TranslatedbyCharlesCottonEditedbyWilliamCarewHazilitt1877
CONTENTSOFVOLUME1。
PrefaceTheLifeofMontaigneTheLettersofMontaignePREFACE。
Thepresentpublicationisintendedtosupplyarecogniseddeficiencyinourliterature——alibraryeditionoftheEssaysofMontaigne。ThisgreatFrenchwriterdeservestoberegardedasaclassic,notonlyinthelandofhisbirth,butinallcountriesandinallliteratures。HisEssays,whichareatoncethemostcelebratedandthemostpermanentofhisproductions,formamagazineoutofwhichsuchmindsasthoseofBaconandShakespearedidnotdisdaintohelpthemselves;and,indeed,asHallamobserves,theFrenchman’sliteraryimportancelargelyresultsfromthesharewhichhismindhadininfluencingotherminds,coevalandsubsequent。But,atthesametime,estimatingthevalueandrankoftheessayist,wearenottoleaveoutoftheaccountthedrawbacksandthecircumstancesoftheperiod:theimperfectstateofeducation,thecomparativescarcityofbooks,andthelimitedopportunitiesofintellectualintercourse。Montaignefreelyborrowedofothers,andhehasfoundmenwillingtoborrowofhimasfreely。Weneednotwonderatthereputationwhichhewithseemingfacilityachieved。Hewas,withoutbeingawareofit,theleaderofanewschoolinlettersandmorals。Hisbookwasdifferentfromallotherswhichwereatthatdateintheworld。
Itdivertedtheancientcurrentsofthoughtintonewchannels。Ittolditsreaders,withunexampledfrankness,whatitswriter’sopinionwasaboutmenandthings,andthrewwhatmusthavebeenastrangekindofnewlightonmanymattersbutdarklyunderstood。Aboveall,theessayistuncasedhimself,andmadehisintellectualandphysicalorganismpublicproperty。Hetooktheworldintohisconfidenceonallsubjects。Hisessayswereasortofliteraryanatomy,wherewegetadiagnosisofthewriter’smind,madebyhimselfatdifferentlevelsandunderalargevarietyofoperatinginfluences。
Ofallegotists,Montaigne,ifnotthegreatest,wasthemostfascinating,because,perhaps,hewastheleastaffectedandmosttruthful。Whathedid,andwhathehadprofessedtodo,wastodissecthismind,andshowus,asbesthecould,howitwasmade,andwhatrelationitboretoexternalobjects。Heinvestigatedhismentalstructureasaschoolboypullshiswatchtopieces,toexaminethemechanismoftheworks;andtheresult,accompaniedbyillustrationsaboundingwithoriginalityandforce,hedeliveredtohisfellow—meninabook。
Eloquence,rhetoricaleffect,poetry,werealikeremotefromhisdesign。
Hedidnotwritefromnecessity,scarcelyperhapsforfame。ButhedesiredtoleaveFrance,nay,andtheworld,somethingtoberememberedby,somethingwhichshouldtellwhatkindofamanhewas——whathefelt,thought,suffered——andhesucceededimmeasurably,Iapprehend,beyondhisexpectations。
ItwasreasonableenoughthatMontaigneshouldexpectforhisworkacertainshareofcelebrityinGascony,andeven,astimewenton,throughoutFrance;butitisscarcelyprobablethatheforesawhowhisrenownwastobecomeworld—wide;howhewastooccupyanalmostuniquepositionasamanoflettersandamoralist;howtheEssayswouldberead,inalltheprincipallanguagesofEurope,bymillionsofintelligenthumanbeings,whoneverheardofPerigordortheLeague,andwhoareindoubt,iftheyarequestioned,whethertheauthorlivedinthesixteenthortheeighteenthcentury。Thisistruefame。Amanofgeniusbelongstonoperiodandnocountry。Hespeaksthelanguageofnature,whichisalwayseverywherethesame。
ThetextofthesevolumesistakenfromthefirsteditionofCotton’sversion,printedin3vols。8vo,1685—6,andrepublishedin1693,1700,1711,1738,and1743,inthesamenumberofvolumesandthesamesize。
Intheearliestimpressiontheerrorsofthepressarecorrectedmerelyasfaraspage240ofthefirstvolume,andalltheeditionsfollowoneanother。Thatof1685—6wastheonlyonewhichthetranslatorlivedtosee。Hediedin1687,leavingbehindhimaninterestingandlittle—knowncollectionofpoems,whichappearedposthumously,8vo,1689。
