CHAPTERXV
OFTHEPUNISHMENTOFCOWARDICE
Ionceheardofaprince,andagreatcaptain,havinganarrationgivenhimashesatattableoftheproceedingagainstMonsieurdeVervins,whowassentencedtodeathforhavingsurrenderedBoulognetotheEnglish,——[ToHenryVIII。in1544]——openlymaintainingthatasoldiercouldnotjustlybeputtodeathforwantofcourage。And,intruth,’tisreasonthatamanshouldmakeagreatdifferencebetwixtfaultsthatmerelyproceedfrominfirmity,andthosethatarevisiblytheeffectsoftreacheryandmalice:for,inthelast,weactagainsttherulesofreasonthatnaturehasimprintedinus;whereas,intheformer,itseemsasifwemightproducethesamenature,wholeftusinsuchastateofimperfectionandweaknessofcourage,forourjustification。Insomuchthatmanyhavethoughtwearenotfairlyquestionableforanythingbutwhatwecommitagainstourconscience;anditispartlyuponthisrulethatthosegroundtheiropinionwhodisapproveofcapitalorsanguinarypunishmentsinflicteduponhereticsandmisbelievers;andtheirsalsowhoadvocateorajudgeisnotaccountableforhavingfrommereignorancefailedinhisadministration。
Butastocowardice,itiscertainthatthemostusualwayofchastisingitisbyignominyandanditissupposedthatthispracticebroughtintousebythelegislatorCharondas;andthat,beforehistime,thelawsofGreecepunishedthosewithdeathwhofledfromabattle;whereasheordainedonlythattheybeforthreedaysexposedinthepublicdressedinwoman’sattire,hopingyetforsomeservicefromthem,havingawakenedtheircouragebythisopenshame:
"Suffunderemalishomimssanguinem,quameffundere。"
["Ratherbringthebloodintoaman’scheekthanletitoutofhisbody。"TertullianinhisApologetics。]
ItappearsalsothattheRomanlawsdidancientlypunishthosewithdeathwhohadrunaway;forAmmianusMarcellinussaysthattheEmperorJuliancommandedtenofhissoldiers,whohadturnedtheirbacksinanencounteragainsttheParthians,tobefirstdegraded,andafterwardputtodeath,according,sayshe,totheancientlaws,——[AmmianusMarcellinus,xxiv。
4;xxv。i。]——andyetelsewhereforthelikeoffenceheonlycondemnedotherstoremainamongsttheprisonersunderthebaggageensign。TheseverepunishmentthepeopleofRomeinflicteduponthosewhofledfromthebattleofCannae,andthosewhoranawaywithAeneiusFulviusathisdefeat,didnotextendtodeath。Andyet,methinks,’tistobefeared,lestdisgraceshouldmakesuchdelinquentsdesperate,andnotonlyfaintfriends,butenemies。
Oflatememory,——[In1523]——theSeigneurdeFrauget,lieutenanttotheMareschaldeChatillon’scompany,havingbytheMareschaldeChabannesbeenputingovernmentofFuentarabiaintheplaceofMonsieurdeLude,andhavingsurrenderedittotheSpaniard,hewasforthatcondemnedtobedegradedfromallnobility,andbothhimselfandhisposteritydeclaredignoble,taxable,andforeverincapableofbearingarms,whichseveresentencewasafterwardsaccordinglyexecutedatLyons。——[In1536]
——And,sincethat,allthegentlemenwhowereinGuisewhentheCountofNassauenteredintoit,underwentthesamepunishment,asseveralothershavedonesinceforthelikeoffence。Notwithstanding,incaseofsuchamanifestignoranceorcowardiceasexceedsallordinaryexample,’tisbutreasontotakeitforasufficientproofoftreacheryandmalice,andforsuchtobepunished。
CHAPTERXVI
APROCEEDINGOFSOMEAMBASSADORS
Iobserveinmytravelsthiscustom,evertolearnsomethingfromtheinformationofthosewithwhomIconfer(whichisthebestschoolofallothers),andtoputmycompanyuponthosesubjectstheyarethebestabletospeakof:——
"Bastialnocchieroragionarde’venti,Albifolcodeitori;etlesuepiagheConti’lguerrier;conti’lpastorgliarmenti。"
