BOOKII:OFTHERELIGIONSOFTHEUTOPIANS
THEREareseveralsortsofreligions,notonlyindifferentparts
oftheisland,butevenineverytown;someworshippingthesun,
othersthemoonoroneoftheplanets:someworshipsuchmenas
havebeeneminentinformertimesforvirtueorglory,notonlyas
ordinarydeities,butasthesupremeGod:yetthegreaterand
wisersortofthemworshipnoneofthese,butadoreoneeternal,
invisible,infinite,andincomprehensibleDeity;asabeingthat
isfaraboveallourapprehensions,thatisspreadoverthewhole
universe,notbyHisbulk,butbyHispowerandvirtue;Himthey
calltheFatherofAll,andacknowledgethatthebeginnings,the
increase,theprogress,thevicissitudes,andtheendofall
thingscomeonlyfromHim;nordotheyofferdivinehonorstoany
buttoHimalone。Andindeed,thoughtheydifferconcerningother
things,yetallagreeinthis,thattheythinkthereisone
SupremeBeingthatmadeandgovernstheworld,whomtheycallin
thelanguageoftheircountryMithras。Theydifferinthis,that
onethinksthegodwhomheworshipsisthisSupremeBeing,and
anotherthinksthathisidolisthatGod;buttheyallagreein
oneprinciple,thatwhoeveristhisSupremeBeing,Heisalsothat
greatEssencetowhosegloryandmajestyallhonorsareascribed
bytheconsentofallnations。
Bydegrees,theyfallofffromthevarioussuperstitionsthatare
amongthem,andgrowuptothatonereligionthatisthebestand
mostinrequest;andthereisnodoubttobemadebutthatallthe
othershadvanishedlongago,ifsomeofthosewhoadvisedthemto
layasidetheirsuperstitionshadnotmetwithsomeunhappy
accident,whichbeingconsideredasinflictedbyheaven,madethem
afraidthattheGodwhoseworshiphadliketohavebeenabandoned,
hadinterposed,andrevengedthemselvesonthosewhodespised
theirauthority。Aftertheyhadheardfromusanaccountofthe
doctrine,thecourseoflife,andthemiraclesofChrist,andof
thewonderfulconstancyofsomanymartyrs,whoseblood,so
willinglyofferedupbythem,wasthechiefoccasionofspreading
theirreligionoveravastnumberofnations;itisnottobe
imaginedhowinclinedtheyweretoreceiveit。Ishallnot
determinewhetherthisproceededfromanysecretinspirationof
God,orwhetheritwasbecausetseemedsofavorabletothat
communityofgoods,whichisanopinionsoparticularaswellas
sodeartothem;sincetheyperceivedthatChristandhis
followerslivedbythatruleandthatitwasstillkeptupinsome
communitiesamongthesincerestsortofChristians。From
whichsoeverofthesemotivesitmightbe,trueitisthatmanyof
themcameovertoourreligion,andwereinitiatedintoitby
baptism。Butastwoofournumberweredead,sononeofthefour
thatsurvivedwereinpriest’sorders;wethereforecouldonly
baptizethem;sothattoourgreatregrettheycouldnotpartake
oftheothersacraments,thatcanonlybeadministeredbypriests;
buttheyareinstructedconcerningthem,andlongmostvehemently
forthem。Theyhavehadgreatdisputesamongthemselves,whether
onechosenbythemtobeapriestwouldnotbetherebyqualified
todoallthethingsthatbelongtothatcharacter,eventhoughhe
hadnoauthorityderivedfromthePope;andtheyseemedtobe
resolvedtochoosesomeforthatemployment,buttheyhadnotdone
itwhenIleftthem。
Thoseamongthemthathavenotreceivedourreligion,donot
frightanyfromit,andusenoneillthatgoesovertoit;sothat
allthewhileIwasthere,onemanwasonlypunishedonthis
occasion。Hebeingnewlybaptized,did,notwithstandingallthat
wecouldsaytothecontrary,disputepubliclyconcerningthe
Christianreligionwithmorezealthandiscretion;andwithso
muchheat,thathenotonlypreferredourworshiptotheirs,but
condemnedalltheirritesasprofane;andcriedoutagainstall
thatadheredtothem,asimpiousandsacrilegiouspersons,that
weretobedamnedtoeverlastingburnings。Uponhishaving
frequentlypreachedinthismanner,hewasseized,andaftertrial
hewascondemnedtobanishment,notforhavingdisparagedtheir
religion,butforhisinflamingthepeopletosedition:forthis
isoneoftheirmostancientlaws,thatnomanoughttobe
punishedforhisreligion。Atthefirstconstitutionoftheir
government,Utopushavingunderstoodthatbeforehiscomingamong
themtheoldinhabitantshadbeenengagedingreatquarrels
concerningreligion,bywhichtheyweresodividedamong
themselves,thathefounditaneasythingtoconquerthem,since
insteadofunitingtheirforcesagainsthim,everydifferentparty
inreligionfoughtbythemselves;afterhehadsubduedthem,he