ItwasconsideredimperativetocorrectCotton’stranslationbyacarefulcollationwiththe’variorum’editionoftheoriginal,Paris,1854,4vols。8voor12mo,andparallelpassagesfromFlorin’searlierundertakinghaveoccasionallybeeninsertedatthefootofthepage。A
LifeoftheAuthorandallhisrecoveredLetters,sixteeninnumber,havealsobeengiven;but,asregardsthecorrespondence,itcanscarcelybedoubtedthatitisinapurelyfragmentarystate。TodomorethanfurnishasketchoftheleadingincidentsinMontaigne’slifeseemed,inthepresenceofBayleSt。John’scharmingandablebiography,anattemptasdifficultasitwasuseless。
ThebesettingsinofbothMontaigne’stranslatorsseemstohavebeenapropensityforreducinghislanguageandphraseologytothelanguageandphraseologyoftheageandcountrytowhichtheybelonged,and,moreover,insertingparagraphsandwords,nothereandthereonly,butconstantlyandhabitually,fromanevidentdesireandviewtoelucidateorstrengthentheirauthor’smeaning。Theresulthasgenerallybeenunfortunate;andIhave,inthecaseofalltheseinterpolationsonCotton’spart,feltbound,whereIdidnotcancelthem,tothrowthemdownintothenotes,notthinkingitrightthatMontaigneshouldbeallowedanylongertostandsponsorforwhatheneverwrote;andreluctant,ontheotherhand,tosuppresstheintrudingmatterentirely,whereitappearedtopossessavalueofitsown。
NorisredundancyorparaphrasetheonlyformoftransgressioninCotton,forthereareplacesinhisauthorwhichhethoughtpropertoomit,anditishardlynecessarytosaythattherestorationofallsuchmattertothetextwasconsideredessentialtoitsintegrityandcompleteness。
Mywarmestthanksareduetomyfather,MrRegistrarHazlitt,theauthorofthewell—knownandexcellenteditionofMontaignepublishedin1842,fortheimportantassistancewhichhehasrenderedtomeinverifyingandretranslatingthequotations,whichwereinamostcorruptstate,andofwhichCotton’sEnglishversionsweresingularlylooseandinexact,andforthezealwithwhichhehasco—operatedwithmeincollatingtheEnglishtext,lineforlineandwordforword,withthebestFrenchedition。
BythefavourofMrF。W。Cosens,Ihavehadbyme,whileatworkonthissubject,thecopyofCotgrave’sDictionary,folio,1650,whichbelongedtoCotton。IthashisautographandcopiousMSS。notes,norisittoomuchtopresumethatitistheverybookemployedbyhiminhistranslation。
W。C。H。
KENSINGTON,November1877。
BOOKTHEFIRST。
THELIFEOFMONTAIGNE
[Thisistranslatedfreelyfromthatprefixedtothe’variorum’Parisedition,1854,4vols。8vo。ThisbiographyisthemoredesirablethatitcontainsallreallyinterestingandimportantmatterinthejournaloftheTourinGermanyandItaly,which,asitwasmerelywrittenunderMontaigne’sdictation,isinthethirdperson,isscarcelyworthpublication,asawhole,inanEnglishdress。]
TheauthoroftheEssayswasborn,asheinformsushimself,betweenelevenandtwelveo’clockintheday,thelastofFebruary1533,atthechateauofSt。MicheldeMontaigne。Hisfather,PierreEyquem,esquire,wassuccessivelyfirstJuratofthetownofBordeaux(1530),Under—Mayor1536),Juratforthesecondtimein1540,Procureurin1546,andatlengthMayorfrom1553to1556。Hewaswmanofaustereprobity,whohad"aparticularregardforhonourandforproprietyinhispersonandattire……amightygoodfaithinhisspeech,andaconscienceandareligiousfeelingincliningtosuperstition,ratherthantotheotherextreme。"[Essays,ii。2。]PierreEyquembestowedgreatcareontheeducationofhischildren,especiallyonthepracticalsideofit。ToassociatecloselyhissonMichelwiththepeople,andattachhimtothosewhostandinneedofassistance,hecausedhimtobeheldatthefontbypersonsofmeanestposition;subsequentlyheputhimouttonursewithapoorvillager,andthen,atalaterperiod,madehimaccustomhimselftothemostcommonsortofliving,takingcare,nevertheless,tocultivatehismind,andsuperintenditsdevelopmentwithouttheexerciseofunduerigourorconstraint。Michel,whogivesustheminutestaccountofhisearliestyears,charminglynarrateshowtheyusedtoawakehimbythesoundofsomeagreeablemusic,andhowhelearnedLatin,withoutsufferingtherodorsheddingatear,beforebeginningFrench,thankstotheGermanteacherwhomhisfatherhadplacednearhim,andwhoneveraddressedhimexceptinthelanguageofVirgilandCicero。ThestudyofGreektookprecedence。AtsixyearsofageyoungMontaignewenttotheCollegeofGuienneatBordeaux,wherehehadaspreceptorsthemosteminentscholarsofthesixteenthcentury,NicolasGrouchy,Guerente,Muret,andBuchanan。Atthirteenhehadpassedthroughalltheclasses,andashewasdestinedforthelawheleftschooltostudythatscience。
