WefindasentencebearingdatethefirstofMay,1660,inflictingafineandreprimandonayoungwomanwhowasaccusedofusingimproperlanguage,andofallowingherselftobekissed。
*tTheCodeof1650aboundsinpreventivemeasures。Itpunishesidlenessanddrunkennesswithseverity。*uInnkeepersareforbiddentofurnishmorethanacertainquantityofliquortoeachconsumer;andsimplelying,wheneveritmaybeinjurious,*vischeckedbyafineoraflogging。Inotherplaces,thelegislator,entirelyforgettingthegreatprinciplesofreligioustolerationwhichhehadhimselfupheldinEurope,rendersattendanceondivineservicecompulsory,*wandgoessofarastovisitwithseverepunishment,**andevenwithdeath,theChristianswhochosetoworshipGodaccordingtoaritualdifferingfromhisown。*xSometimesindeedthezealofhisenactmentsinduceshimtodescendtothemostfrivolousparticulars:thusalawistobefoundinthesameCodewhichprohibitstheuseoftobacco。*yItmustnotbeforgottenthatthesefantasticalandvexatiouslawswerenotimposedbyauthority,butthattheywerefreelyvotedbyallthepersonsinterested,andthatthemannersofthecommunitywereevenmoreaustereandmorepuritanicalthanthelaws。In1649asolemnassociationwasformedinBostontochecktheworldlyluxuryoflonghair。*z[Footnotes:Codeof1650,p。48。Itseemssometimestohavehappenedthatthejudgessuperaddedthesepunishmentstoeachother,asisseeninasentencepronouncedin1643(p。114,"NewHavenAntiquities"),bywhichMargaretBedford,convictedoflooseconduct,wascondemnedtobewhipped,andafterwardstomarryNicholasJemmings,heraccomplice。]
[Footnotet:"NewHavenAntiquities,"p。104。Seealso"Hutchinson’sHistory,"forseveralcausesequallyextraordinary。]
[Footnoteu:Codeof1650,pp。50,57。]
[Footnotev:Ibid。,p。64。]
[Footnotew:Ibid。,p。44。]
[Footnote*:ThiswasnotpeculiartoConnecticut。See,forinstance,thelawwhich,onSeptember13,1644,banishedtheAnabaptistsfromtheStateofMassachusetts。("HistoricalCollectionofStatePapers,"vol。i。p。538。)SeealsothelawagainsttheQuakers,passedonOctober14,1656:"Whereas,"saysthepreamble,"anaccursedraceofhereticscalledQuakershassprungup,"etc。TheclausesofthestatuteinflictaheavyfineonallcaptainsofshipswhoshouldimportQuakersintothecountry。TheQuakerswhomaybefoundthereshallbewhippedandimprisonedwithhardlabor。Thosemembersofthesectwhoshoulddefendtheiropinionsshallbefirstfined,thenimprisoned,andfinallydrivenoutoftheprovince。—"HistoricalCollectionofStatePapers,"vol。i。p。630。]
[Footnotex:BythepenallawofMassachusetts,anyCatholicpriestwhoshouldsetfootinthecolonyafterhavingbeenoncedrivenoutofitwasliabletocapitalpunishment。]
[Footnotey:Codeof1650,p。96。]
[Footnotez:"NewEngland’sMemorial,"p。316。SeeAppendix,E。]
Theseerrorsarenodoubtdiscreditabletohumanreason;
theyattesttheinferiorityofournature,whichisincapableoflayingfirmholduponwhatistrueandjust,andisoftenreducedtothealternativeoftwoexcesses。Instrictconnectionwiththispenallegislation,whichbearssuchstrikingmarksofanarrowsectarianspirit,andofthosereligiouspassionswhichhadbeenwarmedbypersecutionandwerestillfermentingamongthepeople,abodyofpoliticallawsistobefound,which,thoughwrittentwohundredyearsago,isstillaheadofthelibertiesofourage。Thegeneralprincipleswhicharethegroundworkofmodernconstitutions—principleswhichwereimperfectlyknowninEurope,andnotcompletelytriumphanteveninGreatBritain,intheseventeenthcentury—wereallrecognizedanddeterminedbythelawsofNewEngland:theinterventionofthepeopleinpublicaffairs,thefreevotingoftaxes,theresponsibilityofauthorities,personalliberty,andtrialbyjury,wereallpositivelyestablishedwithoutdiscussion。FromthesefruitfulprinciplesconsequenceshavebeenderivedandapplicationshavebeenmadesuchasnonationinEuropehasyetventuredtoattempt。
