TheQueristcontainingseveralQueriesproposedtotheconsiderationofthePublicItheLordhavebroughtdownthehightree,haveexaltedthelowtree,havedriedupthegreentree,andhavemadethedrytreetoflourish。——Ezek。xvii,24。
AdvertisementbytheAuthorTheQueristwasfirstpublishedintheyearonethousandsevenhundredandthirty—five;sincewhichtimethefaceofthingsissomewhatchanged。Inthiseditionsomealterationshavebeenmade。ThethreePartsarepublishedinone;somefewQueriesareadded,andmanyomitted,particularlyofthoserelatingtothesketchorplanofanationalbank,whichitmaybetimeenoughtotakeagaininhandwhenthepublicshallseemdisposedtomakeuseofsuchanexpedient。IhaddeterminedwithmyselfnevertoprefixmynametotheQuerist,butinthelasteditionwasoverruledbyafriend,whowasremarkableforpursuingthepublicinterestwithasmuchdiligenceasothersdotheirown。I
apprehendthesamecensureonthisthatIincurreduponanotheroccasion,formeddlingoutofmyprofession;thoughtofeedthehungryandclothethenaked,bypromotinganhonestindustry,will,perhaps,bedeemednoimproperemploymentforaclergymanwhostillthingshimselfamemberofthecommonwealth。Asthesumofhumanhappinessissupposedtoconsistinthegoodsofmind,body,andfortune,Iwouldfainmakemystudiesofsomeusetomankindwithregardtoeachofthesethreeparticulars,andhopeitwillnotbethoughtfaultyorindecentinanyman,ofwhatprofessionsoever,toofferhismitetowardsimprovingthemanners,health,andprosperityofhisfellow—creatures。
QUERY1Whetherthereeverwas,is,orwillbe,anindustriousnationpoor,oranidlerich?
2Whetherapeoplecanbecalledpoor,wherethecommonsortarewellfed,clothed,andlodged?
3WhetherthedriftandaimofeverywiseStateshouldnotbe,toencourageindustryinitsmembers?Andwhetherthosewhoemployneitherheadsnorhandsforthecommonbenefitdeservenottobeexpelledlikedronesoutofawell—governedState?
4Whetherthefourelements,andman’slabourtherein,benotthetruesourceofwealth?
5Whethermoneybenotonlysofaruseful,asitstirrethupindustry,enablingmenmutuallytoparticipatethefruitsofeachother’slabour?
6Whetheranyothermeans,equallyconducingtoexciteandcirculatetheindustryofmankind,maynotbeasusefulasmoney。
7Whethertherealendandaimofmenbenotpower?Andwhetherhewhocouldhaveeverythingelseathiswishorwillwouldvaluemoney?
8Whetherthepublicaimineverywell—governedStatebenotthateachmember,accordingtohisjustpretensionsandindustry,shouldhavepower?
9Whetherpowerbenotreferredtoaction;andwhetheractiondothnotfollowappetiteorwill?
10Whetherfashiondothnotcreateappetites;andwhethertheprevailingwillofanationisnotthefashion?
11Whetherthecurrentofindustryandcommercebenotdeterminedbythisprevailingwill?
12Whetheritbenotowingtocustomthatthefashionsareagreeable?
13Whetheritmaynotconcernthewisdomofthelegislaturetointerposeinthemakingoffashions;andnotleaveanaffairofsogreatinfluencetothemanagementofwomenandfops,tailorsandvintners?
14Whetherreasonablefashionsareagreaterrestraintonfreedomthanthosewhichareunreasonable?
15Whetherageneralgoodtasteinapeoplewouldnotgreatlyconducetotheirthriving?Andwhetheranuneducatedgentrybenotthegreatestofnationalevils?
16Whethercustomsandfashionsdonotsupplytheplaceofreasoninthevulgarofallranks?Whether,therefore,itdothnotverymuchimportthattheyshouldbewiselyframed?
17Whethertheimitatingthoseneighboursinourfashions,towhomwebearnolikenessinourcircumstances,benotonecauseofdistresstothisnation?
18Whetherfrugalfashionsintheupperrank,andcomfortablelivinginthelower,benotthemeanstomultiplyinhabitants?
19WhetherthebulkofourIrishnativesarenotkeptfromthriving,bythatcynicalcontentindirtandbeggarywhichtheypossesstoadegreebeyondanyotherpeopleinChristendom?
20Whetherthecreatingofwantsbenotthelikeliestwaytoproduceindustryinapeople?Andwhether,ifourpeasantswereaccustomedtoeatbeefandwearshoes,theywouldnotbemoreindustrious?
21Whetherotherthingsbeinggiven,asclimate,soil,etc。,thewealthbenotproportionedtotheindustry,andthistothecirculationofcredit,bethecreditcirculatedortransferredbywhatmarksortokenssoever?
22Whether,therefore,lessmoneyswiftlycirculating,benot,ineffect,equivalenttomoremoneyslowlycirculating?Or,whether,ifthecirculationbereciprocallyasthequantityofcoin,thenationcanbealoser?
23Whethermoneyistobeconsideredashavinganintrinsicvalue,orasbeingacommodity,astandard,ameasure,orapledge,asisvariouslysuggestedbywriters?Andwhetherthetrueideaofmoney,assuch,benotaltogetherthatofaticketorcounter?
24Whetherthevalueorpriceofthingsbenotacompoundedproportion,directlyasthedemand,andreciprocallyastheplenty?
25Whetherthetermscrown,livre,poundsterling,etc。,arenottobeconsideredasexponentsordenominationsofsuchproportion?Andwhethergold,silver,andpaperarenotticketsorcountersforreckoning,recording,andtransferringthereof?
