Itissurelytimethatancientliteratureshouldbeexaminedinadifferentmanner,withoutpedanticalprepossessions,butwithajustallowance,atthesametime,forthedifferenceofcircumstancesandmanners。Iamfarfrompretendingtotheknowledgeorabilitywhichsuchataskwouldrequire。AllthatI
meantoofferisacollectionofdesultoryremarksuponamostinterestingportionofGreekliterature。
ItmaybedoubtedwhetheranycompositionswhichhaveeverbeenproducedintheworldareequallyperfectintheirkindwiththegreatAthenianorations。Geniusissubjecttothesamelawswhichregulatetheproductionofcottonandmolasses。Thesupplyadjustsitselftothedemand。Thequantitymaybediminishedbyrestrictions,andmultipliedbybounties。ThesingularexcellencetowhicheloquenceattainedatAthensistobemainlyattributedtotheinfluencewhichitexertedthere。Inturbulenttimes,underaconstitutionpurelydemocratic,amongapeopleeducatedexactlytothatpointatwhichmenaremostsusceptibleofstrongandsuddenimpressions,acute,butnotsoundreasoners,warmintheirfeelings,unfixedintheirprinciples,andpassionateadmirersoffinecomposition,oratoryreceivedsuchencouragementasithasneversinceobtained。
ThetasteandknowledgeoftheAthenianpeoplewasafavouriteobjectofthecontemptuousderisionofSamuelJohnson;amanwhoknewnothingofGreekliteraturebeyondthecommonschool—books,andwhoseemstohavebroughttowhathehadreadscarcelymorethanthediscernmentofacommonschool—boy。Heusedtoassert,withthatarrogantabsurditywhich,inspiteofhisgreatabilitiesandvirtues,rendershim,perhapsthemostridiculouscharacterinliteraryhistory,thatDemosthenesspoketoapeopleofbrutes;——toabarbarouspeople;——thattherecouldhavebeennocivilisationbeforetheinventionofprinting。Johnsonwasakeenbutaverynarrow—mindedobserverofmankind。Heperpetuallyconfoundedtheirgeneralnaturewiththeirparticularcircumstances。HeknewLondonintimately。Thesagacityofhisremarksonitssocietyisperfectlyastonishing。ButFleetStreetwastheworldtohim。HesawthatLondonerswhodidnotreadwereprofoundlyignorant;andheinferredthataGreek,whohadfewornobooks,musthavebeenasuninformedasoneofMrThrale’sdraymen。
Thereseemstobe,onthecontrary,everyreasontobelieve,that,ingeneralintelligence,theAthenianpopulacefarsurpassedthelowerordersofanycommunitythathaseverexisted。Itmustbeconsidered,thattobeacitizenwastobealegislator,——asoldier,——ajudge,——oneuponwhosevoicemightdependthefateofthewealthiesttributarystate,ofthemosteminentpublicman。Thelowestoffices,bothofagricultureandoftrade,were,incommon,performedbyslaves。Thecommonwealthsupplieditsmeanestmemberswiththesupportoflife,theopportunityofleisure,andthemeansofamusement。Bookswereindeedfew:buttheywereexcellent;andtheywereaccuratelyknown。Itisnotbyturningoverlibraries,butbyrepeatedlyperusingandintentlycontemplatingafewgreatmodels,thatthemindisbestdisciplined。Amanoflettersmustnowreadmuchthathesoonforgets,andmuchfromwhichhelearnsnothingworthytoberemembered。Thebestworksemploy,ingeneral,butasmallportionofhistime。DemosthenesissaidtohavetranscribedsixtimesthehistoryofThucydides。Ifhehadbeenayoungpoliticianofthepresentage,hemightinthesamespaceoftimehaveskimmedinnumerablenewspapersandpamphlets。Idonotcondemnthatdesultorymodeofstudywhichthestateofthings,inourday,rendersamatterofnecessity。ButImaybeallowedtodoubtwhetherthechangesonwhichtheadmirersofmoderninstitutionsdelighttodwellhaveimprovedourconditionsomuchinrealityasinappearance。Rumford,itissaid,proposedtotheElectorofBavariaaschemeforfeedinghissoldiersatamuchcheaperratethanformerly。Hisplanwassimplytocompelthemtomasticatetheirfoodthoroughly。A
smallquantity,thuseaten,would,accordingtothatfamousprojector,affordmoresustenancethanalargemealhastilydevoured。IdonotknowhowRumford’spropositionwasreceived;
buttothemind,Ibelieve,itwillbefoundmorenutritioustodigestapagethantodevouravolume。
Books,however,weretheleastpartoftheeducationofanAtheniancitizen。Letus,foramoment,transportourselvesinthought,tothatgloriouscity。Letusimaginethatweareenteringitsgates,inthetimeofitspowerandglory。Acrowdisassembledroundaportico。Allaregazingwithdelightattheentablature;forPhidiasisputtingupthefrieze。Weturnintoanotherstreet;arhapsodistisrecitingthere:men,women,childrenarethrongingroundhim:thetearsarerunningdowntheircheeks:theireyesarefixed:theirverybreathisstill;
forheistellinghowPriamfellatthefeetofAchilles,andkissedthosehands,——theterrible——themurderous,——whichhadslainsomanyofhissons。
(——kaikusecheiras,deinas,anorophonous,aioipoleasktanonuias。)
Weenterthepublicplace;thereisaringofyouths,allleaningforward,withsparklingeyes,andgesturesofexpectation。
Socratesispittedagainstthefamousatheist,fromIonia,andhasjustbroughthimtoacontradictioninterms。Butweareinterrupted。Theheraldiscrying——"RoomforthePrytanes。"Thegeneralassemblyistomeet。Thepeopleareswarminginoneveryside。Proclamationismade——"Whowishestospeak?"Thereisashout,andaclappingofhands:Periclesismountingthestand。
ThenforaplayofSophocles;andawaytosupwithAspasia。I
knowofnomodernuniversitywhichhassoexcellentasystemofeducation。