InConnecticuttheelectoralbodyconsisted,fromitsorigin,ofthewholenumberofcitizens;andthisisreadilytobeunderstood,*awhenwerecollectthatthispeopleenjoyedanalmostperfectequalityoffortune,andastillgreateruniformityofopinions。*bInConnecticut,atthisperiod,alltheexecutivefunctionarieswereelected,includingtheGovernoroftheState。*cThecitizensabovetheageofsixteenwereobligedtobeararms;theyformedanationalmilitia,whichappointeditsownofficers,andwastoholditselfatalltimesinreadinesstomarchforthedefenceofthecountry。*d[Footnotea:Constitutionof1638,p。17。]
[Footnoteb:In1641theGeneralAssemblyofRhodeIslandunanimouslydeclaredthatthegovernmentoftheStatewasademocracy,andthatthepowerwasvestedinthebodyoffreecitizens,whoalonehadtherighttomakethelawsandtowatchtheirexecution。—Codeof1650,p。70。]
[Footnotec:"Pitkin’sHistory,"p。47。]
[Footnoted:Constitutionof1638,p。12。]
InthelawsofConnecticut,aswellasinallthoseofNewEngland,wefindthegermandgradualdevelopmentofthattownshipindependencewhichisthelifeandmainspringofAmericanlibertyatthepresentday。ThepoliticalexistenceofthemajorityofthenationsofEuropecommencedinthesuperiorranksofsociety,andwasgraduallyandimperfectlycommunicatedtothedifferentmembersofthesocialbody。InAmerica,ontheotherhand,itmaybesaidthatthetownshipwasorganizedbeforethecounty,thecountybeforetheState,theStatebeforetheUnion。InNewEnglandtownshipswerecompletelyanddefinitivelyconstitutedasearlyas1650。Theindependenceofthetownshipwasthenucleusroundwhichthelocalinterests,passions,rights,anddutiescollectedandclung。Itgavescopetotheactivityofarealpoliticallifemostthoroughlydemocraticandrepublican。Thecoloniesstillrecognizedthesupremacyofthemother—country;monarchywasstillthelawoftheState;buttherepublicwasalreadyestablishedineverytownship。Thetownsnamedtheirownmagistratesofeverykind,ratedthemselves,andleviedtheirowntaxes。*eIntheparishofNewEnglandthelawofrepresentationwasnotadopted,buttheaffairsofthecommunitywerediscussed,asatAthens,inthemarket—place,byageneralassemblyofthecitizens。
[Footnotee:Codeof1650,p。80。]
InstudyingthelawswhichwerepromulgatedatthisfirsteraoftheAmericanrepublics,itisimpossiblenottobestruckbytheremarkableacquaintancewiththescienceofgovernmentandtheadvancedtheoryoflegislationwhichtheydisplay。TheideasthereformedofthedutiesofsocietytowardsitsmembersareevidentlymuchloftierandmorecomprehensivethanthoseoftheEuropeanlegislatorsatthattime:obligationswerethereimposedwhichwereelsewhereslighted。IntheStatesofNewEngland,fromthefirst,theconditionofthepoorwasprovidedfor;*fstrictmeasuresweretakenforthemaintenanceofroads,andsurveyorswereappointedtoattendtothem;*gregisterswereestablishedineveryparish,inwhichtheresultsofpublicdeliberations,andthebirths,deaths,andmarriagesofthecitizenswereentered;*hclerksweredirectedtokeeptheseregisters;*iofficerswerechargedwiththeadministrationofvacantinheritances,andwiththearbitrationoflitigatedlandmarks;andmanyotherswerecreatedwhosechieffunctionswerethemaintenanceofpublicorderinthecommunity。*jThelawentersintoathousandusefulprovisionsforanumberofsocialwantswhichareatpresentveryinadequatelyfeltinFrance。
[Footnotef:Ibid。,p。78。]
[Footnoteg:Ibid。,p。49。]
