseemtobeintheoppositeargument;eitherhemuststoutlymeetit,orretire,undercolourofnotunderstandingit,totry,onallparts,howitislodgedintheauthor。Itmayhappenthatweentangleourselves,andhelptostrengthenthepointitself。Ihavesometimes,inthenecessityandheatofthecombat,madeanswersthathavegonethroughandthrough,beyondmyexpectationorhope;Ionlygavetheminnumber,theywerereceivedinweight。As,whenIcontendwithavigorousman,Ipleasemyselfwithanticipatinghisconclusions,Ieasehimofthetroubleofexplaininghimself,Istrivetoforestallhisimaginationwhilstitisyetspringingandimperfect;theorderandpertinencyofhisunderstandingwarnandthreatenmeafaroff:Idealquitecontrarywiththeothers;Imustunderstand,andpresupposenothingbutbythem。Iftheydetermineingeneralwords,"thisisgood,thatisnaught,"andthattheyhappentobeintheright,seeifitbenotfortunethathitsitoffforthem:letthemalittlecircumscribeandlimittheirjudgment;why,orhow,itisso。TheseuniversaljudgmentsthatIseesocommon,signifynothing;thesearemenwhosaluteawholepeopleinacrowdtogether;they,whohavearealacquaintance,takenoticeofandsalutethemindividuallyandbyname。But’tisahazardousattempt;andfromwhichIhave,morethaneveryday,seenitfallout,thatweakunderstandings,havingamindtoappearingenious,intakingnotice,astheyreadabook,ofwhatisbestandmosttobeadmired,fixtheiradmirationuponsomethingsoveryillchosen,thatinsteadofmakingusdiscerntheexcellenceoftheauthor;theymakeusverywellseetheirownignorance。Thisexclamationissafe,"Thatisfine,"afterhavingheardawholepageofVirgil;bythatthecunningsortsavethemselves;buttoundertaketofollowhimlinebyline,and,withanexpertandtriedjudgment,toobservewhereagoodauthorexcelshimself,weighingthewords,phrases,inventions,andhisvariousexcellences,oneafteranother;keepalooffromthat:
"Videndumest,nonmodoquidquisqueloquatur,sedetiamquidquisquesentiat,atqueetiamquadecausaquisquesentiat。"
[Amanisnotonlytoexaminewhateveryonesays,butalsowhateveryonethinks,andfromwhatreasoneveryonethinks。
——"Cicero,DeOffic:,i。41。]
Ieverydayhearfoolssaythingsthatarenotfoolish:theysayagoodthing;letusexaminehowfartheyunderstandit,whencetheyhaveit,andwhattheymeanbyit。Wehelpthemtomakeuseofthisfineexpression,ofthisfinesentence,whichisnoneoftheirs;theyonlyhaveitinkeeping;theyhavebolteditoutataventure;weplaceitforthemincreditandesteem。Youlendthemyourhand。Towhatpurpose?
theydonotthinkthemselvesobligedtoyouforit,andbecomemoreineptstill。Don’thelpthem;letthemalone;theywillhandlethematterlikepeoplewhoareafraidofburningtheirfingers;theydarechangeneitheritsseatnorlight,norbreakintoit;shakeitneversolittle,itslipsthroughtheirfingers;theygiveitup,beitneversostrongorfairtheyarefineweapons,butillhafted:HowmanytimeshaveIseentheexperienceofthis?Now,ifyoucometoexplainanythingtothem,andtoconfirmthem,theycatchatit,andpresentlyrobyouoftheadvantageofyourinterpretation;"ItwaswhatIwasabouttosay;itwasjustmyidea;ifIdidnotexpressitso,itwasforwantoflanguage。"Merewind!Maliceitselfmustbeemployedtocorrectthisarrogantignorance。
ThedogmaofHegesias,"thatweareneithertohatenoraccuse,butinstruct,"iscorrectelsewhere;buthere’tisinjusticeandinhumanitytorelieveandsethimrightwhostandsinnoneedon’t,andistheworsefor’t。Ilovetoletthemstepdeeperintothemire;andsodeep,that,ifitbepossible,theymayatlastdiscerntheirerror。
Follyandabsurdityarenottobecuredbybareadmonition;andwhatCyrusansweredtohim,whoimportunedhimtoharanguehisarmy,uponthepointofbattle,"thatmendonotbecomevaliantandwarlikeuponasudden,byafineoration,nomorethanamanbecomesagoodmusicianbyhearingafinesong,"mayproperlybesaidofsuchanadmonitionasthis。
Theseareapprenticeshipsthataretobeservedbeforehand,byalongandcontinuededucation。Weowethiscareandthisassiduityofcorrectionandinstructiontoourownpeople;buttogopreachtothefirstpasser—
by,andtobecometutortotheignoranceandfollyofthefirstwemeet,isathingthatIabhor。Irarelydoit,eveninprivateconversation,andrathergiveupthewholethingthanproceedtotheseinitiatoryandschoolinstructions;myhumourisunfiteithertospeakorwriteforbeginners;butforthingsthataresaidincommondiscourse,oramongstotherthings,Ineveropposethemeitherbywordorsign,howfalseorabsurdsoever。
Astotherest,nothingvexesmesomuchinfollyasthatitismoresatisfiedwithitselfthananyreasoncanreasonablybe。’Tisunfortunatethatprudenceforbidsustosatisfyandtrustourselves,andalwaysdismissesustimorousanddiscontented;whereasobstinacyandtemerityfillthosewhoarepossessedwiththemwithjoyandassurance。
’Tisforthemostignoranttolookatothermenovertheshoulder,alwaysreturningfromthecombatfullofjoyandtriumph。Andmoreover,forthemostpart,thisarroganceofspeechandgaietyofcountenancegivesthemthebetterofitintheopinionoftheaudience,whichiscommonlyweakandincapableofwelljudginganddiscerningtherealadvantage。
Obstinacyofopinionandheatinargumentarethesurestproofsoffolly;
isthereanythingsoassured,resolute,disdainful,contemplative,seriousandgraveastheass?