Knowledgethusacquiredandopinionsthusformedwere,indeed,likelytobe,insomerespects,defective。Propositionswhichareadvancedindiscoursegenerallyresultfromapartialviewofthequestion,andcannotbekeptunderexaminationlongenoughtobecorrected。Menofgreatconversationalpowersalmostuniversallypractiseasortoflivelysophistryandexaggeration,whichdeceives,forthemoment,boththemselvesandtheirauditors。Thusweseedoctrines,whichcannotbearacloseinspection,triumphperpetuallyindrawing—rooms,indebatingsocieties,andeveninlegislativeorjudicialassemblies。TotheconversationaleducationoftheAtheniansIaminclinedtoattributethegreatloosenessofreasoningwhichisremarkableinmostoftheirscientificwritings。Eventhemostillogicalofmodernwriterswouldstandperfectlyaghastatthepuerilefallacieswhichseemtohavedeludedsomeofthegreatestmenofantiquity。SirThomasLethbridgewouldstareatthepoliticaleconomyofXenophon;andtheauthorof"SoireesdePetersbourg"
wouldbeashamedofsomeofthemetaphysicalargumentsofPlato。
Buttheverycircumstanceswhichretardedthegrowthofsciencewerepeculiarlyfavourabletothecultivationofeloquence。Fromtheearlyhabitoftakingashareinanimateddiscussiontheintelligentstudentwouldderivethatreadinessofresource,thatcopiousnessoflanguage,andthatknowledgeofthetemperandunderstandingofanaudience,whicharefarmorevaluabletoanoratorthanthegreatestlogicalpowers。
Horacehasprettilycomparedpoemstothosepaintingsofwhichtheeffectvariesasthespectatorchangeshisstand。Thesameremarkapplieswithatleastequaljusticetospeeches。Theymustbereadwiththetemperofthosetowhomtheywereaddressed,ortheymustnecessarilyappeartooffendagainstthelawsoftasteandreason;asthefinestpicture,seeninalightdifferentfromthatforwhichitwasdesigned,willappearfitonlyforasign。Thisisperpetuallyforgottenbythosewhocriticiseoratory。Becausetheyarereadingatleisure,pausingateveryline,reconsideringeveryargument,theyforgetthatthehearerswerehurriedfrompointtopointtoorapidlytodetectthefallaciesthroughwhichtheywereconducted;thattheyhadnotimetodisentanglesophisms,ortonoticeslightinaccuraciesofexpression;thatelaborateexcellence,eitherofreasoningoroflanguage,wouldhavebeenabsolutelythrownaway。Torecurtotheanalogyofthesisterart,theseconnoisseursexamineapanoramathroughamicroscope,andquarrelwithascene—painterbecausehedoesnotgivetohisworktheexquisitefinishofGerardDow。
Oratoryistobeestimatedonprinciplesdifferentfromthosewhichareappliedtootherproductions。Truthistheobjectofphilosophyandhistory。Truthistheobjectevenofthoseworkswhicharepeculiarlycalledworksoffiction,butwhich,infact,bearthesamerelationtohistorywhichalgebrabearstoarithmetic。Themeritofpoetry,initswildestforms,stillconsistsinitstruth,——truthconveyedtotheunderstanding,notdirectlybythewords,butcircuitouslybymeansofimaginativeassociations,whichserveasitsconductors。Theobjectoforatoryaloneisnottruth,butpersuasion。TheadmirationofthemultitudedoesnotmakeMooreagreaterpoetthanColeridge,orBeattieagreaterphilosopherthanBerkeley。Butthecriterionofeloquenceisdifferent。Aspeakerwhoexhauststhewholephilosophyofaquestion,whodisplayseverygraceofstyle,yetproducesnoeffectonhisaudience,maybeagreatessayist,agreatstatesman,agreatmasterofcomposition;butheisnotanorator。Ifhemissthemark,itmakesnodifferencewhetherhehavetakenaimtoohighortoolow。
TheeffectofthegreatfreedomofthepressinEnglandhasbeen,inagreatmeasure,todestroythisdistinction,andtoleaveamonguslittleofwhatIcallOratoryProper。Ourlegislators,ourcandidates,ongreatoccasionsevenouradvocates,addressthemselveslesstotheaudiencethantothereporters。Theythinklessofthefewhearersthanoftheinnumerablereaders。
AtAthensthecasewasdifferent;theretheonlyobjectofthespeakerwasimmediateconvictionandpersuasion。He,therefore,whowouldjustlyappreciatethemeritoftheGrecianoratorsshouldplacehimself,asnearlyaspossible,inthesituationoftheirauditors:heshoulddivesthimselfofhismodernfeelingsandacquirements,andmaketheprejudicesandinterestsoftheAtheniancitizenhisown。Hewhostudiestheirworksinthisspiritwillfindthatmanyofthosethingswhich,toanEnglishreader,appeartobeblemishes,——thefrequentviolationofthoseexcellentrulesofevidencebywhichourcourtsoflawareregulated,——theintroductionofextraneousmatter,——thereferencetoconsiderationsofpoliticalexpediencyinjudicialinvestigations,——theassertions,withoutproof,——thepassionateentreaties,——thefuriousinvectives,——arereallyproofsoftheprudenceandaddressofthespeakers。Hemustnotdwellmaliciouslyonargumentsorphrases,butacquiesceinhisfirstimpressions。Itrequiresrepeatedperusalandreflectiontodeciderightlyonanyotherportionofliterature。Butwithrespecttoworksofwhichthemeritdependsontheirinstantaneouseffectthemosthastyjudgmentislikelytobebest。
ThehistoryofeloquenceatAthensisremarkable。Fromaveryearlyperiodgreatspeakershadflourishedthere。PisistratusandThemistoclesaresaidtohaveowedmuchoftheirinfluencetotheirtalentsfordebate。Welearn,withmorecertainty,thatPericleswasdistinguishedbyextraordinaryoratoricalpowers。