[Footnoteh:See"Hutchinson’sHistory,"vol。i。p。455。]
[Footnotei:Codeof1650,p。86。]
[Footnotej:Ibid。,p。40。]
ButitisbytheattentionitpaystoPublicEducationthattheoriginalcharacterofAmericancivilizationisatonceplacedintheclearestlight。"Itbeing,"saysthelaw,"onechiefprojectofSatantokeepmenfromtheknowledgeoftheScripturebypersuadingfromtheuseoftongues,totheendthatlearningmaynotbeburiedinthegravesofourforefathers,inchurchandcommonwealth,theLordassistingourendeavors……"*kHerefollowclausesestablishingschoolsineverytownship,andobligingtheinhabitants,underpainofheavyfines,tosupportthem。Schoolsofasuperiorkindwerefoundedinthesamemannerinthemorepopulousdistricts。Themunicipalauthoritieswereboundtoenforcethesendingofchildrentoschoolbytheirparents;theywereempoweredtoinflictfinesuponallwhorefusedcompliance;andincaseofcontinuedresistancesocietyassumedtheplaceoftheparent,tookpossessionofthechild,anddeprivedthefatherofthosenaturalrightswhichheusedtosobadapurpose。Thereaderwillundoubtedlyhaveremarkedthepreambleoftheseenactments:inAmericareligionistheroadtoknowledge,andtheobservanceofthedivinelawsleadsmantocivilfreedom。
[Footnotek:Ibid。,p。90。]
If,afterhavingcastarapidglanceoverthestateofAmericansocietyin1650,weturntotheconditionofEurope,andmoreespeciallytothatoftheContinent,atthesameperiod,wecannotfailtobestruckwithastonishment。OntheContinentofEurope,atthebeginningoftheseventeenthcentury,absolutemonarchyhadeverywheretriumphedovertheruinsoftheoligarchicalandfeudallibertiesoftheMiddleAges。NeverwerethenotionsofrightmorecompletelyconfoundedthaninthemidstofthesplendorandliteratureofEurope;neverwastherelesspoliticalactivityamongthepeople;neverweretheprinciplesoftruefreedomlesswidelycirculated;andatthatverytimethoseprinciples,whichwerescornedorunknownbythenationsofEurope,wereproclaimedinthedesertsoftheNewWorld,andwereacceptedasthefuturecreedofagreatpeople。Theboldesttheoriesofthehumanreasonwereputintopracticebyacommunitysohumblethatnotastatesmancondescendedtoattendtoit;andalegislationwithoutaprecedentwasproducedoffhandbytheimaginationofthecitizens。Inthebosomofthisobscuredemocracy,whichhadasyetbroughtforthneithergenerals,norphilosophers,norauthors,amanmightstandupinthefaceofafreepeopleandpronouncethefollowingfinedefinitionofliberty。*l[Footnotel:Mather’s"MagnaliaChristiAmericana,"vol。ii。p。
13。ThisspeechwasmadebyWinthrop;hewasaccusedofhavingcommittedarbitraryactionsduringhismagistracy,butafterhavingmadethespeechofwhichtheaboveisafragment,hewasacquittedbyacclamation,andfromthattimeforwardshewasalwaysre—electedgovernoroftheState。SeeMarshal,vol。i。
p。166。]
"NorwouldIhaveyoutomistakeinthepointofyourownliberty。Thereisalibertyofacorruptnaturewhichiseffectedbothbymenandbeaststodowhattheylist,andthislibertyisinconsistentwithauthority,impatientofallrestraint;bythisliberty’sumusomnesdeteriores’:’tisthegrandenemyoftruthandpeace,andalltheordinancesofGodarebentagainstit。Butthereisacivil,amoral,afederallibertywhichistheproperendandobjectofauthority;itisalibertyforthatonlywhichisjustandgood:forthislibertyyouaretostandwiththehazardofyourverylivesandwhatsoevercrossesitisnotauthority,butadistemperthereof。Thislibertyismaintainedinawayofsubjectiontoauthority;andtheauthoritysetoveryouwill,inalladministrationsforyourgood,bequietlysubmitteduntobyallbutsuchashaveadispositiontoshakeofftheyokeandlosetheirtrueliberty,bytheirmurmuringatthehonorandpowerofauthority。"