madealawthateverymanmightbeofwhatreligionhepleased,
andmightendeavortodrawotherstoitbyforceofargument,and
byamicableandmodestways,butwithoutbitternessagainstthose
ofotheropinions;butthatheoughttousenootherforcebut
thatofpersuasion,andwasneithertomixwithitreproachesnor
violence;andsuchasdidotherwiseweretobecondemnedto
banishmentorslavery。
ThislawwasmadebyUtopus,notonlyforpreservingthepublic
peace,whichhesawsufferedmuchbydailycontentionsand
irreconcilableheats,butbecausehethoughttheinterestof
religionitselfrequiredit。Hejudgeditnotfittodetermine
anythingrashly,andseemedtodoubtwhetherthosedifferentforms
ofreligionmightnotallcomefromGod,whomightinspiremenin
adifferentmanner,andbepleasedwiththisvariety;hetherefore
thoughtitindecentandfoolishforanymantothreatenand
terrifyanothertomakehimbelievewhatdidnotappeartohimto
betrue。Andsupposingthatonlyonereligionwasreallytrue,and
therestfalse,heimaginedthatthenativeforceoftruthwould
atlastbreakforthandshinebright,ifsupportedonlybythe
strengthofargument,andattendedtowithagentleand
unprejudicedmind;while,ontheotherhand,ifsuchdebateswere
carriedonwithviolenceandtumults,asthemostwickedare
alwaysthemostobstinate,sothebestandmostholyreligion
mightbechokedwithsuperstition,ascorniswithbriarsand
thorns。
Hethereforeleftmenwhollytotheirliberty,thattheymightbe
freetobelieveastheyshouldseecause;onlyhemadeasolemn
andseverelawagainstsuchasshouldsofardegeneratefromthe
dignityofhumannatureastothinkthatoursoulsdiedwithour
bodies,orthattheworldwasgovernedbychance,withoutawise
overrulingProvidence:fortheyallformerlybelievedthatthere
wasastateofrewardsandpunishmentstothegoodandbadafter
thislife;andtheynowlookonthosethatthinkotherwiseas
scarcefittobecountedmen,sincetheydegradesonobleabeing
asthesoul,andreckonitnobetterthanabeast’s:thustheyare
farfromlookingonsuchmenasfitforhumansociety,ortobe
citizensofawell-orderedcommonwealth;sinceamanofsuch
principlesmustneeds,asoftashedaresdoit,despisealltheir
lawsandcustoms:forthereisnodoubttobemadethatamanwho
isafraidofnothingbutthelaw,andapprehendsnothingafter
death,willnotscrupletobreakthroughallthelawsofhis
country,eitherbyfraudorforce,whenbythismeanshemay
satisfyhisappetites。Theyneverraiseanythatholdthese
maxims,eithertohonorsoroffices,noremploytheminanypublic
trust,butdespisethem,asmenofbaseandsordidminds:yetthey
donotpunishthem,becausetheylaythisdownasamaximthata
mancannotmakehimselfbelieveanythinghepleases;nordothey
driveanytodissembletheirthoughtsbythreatenings,sothatmen
arenottemptedtolieordisguisetheiropinions;whichbeinga
sortoffraud,isabhorredbytheUtopians。Theytakecareindeed
topreventtheirdisputingindefenceoftheseopinions,
especiallybeforethecommonpeople;buttheysuffer,andeven
encouragethemtodisputeconcerningtheminprivatewiththeir
priestsandothergravemen,beingconfidentthattheywillbe
curedofthosemadopinionsbyhavingreasonlaidbeforethem。
Therearemanyamongthemthatrunfartotheotherextreme,
thoughitisneitherthoughtanillnorunreasonableopinion,and
thereforeisnotatalldiscouraged。Theythinkthatthesoulsof
beastsareimmortal,thoughfarinferiortothedignityofthe
humansoul,andnotcapableofsogreatahappiness。Theyare
almostallofthemveryfirmlypersuadedthatgoodmenwillbe
infinitelyhappyinanotherstate;sothatthoughtheyare
compassionatetoallthataresick,yettheylamentnoman’s
death,excepttheyseehimlothtodepartwithlife;fortheylook
onthisasaveryillpresage,asifthesoul,conscioustoitself
ofguilt,andquitehopeless,wasafraidtoleavethebody,from
somesecrethintsofapproachingmisery。Theythinkthatsucha
man’sappearancebeforeGodcannotbeacceptabletohim,whobeing
calledon,doesnotgooutcheerfully,butisbackwardand
unwilling,andis,asitwere,draggedtoit。Theyarestruckwith
horrorwhentheyseeanydieinthismanner,andcarrythemoutin
silenceandwithsorrow,andprayingGodthathewouldbemerciful
totheerrorsofthedepartedsoul,theylaythebodyinthe
ground;butwhenanydiecheerfully,andfullofhope,theydonot
mournforthem,butsinghymnswhentheycarryouttheirbodies,
andcommendingtheirsoulsveryearnestlytoGod:theirwhole
behavioristhenrathergravethansad,theyburnthebody,and