ThesubstanceofsomeofhisspeechesistransmittedtousbyThucydides;andthatexcellentwriterhasdoubtlessfaithfullyreportedthegenerallineofhisarguments。Butthemanner,whichinoratoryisofatleastasmuchconsequenceasthematter,wasofnoimportancetohisnarration。Itisevidentthathehasnotattemptedtopreserveit。Throughouthiswork,everyspeechoneverysubject,whatevermayhavebeenthecharacterofthedialectofthespeaker,isinexactlythesameform。ThegravekingofSparta,thefuriousdemagogueofAthens,thegeneralencouraginghisarmy,thecaptivesupplicatingforhislife,allarerepresentedasspeakersinoneunvariedstyle,—
—astylemoreoverwhollyunfitfororatoricalpurposes。Hismodeofreasoningissingularlyelliptical,——inrealitymostconsecutive,——yetinappearanceoftenincoherent。Hismeaning,initselfsufficientlyperplexing,iscompressedintothefewestpossiblewords。Hisgreatfondnessforantitheticalexpressionhasnotalittleconducedtothiseffect。EveryonemusthaveobservedhowmuchmorethesenseiscondensedintheversesofPopeandhisimitators,whoneverventuredtocontinuethesameclausefromcouplettocouplet,thaninthoseofpoetswhoallowthemselvesthatlicense。Everyartificialdivision,whichisstronglymarked,andwhichfrequentlyrecurs,hasthesametendency。Thenaturalandperspicuousexpressionwhichspontaneouslyrisestothemindwilloftenrefusetoaccommodateitselftosuchaform。Itisnecessaryeithertoexpanditintoweakness,ortocompressitintoalmostimpenetrabledensity。
Thelatterisgenerallythechoiceofanableman,andwasassuredlythechoiceofThucydides。
Itisscarcelynecessarytosaythatsuchspeechescouldneverhavebeendelivered。TheyareperhapsamongthemostdifficultpassagesintheGreeklanguage,andwouldprobablyhavebeenscarcelymoreintelligibletoanAthenianauditorthantoamodernreader。TheirobscuritywasacknowledgedbyCicero,whowasasintimatewiththeliteratureandlanguageofGreeceasthemostaccomplishedofitsnatives,andwhoseemstohaveheldarespectablerankamongtheGreekauthors。Theirdifficultytoamodernreaderlies,notinthewords,butinthereasoning。A
dictionaryisoffarlessuseinstudyingthemthanaclearheadandacloseattentiontothecontext。Theyarevaluabletothescholarasdisplaying,beyondalmostanyothercompositions,thepowersofthefinestoflanguages:theyarevaluabletothephilosopherasillustratingthemoralsandmannersofamostinterestingage:theyaboundinjustthoughtandenergeticexpression。ButtheydonotenableustoformanyaccurateopiniononthemeritsoftheearlyGreekorators。
Thoughitcannotbedoubtedthat,beforethePersianwars,Athenshadproducedeminentspeakers,yettheperiodduringwhicheloquencemostflourishedamonghercitizenswasbynomeansthatofhergreatestpowerandglory。ItcommencedatthecloseofthePeloponnesianwar。Infact,thestepsbywhichAthenianoratoryapproachedtoitsfinishedexcellenceseemtohavebeenalmostcontemporaneouswiththosebywhichtheAtheniancharacterandtheAthenianempiresunktodegradation。Atthetimewhenthelittlecommonwealthachievedthosevictorieswhichtwenty—
fiveeventfulcenturieshaveleftunequalled,eloquencewasinitsinfancy。ThedeliverersofGreecebecameitsplunderersandoppressors。Unmeasuredexaction,atrociousvengeance,themadnessofthemultitude,thetyrannyofthegreat,filledtheCycladeswithtears,andblood,andmourning。Theswordunpeopledwholeislandsinaday。Theploughpassedovertheruinsoffamouscities。TheimperialrepublicsentforthherchildrenbythousandstopineinthequarriesofSyracuse,ortofeedthevulturesofAegospotami。Shewasatlengthreducedbyfamineandslaughtertohumbleherselfbeforeherenemies,andtopurchaseexistencebythesacrificeofherempireandherlaws。
Duringthesedisastrousandgloomyyears,oratorywasadvancingtowardsitshighestexcellence。Anditwaswhenthemoral,thepolitical,andthemilitarycharacterofthepeoplewasmostutterlydegraded,itwaswhentheviceroyofaMacedoniansovereigngavelawtoGreece,thatthecourtsofAthenswitnessedthemostsplendidcontestofeloquencethattheworldhaseverknown。
Thecausesofthisphenomenonitisnot,Ithink,difficulttoassign。Thedivisionoflabouroperatesontheproductionsoftheoratorasitdoesonthoseofthemechanic。ItwasremarkedbytheancientsthatthePentathlete,whodividedhisattentionbetweenseveralexercises,thoughhecouldnotviewithaboxerintheuseofthecestus,orwithonewhohadconfinedhisattentiontorunninginthecontestofthestadium,yetenjoyedfargreatergeneralvigourandhealththaneither。Itisthesamewiththemind。Thesuperiorityintechnicalskillisoftenmorethancompensatedbytheinferiorityingeneralintelligence。
Andthisispeculiarlythecaseinpolitics。Stateshavealwaysbeenbestgovernedbymenwhohavetakenawideviewofpublicaffairs,andwhohaveratherageneralacquaintancewithmanysciencesthanaperfectmasteryofone。TheunionofthepoliticalandmilitarydepartmentsinGreececontributednotalittletothesplendourofitsearlyhistory。Aftertheirseparationmoreskilfulgeneralsandgreaterspeakersappeared;
butthebreedofstatesmendwindledandbecamealmostextinct。
ThemistoclesorPericleswouldhavebeennomatchforDemosthenesintheassembly,orforIphicratesinthefield。Butsurelytheywereincomparablybetterfittedthaneitherforthesupremedirectionofaffairs。
Thereisindeedaremarkablecoincidencebetweentheprogressoftheartofwar,andthatoftheartoforatory,amongtheGreeks。
