首页 >出版文学> The Essays of Montaigne>第28章
  Allthings,saysanoldadage,aretobehopedforbyamanwhilsthelives;ay,but,repliesSeneca,whyshouldthisratherbealwaysrunninginaman’sheadthatfortunecandoallthingsforthelivingman,thanthis,thatfortunehasnopoweroverhimthatknowshowtodie?
  Josephus,whenengagedinsonearandapparentdanger,awholepeoplebeingviolentlybentagainsthim,thattherewasnovisiblemeansofescape,nevertheless,being,ashehimselfsays,inthisextremitycounselledbyoneofhisfriendstodespatchhimself,itwaswellforhimthatheyetmaintainedhimselfinhope,forfortunedivertedtheaccidentbeyondallhumanexpectation,sothathesawhimselfdeliveredwithoutanymannerofinconvenience。WhereasBrutusandCassius,onthecontrary,threwawaytheremainsoftheRomanliberty,ofwhichtheywerethesoleprotectors,bytheprecipitationandtemeritywherewiththeykilledthemselvesbeforetheduetimeandajustoccasion。Monsieurd’Anguien,atthebattleofSerisolles,twiceattemptedtorunhimselfthrough,despairingofthefortuneoftheday,whichwentindeedveryuntowardlyonthatsideofthefieldwherehewasengaged,andbythatprecipitationwasveryneardeprivinghimselfoftheenjoymentofsobraveavictory。Ihaveseenahundredharesescapeoutoftheveryteethofthegreyhounds:
  "Aliquiscarnificisuosuperstesfuit。"
  ["Somehavesurvivedtheirexecutioners。"——Seneca,Ep。,13。]
  "Multadies,variusquelabormutabilisneviRettulitinmelius;multosalternarevisensLusit,etinsolidorursusfortunalocavit。"
  [Lengthofdays,andthevariouslabourofchangefultime,havebroughtthingstoabetterstate;fortuneturning,shewsareverseface,andagainrestoresmentoprosperity。"——AEneid,xi。425。]
  Pinysaystherearebutthreesortsofdiseases,toescapewhichamanhasgoodtitletodestroyhimself;theworstofwhichisthestoneinthebladder,whentheurineissuppressed。
  ["Inthequartoeditionoftheseessays,in1588,Plinyissaidtomentiontwomore,viz。,apaininthestomachandaheadache,which,hesays(lib。xxv。c。9。),weretheonlythreedistempersalmostforwhichmenkilledthemselves。"]
  Senecasaysthoseonlywhichforalongtimearediscomposingthefunctionsofthesoul。Andsometherehavebeenwho,toavoidaworsedeath,havechosenonetotheirownliking。Democritus,generaloftheAEtolians,beingbroughtprisonertoRome,foundmeanstomakehisescapebynight:butclosepursuedbyhiskeepers,ratherthansufferhimselftoberetaken,hefelluponhisownswordanddied。AntinousandTheodotus,theircityofEpirusbeingreducedbytheRomanstothelastextremity,gavethepeoplecounseluniversallytokillthemselves;but,thesepreferringtogivethemselvesuptotheenemy,thetwochiefswenttoseekthedeaththeydesired,rushingfuriouslyupontheenemy,withintentiontostrikehomebutnottowardablow。TheIslandofGozzobeingtakensomeyearsagobytheTurks,aSicilian,whohadtwobeautifuldaughtersmarriageable,killedthembothwithhisownhand,andtheirmother,runningintosavethem,toboot,whichhavingdone,sallyingoutofthehousewithacross—bowandharquebus,withtwoshotshekilledtwooftheTurksnearesttohisdoor,anddrawinghissword,chargedfuriouslyinamongsttherest,wherehewassuddenlyenclosedandcuttopieces,bythatmeansdeliveringhisfamilyandhimselffromslaveryanddishonour。TheJewishwomen,afterhavingcircumcisedtheirchildren,threwthemandthemselvesdownaprecipicetoavoidthecrueltyofAntigonus。Ihavebeentoldofapersonofconditioninoneofourprisons,thathisfriends,beinginformedthathewouldcertainlybecondemned,toavoidtheignominyofsuchadeathsubornedapriesttotellhimthattheonlymeansofhisdeliverancewastorecommendhimselftosuchasaint,undersuchandsuchvows,andtofasteightdaystogetherwithouttakinganymannerofnourishment,whatweaknessorfaintnesssoeverhemightfindinhimselfduringthetime;hefollowedtheiradvice,andbythatmeansdestroyedhimselfbeforehewasaware,notdreamingofdeathoranydangerintheexperiment。ScriboniaadvisinghernephewLibotokillhimselfratherthanawaitthestrokeofjustice,toldhimthatitwastodootherpeople’sbusinesstopreservehislifetoputitafterintothehandsofthosewhowithinthreeorfourdayswouldfetchhimtoexecution,andthatitwastoservehisenemiestokeephisbloodtogratifytheirmalice。
