Thesetwocausesdonotactinthesamemanneruponaristocraticarmies:asmenarepromotedinthembyrightofbirthmuchmorethanbyrightofseniority,thereareinallranksacertainnumberofyoungmen,whobringtotheirprofessionalltheearlyvigorofbodyandmind。Again,asthemenwhoseekformilitaryhonorsamongstanaristocraticpeople,enjoyasettledpositionincivilsociety,theyseldomcontinueinthearmyuntiloldageovertakesthem。Afterhavingdevotedthemostvigorousyearsofyouthtothecareerofarms,theyvoluntarilyretire,andspendathometheremainderoftheirmatureryears。
Alongpeacenotonlyfillsdemocraticarmieswithelderlyofficers,butitalsogivestoalltheofficershabitsbothofbodyandmindwhichrenderthemunfitforactualservice。Themanwhohaslonglivedamidstthecalmandlukewarmatmosphereofdemocraticmannerscanatfirstilladapthimselftothehardertoilsandsternerdutiesofwarfare;andifhehasnotabsolutelylostthetasteforarms,atleasthehasassumedamodeoflifewhichunfitshimforconquest。
Amongstaristocraticnations,theeaseofcivillifeexerciseslessinfluenceonthemannersofthearmy,becauseamongstthosenationsthearistocracycommandsthearmy:andanaristocracy,howeverplungedinluxuriouspleasures,hasalwaysmanyotherpassionsbesidesthatofitsownwell—being,andtosatisfythosepassionsmorethoroughlyitswell—beingwillbereadilysacrificed。*a[Footnotea:SeeAppendixV。]
Ihaveshownthatindemocraticarmies,intimeofpeace,promotionisextremelyslow。Theofficersatfirstsupportthisstateofthingswithimpatience,theygrowexcited,restless,exasperated,butintheendmostofthemmakeuptheirmindstoit。Thosewhohavethelargestshareofambitionandofresourcesquitthearmy;others,adaptingtheirtastesandtheirdesirestotheirscantyfortunes,ultimatelylookuponthemilitaryprofessioninacivilpointofview。Thequalitytheyvaluemostinitisthecompetencyandsecuritywhichattendit:
theirwholenotionofthefuturerestsuponthecertaintyofthislittleprovision,andalltheyrequireispeaceablytoenjoyit。
Thusnotonlydoesalongpeacefillanarmywitholdmen,butitisfrequentlyimpartstheviewsofoldmentothosewhoarestillintheprimeoflife。
Ihavealsoshownthatamongstdemocraticnationsintimeofpeacethemilitaryprofessionisheldinlittlehonorandindifferentlyfollowed。Thiswantofpublicfavorisaheavydiscouragementtothearmy;itweighsdownthemindsofthetroops,andwhenwarbreaksoutatlast,theycannotimmediatelyresumetheirspringandvigor。Nosimilarcauseofmoralweaknessoccursinaristocraticarmies:theretheofficersareneverloweredeitherintheirowneyesorinthoseoftheircountrymen,because,independentlyoftheirmilitarygreatness,theyarepersonallygreat。Buteveniftheinfluenceofpeaceoperatedonthetwokindsofarmiesinthesamemanner,theresultswouldstillbedifferent。Whentheofficersofanaristocraticarmyhavelosttheirwarlikespiritandthedesireofraisingthemselvesbyservice,theystillretainacertainrespectforthehonoroftheirclass,andanoldhabitofbeingforemosttosetanexample。Butwhentheofficersofademocraticarmyhavenolongertheloveofwarandtheambitionofarms,nothingwhateverremainstothem。