Theybothadvancedtoperfectionbycontemporaneoussteps,andfromsimilarcauses。Theearlyspeakers,liketheearlywarriorsofGreece,weremerelyamilitia。Itwasfoundthatinbothemploymentspracticeanddisciplinegavesuperiority。(Ithasoftenoccurredtome,thattothecircumstancesmentionedinthetextistobereferredoneofthemostremarkableeventsinGrecianhistory;ImeanthesilentbutrapiddownfalloftheLacedaemonianpower。SoonaftertheterminationofthePeloponnesianwar,thestrengthofLacedaemonbegantodecline。
Itsmilitarydiscipline,itssocialinstitutions,werethesame。
Agesilaus,duringwhosereignthechangetookplace,wastheablestofitskings。YettheSpartanarmieswerefrequentlydefeatedinpitchedbattles,——anoccurrenceconsideredimpossibleintheearlieragesofGreece。Theyareallowedtohavefoughtmostbravely;yettheywerenolongerattendedbythesuccesstowhichtheyhadformerlybeenaccustomed。Nosolutionofthesecircumstancesisoffered,asfarasIknow,byanyancientauthor。Therealcause,Iconceive,wasthis。TheLacedaemonians,aloneamongtheGreeks,formedapermanentstandingarmy。Whilethecitizensofothercommonwealthswereengagedinagricultureandtrade,theyhadnoemploymentwhateverbutthestudyofmilitarydiscipline。Hence,duringthePersianandPeloponnesianwars,theyhadthatadvantageovertheirneighbourswhichregulartroopsalwayspossessovermilitia。
Thisadvantagetheylost,whenotherstatesbegan,atalaterperiod,toemploymercenaryforces,whowereprobablyassuperiortothemintheartofwarastheyhadhithertobeentotheirantagonists。)Eachpursuitthereforebecamefirstanart,andthenatrade。Inproportionastheprofessorsofeachbecamemoreexpertintheirparticularcraft,theybecamelessrespectableintheirgeneralcharacter。Theirskillhadbeenobtainedattoogreatexpensetobeemployedonlyfromdisinterestedviews。Thus,thesoldiersforgotthattheywerecitizens,andtheoratorsthattheywerestatesmen。IknownottowhatDemosthenesandhisfamouscontemporariescanbesojustlycomparedastothosemercenarytroopswho,intheirtime,overranGreece;orthosewho,fromsimilarcauses,weresomecenturiesagothescourgeoftheItalianrepublics,——perfectlyacquaintedwitheverypartoftheirprofession,irresistibleinthefield,powerfultodefendortodestroy,butdefendingwithoutlove,anddestroyingwithouthatred。WemaydespisethecharactersofthesepoliticalCondottieri;butisimpossibletoexaminethesystemoftheirtacticswithoutbeingamazedatitsperfection。
Ihadintendedtoproceedtothisexamination,andtoconsiderseparatelytheremainsofLysias,ofAeschines,ofDemosthenes,andofIsocrates,who,thoughstrictlyspeakinghewasratherapamphleteerthananorator,deserves,onmanyaccounts,aplaceinsuchadisquisition。Thelengthofmyprolegomenaanddigressionscompelsmetopostponethispartofthesubjecttoanotheroccasion。AMagazineiscertainlyadelightfulinventionforaveryidleoraverybusyman。Heisnotcompelledtocompletehisplanortoadheretohissubject。Hemayrambleasfarasheisinclined,andstopassoonasheistired。Noonetakesthetroubletorecollecthiscontradictoryopinionsorhisunredeemedpledges。Hemaybeassuperficial,asinconsistent,andascarelessashechooses。Magazinesresemblethoselittleangels,who,accordingtotheprettyRabbinicaltradition,aregeneratedeverymorningbythebrookwhichrollsovertheflowersofParadise,——whoselifeisasong,——whowarbletillsunset,andthensinkbackwithoutregretintonothingness。SuchspiritshavenothingtodowiththedetectingspearofIthurielorthevictoriousswordofMichael。Itisenoughforthemtopleaseandbeforgotten……
APROPHETICACCOUNTOFAGRANDNATIONALEPICPOEM,TOBEENTITLED
"THEWELLINGTONIAD,"ANDTOBEPUBLISHEDA。D。2824。
(November1824。)
HowIbecameaprophetitisnotveryimportanttothereadertoknow。NeverthelessIfeelalltheanxietywhich,undersimilarcircumstances,troubledthesensitivemindofSidrophel;and,likehim,ameagertovindicatemyselffromthesuspicionofhavingpractisedforbiddenarts,orheldintercoursewithbeingsofanotherworld。Isolemnlydeclare,therefore,thatIneversawaghost,likeLordLyttleton;consultedagipsy,likeJosephine;orheardmynamepronouncedbyanabsentperson,likeDrJohnson。Thoughitisnowalmostasusualforgentlementoappearatthemomentoftheirdeathtotheirfriendsastocallonthemduringtheirlife,noneofmyacquaintancehavebeensopoliteastopaymethatcustomaryattention。Ihavederivedmyknowledgeneitherfromthedeadnorfromtheliving;neitherfromthelinesofahand,norfromthegroundsofatea—cup;neitherfromthestarsofthefirmament,norfromthefiendsoftheabyss。Ihavenever,liketheWesleyfamily,heard"thatmightyleadingangel,"who"drewafterhimthethirdpartofheaven’ssons,"scratchinginmycupboard。Ihaveneverbeenenticedtosignanyofthosedelusivebondswhichhavebeentheruinofsomanypoorcreatures;and,havingalwaysbeenanindifferenthorseman,Ihavebeencarefulnottoventuremyselfonabroomstick。
Myinsightintofuturity,likethatofGeorgeFoxthequaker,andthatofourgreatandphilosophicpoet,LordByron,isderivedfromsimplepresentiment。Thisisafarlessartificialprocessthanthosewhichareemployedbysomeothers。Yetmypredictionswill,Ibelieve,befoundmorecorrectthantheirs,or,atallevents,asSirBenjaminBackbitesaysintheplay,"morecircumstantial。"
Iprophesythen,that,intheyear2824,accordingtoourpresentreckoning,agrandnationalEpicPoem,worthytobecomparedwiththeIliad,theAeneid,ortheJerusalem,willbepublishedinLondon。