  WereadintheBiblethatNicanor,thepersecutorofthelawofGod,havingsenthissoldierstoseizeuponthegoodoldmanRazis,surnamedinhonourofhisvirtuethefatheroftheJews:thegoodman,seeingnootherremedy,hisgatesburneddown,andtheenemiesreadytoseizehim,choosingrathertodienoblythantofallintothehandsofhiswickedadversariesandsufferhimselftobecruellybutcheredbythem,contrarytothehonourofhisrankandquality,stabbedhimselfwithhisownsword,buttheblow,forhaste,nothavingbeengivenhome,heranandthrewhimselffromthetopofawallheadlongamongthem,whoseparatingthemselvesandmakingroom,hepitcheddirectlyuponhishead;
  notwithstandingwhich,feelingyetinhimselfsomeremainsoflife,herenewedhiscourage,andstartingupuponhisfeetallbloodyandwoundedashewas,andmakinghiswaythroughthecrowdtoaprecipitousrock,there,throughoneofhiswounds,drewouthisbowels,which,tearingandpullingtopieceswithbothhishands,hethrewamongsthispursuers,allthewhileattestingandinvokingtheDivinevengeanceuponthemfortheircrueltyandinjustice。
  Ofviolencesofferedtotheconscience,thatagainstthechastityofwomanis,inmyopinion,mosttobeavoided,forasmuchasthereisacertainpleasurenaturallymixedwithit,andforthatreasonthedissentthereincannotbesufficientlyperfectandentire,sothattheviolenceseemstobemixedwithalittleconsentoftheforcedparty。Theecclesiasticalhistoryhasseveralexamplesofdevoutpersonswhohaveembraceddeathtosecurethemfromtheoutragespreparedbytyrantsagainsttheirreligionandhonour。PelagiaandSophronia,bothcanonised,thefirstoftheseprecipitatedherselfwithhermotherandsistersintotherivertoavoidbeingforcedbysomesoldiers,andthelastalsokilledherselftoavoidbeingravishedbytheEmperorMaxentius。
  Itmay,peradventure,beanhonourtousinfutureages,thatalearnedauthorofthispresenttime,andaParisian,takesagreatdealofpainstopersuadetheladiesofouragerathertotakeanyothercoursethantoenterintothehorridmeditationofsuchadespair。Iamsorryhehadneverheard,thathemighthaveinserteditamongsthisotherstories,thesayingofawoman,whichwastoldmeatToulouse,whohadpassedthroughthehandlingofsomesoldiers:"Godbepraised,"saidshe,"thatonceatleastinmylifeIhavehadmyfillwithoutsin。"Intruth,thesecrueltiesareveryunworthytheFrenchgoodnature,andalso,Godbethanked,ourairisverywellpurgedofthemsincethisgoodadvice:
  ’tisenoughthattheysay"no"indoingit,accordingtotheruleofthegoodMarot。
  "Undoulxnenny,avecundoulxsourireEsttanthonneste。"——Marot。
  Historyiseverywherefullofthosewhobyathousandwayshaveexchangedapainfulandirksomelifefordeath。LuciusAruntiuskilledhimself,tofly,hesaid,boththefutureandthepast。GraniusSilvanusandStatiusProximus,afterhavingbeenpardonedbyNero,killedthemselves;eitherdisdainingtolivebythefavourofsowickedaman,orthattheymightnotbetroubled,atsomeothertime,toobtainasecondpardon,consideringtheproclivityofhisnaturetosuspectandcreditaccusationsagainstworthymen。Spargapises,sonofQueenTomyris,beingaprisonerofwartoCyrus,madeuseofthefirstfavourCyrusshewedhim,incommandinghimtobeunbound,tokillhimself,havingpretendedtonootherbenefitofliberty,butonlytoberevengedofhimselfforthedisgraceofbeingtaken。Boges,governorinEionforKingXerxes,beingbesiegedbytheAthenianarmyundertheconductofCimon,refusedtheconditionsoffered,thathemightsafereturnintoAsiawithallhiswealth,impatienttosurvivethelossofaplacehismasterhadgivenhimtokeep;wherefore,havingdefendedthecitytothelastextremity,nothingbeinglefttoeat,hefirstthrewallthegoldandwhateverelsetheenemycouldmakebootyofintotheriverStrymon,andthencausingagreatpiletobesetonfire,andthethroatsofallthewomen,children,concubines,andservantstobecut,hethrewtheirbodiesintothefire,andatlastleapedintoithimself。
  Ninachetuen,anIndianlord,sosoonasheheardthefirstwhisperofthePortugueseViceroy’sdeterminationtodispossesshim,withoutanyapparentcause,ofhiscommandinMalacca,totransferittotheKingofCampar,hetookthisresolutionwithhimself:hecausedascaffold,morelongthanbroad,tobeerected,supportedbycolumnsroyallyadornedwithtapestryandstrewedwithflowersandabundanceofperfumes;allwhichbeingprepared,inarobeofclothofgold,setfullofjewelsofgreatvalue,hecameoutintothestreet,andmountedthestepstothescaffold,atonecornerofwhichhehadapilelightedofaromaticwood。