["Letthesailorcontenthimselfwithtalkingofthewinds;thecowherdofhisoxen;thesoldierofhiswounds;theshepherdofhisflocks。"——AnItaliantranslationofPropertius,ii。i,43]
Foritoftenfallsoutthat,onthecontrary,everyonewillratherchoosetobepratingofanotherman’sprovincethanhisown,thinkingitsomuchnewreputationacquired;witnessthejeerArchidamusputuponPertander,"thathehadquittedthegloryofbeinganexcellentphysiciantogainthereputeofaverybadpoet。——[Plutarch,Apoth。oftheLacedaemonians,’invoce’Archidamus。]——AnddobutobservehowlargeandampleCaesaristomakeusunderstandhisinventionsofbuildingbridgesandcontrivingenginesofwar,——[DeBelloGall。,iv。17。]——andhowsuccinctandreservedincomparison,wherehespeaksoftheofficesofhisprofession,hisownvalour,andmilitaryconduct。Hisexploitssufficientlyprovehimagreatcaptain,andthatheknewwellenough;buthewouldbethoughtanexcellentengineertoboot;aqualitysomethingdifferent,andnotnecessarytobeexpectedinhim。TheelderDionysiuswasaverygreatcaptain,asitbefittedhisfortuneheshouldbe;buthetookverygreatpainstogetaparticularreputationbypoetry,andyethewasnevercutoutforapoet。Amanofthelegalprofessionbeingnotlongsincebroughttoseeastudyfurnishedwithallsortsofbooks,bothofhisownandallotherfaculties,tooknooccasionatalltoentertainhimselfwithanyofthem,butfellveryrudelyandmagisteriallytodescantuponabarricadeplacedonthewindingstairbeforethestudydoor,athingthatahundredcaptainsandcommonsoldiersseeeverydaywithouttakinganynoticeoroffence。
"Optatephippiabospiger,optatararecaballus。"
[Thelazyoxdesiresasaddleandbridle;thehorsewantstoplough。"——Hor。,Ep。,i。14,43。]
Bythiscourseamanshallneverimprovehimself,norarriveatanyperfectioninanything。Hemust,therefore,makeithisbusinessalwaystoputthearchitect,thepainter,thestatuary,everymechanicartisan,upondiscourseoftheirowncapacities。
And,tothispurpose,inreadinghistories,whichiseverybody’ssubject,Iusetoconsiderwhatkindofmenaretheauthors:iftheybepersonsthatprofessnothingbutmereletters,I,inandfromthem,principallyobserveandlearnstyleandlanguage;ifphysicians,Itheratherinclinetocreditwhattheyreportofthetemperatureoftheair,ofthehealthandcomplexionsofprinces,ofwoundsanddiseases;iflawyers,wearefromthemtotakenoticeofthecontroversiesofrightsandwrongs,theestablishmentoflawsandcivilgovernment,andthelike;ifdivines,theaffairsoftheChurch,ecclesiasticalcensures,marriages,anddispensations;ifcourtiers,mannersandceremonies;ifsoldiers,thethingsthatproperlybelongtotheirtrade,and,principally,theaccountsoftheactionsandenterpriseswhereintheywerepersonallyengaged;ifambassadors,wearetoobservenegotiations,intelligences,andpractices,andthemannerhowtheyaretobecarriedon。
Andthisisthereasonwhy(whichperhapsIshouldhavelightlypassedoverinanother)IdweltuponandmaturelyconsideredonepassageinthehistorywrittenbyMonsieurdeLangey,amanofverygreatjudgmentinthingsofthatnature:afterhavinggivenanarrativeofthefineorationCharlesV。hadmadeintheConsistoryatRome,andinthepresenceoftheBishopofMaconandMonsieurduVelly,ourambassadorsthere,whereinhehadmixedseveralinjuriousexpressionstothedishonourofournation;
