NeitherdoIallowoftheconjectureoftheParians,senttoregulatetheMilesianssufficientforsuchaconsequenceastheyfromthencederivedcomingtovisittheisland,theytooknoticeofsuchgroundsaswerebesthusbanded,andsuchcountry—housesaswerebestgoverned;andhavingtakenthenamesoftheowners,whentheyhadassembledthecitizens,theyappointedthesefarmersfornewgovernorsandmagistrates;concludingthatthey,whohadbeensoprovidentintheirownprivateconcerns,wouldbesoofthepublictoo。Wearealllumps,andofsovariousandinformacontexture,thateverypieceplays,everymoment,itsowngame,andthereisasmuchdifferencebetwixtusandourselvesasbetwixtusandothers:
"Magnamremputa,unumhominemagere。"
["Esteemitagreatthingalwaystoactasoneandthesameman。"——Seneca,Ep。,150。]
Sinceambitioncanteachmanvalour,temperance,andliberality,andevenjusticetoo;seeingthatavaricecaninspirethecourageofashop—boy,bredandnursedupinobscurityandease,withtheassurancetoexposehimselfsofarfromthefiresidetothemercyofthewavesandangryNeptuneinafrailboat;thatshefurtherteachesdiscretionandprudence;andthatevenVenuscaninflateboysunderthedisciplineoftherodwithboldnessandresolution,andinfusemasculinecourageintotheheartoftendervirginsintheirmothers’arms:
"Hacduce,custodesfurtimtransgressajacentes,Adjuvenemtenebrissolapuellavenit:"
["Sheleading,themaiden,furtivelypassingbytherecumbentguards,goesaloneinthedarknesstotheyouth。"
——Tibullus,ii。2,75。]
’tisnotalltheunderstandinghastodo,simplytojudgeusbyouroutwardactions;itmustpenetratetheverysoul,andtherediscoverbywhatspringsthemotionisguided。Butthatbeingahighandhazardousundertaking,Icouldwishthatfewerwouldattemptit。
CHAPTERII
OFDRUNKENNESS
Theworldisnothingbutvarietyanddisemblance,vicesareallalike,astheyarevices,andperadventuretheStoicsunderstandthemso;butalthoughtheyareequallyvices,yettheyarenotallequalvices;andhewhohastransgressedtheordinaryboundsahundredpaces:
"Quosultracitraquenequitconsistererectum,"
["Beyondorwithinwhichtherightcannotexist。"
——Horace,Sat。,i,1,107。]
shouldnotbeinaworseconditionthanhethathasadvancedbutten,isnottobebelieved;orthatsacrilegeisnotworsethanstealingacabbage:
"Necvincetratiohoc,tantumdemutpeccet,idemque,Quiteneroscaulesalienifregerithorti,Etquinocturnusdivumsacralegerit。"
Thereisinthisasgreatdiversityasinanythingwhatever。Theconfoundingoftheorderandmeasureofsinsisdangerous:murderers,traitors,andtyrantsgettoomuchbyit,anditisnotreasonabletheyshouldflattertheirconsciences,becauseanothermanisidle,lascivious,ornotassiduousathisdevotion。Everyoneoverratestheoffenceofhiscompanions,butextenuateshisown。Ourveryinstructorsthemselvesrankthemsometimes,inmyopinion,veryill。AsSocratessaidthattheprincipalofficeofwisdomwastodistinguishgoodfromevil,we,thebestofwhomarevicious,oughtalsotosaythesameofthescienceofdistinguishingbetwixtviceandvice,withoutwhich,andthatveryexactlyperformed,thevirtuousandthewickedwillremainconfoundedandunrecognised。
Now,amongsttherest,drunkennessseemstometobeagrossandbrutishvice。Thesoulhasgreaterpartintherest,andtherearesomevicesthathavesomething,ifamanmaysosay,ofgenerousinthem;thereareviceswhereinthereisamixtureofknowledge,diligence,valour,prudence,dexterity,andaddress;thisoneistotallycorporealandearthly。AndtherudestnationthisdayinEuropeisthatalonewhereitisinfashion。Othervicesdiscomposetheunderstanding:thistotallyoverthrowsitandrendersthebodystupid:
"Cumvinivispenetravit……
Consequiturgravitasmembrorum,praepediunturCruravacillanti,tardescitlingua,madetmens,Nantoculi;clamor,singultus,jurgia,gliscunt。"
["Whenthepowerofwinehaspenetratedus,aheavinessofthelimbsfollows,thelegsofthetotteringpersonareimpeded;thetonguegrowstorpid,themindisdimmed,theeyesswim;noise,hiccup,andquarrelsarise。——"Lucretius,i。3,475。]
Theworststateofmanisthatwhereinhelosestheknowledgeandgovernmentofhimself。And’tissaidamongstotherthingsuponthissubject,that,asthemustfermentinginavessel,worksuptothetopwhateverithasinthebottom,sowine,inthosewhohavedrunkbeyondmeasure,ventsthemostinwardsecrets:
"TusapientumCurasetarcanumjocosoConsiliumretegisLyaeo。"
["ThoudisclosesttothemerryLyacusthecaresandsecretcounselofthewise。"——Horace,Od。,xxi。1,114。]
[Lyacus,anamegiventoBacchus。]
Josephustellsusthatbygivinganambassadortheenemyhadsenttohimhisfulldoseofliquor,hewormedouthissecrets。Andyet,Augustus,committingthemostinwardsecretsofhisaffairstoLuciusPiso,whoconqueredThrace,neverfoundhimfaultyintheleast,nomorethanTiberiasdidCossus,withwhomheintrustedhiswholecounsels,thoughweknowtheywerebothsogiventodrinkthattheyhaveoftenbeenfaintocarryboththeoneandtheotherdrunkoutoftheSenate:
"Hesternoinflatumvenasutsemper,Lyaeo。"
["Theirveinsfull,asusual,ofyesterday’swine。"
——Virgil,Egl。,vi。15。]
AndthedesignofkillingCaesarwasassafelycommunicatedtoCimber,thoughhewouldoftenbedrunk,astoCassius,whodranknothingbutwater。
[AstowhichCassiuspleasantlysaid:"What,shallIbearatyrant,Iwhocannotbearwine?"]