setupapillarwherethepilewasmade,withaninscriptionto
thehonorofthedeceased。
Whentheycomefromthefuneral,theydiscourseofhisgoodlife
andworthyactions,butspeakofnothingoftenerandwithmore
pleasurethanofhisserenityatthehourofdeath。Theythink
suchrespectpaidtothememoryofgoodmenisboththegreatest
incitementtoengageotherstofollowtheirexample,andthemost
acceptableworshipthatcanbeofferedthem;fortheybelievethat
thoughbytheimperfectionofhumansighttheyareinvisibleto
us,yettheyarepresentamongus,andhearthosediscoursesthat
passconcerningthemselves。Theybelieveitinconsistentwiththe
happinessofdepartedsoulsnottobeatlibertytobewherethey
will,anddonotimaginethemcapableoftheingratitudeofnot
desiringtoseethosefriendswithwhomtheylivedonearthinthe
strictestbondsofloveandkindness:besidestheyarepersuaded
thatgoodmenafterdeathhavetheseaffectionsandallothergood
dispositionsincreasedratherthandiminished,andtherefore
concludethattheyarestillamongtheliving,andobserveall
theysayordo。Fromhencetheyengageinalltheiraffairswith
thegreaterconfidenceofsuccess,astrustingtotheir
protection;whilethisopinionofthepresenceoftheirancestors
isarestraintthatpreventstheirengaginginilldesigns。
Theydespiseandlaughatauguries,andtheothervainand
superstitiouswaysofdivination,somuchobservedamongother
nations;buthavegreatreverenceforsuchmiraclesascannotflow
fromanyofthepowersofnature,andlookonthemaseffectsand
indicationsofthepresenceoftheSupremeBeing,ofwhichthey
saymanyinstanceshaveoccurredamongthem;andthatsometimes
theirpublicprayers,whichupongreatanddangerousoccasions
theyhavesolemnlyputuptoGod,withassuredconfidenceofbeing
heard,havebeenansweredinamiraculousmanner。
TheythinkthecontemplatingGodinHisworks,andtheadoringHim
forthem,isaveryacceptablepieceofworshiptoHim。
Therearemanyamongthem,thatuponamotiveofreligionneglect
learning,andapplythemselvestonosortofstudy;nordothey
allowthemselvesanyleisuretime,butareperpetuallyemployed。
believingthatbythegoodthingsthatamandoeshesecuresto
himselfthathappinessthatcomesafterdeath。Someofthesevisit
thesick;othersmendhighways,cleanseditches,repairbridges,
ordigturf,gravel,orstones。Othersfellandcleavetimber,and
bringwood,corn,andothernecessariesoncartsintotheirtowns。
Nordotheseonlyservethepublic,buttheyserveevenprivate
men,morethantheslavesthemselvesdo;forifthereisanywhere
arough,hard,andsordidpieceofworktobedone,fromwhich
manyarefrightenedbythelaborandloathsomenessofit,ifnot
thedespairofaccomplishingit,theycheerfully,andoftheirown
accord,takethattotheirshare;andbythatmeans,astheyease
othersverymuch,sotheyafflictthemselves,andspendtheir
wholelifeinhardlabor;andyettheydonotvaluethemselves
uponthis,norlessenotherpeople’scredittoraisetheirown;
butbytheirstoopingtosuchservileemployments,theyaresofar
frombeingdespised,thattheyaresomuchthemoreesteemedby
thewholenation
Ofthesetherearetwosorts;someliveunmarriedandchaste,and
abstainfromeatinganysortofflesh;andthusweaningthemselves
fromallthepleasuresofthepresentlife,whichtheyaccount
hurtful,theypursue,evenbythehardestandpainfullestmethods
possible,thatblessednesswhichtheyhopeforhereafter;andthe
nearertheyapproachtoit,theyarethemorecheerfulandearnest
intheirendeavorsafterit。Anothersortofthemislesswilling
toputthemselvestomuchtoil,andthereforepreferamarried
statetoasingleone;andastheydonotdenythemselvesthe
pleasureofit,sotheythinkthebegettingofchildrenisadebt
whichtheyowetohumannatureandtotheircountry;nordothey
avoidanypleasurethatdoesnothinderlabor,andthereforeeat
fleshsomuchthemorewillingly,astheyfindthatbythismeans
theyarethemoreabletowork;theUtopianslookupontheseas
thewisersect,buttheyesteemtheothersasthemostholy。They
wouldindeedlaughatanyman,whofromtheprinciplesofreason
wouldpreferanunmarriedstatetoamarried,oralifeoflabor
toaneasylife;buttheyreverenceandadmiresuchasdoitfrom
themotivesofreligion。Thereisnothinginwhichtheyaremore
cautiousthaningivingtheiropinionpositivelyconcerningany
sortofreligion。Thementhatleadthoseseverelivesarecalled
inthelanguageoftheircountryBrutheskas,whichanswersto
thosewecallreligiousorders。