Maywenotincludeunderthetitleofconferenceandcommunicationthequickandsharpreparteeswhichmirthandfamiliarityintroduceamongstfriends,pleasantlyandwittilyjestingandrallyingwithoneanother?
’Tisanexerciseforwhichmynaturalgaietyrendersmefitenough,andwhich,ifitbenotsotenseandseriousastheotherIspokeofbutnow,is,asLycurgusthought,nolesssmartandingenious,noroflessutility。Formypart,Icontributetoitmorelibertythanwit,andhavethereinmoreofluckthaninvention;butIamperfectinsuffering,forI
endurearetaliationthatisnotonlytart,butindiscreettoboot,withoutbeingmovedatall;andwhoeverattacksme,ifIhavenotabriskanswerimmediatelyready,Idonotstudytopursuethepointwithatediousandimpertinentcontest,borderinguponobstinacy,butletitpass,andhangingdowncheerfullymyears,defermyrevengetoanotherandbettertime:thereisnomerchantthatalwaysgains:Mostmenchangetheircountenanceandtheirvoicewheretheirwitsfail,andbyanunseasonableanger,insteadofrevengingthemselves,accuseatoncetheirownfollyandimpatience。Inthisjollity,wesometimespinchthesecretstringsofourimperfectionswhich,atanotherandgravertime,wecannottouchwithoutoffence,andsoprofitablygiveoneanotherahintofourdefects。Thereareotherjeuxdemain,——[practicaljokes]——rudeandindiscreet,aftertheFrenchmanner,thatImortallyhate;myskinisverytenderandsensible:Ihaveinmytimeseentwoprincesofthebloodburieduponthatveryaccount。’Tisunhandsometofightinplay。Astotherest,whenIhaveamindtojudgeofanyone,Iaskhimhowfarheiscontentedwithhimself;towhatdegreehisspeakingorhisworkpleaseshim。Iwillnoneofthesefineexcuses,"Ididitonlyinsport:
’Ablatummediisopusestincudibusistud。’
["Thatworkwastakenfromtheanvilhalffinished。"
——Ovid,Trist。,i。6,29。]
Iwasnotanhouraboutit:Ihaveneverlookedatitsince。"Well,then,sayI,laytheseaside,andgivemeaperfectone,suchasyouwouldbemeasuredby。Andthen,whatdoyouthinkisthebestthinginyourwork?isitthispartorthat?isitgraceorthematter,theinvention,thejudgment,orthelearning?ForIfindthatmenare,commonly,aswideofthemarkinjudgingoftheirownworks,asofthoseofothers;notonlybyreasonofthekindnesstheyhaveforthem,butforwantofcapacitytoknowanddistinguishthem:thework,byitsownforceandfortune,maysecondtheworkman,andsometimesoutstriphim,beyondhisinventionandknowledge。Formypart,Ijudgeofthevalueofothermen’sworksmoreobscurelythanofmyown;andplacetheEssays,nowhigh,orlow,withgreatdoubtandinconstancy。Thereareseveralbooksthatareusefulupontheaccountoftheirsubjects,fromwhichtheauthorderivesnopraise;andgoodbooks,aswellasgoodworks,thatshametheworkman。Imaywritethemannerofourfeasts,andthefashionofourclothes,andmaywritethemill;Imaypublishtheedictsofmytime,andthelettersofprincesthatpassfromhandtohand;Imaymakeanabridgmentofagoodbook(andeveryabridgmentofagoodbookisafoolishabridgment),whichbookshallcometobelost;andsoon:
posteritywillderiveasingularutilityfromsuchcompositions:butwhathonourshallIhaveunlessbygreatgoodfortune?Mostpartofthefamousbooksareofthiscondition。
WhenIreadPhilipdeCommines,doubtlessaverygoodauthor,severalyearsago,Itheretooknoticeofthisfornovulgarsaying,"Thatamanmusthaveacarenottodohismastersogreatservice,thatatlasthewillnotknowhowtogivehimhisjustreward";butIoughttocommendtheinvention,nothim,becauseImetwithitinTacitus,notlongsince:
"Beneficiaeausquelxtasunt,dumvidenturexsolviposse;
ubimultumantevenere,progratisodiumredditur;"
["Benefitsaresofaracceptableastheyappeartobecapableofrecompense;wheretheymuchexceedthatpoint,hatredisreturnedinsteadofthanks。"——Tacitus,Annal。,iv。18。]
andSenecavigorouslysays:
"Namquiputatesseturpenonreddere,nonvultessecuireddat:"
["Forhewhothinksitashamenottorequite,doesnotwishtohavethemanlivetowhomheowesreturn。"——Seneca,Ep。,81。]
Q。Cicerosayswithlessdirectness。:
"Quisenonputatsatisfacere,amicusessenullomodopotest。"
