19。OfLegislators。AristotlewantedtoindulgesometimeshisjealousyagainstPlato,andsometimeshispassionforAlexander。PlatowasincensedagainstthetyrannyofthepeopleofAthens。Machiavelwasfullofhisidol,theDukeofValentinois。SirThomasMore,whospokeratherofwhathehadreadthanofwhathethought,wantedtogovernallstateswiththesimplicityofaGreekcity。[49]HarringtonwasfulloftheideaofhisfavouriterepublicofEngland,whileacrowdofwriterssawnothingbutconfusionwheremonarchyisabolished。Thelawsalwaysconformtothepassionsandprejudicesofthelegislator;sometimesthelatterpassthrough,andonlytincturethem;sometimestheyremain,andareincorporatedwiththem。
______
1。Aristotle,Politics,iv。11。
2。Bookxx。1。
3。Ceciliussaysthatheneversawnorreadofaninstanceinwhichthispunishmenthadbeeninflicted;butitislikelythatnosuchpunishmentwaseverestablished:theopinionofsomecivilians,thatthelawoftheTwelveTablesmeantonlythedivisionofthemoneyarisingfromthesaleofthedebtor,seemsveryprobable。
4。DeFalsalegatione。
5。Dio,xli。
6。Aristotle,Politics,v。13。
7。Plutarch,Dionysius。
8。Seexxvi。17,p。223,above。
9。Whentheinheritancewastoomuchencumberedtheyeludedthepontificallawbycertainsales,whencecomethewordssinesacrish?reditas。
10。Lawsix。
11。Tacitus,Annals,vi。29。
12。RescriptoftheEmperorPiusinLeg。3,§§1,2,ff。deboniseorumquiantesententiammortemsibiconsciverunt。
13。Leg。18,ff。deinfusvocando。
14。SeetheLawoftheTwelveTables。
15。Rapitinjus。——Horace,Sat。,i。9。Hencetheycouldnotsummonthosetowhomaparticularrespectwasdue。
16。SeeLeg。18,ff。deinjusvocando。
17。BytheancientFrenchlaw,witnesseswereheardonbothsides;hencewefindintheInstitutionsofSt。Louis,i。7,thattherewasonlyapecuniarypunishmentagainstfalsewitnesses。
18。Leg。1,ff。dereceptatoribus。
19。Ibid。
20。SeewhatFavorinussaysinAulusGellius,xx。1。
21。ComparewhatPlutarchsaysintheLycurguswiththelawsoftheDigest,titleDefurtis;andtheInstitutes,iv,tit。1,§§1,2,3。
22。Laws,i。
23。Syrian。,inHermog。
24。TheCornelianlawDeSicariis,Institutes,iv,tit。3,delegeAquilia,§7。
25。SeeLeg。4,ff。adleg。Aquil。
26。Ibid。;seethedecreeofTassillonaddedtothelawoftheBavarians,depopularib。Legib。art。4。
27。Utcarmennecessarium。——Cicero,DeLeg。ii,23。
28。ItistheworkofIrnerius。
29。Testament。Polit。
30。AppendixtotheTheodosiancodeinthefirstvolumeofFatherSirmond’sworks,p。737。
31。AulusGellius,xx。1。
32。Wefindintheverbalprocessofthisordinancethemotivesthatdeterminedhim。
33。InhisordinanceofMontel—les—Tours,intheyear1453。
34。Theymightpunishtheattorney,withouttherebeinganynecessityofdisturbingthepublicorder。
35。Theordinanceoftheyear1667hasmadesomeregulationsuponthishead。
36。Bookii,tit。37。
37。InFatherSirmond’sappendixtotheTheodosiancode,i。
38。Leg。1,Cod。derepudiis。
39。Seetheauthenticsedhodie,intheCod。derepudiis。
40。Leg。1,ff。dePostulando。
41。Sentences,iv。9。
42。DellaguerracivilediFrancia,p。96。
43。ItwasmadeonNovember18,1702。
44。Laws,ix。
45。Itistheauthenticsedcumtestator。
46。Bookxii,tit。2,§16。
47。SeeJuliusCapitolinus,inMacrinus,13。
48。Ibid。
49。InhisUtopia。