Hewasthenaboutfourteen,buttheseearlyyearsofhislifeareinvolvedinobscurity。Thenextinformationthatwehaveisthatin1554
hereceivedtheappointmentofcouncillorintheParliamentofBordeaux;
in1559hewasatBar—le—DucwiththecourtofFrancisII,andintheyearfollowinghewaspresentatRouentowitnessthedeclarationofthemajorityofCharlesIX。Wedonotknowinwhatmannerhewasengagedontheseoccasions。
Between1556and1563animportantincidentoccurredinthelifeofMontaigne,inthecommencementofhisromanticfriendshipwithEtiennedelaBoetie,whomhehadmet,ashetellsus,bypurechanceatsomefestivecelebrationinthetown。Fromtheirveryfirstinterviewthetwofoundthemselvesdrawnirresistiblyclosetooneanother,andduringsixyearsthisalliancewasforemostintheheartofMontaigne,asitwasafterwardsinhismemory,whendeathhadseveredit。
Althoughheblamesseverelyinhisownbook[Essays,i。27。]thosewho,contrarytotheopinionofAristotle,marrybeforefive—and—thirty,MontaignedidnotwaitfortheperiodfixedbythephilosopherofStagyra,butin1566,inhisthirty—thirdyear,heespousedFrancoisedeChassaigne,daughterofacouncillorintheParliamentofBordeaux。Thehistoryofhisearlymarriedlifeviesinobscuritywiththatofhisyouth。Hisbiographersarenotagreedamongthemselves;andinthesamedegreethathelaysopentoourviewallthatconcernshissecretthoughts,theinnermostmechanismofhismind,heobservestoomuchreticenceinrespecttohispublicfunctionsandconduct,andhissocialrelations。ThetitleofGentlemaninOrdinarytotheKing,whichheassumes,inapreface,andwhichHenryII。giveshiminaletter,whichweprintalittlefartheron;whathesaysastothecommotionsofcourts,wherehepassedaportionofhislife;theInstructionswhichhewroteunderthedictationofCatherinedeMediciforKingCharlesIX。,andhisnoblecorrespondencewithHenryIV。,leavenodoubt,however,astothepartwhichheplayedinthetransactionsofthosetimes,andwefindanunanswerableproofoftheesteeminwhichhewasheldbythemostexaltedpersonages,inaletterwhichwasaddressedtohimbyCharlesatthetimehewasadmittedtotheOrderofSt。Michael,whichwas,asheinformsushimself,thehighesthonouroftheFrenchnoblesse。
AccordingtoLacroixduMaine,Montaigne,uponthedeathofhiseldestbrother,resignedhispostofCouncillor,inordertoadoptthemilitaryprofession,while,ifwemightcreditthePresidentBouhier,heneverdischargedanyfunctionsconnectedwitharms。However,severalpassagesintheEssaysseemtoindicatethathenotonlytookservice,butthathewasactuallyinnumerouscampaignswiththeCatholicarmies。Letusadd,thatonhismonumentheisrepresentedinacoatofmail,withhiscasqueandgauntletsonhisrightside,andalionathisfeet,allwhichsignifies,inthelanguageoffuneralemblems,thatthedepartedhasbeenengagedinsomeimportantmilitarytransactions。
Howeveritmaybeastotheseconjectures,ourauthor,havingarrivedathisthirty—eighthyear,resolvedtodedicatetostudyandcontemplationtheremainingtermofhislife;andonhisbirthday,thelastofFebruary1571,hecausedaphilosophicalinscription,inLatin,tobeplacedupononeofthewallsofhischateau,whereitisstilltobeseen,andofwhichthetranslationistothiseffect:——"IntheyearofChrist……
inhisthirty—eighthyear,ontheeveoftheCalendsofMarch,hisbirthday,MichelMontaigne,alreadywearyofcourtemploymentsandpublichonours,withdrewhimselfentirelyintotheconverseofthelearnedvirginswhereheintendstospendtheremainingmoietyofthetoallottedtohimintranquilseclusion。"