andamongsttherest,"thatifhiscaptainsandsoldierswerenotmenofanotherkindoffidelity,resolution,andsufficiencyintheknowledgeofarmsthanthoseoftheKing,hewouldimmediatelygowitharopeabouthisneckandsuetohimformercy"(anditshouldseemtheEmperorhadreallythis,oraverylittlebetteropinionofourmilitarymen,forheafterwards,twiceorthriceinhislife,saidtheverysamething);asalso,thathechallengedtheKingtofighthiminhisshirtwithrapierandpoignardinaboat。ThesaidSieurdeLangey,pursuinghishistory,addsthattheforenamedambassadors,sendingadespatchtotheKingofthesethings,concealedthegreatestpart,andparticularlythelasttwopassages。AtwhichIcouldnotbutwonderthatitshouldbeinthepowerofanambassadortodispensewithanythingwhichheoughttosignifytohismaster,especiallyofsogreatimportanceasthis,comingfromthemouthofsuchaperson,andspokeninsogreatanassembly;andIshouldratherconceiveithadbeentheservant’sdutyfaithfullytohaverepresentedtohimthewholethingasitpassed,totheendthatthelibertyofselecting,disposing,judging,andconcludingmighthaveremainedinhim:foreithertoconcealortodisguisethetruthforfearheshouldtakeitotherwisethanheoughttodo,andlestitshouldprompthimtosomeextravagantresolution,and,inthemeantime,toleavehimignorantofhisaffairs,shouldseem,methinks,rathertobelongtohimwhoistogivethelawthantohimwhoisonlytoreceiveit;tohimwhoisinsupremecommand,andnottohimwhooughttolookuponhimselfasinferior,notonlyinauthority,butalsoinprudenceandgoodcounsel。I,formypart,wouldnotbesoservedinmylittleconcerns。
Wesowillinglyslipthecollarofcommanduponanypretencewhatever,andaresoreadytousurpupondominion,everyonedoessonaturallyaspiretolibertyandpower,thatnoutilitywhateverderivedfromthewitorvalourofthoseheemploysoughttobesodeartoasuperiorasadownrightandsincereobedience。Toobeymoreupontheaccountofunderstandingthanofsubjection,istocorrupttheofficeofcommand——
[TakenfromAulusGellius,i。13。]——;insomuchthatP。Crassus,thesamewhomtheRomansreputedfivetimeshappy,atthetimewhenhewasconsulinAsia,havingsenttoaGreekengineertocausethegreateroftwomastsofshipsthathehadtakennoticeofatAthenstobebroughttohim,tobeemployedaboutsomeengineofbatteryhehadadesigntomake;
theother,presuminguponhisownscienceandsufficiencyinthoseaffairs,thoughtfittodootherwisethandirected,andtobringtheless,which,accordingtotherulesofart,wasreallymoreproperfortheusetowhichitwasdesigned;butCrassus,thoughhegaveeartohisreasonswithgreatpatience,wouldnot,however,takethem,howsoundorconvincingsoever,forcurrentpay,butcausedhimtobewellwhippedforhispains,valuingtheinterestofdisciplinemuchmorethanthatoftheworkinhand。
Notwithstanding,wemayontheothersideconsiderthatsopreciseandimplicitanobedienceasthisisonlyduetopositiveandlimitedcommands。Theemploymentofambassadorsisneversoconfined,manythingsintheirmanagementofaffairsbeingwhollyreferredtotheabsolutesovereigntyoftheirownconduct;theydonotsimplyexecute,butalso,totheirowndiscretionandwisdom,formandmodeltheirmaster’spleasure。Ihave,inmytime,knownmenofcommandcheckedforhavingratherobeyedtheexpresswordsoftheking’sletters,thanthenecessityoftheaffairstheyhadinhand。Menofunderstandingdoyet,tothisday,condemnthecustomofthekingsofPersiatogivetheirlieutenantsandagentssolittlerein,that,upontheleastarisingdifficulties,theymustfainhaverecoursetotheirfurthercommands;
thisdelay,insovastanextentofdominion,havingoftenverymuchprejudicedtheiraffairs;andCrassus,writingtoamanwhoseprofessionitwasbesttounderstandthosethings,andpre—acquaintinghimtowhatusethismastwasdesigned,didhenotseemtoconsulthisadvice,andinamannerinvitehimtointerposehisbetterjudgment?