WeseeourGermans,whendrunkasthedevil,knowtheirpost,remembertheword,andkeeptotheirranks:
"Necfacilisvictoriademadidis,etBlaesis,atquemerotitubantibus。"
["Norisavictoryeasilyobtainedovermensodrunk,theycanscarcespeakorstand。"——Juvenal,Sat。,xv。47。]
Icouldnothavebelievedtherehadbeensoprofound,senseless,anddeadadegreeofdrunkennesshadInotreadinhistorythatAttalushaving,toputanotableaffrontuponhim,invitedtosupperthesamePausanias,whoupontheverysameoccasionafterwardskilledPhilipofMacedon,akingwhobyhisexcellentqualitiesgavesufficienttestimonyofhiseducationinthehouseandcompanyofEpaminondas,madehimdrinktosuchapitchthathecouldafterabandonhisbeauty,asofahedgestrumpet,tothemuleteersandservantsofthebasestofficeinthehouse。AndI
havebeenfurthertoldbyaladywhomIhighlyhonourandesteem,thatnearBordeauxandaboutCastreswhereshelives,acountrywoman,awidowofchasterepute,perceivinginherselfthefirstsymptomsofbreeding,innocentlytoldherneighboursthatifshehadahusbandsheshouldthinkherselfwithchild;butthecausesofsuspicioneverydaymoreandmoreincreasing,andatlastgrowinguptoamanifestproof,thepoorwomanwasreducedtothenecessityofcausingittobeproclaimedinherparishchurch,thatwhoeverhaddonethatdeedandwouldfranklyconfessit,shedidnotonlypromisetoforgive,butmoreovertomarryhim,ifhelikedthemotion;whereuponayoungfellowthatservedherinthequalityofalabourer,encouragedbythisproclamation,declaredthathehadoneholidayfoundher,havingtakentoomuchofthebottle,sofastasleepbythechimneyandinsoindecentaposture,thathecouldconvenientlydohisbusinesswithoutwakingher;andtheyyetlivetogethermanandwife。
Itistruethatantiquityhasnotmuchdecriedthisvice;thewritingsevenofseveralphilosophersspeakverytenderlyofit,andevenamongsttheStoicstherearesomewhoadvisefolkstogivethemselvessometimesthelibertytodrink,nay,todrunkenness,torefreshthesoul:
"Hocquoquevirtutumquondamcertamine,magnumSocratempalmampromeruisseferunt。"
["InthistrialofpowerformerlytheyrelatethatthegreatSocratesdeservedthepalm。"——Cornet。Gallus,Ep。,i。47。]
Thatcensorandreproverofothers,Cato,wasreproachedthathewasaharddrinker:
NarraturetprisciCatonisSaepemerocaluissevirtus。"
["AndofoldCatoitissaid,thathiscouragewasoftenwarmedwithwine。"——Horace,Od。,xxi。3,11。——CatotheElder。]
Cyrus,thatsorenownedking,amongsttheotherqualitiesbywhichheclaimedtobepreferredbeforehisbrotherArtaxerxes,urgedthisexcellence,thathecoulddrinkagreatdealmorethanhe。Andinthebestgovernednationsthistrialofskillindrinkingisverymuchinuse。IhaveheardSilvius,anexcellentphysicianofParis,saythatlestthedigestivefacultiesofthestomachshouldgrowidle,itwerenotamissonceamonthtorousethembythisexcess,andtospurthemlesttheyshouldgrowdullandrusty;andoneauthortellsusthatthePersiansusedtoconsultabouttheirmostimportantaffairsafterbeingwellwarmedwithwine。