Atthetimetowhichwehavecome,Montaignewasunknowntotheworldofletters,exceptasatranslatorandeditor。In1569hehadpublishedatranslationofthe"NaturalTheology"ofRaymonddeSebonde,whichhehadsolelyundertakentopleasehisfather。In1571hehadcausedtobeprintedatPariscertain’opuscucla’ofEtiennedelaBoetie;andthesetwoefforts,inspiredinonecasebyfilialduty,andintheotherbyfriendship,provethataffectionatemotivesoverruledwithhimmerepersonalambitionasaliteraryman。WemaysupposethathebegantocomposetheEssaysattheveryoutsetofhisretirementfrompublicengagements;foras,accordingtohisownaccount,observesthePresidentBouhier,hecaredneitherforthechase,norbuilding,norgardening,noragriculturalpursuits,andwasexclusivelyoccupiedwithreadingandreflection,hedevotedhimselfwithsatisfactiontothetaskofsettingdownhisthoughtsjustastheyoccurredtohim。Thosethoughtsbecameabook,andthefirstpartofthatbook,whichwastoconferimmortalityonthewriter,appearedatBordeauxin1580。Montaignewasthenfifty—
seven;hehadsufferedforsomeyearspastfromrenalcolicandgravel;
anditwaswiththenecessityofdistractionfromhispain,andthehopeofderivingrelieffromthewaters,thatheundertookatthistimeagreatjourney。AstheaccountwhichhehasleftofhistravelsinGermanyandItalycomprisessomehighlyinterestingparticularsofhislifeandpersonalhistory,itseemsworthwhiletofurnishasketchoranalysisofit。
"TheJourney,ofwhichweproceedtodescribethecoursesimply,"saystheeditoroftheItinerary,"had,fromBeaumont—sur—OisetoPlombieres,inLorraine,nothingsufficientlyinterestingtodetainus……wemustgoasfar,asBasle,ofwhichwehaveadescription,acquaintinguswithitsphysicalandpoliticalconditionatthatperiod,aswellaswiththecharacterofitsbaths。ThepassageofMontaignethroughSwitzerlandisnotwithoutinterest,asweseetherehowourphilosophicaltravelleraccommodatedhimselfeverywheretothewaysofthecountry。Thehotels,theprovisions,theSwisscookery,everything,wasagreeabletohim;itappears,indeed,asifhepreferredtotheFrenchmannersandtastesthoseoftheplaceshewasvisiting,andofwhichthesimplicityandfreedom(orfrankness)accordedmorewithhisownmodeoflifeandthinking。Inthetownswherehestayed,MontaignetookcaretoseetheProtestantdivines,tomakehimselfconversantwithalltheirdogmas。Heevenhaddisputationswiththemoccasionally。
"HavingleftSwitzerlandhewenttoIsne,animperialthenontoAugsburgandMunich。HeafterwardsproceededtotheTyrol,wherehewasagreeablysurprised,afterthewarningswhichhehadreceived,attheveryslightinconvenienceswhichhesuffered,whichgavehimoccasiontoremarkthathehadallhislifedistrustedthestatementsofothersrespectingforeigncountries,eachperson’stastesbeingaccordingtothenotionsofhisnativeplace;andthathehadconsequentlysetverylittleonwhathewastoldbeforehand。
"UponhisarrivalatBotzen,MontaignewrotetoFrancoisHottmann,tosaythathehadbeensopleasedwithhisvisittoGermanythathequitteditwithgreatregret,althoughitwastogointoItaly。HethenpassedthroughBrunsol,Trent,whereheputupattheRose;thencegoingtoRovera;andherehefirstlamentedthescarcityofcrawfish,butmadeupforthelossbypartakingoftrufflescookedinoilandvinegar;oranges,citrons,andolives,inallofwhichhedelighted。
Afterpassingarestlessnight,whenhebethoughthimselfinthemorningthattherewassomenewtownordistricttobeseen,herose,wearetold,withalacrityandpleasure。