CHAPTERXVII
OFFEAR
"Obstupui,steteruntquecomaeetvoxfaucibushaesit。"
["Iwasamazed,myhairstoodonend,andmyvoicestuckinmythroat。Virgil,AEneid,ii。774。]
Iamnotsogoodanaturalist(astheycallit)astodiscernbywhatsecretspringsfearhasitsmotioninus;but,bethisasitmay,’tisastrangepassion,andsuchaonethatthephysicianssaythereisnootherwhateverthatsoonerdethronesourjudgmentfromitsproperseat;whichissotrue,thatImyselfhaveseenverymanybecomefranticthroughfear;and,eveninthoseofthebestsettledtemperitismostcertainthatitbegetsaterribleastonishmentandconfusionduringthefit。
Iomitthevulgarsort,towhomitonewhilerepresentstheirgreat—
grandsiresrisenoutoftheirgravesintheirshrouds,anotherwhilewerewolves,nightmares,andchimaeras;butevenamongstsoldiers,asortofmenoverwhom,ofallothers,itoughttohavetheleastpower,howoftenhasitconvertedflocksofsheepintoarmedsquadrons,reedsandbullrushesintopikesandlances,friendsintoenemies,andtheFrenchwhitecrossintotheredcrossofSpain!WhenMonsieurdeBourbontookRome,——[In1527]——anensignwhowasuponguardatBorgoSanPietrowasseizedwithsuchafrightuponthefirstalarm,thathethrewhimselfoutatabreachwithhiscoloursuponhisshoulder,andrandirectlyupontheenemy,thinkinghehadretreatedtowardtheinwarddefencesofthecity,andwithmuchado,seeingMonsieurdeBourbon’speople,whothoughtithadbeenasallyuponthem,drawuptoreceivehim,atlastcametohimself,andsawhiserror;andthenfacingabout,heretreatedfullspeedthroughthesamebreachbywhichhehadgoneout,butnottillhehadfirstblindlyadvancedabovethreehundredpacesintotheopenfield。
Itdidnot,however,falloutsowellwithCaptainGiulio’sensign,atthetimewhenSt。PaulwastakenfromusbytheComtedeBuresandMonsieurdeReu,forhe,beingsoastonishedwithfearastothrowhimself,coloursandall,outofaporthole,wasimmediately,cuttopiecesbytheenemy;andinthesamesiege,itwasaverymemorablefearthatsoseized,contracted,andfrozeuptheheartofagentleman,thathesankdown,stone—dead,inthebreach,withoutanymannerofwoundorhurtatall。Thelikemadnessdoessometimespushonawholemultitude;
forinoneoftheencountersthatGermanicushadwiththeGermans,twogreatpartiesweresoamazedwithfearthattheyrantwooppositeways,theonetothesameplacefromwhichtheotherhadfled。——[Tacit,Annal。,i。63。]——Sometimesitaddswingstotheheels,asinthetwofirst:
sometimesitnailsthemtotheground,andfettersthemfrommoving;aswereadoftheEmperorTheophilus,who,inabattlehelostagainsttheAgarenes,wassoastonishedandstupefiedthathehadnopowertofly——
"Adeopavoretiamauxiliaformidat"
["Somuchdoesfeardreadeventhemeansofsafety。"——Quint。
Curt。,ii。II。]
——tillsuchtimeasManuel,oneoftheprincipalcommandersofhisarmy,havingjoggedandshakedhimsoastorousehimoutofhistrance,saidtohim,"Sir,ifyouwillnotfollowme,Iwillkillyou;foritisbetteryoushouldloseyourlifethan,bybeingtaken,loseyourempire。"
——[Zonaras,lib。iii。]——Butfeardoesthenmanifestitsutmostpowerwhenitthrowsusuponavaliantdespair,havingbeforedeprivedusofallsensebothofdutyandhonour。InthefirstpitchedbattletheRomanslostagainstHannibal,undertheConsulSempronius,abodyoftenthousandfoot,thathadtakenfright,seeingnootherescapefortheircowardice,wentandthrewthemselvesheadlonguponthegreatbattalionoftheenemies,whichwithmarvellousforceandfurytheychargedthroughandthrough,androutedwithaverygreatslaughteroftheCarthaginians,thuspurchasinganignominiousflightatthesamepricetheymighthavegainedagloriousvictory。——[Livy,xxi。56。]