Mytasteandconstitutionaregreaterenemiestothisvicethanmydiscourse;forbesidesthatIeasilysubmitmybelieftotheauthorityofancientopinions,Ilookuponitindeedasanunmanlyandstupidvice,butlessmaliciousandhurtfulthantheothers,which,almostall,moredirectlyjostlepublicsociety。Andifwecannotpleaseourselvesbutitmustcostussomething,astheyhold,Ifindthisvicecostsaman’sconsciencelessthantheothers,besidesthatitisofnodifficultpreparation,norhardtobefound,aconsiderationnotaltogethertobedespised。Amanwelladvancedbothindignityandage,amongstthreeprincipalcommoditiesthathesaidremainedtohimoflife,reckonedtomethisforone,andwherewouldamanmorejustlyfinditthanamongstthenaturalconveniences?Buthedidnottakeitright,fordelicacyandthecuriouschoiceofwinesisthereintobeavoided。Ifyoufoundyourpleasureupondrinkingofthebest,youcondemnyourselftothepenanceofdrinkingoftheworst。Yourtastemustbemoreindifferentandfree;
sodelicateapalateisnotrequiredtomakeagoodtoper。TheGermansdrinkalmostindifferentlyofallwineswithdelight;theirbusinessistopourdownandnottotaste;andit’ssomuchthebetterforthem:
theirpleasureissomuchthemoreplentifulandnearerathand。
Secondly,todrink,aftertheFrenchfashion,butattwomeals,andthenverymoderately,istobetoosparingofthefavoursofthegod。Thereismoretimeandconstancyrequiredthanso。Theancientsspentwholenightsinthisexercise,andofttimesaddedthedayfollowingtoekeitout,andthereforewearetotakegreaterlibertyandstickclosertoourwork。Ihaveseenagreatlordofmytime,amanofhighenterpriseandfamoussuccess,thatwithoutsettinghimselfto’t,andafterhisordinaryrateofdrinkingatmeals,dranknotmuchlessthanfivequartsofwine,andathisgoingawayappearedbuttoowiseanddiscreet,tothedetrimentofouraffairs。Thepleasureweholdinesteemforthecourseofourlivesoughttohaveagreatershareofourtimededicatedtoit;
weshould,likeshopboysandlabourers,refusenooccasionnoromitanyopportunityofdrinking,andalwayshaveitinourminds。Methinksweeverydayabridgeandcurtailtheuseofwine,andthattheafterbreakfasts,dinnersnatches,andcollationsIusedtoseeinmyfather’shouse,whenIwasaboy,weremoreusualandfrequentthenthannow。
Isitthatwepretendtoareformation?Truly,no:butitmaybewearemoreaddictedtoVenusthanourfatherswere。Theyaretwoexercisesthatthwartandhinderoneanotherintheirvigour。Lecheryweakensourstomachontheoneside;andontheothersobrietyrendersusmorespruceandamorousfortheexerciseoflove。
’TiswonderfulwhatstrangestoriesIhaveheardmyfathertellofthechastityofthatagewhereinhelived。Itwasforhimtosayit,beingbothbyartandnaturecutoutandfinishedfortheserviceofladies。
Hespokewellandlittle:evermixinghislanguagewithsomeillustrationoutofauthorsmostinuse,especiallyinSpanish,andamongtheSpanishhewhomtheycalledMarcusAurelius——[Guevara’sGoldenBookofMarcusAureliusAntoninus。]——wasordinarilyinhismouth。Hisbehaviourwasgentlygrave,humble,andverymodest;hewasverysolicitousofneatnessandproprietybothinhispersonandclothes,whetheronhorsebackorafoot,hewasmonstrouslypunctualinhisword;andofaconscienceandreligiongenerallytendingrathertowardssuperstitionthanotherwise。
Foramanoflittlestature,verystrong,wellproportioned,andwellknit;ofapleasingcountenanceincliningtobrown,andveryadroitinallnobleexercises。Ihaveyetinthehousetobeseencanespouredfulloflead,withwhichtheysayheexercisedhisarmsforthrowingthebarorthestone,orinfencing;andshoeswithleadensolestomakehimlighterforrunningorleaping。Ofhisvaultinghehasleftlittlemiraclesbehindhim:Ihaveseenhimwhenpastthreescorelaughatourexercises,andthrowhimselfinhisfurredgownintothesaddle,makethetourofatableuponhisthumbsandscarceevermountthestairsintohischamberwithouttakingthreeorfourstepsatatime。ButastowhatI