26Whetherthedenominationsbeingretained,althoughthebullionweregone,thingsmightnotneverthelessberated,bought,andsold,industrypromoted,andacirculationofcommercemaintained?
27Whetheranequalraisingofallsortsofgold,silver,andcoppercoincanhaveanyeffectinbringingmoneyintothe?Andwhetheralteringtheproportionsbetweenthekingdomseveralsortscanhaveanyothereffectbutmultiplyingonekindandlesseninganother,withoutanyincreaseofthesumtotal?
28Whetherarbitrarychangingthedenominationofcoinbenotapubliccheat?
29Whatmakesawealthypeople?Whetherminesofgoldandsilverarecapableofdoingthis?Andwhetherthenegroes,amidstthegoldsandsofAfric,arenotpooranddestitute?
30Whethertherebeanyvirtueingoldorsilver,otherthanastheysetpeopleatwork,orcreateindustry?
31Whetheritbenottheopinionorwillofthepeople,excitingthemtoindustry,thattrulyenrichethanation?Andwhetherthisdothnotprincipallydependonthemeansforcounting,transferring,andpreservingpower,thatis,propertyofallkinds?
32Whetheriftherewasnosilverorgoldinthekingdom,ourtrademightnot,nevertheless,supplybillsofexchange,sufficienttoanswerthedemandsofabsenteesinEnglandorelsewhere?
33Whethercurrentbank—notesmaynotbedeemedmoney?Andwhethertheyarenotactuallythegreaterpartofthemoneyofthiskingdom?
34Providedthewheelsmove,whetheritisnotthesamething,astotheeffectofthemachine,bethisdonebytheforceofwind,orwater,oranimals?
35Whetherpowertocommandtheindustryofothersbenotrealwealth?Andwhethermoneybenotintruthticketsortokensforconveyingandrecordingsuchpower,andwhetheritbeofgreatconsequencewhatmaterialstheticketsaremadeof?
36Whethertrade,eitherforeignordomestic,beintruthanymorethanthiscommerceofindustry?
37Whethertopromote,transfer,andsecurethiscommerce,andthispropertyinhumanlabour,or,inotherwords,thispower,benotthesolemeansofenrichingapeople,andhowfarthismaybedoneindependentlyofgoldandsilver?
38Whetheritwerenotwrongtosupposelanditselftobewealth?
Andwhethertheindustryofthepeopleisnotfirsttobeconsidered,asthatwhichconstituteswealth,whichmakesevenlandandsilvertobewealth,neitherofwhichwouldhave,anyvaluebutasmeansandmotivestoindustry?
39WhetherinthewastesofAmericaamanmightnotpossesstwentymilessquareofland,andyetwanthisdinner,oracoattohisback?
40Whetherafertileland,andtheindustryofitsinhabitants,wouldnotproveinexhaustiblefundsofrealwealth,bethecountersforconveyingandrecordingthereofwhatyouwill,paper,gold,orsilver?
41Whetherasinglehintbesufficienttoovercomeaprejudice?
Andwhetherevenobvioustruthswillnotsometimesbearrepeating?
42Whether,ifhumanlabourbethetruesourceofwealth,itdothnotfollowthatidlenessshouldofallthingsbediscouragedinawiseState?
43Whetherevengoldorsilver,iftheyshouldlessentheindustryofitsinhabitants,wouldnotberuinoustoacountry?
AndwhetherSpainbenotaninstanceofthis?
44Whethertheopinionofmen,andtheirindustryconsequentthereupon,benotthetruewealthofHollandandnotthesilversupposedtobedepositedinthebankatAmsterdam?
45Whetherthereisintruthanysuchtreasurelyingdead?Andwhetheritbeofgreatconsequencetothepublicthatitshouldberealratherthannotional?
46Whether,inordertounderstandthetruenatureofwealthandcommerce,itwouldnotberighttoconsideraship’screwcastuponadesertisland,andbydegreesformingthemselvestobusinessandcivillife,whileindustrybegotcredit,andcreditmovedtoindustry?
47Whethersuchmenwouldnotallsetthemselvestowork?Whethertheywouldnotsubsistbythemutualparticipationofeachother’sindustry?Whether,whenonemanhadinhiswayprocuredmorethanhecouldconsume,hewouldnotexchangehissuperfluitiestosupplyhiswants?Whetherthismustnotproducecredit?Whether,tofacilitatetheseconveyances,torecordandcirculatethiscredit,theywouldnotsoonagreeoncertaintallies,tokens,tickets,orcounters?
48Whetherreflectioninthebettersortmightnotsoonremedyourevils?Andwhetherourrealdefectbenotawrongwayofthinking?
49Whetheritwouldnotbeanunhappyturninourgentlemen,iftheyshouldtakemorethoughttocreateaninteresttothemselvesinthisorthatcounty,orborough,thantopromotetherealinterestoftheircountry?
50Whetherifamanbuildsahousehedothnotinthefirstplaceprovideaplanwhichgovernshiswork?Andshallthepubicactwithoutanend,aview,aplan?
51Whetherbyhowmuchthelessparticularfolkthinkforthemselves,thepublicbenotsomuchthemoreobligedtothinkforthem?
52Whethersmallgainsbenotthewaytogreatprofit?Andifourtradesmenarebeggars,whethertheymaynotthankthemselvesforit?
53Whethersomewaymightnotbefoundformakingcriminalsusefulinpublicworks,insteadofsendingthemeithertoAmerica,ortotheotherworld?
54Whetherwemaynot,aswellasothernations,contriveemploymentforthem?Andwhetherservitude,chains,andhardlabour,foratermofyears,wouldnotbeamorediscouragingaswellasamoreadequatepunishmentforfelonsthanevendeathitself?
55WhethertherearenotsuchthingsinHollandasbetteringhousesforbringingyounggentlementoorder?Andwhethersuchaninstitutionwouldbeuselessamongus?