ThethingintheworldIammostafraidofisfear,thatpassionalone,inthetroubleofit,exceedingallotheraccidents。WhatafflictioncouldbegreaterormorejustthanthatofPompey’sfriends,who,inhisship,werespectatorsofthathorriblemurder?Yetsoitwas,thatthefearoftheEgyptianvesselstheysawcomingtoboardthem,possessedthemwithsogreatalarmthatitisobservedtheythoughtofnothingbutcallinguponthemarinerstomakehaste,andbyforceofoarstoescapeaway,tillbeingarrivedatTyre,anddeliveredfromfear,theyhadleisuretoturntheirthoughtstothelossoftheircaptain,andtogiveventtothosetearsandlamentationsthattheothermorepotentpassionhadtillthensuspended。
"Tumpavorsapientiamomnemmihiexanimoexpectorat。"
["Thenfeardroveoutallintelligencefrommymind。"——Ennius,ap。
Cicero,Tusc。,iv。8。]
Suchashavebeenwellrubbedinsomeskirmish,mayyet,allwoundedandbloodyastheyare,bebroughtonagainthenextdaytocharge;butsuchashaveonceconceivedagoodsoundfearoftheenemy,willneverbemadesomuchastolookhimintheface。Suchasareinimmediatefearofalosingtheirestates,ofbanishment,orofslavery,liveinperpetualanguish,andloseallappetiteandrepose;whereassuchasareactuallypoor,slaves,orexiles,ofttimesliveasmerrilyasotherfolk。Andthemanypeoplewho,impatientoftheperpetualalarmsoffear,havehangedordrownedthemselves,ordashedthemselvestopieces,giveussufficientlytounderstandthatfearismoreimportunateandinsupportablethandeathitself。
TheGreeksacknowledgedanotherkindoffear,differingfromanywehavespokenofyet,thatsurprisesuswithoutanyvisiblecause,byanimpulsefromheaven,sothatwholenationsandwholearmieshavebeenstruckwithit。SuchaonewasthatwhichbroughtsowonderfuladesolationuponCarthage,wherenothingwastobeheardbutaffrightedvoicesandoutcries;wheretheinhabitantswereseentosallyoutoftheirhousesastoanalarm,andtheretocharge,wound,andkilloneanother,asiftheyhadbeenenemiescometosurprisetheircity。Allthingswereindisorderandfurytill,withprayersandsacrifices,theyhadappeasedtheirgods——[Diod。Sic。,xv。7];andthisisthattheycallpanicterrors。——[Ibid。;PlutarchonIsisandOsiris,c。8。]
CHAPTERXVIII
THATMENARENOTTOJUDGEOFOURHAPPINESSTILLAFTERDEATH。
[Charronhasborrowedwithunusualliberalityfromthisandthesucceedingchapter。SeeNodier,Questions,p。206。]
"ScilicetultimasemperExspectandadieshominiest;diciquebeatusAnteobitumnemosupremaquefuneradebet。"
["Weshouldalllookforwardtoourlastday:noonecanbecalledhappytillheisdeadandburied。"——Ovid,Met,iii。135]
TheverychildrenknowthestoryofKingCroesustothispurpose,whobeingtakenprisonerbyCyrus,andbyhimcondemnedtodie,ashewasgoingtoexecutioncriedout,"OSolon,Solon!"whichbeingpresentlyreportedtoCyrus,andhesendingtoinquireofhimwhatitmeant,CroesusgavehimtounderstandthathenowfoundtheteachingSolonhadformerlygivenhimtruetohiscost;whichwas,"Thatmen,howeverfortunemaysmileuponthem,couldneverbesaidtobehappytilltheyhadbeenseentopassoverthelastdayoftheirlives,"byreasonoftheuncertaintyandmutabilityofhumanthings,which,uponverylightandtrivialoccasions,aresubjecttobetotallychangedintoaquitecontrarycondition。AndsoitwasthatAgesilausmadeanswertoonewhowassayingwhatahappyyoungmantheKingofPersiawas,tocomesoyoungtosomightyakingdom:"’Tistrue,"saidhe,"butneitherwasPriamunhappyathisyears。"——[Plutarch,ApothegmsoftheLacedaemonians。]——Inashorttime,kingsofMacedon,successorstothatmightyAlexander,becamejoinersandscrivenersatRome;atyrantofSicily,apedantatCorinth;aconquerorofone—halfoftheworldandgeneralofsomanyarmies,amiserablesupplianttotherascallyofficersofakingofEgypt:somuchdidtheprolongationoffiveorsixmonthsoflifecostthegreatPompey;and,inourfathers’days,LudovicoSforza,thetenthDukeofMilan,whomallItalyhadsolongtruckledunder,wasseentodieawretchedprisoneratLoches,butnottillhehadlivedtenyearsincaptivity,——[HewasimprisonedbyLouisXI。inanironcage]——