Theirpriestsaremenofeminentpiety,andthereforetheyarebut
fewforthereareonlythirteenineverytown,oneforevery
temple;butwhentheygotowar,sevenofthesegooutwiththeir
forces,andsevenothersarechosentosupplytheirroomintheir
absence;buttheseenteragainupontheiremploymentwhenthey
return;andthosewhoservedintheirabsenceattenduponthe
high-priest,tillvacanciesfallbydeath;forthereisoneset
overalltherest。Theyarechosenbythepeopleastheother
magistratesare,bysuffragesgiveninsecret,forpreventingof
factions;andwhentheyarechosentheyareconsecratedbythe
CollegeofPriests。Thecareofallsacredthings,theworshipof
God,andaninspectionintothemannersofthepeople,are
committedtothem。Itisareproachtoamantobesentforbyany
ofthem,orforthemtospeaktohiminsecret,forthatalways
givessomesuspicion。Allthatisincumbentonthemisonlyto
exhortandadmonishthepeople;forthepowerofcorrectingand
punishingillmenbelongswhollytothePrinceandtotheother
magistrates。Theseverestthingthatthepriestdoesisthe
excludingthosethataredesperatelywickedfromjoiningintheir
worship。Thereisnotanysortofpunishmentmoredreadedbythem
thanthis,forasitloadsthemwithinfamy,soitfillsthemwith
secrethorrors,suchistheirreverencetotheirreligion;nor
willtheirbodiesbelongexemptedfromtheirshareoftrouble;
foriftheydonotveryquicklysatisfythepriestsofthetruth
oftheirrepentance,theyareseizedonbytheSenate,and
punishedfortheirimpiety。Theeducationofyouthbelongstothe
priests,yettheydonottakesomuchcareofinstructingthemin
lettersasinformingtheirmindsandmannersaright;theyuseall
possiblemethodstoinfuseveryearlyintothetenderandflexible
mindsofchildrensuchopinionsasarebothgoodinthemselvesand
willbeusefultotheircountry。Forwhendeepimpressionsof
thesethingsaremadeatthatage,theyfollowmenthroughthe
wholecourseoftheirlives,andconducemuchtopreservethe
peaceofthegovernment,whichsuffersbynothingmorethanby
vicesthatriseoutofill-opinions。Thewivesoftheirpriests
arethemostextraordinarywomenofthewholecountry;sometimes
thewomenthemselvesaremadepriests,thoughthatfallsoutbut
seldom,norareanybutancientwidowschosenintothatorder。
Noneofthemagistrateshasgreaterhonorpaidhimthanispaid
thepriests;andiftheyshouldhappentocommitanycrime,they
wouldnotbequestionedforit。TheirpunishmentislefttoGod,
andtotheirownconsciences;fortheydonotthinkitlawfulto
layhandsonanyman,howwickedsoeverheis,thathasbeenina
peculiarmannerdedicatedtoGod;nordotheyfindanygreat
inconvenienceinthis,bothbecausetheyhavesofewpriests,and
becausethesearechosenwithmuchcaution,sothatitmustbea
veryunusualthingtofindonewhomerelyoutofregardtohis
virtue,andforhisbeingesteemedasingularlygoodman,was
raiseduptosogreatadignity,degenerateintocorruptionand
vice。Andifsuchathingshouldfallout,formanisachangeable
creature,yettherebeingfewpriests,andthesehavingno
authoritybutwhatrisesoutoftherespectthatispaidthem,
nothingofgreatconsequencetothepubliccanproceedfromthe
indemnitythatthepriestsenjoy。
Theyhaveindeedveryfewofthem,lestgreaternumberssharingin
thesamehonormightmakethedignityofthatorderwhichthey
esteemsohighlytosinkinitsreputation。Theyalsothinkit
difficulttofindoutmanyofsuchanexaltedpitchofgoodness,
astobeequaltothatdignitywhichdemandstheexerciseofmore
thanordinaryvirtues。Norarethepriestsingreaterveneration
amongthemthantheyareamongtheirneighboringnations,asyou
mayimaginebythatwhichIthinkgivesoccasionforit。
WhentheUtopiansengageinbattle,thepriestswhoaccompanythem
tothewar,apparelledintheirsacredvestments,kneeldown
duringtheaction,inaplacenotfarfromthefield;andlifting
uptheirhandstoheaven,pray,firstforpeace,andthenfor
victorytotheirownside,andparticularlythatitmaybegained
withouttheeffusionofmuchbloodoneitherside;andwhenthe
victoryturnstotheirside,theyruninamongtheirownmento
restraintheirfury;andifanyoftheirenemiesseethem,orcall
tothem,theyarepreservedbythatmeans;andsuchascancomeso
nearthemastotouchtheirgarments,havenotonlytheirlives,
buttheirfortunessecuredtothem;itisuponthisaccountthat
allthenationsroundaboutconsiderthemsomuch,andtreatthem
withsuchreverence,thattheyhavebeenoftennolessableto
preservetheirownpeoplefromthefuryoftheirenemies,thanto