  Everybodyrantoseetowhatendtheseunusualpreparationsweremade;
  whenNinachetuen,withamanlybutdispleasedcountenance,setforthhowmuchhehadobligedthePortuguesenation,andwithhowunspottedfidelityhehadcarriedhimselfinhischarge;thathavingsooften,swordinhand,manifestedinthebehalfofothers,thathonourwasmuchmoredeartohimthanlife,hewasnottoabandontheconcernofitforhimself:thatfortunedenyinghimallmeansofopposingtheaffrontdesignedtobeputuponhim,hiscourageatleastenjoinedhimtofreehimselffromthesenseofit,andnottoserveforafabletothepeople,norforatriumphtomenlessdeservingthanhimself;whichhavingsaidheleapedintothefire。
  Sextilia,wifeofScaurus,andPaxaea,wifeofLabeo,toencouragetheirhusbandstoavoidthedangersthatpresseduponthem,whereintheyhadnoothersharethanconjugalaffection,voluntarilysacrificedtheirownlivestoservetheminthisextremenecessityforcompanyandexample。
  Whattheydidfortheirhusbands,CocceiusNervadidforhiscountry,withlessutilitythoughwithequalaffection:thisgreatlawyer,flourishinginhealth,riches,reputation,andfavourwiththeEmperor,hadnoothercausetokillhimselfbutthesolecompassionofthemiserablestateoftheRomanRepublic。NothingcanbeaddedtothebeautyofthedeathofthewifeofFulvius,afamiliarfavouriteofAugustus:Augustushavingdiscoveredthathehadventedanimportantsecrethehadentrustedhimwithal,onemorningthathecametomakehiscourt,receivedhimverycoldlyandlookedfrowninglyuponhim。Hereturnedhome,fullof,despair,wherehesorrowfullytoldhiswifethat,havingfallenintothismisfortune,hewasresolvedtokillhimself:towhichsheroundlyreplied,"’tisbutreasonyoushould,seeingthathavingsooftenexperiencedtheincontinenceofmytongue,youcouldnottakewarning:butletmekillmyselffirst,"andwithoutanymoresayingranherselfthroughthebodywithasword。VibiusVirrius,despairingofthesafetyofhiscitybesiegedbytheRomansandoftheirmercy,inthelastdeliberationofhiscity’ssenate,aftermanyargumentsconducingtothatend,concludedthatthemostnoblemeanstoescapefortunewasbytheirownhands:tellingthemthattheenemywouldhavetheminhonour,andHannibalwouldbesensiblehowmanyfaithfulfriendshehadabandoned;invitingthosewhoapprovedofhisadvicetocometoagoodsupperhehadreadyathome,whereaftertheyhadeatenwell,theywoulddrinktogetherofwhathehadprepared;abeverage,saidhe,thatwilldeliverourbodiesfromtorments,oursoulsfrominsult,andoureyesandearsfromthesenseofsomanyhatefulmischiefs,astheconqueredsufferfromcruelandimplacableconquerors。Ihave,saidhe,takenorderforfitpersonstothrowourbodiesintoafuneralpilebeforemydoorsosoonaswearedead。Manyenoughapprovedthishighresolution,butfewimitatedit;seven—and—twentysenatorsfollowedhim,who,afterhavingtriedtodrownthethoughtofthisfataldeterminationinwine,endedthefeastwiththemortalmess;andembracingoneanother,aftertheyhadjointlydeploredthemisfortuneoftheircountry,someretiredhometotheirownhouses,othersstayedtobeburnedwithVibiusinhisfuneralpyre;andwereallofthemsolongindying,thevapourofthewinehavingprepossessedtheveins,andbythatmeansdeferredtheeffectofpoison,thatsomeofthemwerewithinanhourofseeingtheenemyinsidethewallsofCapua,whichwastakenthenextmorning,andofundergoingthemiseriestheyhadatsodeararateendeavouredtoavoid。JubelliusTaurea,anothercitizenofthesamecountry,theConsulFulviusreturningfromtheshamefulbutcheryhehadmadeoftwohundredandtwenty—fivesenators,calledhimbackfiercelybyname,andhavingmadehimstop:
  "Givetheword,"saidhe,"thatsomebodymaydispatchmeafterthemassacreofsomanyothers,thatthoumayestboasttohavekilledamuchmorevaliantmanthanthyself。"Fulvius,disdaininghimasamanoutofhiswits,andalsohavingreceivedlettersfromRomecensuringtheinhumanityofhisexecutionwhichtiedhishands,Jubelliusproceeded:
  "Sincemycountryhasbeentaken,myfriendsdead,andhavingwithmyownhandsslainmywifeandchildrentorescuethemfromthedesolationofthisruin,Iamdeniedtodiethedeathofmyfellow—citizens,letmeborrowfromvirtuevengeanceonthishatedlife,"andtherewithaldrawingashortswordhecarriedconcealedabouthim,heranitthroughhisownbosom,fallingdownbackward,andexpiringattheconsul’sfeet。