whichwastheworstpartofhisfortune。Thefairestofallqueens,——[Mary,QueenofScots。]——widowtothegreatestkinginEurope,didshenotcometodiebythehandofanexecutioner?Unworthyandbarbarouscruelty!Andathousandmoreexamplesthereareofthesamekind;foritseemsthatasstormsandtempestshaveamaliceagainsttheproudandovertoweringheightsofourloftybuildings,therearealsospiritsabovethatareenviousofthegreatnessesherebelow:
"UsqueadeoreshumanasvisabditaquaedamObterit,etpulchrosfasces,saevasquesecuresProculcare,acludibriosibihaberevidetur。"
["Sotrueitisthatsomeoccultpowerupsetshumanaffairs,theglitteringfascesandthecruelaxesspurnsunderfoot,andseemstomakesportofthem。"——Lucretius,v。1231。]
Anditshouldseem,also,thatFortunesometimesliesinwaittosurprisethelasthourofourlives,toshowthepowershehas,inamoment,tooverthrowwhatshewassomanyyearsinbuilding,makinguscryoutwithLaberius:
"NimirumhacdieUnaplusviximihi,quamvivendumfuit。"
["IhavelivedlongerbythisonedaythanIshouldhavedone。"——Macrobius,ii。7。]
And,inthissense,thisgoodadviceofSolonmayreasonablybetaken;
buthe,beingaphilosopher(withwhichsortofmenthefavoursanddisgracesofFortunestandfornothing,eithertothemakingamanhappyorunhappy,andwithwhomgrandeursandpowersareaccidentsofaqualityalmostindifferent)Iamapttothinkthathehadsomefurtheraim,andthathismeaningwas,thattheveryfelicityoflifeitself,whichdependsuponthetranquillityandcontentmentofawell—descendedspirit,andtheresolutionandassuranceofawell—orderedsoul,oughtnevertobeattributedtoanymantillhehasfirstbeenseentoplaythelast,and,doubtless,thehardestactofhispart。Theremaybedisguiseanddissimulationinalltherest:wherethesefinephilosophicaldiscoursesareonlyputon,andwhereaccident,nottouchingustothequick,givesusleisuretomaintainthesamegravityofaspect;but,inthislastsceneofdeath,thereisnomorecounterfeiting:wemustspeakoutplain,anddiscoverwhatthereisofgoodandcleaninthebottomofthepot,"Namvera;vocesturndemumpectoreabimoEjiciuntur;eteripiturpersona,manetres。"
[Thenatlasttruthissuesfromtheheart;thevisor’sgone,themanremains。"——Lucretius,iii。57。]
Wherefore,atthislast,alltheotheractionsofourlifeoughttobetriedandsifted:’tisthemaster—day,’tisthedaythatisjudgeofalltherest,"’tistheday,"saysoneoftheancients,——[Seneca,Ep。,102]——
"thatmustbejudgeofallmyforegoingyears。"TodeathdoIrefertheassayofthefruitofallmystudies:weshallthenseewhethermydiscoursescameonlyfrommymouthorfrommyheart。Ihaveseenmanybytheirdeathgiveagoodoranillreputetotheirwholelife。Scipio,thefather—in—lawofPompey,indying,wellremovedtheillopinionthattilltheneveryonehadconceivedofhim。Epaminondasbeingaskedwhichofthethreehehadingreatestesteem,Chabrias,Iphicrates,orhimself。
"Youmustfirstseeusdie,"saidhe,"beforethatquestioncanberesolved。"——[Plutarch,Apoth。]——And,intruth,hewouldinfinitelywrongthatmanwhowouldweighhimwithoutthehonourandgrandeurofhisend。
GodhasorderedallthingsasithasbestpleasedHim;butIhave,inmytime,seenthreeofthemostexecrablepersonsthateverIknewinallmannerofabominableliving,andthemostinfamoustoboot,whoalldiedaveryregulardeath,andinallcircumstancescomposed,eventoperfection。Therearebraveandfortunatedeaths:Ihaveseendeathcutthethreadoftheprogressofaprodigiousadvancement,andintheheightandflowerofitsincrease,ofacertainperson,——[MontaignedoubtlessreferstohisfriendEtiennedelaBoetie,atwhosedeathin1563hewaspresent。]——withsogloriousanendthat,inmyopinion,hisambitiousandgenerousdesignshadnothinginthemsohighandgreatastheirinterruption。Hearrived,withoutcompletinghiscourse,attheplacetowhichhisambitionaimed,withgreaterglorythanhecouldeitherhavehopedordesired,anticipatingbyhisfallthenameandpowertowhichheaspiredinperfectinghiscareer。InthejudgmentImakeofanotherman’slife,Ialwaysobservehowhecarriedhimselfathisdeath;andtheprincipalconcernIhaveformyownisthatImaydiewell——thatis,patientlyandtranquilly。