TheremarksIhavemadewillsufficetodisplaythecharacterofAnglo—Americancivilizationinitstruelight。Itistheresult(andthisshouldbeconstantlypresenttothemindoftwodistinctelements,whichinotherplaceshavebeeninfrequenthostility,butwhichinAmericahavebeenadmirablyincorporatedandcombinedwithoneanother。IalludetothespiritofReligionandthespiritofLiberty。
ThesettlersofNewEnglandwereatthesametimeardentsectariansanddaringinnovators。Narrowasthelimitsofsomeoftheirreligiousopinionswere,theywereentirelyfreefrompoliticalprejudices。Hencearosetwotendencies,distinctbutnotopposite,whichareconstantlydiscernibleinthemannersaswellasinthelawsofthecountry。
Itmightbeimaginedthatmenwhosacrificedtheirfriends,theirfamily,andtheirnativelandtoareligiousconvictionwereabsorbedinthepursuitoftheintellectualadvantageswhichtheypurchasedatsodeararate。Theenergy,however,withwhichtheystrovefortheacquirementofwealth,moralenjoyment,andthecomfortsaswellaslibertiesoftheworld,isscarcelyinferiortothatwithwhichtheydevotedthemselvestoHeaven。
Politicalprinciplesandallhumanlawsandinstitutionsweremouldedandalteredattheirpleasure;thebarriersofthesocietyinwhichtheywerebornwerebrokendownbeforethem;theoldprincipleswhichhadgovernedtheworldforageswerenomore;apathwithoutaturnandafieldwithoutanhorizonwereopenedtotheexploringandardentcuriosityofman:butatthelimitsofthepoliticalworldhecheckshisresearches,hediscreetlylaysasidetheuseofhismostformidablefaculties,henolongerconsentstodoubtortoinnovate,butcarefullyabstainingfromraisingthecurtainofthesanctuary,heyieldswithsubmissiverespecttotruthswhichhewillnotdiscuss。
Thus,inthemoralworldeverythingisclassed,adapted,decided,andforeseen;inthepoliticalworldeverythingisagitated,uncertain,anddisputed:intheoneisapassive,thoughavoluntary,obedience;intheotheranindependencescornfulofexperienceandjealousofauthority。
Thesetwotendencies,apparentlysodiscrepant,arefarfromconflicting;theyadvancetogether,andmutuallysupporteachother。Religionperceivesthatcivillibertyaffordsanobleexercisetothefacultiesofman,andthatthepoliticalworldisafieldpreparedbytheCreatorfortheeffortsoftheintelligence。Contentedwiththefreedomandthepowerwhichitenjoysinitsownsphere,andwiththeplacewhichitoccupies,theempireofreligionisnevermoresurelyestablishedthanwhenitreignsintheheartsofmenunsupportedbyaughtbesideitsnativestrength。Religionisnolessthecompanionoflibertyinallitsbattlesanditstriumphs;thecradleofitsinfancy,andthedivinesourceofitsclaims。Thesafeguardofmoralityisreligion,andmoralityisthebestsecurityoflawandthesurestpledgeoffreedom。*m[Footnotem:SeeAppendix,F。]
ReasonsOfCertainAnomaliesWhichTheLawsAndCustomsOfTheAnglo—AmericansPresentRemainsofaristocraticinstitutionsinthemidstofacompletedemocracy—Why?—DistinctioncarefullytobedrawnbetweenwhatisofPuritanicalandwhatisofEnglishorigin。
Thereaderiscautionednottodrawtoogeneralortooabsoluteaninferencefromwhathasbeensaid。Thesocialcondition,thereligion,andthemannersofthefirstemigrantsundoubtedlyexercisedanimmenseinfluenceonthedestinyoftheirnewcountry。Neverthelesstheywerenotinasituationtofoundastateofthingssolelydependentonthemselves:nomancanentirelyshakeofftheinfluenceofthepast,andthesettlers,intentionallyorinvoluntarily,mingledhabitsandnotionsderivedfromtheireducationandfromthetraditionsoftheircountrywiththosehabitsandnotionswhichwereexclusivelytheirown。ToformajudgmentontheAnglo—AmericansofthepresentdayitisthereforenecessarytodistinguishwhatisofPuritanicalandwhatisofEnglishorigin。