56WhetheritbetruethatthepoorinHollandhavenoresourcebuttheirownlabour,andyettherearenobeggarsintheirstreets?
57Whetherhewhoseluxuryconsumethforeignproducts,andwhoseindustryproducethnothingdomestictoexchangeforthem,isnotsofarforthinjurioustohiscountry?
58Whethernecessityisnottobehearkenedtobeforeconvenience,andconveniencebeforeluxury?
59Whethertoprovideplentifullyforthepoorbenotfeedingtheroot,thesubstancewhereofwillshootupwardsintothebranches,andcausethetoptoflourish?
60WhethertherebeanyinstanceofaStatewhereinthepeople,livingneatlyandplentifully,didnotaspiretowealth?
61Whethernastinessandbeggarydonot,onthecontrary,extinguishallsuchambition,makingmenlistless,hopeless,andslothful?
62Whetheracountryinhabitedbypeoplewellfed,clothedandlodgedwouldnotbecomeeverydaymorepopulous?Andwhetheranumerousstockofpeopleinsuchcircumstanceswould?andhowfartheproductofnotconstituteaflourishingnation;ourowncountrymaysufficeforthecompassingofthisend?
63Whetherapeoplewhohadprovidedthemselveswiththenecessariesoflifeingoodplentywouldnotsoonextendtheirindustrytonewartsandnewbranchesofcommerce?
64WhetherthosesamemanufactureswhichEnglandimportsfromothercountriesmaynotbeadmittedfromIreland?And,ifso,whetherlace,carpets,andtapestry,threeconsiderablearticlesofEnglishimportation,mightnotfindencouragementinIreland?
Andwhetheranacademyfordesignmightnotgreatlyconducetotheperfectingthosemanufacturesamongus?
65WhetherFranceandFlanderscouldhavedrawnsomuchmoneyfromEnglandforfiguredsilks,lace,andtapestry,iftheyhadnothadacademiesfordesigning?
66Whether,whenaroomwasonceprepared,andmodelsinplasterofParis,theannualexpenseofsuchanacademyneedstandthepubicinabovetwohundredpoundsayear?
67Whetherourlinen—manufacturewouldnotfindthebenefitofthisinstitution?AndwhethertherebeanythingthatmakesusfallshortoftheDutchindamasks,diapers,andprintedlinen,butourignoranceindesign?
68Whetherthosewhomayslightthisaffairasnotionalhavesufficientlyconsideredtheextensiveuseoftheartofdesign,anditsinfluenceinmosttradesandmanufactures,whereintheformsofthingsareoftenmoreregardedthanthematerials?
69Whethertherebeanyartsoonerlearnedthanthatofmakingcarpets?Andwhetherourwomen,withlittletimeandpains,maynotmakemorebeautifulcarpetsthanthoseimportedfromTurkey?
Andwhetherthisbranchofthewoollenmanufacturebenotopentous?
70Whetherhumanindustrycanproduce,fromsuchcheapmaterials,amanufactureofsogreatvaluebyanyotherartasbythoseofsculptureandpainting?
71Whetherpicturesandstatuesarenotinfactsomuchtreasure?
AndwhetherRomeandFlorencewouldnotbepoortownswithoutthem?
72Whethertheydonotbringreadymoneyaswellasjewels?
WhetherinItalydebtsarenotpaid,andchildrenportionedwiththem,aswithgoldandsilver?
73Whetheritwouldnotbemoreprudent,tostrikeoutandexertourselvesinpermittedbranchesoftrade,thantofoldourhands,andrepinethatwearenotallowedthewoollen?
74WhetheritbetruethattwomillionsareyearlyexpendedbyEnglandinforeignlaceandlinen?
75WhetherimmensesumsarenotdrawnyearlyintotheNortherncountries,forsupplyingtheBritishnavywithhempenmanufactures?
76Whethertherebeanythingmoreprofitablethan。hemp?Andwhetherthereshouldnotbegreatpremiumsforencouragingourhempentrade?WhatadvantagesmaynotGreatBritainmakeofacountrywherelandandlabouraresocheap?
77WhetherIrelandalonemightnotraisehempsufficientfortheBritishnavy?AndwhetheritwouldnotbevaintoexpectthisfromtheBritishColoniesinAmerica,wherehandsaresoscarce,andlaboursoexcessivelydear?
78Whether,ifourownpeoplewantwillorcapacityforsuchanattempt,itmightnotbeworthwhileforsomeundertakingspiritsinEnglandtomakesettlements,andraisehempinthecountiesofClareandLimerick,thanwhich,perhaps,thereisnotfitterlandintheworldforthatpurpose?Andwhetherbothnationswouldnotfindtheiradvantagetherein?
79Whetherifalltheidlehandsinthiskingdomwereemployedonhempandflax,wemightnotfindsufficientventforthesemanufactures?
80Howfaritmaybeinourownpowertobetterouraffairs,withoutinterferingwithourneighbours?
81Whethertheprohibitionofourwoollentradeoughtnotnaturallytoputusonothermethodswhichgivenojealousy?
82Whetherpaperbenotavaluablearticleofcommerce?AndwhetheritbenottruethatonesinglebooksellerinLondonyearlyexpendedabovefourthousandpoundsinthatforeigncommodity?
83HowitcomestopassthattheVenetiansandGenoese,whowearsomuchlesslinen,andsomuchworsethanwedo,shouldyetmakeverygoodpaper,andingreatquantity,whilewemakeverylittle?
84Howlongitwillbebeforemycountrymenfindoutthatitisworthwhiletospendapennyinordertogetagroat?