["Whothinkshimselfbehindinobligation,canbynomeansbeafriend。"——Q。Cicero,DePetitioneConsul,c。9。]
Thesubject,accordingtowhatitis,maymakeamanlookeduponaslearnedandofgoodmemory;buttojudgeinhimthepartsthataremosthisownandthemostworthy,thevigourandbeautyofhissoul,onemustfirstknowwhatishisownandwhatisnot;andinthatwhichisnothisown,howmuchweareobligedtohimforthechoice,disposition,ornament,andlanguagehehastherepresenteduswith。Whatifhehasborrowedthematterandspoiledtheform,asitoftenfallsout?We,whoarelittlereadinbooks,areinthisstrait,thatwhenwemeetwithahighfancyinsomenewpoet,orsomestrongargumentinapreacher,wedarenot,nevertheless,commendittillwehavefirstinformedourselves,throughsomelearnedman,ifitbethewriter’switorborrowedfromsomeother;untilthatIalwaysstanduponmyguard。
IhavelatelybeenreadingthehistoryofTacitusquitethrough,withoutinterruptingitwithanythingelse(whichbutseldomhappenswithme,itbeingtwentyyearssinceIhavekepttoanyonebookanhourtogether),andIdiditattheinstanceofagentlemanforwhomFrancehasagreatesteem,aswellforhisownparticularworth,asupontheaccountofaconstantformofcapacityandvirtuewhichrunsthroughagreatmanybrothersofthem。Idonotknowanyauthorinapublicnarrativewhomixessomuchconsiderationofmannersandparticularinclinations:andI
amofaquitecontraryopiniontohim,holdingthat,havingespeciallytofollowthelivesoftheemperorsofhistime,sovariousandextremeinallsortsofforms,somanynotableactionsastheircrueltyespeciallyproducedintheirsubjects,hehadastrongerandmoreattractivemattertotreatofthanifhehadhadtodescribebattlesanduniversalcommotions;sothatIoftenfindhimsterile,runningoverthosebravedeathsasifhefearedtotroubleuswiththeirmultitudeandlength。
Thisformofhistoryisbymuchthemostuseful;publicmovementsdependmostupontheconductoffortune,privateonesuponourown。’Tisratherajudgmentthananarrationofhistory;thereareinitmorepreceptsthanstories:itisnotabooktoread,’tisabooktostudyandlearn;
’tisfullofsententiousopinions,rightorwrong;’tisanurseryofethicandpoliticdiscourses,fortheuseandornamentofthosewhohaveanyplaceinthegovernmentoftheworld。Healwaysarguesbystrongandsolidreasons,afterapointedandsubtlemanner,accordingtotheaffectedstyleofthatage,whichwassoinlovewithaninflatedmanner,thatwherepointandsubtletywerewantinginthingsitsuppliedthesewithloftyandswellingwords。’TisnotmuchunlikethestyleofSeneca:
IlookuponTacitusasmoresinewy,andSenecaasmoresharp。Hispenseemsmostproperforatroubledandsickstate,asoursatpresentis;
youwouldoftensaythathepaintsandpinchesus。
Theywhodoubthisgoodfaithsufficientlyaccusethemselvesofbeinghisenemyuponsomeotheraccount。Hisopinionsaresound,andleantotherightsideintheRomanaffairs。AndyetIamangryathimforjudgingmoreseverelyofPompeythanconsistswiththeopinionofthoseworthymenwholivedinthesametime,andhaddealingswithhim;andtohavereputedhimonaparwithMariusandSylla,exceptingthathewasmoreclose。Otherwritershavenotacquittedhisintentioninthegovernmentofaffairsfromambitionandrevenge;andevenhisfriendswereafraidthatvictorywouldhavetransportedhimbeyondtheboundsofreason,butnottosoimmeasurableadegreeastheirs;nothinginhislifethreatenedsuchexpresscrueltyandtyranny。Neitheroughtwetosetsuspicionagainstevidence;andthereforeIdonotbelievePlutarchinthismatter。
Thathisnarrationsweregenuineandstraightforwardmay,perhaps,bearguedfromthisverything,thattheydonotalwaysapplytotheconclusionsofhisjudgments,whichhefollowsaccordingtothebiashehastaken,veryoftenbeyondthematterhepresentsuswithal,whichhehasnotdeignedtoalterintheleastdegree。Heneedsnoexcuseforhavingapprovedthereligionofhistime,accordingasthelawsenjoined,andtohavebeenignorantofthetrue;thiswashismisfortune,nothisfault。