  Alexander,layingsiegetoacityoftheIndies,thosewithin,findingthemselvesveryhardlyset,putonavigorousresolutiontodeprivehimofthepleasureofhisvictory,andaccordinglyburnedthemselvesingeneral,togetherwiththeircity,indespiteofhishumanity:anewkindofwar,wheretheenemiessoughttosavethem,andtheytodestroythemselves,doingtomakethemselvessureofdeath,allthatmendotosecurelife。
  Astapa,acityofSpain,findingitselfweakinwallsanddefencetowithstandtheRomans,theinhabitantsmadeaheapofalltheirrichesandfurnitureinthepublicplace;and,havingrangeduponthisheapallthewomenandchildren,andpiledthemroundwithwoodandothercombustiblemattertotakesuddenfire,andleftfiftyoftheiryoungmenfortheexecutionofthatwhereontheyhadresolved,theymadeadesperatesally,whereforwantofpowertoovercome,theycausedthemselvestobeeverymanslain。Thefifty,afterhavingmassacredeverylivingsoulthroughoutthewholecity,andputfiretothispile,threwthemselveslastlyintoit,finishingtheirgenerousliberty,ratherafteraninsensible,thanafterasorrowfulanddisgracefulmanner,givingtheenemytounderstand,thatiffortunehadbeensopleased,theyhadaswellthecouragetosnatchfromthemvictoryastheyhadtofrustrateandrenderitdreadful,andevenmortaltothosewho,alluredbythesplendourofthegoldmeltinginthisflame,havingapproachedit,agreatnumberweretheresuffocatedandburned,beingkeptfromretiringbythecrowdthatfollowedafter。
  TheAbydeans,beingpressedbyKingPhilip,putonthesameresolution;
  but,nothavingtime,theycouldnotputit’ineffect。Theking,whowasstruckwithhorrorattherashprecipitationofthisexecution(thetreasureandmovablesthattheyhadcondemnedtotheflamesbeingfirstseized),drawingoffhissoldiers,grantedthemthreedays’timetokillthemselvesin,thattheymightdoitwithmoreorderandatgreaterease:
  whichtimetheyfilledwithbloodandslaughterbeyondtheutmostexcessofallhostilecruelty,sothatnotsomuchasanyonesoulwasleftalivethathadpowertodestroyitself。Thereareinfiniteexamplesoflikepopularresolutionswhichseemthemorefierceandcruelinproportionastheeffectismoreuniversal,andyetarereallylesssothanwhensinglyexecuted;whatargumentsandpersuasioncannotdowithindividualmen,theycandowithall,theardourofsocietyravishingparticularjudgments。
  ThecondemnedwhowouldlivetobeexecutedinthereignofTiberius,forfeitedtheirgoodsandweredeniedtheritesofsepulture;thosewho,bykillingthemselves,anticipatedit,wereinterred,andhadlibertytodisposeoftheirestatesbywill。
  Butmensometimescovetdeathoutofhopeofagreatergood。"Idesire,"
  saysSt。Paul,"tobewithChrist,"and"whoshallridmeofthesebands?"CleombrotusofAmbracia,havingreadPlato’sPheedo,enteredintosogreatadesireofthelifetocomethat,withoutanyotheroccasion,hethrewhimselfintothesea。Bywhichitappearshowimproperlywecallthisvoluntarydissolution,despair,towhichtheeagernessofhopeofteninclinesus,and,often,acalmandtemperatedesireproceedingfromamatureanddeliberatejudgment。JacquesduChastel,bishopofSoissons,inSt。Louis’sforeignexpedition,seeingthekingandwholearmyuponthepointofreturningintoFrance,leavingtheaffairsofreligionimperfect,tookaresolutionrathertogointoParadise;wherefore,havingtakensolemnleaveofhisfriends,hechargedalone,inthesightofeveryone,intotheenemy’sarmy,wherehewaspresentlycuttopieces。Inacertainkingdomofthenewdiscoveredworld,uponadayofsolemnprocession,whentheidoltheyadoreisdrawnaboutinpublicuponachariotofmarvellousgreatness;besidesthatmanyarethenseencuttingoffpiecesoftheirfleshtooffertohim,thereareanumberofotherswhoprostratethemselvesupontheplace,causingthemselvestobecrushedandbrokentopiecesundertheweightywheels,toobtainthevenerationofsanctityafterdeath,whichisaccordinglypaidthem。Thedeathofthebishop,swordinhand,hasmoreofmagnanimityinit,andlessofsentiment,theardourofcombattakingawaypartofthelatter。
  Therearesomegovernmentswhohavetakenuponthemtoregulatethejusticeandopportunityofvoluntarydeath。InformertimestherewaskeptinourcityofMarseillesapoisonpreparedoutofhemlock,atthepubliccharge,forthosewhohadamindtohastentheirend,havingfirst,beforethesixhundred,whoweretheirsenate,givenaccountofthereasonsandmotivesoftheirdesign,anditwasnototherwiselawful,thanbyleavefromthemagistrateanduponjustoccasiontodoviolencetothemselves。——[ValeriusMaximus,ii。6,7。]——Thesamelawwasalsoinuseinotherplaces。