wasspeakingofbefore;hesaidtherewasscarceonewomanofqualityofillfameinthewholeprovince:hewouldtellofstrangeconfidences,andsomeofthemhisown,withvirtuouswomen,freefromanymannerofsuspicionofill,andforhisownpartsolemnlysworehewasavirginathismarriage;andyetitwasafteralongpracticeofarmsbeyondthemountains,ofwhichwarsheleftusajournalunderhisownhand,whereinhehasgivenapreciseaccountfrompointtopointofallpassages,bothrelatingtothepublicandtohimself。Andhewas,moreover,marriedatawelladvancedmaturity,intheyear1528,thethree—and—thirtiethyearofhisage,uponhiswayhomefromItaly。Butletusreturntoourbottles。
Theincommoditiesofoldage,thatstandinneedofsomerefreshmentandsupport,mightwithreasonbegetinmeadesireofthisfaculty,itbeingasitwerethelastpleasurethecourseofyearsdeprivesusof。Thenaturalheat,saythegood—fellows,firstseatsitselfinthefeet:thatconcernsinfancy;thenceitmountsintothemiddleregion,whereitmakesalongabodeandproduces,inmyopinion,thesoletruepleasuresofhumanlife;allotherpleasuresincomparisonsleep;towardstheend,likeavapourthatstillmountsupward,itarrivesatthethroat,whereitmakesitsfinalresidence,andconcludestheprogress。Idonot,nevertheless,understandhowamancanextendthepleasureofdrinkingbeyondthirst,andforgeinhisimaginationanappetiteartificialandagainstnature;mystomachwouldnotproceedsofar;ithasenoughtodotodealwithwhatittakesinforitsnecessity。Myconstitutionisnottocarefordrinkbutasfollowingeatingandwashingdownmymeat,andforthatreasonmylastdraughtisalwaysthegreatest。Andseeingthatinoldagewehaveourpalatefurredwithphlegmsordepravedbysomeotherillconstitution,thewinetastesbettertousastheporesarecleanerwashedandlaidmoreopen。Atleast,Iseldomtastethefirstglasswell。AnacharsiswonderedthattheGreeksdrankingreaterglassestowardstheendofamealthanatthebeginning;whichwas,Isuppose,forthesamereasontheGermansdothesame,whothenbeginthebattleofdrink。
Platoforbidschildrenwinetilleighteenyearsofage,andtogetdrunktillforty;but,afterforty,givesthemleavetopleasethemselves,andtomixalittleliberallyintheirfeaststheinfluenceofDionysos,thatgooddeitywhorestorestoyoungermentheirgaietyandtooldmentheiryouth;whomollifiesthepassionsofthesoul,asironissoftenedbyfire;andinhisLazesallowssuchmerrymeetings,providedtheyhaveadiscreetchieftogovernandkeeptheminorder,asgoodandofgreatutility;drunkennessbeing,hesays,atrueandcertaintrialofeveryone’snature,and,withal,fittoinspireoldmenwithmettletodivertthemselvesindancingandmusic;thingsofgreatuse,andthattheydarenotattemptwhensober。He,moreover,saysthatwineisabletosupplythesoulwithtemperanceandthebodywithhealth。Nevertheless,theserestrictions,inpartborrowedfromtheCarthaginians,pleasehim:thatmenforbearexcessesintheexpeditionsofwar;thateveryjudgeandmagistrateabstainfromitwhenabouttheadministrationsofhisplaceortheconsultationsofthepublicaffairs;thatthedayisnottobeemployedwithit,thatbeingatimeduetootheroccupations,northenightonwhichamanintendstogetchildren。
’TissaidthatthephilosopherStilpo,whenoppressedwithage,purposelyhastenedhisendbydrinkingpurewine。Thesamething,butnotdesignedbyhim,despatchedalsothephilosopherArcesilaus。
But’tisanoldandpleasantquestion,whetherthesoulofawisemancanbeovercomebythestrengthofwine?