Ihaveprincipallyconsideredhisjudgment,andamnotverywellsatisfiedtherewiththroughout;asthesewordsintheletterthatTiberius,oldandsick,senttothesenate。"WhatshallIwritetoyou,sirs,orhowshouldIwritetoyou,orwhatshouldInotwritetoyouatthistime?MaythegodsandgoddesseslayaworsepunishmentuponmethanIameverydaytormentedwith,ifIknow!"IdonotseewhyheshouldsopositivelyapplythemtoasharpremorsethattormentedtheconscienceofTiberius;atleast,whenIwasinthesamecondition,I
perceivednosuchthing。
Andthisalsoseemedtomealittlemeaninhimthat,havingtosaythathehadborneanhonourableofficeinRome,heexcuseshimselfthathedoesnotsayitoutofostentation;thisseems,Isay,meanforsuchasoulashis;fornottospeakroundlyofaman’sselfimpliessomewantofcourage;amanofsolidandloftyjudgment,whojudgessoundlyandsurely,makesuseofhisownexampleuponalloccasions,aswellasthoseofothers;andgivesevidenceasfreelyofhimselfasofathirdperson。
Wearetopassbythesecommonrulesofcivility,infavouroftruthandliberty。Idarenotonlyspeakofmyself,buttospeakonlyofmyself:
whenIwriteofanythingelse,Imissmywayandwanderfrommysubject。
Iamnotsoindiscreetlyenamouredofmyself,sowhollymixedupwith,andboundtomyself,thatIcannotdistinguishandconsidermyselfapart,asIdoaneighbouroratree:’tisequallyafaultnottodiscernhowfaraman’sworthextends,andtosaymorethanamandiscoversinhimself。WeowemorelovetoGodthantoourselves,andknowHimless;
andyetspeakofHimasmuchaswewill。
IfthewritingsofTacitusindicateanythingtrueofhisqualities,hewasagreatpersonage,uprightandbold,notofasuperstitiousbutofaphilosophicalandgenerousvirtue。Onemaythinkhimboldinhisrelations;aswherehetellsus,thatasoldiercarryingaburdenofwood,hishandsweresofrozenandsostucktotheloadthattheythereremainedclosedanddead,beingseveredfromhisarms。Ialwaysinsuchthingsbowtotheauthorityofsogreatwitnesses。
Whatalsohesays,thatVespasian,bythefavourofthegodSerapis,curedablindwomanatAlexandriabyanointinghereyeswithhisspittle,andIknownotwhatothermiracle,"hesaysbytheexampleanddutyofallhisgoodhistorians。Theyrecordalleventsofimportance;andamongstpublicincidentsarethepopularrumoursandopinions。’Tistheirparttorelatecommonbeliefs,nottoregulatethem:thatpartconcernsdivinesandphilosophers,directorsofconsciences;andthereforeitwasthatthiscompanionofhis,andagreatmanlikehimself,verywiselysaid:
"Equidempluratranscribo,quamcredo:namnecaffirmaresustineo,dequibusdubito,necsubducerequaeaccepi;"
["Truly,IsetdownmorethingsthanIbelieve,forIcanneitheraffirmthingswhereofIdoubt,norsuppresswhatIhaveheard。"
——"QuintusCurtius,ix。]
andthisother:
"Haecnequeaffirmarenequerefellereoperaepretiumest;famaererumstandumest。"
[’Tisneitherworththewhiletoaffirmortorefutethesethings;
wemuststandtoreport"——Livy,i。,Praef。,andviii。6。]
Andwritinginanagewhereinthebeliefofprodigiesbegantodecline,hesayshewouldnot,nevertheless,forbeartoinsertinhisAnnals,andtogivearelationofthingsreceivedbysomanyworthymen,andwithsogreatreverenceofantiquity;’tisverywellsaid。Letthemdelivertoushistory,moreastheyreceiveitthanastheybelieveit。I,whoammonarchofthematterwhereofItreat,andwhoamaccountabletonone,donot,nevertheless,alwaysbelievemyself;Ioftenhazardsalliesofmyownwit,whereinIverymuchsuspectmyself,andcertainverbalquibbles,atwhichIshakemyears;butIletthemgoataventure。Iseethatothersgetreputationbysuchthings:’tisnotformealonetojudge。I
presentmyselfstandingandlying,beforeandbehind,myrightsideandmyleft,and,inallmynaturalpostures。Wits,thoughequalinforce,arenotalwaysequalintasteandapplication。
Thisiswhatmymemorypresentstomeingross,andwithuncertaintyenough;alljudgmentsingrossareweakandimperfect。
EndTheEssaysofMontaigne,V17
byMicheldeMontaigneTranslatedbyCharlesCottonEditedbyWilliamCarewHazilitt1877
CONTENTSOFVOLUME17。
IX。OfVanityCHAPTERIX
OFVANITY