Mennaturallytakeaninterestintheadventuresofeveryeminentwriter。Iwill,therefore,gratifythelaudablecuriosity,which,onthisoccasion,willdoubtlessbeuniversal,byprefixingtomyaccountofthepoemaconcisememoirofthepoet。
RichardQuongtiwillbebornatWestminsteronthe1stofJuly,2786。HewillbetheyoungersonoftheyoungerbranchofoneofthemostrespectablefamiliesinEngland。HewillbelinearlydescendedfromQuongti,thefamousChineseliberal,who,afterthefailureoftheheroicattemptofhispartytoobtainaconstitutionfromtheEmperorFimFam,willtakerefugeinEngland,inthetwenty—thirdcentury。Herehisdescendantswillobtainconsiderablenote;andonebranchofthefamilywillberaisedtothepeerage。
Richard,however,thoughdestinedtoexalthisfamilytodistinctionfarnoblerthananywhichwealthortitlescanbestow,willbeborntoaveryscantyfortune。HewilldisplayinhisearlyyouthsuchstrikingtalentsaswillattractthenoticeofViscountQuongti,histhirdcousin,thensecretaryofstatefortheSteamDepartment。Attheexpenseofthiseminentnobleman,hewillbesenttoprosecutehisstudiesattheuniversityofTombuctoo。TothatillustriousseatofthemusesalltheingenuousyouthofeverycountrywillthenbeattractedbythehighscientificcharacterofProfessorQuashaboo,andtheeminentliteraryattainmentsofProfessorKisseyKickey。Inspiteofthisformidablecompetition,however,Quongtiwillacquirethehighesthonoursineverydepartmentofknowledge,andwillobtaintheesteemofhisassociatesbyhisamiableandunaffectedmanners。TheguardiansoftheyoungDukeofCarrington,premierpeerofEngland,andthelastremainingscionoftheancientandillustrioushouseofSmith,willbedesiroustosecuresoableaninstructorfortheirward。WiththeDuke,Quongtiwillperformthegrandtour,andvisitthepolishedcourtsofSydneyandCapetown。Afterprevailingonhispupil,withgreatdifficulty,tosubdueaviolentandimprudentpassionwhichhehadconceivedforaHottentotlady,ofgreatbeautyandaccomplishmentsindeed,butofdubiouscharacter,hewilltravelwithhimtotheUnitedStatesofAmerica。ButthattremendouswarwhichwillbefataltoAmericanlibertywill,atthattime,beragingthroughthewholefederation。AtNewYorkthetravellerswillhearofthefinaldefeatanddeathoftheillustriouschampionoffreedom,JonathonHigginbottom,andoftheelevationofEbenezerHogsfleshtotheperpetualPresidency。
Theywillnotchoosetoproceedinajourneywhichwouldexposethemtotheinsultsofthatbrutalsoldiery,whosecrueltyandrapacitywillhavedevastatedMexicoandColombia,andnow,atlength,enslavedtheirowncountry。
OntheirreturntoEngland,A。D。2810,thedeathoftheDukewillcompelhispreceptortoseekforasubsistencebyliterarylabours。Hisfamewillberaisedbymanysmallproductionsofconsiderablemerit;andhewillatlastobtainapermanentplaceinthehighestclassofwritersbyhisgreatepicpoem。
Thecelebratedworkwillbecome,withunexampledrapidity,apopularfavourite。Thesalewillbesobeneficialtotheauthorthat,insteadofgoingaboutthedirtystreetsonhisvelocipede,hewillbeenabledtosetuphisballoon。
ThecharacterofthisnoblepoemwillbesofinelyandjustlygivenintheTombuctooReviewforApril2825,thatIcannotrefrainfromtranslatingthepassage。Theauthorwillbeourpoet’soldpreceptor,ProfessorKisseyKickey。
"Inpathos,insplendouroflanguage,insweetnessofversification,MrQuongtihaslongbeenconsideredasunrivalled。
InhisexquisitepoemontheOrnithorhynchusParadoxusallthesequalitiesaredisplayedintheirgreatestperfection。Howexquisitelydoesthatworkarrestandembodytheundefinedandvagueshadowswhichflitoveranimaginativemind。Thecoldworldlingmaynotcomprehendit;butitwillfindaresponseinthebosomofeveryyouthfulpoet,ofeveryenthusiasticlover,whohasseenanOrnithorhynchusParadoxusbymoonlight。Butwewereyettolearnthathepossessedthecomprehension,thejudgment,andthefertilityofmindindispensabletotheepicpoet。
"Itisdifficulttoconceiveaplotmoreperfectthanthatofthe’Wellingtoniad。’Itismostfaithfultothemannersoftheagetowhichitrelates。Itpreservesexactlyallthehistoricalcircumstances,andinterweavesthemmostartfullywithallthespeciosamiraculaofsupernaturalagency。"
ThusfarthelearnedProfessorofHumanityintheuniversityofTombuctoo。Ifearthatthecriticsofourtimewillformanopiniondiametricallyoppositeastotheseeverypoints。Somewill,Ifear,bedisgustedbythemachinery,whichisderivedfromthemythologyofancientGreece。Icanonlysaythat,inthetwenty—ninthcentury,thatmachinerywillbeuniversallyinuseamongpoets;andthatQuongtiwilluseit,partlyinconformitywiththegeneralpractice,andpartlyfromaveneration,perhapsexcessive,forthegreatremainsofclassicalantiquity,whichwillthen,asnow,beassiduouslyreadbyeverymanofeducation;thoughTomMoore’ssongswillbeforgotten,andonlythreecopiesofLordByron’sworkswillexist:oneinthepossessionofKingGeorgetheNineteenth,oneintheDukeofCarrington’scollection,andoneinthelibraryoftheBritishMuseum。Finally,shouldanygoodpeoplebeconcernedtohearthatPaganfictionswillsolongretaintheirinfluenceoverliterature,letthemreflectthat,astheBishopofStDavid’ssays,inhis"ProofsoftheInspirationoftheSibyllineVerses,"
readatthelastmeetingoftheRoyalSocietyofLiterature,"atallevents,aPaganisnotaPapist。"