savetheirenemiesfromtheirrage;forithassometimesfallen
out,thatwhentheirarmieshavebeenindisorder,andforcedto
fly,sothattheirenemieswererunningupontheslaughterand
spoil,thepriestsbyinterposinghaveseparatedthemfromone
another,andstoppedtheeffusionofmoreblood;sothatbytheir
mediationapeacehasbeenconcludedonveryreasonableterms;nor
isthereanynationaboutthemsofierce,cruel,orbarbarousas
nottolookupontheirpersonsassacredandinviolable。
Thefirstandthelastdayofthemonth,andoftheyear,isa
festival。Theymeasuretheirmonthsbythecourseofthemoon,and
theiryearsbythecourseofthesun。Thefirstdaysarecalledin
theirlanguagetheCynemernes,andthelasttheTrapemernes;which
answersinourlanguagetothefestivalthatbegins,orends,the
season。
Theyhavemagnificenttemples,thatarenotonlynoblybuilt,but
extremelyspacious;whichisthemorenecessary,astheyhaveso
fewofthem;theyarealittledarkwithin,whichproceedsnot
fromanyerrorinthearchitecture,butisdonewithdesign;for
theirprieststhinkthattoomuchlightdissipatesthethoughts,
andthatamoremoderatedegreeofitbothrecollectsthemindand
raisesdevotion。Thoughtherearemanydifferentformsofreligion
amongthem,yetallthese,howvarioussoever,agreeinthemain
point,whichistheworshippingoftheDivineEssence;and
thereforethereisnothingtobeseenorheardintheirtemplesin
whichtheseveralpersuasionsamongthemmaynotagree;forevery
sectperformsthoseritesthatarepeculiartoit,intheir
privatehouses,noristhereanythinginthepublicworshipthat
contradictstheparticularwaysofthosedifferentsects。There
arenoimagesforGodintheirtemples,sothateveryonemay
representHimtohisthoughts,accordingtothewayofhis
religion;nordotheycallthisoneGodbyanyothernamethan
thatofMithras,whichisthecommonnamebywhichtheyall
expresstheDivineEssence,whatsoeverotherwisetheythinkitto
be;norarethereanyprayersamongthembutsuchaseveryoneof
themmayusewithoutprejudicetohisownopinion。
Theymeetintheirtemplesontheeveningofthefestivalthat
concludesaseason:andnothavingyetbroketheirfast,they
thankGodfortheirgoodsuccessduringthatyearormonth,which
isthenatanend;andthenextdaybeingthatwhichbeginsthe
newseason,theymeetearlyintheirtemples,toprayforthe
happyprogressofalltheiraffairsduringthatperioduponwhich
theythenenter。Inthefestivalwhichconcludestheperiod,
beforetheygotothetemple,bothwivesandchildrenfallon
theirkneesbeforetheirhusbandsorparents,andconfess
everythinginwhichtheyhaveeithererredorfailedintheir
duty,andbegpardonforit。Thusalllittlediscontentsin
familiesareremoved,thattheymayofferuptheirdevotionswith
apureandserenemind;fortheyholditagreatimpietytoenter
uponthemwithdisturbedthoughts,orwithaconsciousnessof
theirbearinghatredorangerintheirheartstoanyperson
whatsoever;andthinkthattheyshouldbecomeliabletosevere
punishmentsiftheypresumedtooffersacrificeswithoutcleansing
theirhearts,andreconcilingalltheirdifferences。Inthe
temples,thetwosexesareseparated,themengototheright
hand,andthewomentotheleft;andthemalesandfemalesall
placethemselvesbeforetheheadandmasterormistressofthat
familytowhichtheybelong;sothatthosewhohavethegovernment
ofthemathomemayseetheirdeportmentinpublic;andthey
interminglethemso,thattheyoungerandtheoldermaybesetby
oneanother;foriftheyoungersortwereallsettogether,they
wouldperhapstrifleawaythattimetoomuchinwhichtheyought
tobegetinthemselvesthatreligiousdreadoftheSupremeBeing,
whichisthegreatestandalmosttheonlyincitementtovirtue。
Theyofferupnolivingcreatureinsacrifice,nordotheythink
itsuitabletotheDivineBeing,fromwhosebountyitisthat
thesecreatureshavederivedtheirlives,totakepleasurein
theirdeaths,ortheofferingupoftheirblood。Theyburnincense
andothersweetodors,andhaveagreatnumberofwaxlights
duringtheirworship;notoutofanyimaginationthatsuch
oblationscanaddanythingtothedivinenature,whicheven
prayerscannotdo;butasitisaharmlessandpurewayof
worshippingGod,sotheythinkthosesweetsavorsandlights,
togetherwithsomeotherceremonies,byasecretandunaccountable
virtue,elevatemen’ssouls,andinflamethemwithgreaterenergy
andcheerfulnessduringthedivineworship。
Allthepeopleappearinthetemplesinwhitegarments,butthe