Thereis,peradventure,nomoremanifestvanitythantowriteofitsovainly。Thatwhichdivinityhassodivinelyexpressedtous——["Vanityofvanities:allisvanity。"——Eccles。,i。2。]——oughttobecarefullyandcontinuallymeditatedbymenofunderstanding。WhodoesnotseethatI
havetakenaroad,inwhich,incessantlyandwithoutlabour,Ishallproceedsolongasthereshallbeinkandpaperintheworld?Icangivenoaccountofmylifebymyactions;fortunehasplacedthemtoolow:I
mustdoitbymyfancies。AndyetIhaveseenagentlemanwhoonlycommunicatedhislifebytheworkingsofhisbelly:youmightseeonhispremisesashowofarowofbasinsofsevenoreightdays’standing;itwashisstudy,hisdiscourse;allothertalkstankinhisnostrils。
Here,butnotsonauseous,aretheexcrementsofanoldmind,sometimesthick,sometimesthin,andalwaysindigested。AndwhenshallIhavedonerepresentingthecontinualagitationandmutationofmythoughts,astheycomeintomyhead,seeingthatDiomedeswrotesixthousandbooksuponthesolesubjectofgrammar?
[ItwasnotDiomedes,butDidymusthegrammarian,who,asSeneca(Ep。,88)tellsus,wrotefournotsixthousandbooksonquestionsofvainliterature,whichwastheprincipalstudyoftheancientgrammarian。——Coste。Butthenumberisprobablyexaggerated,andforbooksweshoulddoubtlessreadpamphletsoressays。]
What,then,oughtpratingtoproduce,sinceprattlingandthefirstbeginningtospeak,stuffedtheworldwithsuchahorribleloadofvolumes?Somanywordsforwordsonly。OPythagoras,whydidstnotthouallaythistempest?TheyaccusedoneGalbaofoldforlivingidly;hemadeanswer,"Thateveryoneoughttogiveaccountofhisactions,butnotofhishome。"Hewasmistaken,forjusticealsotakescognisanceofthosewhogleanafterthereaper。
Butthereshouldbesomerestraintoflawagainstfoolishandimpertinentscribblers,aswellasagainstvagabondsandidlepersons;whichiftherewere,bothIandahundredotherswouldbebanishedfromthereachofourpeople。Idonotspeakthisinjest:scribblingseemstobeasymptomofadisorderedandlicentiousage。Whendidwewritesomuchassinceourtroubles?whentheRomanssomuch,asuponthepointofruin?Besidesthat,therefiningofwitsdoesnotmakepeoplewiserinagovernment:
thisidleemploymentspringsfromthis,thateveryoneapplieshimselfnegligentlytothedutyofhisvocation,andiseasilydebauchedfromit。
Thecorruptionoftheageismadeupbytheparticularcontributionofeveryindividualman;somecontributetreachery,othersinjustice,irreligion,tyranny,avarice,cruelty,accordingtotheirpower;theweakersortcontributefolly,vanity,andidleness;oftheseIamone。
Itseemsasifitweretheseasonforvainthings,whenthehurtfuloppressus;inatimewhendoingilliscommon,todobutwhatsignifiesnothingisakindofcommendation。’Tismycomfort,thatIshallbeoneofthelastwhoshallbecalledinquestion;andwhilstthegreateroffendersarebeingbroughttoaccount,Ishallhaveleisuretoamend:
foritwould,methinks,beagainstreasontopunishlittleinconveniences,whilstweareinfestedwiththegreater。AsthephysicianPhilotimussaidtoonewhopresentedhimhisfingertodress,andwhoheperceived,bothbyhiscomplexionandhisbreath,hadanulcerinhislungs:"Friend,itisnotnowtimetoplaywithyournails。"——
[Plutarch,HowwemaydistinguishaFlattererfromaFriend。]
AndyetIsaw,someyearsago,aperson,whosenameandmemoryIhaveinverygreatesteem,intheveryheightofourgreatdisorders,whentherewasneitherlawnorjustice,normagistratewhoperformedhisoffice,nomorethanthereisnow,publishIknownotwhatpitifulreformationsaboutcloths,cookery,andlawchicanery。Thoseareamusementswherewithtofeedapeoplethatareill—used,toshowthattheyarenottotallyforgotten。Thoseothersdothesame,whoinsistuponprohibitingparticularwaysofspeaking,dances,andgames,toapeopletotallyabandonedtoallsortsofexecrablevices。’Tisnotimetobatheandcleanseone’sself,whenoneisseizedbyaviolentfever;itwasfortheSpartansalonetofalltocombingandcurlingthemselves,whentheywerejustuponthepointofrunningheadlongintosomeextremedangeroftheirlife。
Formypart,Ihavethatworsecustom,thatifmyslippergoawry,Iletmyshirtandmycloakdosotoo;Iscorntomendmyselfbyhalves。