BookXXX。TheoryoftheFeudalLawsamongtheFranksintheRelationTheyBeartotheEstablishmentoftheMonarchy1。OfFeudalLaws。IshouldthinkmyworkimperfectwereItopassoverinsilenceaneventwhichneveragain,perhaps,willhappen;wereInottospeakofthoselawswhichsuddenlyappearedoverallEuropewithoutbeingconnectedwithanyoftheformerinstitutions;ofthoselawswhichhavedoneinfinitegoodandinfinitemischief;whichhavesufferedrightstoremainwhenthedemesnehasbeenceded;whichbyvestingseveralwithdifferentkindsofseignoryoverthesamethingsorpersonshavediminishedtheweightofthewholeseignory;whichhaveestablisheddifferentlimitsinempiresoftoogreatextent;whichhavebeenproductiveofrulewithabiastoanarchy,andofanarchywithatendencytoorderandharmony。
Thiswouldrequireaparticularworktoitself;butconsideringthenatureofthepresentundertaking,thereaderwillheremeetratherwithageneralsurveythanwithacompletetreatiseofthoselaws。
Thefeudallawsformaverybeautifulprospect。Avenerableoldoakraisesitsloftyheadtotheskies,theeyeseesfromafaritsspreadingleaves;upondrawingnearer,itperceivesthetrunkbutdoesnotdiscerntheroot;thegroundmustbeduguptodiscoverit。[1]
2。OftheSourceofFeudalLaws。TheconquerorsoftheRomanempirecamefromGermany。Thoughfewancientauthorshavedescribedtheirmanners,yetwehavetwoofverygreatweight。C?sarmakingwaragainsttheGermansdescribesthemannersofthatnation;[2]andupontheseheregulatedsomeofhisenterprises。[3]AfewpagesofC?saruponthissubjectareequaltowholevolumes。
TacitushaswrittenanentireworkonthemannersoftheGermans。Thisworkisshort,butitcomesfromthepenofTacitus,whowasalwaysconcise,becausehesaweverythingatoneglance。
ThesetwoauthorsagreesoperfectlywiththecodesstillextantofthelawsoftheBarbarians,thatreadingC?sarandTacitusweimagineweareperusingthesecodes,andperusingthesecodeswefancywearereadingC?sarandTacitus。
ButifinthisresearchintothefeudallawsIshouldfindmyselfentangledandlostinadarklabyrinth,IfancyIhavetheclueinmyhand,andthatIshallbeabletofindmywaythrough。
3。TheOriginofVassalage。C?sarsays[4]that,"TheGermansneglectedagriculture;thatthegreatestpartofthemliveduponmilk,cheeseandflesh;thatnoonehadlandsorboundariesofhisown;thattheprincesandmagistratesofeachnationallottedwhatportionoflandtheypleasedtoindividuals,andobligedthemtheyearfollowingtoremovetosomeotherpart。"Tacitussays[5]that,"Eachprincehadamultitudeofmen,whowereattachedtohisservice,andfollowedhimwhereverhewent。"Thisauthorgivesthemanameinhislanguageinaccordancewiththeirstate,whichisthatofcompanions。[6]Theyhadastrongemulationtoobtaintheprince’sesteem;andtheprinceshadthesameemulationtodistinguishthemselvesinthebraveryandnumberoftheircompanions。
"Theirdignityandpower,"continuesTacitus,"consistinbeingconstantlysurroundedbyamultitudeofyoungandchosenpeople;thistheyreckontheirornamentinpeace,thistheirdefenceandsupportinwar。Theirnamebecomesfamousathome,andamongneighbouringnations,whentheyexcelallothersinthenumberandcourageoftheircompanions:theyreceivepresentsandembassiesfromallparts。
Reputationfrequentlydecidesthefateofwar。Inbattleitisinfamyintheprincetobesurpassedincourage;itisinfamyinthecompanionsnottofollowthebraveexampleoftheirprince;itisaneternaldisgracetosurvivehim。Todefendhimistheirmostsacredengagement。
Ifacitybeatpeace,theprincesgotothosewhoareatwar;anditisthustheyretainagreatnumberoffriends。Tothesetheygivethewarhorseandtheterriblejavelin。Theirpayconsistsincoarsebutplentifulrepasts。Theprincesupportshisliberalitymerelybywarandplunder。Youmightmoreeasilypersuadethemtoattackanenemyandtoexposethemselvestothedangersofwar,thantocultivatetheland,ortoattendtothecaresofhusbandry;theyrefusetoacquirebysweatwhattheycanpurchasewithblood。"