LawsandcustomsarefrequentlytobemetwithintheUnitedStateswhichcontraststronglywithallthatsurroundsthem。
TheselawsseemtobedrawnupinaspiritcontrarytotheprevailingtenoroftheAmericanlegislation;andthesecustomsarenolessopposedtothetoneofsociety。IftheEnglishcolonieshadbeenfoundedinanageofdarkness,oriftheiroriginwasalreadylostinthelapseofyears,theproblemwouldbeinsoluble。
IshallquoteasingleexampletoillustratewhatIadvance。
ThecivilandcriminalprocedureoftheAmericanshasonlytwomeansofaction—committalandbail。Thefirstmeasuretakenbythemagistrateistoexactsecurityfromthedefendant,or,incaseofrefusal,toincarceratehim:thegroundoftheaccusationandtheimportanceofthechargesagainsthimarethendiscussed。
Itisevidentthatalegislationofthiskindishostiletothepoorman,andfavorableonlytotherich。Thepoormanhasnotalwaysasecuritytoproduce,eveninacivilcause;andifheisobligedtowaitforjusticeinprison,heisspeedilyreducedtodistress。Thewealthyindividual,onthecontrary,alwaysescapesimprisonmentincivilcauses;nay,more,hemayreadilyeludethepunishmentwhichawaitshimforadelinquencybybreakinghisbail。Sothatallthepenaltiesofthelaware,forhim,reducibletofines。*nNothingcanbemorearistocraticthanthissystemoflegislation。YetinAmericaitisthepoorwhomakethelaw,andtheyusuallyreservethegreatestsocialadvantagestothemselves。TheexplanationofthephenomenonistobefoundinEngland;thelawsofwhichIspeakareEnglish,*oandtheAmericanshaveretainedthem,howeverrepugnanttheymaybetothetenoroftheirlegislationandthemassoftheirideas。
Nexttoitshabits,thethingwhichanationisleastapttochangeisitscivillegislation。Civillawsareonlyfamiliarlyknowntolegalmen,whosedirectinterestitistomaintainthemastheyare,whethergoodorbad,simplybecausetheythemselvesareconversantwiththem。Thebodyofthenationisscarcelyacquaintedwiththem;itmerelyperceivestheiractioninparticularcases;butithassomedifficultyinseizingtheirtendency,andobeysthemwithoutpremeditation。Ihavequotedoneinstancewhereitwouldhavebeeneasytoadduceagreatnumberofothers。ThesurfaceofAmericansocietyis,ifImayusetheexpression,coveredwithalayerofdemocracy,frombeneathwhichtheoldaristocraticcolorssometimespeep。
[Footnoten:Crimesnodoubtexistforwhichbailisinadmissible,buttheyarefewinnumber。]
[Footnoteo:SeeBlackstone;andDelolme,bookIchap。x。]
ChapterIII:SocialConditionsOfTheAnglo—AmericansChapterSummaryASocialconditioniscommonlytheresultofcircumstances,sometimesoflaws,oftenerstillofthesetwocausesunited;butwhereveritexists,itmayjustlybeconsideredasthesourceofalmostallthelaws,theusages,andtheideaswhichregulatetheconductofnations;whateveritdoesnotproduceitmodifies。Itisthereforenecessary,ifwewouldbecomeacquaintedwiththelegislationandthemannersofanation,tobeginbythestudyofitssocialcondition。
TheStrikingCharacteristicOfTheSocialConditionOfTheAnglo—
AmericansInItsEssentialDemocracyThefirstemigrantsofNewEngland—Theirequality—
AristocraticlawsintroducedintheSouth—PeriodoftheRevolution—Changeinthelawofdescent—Effectsproducedbythischange—DemocracycarriedtoitsutmostlimitsinthenewStatesoftheWest—Equalityofeducation。