priest’svestmentsareparti-colored,andboththeworkandcolors
arewonderful。Theyaremadeofnorichmaterials,fortheyare
neitherembroiderednorsetwithpreciousstones,butarecomposed
oftheplumesofseveralbirds,laidtogetherwithsomuchartand
soneatly,thatthetruevalueofthemisfarbeyondthecostliest
materials。Theysaythatintheorderingandplacingthoseplumes
somedarkmysteriesarerepresented,whichpassdownamongtheir
priestsinasecrettraditionconcerningthem;andthattheyare
ashieroglyphics,puttingtheminmindoftheblessingsthatthey
havereceivedfromGod,andoftheirdutiesbothtoHimandto
theirneighbors。Assoonasthepriestappearsinthoseornaments,
theyallfallprostrateontheground,withsomuchreverenceand
sodeepasilencethatsuchaslookoncannotbutbestruckwith
it,asifitweretheeffectoftheappearanceofadeity。After
theyhavebeenforsometimeinthisposture,theyallstandup,
uponasigngivenbythepriest,andsinghymnstothehonorof
God,somemusicalinstrumentsplayingallthewhile。Theseare
quiteofanotherformthanthoseusedamongus:butasmanyof
themaremuchsweeterthanours,soothersaremadeuseofbyus。
Yetinonethingtheyverymuchexceedus;alltheirmusic,both
vocalandinstrumental,isadaptedtoimitateandexpressthe
passions,andissohappilysuitedtoeveryoccasion,thatwhether
thesubjectofthehymnbecheerfulorformedtosootheortrouble
themind,ortoexpressgrieforremorse,themusictakesthe
impressionofwhateverisrepresented,affectsandkindlesthe
passions,andworksthesentimentsdeepintotheheartsofthe
hearers。Whenthisisdone,bothpriestsandpeopleofferupvery
solemnprayerstoGodinasetformofwords;andtheseareso
composed,thatwhatsoeverispronouncedbythewholeassemblymay
belikewiseappliedbyeverymaninparticulartohisown
condition;inthesetheyacknowledgeGodtobetheauthorand
governoroftheworld,andthefountainofallthegoodthey
receive,andthereforeofferuptoHimtheirthanksgiving;andin
particularblessHimforHisgoodnessinorderingitsothatthey
arebornunderthehappiestgovernmentintheworld,andareofa
religionwhichtheyhopeisthetruestofallothers:butifthey
aremistaken,andifthereiseitherabettergovernmentora
religionmoreacceptabletoGod,theyimploreHimgoodnesstolet
themknowit,vowingthattheyresolvetofollowHimwhithersoever
Heleadsthem。Butiftheirgovernmentisthebestandtheir
religionthetruest,thentheypraythatHemayfortifythemin
it,andbringalltheworldbothtothesamerulesoflife,andto
thesameopinionsconcerningHimself;unless,accordingtothe
unsearchablenessofHismind,Heispleasedwithavarietyof
religions。ThentheypraythatGodmaygivethemaneasypassage
atlasttoHimself;notpresumingtosetlimitstoHim,howearly
orlateitshouldbe;butifitmaybewishedfor,without
derogatingfromHissupremeauthority,theydesiretobequickly
delivered,andtobetakentoHimself,thoughbythemostterrible
kindofdeath,ratherthantobedetainedlongfromseeingHimby
themostprosperouscourseoflife。Whenthisprayerisended,
theyallfalldownagainupontheground,andafteralittlewhile
theyriseup,gohometodinner,andspendtherestofthedayin
diversionormilitaryexercises。
ThushaveIdescribedtoyou,asparticularlyasIcould,the
constitutionofthatcommonwealth,whichIdonotonlythinkthe
bestintheworld,butindeedtheonlycommonwealththattruly
deservesthatname。Inallotherplacesitisvisible,thatwhile
peopletalkofacommonwealth,everymanonlyseekshisown
wealth;butthere,wherenomanhasanyproperty,allmen
zealouslypursuethegoodofthepublic:and,indeed,itisno
wondertoseemenactsodifferently;forinothercommonwealths,
everymanknowsthatunlessheprovidesforhimself,how
flourishingsoeverthecommonwealthmaybe,hemustdieofhunger;
sothatheseesthenecessityofpreferringhisownconcernsto
thepublic;butinUtopia,whereeverymanhasarightto
everything,theyallknowthatifcareistakentokeepthepublic
storesfull,noprivatemancanwantanything;foramongthem
thereisnounequaldistribution,sothatnomanispoor,nonein
necessity;andthoughnomanhasanything,yettheyareallrich;
forwhatcanmakeamansorichastoleadasereneandcheerful
life,freefromanxieties;neitherapprehendingwanthimself,nor
vexedwiththeendlesscomplaintsofhiswife?Heisnotafraidof
themiseryofhischildren,norishecontrivinghowtoraisea
portionforhisdaughters,butissecureinthis,thatbothheand
hiswife,hischildrenandgrandchildren,toasmanygenerations