SomereadersofthepresentdaymaythinkthatQuongtiisbynomeansentitledtothecomplimentswhichhisNegrocriticpayshimonhisadherencetothehistoricalcircumstancesofthetimeinwhichhehaschosenhissubject;that,whereheintroducesanytraitofourmanners,itisinthewrongplace,andthatheconfoundsthecustomsofouragewiththoseofmuchmoreremoteperiods。IcanonlysaythatthechargeisinfinitelymoreapplicabletoHomer,Virgil,andTasso。If,therefore,thereadershoulddetect,inthefollowingabstractoftheplot,anylittledeviationfromstricthistoricalaccuracy,lethimreflect,foramoment,whetherAgamemnonwouldnothavefoundasmuchtocensureintheIliad,——DidointheAeneid,——orGodfreyintheJerusalem。Lethimnotsufferhisopinionstodependoncircumstanceswhichcannotpossiblyaffectthetruthorfalsehoodoftherepresentation。Ifitbeimpossibleforasinglemantokillhundredsinbattle,theimpossibilityisnotdiminishedbydistanceoftime。IfitbeascertainthatRinaldoneverdisenchantedaforestinPalestineasitisthattheDukeofWellingtonneverdisenchantedtheforestofSoignies,canwe,asrationalmen,toleratetheonestoryandridiculetheother?Ofthis,atleast,Iamcertain,thatwhateverexcusewehaveforadmiringtheplotsofthosefamouspoemsourchildrenwillhaveforextollingthatofthe"Wellingtoniad。"
Ishallproceedtogiveasketchofthenarrative。Thesubjectis"TheReignoftheHundredDays。"
BOOKI。
Thepoemcommences,inform,withasolemnpropositionofthesubject。Thenthemuseisinvokedtogivethepoetaccurateinformationastothecausesofsoterribleacommotion。Theanswertothisquestion,being,itistobesupposed,thejointproductionofthepoetandthemuse,ascribestheeventtocircumstanceswhichhavehithertoeludedalltheresearchofpoliticalwriters,namely,theinfluenceofthegodMars,who,wearetold,hadsomefortyyearsbeforeusurpedtheconjugalrightsofoldCarloBuonaparte,andgivenbirthtoNapoleon。Byhisincitementitwasthattheemperorwithhisdevotedcompanionswasnowonthesea,returningtohisancientdominions。Thegodswereatpresent,fortunatelyfortheadventurer,feastingwiththeEthiopians,whoseentertainments,accordingtotheancientcustomdescribedbyHomer,theyannuallyattended,withthesamesortofcondescendinggluttonywhichnowcarriesthecabinettoGuildhallonthe9thofNovember。Neptunewas,inconsequence,absent,andunabletopreventtheenemyofhisfavouriteislandfromcrossinghiselement。Boreas,however,whohadhisabodeonthebanksoftheRussianocean,andwho,likeThetisintheIliad,wasnotofsufficientqualitytohaveaninvitationtoEthiopia,resolvestodestroythearmamentwhichbringswaranddangertohisbelovedAlexander。Heaccordinglyraisesastormwhichismostpowerfullydescribed。Napoleonbewailstheingloriousfateforwhichheseemstobereserved。"Oh!thricehappy,"sayshe,"thosewhowerefrozentodeathatKrasnoi,orslaughteredatLeipsic。Oh,Kutusoff,bravestoftheRussians,whereforewasInotpermittedtofallbythyvictorioussword?"
HethenoffersaprayertoAeolus,andvowstohimasacrificeofablackram。Inconsequence,thegodrecallshisturbulentsubject;theseaiscalmed;andtheshipanchorsintheportofFrejus。NapoleonandBertrand,whoisalwayscalledthefaithfulBertrand,landtoexplorethecountry;Marsmeetsthemdisguisedasalanceroftheguard,wearingthecrossofthelegionofhonour。Headvisesthemtoapplyfornecessariesofallkindstothegovernor,showsthemtheway,anddisappearswithastrongsmellofgunpowder。Napoleonmakesapatheticspeech,andentersthegovernor’shouse。HereheseeshangingupafineprintofthebattleofAusterlitz,himselfintheforegroundgivinghisorders。Thisputshiminhighspirits;headvancesandsalutesthegovernor,whoreceiveshimmostloyally,giveshimanentertainment,and,accordingtotheusageofallepichosts,insistsafterdinneronafullnarrationofallthathashappenedtohimsincethebattleofLeipsic。
BOOKII。
NapoleoncarrieshisnarrativefromthebattleofLeipsictohisabdication。But,asweshallhaveagreatquantityoffightingonourhands,Ithinkitbesttoomitthedetails。
BOOKIII。
NapoleondescribeshissojournatElba,andhisreturn;howhewasdrivenbystressofweathertoSardinia,andfoughtwiththeharpiesthere;howhewasthencarriedsouthwardtoSicily,wherehegenerouslytookonboardanEnglishsailor,whomaman—of—warhadunhappilyleftthere,andwhowasinimminentdangerofbeingdevouredbytheCyclops;howhelandedinthebayofNaples,sawtheSibyl,anddescendedtoTartarus;howheheldalongandpatheticconversationwithPoniatowski,whomhefoundwanderingunburiedonthebanksofStyx;howhesworetogivehimasplendidfuneral;howhehadalsoanaffectionateinterviewwithDesaix;howMoreauandSirRalphAbercrombiefledatthesightofhim。Herelatesthathethenre—embarked,andmetwithnothingofimportancetillthecommencementofthestormwithwhichthepoemopens。
BOOKIV。
ThescenechangestoParis。Fame,inthegarbofanexpress,bringsintelligenceofthelandingofNapoleon。Thekingperformsasacrifice:buttheentrailsareunfavourable;andthevictimiswithoutaheart。Hepreparestoencountertheinvader。
Ayoungcaptainoftheguard,——thesonofMariaAntoinettebyApollo,——intheshapeofafiddler,rushesintotellhimthatNapoleonisapproachingwithavastarmy。Theroyalforcesaredrawnoutforbattle。Fullcataloguesaregivenoftheregimentsonbothsides;theircolonels,lieutenant—colonels,anduniform。
BOOKV。