"Simunitaeadhibetvimsapientiae。"
Towhatvanitydoesthegoodopinionwehaveofourselvespushus?Themostregularandmostperfectsoulintheworldhasbuttoomuchtodotokeepitselfupright,andfrombeingoverthrownbyitsownweakness。
Thereisnotoneofathousandthatisrightandsettledsomuchasoneminuteinawholelife,andthatmaynotverywelldoubt,whetheraccordingtohernaturalconditionsheevercanbe;buttojoinconstancytoitisherutmostperfection;Imeanwhennothingshouldjostleanddiscomposeher,whichathousandaccidentsmaydo。’TistomuchpurposethatthegreatpoetLucretiuskeepssuchaclatterwithhisphilosophy,when,behold!hegoesmadwithalovephiltre。IsittobeimaginedthatanapoplexywillnotstunSocratesaswellasaporter?Somemenhaveforgottentheirownnamesbytheviolenceofadisease;andaslightwoundhasturnedthejudgmentofotherstopsy—turvy。Lethimbeaswiseashewill,afterallheisbutaman;andthanthatwhatistheremorefrail,moremiserable,ormorenothing?Wisdomdoesnotforceournaturaldispositions,"Sudoresitaque,etpalloremexsisteretotoCorpore,etinfringilinguam,vocemqueaboriri,Caligareoculos,sonereaures,succidereartus,Demqueconcidere,exanimiterrore,videmus。"
["Sweatandpalenesscomeoverthewholebody,thetongueisrenderedpowerless,thevoicediesaway,theeyesaredarkened,thereisringingintheears,thelimbssinkunderusbytheinfluenceoffear。"——Lucretius,iii。155。]
hemustshuthiseyesagainsttheblowthatthreatenshim;hemusttrembleuponthemarginofaprecipice,likeachild;naturehavingreservedtheselightmarksofherauthority,nottobeforcedbyourreasonandthestoicvirtue,toteachmanhismortalityandourweakness;
heturnspalewithfear,redwithshame,andgroanswiththecholic,ifnotwithdesperateoutcry,atleastwithhoarseandbrokenvoice:
"Humaniasenihilalienumputet。"
["Lethimnotthinkhimselfexemptfromthatwhichisincidentaltomeningeneral。"——Terence,Heauton,i。1,25。]
Thepoets,thatfeignallthingsatpleasure,darenotacquittheirgreatestheroesoftears:
"Sicfaturlacrymans,classiqueimmittithabenas。"
["Thushespeaks,weeping,andthensetssailwithhisfleet。"
——Aeneid,vi。i。]
’Tissufficientforamantocurbandmoderatehisinclinations,fortotallytosuppressthemisnotinhimtodo。EvenourgreatPlutarch,thatexcellentandperfectjudgeofhumanactions,whenheseesBrutusandTorquatuskilltheirchildren,beginstodoubtwhethervirtuecouldproceedsofar,andtoquestionwhetherthesepersonshadnotratherbeenstimulatedbysomeotherpassion。——[Plutarch,LifeofPublicola,c。3。]
——Allactionsexceedingtheordinaryboundsareliabletosinisterinterpretation,forasmuchasourlikingnomoreholdswithwhatisabovethanwithwhatisbelowit。
Letusleavethatothersect,thatsetsupanexpressprofessionofscornfulsuperiority——[TheStoics。]——:butwheneveninthatsect,reputedthemostquietandgentle,weheartheserhodomontadesofMetrodorus:
"Occupavite,Fortuna,atquecepi:omnesqueaditustuosinterclusiutadmeaspirarenonposses;"
[Fortune,Ihavegotthebetterofthee,andhavemadealltheavenuessosurethoucanstnotcomeatme。"
——Cicero,Tusc。Quaes。,v。9。]
whenAnaxarchus,bycommandofNicocreonthetyrantofCyprus,wasputintoastonemortar,andlaiduponwithmaulsofiron,ceasesnottosay,"Strike,batter,break;’tisnotAnaxarchus,’tisbuthissheaththatyoupoundandbrayso";whenwehearourmartyrscryouttothetyrantfromthemiddleoftheflame,"Thissideisroastedenough,falltoandeat,itisenoughdone;falltoworkwiththeother;"whenwehearthechildinJosephus’tornpiece—mealwithpincers,defyingAntiochus,andcryingoutwithaconstantandassuredvoice:"Tyrant,thoulosestthylabour,Iamstillatease;whereisthepain,wherearethetormentswithwhichthoudidstsothreatenme?Isthisallthoucanstdo?Myconstancytormentstheemorethanthycrueltydoesme。Opitifulcoward,thoufaintest,andIgrowstronger;makemecomplain,makemebend,makemeyieldifthoucanst;encouragethyguards,cheerupthyexecutioners;
see,seetheyfaint,andcandonomore;armthem,fleshthemanew,spurthemup";truly,amanmustconfessthatthereissomephrenzy,somefury,howholysoever,thatatthattimepossessesthosesouls。WhenwecometotheseStoicalsallies:"Ihadratherbemadthanvoluptuous,"asayingofAntisthenes。WhenSextiustellsus,"hehadratherbefetteredwithafflictionthanpleasure":whenEpicurustakesuponhimtoplaywithhisgout,and,refusinghealthandease,defiesalltorments,anddespisingthelesserpains,asdisdainingtocontendwiththem,hecovetsandcallsoutforotherssharper,moreviolent,andmoreworthyofhim;