  SextusPompeius,inhisexpeditionintoAsia,touchedattheisleofCeainNegropont:ithappenedwhilsthewasthere,aswehaveitfromonethatwaswithhim,thatawomanofgreatquality,havinggivenanaccounttohercitizenswhyshewasresolvedtoputanendtoherlife,invitedPompeiustoherdeath,torenderitthemorehonourable,aninvitationthatheaccepted;andhavinglongtriedinvainbythepowerofhiseloquence,whichwasverygreat,andpersuasion,todivertherfromthatdesign,heacquiescedintheendinherownwill。Shehadpassedtheageoffourscoreandteninaveryhappystate,bothofbodyandmind;beingthenlaiduponherbed,betterdressedthanordinaryandleaninguponherelbow,"Thegods,"saidshe,"OSextusPompeius,andratherthoseIleavethanthoseIgotoseek,rewardthee,forthatthouhastnotdisdainedtobeboththecounsellorofmylifeandthewitnessofmydeath。Formypart,havingalwaysexperiencedthesmilesoffortune,forfearlestthedesireoflivingtoolongmaymakemeseeacontraryface,Iamgoing,byahappyend,todismisstheremainsofmysoul,leavingbehindtwodaughtersofmybodyandalegionofnephews";whichhavingsaid,withsomeexhortationstoherfamilytoliveinpeace,shedividedamongstthemhergoods,andrecommendingherdomesticgodstohereldestdaughter,sheboldlytookthebowlthatcontainedthepoison,andhavingmadehervowsandprayerstoMercurytoconducthertosomehappyabodeintheotherworld,sheroundlyswallowedthemortalpoison。Thisbeingdone,sheentertainedthecompanywiththeprogressofitsoperation,andhowthecoldbydegreesseizedtheseveralpartsofherbodyoneafteranother,tillhavingintheendtoldthemitbegantoseizeuponherheartandbowels,shecalledherdaughterstodothelastofficeandclosehereyes。
  PlinytellsusofacertainHyperboreannationwhere,byreasonofthesweettemperatureoftheair,livesrarelyendedbutbythevoluntarysurrenderoftheinhabitants,who,beingwearyofandsatiatedwithliving,hadthecustom,ataveryoldage,afterhavingmadegoodcheer,toprecipitatethemselvesintotheseafromthetopofacertainrock,assignedforthatservice。Painandthefearofaworsedeathseemtomethemostexcusableincitements。,CHAPTERIV
  TO—MORROW’SANEWDAY
  Igive,asitseemstome,withgoodreasonthepalmtoJacquesAmyotofallourFrenchwriters,notonlyforthesimplicityandpurityofhislanguage,whereinheexcelsallothers,norforhisconstancyingoingthroughsolongawork,norforthedepthofhisknowledge,havingbeenablesosuccessfullytosmoothandunravelsoknottyandintricateanauthor(forletpeopletellmewhattheywill,IunderstandnothingofGreek;butImeetwithsensesowellunitedandmaintainedthroughouthiswholetranslation,thatcertainlyheeitherknewthetruefancyoftheauthor,orhaving,bybeinglongconversantwithhim,imprintedavividandgeneralideaofthatofPlutarchinhissoul,hehasdeliveredusnothingthateitherderogatesfromorcontradictshim),butaboveall,I
  amthemosttakenwithhimforhavingmadesodiscreetachoiceofabooksoworthyandofsogreatutilitywherewithtopresenthiscountry。Weignorantfellowshadbeenlost,hadnotthisbookraisedusoutofthedirt;bythisfavourofhiswedarenowspeakandwrite;theladiesareabletoreadtoschoolmasters;’tisourbreviary。Ifthisgoodmanbeyetliving,IwouldrecommendtohimXenophon,todoasmuchbythat;
  ’tisamuchmoreeasytaskthantheother,andconsequentlymoreproperforhisage。And,besides,thoughIknownothow,methinkshedoesbriskly——andclearlyenoughtripoverstepsanotherwouldhavestumbledat,yetneverthelesshisstyleseemstobemorehisownwherehedoesnotencounterthosedifficulties,androllsawayathisownease。
  IwasjustnowreadingthispassagewherePlutarchsaysofhimself,thatRusticusbeingpresentatadeclamationofhisatRome,therereceivedapacketfromtheemperor,anddeferredtoopenittillallwasdone:forwhich,sayshe,allthecompanyhighlyapplaudedthegravityofthisperson。’Tistrue,thatbeinguponthesubjectofcuriosityandofthateagerpassionfornews,whichmakesuswithsomuchindiscretionandimpatienceleavealltoentertainanewcomer,andwithoutanymannerofrespectoroutcry,tearopenonasudden,inwhatcompanysoever,thelettersthataredeliveredtous,hehadreasontoapplaudthegravityofRusticusuponthisoccasion;andmightmoreoverhaveaddedtoitthecommendationofhiscivilityandcourtesy,thatwouldnotinterruptthecurrentofhisdeclamation。ButIdoubtwhetheranyonecancommendhisprudence;forreceivingunexpectedletters,andespeciallyfromanemperor,itmighthavefallenoutthatthedeferringtoreadthemmighthavebeenofgreatprejudice。Theviceoppositetocuriosityisnegligence,towhichInaturallyincline,andwhereinIhaveseensomemensoextremethatonemighthavefoundletterssentthemthreeorfourdaysbefore,stillsealedupintheirpockets。