ThekingcomesforwardanddefiesNapoleontosinglecombat。
Napoleonacceptsit。Sacrificesareoffered。ThegroundismeasuredbyNeyandMacdonald。Thecombatantsadvance。Louissnapshispistolinvain。ThebulletofNapoleon,onthecontrary,carriesoffthetipoftheking’sear。Napoleonthenrushesonhimswordinhand。ButLouissnatchesupastone,suchastenmenofthosedegeneratedayswillbeunabletomove,andhurlsitathisantagonist。Marsavertsit。NapoleonthenseizesLouis,andisabouttostrikeafatalblow,whenBacchusintervenes,likeVenusinthethirdbookoftheIliad,bearsoffthekinginathickcloud,andseatshiminanhotelatLille,withabottleofMaraschinoandabasinofsoupbeforehim。BotharmiesinstantlyproclaimNapoleonemperor。
BOOKVI。
Neptune,returnedfromhisEthiopianrevels,seeswithragetheeventswhichhavetakenplaceinEurope。HefliestothecaveofAlecto,anddragsoutthefiend,commandinghertoexciteuniversalhostilityagainstNapoleon。TheFuryrepairstoLordCastlereagh;and,as,whenshevisitedTurnus,sheassumedtheformofanoldwoman,shehereappearsinthekindredshapeofMrVansittart,andinanimpassionedaddressexhortshislordshiptowar。Hislordship,likeTurnus,treatsthisunwontedmonitorwithgreatdisrespect,tellshimthatheisanolddotingfool,andadviseshimtolookafterthewaysandmeans,andleavequestionsofpeaceandwartohisbetters。TheFurythendisplaysallherterrors。Theneatpowderedhairbristlesupintosnakes;theblackstockingsappearclottedwithblood;and,brandishingatorch,sheannounceshernameandmission。LordCastlereagh,seizedwithfury,fliesinstantlytotheParliament,andrecommendswarwithatorrentofeloquentinvective。Allthemembersinstantlyclamourforvengeance,seizetheirarmswhicharehangingroundthewallsofthehouse,andrushforthtoprepareforinstanthostilities。
BOOKVII。
InthisbookintelligencearrivesatLondonoftheflightoftheDuchessd’AngoulemefromFrance。Itisstatedthatthisheroine,armedfromheadtofoot,defendedBordeauxagainsttheadherentsofNapoleon,andthatshefoughthandtohandwithClausel,andbeathimdownwithanenormousstone。Desertedbyherfollowers,sheatlast,likeTurnus,plunged,armedasshewas,intotheGaronne,andswamtoanEnglishshipwhichlayoffthecoast。
ThisintelligenceyetmoreinflamestheEnglishtowar。
Ayetbolderflightthananywhichhasbeenmentionedfollows。
TheDukeofWellingtongoestotakeleaveoftheduchess;andascenepassesquiteequaltothefamousinterviewofHectorandAndromache。LordDouroisfrightenedathisfather’sfeather,butbegsforhisepaulette。
BOOKVIII。
Neptune,tremblingfortheeventofthewar,imploresVenus,who,astheoffspringofhiselement,naturallyvenerateshim,toprocurefromVulcanadeadlyswordandapairofunerringpistolsfortheDuke。Theyareaccordinglymade,andsuperblydecorated。
Thesheathofthesword,liketheshieldofAchilles,iscarved,inexquisitelyfineminiature,withscenesfromthecommonlifeoftheperiod;adanceatAlmack’saboxingmatchattheFives—
court,alordmayor’sprocession,andamanhanging。Allthesearefullyandelegantlydescribed。TheDukethusarmedhastenstoBrussels。
BOOKIX。
TheDukeisreceivedatBrusselsbytheKingoftheNetherlandswithgreatmagnificence。Heisinformedoftheapproachofthearmiesofalltheconfederatekings。Thepoet,however,withalaudablezealforthegloryofhiscountry,completelypassesovertheexploitsoftheAustriansinItaly,andthediscussionsofthecongress。EnglandandFrance,WellingtonandNapoleon,almostexclusivelyoccupyhisattention。SeveraldaysarespentatBrusselsinrevelry。TheEnglishheroesastonishtheiralliesbyexhibitingsplendidgames,similartothosewhichdrawthefloweroftheBritisharistocracytoNewmarketandMoulseyHurst,andwhichwillbeconsideredbyourdescendantswithasmuchvenerationastheOlympianandIsthmiancontestsbyclassicalstudentsofthepresenttime。Inthecombatofthecestus,Shaw,thelifeguardsman,vanquishesthePrinceofOrange,andobtainsabullasaprize。Inthehorse—race,theDukeofWellingtonandLordUxbridgerideagainsteachother;theDukeisvictorious,andisrewardedwithtwelveopera—girls。Onthelastdayofthefestivities,asplendiddancetakesplace,atwhichalltheheroesattend。
BOOKX。
Mars,seeingtheEnglisharmythusinactive,hastenstorouseNapoleon,who,conductedbyNightandSilence,unexpectedlyattacksthePrussians。Theslaughterisimmense。Napoleonkillsmanywhosehistoriesandfamiliesarehappilyparticularised。HeslaysHerman,thecraniologist,whodweltbythelinden—shadowedElbe,andmeasuredwithhiseyetheskullsofallwhowalkedthroughthestreetsofBerlin。Alas!hisownskullisnowcleftbytheCorsicansword。FourpupilsoftheUniversityofJenaadvancetogethertoencountertheEmperor;atfourblowshedestroysthemall。Blucherrushestoarrestthedevastation;
Napoleonstrikeshimtotheground,andisonthepointofkillinghim,butGneisenau,Ziethen,Bulow,andalltheotherheroesofthePrussianarmy,gatherroundhim,andbearthevenerablechieftoadistancefromthefield。Theslaughteriscontinuedtillnight。InthemeantimeNeptunehasdespatchedFametobeartheintelligencetotheDuke,whoisdancingatBrussels。Thewholearmyisputinmotion。TheDukeofBrunswick’shorsespeakstoadmonishhimofhisdanger,butinvain。
BOOKVI。