Hissecretary,towhomhedictatedhisJournal,assuresusthatheneversawhimtakesomuchinterestinsurroundingscenesandpersons,andbelievesthatthecompletechangehelpedtomitigatehissufferingsinconcentratinghisattentiononotherpoints。Whentherewasacomplaintmadethathehadledhispartyoutofthebeatenroute,andthenreturnedverynearthespotfromwhichtheystarted,hisanswerwasthathehadnosettledcourse,andthathemerelyproposedtohimselftopayvisitstoplaceswhichhehadnotseen,andsolongastheycouldnotconvicthimoftraversingthesamepathtwice,orrevisitingapointalreadyseen,hecouldperceivenoharminhisplan。AstoRome,hecaredlesstogothere,inasmuchaseverybodywentthere;andhesaidthatheneverhadalacqueywhocouldnottellhimallaboutFlorenceorFerrara。Healsowouldsaythatheseemedtohimselflikethosewhoarereadingsomepleasantstoryorsomefinebook,ofwhichtheyfeartocometotheend:
hefeltsomuchpleasureintravellingthathedreadedthemomentofarrivalattheplacewheretheyweretostopforthenight。
WeseethatMontaignetravelled,justashewrote,completelyathisease,andwithouttheleastconstraint,turning,justashefancied,fromthecommonorordinaryroadstakenbytourists。Thegoodinns,thesoftbeds,thefineviews,attractedhisnoticeateverypoint,andinhisobservationsonmenandthingsheconfineshimselfchieflytothepracticalside。Theconsiderationofhishealthwasconstantlybeforehim,anditwasinconsequenceofthisthat,whileatVenice,whichdisappointedhim,hetookoccasiontonote,forthebenefitofreaders,thathehadanattackofcolic,andthatheevacuatedtwolargestonesaftersupper。OnquittingVenice,hewentinsuccessiontoFerrara,Rovigo,Padua,Bologna(wherehehadastomach—ache),Florence,&c。;andeverywhere,beforealighting,hemadeitaruletosendsomeofhisservantstoascertainwherethebestaccommodationwastobehad。HepronouncedtheFlorentinewomenthefinestintheworld,buthadnotanequallygoodopinionofthefood,whichwaslessplentifulthaninGermany,andnotsowellserved。HeletsusunderstandthatinItalytheysendupdisheswithoutdressing,butinGermanytheyweremuchbetterseasoned,andservedwithavarietyofsaucesandgravies。Heremarkedfurther,thattheglassesweresingularlysmallandthewinesinsipid。
AfterdiningwiththeGrand—DukeofFlorence,Montaignepassedrapidlyovertheintermediatecountry,whichhadnofascinationforhim,andarrivedatRomeonthelastdayofNovember,enteringbythePortadelPopolo,andputtingupatBear。Butheafterwardshired,attwentycrownsamonth,finefurnishedroomsinthehouseofaSpaniard,whoincludedinthesetermstheuseofthekitchenfire。WhatmostannoyedhimintheEternalCitywasthenumberofFrenchmenhemet,whoallsalutedhiminhisnativetongue;butotherwisehewasverycomfortable,andhisstayextendedtofivemonths。Amindlikehis,fullofgrandclassicalreflections,couldnotfailtobeprofoundlyimpressedinthepresenceoftheruinsatRome,andhehasenshrinedinamagnificentpassageoftheJournalthefeelingsofthemoment:"Hesaid,"writeshissecretary,"thatatRomeonesawnothingbuttheskyunderwhichshehadbeenbuilt,andtheoutlineofhersite:thattheknowledgewehadofherwasabstract,contemplative,notpalpabletotheactualsenses:thatthosewhosaidtheybeheldatleasttheruinsofRome,wenttoofar,fortheruinsofsogiganticastructuremusthavecommandedgreaterreverence—itwasnothingbuthersepulchre。Theworld,jealousofher,prolongedempire,hadinthefirstplacebrokentopiecesthatadmirablebody,andthen,whentheyperceivedthattheremainsattractedworshipandawe,hadburiedtheverywreckitself。——[CompareapassageinoneofHoraceWalpole’sletterstoRichardWest,22March1740(Cunningham’sedit。i。41),whereWalpole,speakingofRome,describesherveryruinsasruined。]——Astothosesmallfragmentswhichwerestilltobeseenonthesurface,notwithstandingtheassaultsoftimeandallotherattacks,againandagainrepeated,theyhadbeenfavouredbyfortunetobesomeslightevidenceofthatinfinitegrandeurwhichnothingcouldentirelyextingish。Butitwaslikelythatthesedisfiguredremainsweretheleastentitledtoattention,andthattheenemiesofthatimmortalrenown,intheirfury,hadaddressedthemselvesinthefirstinstancetothedestructionofwhatwasmostbeautifulandworthiestofpreservation;