ashecanfancy,willalllivebothplentifullyandhappily;since
amongthemthereisnolesscaretakenofthosewhowereonce
engagedinlabor,butgrowafterwardunabletofollowit,than
thereiselsewhereofthesethatcontinuestillemployed。
Iwouldgladlyhearanymancomparethejusticethatisamongthem
withthatofallothernations;amongwhom,mayIperish,ifIsee
anythingthatlookseitherlikejusticeorequity:forwhat
justiceisthereinthis,thatanobleman,agoldsmith,abanker,
oranyotherman,thateitherdoesnothingatall,oratbestis
employedinthingsthatareofnousetothepublic,shouldlive
ingreatluxuryandsplendor,uponwhatissoillacquired;anda
meanman,acarter,asmith,oraploughman,thatworksharder
eventhanthebeaststhemselves,andisemployedinlaborsso
necessary,thatnocommonwealthcouldholdoutayearwithout
them,canonlyearnsopooralivelihood,andmustleadso
miserablealife,thattheconditionofthebeastsismuchbetter
thantheirs?Forasthebeastsdonotworksoconstantly,sothey
feedalmostaswell,andwithmorepleasure;andhavenoanxiety
aboutwhatistocome,whilstthesemenaredepressedbyabarren
andfruitlessemployment,andtormentedwiththeapprehensionsof
wantintheiroldage;sincethatwhichtheygetbytheirdaily
labordoesbutmaintainthematpresent,andisconsumedasfast
asitcomesin,thereisnooverpluslefttolayupforoldage。
Isnotthatgovernmentbothunjustandungrateful,thatisso
prodigalofitsfavorstothosethatarecalledgentlemen,or
goldsmiths,orsuchotherswhoareidle,orliveeitherby
flattery,orbycontrivingtheartsofvainpleasure;andonthe
otherhand,takesnocareofthoseofameanersort,suchas
ploughmen,colliers,andsmiths,withoutwhomitcouldnot
subsist?Butafterthepublichasreapedalltheadvantageof
theirservice,andtheycometobeoppressedwithage,sickness,
andwant,alltheirlaborsandthegoodtheyhavedoneis
forgotten;andalltherecompensegiventhemisthattheyareleft
todieingreatmisery。Therichersortareoftenendeavoringto
bringthehireoflaborerslower,notonlybytheirfraudulent
practices,butbythelawswhichtheyprocuretobemadetothat
effect;sothatthoughitisathingmostunjustinitself,to
givesuchsmallrewardstothosewhodeservesowellofthe
public,yettheyhavegiventhosehardshipsthenameandcolorof
justice,byprocuringlawstobemadeforregulatingthem。
ThereforeImustsaythat,asIhopeformercy,Icanhaveno
othernotionofalltheothergovernmentsthatIseeorknow,than
thattheyareaconspiracyoftherich,whoonpretenceof
managingthepubliconlypursuetheirprivateends,anddeviseall
thewaysandartstheycanfindout;first,thattheymay,without
danger,preserveallthattheyhavesoillacquired,andthenthat
theymayengagethepoortotoilandlaborforthemataslow
ratesaspossible,andoppressthemasmuchastheyplease。Andif
theycanbutprevailtogetthesecontrivancesestablishedbythe
showofpublicauthority,whichisconsideredasthe
representativeofthewholepeople,thentheyareaccountedlaws。
Yetthesewickedmenaftertheyhave,byamostinsatiable
covetousness,dividedthatamongthemselveswithwhichallthe
restmighthavebeenwellsupplied,arefarfromthathappiness
thatisenjoyedamongtheUtopians:fortheuseaswellasthe
desireofmoneybeingextinguished,muchanxietyandgreat
occasionsofmischiefiscutoffwithit。Andwhodoesnotsee
thatthefrauds,thefts,robberies,quarrels,tumults,
contentions,seditions,murders,treacheries,andwitchcrafts,
whichareindeedratherpunishedthanrestrainedbytheseverities
oflaw,wouldallfalloff,ifmoneywerenotanymorevaluedby
theworld?Men’sfears,solicitudes,cares,labors,andwatchings,
wouldallperishinthesamemomentwiththevalueofmoney:even
povertyitself,forthereliefofwhichmoneyseemsmost
necessary,wouldfall。But,inordertotheapprehendingthis
aright,takeoneinstance。
Consideranyyearthathasbeensounfruitfulthatmanythousands
havediedofhunger;andyetifattheendofthatyearasurvey
wasmadeofthegranariesofalltherichmenthathavehoardedup
thecorn,itwouldbefoundthattherewasenoughamongthemto
havepreventedallthatconsumptionofmenthatperishedin
misery;andthatifithadbeendistributedamongthem,nonewould
havefelttheterribleeffectsofthatscarcity;soeasyathing
woulditbetosupplyallthenecessitiesoflife,ifthatblessed
thingcalledmoney,whichispretendedtobeinventedfor
procuringthem,wasnotreallytheonlythingthatobstructed
theirbeingprocured!