85Ifallthelandweretilledthatisfitfortillage,andallthatsowedwithhempandflaxthatisfitforraisingthem,whetherweshouldhavemuchsheep—walkbeyondwhatwassufficienttosupplythenecessitiesofthekingdom?
86Whetherothercountrieshavenotflourishedwithoutthewoollentrade?
87Whetheritbenotasuresignoreffectofacountry’sinhabitants?And,thriving,toseeitwellcultivatedandfullof;ifso,whetheragreatquantityofsheep—walkbenotruinoustoacountry,renderingitwasteandthinlyinhabited?
88WhethertheemployingsomuchofourlandundersheepbenotinfactanIrishblunder?
89WhetherourhankeringafterourwoollentradebenotthetrueandonlyreasonwhichhathcreatedajealousyinEnglandtowardsIreland?Andwhetheranythingcanhurtusmorethansuchjealousy?
90Whetheritbenotthetrueinterestofbothnationstobecomeonepeople?Andwhethereitherbesufficientlyapprisedofthis?
91WhethertheupperpartofthispeoplearenottrulyEnglish,byblood,language,religion,manners,inclination,andinterest?
92WhetherwearenotasmuchEnglishmenasthechildrenofoldRomans,borninBritain,werestillRomans?
93Whetheritbenotourtrueinterestnottointerferewiththem;and,ineveryothercase,whetheritbenottheirtrueinteresttobefriendus?
94WhetheramintinIrelandmightnotbeofgreatconveniencetothekingdom;andwhetheritcouldbeattendedwithanypossibleinconveniencetoGreatBritain?AndwhethertherewerenotmintsinNaplesandSicily,whenthosekingdomswereprovincestoSpainorthehouseofAustria?
95WhetheranythingcanbemoreridiculousthanforthenorthofIrelandtobejealousofalinenmanufacturerinthesouth?
96WhetherthecountyofTipperarybenotmuchbetterlandthanthecountyofArmagh;andyetwhetherthelatterisnotmuchbetterimprovedandinhabitedthantheformer?
97Whethereverylandlordinthekingdomdothnotknowthecauseofthis?Andyethowfewarethebetterforsuchtheirknowledge?
98Whetherlargefarmsunderfewhands,orsmallonesundermany,arelikelytobemademostof?Andwhetherflaxandtillagedonotnaturallymultiplyhands,anddividelandintosmallholdings,andwell—improved?
99Whether,asourexportsarelessened,weoughtnottolessenourimports?Andwhetherthesewillnotbelessenedasourdemands,andtheseasourwants,andtheseasourcustomsorfashions?Ofhowgreatconsequencethereforearefashionstothepublic?
100Whetheritwouldnotbemorereasonabletomendourstatethantocomplainofit;andhowfarthismaybeinourownpower?
101WhatthenationgainsbythosewholiveinIrelandupontheproduceofforeignCountries?
102Howfarthevanityofourladiesindressing,andofourgentlemenindrinking,contributestothegeneralmiseryofthepeople?
103Whethernations,aswiseandopulentasours,havenotmadesumptuarylaws;andwhathindersusfromdoingthesame?
104Whetherthosewhodrinkforeignliquors,anddeckthemselvesandtheirfamilieswithforeignornaments,arenotsofarforthtobereckonedabsentees?
105Whether,asourtradeislimited,weoughtnottolimitourexpenses;andwhetherthisbenotthenaturalandobviousremedy?
106Whetherthedirt,andfamine,andnakednessofthebulkofourpeoplemightnotberemedied,evenalthoughwehadnoforeigntrade?Andwhetherthisshouldnotbeourfirstcare;andwhether,ifthiswereonceprovidedfor,theconveniencesoftherichwouldnotsoonfollow?
107Whethercomfortablelivingdothnotproducewants,andwantsindustry,andindustrywealth?
108WhetherthereisnotagreatdifferencebetweenHollandandIreland?Andwhetherforeigncommerce,withoutwhichtheonecouldnotsubsist,besonecessaryfortheother?
109Mightwenotputahandtotheplough,orthespade,althoughwehadnoforeigncommerce?
110Whethertheexigenciesofnaturearenottobeansweredbyindustryonourownsoil?Andhowfartheconveniencesandcomfortsoflifemaybeprocuredbyadomesticcommercebetweentheseveralpartsofthiskingdom?
111Whetherthewomenmaynotsew,spin,weave,embroidersufficientlyfortheembellishmentoftheirpersons,andevenenoughtoraiseenvyineachother,withoutbeingbeholdentoforeigncountries?
112Supposethebulkofourinhabitantshadshoestotheirfeet,clothestotheirbacks,andbeefintheirbellies,mightnotsuchastatebeeligibleforthepublic,eventhoughthesquireswerecondemnedtodrinkaleandcider?
113Whether,ifdrunkennessbeanecessaryevil,menmaynotaswelldrinkthegrowthoftheirowncountry?
114Whetheranationwithinitselfmightnothaverealwealth,sufficienttogiveitsinhabitantspoweranddistinction,withoutthehelpofgoldandsilver?
115Whether,iftheartsofsculptureandpaintingwereencouragedamongus,wemightnotfurnishourhousesinamuchnoblermannerwithourownmanufactures?
116Whetherwehavenot,ormaynothave,allthenecessarymaterialsforbuildingathome?
117WhethertilesandplastermaynotsupplytheplaceofNorwayfirforflooringandwainscot?
118Whetherplasterbenotwarmer,aswellasmoresecure,thandeal?Andwhetheramodernfashionablehouse,linedwithfir,daubedoverwithoilandpaint,benotlikeafire—ship,readytobelightedupbyallaccidents?
119Whetherlargerhouses,betterbuiltandfurnished,agreatertrainofservants,thedifferencewithregardtoequipageandtablebetweenfinerandcoarser,moreandlesselegant,maynotbesufficienttofeedareasonableshareofvanity,orsupportallproperdistinctions?Andwhetherallthesemaynotbeprocuredbydomesticindustryoutofthefourelements,withoutransackingthefourquartersoftheglobe?
