Commencedbythemiddleclassesfortheirownprofit,theRevolutionspeedilybecameapopularmovement,andatthesametimeastruggleoftheinstinctiveagainsttherational,arevoltagainstalltheconstraintswhichmakecivilisationoutofbarbarism。Itwasbyrelyingontheprincipleofpopularsovereigntythatthereformersattemptedtoimposetheirdoctrines。Guidedbyleaders,thepeopleintervenedincessantlyinthedeliberationsoftheAssemblies,andcommittedthemostsanguinaryactsofviolence。
ThehistoryofthemultitudesduringtheRevolutioniseminentlyinstructive。Itshowstheerrorofthepoliticianswhoattributeallthevirtuestothepopularsoul。
ThefactsoftheRevolutionteachus,onthecontrary,thatapeoplefreedfromsocialconstraints,thefoundationsofcivilisation,andabandonedtoitsinstinctiveimpulses,speedilyrelapsesintoitsancestralsavagery。Everypopularrevolutionwhichsucceedsintriumphingisatemporaryreturntobarbarism。
IftheCommuneof1871hadlasted,itwouldhaverepeatedtheTerror。Nothavingthepowertokillsomanypeople,ithadtoconfineitselftoburningtheprincipalmonumentsofthecapital。
TheRevolutionrepresentstheconflictofpsychologicalforcesliberatedfromthebondswhosefunctionitistorestrainthem。
Popularinstincts,Jacobinbeliefs,ancestralinfluences,appetites,andpassionsunloosed,allthesevariousinfluencesengagedinafuriousmutualconflictforthespaceoftenyears,duringwhichtimetheysoakedFranceinbloodandcoveredthelandwithruins。
Seenfromadistance,thisseemstobethewholeupshotoftheRevolution。Therewasnothinghomogeneousaboutit。Onemustresorttoanalysisbeforeonecanunderstandandgraspthegreatdramaanddisplaytheimpulseswhichcontinuallyactuateditsheroes。Innormaltimesweareguidedbythevariousformsoflogic——rational,affective,collective,andmystic——whichmoreorlessperfectlybalanceoneanother。Duringseasonsofupheavaltheyenterintoconflict,andmanisnolongerhimself。
WehavebynomeansundervaluedinthisworktheimportanceofcertainacquisitionsoftheRevolutioninrespectoftherightsofthepeople。Butwithmanyotherhistorians,weareforcedtoadmitthattheprizegainedatthecostofsuchruinandbloodshedwouldhavebeenobtainedatalaterdatewithouteffort,bythemereprogressofcivilisation。Forafewyearsgained,whataloadofmaterialdisaster,whatmoraldisintegration!Wearestillsufferingasaresultofthelatter。Thesebrutalpagesinthebookofhistorywilltakelongtoefface:theyarenoteffacedasyet。
Ouryoungmenofto—dayseemtopreferactiontothought。
Disdainingthesteriledissertationsofthephilosophers,theytakenointerestinvainspeculationconcerningmatterswhoseessentialnatureremainsunknown。
Actioniscertainlyanexcellentthing,andallrealprogressisaresultofaction,butitisonlyusefulwhenproperlydirected。
ThemenoftheRevolutionwereassuredlymenofaction,yettheillusionswhichtheyacceptedasguidesledthemtodisaster。
Actionisalwayshurtfulwhen,despisingrealities,itprofessesviolentlytochangethecourseofevents。Onecannotexperimentwithsocietyaswithapparatusinalaboratory。Ourpoliticalupheavalsshowuswhatsuchsocialerrorsmaycost。
AlthoughthelessonoftheRevolutionwasextremelycategorical,manyunpracticalspirits,hallucinatedbytheirdreams,arehopingtorecommenceit。Socialism,themodernsynthesisofthishope,wouldbearegressiontolowerformsofevolution,foritwouldparalysethegreatestsourcesofouractivity。Byreplacingindividualinitiativeandresponsibilitybycollectiveinitiativeandresponsibilitymankindwoulddescendseveralstepsonthescaleofhumanvalues。