ManyimportantobservationssuggestthemselvesuponthesocialconditionoftheAnglo—Americans,butthereisonewhichtakesprecedenceofalltherest。ThesocialconditionoftheAmericansiseminentlydemocratic;thiswasitscharacteratthefoundationoftheColonies,andisstillmorestronglymarkedatthepresentday。IhavestatedintheprecedingchapterthatgreatequalityexistedamongtheemigrantswhosettledontheshoresofNewEngland。ThegermofaristocracywasneverplantedinthatpartoftheUnion。Theonlyinfluencewhichobtainedtherewasthatofintellect;thepeoplewereusedtoreverencecertainnamesastheemblemsofknowledgeandvirtue。Someoftheirfellow—citizensacquiredapowerovertherestwhichmighttrulyhavebeencalledaristocratic,ifithadbeencapableoftransmissionfromfathertoson。
ThiswasthestateofthingstotheeastoftheHudson:tothesouth—westofthatriver,andinthedirectionoftheFloridas,thecasewasdifferent。InmostoftheStatessituatedtothesouth—westoftheHudsonsomegreatEnglishproprietorshadsettled,whohadimportedwiththemaristocraticprinciplesandtheEnglishlawofdescent。IhaveexplainedthereasonswhyitwasimpossibleevertoestablishapowerfularistocracyinAmerica;thesereasonsexistedwithlessforcetothesouth—westoftheHudson。IntheSouth,oneman,aidedbyslaves,couldcultivateagreatextentofcountry:itwasthereforecommontoseerichlandedproprietors。ButtheirinfluencewasnotaltogetheraristocraticasthattermisunderstoodinEurope,sincetheypossessednoprivileges;andthecultivationoftheirestatesbeingcarriedonbyslaves,theyhadnotenantsdependingonthem,andconsequentlynopatronage。Still,thegreatproprietorssouthoftheHudsonconstitutedasuperiorclass,havingideasandtastesofitsown,andformingthecentreofpoliticalaction。Thiskindofaristocracysympathizedwiththebodyofthepeople,whosepassionsandinterestsiteasilyembraced;butitwastooweakandtooshort—livedtoexciteeitherloveorhatredforitself。ThiswastheclasswhichheadedtheinsurrectionintheSouth,andfurnishedthebestleadersoftheAmericanrevolution。
Attheperiodofwhichwearenowspeakingsocietywasshakentoitscentre:thepeople,inwhosenamethestrugglehadtakenplace,conceivedthedesireofexercisingtheauthoritywhichithadacquired;itsdemocratictendencieswereawakened;
andhavingthrownofftheyokeofthemother—country,itaspiredtoindependenceofeverykind。Theinfluenceofindividualsgraduallyceasedtobefelt,andcustomandlawunitedtogethertoproducethesameresult。
Butthelawofdescentwasthelaststeptoequality。Iamsurprisedthatancientandmodernjuristshavenotattributedtothislawagreaterinfluenceonhumanaffairs。*aItistruethattheselawsbelongtocivilaffairs;buttheyoughtneverthelesstobeplacedattheheadofallpoliticalinstitutions;for,whilstpoliticallawsareonlythesymbolofanation’scondition,theyexerciseanincredibleinfluenceuponitssocialstate。Theyhave,moreover,asureanduniformmannerofoperatinguponsociety,affecting,asitwere,generationsyetunborn。
[Footnotea:Iunderstandbythelawofdescentallthoselawswhoseprincipalobjectistoregulatethedistributionofpropertyafterthedeathofitsowner。Thelawofentailisofthisnumber;itcertainlypreventstheownerfromdisposingofhispossessionsbeforehisdeath;butthisissolelywiththeviewofpreservingthementirefortheheir。Theprincipalobject,therefore,ofthelawofentailistoregulatethedescentofpropertyafterthedeathofitsowner:itsotherprovisionsaremerelymeanstothisend。]