120Whetheranythingisanoblerornament,intheeyeoftheworld,thananItalianpalace,thatis,stoneandmortarskilfullyputtogether,andadornedwithsculptureandpainting;
andwhetherthismaynotbecompassedwithoutforeigntrade?
121Whetheranexpenseingardensandplantationswouldnotbeanelegantdistinctionfortherich,adomesticmagnificenceemployingmanyhandswithin,anddrawingnothingfromabroad?
122WhethertheapologywhichismadeforforeignluxuryinEngland,towit,thattheycouldnotcarryontheirtradewithoutimportsaswellasexports,willholdinIreland?
123Whetheronemaynotbeallowedtoconceiveandsupposeasocietyornationofhumancreatures,cladinwoollenclothsandstuffs,eatinggoodbread,beefandmutton,poultryandfish,ingreatplenty,drinkingale,mead,andcider,inhabitingdecenthousesbuiltofbrickandmarble,takingtheirpleasureinfairparksandgardens,dependingonnoforeignimportseitherforfoodorraiment?Andwhethersuchpeopleoughtmuchtobepitied?
124WhetherIrelandbenotaswellqualifiedforsuchastateasanynationunderthesun?
125Whetherinsuchastatetheinhabitantsmaynotcontrivetopassthetwenty—fourhourswithtolerableeaseandcheerfulness?
Andwhetheranypeopleuponearthcandomore?
126Whethertheymaynoteat,drink,play,dress,visit,sleepingoodbeds,sitbygoodfires,build,plant,raiseaname,makeestates,andspendthem?
127Whether,uponthewhole,adomestictrademaynotsufficeinsuchacountryasIreland,tonourishandclotheitsinhabitants,andprovidethemwiththereasonableconveniencesandevencomfortsoflife?
128Whetherageneralhabitoflivingwellwouldnotproducenumbersandindustry’andwhether,consideringthetendencyofhumankind,theconsequencethereofwouldnotbeforeigntradeandriches,howunnecessarysoever?
129Whether,nevertheless,itbeacrimetoinquirehowfarwemaydowithoutforeigntrade,andwhatwouldfollowonsuchasupposition?
130Whetherthenumberandwelfareofthesubjectsbenotthetruestrengthofthecrown?
131Whetherinallpublicinstitutionsthereshouldnotbeanendproposed,whichistobetheruleandlimitofthemeans?Whetherthisendshouldnotbethewell—beingofthewhole?Andwhether,inordertothis,thefirststepshouldnotbetoclotheandfeedourpeople?
132WhethertherebeuponearthanyChristianorcivilizedpeoplesobeggarly,wretched,anddestituteasthecommonIrish?
133Whether,nevertheless,thereisanyotherpeoplewhosewantsmaybemoreeasilysuppliedfromhome?
134Whether,iftherewasawallofbrassathousandcubitshighroundthiskingdom,ournativesmightnotneverthelesslivecleanlyandcomfortably,tilltheland,andreapthefruitsofit?
135Whatshouldhinderusfromexertingourselves,usingourhandsandbrains,doingsomethingorother,man,woman,andchild,liketheotherinhabitantsofGod’searth?
136Betherestrainingourtradewellorilladvisedinourneighbours,withrespecttotheirowninterest,yetwhetheritbenotplainlyourstoaccommodateourselvestoit?
137Whetheritbenotvaintothinkofpersuadingotherpeopletoseetheirinterest,whilewecontinueblindtoourown?
138Whethertherebeanyothernationpossessedofsomuchgoodland,andsomanyablehandstoworkit,whichyetisbeholdenforbreadtoforeigncountries?
139Whetheritbetruethatweimportcorntothevalueoftwohundredthousandpoundsinsomeyears?
140Whetherwearenotundonebyfashionsmadeforotherpeople?
Andwhetheritbenotmadnessinapoornationtoimitatearichone?
141Whetherawomanoffashionoughtnottobedeclaredapublicenemy?
142WhetheritbenotcertainthatfromthesingletownofCorkwereexported,inoneyear,nolessthanonehundredandseventhousandonehundredandsixty—onebarrelsofbeef;seventhousandthreehundredandseventy—ninebarrelsofpork;thirteenthousandfourhundredandsixty—onecasks,andeighty—fivethousandsevenhundredandtwenty—sevenfirkinsofbutter?Andwhathandswereemployedinthismanufacture?
143Whetheraforeignercouldimaginethatonehalfofthepeoplewerestarving,inacountrywhichsentoutsuchplentyofprovisions?
144WhetheranIrishlady,setoutwithFrenchsilksandFlanderslace,maynotbesaidtoconsumemorebeefandbutterthanahundredofourlabouringpeasants?
145Whethernine—tenthsofourforeigntradebenotcarriedonsinglytosupportthearticleofvanity?
146Whetheritcanbehopedthatprivatepersonswillnotindulgethisfolly,unlessrestrainedbythepublic?
147Howvanityismaintainedinothercountries?WhetherinHungary,forinstance,aproudnobilityarenotsubsistedwithsmallimportsfromabroad?
148WhethertherebeaprouderpeopleuponearththanthenobleVenetians,althoughtheyallwearplainblackclothes?
149Whetherapeoplearetobepitiedthatwillnotsacrificetheirlittleparticularvanitiestothepublic。good?Andyet,whethereachpartwouldnotexcepttheirownfoiblefromthispublicsacrifice,thesquirehisbottle,theladyherlace?
150Whetherclaretbenotoftendrankratherforvanitythanforhealth,orpleasure?