Iamthereforeofopinionthat,whenademocraticpeopleengagesinawarafteralongpeace,itincursmuchmoreriskofdefeatthananyothernation;butitoughtnoteasilytobecastdownbyitsreverses,forthechancesofsuccessforsuchanarmyareincreasedbythedurationofthewar。Whenawarhasatlength,byitslongcontinuance,rousedthewholecommunityfromtheirpeacefuloccupationsandruinedtheirminorundertakings,thesamepassionswhichmadethemattachsomuchimportancetothemaintenanceofpeacewillbeturnedtoarms。War,afterithasdestroyedallmodesofspeculation,becomesitselfthegreatandsolespeculation,towhichalltheardentandambitiousdesireswhichequalityengendersareexclusivelydirected。Henceitisthattheselfsamedemocraticnationswhicharesoreluctanttoengageinhostilities,sometimesperformprodigiousachievementswhenoncetheyhavetakenthefield。Asthewarattractsmoreandmoreofpublicattention,andisseentocreatehighreputationsandgreatfortunesinashortspaceoftime,thechoicestspiritsofthenationenterthemilitaryprofession:alltheenterprising,proud,andmartialminds,nolongerofthearistocracysolely,butofthewholecountry,aredrawninthisdirection。Asthenumberofcompetitorsformilitaryhonorsisimmense,andwardriveseverymantohisproperlevel,greatgeneralsarealwayssuretospringup。Alongwarproducesuponademocraticarmythesameeffectsthatarevolutionproducesuponapeople;itbreaksthroughregulations,andallowsextraordinarymentoriseabovethecommonlevel。Thoseofficerswhosebodiesandmindshavegrownoldinpeace,areremoved,orsuperannuated,ortheydie。Intheirsteadahostofyoungmenarepressingon,whoseframesarealreadyhardened,whosedesiresareextendedandinflamedbyactiveservice。Theyarebentonadvancementatallhazards,andperpetualadvancement;theyarefollowedbyotherswiththesamepassionsanddesires,andaftertheseareothersyetunlimitedbyaughtbutthesizeofthearmy。
Theprincipleofequalityopensthedoorofambitiontoall,anddeathprovideschancesforambition。Deathisconstantlythinningtheranks,makingvacancies,closingandopeningthecareerofarms。
Thereismoreoverasecretconnectionbetweenthemilitarycharacterandthecharacterofdemocracies,whichwarbringstolight。Themenofdemocraciesarenaturallypassionatelyeagertoacquirewhattheycovet,andtoenjoyitoneasyconditions。
Theyforthemostpartworshipchance,andaremuchlessafraidofdeaththanofdifficulty。Thisisthespiritwhichtheybringtocommerceandmanufactures;andthissamespirit,carriedwiththemtothefieldofbattle,inducesthemwillinglytoexposetheirlivesinordertosecureinamomenttherewardsofvictory。Nokindofgreatnessismorepleasingtotheimaginationofademocraticpeoplethanmilitarygreatness—agreatnessofvividandsuddenlustre,obtainedwithouttoil,bynothingbuttheriskoflife。Thus,whilsttheinterestsandthetastesofthemembersofademocraticcommunitydivertthemfromwar,theirhabitsofmindfitthemforcarryingonwarwell;theysoonmakegoodsoldiers,whentheyarerousedfromtheirbusinessandtheirenjoyments。Ifpeaceispeculiarlyhurtfultodemocraticarmies,warsecurestothemadvantageswhichnootherarmieseverpossess;andtheseadvantages,howeverlittlefeltatfirst,cannotfailintheendtogivethemthevictory。Anaristocraticnation,whichinacontestwithademocraticpeopledoesnotsucceedinruiningthelatterattheoutsetofthewar,alwaysrunsagreatriskofbeingconqueredbyit。
ChapterXXV:OfDisciplineInDemocraticArmiesItisaverygeneralopinion,especiallyinaristocraticcountries,thatthegreatsocialequalitywhichprevailsindemocraciesultimatelyrenderstheprivatesoldierindependentoftheofficer,andthusdestroysthebondofdiscipline。Thisisamistake,fortherearetwokindsofdiscipline,whichitisimportantnottoconfound。Whentheofficerisnobleandthesoldieraserf—onerich,theotherpoor—theformereducatedandstrong,thelatterignorantandweak—thestrictestbondofobediencemayeasilybeestablishedbetweenthetwomen。Thesoldierisbrokenintomilitarydiscipline,asitwere,beforeheentersthearmy;orrather,militarydisciplineisnothingbutanenhancementofsocialservitude。Inaristocraticarmiesthesoldierwillsoonbecomeinsensibletoeverythingbuttheordersofhissuperiorofficers;heactswithoutreflection,triumphswithoutenthusiasm,anddieswithoutcomplaint:inthisstateheisnolongeraman,butheisstillamostformidableanimaltrainedforwar。