  Ineveropenanylettersdirectedtoanother;notonlythoseintrustedwithme,butevensuchasfortunehasguidedtomyhand;andamangrywithmyselfifmyeyesunawaresstealanycontentsoflettersofimportanceheisreadingwhenIstandnearagreatman。Neverwasmanlessinquisitiveorlesspryingintoothermen’saffairsthanI。
  Inourfathers’days,MonsieurdeBoutiereshadliketohavelostTurinfromhaving,whileengagedingoodcompanyatsupper,delayedtoreadinformationthatwassenthimofthetreasonplottedagainstthatcitywherehecommanded。AndthisveryPlutarchhasgivenmetounderstand,thatJuliusCaesarhadpreservedhimself,if,goingtotheSenatethedayhewasassassinatedbytheconspirators,hehadreadanotewhichwaspresentedtohimby,theway。HetellsalsothestoryofArchias,thetyrantofThebes,thatthenightbeforetheexecutionofthedesignPelopidashadplottedtokillhimtorestorehiscountrytoliberty,hehadafullaccountsenthiminwritingbyanotherArchias,anAthenian,ofthewholeconspiracy,andthat,thispackethavingbeendeliveredtohimwhilehesatatsupper,hedeferredtheopeningofit,saying,whichafterwardsturnedtoaproverbinGreece,"Businessto—morrow。"
  Awisemanmay,Ithink,outofrespecttoanother,asnottodisturbthecompany,asRusticusdid,ornottobreakoffanotheraffairofimportanceinhand,defertoreadorhearanynewthingthatisbroughthim;butforhisowninterestorparticularpleasure,especiallyifhebeapublicminister,thathewillnotinterrupthisdinnerorbreakhissleepisinexcusable。AndtherewasancientlyatRome,theconsularplace,astheycalledit,whichwasthemosthonourableatthetable,asbeingaplaceofmostliberty,andofmoreconvenientaccesstothosewhocameintospeaktothepersonseatedthere;bywhichitappears,thatbeingatmeat,theydidnottotallyabandontheconcernofotheraffairsandincidents。Butwhenallissaid,itisveryhardinhumanactionstogivesoexactaruleuponmoralreasons,thatfortunewillnotthereinmaintainherownright。
  CHAPTERV
  OFCONSCIENCE
  TheSieurdelaBrousse,mybrother,andI,travellingonedaytogetherduringthetimeofourcivilwars,metagentlemanofgoodsort。Hewasofthecontraryparty,thoughIdidnotknowsomuch,forhepretendedotherwise:andthemischiefon’tis,thatinthissortofwarthecardsaresoshuffled,yourenemynotbeingdistinguishedfromyourselfbyanyapparentmarkeitheroflanguageorhabit,andbeingnourishedunderthesamelaw,air,andmanners,itisveryhardtoavoiddisorderandconfusion。ThismademeafraidmyselfofmeetinganyofourtroopsinaplacewhereIwasnotknown,thatImightnotbeinfeartotellmyname,andperadventureofsomethingworse;asithadbefallenmebefore,where,bysuchamistake,Ilostbothmenandhorses,andamongstothersanItaliangentlemanmypage,whomIbredwiththegreatestcareandaffection,wasmiserablyslain,inwhomayouthofgreatpromiseandexpectationwasextinguished。ButthegentlemanmybrotherandImethadsodesperate,half—deadafearuponhimatmeetingwithanyhorse,orpassingbyanyofthetownsthatheldfortheKing,thatIatlastdiscoveredittobealarmsofconscience。Itseemedtothepoormanasifthroughhisvisorandthecrossesuponhiscassock,onewouldhavepenetratedintohisbosomandreadthemostsecretintentionsofhisheart;sowonderfulisthepowerofconscience。Itmakesusbetray,accuse,andfightagainstourselves,andforwantofotherwitnesses,togiveevidenceagainstourselves:
  "Occultumquatiensanimotortoreflagellum。"
  ["Thetorturerofthesoulbrandishingasharpscourgewithin。"
  ——Juvenal,iii。195。]
  Thisstoryisineverychild’smouth:BessusthePaeonian,beingreproachedforwantonlypullingdownanestofyoungsparrowsandkillingthem,replied,thathehadreasontodoso,seeingthatthoselittlebirdsneverceasedfalselytoaccusehimofthemurderofhisfather。
  Thisparricidehadtillthenbeenconcealedandunknown,buttherevengingfuryofconsciencecausedittobediscoveredbyhimhimself,whowastosufferforit。HesiodcorrectsthesayingofPlato,thatpunishmentcloselyfollowssin,itbeing,ashesays,bornatthesametimewithit。Whoeverexpectspunishmentalreadysuffersit,andwhoeverhasdeserveditexpectsit。Wickednesscontrivestormentsagainstitself:
  "Malumconsiliumconsultoripessimum:"
  [Illdesignsareworsttothecontriver。"
  ——ApudAul。Gellium,iv。5。]
  asthewaspstingsandhurtsanother,butmostofallitself,forittherelosesitsstinganditsuseforever,"Vitasqueinvulnereponunt。"
  [Andleavetheirownlivesinthewound。"
  ——Virgil,Geo。,iv。238。]
  Cantharideshavesomewhereaboutthem,byacontrarietyofnature,acounterpoisonagainsttheirpoison。Inlikemanner,atthesametimethatmentakedelightinvice,therespringsintheconscienceadispleasurethatafflictsussleepingandwakingwithvarioustormentingimaginations:
  "Quippeubisemulti,persomniasaepeloquentes,Autmorbodelirantes,protraxeferantur,Etcelatadiuinmediumpeccatadedisse。"
  ["Surelywheremany,oftentalkingintheirsleep,orravingindisease,aresaidtohavebetrayedthemselves,andtohavegivenpublicitytooffenceslongconcealed。"——Lucretius,v。1157。]
  ApollodorusdreamedthathesawhimselfflayedbytheScythiansandafterwardsboiledinacauldron,andthathisheartmutteredthesewords"Iamthecauseofallthesemischiefsthathavebefallenthee。"
  Epicurussaidthatnohiding—holecouldconcealthewicked,sincetheycouldneverassurethemselvesofbeinghidwhilsttheirconsciencediscoveredthemtothemselves。
  "Primaesthaecultio,quodseJudicenemonocensabsohitur。"
  ["Tisthefirstpunishmentofsinthatnomanabsolveshimself。"or:
  "Thisisthehighestrevenge,thatbyitsjudgmentnooffenderisabsolved。"——Juvenal,xiii。2。]
  Asanillconsciencefillsuswithfear,soagoodonegivesusgreaterconfidenceandassurance;andIcantrulysaythatIhavegonethroughseveralhazardswithamoresteadypaceinconsiderationofthesecretknowledgeIhadofmyownwillandtheinnocenceofmyintentions:
  "Consciamensutcuiquesuaest,itaconcipitintraPectoraprofactospemquemetumquesuo。"
  ["Asaman’sconscienceis,sowithinhopeorfearprevails,suitingtohisdesign。"——Ovid,Fast。,i。485。]
  Ofthisareathousandexamples;butitwillbeenoughtoinstancethreeofoneandthesameperson。Scipio,beingonedayaccusedbeforethepeopleofRomeofsomecrimesofaveryhighnature,insteadofexcusinghimselforflatteringhisjudges:"Itwillbecomeyouwell,"saidhe,"tositinjudgmentuponahead,bywhosemeansyouhavethepowertojudgealltheworld。"Anothertime,alltheanswerhegavetoseveralimpeachmentsbroughtagainsthimbyatribuneofthepeople,insteadofmakinghisdefence:"Letusgo,citizens,"saidhe,"letusgorenderthankstothegodsforthevictorytheygavemeovertheCarthaginiansasthisday,"andadvancinghimselfbeforetowardstheTemple,hehadpresentlyalltheassemblyandhisveryaccuserhimselffollowingathisheels。AndPetilius,havingbeensetonbyCatotodemandanaccountofthemoneythathadpassedthroughhishandsintheprovinceofAntioch,Scipiobeingcomeintothesenatetothatpurpose,producedabookfromunderhisrobe,whereinhetoldthemwasanexactaccountofhisreceiptsanddisbursements;butbeingrequiredtodeliverittotheprothonotarytobeexamined,herefused,saying,hewouldnotdohimselfsogreatadisgrace;andinthepresenceofthewholesenatetorethebookwithhisownhandstopieces。Idonotbelievethatthemostsearedconsciencecouldhavecounterfeitedsogreatanassurance。Hehadnaturallytoohighaspiritandwasaccustomedtotoohighafortune,saysTitiusLivius,toknowhowtobecriminal,andtolowerhimselftothemeannessofdefendinghisinnocence。Theputtingmentotherackisadangerousinvention,andseemstoberatheratrialofpatiencethanoftruth。
  Bothhewhohasthefortitudetoendureitconcealsthetruth,andhewhohasnot:forwhyshouldpainsoonermakemeconfesswhatreallyis,thanforcemetosaywhatisnot?And,onthecontrary,ifhewhoisnotguiltyofthatwhereofheisaccused,hasthecouragetoundergothosetorments,whyshouldnothewhoisguiltyhavethesame,sofairarewardaslifebeinginhisprospect?Ibelievethegroundofthisinventionproceedsfromtheconsiderationoftheforceofconscience:for,totheguilty,itseemstoassisttheracktomakehimconfesshisfaultandtoshakehisresolution;and,ontheotherside,thatitfortifiestheinnocentagainstthetorture。Butwhenallisdone,’tis,inplaintruth,atrialfullofuncertaintyanddangerwhatwouldnotamansay,whatwouldnotamando,toavoidsointolerabletorments?