Thepresenttimeishardlyfavourabletosuchexperiments。Whiledreamersarepursuingtheirdreams,excitingappetitesandthepassionsofthemultitude,thepeoplesareeverydayarmingthemselvesmorepowerfully。Allfeelthatamidtheuniversalcompetitionofthepresenttimethereisnoroomforweaknations。
InthecentreofEuropeaformidablemilitaryPowerisincreasinginstrength,andaspiringtodominatetheworld,inordertofindoutletsforitsgoods,andforanincreasingpopulation,whichitwillsoonbeunabletonourish。
Ifwecontinuetoshatterourcohesionbyintestinestruggles,partyrivalries,basereligiouspersecutions,andlawswhichfetterindustrialdevelopment,ourpartintheworldwillsoonbeover。Weshallhavetomakeroomforpeoplesmoresolidlyknit,whohavebeenabletoadaptthemselvestonaturalnecessitiesinsteadofpretendingtoturnbackupontheircourse。Thepresentdoesnotrepeatthepast,andthedetailsofhistoryarefullofunforeseenconsequences;butintheirmainlineseventsareconditionedbyeternallaws。
INDEX
Absolutemonarchy,theAccelerationofforcesofviolenceAdministrations,realrulingforcesAffectivelogicAffirmation,powerofAlexanderIofRussiaAlsacelossofAmbition,asamotiveofrevolutionAnarchy,followedbydictatorship;mentalAncestralsoulAncienregime,basesofthe;inconveniencesof;lifeunder;
dissolutionofAncients,CouncilofAnti—clericallawsArmies,oftheRepublic;characterof;victoriesof;causesofsuccessArmy,roleof,inrevolution;in1789
Assemblies,theRevolutionary;psychologyof;obedienttotheclubs;seeNational,Constituent,LegislativeAssemblies,Convention,&c。
AssignatsAugustine,St。
Aulaud,M。
Austria,revolutionin;royalistillusionsastoherattitude;
attackstheRepublicBalfour,Rt。Hon。A。J。,oncoalstrikeBarrasBarrereBartholomew,St。,Massacreof;EuropeanrejoicingoverBastille,takingoftheBattifol,M。
Bayle,P。
Beaulieu,EdictofBedouin,executionsatBelgium,invasionofBeliefs,affectiveandmysticoriginof;intoleranceof;
justificationof;intolerancegreatestbetweenalliedbeliefs;
intoleranceofdemocraticandsocialisticbeliefsBerquin,executedbySorbonneBerry,DuchessdeBillaud—VarenneBismarckBlanc,LouisBlois,StatesofBonaparte,seeNapoleonBonnal,GeneralBossuetBourdeau,M。
Bourgeoisie,theirjealousyofthenoblescausestheRevolution;
theirthirstforrevenge;therealauthorsoftheRevolution;
philosophicideasofBrazilianRevolution,theBritanny,revoltinBroglie,deBrumaire,coupd’etatofBrunswick,Dukeof,hismanifestoBuddhismBureaucracyinFranceCaesar,ondivisionamidtheGaulsCaesarismCaesarsfollowanarchyanddominatemobsCahiers,theCalvin;comparedtoRobespierreCarnotCarrier;crimesof,andtrialCatechismoftheScottishPresbyteriansCatherinedeMedicisCatholicLeagueCavaignac,GeneralChalandonChamp—de—Mars,affairoftheCharlesIX
CharlesX
China,revolutioninChineselabourChristianRevolution,theChristians,mutualhatredofChurch,confiscationofgoodsoftheCivilWarClemenceau,M。
Clergy;civilconstitutionofClubs,the,24—psychologyofthe;obeyedbytheAssemblies;
closed;increasingpowerofthe;seeJacobinsCoalition,theCochin,A。
Colin,M。
Collectiveideas;collectivelogicCollotd’HerboisCommissariesoftheConvention,psychologyofCommittees,theGovernmentalCommuneofParis,the;ininsurrection;chiefpowerinState;
ordersmassacreofSeptember;tyrannyofCommuneof1871
Communes,therevolutionaryComte,A。