Throughtheirmeansmanacquiresakindofpreternaturalpoweroverthefuturelotofhisfellow—creatures。Whenthelegislatorhasregulatedthelawofinheritance,hemayrestfromhislabor。Themachineonceputinmotionwillgoonforages,andadvance,asifself—guided,towardsagivenpoint。Whenframedinaparticularmanner,thislawunites,drawstogether,andvestspropertyandpowerinafewhands:itstendencyisclearlyaristocratic。Onoppositeprinciplesitsactionisstillmorerapid;itdivides,distributes,anddispersesbothpropertyandpower。Alarmedbytherapidityofitsprogress,thosewhodespairofarrestingitsmotionendeavortoobstructitbydifficultiesandimpediments;theyvainlyseektocounteractitseffectbycontraryefforts;butitgraduallyreducesordestroyseveryobstacle,untilbyitsincessantactivitythebulwarksoftheinfluenceofwealtharegrounddowntothefineandshiftingsandwhichisthebasisofdemocracy。Whenthelawofinheritancepermits,stillmorewhenitdecrees,theequaldivisionofafather’spropertyamongstallhischildren,itseffectsareoftwokinds:itisimportanttodistinguishthemfromeachother,althoughtheytendtothesameend。
Invirtueofthelawofpartibleinheritance,thedeathofeveryproprietorbringsaboutakindofrevolutioninproperty;
notonlydohispossessionschangehands,buttheirverynatureisaltered,sincetheyareparcelledintoshares,whichbecomesmallerandsmallerateachdivision。Thisisthedirectand,asitwere,thephysicaleffectofthelaw。Itfollows,then,thatincountrieswhereequalityofinheritanceisestablishedbylaw,property,andespeciallylandedproperty,musthaveatendencytoperpetualdiminution。Theeffects,however,ofsuchlegislationwouldonlybeperceptibleafteralapseoftime,ifthelawwasabandonedtoitsownworking;forsupposingthefamilytoconsistoftwochildren(andinacountrypeopleasFranceistheaveragenumberisnotabovethree),thesechildren,sharingamongstthemthefortuneofbothparents,wouldnotbepoorerthantheirfatherormother。
Butthelawofequaldivisionexercisesitsinfluencenotmerelyuponthepropertyitself,butitaffectsthemindsoftheheirs,andbringstheirpassionsintoplay。Theseindirectconsequencestendpowerfullytothedestructionoflargefortunes,andespeciallyoflargedomains。Amongnationswhoselawofdescentisfoundedupontherightofprimogeniturelandedestatesoftenpassfromgenerationtogenerationwithoutundergoingdivision,theconsequenceofwhichisthatfamilyfeelingistoacertaindegreeincorporatedwiththeestate。Thefamilyrepresentstheestate,theestatethefamily;whosename,togetherwithitsorigin,itsglory,itspower,anditsvirtues,isthusperpetuatedinanimperishablememorialofthepastandasurepledgeofthefuture。
Whentheequalpartitionofpropertyisestablishedbylaw,theintimateconnectionisdestroyedbetweenfamilyfeelingandthepreservationofthepaternalestate;thepropertyceasestorepresentthefamily;forasitmustinevitablybedividedafteroneortwogenerations,ithasevidentlyaconstanttendencytodiminish,andmustintheendbecompletelydispersed。Thesonsofthegreatlandedproprietor,iftheyarefewinnumber,oriffortunebefriendsthem,mayindeedentertainthehopeofbeingaswealthyastheirfather,butnotthatofpossessingthesamepropertyashedid;therichesmustnecessarilybecomposedofelementsdifferentfromhis。
Now,fromthemomentthatyoudivestthelandownerofthatinterestinthepreservationofhisestatewhichhederivesfromassociation,fromtradition,andfromfamilypride,youmaybecertainthatsoonerorlaterhewilldisposeofit;forthereisastrongpecuniaryinterestinfavorofselling,asfloatingcapitalproduceshigherinterestthanrealproperty,andismorereadilyavailabletogratifythepassionsofthemoment。
Greatlandedestateswhichhaveoncebeendividednevercometogetheragain;forthesmallproprietordrawsfromhislandabetterrevenue,inproportion,thanthelargeownerdoesfromhis,andofcoursehesellsitatahigherrate。*bThecalculationsofgain,therefore,whichdecidetherichmantosellhisdomainwillstillmorepowerfullyinfluencehimagainstbuyingsmallestatestounitethemintoalargeone。