"Spumantemquedari,pecorainterinertia,votisOptataprum,autfulvumdescenderemonteleonem:"
["Andinsteadoftimidbeasts,wishesthefoamingboarortawnylionwouldcomefromthemountain。"——AEneid,iv。158。]
whobutmustconcludethatthesearewildsalliespushedonbyacouragethathasbrokenloosefromitsplace?Oursoulcannotfromherownseatreachsohigh;’tisnecessaryshemustleaveit,raiseherselfup,and,takingthebridleinherteeth,transporthermansofarthatheshallafterwardshimselfbeastonishedatwhathehasdone;as,inwar,theheatofbattleimpelsgeneroussoldierstoperformthingsofsoinfinitedanger,asafterwards,recollectingthem,theythemselvesarethefirsttowonderat;asitalsofareswiththepoets,whoareoftenraptwithadmirationoftheirownwritings,andknownotwhereagaintofindthetrackthroughwhichtheyperformedsofineaCareer;whichalsoisinthemcalledfuryandrapture。AndasPlatosays,’tistonopurposeforasober—mindedmantoknockatthedoorofpoesy:soAristotlesays,thatnoexcellentsoulisexemptfromamixtureofmadness;andhehasreasontocallalltransports,howcommendablesoever,thatsurpassourownjudgmentandunderstanding,madness;forasmuchaswisdomisaregulargovernmentofthesoul,whichiscarriedonwithmeasureandproportion,andforwhichsheistoherselfresponsible。Platoarguesthus,thatthefacultyofprophesyingissofaraboveus,thatwemustbeoutofourselveswhenwemeddlewithit,andourprudencemusteitherbeobstructedbysleeporsickness,orliftedfromherplacebysomecelestialrapture。
CHAPTERIII
ACUSTOMOFTHEISLEOFCEA
[Cos。CeaistheformofthenamegivenbyPliny]
Iftophilosophisebe,as’tisdefined,todoubt,muchmoretowriteatrandomandplaythefool,asIdo,oughttobereputeddoubting,foritisfornovicesandfreshmentoinquireandtodispute,andforthechairmantomoderateanddetermine。
Mymoderatoristheauthorityofthedivinewill,thatgovernsuswithoutcontradiction,andthatisseatedabovethesehumanandvaincontestations。
PhiliphavingforciblyenteredintoPeloponnesus,andsomeonesayingtoDamidasthattheLacedaemonianswerelikelyverymuchtosufferiftheydidnotintimereconcilethemselvestohisfavour:"Why,youpitifulfellow,"repliedhe,"whatcantheysufferwhodonotfeartodie?"ItbeingalsoaskedofAgis,whichwayamanmightlivefree?"Why,"saidhe,"bydespisingdeath。"These,andathousandothersayingstothesamepurpose,distinctlysoundofsomethingmorethanthepatientattendingthestrokeofdeathwhenitshallcome;forthereareseveralaccidentsinlifefarworsetosufferthandeathitself。WitnesstheLacedaemonianboytakenbyAntigonus,andsoldforaslave,whobeingbyhismastercommandedtosomebaseemployment:"Thoushaltsee,"saystheboy,"whomthouhastbought;itwouldbeashameformetoserve,beingsonearthereachofliberty,"andhavingsosaid,threwhimselffromthetopofthehouse。AntipaterseverelythreateningtheLacedaemonians,thathemightthebetterinclinethemtoacquiesceinacertaindemandofhis:"Ifthouthreatenestuswithmorethandeath,"repliedthey,"weshallthemorewillinglydie";andtoPhilip,havingwrittenthemwordthathewouldfrustratealltheirenterprises:"What,wiltthoualsohinderusfromdying?"Thisisthemeaningofthesentence,"Thatthewisemanlivesaslongasheought,notsolongashecan;andthatthemostobligingpresentNaturehasmadeus,andwhichtakesfromusallcolourofcomplaintofourcondition,istohavedeliveredintoourowncustodythekeysoflife;shehasonlyordered,onedoorintolife,butahundredthousandwaysout。Wemaybestraitenedforearthtoliveupon,butearthsufficienttodieuponcanneverbewanting,asBoiocalusansweredtheRomans。"——[Tacitus,Annal。,xiii。56。]——Whydostthoucomplainofthisworld?itdetainstheenot;thyowncowardiceisthecause,ifthoulivestinpain。Thereneedsnomoretodiebuttowilltodie:
"Ubiquemorsest;optimehoccavitdeus。
Eriperevitamnemononhominipotest;
Atnemomortem;milleadhancadituspatent。"
["Deathiseverywhere:heavenhaswellprovidedforthat。Anyonemaydepriveusoflife;noonecandepriveusofdeath。Todeaththereareathousandavenues。"——Seneca,Theb:,i,I,151。]
Neitherisitarecipeforonediseaseonly;deathistheinfalliblecureofall;’tisamostassuredportthatisnevertobefeared,andveryoftentobesought。Itcomesalltoone,whetheramangivehimselfhisend,orstaystoreceiveitbysomeothermeans;whetherhepaysbeforehisday,orstaytillhisdayofpaymentcome;fromwhencesoeveritcomes,itisstillhis;inwhatpartsoeverthethreadbreaks,there’stheendoftheclue。Themostvoluntarydeathisthefinest。Lifedependsuponthepleasureofothers;deathuponourown。Weoughtnottoaccommodateourselvestoourownhumourinanythingsomuchasinthis。