Idonotdoubtbutrichmenaresensibleofthis,andthatthey
wellknowhowmuchagreaterhappinessitistowantnothing
necessarythantoaboundinmanysuperfluities,andtoberescued
outofsomuchmiserythantoaboundwithsomuchwealth;andI
cannotthinkbutthesenseofeveryman’sinterest,addedtothe
authorityofChrist’scommands,whoasHewasinfinitelywise,
knewwhatwasbest,andwasnotlessgoodindiscoveringittous,
wouldhavedrawnalltheworldovertothelawsoftheUtopians,
ifpride,thatplagueofhumannature,thatsourceofsomuch
misery,didnothinderit;forthisvicedoesnotmeasure
happinesssomuchbyitsownconveniencesasbythemiseriesof
others;andwouldnotbesatisfiedwithbeingthoughtagoddess,
ifnonewereleftthatweremiserable,overwhomshemightinsult。
Pridethinksitsownhappinessshinesthebrighterbycomparingit
withthemisfortunesofotherpersons;thatbydisplayingitsown
wealth,theymayfeeltheirpovertythemoresensibly。Thisis
thatinfernalserpentthatcreepsintothebreastsofmortals,and
possessesthemtoomuchtobeeasilydrawnout;andthereforeIam
gladthattheUtopianshavefallenuponthisformofgovernment,
inwhichIwishthatalltheworldcouldbesowiseastoimitate
them;fortheyhaveindeedlaiddownsuchaschemeandfoundation
ofpolicy,thatasmenlivehappilyunderit,soitisliketobe
ofgreatcontinuance;fortheyhavingrootedoutofthemindsof
theirpeoplealltheseedsbothofambitionandfaction,thereis
nodangerofanycommotionathome;whichalonehasbeentheruin
ofmanyStatesthatseemedotherwisetobewellsecured;butas
longastheyliveinpeaceathome,andaregovernedbysuchgood
laws,theenvyofalltheirneighboringprinces,whohaveoften
thoughinvainattemptedtheirruin,willneverbeabletoput
theirStateintoanycommotionordisorder。
WhenRaphaelhadthusmadeanendofspeaking,thoughmanythings
occurredtome,bothconcerningthemannersandlawsofthat
people,thatseemedveryabsurd,aswellintheirwayofmaking
war,asintheirnotionsofreligionanddivinematters;together
withseveralotherparticulars,butchieflywhatseemedthe
foundationofalltherest,theirlivingincommon,withoutthe
useofmoney,bywhichallnobility,magnificence,splendor,and
majesty,which,accordingtothecommonopinion,arethetrue
ornamentsofanation,wouldbequitetakenaway;——yetsinceI
perceivedthatRaphaelwasweary,andwasnotsurewhetherhe
couldeasilybearcontradiction,rememberingthathehadtaken
noticeofsomewhoseemedtothinktheywereboundinhonorto
supportthecreditoftheirownwisdom,byfindingoutsomething
tocensureinallothermen’sinventions,besidestheirown;I
onlycommendedtheirconstitution,andtheaccounthehadgivenof
itingeneral;andsotakinghimbythehand,carriedhimto
supper,andtoldhimIwouldfindoutsomeothertimefor
examiningthissubjectmoreparticularly,andfordiscoursingmore
copiouslyuponit;andindeedIshallbegladtoembracean
opportunityofdoingit。Inthemeanwhile,thoughitmustbe
confessedthatheisbothaverylearnedman,andapersonwhohas
obtainedagreatknowledgeoftheworld,Icannotperfectlyagree
toeverythinghehasrelated;however,therearemanythingsin
theCommonwealthofUtopiathatIratherwish,thanhope,tosee
followedinourgovernments。
第4章