[Footnoteb:Idonotmeantosaythatthesmallproprietorcultivateshislandbetter,buthecultivatesitwithmoreardorandcare;sothathemakesupbyhislaborforhiswantofskill。]
Whatiscalledfamilyprideisoftenfoundeduponanillusionofself—love。Amanwishestoperpetuateandimmortalizehimself,asitwere,inhisgreat—grandchildren。
Wheretheespritdefamilleceasestoactindividualselfishnesscomesintoplay。Whentheideaoffamilybecomesvague,indeterminate,anduncertain,amanthinksofhispresentconvenience;heprovidesfortheestablishmentofhissucceedinggeneration,andnomore。Eitheramangivesuptheideaofperpetuatinghisfamily,oratanyrateheseekstoaccomplishitbyothermeansthanthatofalandedestate。Thusnotonlydoesthelawofpartibleinheritancerenderitdifficultforfamiliestopreservetheirancestraldomainsentire,butitdeprivesthemoftheinclinationtoattemptit,andcompelstheminsomemeasuretoco—operatewiththelawintheirownextinction。
Thelawofequaldistributionproceedsbytwomethods:byactinguponthings,itactsuponpersons;byinfluencingpersons,itaffectsthings。Bythesemeansthelawsucceedsinstrikingattherootoflandedproperty,anddispersingrapidlybothfamiliesandfortunes。*c[Footnotec:Landbeingthemoststablekindofproperty,wefind,fromtimetotime,richindividualswhoaredisposedtomakegreatsacrificesinordertoobtainit,andwhowillinglyforfeitaconsiderablepartoftheirincometomakesureoftherest。Buttheseareaccidentalcases。Thepreferenceforlandedpropertyisnolongerfoundhabituallyinanyclassbutamongthepoor。Thesmalllandowner,whohaslessinformation,lessimagination,andfewerpassionsthanthegreatone,isgenerallyoccupiedwiththedesireofincreasinghisestate:anditoftenhappensthatbyinheritance,bymarriage,orbythechancesoftrade,heisgraduallyfurnishedwiththemeans。Thus,tobalancethetendencywhichleadsmentodividetheirestates,thereexistsanother,whichincitesthemtoaddtothem。Thistendency,whichissufficienttopreventestatesfrombeingdividedadinfinitum,isnotstrongenoughtocreategreatterritorialpossessions,certainlynottokeepthemupinthesamefamily。]
MostcertainlyitisnotforusFrenchmenofthenineteenthcentury,whodailywitnessthepoliticalandsocialchangeswhichthelawofpartitionisbringingtopass,toquestionitsinfluence。Itisperpetuallyconspicuousinourcountry,overthrowingthewallsofourdwellingsandremovingthelandmarksofourfields。ButalthoughithasproducedgreateffectsinFrance,muchstillremainsforittodo。Ourrecollections,opinions,andhabitspresentpowerfulobstaclestoitsprogress。
IntheUnitedStatesithasnearlycompleteditsworkofdestruction,andtherewecanbeststudyitsresults。TheEnglishlawsconcerningthetransmissionofpropertywereabolishedinalmostalltheStatesatthetimeoftheRevolution。
Thelawofentailwassomodifiedasnottointerruptthefreecirculationofproperty。*dThefirstgenerationhavingpassedaway,estatesbegantobeparcelledout,andthechangebecamemoreandmorerapidwiththeprogressoftime。Atthismoment,afteralapseofalittlemorethansixtyyears,theaspectofsocietyistotallyaltered;thefamiliesofthegreatlandedproprietorsarealmostallcommingledwiththegeneralmass。IntheStateofNewYork,whichformerlycontainedmanyofthese,therearebuttwowhostillkeeptheirheadsabovethestream,andtheymustshortlydisappear。Thesonsoftheseopulentcitizensarebecomemerchants,lawyers,orphysicians。Mostofthemhavelapsedintoobscurity。Thelasttraceofhereditaryranksanddistinctionsisdestroyed—thelawofpartitionhasreducedalltoonelevel。[Footnoted:SeeAppendix,G。]