151Whetheritbetruethatmenofnicepalateshavebeenimposedon,byelderwineforFrenchclaret,andbymeadforpalmsack?
152DonotEnglishmenabroadpurchasebeerandciderattentimesthepriceofwine?
153HowmanygentlemenarethereinEnglandofathousandpoundsperannumwhoneverdrinkwineintheirownhouses?WhetherthesamemaybesaidofanyinIrelandwhohaveeven?onehundredpoundsperannum。
154WhatreasonshaveourneighboursinEnglandfordiscouragingFrenchwineswhichmaynotholdwithrespecttousalso?
155Howmuchofthenecessarysustenanceofourpeopleisyearlyexportedforbrandy?
156Whether,ifpeoplemustpoisonthemselves,theyhadnotbetterdoitwiththeirowngrowth?
157IfweimportedneitherclaretfromFrance,norfirfromNorway,whatthenationwouldsavebyit?
158Whentherootyieldethinsufficientnourishment,whethermendonottopthetreetomakethelowerbranchesthrive?
159Whether,ifourladiesdranksageorbalmteaoutofIrishware,itwouldbeaninsupportablenationalcalamity?
160Whetheritbereallytruethatsuchwineisbestasmostencouragesdrinking,i。e。,thatmustbegiveninthelargestdosetoproduceitseffect?Andwhetherthisholdswithregardtoanyothermedicine?
161Whetherthattradeshouldnotbeaccountedmostperniciouswhereinthebalanceismostagainstus?AndwhetherthisbenotthetradewithFrance?
162Whetheritbenotevenmadnesstoencouragetradewithanationthattakesnothingofourmanufacture?
163WhetherIrelandcanhopetothriveifthemajorpartofherpatriotsshallbefoundintheFrenchinterest?
164WhethergreatplentyandvarietyofexcellentwinesarenottobehadonthecoastsofItalyandSicily?Andwhetherthosecountrieswouldnottakeourcommoditiesoflinen,leather,butter,etc。inexchangeforthem?
165Particularly,whethertheVinumMamertinum,whichgrowsonthemountainsaboutMessina,aredgenerouswine,highlyesteemed(ifwemaycreditPliny)bytheancientRomans,wouldnotcomecheap,andpleasethepalatesofourIslanders?
166Why,ifabribebythepalateorthepursebeineffectthesamething,theyshouldnotbealikeinfamous?
167Whetherthevanityandluxuryofafewoughttostandincompetitionwiththeinterestofanation?
168Whethernationalwantsoughtnottobetheruleoftrade?Andwhetherthemostpressingwantsof。themajorityoughtnottobefirstconsidered?
169Whetheritispossiblethecountryshouldbewellimproved,whileourbeefisexported,andourlabourersliveuponpotatoes?
170Ifitberesolvedthatwecannotdowithoutforeigntrade,whether,atleast,itmaynotbeworthwhiletoconsiderwhatbranchesthereofdeservetobeentertained,andhowfarwemaybeabletocarryitonunderourpresentlimitations?
171Whatforeignimportsmaybenecessaryforclothingandfeedingthefamiliesofpersonsnotworthaboveonehundredpoundsayear?Andhowmanywealthierthereareinthekingdom,andwhatproportiontheybeartotheotherinhabitants?
172Whethertradebenotthenonarightfoot,whenforeigncommoditiesareimportedinexchangeonlyfordomesticsuperfluities?
173Whetherthequantitiesofbeef,butter,wool,andleather,exportedfromthisisland,canbereckonedthesuperfluitiesofacountry,wheretherearesomanynativesnakedandfamished?
174Whetheritwouldnotbewisesotoorderourtradeastoexportmanufacturesratherthanprovisions,andofthosesuchasemploymosthands?
175Whethershewouldnotbeaveryvilematron,andjustlythoughteithermadorfoolish,thatshouldgiveawaythenecessariesoflifefromhernakedandfamishedchildren,inexchangeforpearlstostickinherhair,andsweetmeatstopleaseherownpalate?
176Whetheranationmightnotbeconsideredasafamily?
177WhethertheremarkmadebyaVenetianambassadortoCardinalRichelieu——’ThatFranceneedednothingtoberichandeasy,buttoknowhowtospendwhatshedissipates’maynotbeofusealsotootherpeople?
178Whetherhungrycattlewillnotleapoverbounds?Andwhethermostmenarenothungryinacountrywhereexpensivefashionsobtain?
179Whetherthereshouldnotbepublishedyearly,schedulesofourtrade,containinganaccountoftheimportsandexportsoftheforegoingyear?
180Whetherothermethodsmaynotbefoundforsupplyingthefunds,besidesthecustomonthingsimported?
181Whetheranyartormanufacturebesodifficultasthemakingofgoodlaws?
182Whetherourpeersandgentlemenarebornlegislators?Or,whetherthatfacultybeacquiredbystudyandreflection?
183Whethertocomprehendtherealinterestofapeople,andthemeanstoprocureit,dothnotimplysomefundofknowledge,historical,moral,andpolitical,withafacultyofreasonimprovedbylearning?
184WhethereveryenemytolearningbenotaGoth?AndwhethereverysuchGothamongusbenotanenemytothecountry?
185Whether,therefore,itwouldnotbeanomenofillpresage,adreadfulphenomenonintheland,ifourgreatmenshouldtakeitintheirheadstoderidelearningandeducation?
186Whether,onthecontrary,itshouldnotseemworthwhiletoerectamartofliteratureinthiskingdom,underwiserregulationsandbetterdisciplinethaninanyotherpartofEurope?Andwhetherthiswouldnotbeaninfalliblemeansofdrawingmenandmoneyintothekingdom?
187Whetherthegovernedbenottoonumerousforthegoverningpartofourcollege?Andwhetheritmightnotbeexpedienttoconvertthirtynatives—placesintotwentyfellowships?