Reputationisnotconcernedinsuchanenterprise;’tisfollytobeconcernedbyanysuchapprehension。Livingisslaveryifthelibertyofdyingbewanting。Theordinarymethodofcureiscarriedonattheexpenseoflife;theytormentuswithcaustics,incisions,andamputationsoflimbs;theyinterdictalimentandexhaustourblood;onestepfartherandwearecuredindeedandeffectually。Whyisnotthejugularveinasmuchatourdisposalasthemedianvein?Foradesperatediseaseadesperatecure。Serviusthegrammarian,beingtormentedwiththegout,couldthinkofnobetterremedythantoapplypoisontohislegs,todeprivethemoftheirsense;letthembegoutyattheirwill,sotheywereinsensibleofpain。GodgivesusleaveenoughtogowhenHeispleasedtoreduceustosuchaconditionthattoliveisfarworsethantodie。’Tisweaknesstotruckleunderinfirmities,butit’smadnesstonourishthem。TheStoicssay,thatitislivingaccordingtonatureinawisemanto,takehisleaveoflife,evenintheheightofprosperity,ifhedoitopportunely;andinafooltoprolongit,thoughhebemiserable,providedhebenotindigentofthosethingswhichtheyreputetobeaccordingtonature。AsIdonotoffendthelawagainstthieveswhenIembezzlemyownmoneyandcutmyownpurse;northatagainstincendiarieswhenIburnmyownwood;soamInotunderthelashofthosemadeagainstmurderersforhavingdeprivedmyselfofmyownlife。
Hegesiassaid,thatastheconditionoflifedid,sotheconditionofdeathoughttodependuponourownchoice。AndDiogenesmeetingthephilosopherSpeusippus,soblownupwithaninveteratedropsythathewasfaintobecarriedinalitter,andbyhimsalutedwiththecompliment,"Iwishyougoodhealth。""Nohealthtothee,"repliedtheother,"whoartcontenttoliveinsuchacondition。
Andinfact,notlongafter,Speusippus,wearyofsolanguishingastateoflife,foundameanstodie。
Butthisdoesnotpasswithoutadmittingadispute:formanyareofopinionthatwecannotquitthisgarrisonoftheworldwithouttheexpresscommandofHimwhohasplacedusinit;andthatitappertainstoGodwhohasplacedushere,notforourselvesonlybutforHisGloryandtheserviceofothers,todismissuswhenitshallbestpleaseHim,andnotforustodepartwithoutHislicence:thatwearenotbornforourselvesonly,butforourcountryalso,thelawsofwhichrequireanaccountfromusuponthescoreoftheirowninterest,andhaveanactionofmanslaughtergoodagainstus;andifthesefailtotakecognisanceofthefact,wearepunishedintheotherworldasdesertersofourduty:
"Proximadeindetenentmaestiloca,quisibiletumInsontespepereremanu,lucemqueperosiProiecereanimas。"
["Thencethesadonesoccupythenextabodes,who,thoughfreefromguilt,werebytheirownhandsslain,and,hatinglight,soughtdeath。"——AEneid,vi。434。]
Thereismoreconstancyinsufferingthechainwearetiedtothaninbreakingit,andmorepregnantevidenceoffortitudeinRegulusthaninCato;’tisindiscretionandimpatiencethatpushusontotheseprecipices:noaccidentscanmaketruevirtueturnherback;sheseeksandrequiresevils,pains,andgrief,asthethingsbywhichsheisnourishedandsupported;themenacesoftyrants,racks,andtorturesserveonlytoanimateandrouseher:
"DurisutilextonsabipennibusNigraeferacifrondisinAlgido,Perdamma,percmdes,abipsoDucitopes,animumqueferro。"
["AsinMountAlgidus,thesturdyoakevenfromtheaxeitselfderivesnewvigourandlife。"——Horace,Od。,iv。4,57。]
Andasanothersays:
"Nonest,utputas,virtus,pater,Timerevitam;sedmalisingentibusObstare,necsevertere,acretrodare。"
["Father,’tisnovirtuetofearlife,buttowithstandgreatmisfortunes,norturnbackfromthem。"——Seneca,Theb。,i。190。]
Orasthis:
"RebusinadversisfacileestcontemneremortemFortiusillefacit,quimiseressepotest。"
["Itiseasyinadversitytodespisedeath;butheactsmorebravely,whocanlivewretched。"——Martial,xi。56,15。]
’Tiscowardice,notvirtue,toliesquatinafurrow,underatomb,toevadetheblowsoffortune;virtueneverstopsnorgoesoutofherpath,forthegreateststormthatblows:
"Sifractusillabaturorbis,Impavidumferientruinae。"
["Shouldtheworld’saxiscrack,theruinswillbutcrushafearlesshead。"——Horace,Od。,iii。3,7。]
Forthemostpart,theflyingfromotherinconveniencesbringsustothis;nay,endeavouringtoevadedeath,weoftenrunintoitsverymouth:
"Hic,rogo,nonfurorest,nemoriare,mori?"