Concordat,theCondorcetConstituentAssembly,the;psychologyofthe;itsfearofthepeople;temporarilyresiststhepeople;losespower;itslastactionConstitutionof1791;of1793;of1795;oftheyearVIII
Constitutions,faithinConstraints,social,necessityofConsulate,theContagion,mental;causesof;incrowdsContratSocial,theConvention,giantsofthe;inconsistencyof;decimatesitself;
psychologyofthe;cowardiceof;mentalcharacteristicsof;
compositionof;fearinthe;besiegedbytheCommune;surrendersGirondists;Governmentofthe;abolishesroyalty;dissolvedCouncilofStateCouthonCriminalmentalityCromwellCrowd,PsychologyoftheCrowdsintheFrenchRevolutionCruppi,M。
CubaCunisset—CarnotCurrency,paperDantonDarwin,CharlesDausset,M。
``Days,’’ofMay31;June2;ofJune20;ofAug。10;ofJune2;ofOct。5
Debidour,M。
DeclarationofRights,theDemocracy;intellectualandpopularDepartmentalinsurrectionsDesmoulins,CamilleDictatorshipfollowsanarchyDiderotDirectory,the,failureof;closesclubs;psychologyofthe;
governmentofthe;deportationsunderDiscontent,resultofDreux—BrezeDrinkmann,BaronDubourg,Anne,burnedDumas,PresidentoftheRevolutionaryTribunalDumouriezDurelEgo,analysisoftheElchingen,GeneralElizabeth,EmpressofRussiaEmigres,banishedEmpire,theSecondEncyclopaedists,theEngland,coalstrikeinEnglishRevolution;ConstitutionEnthusiasmEnvyEqualityEvolutionFaguet,E。
Fatalism,historiansonFaubourgs,disarmedFearFederationFerrer,notesonanniversaryofexecutionofFersenFiveHundred,theFontenelleFrance,kingsof;artificialunityofFrancisI
Franco—PrussianwarFraternityFreethinkers,intoleranceofFrenchRevolution,the,revisionofideasconcerning;generallymisunderstood;anewreligiousmovement;originsof;religionsnatureof;descendstolowerclasses;causesof;opinionsofhistoriansconcerning;becomesapopulargovernment;causesofdemocratisation;causesoftheRevolution;astruggleofinstinctagainstreasonFouche,atLyonsFouquier—TinvilleFreronGalileoGermanEmperors``Giants’’oftheConvention;mediocrityofGilbert—LiendonGirondists,the;lateofthe;surrenderedbytheConvention;voteforLouis’deathGlosson,Professor,experimentincrowdpsychologyGovernments,feebleresistanceof,torevolution;besttacticstopursue;revolutionseffectedbyGreekRevolutionGregoireGregoryXIII
Guillotine,regenerationbyGuiraud,M。
Guise,DukeofGuizotHamel,M。
Hamilton,GeneralHanotaux,G。
HanriotHatred,valueofHaxo,GeneralHebertHebertistsHelvetiusHenriII
HenriIII
HenriIV
HenryIVofGermanyHenryVIIIofEnglandHistorians,mistakenviewsof,reFrenchRevolution;opinionsof;
concerningHoche,GeneralHolbachHolland,invasionofHugo,VictorHuguenots,massacreofHumboldtHunter’sancestralinstinctofcarnageIena,explosiononboardofImpartiality,impossibilityofIncendiarism,ofCommuneof1871
Inequality,cravingforInquisition,theIslamItaly,revolutioninJacobinism;failureof;modern;itscrazeforreformsJacobins,the;realprotagonistsoftheRevolution;claimtoreorganiseFranceinnameofpurereason;theyruleFrance;
resultsoftheirtriumph;theoriesof;smallnumbersof;theclubsclosed,;downfallofJourdan,GeneralLaBruyereLaFayetteLanessan,M。
Langlois,GeneralLatinmind,theLavisseLavoisierLeaders,popular,psychologyofLebonLebrun,Mme。VigeeLegendaryhistoryLegislation,faithinLegislativeAssembly,thepsychologyof;characterof;timidityofLettresdecachetLevy,GeneralLiberte,the,explosiononboard``Liberty,Equality,Fraternity’’
LippomanoLogics,differentspeciesofLouisXIII