andthatthebuildingsofthisbastardRome,raisedupontheancientproductions,althoughtheymightexcitetheadmirationofthepresentage,remindedhimofthecrows’andsparrows’nestsbuiltinthewallsandarchesoftheoldchurches,destroyedbytheHuguenots。Again,hewasapprehensive,seeingthespacewhichthisgraveoccupied,thatthewholemightnothavebeenrecovered,andthattheburialitselfhadbeenburied。And,moreover,toseeawretchedheapofrubbish,aspiecesoftileandpottery,grow(asithadagessince)toaheightequaltothatofMountGurson,——[InPerigord。]——andthricethewidthofit,appearedtoshowaconspiracyofdestinyagainstthegloryandpre—eminenceofthatcity,affordingatthesametimeanovelandextraordinaryproofofitsdepartedgreatness。He(Montaigne)observedthatitwasdifficulttobelieveconsideringthelimitedareatakenupbyanyofhersevenhillsandparticularlythetwomostfavouredones,theCapitolineandthePalatine,thatsomanybuildingsstoodonthesite。JudgingonlyfromwhatisleftoftheTempleofConcord,alongthe’ForumRomanum’,ofwhichthefallseemsquiterecent,likethatofsomehugemountainsplitintohorriblecrags,itdoesnotlookasifmorethantwosuchedificescouldhavefoundroomontheCapitoline,onwhichtherewereatoneperiodfromfive—and—twentytothirtytemples,besidesprivatedwellings。
But,inpointoffact,thereisscarcelyanyprobabilityoftheviewswhichwetakeofthecitybeingcorrect,itsplanandformhavingchangedinfinitely;forinstance,the’Velabrum’,whichonaccountofitsdepressedlevel,receivedthesewageofthecity,andhadalake,hasbeenraisedbyartificialaccumulationtoaheightwiththeotherhills,andMountSavellohas,intruth,grownsimplyoutoftheruinsofthetheatreofMarcellus。HebelievedthatanancientRomanwouldnotrecognisetheplaceagain。Itoftenhappenedthatindiggingdownintoearththeworkmencameuponthecrownofsomeloftycolumn,which,thoughthusburied,wasstillstandingupright。Thepeopletherehavenorecoursetootherfoundationsthanthevaultsandarchesoftheoldhouses,uponwhich,asonslabsofrock,theyraisetheirmodernpalaces。
Itiseasytoseethatseveraloftheancientstreetsarethirtyfeetbelowthoseatpresentinuse。"
ScepticalasMontaigneshowshimselfinhisbooks,yetduringhissojournatRomehemanifestedagreatregardforreligion。HesolicitedthehonourofbeingadmittedtokissthefeetoftheHolyFather,GregoryXIII。;andthePontiffexhortedhimalwaystocontinueinthedevotionwhichhehadhithertoexhibitedtotheChurchandtheserviceoftheMostChristianKing。
"Afterthis,onesees,"saystheeditoroftheJournal,"Montaigneemployingallhistimeinmakingexcursionsbouttheneighbourhoodonhorsebackoronfoot,invisits,inobservationsofeverykind。Thechurches,thestations,theprocessionseven,thesermons;thenthepalaces,thevineyards,thegardens,thepublicamusements,astheCarnival,&c。——nothingwasoverlooked。HesawaJewishchildcircumcised,andwrotedownamostminuteaccountoftheoperation。HemetatSanSistoaMuscoviteambassador,thesecondwhohadcometoRomesincethepontificateofPaulIII。ThisministerhaddespatchesfromhiscourtforVenice,addressedtothe’GrandGovernoroftheSignory’。ThecourtofMuscovyhadatthattimesuchlimitedrelationswiththeotherpowersofEurope,anditwassoimperfectinitsinformation,thatitthoughtVenicetobeadependencyoftheHolySee。"
OfalltheparticularswithwhichhehasfurnishedusduringhisstayatRome,thefollowingpassageinreferencetotheEssaysisnottheleastsingular:"TheMasteroftheSacredPalacereturnedhimhisEssays,castigatedinaccordancewiththeviewsofthelearnedmonks。’Hehadonlybeenabletoformajudgmentofthem,’saidhe,’throughacertainFrenchmonk,notunderstandingFrenchhimself’"——weleaveMontaignehimselftotellthestory——"andhereceivedsocomplacentlymyexcusesandexplanationsoneachofthepassageswhichhadbeenanimadverteduponbytheFrenchmonk,thatheconcludedbyleavingmeatlibertytorevisethetextagreeablytothedictatesofmyownconscience。