Thus,amongtheGermans,therewerevassals,butnofiefs;theyhadnofiefs,becausetheprinceshadnolandstogive;orrathertheirfiefsconsistedinhorsestrainedforwar,inarms,andfeasting。Therewerevassals,becausethereweretrustymenwhobeingboundbytheirwordengagedtofollowtheprincetothefield,anddidverynearlythesameserviceaswasafterwardsperformedforthefiefs。
4。ThesameSubjectcontinued。C?sarsays[7]that"whenanyoftheprincesdeclaredtotheassemblythatheintendedtosetoutuponanexpeditionandaskedthemtofollowhim,thosewhoapprovedtheleaderandtheenterprisestoodupandofferedtheirassistance。Uponwhichtheywerecommendedbythemultitude。But,iftheydidnotfulfiltheirengagements,theylostthepublicesteem,andwerelookeduponasdesertersandtraitors。"
WhatC?sarsaysinthisplace,andwhatwehaveextractedintheprecedingchapterfromTacitus,arethesubstanceofthehistoryofourprincesofthefirstrace。
Wemustnotthereforebesurprisedthatourkingsshouldhavenewarmiestoraiseuponeveryexpedition,newtroopstoencourage,newpeopletoengage;thattoacquiremuchtheywereobligedtoincurgreatexpenses;
thattheyshouldbeconstantgainersbythedivisionoflandsandspoils,andyetgivetheselandsandspoilsincessantlyaway:thattheirdemesneshouldcontinuallyincreaseanddiminish;thatafatheruponsettlingakingdomononeofhischildren[8]shouldalwaysgivehimatreasurewithit:thattheking’streasureshouldbeconsideredasnecessarytothemonarchy;andthatonekingcouldnotgivepartofittoforeigners,eveninportionwithhisdaughter,withouttheconsentoftheotherkings。[9]Themonarchymovedbysprings,whichtheywerecontinuallyobligedtowindup。
5。OftheConquestsoftheFranks。ItisnottruethattheFranksuponenteringGaultookpossessionofthewholecountrytoturnitintofiefs。Somehavebeenofthisopinionbecausetheysawthegreatestpartofthecountrytowardstheendofthesecondraceconvertedintofiefs,rear—fiefs,orotherdependencies;butsuchadispositionwasowingtoparticularcauseswhichweshallexplainhereafter。
Theconsequencewhichsundrywriterswouldinferthence,thatthebarbariansmadeageneralregulationforestablishinginallpartsthestateofvillainageisasfalseastheprinciplefromwhichitisderived。Ifatatimewhenthefiefswereprecarious,allthelandsofthekingdomhadbeenfiefs,ordependenciesoffiefs;andallthemeninthekingdomvassalsorbondmensubordinatetovassals;asthepersonthathaspropertyiseverpossessedofpower,theking,whowouldhavecontinuallydisposedofthefiefs,thatis,oftheonlypropertythenexisting;wouldhavehadapowerasarbitraryasthatoftheSultanisinTurkey;whichiscontradictorytoallhistory。
6。OftheGoths,Burgundians,andFranks。GaulwasinvadedbyGermannations。TheVisigothstookpossessionoftheprovinceofNarbonne,andofalmostallthesouth;theBurgundianssettledintheeast;andtheFrankssubduedverynearlyalltherest。
NodoubtbuttheseBarbariansretainedintheirrespectiveconqueststhemanners,inclinations,andusagesoftheirowncountry;fornonationcanchangeinaninstanttheirmannerofthinkingandacting。ThesepeopleinGermanyneglectedagriculture。ItseemsbyC?sarandTacitusthattheyappliedthemselvesgreatlytoapastorallife;hencetheregulationsofthecodesofBarbarianlawsalmostallrelatetotheirflocks。Roricon,whowroteahistoryamongtheFranks,wasashepherd。
7。DifferentWaysofdividingtheLand。AftertheGothsandBurgundianshad,undervariouspretences,penetratedintotheheartoftheempire,theRomans,inordertoputastoptotheirdevastations,wereobligedtoprovidefortheirsubsistence。Atfirsttheyallowedthemcorn,[10]