  "Etiaminnocentescogitmentiridolor。"
  ["Painwillmakeeventheinnocentlie。"——PubliusSyrus,DeDolore。]
  Whenceitcomestopass,thathimwhomthejudgehasrackedthathemaynotdieinnocent,hemakeshimdiebothinnocentandracked。Athousandandathousandhavechargedtheirownheadsbyfalseconfessions,amongstwhomIplacePhilotas,consideringthecircumstancesofthetrialAlexanderputuponhimandtheprogressofhistorture。Butsoitisthatsomesayitistheleastevilhumanweaknesscouldinvent;veryinhumanly,notwithstanding,andtoverylittlepurpose,inmyopinion。
  ManynationslessbarbarousinthisthantheGreeksandRomanswhocallthemso,reputeithorribleandcrueltotormentandpullamantopiecesforafaultofwhichtheyareyetindoubt。Howcanhehelpyourignorance?Arenotyouunjust,that,nottokillhimwithoutcause,doworsethankillhim?Andthatthisisso,dobutobservehowoftenmenprefertodiewithoutreasonthanundergothisexamination,morepainfulthanexecutionitself;andthatoft—timesbyitsextremityanticipatesexecution,andperformit。IknownotwhereIhadthisstory,butitexactlymatchestheconscienceofourjusticeinthisparticular。A
  country—woman,toageneralofaveryseverediscipline,accusedoneofhissoldiersthathehadtakenfromherchildrenthelittlesoupmeatshehadlefttonourishthemwithal,thearmyhavingconsumedalltherest;
  butofthisprooftherewasnone。Thegeneral,afterhavingcautionedthewomantotakegoodheedtowhatshesaid,forthatshewouldmakeherselfguiltyofafalseaccusationifshetoldalie,andshepersisting,hepresentlycausedthesoldier’sbellytoberippeduptoclearthetruthofthefact,andthewomanwasfoundtoberight。Aninstructivesentence。
  CHAPTERVI
  USEMAKESPERFECT
  ’Tisnottobeexpectedthatargumentandinstruction,thoughweneversovoluntarilysurrenderourbelieftowhatisreadtous,shouldbeofforcetoleadusonsofarastoaction,ifwedonot,overandabove,exerciseandformthesoulbyexperiencetothecourseforwhichwedesignit;itwill,otherwise,doubtlessfinditselfatalosswhenitcomestothepinchofthebusiness。Thisisthereasonwhythoseamongstthephilosopherswhowereambitioustoattaintoagreaterexcellence,werenotcontentedtoawaittheseveritiesoffortuneintheretirementandreposeoftheirownhabitations,lestheshouldhavesurprisedthemrawandinexpertinthecombat,butsalliedouttomeether,andpurposelythrewthemselvesintotheproofofdifficulties。Someofthemabandonedrichestoexercisethemselvesinavoluntarypoverty;otherssoughtoutlabourandanausterityoflife,toinurethemtohardshipsandinconveniences;othershavedeprivedthemselvesoftheirdearestmembers,asofsight,andoftheinstrumentsofgeneration,lesttheirtoodelightfulandeffeminateserviceshouldsoftenanddebauchthestabilityoftheirsouls。
  Butindying,whichisthegreatestworkwehavetodo,practicecangiveusnoassistanceatall。Amanmaybycustomfortifyhimselfagainstpain,shame,necessity,andsuch—likeaccidents,butastodeath,wecanexperimentitbutonce,andareallapprenticeswhenwecometoit。
  Therehave,anciently,beenmensoexcellentmanagersoftheirtimethattheyhavetriedevenindeathitselftorelishandtasteit,andwhohavebenttheirutmostfacultiesofmindtodiscoverwhatthispassageis,buttheyarenoneofthemcomebacktotellusthenews:
  "Nemoexpergitusexstat,Frigidaquernsemelestvitaipausasequuta。"
  ["Noonewakeswhohasoncefallenintothecoldsleepofdeath。"
  ——Lucretius,iii。942]
  JuliusCanus,anobleRoman,ofsingularconstancyandvirtue,havingbeencondemnedtodiebythatworthlessfellowCaligula,besidesmanymarvelloustestimoniesthathegaveofhisresolution,ashewasjustgoingtoreceivethestrokeoftheexecutioner,wasaskedbyaphilosopher,afriendofhis:"Well,Canus,whereaboutisyoursoulnow?
  whatisshedoing?Whatareyouthinkingof?"——"Iwasthinking,"repliedtheother,"tokeepmyselfready,andthefacultiesofmymindfullsettledandfixed,totryifinthisshortandquickinstantofdeath,I
  couldperceivethemotionofthesoulwhenshepartsfromthebody,andwhethershehasanysentimentattheseparation,thatImayaftercomeagainifIcan,toacquaintmyfriendswithit。"Thismanphilosophisesnotuntodeathonly,butindeathitself。Whatastrangeassurancewasthis,andwhatbraveryofcourage,todesirehisdeathshouldbealessontohim,andtohaveleisuretothinkofotherthingsinsogreatanaffair:
  "Jushocanimimorientishabebat。"
  ["Thismightypowerofmindhehaddying。"—Lucan,viii。636。]
  AndyetIfancy,thereisacertainwayofmakingitfamiliartous,andinsomesortofmakingtrialwhatitis。Wemaygainexperience,ifnotentireandperfect,yetsuch,atleast,asshallnotbetotallyuselesstous,andthatmayrenderusmoreconfidentandmoreassured。Ifwecannotovertakeit,wemayapproachitandviewit,andifwedonotadvancesofarasthefort,wemayatleastdiscoverandmakeourselvesacquaintedwiththeavenues。Itisnotwithoutreasonthatwearetaughttoconsidersleepasaresemblanceofdeath:withhowgreatfacilitydowepassfromwakingtosleeping,andwithhowlittleconcerndowelosetheknowledgeoflightandofourselves。Peradventure,thefacultyofsleepingwouldseemuselessandcontrarytonature,sinceitdeprivesusofallactionandsentiment,wereitnotthatbyitnatureinstructsusthatshehasequallymadeustodieastolive;andinlifepresentstoustheeternalstateshereservesforusafterit,toaccustomustoitandtotakefromusthefearofit。Butsuchashavebyviolentaccidentfallenintoaswoon,andinithavelostallsense,these,methinks,havebeenverynearseeingthetrueandnaturalfaceofdeath;forastothemomentofthepassage,itisnottobefearedthatitbringswithitanypainordispleasure,forasmuchaswecanhavenofeelingwithoutleisure;
  oursufferingsrequiretime,whichindeathissoshort,andsoprecipitous,thatitmustnecessarilybeinsensible。Theyaretheapproachesthatwearetofear,andthesemayfallwithinthelimitsofexperience。