Ibeggedhim,onthecontrary,toabidebytheopinionofthepersonwhohadcriticisedme,confessing,amongothermatters,as,forexample,inmyuseofthewordfortune,inquotinghistoricalpoets,inmyapologyforJulian,inmyanimadversiononthetheorythathewhoprayedoughttobeexemptfromviciousinclinationsforthetimebeing;item,inmyestimateofcruelty,assomethingbeyondsimpledeath;item,inmyviewthatachildoughttobebroughtuptodoeverything,andsoon;thattheseweremyopinions,whichIdidnotthinkwrong;astootherthings,Isaidthatthecorrectorunderstoodnotmymeaning。TheMaster,whoisacleverman,mademanyexcusesforme,andgavemetosupposethathedidnotconcurinthesuggestedimprovements;andpleadedveryingeniouslyformeinmypresenceagainstanother(alsoanItalian)whoopposedmysentiments。"
SuchiswhatpassedbetweenMontaigneandthesetwopersonagesatthattime;butwhentheEssayistwasleaving,andwenttobidthemfarewell,theyusedverydifferentlanguagetohim。"Theyprayedme,"sayshe,"topaynoattentiontothecensurepassedonmybook,inwhichotherFrenchpersonshadapprisedthemthatthereweremanyfoolishthings;
adding,thattheyhonouredmyaffectionateintentiontowardstheChurch,andmycapacity;andhadsohighanopinionofmycandourandconscientiousnessthattheyshouldleaveittometomakesuchalterationsaswereproperinthebook,whenIreprintedit;amongotherthings,thewordfortune。Toexcusethemselvesforwhattheyhadsaidagainstmybook,theyinstancedworksofourtimebycardinalsandotherdivinesofexcellentreputewhichhadbeenblamedforsimilarfaults,whichinnowayaffectedreputationoftheauthor,orofthepublicationasawhole;theyrequestedmetolendtheChurchthesupportofmyeloquence(thiswastheirfairspeech),andtomakelongerstayintheplace,whereIshouldbefreefromallfurtherintrusionontheirpart。
Itseemedtomethatwepartedverygoodfriends。"
BeforequittingRome,Montaignereceivedhisdiplomaofcitizenship,bywhichhewasgreatlyflattered;andafteravisittoTivolihesetoutforLoretto,stoppingatAncona,Fano,andUrbino。HearrivedatthebeginningofMay1581,atBagnodellaVilla,whereheestablishedhimself,ordertotrythewaters。There,wefindintheJournal,ofhisownaccordtheEssayistlivedinthestrictestconformitywiththeregime,andhenceforthweonlyhearofdiet,theeffectwhichthewatershadbydegreesuponsystem,ofthemannerinwhichhetookthem;inaword,hedoesnotomitanitemofthecircumstancesconnectedwithhisdailyroutine,hishabitofbody,hisbaths,andtherest。Itwasnolongerthejournalofatravellerwhichhekept,butthediaryofaninvalid,——["IamreadingMontaigne’sTravels,whichhavelatelybeenfound;thereislittleinthembutthebathsandmedicineshetook,andwhathehadeverywherefordinner。"——H。WalpoletoSirHoraceMann,June8,1774。]——attentivetotheminutestdetailsofthecurewhichhewasendeavouringtoaccomplish:asortofmemorandumbook,inwhichhewasnotingdowneverythingthathefeltanddid,forthebenefitofhismedicalmanathome,whowouldhavethecareofhishealthonhisreturn,andtheattendanceonhissubsequentinfirmities。Montaignegivesitashisreasonandjustificationforenlargingtothisextenthere,thathehadomitted,tohisregret,todosoinhisvisitstootherbaths,whichmighthavesavedhimthetroubleofwritingatsuchgreatlengthnow;butitisperhapsabetterreasoninoureyes,thatwhathewrotehewroteforhisownuse。
Wefindintheseaccounts,however,manytoucheswhicharevaluableasillustratingthemannersoftheplace。ThegreaterpartoftheentriesintheJournal,givingtheaccountofthesewaters,andofthetravels,downtoMontaigne’sarrivalatthefirstFrenchtownonhishomewardroute,areinItalian,becausehewishedtoexercisehimselfinthatlanguage。