CHAPTERXIX
THATTOSTUDYPHILOSOPYISTOLEARNTODIE
Cicerosays——[Tusc。,i。31。]——"thattostudyphilosophyisnothingbuttoprepareone’sselftodie。"Thereasonofwhichis,becausestudyandcontemplationdoinsomesortwithdrawfromusoursoul,andemployitseparatelyfromthebody,whichisakindofapprenticeshipandaresemblanceofdeath;or,else,becauseallthewisdomandreasoningintheworlddointheendconcludeinthispoint,toteachusnottofeartodie。Andtosaythetruth,eitherourreasonmocksus,oritoughttohavenootheraimbutourcontentmentonly,nortoendeavouranythingbut,insum,tomakeuslivewell,and,astheHolyScripturesays,atourease。Alltheopinionsoftheworldagreeinthis,thatpleasureisourend,thoughwemakeuseofdiversmeanstoattainit:theywould,otherwise,berejectedatthefirstmotion;forwhowouldgiveeartohimthatshouldproposeafflictionandmiseryforhisend?Thecontroversiesanddisputesofthephilosophicalsectsuponthispointaremerelyverbal:
"Transcurramussolertissimasnugas"
["Letusskipoverthosesubtletrifles。"——Seneca,Ep。,117。]
——thereismoreinthemofoppositionandobstinacythanisconsistentwithsosacredaprofession;butwhatsoeverpersonageamantakesuponhimselftoperform,heevermixeshisownpartwithit。
Letthephilosopherssaywhattheywill,thethingatwhichweallaim,eveninvirtueispleasure。Itamusesmetorattleinearsthisword,whichtheysonauseatetoandifitsignifysomesupremepleasureandcontentment,itismoreduetotheassistanceofvirtuethantoanyotherassistancewhatever。Thispleasure,forbeingmoregay,moresinewy,morerobustandmoremanly,isonlythemoreseriouslyvoluptuous,andweoughtgiveitthenameofpleasure,asthatwhichismorefavourable,gentle,andnatural,andnotthatfromwhichwehavedenominatedit。Theotherandmeanerpleasure,ifitcoulddeservethisfairname,itoughttobebywayofcompetition,andnotofprivilege。Ifinditlessexemptfromtraversesandinconveniencesthanvirtueitself;and,besidesthattheenjoymentismoremomentary,fluid,andfrail,ithasitswatchings,fasts,andlabours,itssweatanditsblood;and,moreover,hasparticulartoitselfsomanyseveralsortsofsharpandwoundingpassions,andsodullasatietyattendingit,asequalittotheseverestpenance。Andwemistakeifwethinkthattheseincommoditiesserveitforaspurandaseasoningtoitssweetness(asinnatureonecontraryisquickenedbyanother),orsay,whenwecometovirtue,thatlikeconsequencesanddifficultiesoverwhelmandrenderitaustereandinaccessible;whereas,muchmoreaptlythaninvoluptuousness,theyennoble,sharpen,andheightentheperfectanddivinepleasuretheyprocureus。Herendershimselfunworthyofitwhowillcounterpoiseitscostwithitsfruit,andneitherunderstandstheblessingnorhowtouseit。Thosewhopreachtousthatthequestofitiscraggy,difficult,andpainful,butitsfruitionpleasant,whatdotheymeanbythatbuttotellusthatitisalwaysunpleasing?Forwhathumanmeanswilleverattainitsenjoyment?Themostperfecthavebeenfaintocontentthemselvestoaspireuntoit,andtoapproachitonly,withouteverpossessingit。Buttheyaredeceived,seeingthatofallthepleasuresweknow,theverypursuitispleasant。Theattempteverrelishesofthequalityofthethingtowhichitisdirected,foritisagoodpartof,andconsubstantialwith,theeffect。ThefelicityandbeatitudethatglittersinVirtue,shinesthroughoutallherappurtenancesandavenues,eventothefirstentryandutmostlimits。