Ademocraticpeoplemustdespairofeverobtainingfromsoldiersthatblind,minute,submissive,andinvariableobediencewhichanaristocraticpeoplemayimposeonthemwithoutdifficulty。Thestateofsocietydoesnotpreparethemforit,andthenationmightbeindangeroflosingitsnaturaladvantagesifitsoughtartificiallytoacquireadvantagesofthisparticularkind。Amongstdemocraticcommunities,militarydisciplineoughtnottoattempttoannihilatethefreespringofthefaculties;allthatcanbedonebydisciplineistodirectit;theobediencethusinculcatedislessexact,butitismoreeagerandmoreintelligent。Ithasitsrootinthewillofhimwhoobeys:itrestsnotonlyonhisinstinct,butonhisreason;
andconsequentlyitwilloftenspontaneouslybecomemorestrictasdangerrequiresit。Thedisciplineofanaristocraticarmyisapttoberelaxedinwar,becausethatdisciplineisfoundeduponhabits,andwardisturbsthosehabits。Thedisciplineofademocraticarmyonthecontraryisstrengthenedinsightoftheenemy,becauseeverysoldierthenclearlyperceivesthathemustbesilentandobedientinordertoconquer。
ThenationswhichhaveperformedthegreatestwarlikeachievementsknewnootherdisciplinethanthatwhichIspeakof。
Amongsttheancientsnonewereadmittedintothearmiesbutfreemenandcitizens,whodifferedbutlittlefromoneanother,andwereaccustomedtotreateachotherasequals。Inthisrespectitmaybesaidthatthearmiesofantiquityweredemocratic,althoughtheycameoutofthebosomofaristocracy;
theconsequencewasthatinthosearmiesasortoffraternalfamiliarityprevailedbetweentheofficersandthemen。
Plutarch’slivesofgreatcommandersfurnishconvincinginstancesofthefact:thesoldierswereintheconstanthabitoffreelyaddressingtheirgeneral,andthegenerallistenedtoandansweredwhateverthesoldiershadtosay:theywerekeptinorderbylanguageandbyexample,farmorethanbyconstraintorpunishment;thegeneralwasasmuchtheircompanionastheirchief。IknownotwhetherthesoldiersofGreeceandRomeevercarriedtheminutiaeofmilitarydisciplinetothesamedegreeofperfectionastheRussianshavedone;butthisdidnotpreventAlexanderfromconqueringAsia—andRome,theworld。
ChapterXXVI:SomeConsiderationsOnWarInDemocraticCommunitiesWhentheprincipleofequalityisingrowth,notonlyamongstasinglenation,butamongstseveralneighboringnationsatthesametime,asisnowthecaseinEurope,theinhabitantsofthesedifferentcountries,notwithstandingthedissimilarityoflanguage,ofcustoms,andoflaws,neverthelessresembleeachotherintheirequaldreadofwarandtheircommonloveofpeace。
*aItisinvainthatambitionorangerputsarmsinthehandsofprinces;theyareappeasedinspiteofthemselvesbyaspeciesofgeneralapathyandgoodwill,whichmakesthesworddropfromtheirgrasp,andwarsbecomemorerare。Asthespreadofequality,takingplaceinseveralcountriesatonce,simultaneouslyimpelstheirvariousinhabitantstofollowmanufacturesandcommerce,notonlydotheirtastesgrowalike,buttheirinterestsaresomixedandentangledwithoneanotherthatnonationcaninflictevilsonothernationswithoutthoseevilsfallingbackuponitself;andallnationsultimatelyregardwarasacalamity,almostasseveretotheconquerorastotheconquered。Thus,ontheonehand,itisextremelydifficultinde...完整阅读请扫描二维码下载丁香书院APP免费看:
第54章