TheminuteandconstantwatchfulnessofMontaigneoverhishealthandoverhimselfmightleadonetosuspectthatexcessivefearofdeathwhichdegeneratesintocowardice。Butwasitnotratherthefearoftheoperationforthestone,atthattimereallyformidable?OrperhapshewasofthesamewayofthinkingwiththeGreekpoet,ofwhomCiceroreportsthissaying:"Idonotdesiretodie;butthethoughtofbeingdeadisindifferenttome。"Letushear,however,whathesayshimselfonthispointveryfrankly:"Itwouldbetooweakandunmanlyonmypartif,certainasIamofalwaysfindingmyselfinthepositionofhavingtosuccumbinthatway,——[Tothestoneorgravel。]——anddeathcomingnearerandnearertome,Ididnotmakesomeeffort,beforethetimecame,tobearthetrialwithfortitude。ForreasonprescribesthatweshouldjoyfullyacceptwhatitmaypleaseGodtosendus。Thereforetheonlyremedy,theonlyrule,andthesoledoctrineforavoidingtheevilsbywhichmankindissurrounded,whatevertheyare,istoresolvetobearthemsofarasournaturepermits,ortoputanendtothemcourageouslyandpromptly。"
HewasstillatthewatersofLaVilla,when,onthe7thSeptember1581,helearnedbyletterthathehadbeenelectedMayorofBordeauxonthe1stAugustpreceding。Thisintelligencemadehimhastenhisdeparture;
andfromLuccaheproceededtoRome。Heagainmadesomestayinthatcity,andhetherereceivedtheletterofthejuratsofBordeaux,notifyingtohimofficiallyhiselectiontotheMayoralty,andinvitinghimtoreturnasspeedilyaspossible。HeleftforFrance,accompaniedbyyoungD’Estissacandseveralothergentlemen,whoescortedhimaconsiderabledistance;butnonewentbacktoFrancewithhim,notevenhistravellingcompanion。HepassedbyPadua,Milan,MontCenis,andChambery;thencehewentontoLyons,andlostnotimeinrepairingtohischateau,afteranabsenceofseventeenmonthsandeightdays。
Wehavejustseenthat,duringhisabsenceinItaly,theauthoroftheEssayswaselectedmayorofBordeaux。"ThegentlemenofBordeaux,"sayshe,"electedmeMayoroftheirtownwhileIwasatadistancefromFrance,andfarfromthethoughtofsuchathing。Iexcusedmyself;buttheygavetounderstandthatIwaswronginsodoing,itbeingalsothecommandofthekingthatIshouldstand。"ThistheletterwhichHenryIII。wrotetohimontheoccasion:
MONSIEUR,DEMONTAIGNE,——InasmuchasIholdingreatesteemyourfidelityandzealousdevotiontomyservice,ithasbeenapleasuretometolearnthatyouhavebeenchosenmayorofmytownofBordeaux。Ihavehadtheagreeabledutyofconfirmingtheselection,andIdidsothemorewillingly,seeingthatitwasmadeduringyourdistantabsence;whereforeitismydesire,andIrequireandcommandyouexpresslythatyouproceedwithoutdelaytoenteronthedutiestowhichyouhavereceivedsolegitimateacall。Andsoyouwillactinamannerveryagreeabletome,whilethecontrarywilldispleasemegreatly。PrayingGod,M。deMontaigne,tohaveyouinhisholykeeping。
"WrittenatParis,the25thdayofNovember1581。
"HENRI。
"AMonsieurdeMONTAIGNE,KnightofmyOrder,GentlemaninOrdinaryofmyChamber,beingatpresentinRome。"
Montaigne,inhisnewemployment,themostimportantintheprovince,obeyedtheaxiom,thatamanmaynotrefuseaduty,thoughitabsorbhistimeandattention,andeveninvolvethesacrificeofhisblood。Placedbetweentwoextremeparties,everonthepointofgettingtoblows,heshowedhimselfinpracticewhatheisinhisbook,thefriendofamiddleandtemperatepolicy。Tolerantbycharacterandonprinciple,hebelonged,likeallthegreatmindsofthesixteenthcentury,tothatpoliticalsectwhichsoughttoimprove,withoutdestroying,institutions;
andwemaysayofhim,whathehimselfsaidofLaBoetie,"thathehadthatmaximindeliblyimpressedonhismind,toobeyandsubmithimselfreligiouslytothelawsunderwhichhewasborn。Affectionatelyattachedtothereposeofhiscountry,anenemytochangesandinnovations,hewouldhavepreferredtoemploywhatmeanshehadtowardstheirdiscouragementandsuppression,thaninpromotingtheirsuccess。"Suchwastheplatformofhisadministration。
Heappliedhimself,inanespecialmanner,tothemaintenanceofpeacebetweenthetworeligiousfactionswhichatthattimedividedthetownofBordeaux;andattheendofhistwofirstyearsofoffice,hisgratefulfellow—citizensconferredonhim(in1583)themayoraltyfortwoyearsmore,adistinctionwhichhadbeenenjoyed,ashetellsus,onlytwicebefore。Ontheexpirationofhisofficialcareer,afterfouryears’
duration,hecouldsayfairlyenoughofhimselfthatheleftbehindhimneitherhatrednorcauseofoffence。