188Whether,ifwehadtwocolleges,theremightnotspringausefulemulationbetweenthem?Andwhetheritmightnotbecontrivedsotodividethefellows,scholars,andrevenuesbetweenboth,asthatnomembershouldbealoserthereby?
189Whethertenthousandpoundswelllaidoutmightnotbuildadecentcollege,fittocontaintwohundredpersons;andwhetherthepurchasemoneyofthechamberswouldnotgoagoodwaytowardsdefrayingtheexpense?
190Wherethiscollegeshouldbesituated?
191Whether,inimitationoftheJesuitsatParis,whoadmitProtestantstostudyintheircolleges,itmaynotberightforusalsotoadmitRomanCatholicsintoourcollege,withoutobligingthemtoattendchapelduties,orcatechisms,ordivinitylectures?Andwhetherthismightnotkeepmoneyinthekingdom,andpreventtheprejudicesofaforeigneducation?
192WhetheritispossibleaStateshouldnotthrive,whereofthelowerpartwereindustrious,andtheupperwise?
193Whetherthecollectedwisdomofagesandnationsbenotfoundinbooks?
194WhetherThemistocleshisartofmakingalittlecity,oralittlepeople,becomeagreatonebelearnedanywheresowellasinthewritingsoftheancients?
195WhetherawiseStatehathanyinterestnearerheartthantheeducationofyouth?
196Whetherthemind,likesoil,dothnotbydisusegrowstiffandwhetherreasoningandstudybenotlikestirringanddividingtheglebe?
197Whetheranearlyhabitofreflexion,althoughobtainedbyspeculativesciences,maynothaveitsuseinpracticalaffairs?
198Whethereventhosepartsofacademicallearningwhicharequiteforgottenmaynothaveimprovedandenrichedthesoil,likethosevegetableswhichareraised,notforthemselves,butploughedinforadressingofland?
199WhetheritwasnotanIrishprofessorwhofirstopenedthepublicschoolsatOxford?Whetherthisislandhathnotbeenancientlyfamousforlearning?Andwhetheratthisdayithathanybetterchanceforbeingconsiderable?
200Whetherwemaynotwithbettergracesitdownandcomplain,whenwehavedoneallthatliesinourpowertohelpourselves?
201Whetherthegentlemanofestatehatharighttobeidle;andwhetherheoughtnottobethegreatpromoteranddirectorofindustryamonghistenantsandneighbours?
202WhetherinthecantonsofSwitzerlandallunderthirtyyearsofagearenotexcludedfromtheirgreatcouncils?
203WhetherHomer’scompendiumofeducation,wouldnotbeagoodruleformoderneducatorsofyouth?Andwhetherhalfthelearningandstudyofthesekingdomsisnotuseless,forwantofaproperdeliveryandpunctuationbeingtaughtinourschoolsandcolleges?
204Whetherinanyorderagoodbuildingcanbemadeofbadmaterials?OrwhetheranyformofgovernmentcanmakeahappyStateoutofbadindividuals?
205WhatwasitthatSolomoncomparedtoajewelofgoldinaswine’ssnout?
206Whetherthepublicismoreconcernedinanythingthanintheprocreationofablecitizens?
207Whethertothemultiplyingofhumankind,itwouldnotmuchconduceifmarriagesweremadewithgood—liking?
208Whether,ifwomenhadnoportions,weshouldthenseesomanyunhappyandunfruitfulmarriages?
209Whetherthelawsbenot,accordingtoAristotle,amindwithoutappetiteorpassion?Andconsequentlywithoutrespectofpersons?
210Supposearichman’ssonmarriesapoorman’sdaughter,supposealsothatapoorman’sdaughterisdeludedanddebauchedbythesonofarichman;whichismosttobepitied?
211Whetherthepunishmentshouldbeplacedontheseducedortheseducer?
212WhetherapromisemadebeforeGodandmaninthemostsolemnmanneroughttobeviolated?
213WhetheritwasPlato’sopinionthat,’forthegoodofthecommunity,richshouldmarrywithrich?’—DeLeg。lib。iv。
214Whether,asseedequallyscatteredproducethagoodlyharvest,evensoanequaldistributionofwealthdothnotcauseanationtoflourish?
215WhenceisitthatBarbsandArabsaresogoodhorses?Andwhetherinthosecountriestheyarenotexactlyniceinadmittingnonebutmalesofagoodkindtotheirmares?
216Whateffectswouldthesamecareproduceinfamilies?
217Whethertherealfoundationforwealthmustnotbelaidinthenumbers,thefrugality,andtheindustryofthepeople?Andwhetherallattemptstoenrichanationbyothermeans,asraisingthecoin,stock—jobbing,andsuchartsarenotvain?
218Whetheradooroughtnottobeshutagainstallothermethodsofgrowingrich,saveonlybyindustryand。merit?Andwhetherwealthgototherwisewouldnotberuinoustothepublic?
219Whethertheabuseofbanksandpaper—moneyisajustobjectionagainsttheusethereof?Andwhethersuchabusemightnoteasilybeprevented?
220WhethernationalbanksarenotfoundusefulinVenice,Holland,andHamburg?AndwhetheritisnotpossibletocontriveonethatmaybeusefulalsoinIreland?
221WhetherthebanksofVeniceandAmsterdamarenotinthehandsofthepublic?
222Whetheritmaynotbeworthwhiletoinformourselvesinthenatureofthosebanks?AndwhatreasoncanbeassignedwhyIrelandshouldnotreapthebenefitofsuchpublicbanksaswellasothercountries?
223Whetherabankofnationalcredit,supportedbypublicfundsandsecuredbyParliament,beachimeraorimpossiblething?Andifnot,whatwouldfollowfromthesupposalofsuchabank?