WhenIaminabadplight,Ifastenuponthemischief;Iabandonmyselfthroughdespair;Iletmyselfgotowardstheprecipice,and,astheysay,"throwthehelveafterthehatchet";Iamobstinateingrowingworse,andthinkmyselfnolongerworthmyowncare;Iameitherwellorillthroughout。’Tisafavourtome,thatthedesolationofthiskingdomfallsoutinthedesolationofmyage:Ibettersufferthatmyillbemultiplied,thanifmywellhadbeendisturbed。——[That,beingill,I
shouldgrowworse,thanthat,beingwell,Ishouldgrowill。]——ThewordsIutterinmishaparewordsofanger:mycouragesetsupitsbristles,insteadoflettingthemdown;and,contrarytoothers,Iammoredevoutingoodthaninevilfortune,accordingtothepreceptofXenophon,ifnotaccordingtohisreason;andammorereadytoturnupmyeyestoheaventoreturnthanks,thantocrave。Iammoresolicitoustoimprovemyhealth,whenIamwell,thantorestoreitwhenIamsick;
prosperitiesarethesamedisciplineandinstructiontomethatadversitiesandrodsaretoothers。Asifgoodfortunewereathinginconsistentwithgoodconscience,mennevergrowgoodbutinevilfortune。Goodfortuneistomeasingularspurtomodestyandmoderation:anentreatywins,athreatchecksme;favourmakesmebend,fearstiffensme。
Amongsthumanconditionsthisiscommonenough:tobebetterpleasedwithforeignthingsthanwithourown,andtoloveinnovationandchange:
"Ipsadiesideonosgratoperluithaustu,Quodpermutatishorarecurritequis:"
["Thelightofdayitselfshinesmorepleasantlyuponusbecauseitchangesitshorseseveryhour。"Spokeofawaterhour—glass,addsCotton。]
Ihavemyshare。Thosewhofollowtheotherextreme,ofbeingquitesatisfiedandpleasedwithandinthemselves,ofvaluingwhattheyhaveabovealltherest,andofconcludingnobeautycanbegreaterthanwhattheysee,iftheyarenotwiserthanwe,arereallymorehappy;Idonotenvytheirwisdom,buttheirgoodfortune。
Thisgreedyhumourofnewandunknownthingshelpstonourishinmethedesireoftravel;butagreatmanymorecircumstancescontributetoit;
Iamverywillingtoquitthegovernmentofmyhouse。Thereis,I
confess,akindofconvenienceincommanding,thoughitwerebutinabarn,andinbeingobeyedbyone’speople;but’tistoouniformandlanguidapleasure,andis,moreover,ofnecessitymixedwithathousandvexatiousthoughts:onewhilethepovertyandtheoppressionofyourtenants:another,quarrelsamongstneighbours:another,thetrespassestheymakeuponyouafflictyou;
"Autverberataegrandinevineae,Fundusquemendax,arborenuncaquasCulpante,nunctorrentiaagrosSidera,nunchyemesiniquas。"
["Orhail—smittenvinesandthedeceptivefarm;nowtreesdamagedbytherains,oryearsofdearth,nowsummer’sheatburningupthepetals,nowdestructivewinters。"——Horatius,Od。,iii。I,29。]
andthatGodscarceinsixmonthssendsaseasonwhereinyourbailiffcandohisbusinessasheshould;butthatifitservesthevines,itspoilsthemeadows:
"Autnimiistorretfervoribusaetheriussol,Autsubitiperimuntimbres,gelidoequepruinae,Flabraqueventorumviolentoturbinevexant;"
["Eitherthescorchingsunburnsupyourfields,orsuddenrainsorfrostsdestroyyourharvests,oraviolentwindcarriesawayallbeforeit。"——Lucretius,V。216。]
towhichmaybeaddedthenewandneat—madeshoeofthemanofold,thathurtsyourfoot,[LeclercmaliciouslysuggeststhatthisisaslyhitatMontaigne’swife,themanofoldbeingthepersonmentionedinPlutarch’sLifeofPaulusEmilius,c。3,who,whenhisfriendsreproachedhimforrepudiatinghiswife,whosevariousmeritstheyextolled,pointedtohisshoe,andsaid,"Thatlooksanicewell—madeshoetoyou;butI
aloneknowwhereitpinches。"]
andthatastrangerdoesnotunderstandhowmuchitcostsyou,andwhatyoucontributetomaintainthatshowoforderthatisseeninyourfamily,andthatperadventureyoubuytoodear。
Icamelatetothegovernmentofahouse:theywhomnaturesentintotheworldbeforemelongeasedmeofthattrouble;sothatIhadalreadytakenanotherbentmoresuitabletomyhumour。Yet,forsomuchasI