butafterwardschosetogivethemlands。Theemperors,ortheRomanmagistrates,intheirname,madeparticularconventionswiththemconcerningthedivisionoflands,[11]aswefindinthechroniclesandinthecodesoftheVisigoths[12]andBurgundians。[13]
TheFranksdidnotfollowthesameplan。IntheSalicandRipuarianlaws,wefindnottheleastvestigeofanysuchdivisionoflands;theyhadconqueredthecountry,andsotookwhattheypleased,makingnoregulationsbutamongthemselves。
Letus,therefore,distinguishbetweentheconductoftheBurgundiansandVisigothsinGaul,ofthosesameVisigothsinSpain,oftheauxiliarytroopsunderAugustulusandOdoacerinltaly,[14]andthatoftheFranksinGaul,asalsooftheVandalsinAfrica。[15]Theformerenteredintoconventionswiththeancientinhabitants,andinconsequencethereofmadeadivisionoflandsbetweenthem;thelatterdidnosuchthing。
8。ThesameSubjectcontinued。WhathasinducedsometothinkthattheRomanlandswereentirelyusurpedbytheBarbariansistheirfindinginthelawsoftheVisigothsandtheBurgundiansthatthesetwonationshadtwo—thirdsofthelands;butthistheytookonlyincertainquartersordistrictsassignedthem。
Gundebaldsays,inthelawoftheBurgundians,thathispeopleattheirestablishmenthadtwo—thirdsofthelandsallowedthem;[16]andthesecondsupplementtothislawnoticesthatonlyamoietywouldbeallowedtothosewhoshouldhereaftercometoliveinthatcountry。[17]
Therefore,allthelandshadnotbeendividedinthebeginningbetweentheRomansandtheBurgundians。
Inthosetworegulationswemeetwiththesameexpressionsinthetext,consequentlytheyexplainoneanother;andasthelattercannotmeanauniversaldivisionoflands,neithercanthissignificationbegiventotheformer。
TheFranksactedwiththesamemoderationastheBurgundians;theydidnotstriptheRomanswherevertheyextendedtheirconquests。Whatwouldtheyhavedonewithsomuchland?Theytookwhatsuitedthem,andlefttheremainder。
9。AjustApplicationoftheLawoftheBurgundians,andofthatoftheVisigoths,inrelationtotheDivisionofLands。Itistobeconsideredthatthosedivisionsoflandwerenotmadewithatyrannicalspirit;butwithaviewofrelievingthereciprocalwantsoftwonationsthatweretoinhabitthesamecountry。
ThelawoftheBurgundiansordainsthataBurgundianshallbereceivedinanhospitablemannerbyaRoman。ThisisagreeabletothemannersoftheGermans,who,accordingtoTacitus,[18]werethemosthospitablepeopleintheworld。
BythelawoftheBurgundians,itisordainedthattheBurgundiansshallhavetwo—thirdsofthelands,andone—thirdofthebondmen。Inthisitconsideredthegeniusoftwonations,andconformedtothemannerinwhichtheyprocuredtheirsubsistence。AstheBurgundianskeptherdsandflocks,theywantedagreatdealoflandandfewbondmen,andtheRomans,fromtheirapplicationtoagriculture,hadneedoflessland,andofagreaternumberofbondmen。Thewoodswereequallydivided,becausetheirwantsinthisrespectwerethesame。
WefindinthecodeoftheBurgundians[19]thateachBarbarianwasplacednearaRoman。Thedivisionthereforewasnotgeneral;buttheRomanswhogavethedivisionwereequalinnumbertotheBurgundianswhoreceivedit。TheRomanwasinjuredleast。TheBurgundiansasamartialpeople,fondofhuntingandofapastorallife,didnotrefusetoacceptofthefallowgrounds;whiletheRomanskeptsuchlandsaswereproperestforculture:theBurgundian’sflockfattenedtheRoman’sfield。