Now,ofallthebenefitsthatvirtueconfersuponus,thecontemptofdeathisoneofthegreatest,asthemeansthataccommodateshumanlifewithasoftandeasytranquillity,andgivesusapureandpleasanttasteofliving,withoutwhichallotherpleasurewouldbeextinct。Whichisthereasonwhyalltherulescentreandconcurinthisonearticle。Andalthoughtheyallinlikemanner,withcommonaccord,teachusalsotodespisepain,poverty,andtheotheraccidentstowhichhumanlifeissubject,itisnot,nevertheless,withthesamesolicitude,aswellbyreasontheseaccidentsarenotofsogreatnecessity,thegreaterpartofmankindpassingovertheirwholeliveswithouteverknowingwhatpovertyis,andsomewithoutsorroworsickness,asXenophilusthemusician,wholivedahundredandsixyearsinaperfectandcontinualhealth;asalsobecause,attheworst,deathcan,wheneverweplease,cutshortandputanendtoallotherinconveniences。Butastodeath,itisinevitable:——
"Omneseodemcogimur;omniumVersatururnaseriusociusSorsexitura,etnosinaeternumExiliumimposituracymbae。"
["Weareallboundonevoyage;thelotofall,soonerorlater,istocomeoutoftheurn。Allmusttoeternalexilesailaway。"
——Hor。,Od。,ii。3,25。]
and,consequently,ifitfrightsus,’tisaperpetualtorment,forwhichthereisnosortofconsolation。Thereisnowaybywhichitmaynotreachus。Wemaycontinuallyturnourheadsthiswayandthat,asinasuspectedcountry:
"Quae,quasisaxumTantalo,semperimpendet。"
["Ever,likeTantalusstone,hangsoverus。"
——Cicero,DeFinib。,i。18。]
Ourcourtsofjusticeoftensendbackcondemnedcriminalstobeexecutedupontheplacewherethecrimewascommitted;but,carrythemtofinehousesbytheway,prepareforthemthebestentertainmentyoucan——
"NonSiculaedapesDulcemelaborabuntsaporem:
NonaviumcyatheaceaecantusSomnumreducent。"
["Siciliandaintieswillnottickletheirpalates,northemelodyofbirdsandharpsbringbacksleep。"——Hor。,Od。,iii。1,18。]
Doyouthinktheycanrelishit?andthatthefatalendoftheirjourneybeingcontinuallybeforetheireyes,wouldnotalteranddepravetheirpalatefromtastingtheseregalios?
"Audititer,numeratquedies,spatioqueviarumMetiturvitam;torqueturpestefutura。"
["Heconsiderstheroute,computesthetimeoftravelling,measuringhislifebythelengthofthejourney;andtormentshimselfbythinkingoftheblowtocome。"——Claudianus,inRuf。,ii。137。]
Theendofourraceisdeath;’tisthenecessaryobjectofouraim,which,ifitfrightus,howisitpossibletoadvanceastepwithoutafitofague?Theremedythevulgaruseisnottothinkon’t;butfromwhatbrutishstupiditycantheyderivesogrossablindness?Theymustbridletheassbythetail:
"Quicapiteipsesuoinstituitvestigiaretro,"
["Whoinhisfollyseekstoadvancebackwards"——Lucretius,iv。474]
’tisnowonderifhebeoftentrappedinthepitfall。Theyaffrightpeoplewiththeverymentionofdeath,andmanycrossthemselves,asitwerethenameofthedevil。Andbecausethemakingaman’swillisinreferencetodying,notamanwillbepersuadedtotakeapeninhandtothatpurpose,tillthephysicianhaspassedsentenceuponandtotallygivenhimover,andthenbetwixtandterror,Godknowsinhowfitaconditionofunderstandingheistodoit。
TheRomans,byreasonthatthispoorsyllabledeathsoundedsoharshlytotheirearsandseemedsoominous,foundoutawaytosoftenandspinitoutbyaperiphrasis,andinsteadofpronouncingsuchaoneisdead,said,"Suchaonehaslived,"or"Suchaonehasceasedtolive"——
[Plutarch,LifeofCicero,c。22:]——for,providedtherewasanymentionoflifeinthecase,thoughpast,itcarriedyetsomesoundofconsolation。Andfromthemitisthatwehaveborrowedourexpression,"ThelateMonsieursuchandsuchaone。"——["feuMonsieuruntel。"]