haveseen,’tisanemploymentmoretroublesomethanhard;whoeveriscapableofanythingelse,willeasilydothis。HadIamindtoberich,thatwaywouldseemtoolong;Ihadservedmykings,amoreprofitabletrafficthananyother。SinceIpretendtonothingbutthereputationofhavinggotnothingordissipatednothing,conformablytotherestofmylife,impropereithertodogoodorillofanymoment,andthatIonlydesiretopasson,Icandoit,thanksbetoGod,withoutanygreatendeavour。Attheworst,evermorepreventpovertybylesseningyourexpense;’tisthatwhichImakemygreatconcern,anddoubtnotbuttodoitbeforeIshallbecompelled。Astotherest,IhavesufficientlysettledmythoughtstoliveuponlessthanIhave,andlivecontentedly:
"Nonaestimationecensus,verumvictuatquecultu,terminanturpecunixmodus。"
["’Tisnotbythevalueofpossessions,butbyourdailysubsistenceandtillage,thatourrichesaretrulyestimated。"
——Cicero,Paradox,vi。3。]
MyrealneeddoesnotsowhollytakeupallIhave,thatFortunehasnotwhereontofastenherteethwithoutbitingtothequick。Mypresence,heedlessandignorantasitis,doesmegreatserviceinmydomesticaffairs;Iemploymyselfinthem,butitgoesagainstthehair,findingthatIhavethisinmyhouse,thatthoughIburnmycandleatoneendbymyself,theotherisnotspared。
Journeysdomenoharmbutonlybytheirexpense,whichisgreat,andmorethanIamwellabletobear,beingalwayswonttotravelwithnotonlyanecessary,butahandsomeequipage;Imustmakethemsomuchshorterandfewer;Ispendthereinbutthefroth,andwhatIhavereservedforsuchuses,delayinganddeferringmymotiontillthatbeready。Iwillnotthatthepleasureofgoingabroadspoilthepleasureofbeingretiredathome;onthecontrary,Iintendtheyshallnourishandfavouroneanother。Fortunehasassistedmeinthis,thatsincemyprincipalprofessioninthislifewastoliveatease,andratheridlythanbusily,shehasdeprivedmeofthenecessityofgrowingrichtoprovideforthemultitudeofmyheirs。Iftherebenotenoughforone,ofthatwhereofIhadsoplentifullyenough,athisperilbeit:hisimprudencewillnotdeservethatIshouldwishhimanymore。Andeveryone,accordingtotheexampleofPhocion,providessufficientlyforhischildrenwhosoprovidesforthemastoleavethemasmuchaswaslefthim。IshouldbynomeanslikeCrates’way。Helefthismoneyinthehandsofabankerwiththiscondition——thatifhischildrenwerefools,heshouldthengiveittothem;ifwise,heshouldthendistributeittothemostfoolishofthepeople;asiffools,forbeinglesscapableoflivingwithoutriches,weremorecapableofusingthem。
Atallevents,thedamageoccasionedbymyabsenceseemsnottodeserve,solongasIamabletosupportit,thatIshouldwaivetheoccasionsofdivertingmyselfbythattroublesomeassistance。
Thereisalwayssomethingthatgoesamiss。Theaffairs,onewhileofonehouse,andthenofanother,tearyoutopieces;youpryintoeverythingtoonear;yourperspicacityhurtsyouhere,aswellasinotherthings。
Istealawayfromoccasionsofvexingmyself,andturnfromtheknowledgeofthingsthatgoamiss;andyetIcannotsoorderit,butthateveryhourIjostleagainstsomethingorotherthatdispleasesme;andthetricksthattheymostconcealfromme,arethosethatIthesoonestcometoknow;sometherearethat,nottomakemattersworse,amanmusthimselfhelptoconceal。Vainvexations;vainsometimes,butalwaysvexations。Thesmallestandslightestimpedimentsarethemostpiercing:
andaslittlelettersmosttiretheeyes,sodolittleaffairsmostdisturbus。Theroutoflittleillsmoreoffendthanone,howgreatsoever。Byhowmuchdomesticthornsarenumerousandslight,bysomuchtheyprickdeeperandwithoutwarning,easilysurprisinguswhenleastwesuspectthem。
[NowHomershewsusclearlyenoughhowsurprisegivestheadvantage;
whorepresentsUlyssesweepingatthedeathofhisdog;andnotweepingatthetearsofhismother;thefirstaccident,trivialasitwas,gotthebetterofhim,cominguponhimquiteunexpectedly;
hesustainedthesecond,thoughmorepotent,becausehewaspreparedforit。’Tislightoccasionsthathumbleourlives。]
Iamnophilosopher;evilsoppressmeaccordingtotheirweight,andtheyweighasmuchaccordingtotheformasthematter,andveryoftenmore。