10。OfServitudes。ThelawoftheBurgundiansnotices[20]thatwhenthosepeoplesettledinGaul,theywereallowedtwo—thirdsoftheland,andone—thirdofthebondmen。ThestateofvillainagewasthereforeestablishedinthatpartofGaulbeforeitwasinvadedbytheBurgundians。[21]
ThelawoftheBurgundians,inpointsrelatingtothetwonations,makesaformaldistinctioninboth,betweenthenobles,thefreebornandthebondmen。[22]ServitudewasnotthereforeathingpeculiartotheRomans;
norlibertyandnobilitytotheBarbarians。
Thisverysamelawsays,[23]thatifaBurgundianfreedmanhadnotgivenacertainsumtohismaster,norreceivedathirdshareofaRoman,hewasalwayssupposedtobelongtohismaster’sfamily。TheRomanproprietorwasthereforefree,sincehedidnotbelongtoanotherperson’sfamily;hewasfree,becausehisthirdportionwasamarkofliberty。
WeneedonlyopentheSalicandRipuarianlawstobesatisfiedthattheRomanswerenomoreinastateofservitudeamongtheFranksthanamongtheotherconquerorsofGaul。
TheCountdeBoulainvilliersismistakeninthecapitalpointofhissystem:hehasnotprovedthattheFranksmadeageneralregulationwhichreducedtheRomansintoakindofservitude。
Asthisauthor’sworkispennedwithoutart,andashespeakswiththesimplicity,frankness,andcandourofthatancientnobilitywhencehedescends,everyoneiscapableofjudgingofthegoodthingshesays,andoftheerrorsintowhichhehasfallen。Ishallnot,therefore,undertaketocriticisehim;Ishallonlyobservethathehadmorewitthanenlightenment,moreenlightenmentthanlearning;thoughhislearningwasnotcontemptible,forhewaswellacquaintedwiththemostvaluablepartofourhistoryandlaws。
TheCountdeBoulainvilliersandtheAbbéduBoshaveformedtwodifferentsystems,oneofwhichseemstobeaconspiracyagainstthecommons,andtheotheragainstthenobility。WhenthesungaveleavetoPh?tontodrivehischariot,hesaidtohim,"Ifyouascendtoohigh,youwillburntheheavenlymansions;ifyoudescendtoolow,youwillreducetheearthtoashes;donotdrivetotheright,youwillmeettherewiththeconstellationoftheSerpent;avoidgoingtoomuchtotheleft,youwilltherefallinwiththatoftheAltar:keepinthemiddle。"[24]
11。ThesameSubjectcontinued。WhatfirstgaverisetothenotionofageneralregulationmadeatthetimeoftheconquestwasourmeetingwithanimmensenumberofformsofservitudeinFrance,towardsthebeginningofthethirdrace;andasthecontinualprogressionoftheseformsofservitudewasnotperceived,peopleimaginedinanageofobscurityagenerallawwhichwasneverframed。
Towardsthecommencementofthefirstracewemeetwithaninfinitenumberoffreemen,bothamongtheFranksandtheRomans;butthenumberofbondmenincreasedtothatdegree,thatatthebeginningofthethirdraceallthehusbandmenandalmostalltheinhabitantsoftownshadbecomebondmen:[25]andwhereas,atthefirstperiod,therewasverynearlythesameadministrationinthecitiesasamongtheRomans,namely,acorporation,asenate,andcourtsofjudicature;attheotherwehardlymeetwithanythingbutalordandhisbondmen。
WhentheFranks,Burgundians,andGothsmadetheirseveralinvasions,theyseizedupongold,silver,movables,clothes,men,women,boys,andwhateverthearmycouldcarry;thewholewasbroughttooneplace,anddividedamongthearmy。[26]Historyshowsthatafterthefirstsettlement,thatis,afterthefirstdevastation,theyenteredintoanagreementwiththeinhabitants,andleftthemalltheirpoliticalandcivilrights。Thiswasthelawofnationsinthosedays;theyplunderedeverythingintimeofwar,andgrantedeverythingintimeofpeace。Wereitnotso,howshouldwefindbothintheSalicandBurgundianlawssuchanumberofregulationsabsolutelycontrarytoageneralservitudeofthepeople?