224Whetherthecurrencyofacreditsowellsecuredwouldnotbeofgreatadvantagetoourtradeandmanufactures?
225Whetherthenotesofsuchpublicbankwouldnothaveamoregeneralcirculationthanthoseofprivatebanks,asbeinglesssubjecttofraudsandhazards?
226Whetheritbenotagreedthatpaperhathinmanyrespectstheadvantageabovecoin,asbeingofmoredispatchinpayments,moreeasilytransferred,preserved,andrecoveredwhenlost?
227Whether,besidestheseadvantages,therebenotanevidentnecessityforcirculatingcreditbypaper,fromthedefectofcoininthiskingdom?
228Whetheritberightlyremarkedbysomethat,asbankingbringsnotreasureintothekingdomliketrade,privatewealthmustsinkasthebankriseth?Andwhetherwhatevercausethindustrytoflourishandcirculatemaynotbesaidtoincreaseourtreasure?
229WhethertheruinouseffectsofMississippi,SouthSea,1andsuchschemeswerenotowingtoanabuseofpapermoneyorcredit,inmakingitameansforidlenessandgaming,insteadofamotiveandhelptoindustry?
230WhethertheriseofthebankofAmsterdamwasnotpurelycasual,forthesecurityanddispatchofpayments?Andwhetherthegoodeffectsthereof,insupplyingtheplaceofcoin,andpromotingareadycirculationofindustryandcommercemaynotbealessontous,todothatbydesignwhichothersfelluponbychance?
231Whetherplentyofsmallcashbenotabsolutelynecessaryforkeepingupacirculationamongthepeople;thatis,whethercopperbenotmorenecessarythangold?
232Whetherthatwhichincreaseththestockofanationbenotameansofincreasingitstrade?Andwhetherthatwhichincreaseththecurrentcreditofanationmaynotbesaidtoincreaseitsstock?
233WhetherthecreditofthepubicfundsbenotamineofgoldtoEngland?Andwhetheranystepthatshouldlessenthiscreditoughtnottobedreaded?
234WhethersuchcreditbenottheprincipaladvantagethatEnglandhathoverFrance?Imayadd,overeveryothercountryinEurope?
235Whetherbythisthepublicisnotbecomepossessedofthewealthofforeignersaswellasnatives?AndwhetherEnglandbenotinsomesortthetreasuryofChristendom?
236Whether,asourcurrentdomesticcreditgrew,industrywouldnotgrowlikewise;andifindustry,ourmanufactures;andifthese,ourforeigncredit?
237Whetherforeigndemandsmaynotbeansweredbyourexportswithoutdrawingcashoutofthekingdom?
238Whetherasindustryincreased,ourmanufactureswouldnotflourish;andastheseflourished,whetherbetterreturnswouldnotbemadefromestatestotheirlandlords,bothwithinandwithoutthekingdom?
239Whetherthesurewaytosupplypeoplewithtoolsandmaterials,andtosetthematwork,benotafreecirculationofmoney,whethersilverorpaper?
240WhetherinNewEnglandalltradeandbusinessisnotasmuchatastand,uponascarcityofpaper—money,aswithusfromthewantofspecie?
241WhetheritbecertainthatthequantityofsilverinthebankofAmsterdambegreaternowthanatfirst;butwhetheritbenotcertainthatthereisagreatercirculationofindustryandextentoftrade,morepeople,ships,houses,andcommoditiesofallsorts,morepowerbyseaandland?
242Whethermoney,lyingdeadinthebankofAmsterdam,wouldnotbeasuselessasinthemine?
243Whetherourvisiblesecurityinlandcouldbedoubted?AndwhethertherebeanythinglikethisinthebankofAmsterdam?
244Whetheritbejusttoapprehenddangerfromtrustinganationalbankwithpowertoextenditscredit,tocirculatenoteswhichitshallbefelonytocounterfeit,toreceivegoodsonloans,topurchaselands,tosellalsooralienatethem,andtodealinbillsofexchange;whenthesepowersarenootherthanhavebeentrustedformanyyearswiththebankofEngland,althoughintruthbutaprivatebank?
245Whethertheobjectionfrommonopoliesandanovergrowthofpower,whicharemadeagainstprivatebanks,canpossiblyholdagainstanationalone?
246Whethertheevileffectswhichoflateyearshaveattendedpaper—moneyandcreditinEuropedidnotspringfromsubscriptions,shares,dividends,andstock—jobbing?
247Whetherthegreatevilsattendingpaper—moneyintheBritishPlantationsofAmericahavenotsprungfromtheoverratingtheirlands,andissuingpaperwithoutdiscretion,andfromthelegislatorsbreakingtheirownrulesinfavourofthemselves,thussacrificingthepublictotheirprivatebenefit?Andwhetheralittlesenseandhonestymightnoteasilypreventallsuchinconveniences?
248Whetherthesubjectoffree—thinkinginreligionbenotexhausted?Andwhetheritbenothightimeforourfreethinkerstoturntheirthoughtstotheimprovementoftheircountry?
249Whetheritmustnotberuinousforanationtositdowntogame,beitwithsilverorwithpaper?
250Whether,therefore,thecirculatingpaper,inthelateruinousschemesofFranceandEngland,wasthetrueevil,andnotratherthecirculatingthereofwithoutindustry?AndwhetherthebankofAmsterdam,whereindustryhadbeenforsomanyyearssubsistedandcirculatedbytransfersonpaper,dothnotclearlydecidethispoint?
251WhethertherearenottobeseeninAmericafair,towns,whereinthepeoplearewelllodged,fed,andclothed,withoutabeggarintheirstreets,althoughtherebenotonegrainofgoldorsilvercurrentamongthem?
第1章