IfIhavethereinmoreperspicacitythanthevulgar,Ihavealsomorepatience;inshort,theyweighwithme,iftheydonothurtme。Lifeisatenderthing,andeasilymolested。Sincemyagehasmademegrowmorepensiveandmorose,"Nemoenimresistitsibi,cumcaeperitimpelli,"
["Fornomanresistshimselfwhenhehasbeguntobedrivenforward。"——Seneca,Ep。,13。]
forthemosttrivialcauseimaginable,Iirritatethathumour,whichafterwardsnourishesandexasperatesitselfofitsownmotion;attractingandheapingupmatteruponmatterwhereontofeed:
"Stillicidicasuslapidemcavat:"
["Theeverfallingdrophollowsoutastone。"——Lucretius,i。314。]
thesecontinualtricklingsconsumeandulcerateme。Ordinaryinconveniencesareneverlight;theyarecontinualandinseparable,especiallywhentheyspringfromthemembersofafamily,continualandinseparable。WhenIconsidermyaffairsatdistanceandingross,I
find,becauseperhapsmymemoryisnoneofthebest,thattheyhavegoneonhithertoimprovingbeyondmyreasonorexpectation;myrevenueseemsgreaterthanitis;itsprosperitybetraysme:butwhenIprymorenarrowlyintothebusiness,andseehowallthingsgo:
"Tumveroincurasanimumdiducimusomnes;"
["Indeedweleadthemindintoallsortsofcares。"
——AEneid,v。720。]
Ihaveathousandthingstodesireandtofear。Togivethemquiteover,isveryeasyformetodo:buttolookafterthemwithouttrouble,isveryhard。’Tisamiserablethingtobeinaplacewhereeverythingyouseeemploysandconcernsyou;andIfancythatImorecheerfullyenjoythepleasuresofanotherman’shouse,andwithgreaterandapurerrelish,thanthoseofmyown。Diogenesansweredaccordingtomyhumourhimwhoaskedhimwhatsortofwinehelikedthebest:"Thatofanother,"
saidhe。——[DiogenesLaertius,vi。54。]
MyfathertookadelightinbuildingatMontaigne,wherehewasborn;andinallthegovernmentofdomesticaffairsIlovetofollowhisexampleandrules,andIshallengagethosewhoaretosucceedme,asmuchasinmelies,todothesame。CouldIdobetterforhim,Iwould;andamproudthathiswillisstillperformingandactingbyme。GodforbidthatinmyhandsIshouldeversufferanyimageoflife,thatIamabletorendertosogoodafather,tofail。AndwhereverIhavetakeninhandtostrengthensomeoldfoundationsofwalls,andtorepairsomeruinousbuildings,inearnestIhavedoneitmoreoutofrespecttohisdesign,thanmyownsatisfaction;andamangryatmyselfthatIhavenotproceededfurthertofinishthebeginningsheleftinhishouse,andsomuchthemorebecauseIamverylikelytobethelastpossessorofmyrace,andtogivethelasthandtoit。For,astomyownparticularapplication,neitherthepleasureofbuilding,whichtheysayissobewitching,norhunting,norgardens,northeotherpleasuresofaretiredlife,canmuchamuseme。And’tiswhatIamangryatmyselffor,asIamforallotheropinionsthatareincommodioustome;whichIwouldnotsomuchcaretohavevigorousandlearned,asIwouldhavethemeasyandconvenientforlife,theyaretrueandsoundenough,iftheyareusefulandpleasing。Suchashearmedeclaremyignoranceinhusbandry,whisperinmyearthatitisdisdain,andthatIneglecttoknowitsinstruments,itsseasons,itsorder,howtheydressmyvines,howtheygraft,andtoknowthenamesandformsofherbsandfruits,andthepreparingthemeatonwhichIlive,thenamesandpricesofthestuffsI
wear,because,saythey;Ihavesetmyheartuponsomehigherknowledge;
theykillmeinsayingso。Itisnotdisdain;itisfolly,andratherstupiditythanglory;Ihadratherbeagoodhorsemanthanagoodlogician:
"Quintoaliquidsaltempotius,quorumindigetusus,Viminibusmolliqueparasdetexerejunco。"
["’Dostthounotratherdosomethingwhichisrequired,andmakeosierandreedbasket。"——Virgil,Eclog。,ii。71。]
Weoccupyourthoughtsaboutthegeneral,andaboutuniversalcausesandconducts,whichwillverywellcarryonthemselveswithoutourcare;andleaveourownbusinessatrandom,andMichaelmuchmoreourconcernthanman。NowIam,indeed,forthemostpartathome;butIwouldbetherebetterpleasedthananywhereelse:
"Sitmeaesedesutinamsenectae,Sitmoduslassomaris,etviarum,Militiaeque。"
["Letmyoldagehaveafixedseat;lettherebealimittofatiguesfromthesea,journeys,warfare。"——Horace,Od。,ii。6,6。]