["Tellme,isitnotmadness,thatoneshoulddieforfearofdying?"——Martial,ii。80,2。]
likethosewho,fromfearofaprecipice,throwthemselvesheadlongintoit;
"MultosinsummapericulamisfitVenturitimoripsemali:fortissimusilleest,Quipromptusmetuendapati,sicominusinstent,Etdifferrepotest。"
["Thefearoffutureillsoftenmakesmenrunintoextremedanger;
heistrulybravewhoboldlydareswithstandthemischiefsheapprehends,whentheyconfronthimandcanbedeferred。"
——Lucan,vii。104。]
"Usqueadeo,mortisformidine,vitaePercipithumanosodium,lucisquevidendae,UtsibiconsciscantmoerentipectorelethumOblitifontemcurarumhuncessetimorem。"
["Deathtothatdegreesofrightenssomemen,thatcausingthemtohatebothlifeandlight,theykillthemselves,miserablyforgettingthatthissamefearisthefountainoftheircares。"
——Lucretius,iii。79。]
Plato,inhisLaws,assignsanignominioussepulturetohimwhohasdeprivedhisnearestandbestfriend,namelyhimself,oflifeandhisdestinedcourse,beingneithercompelledsotodobypublicjudgment,byanysadandinevitableaccidentoffortune,norbyanyinsupportabledisgrace,butmerelypushedonbycowardiceandtheimbecilityofatimoroussoul。Andtheopinionthatmakessolittleoflife,isridiculous;foritisourbeing,’tisallwehave。Thingsofanoblerandmoreelevatedbeingmay,indeed,reproachours;butitisagainstnatureforustocontemnandmakelittleaccountofourselves;’tisadiseaseparticulartoman,andnotdiscernedinanyothercreatures,tohateanddespiseitself。Anditisavanityofthesamestamptodesiretobesomethingelsethanwhatweare;theeffectofsuchadesiredoesnotatalltouchus,forasmuchasitiscontradictedandhinderedinitself。Hethatdesiresofamantobemadeanangel,doesnothingforhimself;hewouldbeneverthebetterforit;for,beingnomore,whoshallrejoiceorbesensibleofthisbenefitforhim。
"Debetenim,miserecuiforti,aegrequefuturumest,Ipsequoqueesseineoturntempore,cummalepossitAccidere。"
["Forhetowhommiseryandpainaretobeinthefuture,musthimselfthenexist,whentheseillsbefallhim。"
——Idem,ibid。,874。]
Security,indolence,impassability,theprivationoftheevilsofthislife,whichwepretendtopurchaseatthepriceofdying,areofnomannerofadvantagetous:thatmanevadeswartoverylittlepurposewhocanhavenofruitionofpeace;andaslittletothepurposedoesheavoidtroublewhocannotenjoyrepose。
Amongstthoseofthefirstofthesetwoopinions,therehasbeengreatdebate,whatoccasionsaresufficienttojustifythemeditationofself—
murder,whichtheycall"Areasonableexit。"——[DiogenesLaertius,LifeofZeno。]——Forthoughtheysaythatmenmustoftendiefortrivialcauses,seeingthosethatdetainusinlifeareofnoverygreatweight,yetthereistobesomelimit。Therearefantasticandsenselesshumoursthathavepromptednotonlyindividualmen,butwholenationstodestroythemselves,ofwhichIhaveelsewheregivensomeexamples;andwefurtherreadoftheMilesianvirgins,thatbyafranticcompacttheyhangedthemselvesoneafteranothertillthemagistratetookorderinit,enactingthatthebodiesofsuchasshouldbefoundsohangedshouldbedrawnbythesamehalterstarknakedthroughthecity。WhenTherykiontriedtopersuadeCleomenestodespatchhimself,byreasonoftheillpostureofhisaffairs,and,havingmissedadeathofmorehonourinthebattlehehadlost,toacceptofthisthesecondinhonourtoit,andnottogivetheconquerorsleisuretomakehimundergoeitheranignominiousdeathoraninfamouslife;Cleomenes,withacouragetrulyStoicandLacedaemonian,rejectedhiscounselasunmanlyandmean;"that,"saidhe,"isaremedythatcanneverbewanting,butwhichamanisnevertomakeuseof,whilstthereisaninchofhoperemaining":tellinghim,"thatitwassometimesconstancyandvalourtolive;thathewouldthatevenhisdeathshouldbeofusetohiscountry,andwouldmakeofitanactofhonourandvirtue。"Therykion,notwithstanding,thoughthimselfintheright,anddidhisownbusiness;andCleomenesafterwardsdidthesame,butnottillhehadfirsttriedtheutmostmalevolenceoffortune。Alltheinconveniencesintheworldarenotconsiderableenoughthatamanshoulddietoevadethem;and,besides,therebeingsomany,sosuddenandunexpectedchangesinhumanthings,itishardrightlytojudgewhenweareattheendofourhope:
"Speratetinsaevavictusgladiatorarena,Sitlicetinfestopolliceturbaminax。"
["Thegladiatorconqueredinthelistshopeson,thoughthemenacingspectators,turningtheirthumb,orderhimtodie。"
——Pentadius,DeSpe,ap。VirgiliiCatadecta。]