LouisXIV;povertyunderLouisXVI;flightandcapture;hischance;powersrestored,;aprisoner;regardedastraitor;suspended;trialof;executionof,ablunderLouisXVII
LouisXVIII
Louis—PhilippeLutherMacMahon,MarshalMadelinMohammedMaistre,deMalesherbesMaratMarieAntoinette;influenceofMarieLouiseMassacres,duringwarsofreligion;duringtheFrenchRevolution;
seeSeptember,Commissaries,&c。
MentalitiesprevalentintimeofrevolutionMerlinMicheletMidi,revoltintheMirabeauMonarch,positionof,undertheReformationMonarchicalfeelingMontagnardsMontesquieuMontlucMoorsinSpainMountain,theMysticlogicMysticmentalityNantes,Edictof;revokedNantes,massacresatNapoleon;inRussia;onfatalism;onthe5thofOctober;inItaly;inEgypt;returns;asConsul;reorganisesFrance;defeatedNapoleonIII
NationalAssembly,theNationalGuardNature,returnto,illusionsrespectingNeckerNoailles,ComtedeNoblesrenounceprivileges;emigrateOctober,``days’’ofOlivier,E。
OpinionsandBeliefsOppede,Barond’
Orleans,Ducd’
Paris,hershareintheRevolution。SeePeoplePasteurPeasants,conditionof,beforeRevolution;burnchateauxPeople,the,inrevolution;neverdirectsitself;supposedpartof;thereality;analysisof;thebasepopulace;commencestoterrorisetheAssemblies;thesectionsrisePeoples,thePsychologyofPersecution,religiousPersonality,transformationof,duringrevolutionPetertheGreatPetionPhilipII
PhilippinesPhilosophers,influenceofPlain,thePoissy,assemblyofPoland,decadenceof;revolutionin;partitionofPoliticalbeliefsPope,thePortugueseRevolutionPositivismPredestinationPresbyterianCatechismProtestants,martyrs;persecuteCatholics;exodusof;mentalityofPrussia,invadesFrancePublicsafety,committeeofQuinetRacialmind,stabilityoftheRambaud,M。
Rationallogic,seldomguidesconduct;originalmotiveinFrenchRevolutionReason,GoddessofReformation,the;rationalpovertyofdoctrinesReforms,JacobincravingforReligion,theFrenchrepublicaformofReligion,warsof,theRepetition,valueofRepublic,thefirst;thesecond;thethirdRevision,necessityofRevolutionof1789;seeFrenchRevolution;of1836;of1848;of1870
Revolutions,classificationof;originof;usualobjectofRevolutions,political;resultsofRevolutions,religiousRevolutions,scientificRevolutionaryarmyRevolutionarycommunesRevolutionarymentalityRevolutionarymunicipalitiesRevolutionarytribunalsRobespierre;comparedtoCalvin;HighPontiff;pontiff;reignsalone;solemasteroftheConvention;psychologyof;hisfallRochelleRoland,Mme。
RomanEmpireRossignolRousseauRoussel,F。
RussiaRussianRevolutionRusso—JapanesewarSaint—Denis,destructionoftombsatSaint—JustSedanSeptember,massacresofSieyesSocialdistinctionsSocialism;hatestheelectSorel,A。
Spain,revolutioninStatesGeneralSullaSuspects,LawofSyndicalismTacitusTaine;onJacobinism;hisworkTaxes,pro—revolutionaryTerror,the;motivesof;psychologyof;executionsduring;
stupefyingeffectof;intheprovinces;inthedepartmentsThermidor,reactionofThiebault,GeneralThiers;PresidentThirdEstate,jealousyoftheTocquevilleTolerance,impossiblebetweenopposedorrelatedbeliefsTogo,AdmiralToulon;fallofTraditionTsushimaTuileries,attacked;Louisprisonerin;attackedbypopulaceTurenneTurgotTurkey,revolutioninUnitedStatesUniversalsuffrageValmyVanity,causeofrevolutionVarennes,flighttoVasariVendee,LaVergniaudVersailles,attackonViolence,causesofVoltaireWendell,BarrettWilliams,H。
Young,ArthurEnd
第19章