Butthoughtheconquestwasnotimmediatelyproductiveofservitude,itaroseneverthelessfromthesamelawofnationswhichsubsistedaftertheconquest。[27]Opposition,revoltsandthetakingoftownswerefollowedbytheslaveryoftheinhabitants。And,nottomentionthewarswhichtheconqueringnationsmadeagainstoneanother,astherewasthispeculiarityamongtheFranks,thatthedifferentpartitionsofthemonarchygaverisecontinuallytocivilwarsbetweenbrothersornephews,inwhichthislawofnationswasconstantlypractised,servitudes,ofcourse,becamemoregeneralinFrancethaninothercountries:andthisis,Ibelieve,oneofthecausesofthedifferencebetweenourFrenchlawsandthoseofItalyandSpain,inrespecttotherightofseigniories。
Theconquestwassoonover,andthelawofnationstheninforcewasproductiveofsomeserviledependences。Thecustomofthesamelawofnations,whichobtainedformanyages,gaveaprodigiousextenttothoseservitudes。
Theodoric[28]imaginingthatthepeopleofAuvergnewerenotfaithfultohim,thusaddressedtheFranksofhisdivision:"Followme,andIwillcarryyouintoacountrywhereyoushallhavegold,silver,captives,clothes,andflocksinabundance;andyoushallremoveallthepeopleintoyourowncountry。"
AftertheconclusionofthepeacebetweenGontramandChilperic,thetroopsemployedinthesiegeofBourges,havinghadorderstoreturn,carriedsuchaconsiderablebootyawaywiththemthattheyhardlylefteithermenorcattleinthecountry。[29]
Theodoric,KingofItaly,whosespiritandpolicyitwasevertodistinguishhimselffromtheotherbarbariankings,uponsendinganarmyintoGaul,wrotethustothegeneral:[30]"ItismywillthattheRomanlawsbefollowed,andthatyourestorethefugitiveslavestotheirrightowners。Thedefenderoflibertyoughtnottoencourageservantstodeserttheirmasters。Letotherkingsdelightintheplunderanddevastationofthetownswhichtheyhavesubdued;wearedesiroustoconquerinsuchamannerthatoursubjectsshalllamenttheirhavingfallentoolateunderourgovernment。"ItisevidentthathisintentionwastocastodiumonthekingsoftheFranksandtheBurgundians,andthathealludedintheabovepassagetotheirparticularlawofnations。
Yetthislawofnationscontinuedinforceunderthesecondrace。KingPepin’sarmy,havingpenetratedintoAquitaine,returnedtoFranceloadedwithanimmensebooty,andwithanumberofbondmen,asweareinformedbytheannalsofMetz。[31]
HeremightIquotenumberlessauthorities;[32]andasthepubliccompassionwasraisedatthesightofthosemiseries,asseveralholyprelates,beholdingthecaptivesinchains,employedthetreasurebelongingtothechurch,andsoldeventhesacredutensils,toransomasmanyastheycould;andasseveralholymonksexertedthemselvesonthatoccasion,itisintheLivesoftheSaintsthatwemeetwiththebestexplanationsonthesubject。[33]And,althoughitmaybeobjectedtotheauthorsofthoselivesthattheyhavebeensometimesalittletoocredulousinrespecttothingswhichGodhascertainlyperformed,iftheywereintheorderofhisprovidence;yetwedrawconsiderablelightthencewithregardtothemannersandusagesofthosetimes。
Whenwecastaneyeuponthemonumentsofourhistoryandlaws,thewholeseemstobeanimmenseexpanse,aboundlessocean;[34]allthosefrigid,dry,insipid,andhardwritingsmustbereadanddevouredinthesamemannerasSaturnisfabledtohavedevouredthestones。
Avastquantityoflandwhichhadbeeninthehandsoffreemen[35]waschangedintomortmain。Whenthecountrywasstrippedofitsfreeinhabitants,thosewhohadagreatmultitudeofbondmeneithertooklargeterritoriesbyforce,orhadthemyieldedbyagreement,andbuiltvillages,asmaybeseenindifferentcharters。Ontheotherhand,thefreemenwhocultivatedtheartsfoundthemselvesreducedtoexercisethoseartsinastateofservitude;thustheservitudesrestoredtotheartsandtoagriculturewhatevertheyhadlost。
Itwasacustomarythingwiththeproprietorsoflands,togivethemtothechurches,inordertoholdthemthemselvesbyaquit—rent,thinkingtopartakebytheirservitudeofthesanctityofthechurches。
12。ThattheLandsbelongingtotheDivisionoftheBarbarianspaidnoTaxes。Apeopleremarkablefortheirsimplicityandpoverty,afreeandmartialpeople,wholivedwithoutanyotherindustrythanthatoftendingtheirflocks,andwhohadnothingbutrushcottagestoattachthemtotheirlands,[36]suchapeople,Isay,musthavefollowedtheirchiefsforthesakeofbooty,andnottopayortoraisetaxes。Theartoftax—gatheringwasinventedlater,andwhenmenbegantoenjoytheblessingsofotherarts。
第53章