Picton,theDukeofBrunswick,andthePrinceofOrange,engageNeyatQuatreBras。NeykillstheDukeofBrunswick,andstripshim,sendinghisbelttoNapoleon。TheEnglishfallbackonWaterloo。Jupitercallsacouncilofthegods,andcommandsthatnoneshallinterfereoneitherside。MarsandNeptunemakeveryeloquentspeeches。ThebattleofWaterloocommences。NapoleonkillsPictonandDelancy。NeyengagesPonsonbyandkillshim。
ThePrinceofOrangeiswoundedbySoult。LordUxbridgefliestocheckthecarnage。HeisseverelywoundedbyNapoleon,andonlysavedbytheassistanceofLordHill。InthemeantimetheDukemakesatremendouscarnageamongtheFrench。HeencountersGeneralDuhesmeandvanquisheshim,butspareshislife。HekillsToubert,whokeptthegaming—houseinthePalaisRoyal,andMaronet,wholovedtospendwholenightsindrinkingchampagne。
Clerval,whohadbeenhootedfromthestage,andhadthenbecomeacaptainintheImperialGuard,wishedthathehadstillcontinuedtofacethemoreharmlessenmityoftheParisianpit。
ButLarrey,thesonofEsculapius,whomhisfatherhadinstructedinallthesecretsofhisart,andwhowassurgeon—generaloftheFrencharmy,embracedthekneesofthedestroyer,andconjuredhimnottogivedeathtoonewhoseofficeitwastogivelife。
TheDukeraisedhim,andbadehimlive。
Butwemusthastentotheclose。NapoleonrushestoencounterWellington。Botharmiesstandinmuteamaze。Theheroesfiretheirpistols;thatofNapoleonmisses,butthatofWellington,formedbythehandofVulcan,andprimedbytheCyclops,woundstheEmperorinthethigh。Heflies,andtakesrefugeamonghistroops。Theflightbecomespromiscuous。ThearrivalofthePrussians,fromamotiveofpatriotism,thepoetcompletelypassesover。
BOOKXII。
Thingsarenowhasteningtothecatastrophe。NapoleonfliestoLondon,and,seatinghimselfonthehearthoftheRegent,embracesthehouseholdgodsandconjureshim,bythevenerableageofGeorgeIII。,andbytheopeningperfectionsofthePrincessCharlotte,tosparehim。ThePrinceisinclinedtodoso;when,lookingonhisbreast,heseestherethebeltoftheDukeofBrunswick。Heinstantlydrawshissword,andisabouttostabthedestroyerofhiskinsman。Pietyandhospitality,however,restrainhishand。Hetakesamiddlecourse,andcondemnsNapoleontobeexposedonadesertisland。TheKingofFrancere—entersParis;andthepoemconcludes……
ONMITFORD’SHISTORYOFGREECE。
(November1824。)
Thisisabookwhichenjoysagreatandincreasingpopularity:
but,whileithasattractedaconsiderableshareofthepublicattention,ithasbeenlittlenoticedbythecritics。MrMitfordhasalmostsucceededinmounting,unperceivedbythosewhoseofficeitistowatchsuchaspirants,toahighplaceamonghistorians。Hehastakenaseatonthedaiswithoutbeingchallengedbyasingleseneschal。Toopposetheprogressofhisfameisnowalmostahopelessenterprise。Hadhebeenreviewedwithcandidseverity,whenhehadpublishedonlyhisfirstvolume,hisworkwouldeitherhavedeserveditsreputation,orwouldneverhaveobtainedit。"Then,"asIndrasaysofKehama,"thenwasthetimetostrike。"Thetimewasneglected;andtheconsequenceisthatMrMitfordlikeKehama,haslaidhisvictorioushandontheliteraryAmreeta,andseemsabouttotastethepreciouselixirofimmortality。IshallventuretoemulatethecourageofthehonestGlendoveer——
"WhennowHesawtheAmreetainKehama’shand,Animpulsethatdefiedallself—command,Inthatextremity,Stunghim,andheresolvedtoseizethecup,AnddaretheRajah’sforceinSeeva’ssight,Forwardhesprungtotempttheunequalfray。"
Inplainwords,Ishallofferafewconsiderations,whichmaytendtoreduceanoverpraisedwritertohisproperlevel。
Theprincipalcharacteristicofthishistorian,theoriginofhisexcellenciesandhisdefects,isaloveofsingularity。Hehasnonotionofgoingwithamultitudetodoeithergoodorevil。
Anexplodedopinion,oranunpopularperson,hasanirresistiblecharmforhim。Thesameperversenessmaybetracedinhisdiction。Hisstylewouldneverhavebeenelegant;butitmightatleasthavebeenmanlyandperspicuous;andnothingbutthemostelaboratecarecouldpossiblyhavemadeitsobadasitis。
Itisdistinguishedbyharshphrases,strangecollocations,occasionalsolecisms,frequentobscurity,and,aboveall,byapeculiaroddity,whichcannomorebedescribedthanitcanbeoverlooked。Noristhisall。MrMitfordpiqueshimselfonspellingbetterthananyofhisneighbours;andthisnotonlyinancientnames,whichhemanglesindefiancebothofcustomandofreason,butinthemostordinarywordsoftheEnglishlanguage。
Itis,initself,amatterperfectlyindifferentwhetherwecallaforeignerbythenamewhichhebearsinhisownlanguage,orbythatwhichcorrespondstoitinours;whetherwesayLorenzodeMedici,orLawrencedeMedici,JeanChauvin,orJohnCalvin。InsuchcasesestablishedusageisconsideredaslawbyallwritersexceptMrMitford。Ifhewerealwaysconsistentwithhimself,hemightbeexcusedforsometimesdisagreeingwithhisneighbours;
butheproceedsonnoprinciplebutthatofbeingunliketherestoftheworld。EverychildhasheardofLinnaeus;thereforeMrMitfordcallshimLinne:RousseauisknownalloverEuropeasJeanJacques;thereforeMrMitfordbestowsonhimthestrangeappellationofJohnJames。
HadMrMitfordundertakenaHistoryofanyothercountrythanGreece,thispropensitywouldhaverenderedhisworkuselessandabsurd。HisoccasionalremarksontheaffairsofancientRomeandofmodernEuropearefulloferrors:buthewritesoftimeswithrespecttowhichalmosteveryotherwriterhasbeeninthewrong;and,therefore,byresolutelydeviatingfromhispredecessors,heisoftenintheright。
AlmostallthemodernhistoriansofGreecehaveshownthegrossestignoranceofthemostobviousphenomenaofhumannature。