TheConstitutionoftheUnitedStatesislikethoseexquisiteproductionsofhumanindustrywhichensurewealthandrenowntotheirinventors,butwhichareprofitlessinanyotherhands。ThistruthisexemplifiedbytheconditionofMexicoatthepresenttime。TheMexicansweredesirousofestablishingafederalsystem,andtheytooktheFederalConstitutionoftheirneighbors,theAnglo—Americans,astheirmodel,andcopieditwithconsiderableaccuracy。*sButalthoughtheyhadborrowedtheletterofthelaw,theywereunabletocreateortointroducethespiritandthesensewhichgiveitlife。Theywereinvolvedinceaselessembarrassmentsbetweenthemechanismoftheirdoublegovernment;thesovereigntyoftheStatesandthatoftheUnionperpetuallyexceededtheirrespectiveprivileges,andenteredintocollision;andtothepresentdayMexicoisalternatelythevictimofanarchyandtheslaveofmilitarydespotism。
[Footnotes:SeetheMexicanConstitutionof1824。]
ThesecondandthemostfatalofallthedefectsIhavealludedto,andthatwhichIbelievetobeinherentinthefederalsystem,istherelativeweaknessofthegovernmentoftheUnion。Theprincipleuponwhichallconfederationsrestisthatofadividedsovereignty。Thelegislatormayrenderthispartitionlessperceptible,hemayevenconcealitforatimefromthepubliceye,buthecannotpreventitfromexisting,andadividedsovereigntymustalwaysbelesspowerfulthananentiresupremacy。ThereaderhasseenintheremarksIhavemadeontheConstitutionoftheUnitedStatesthattheAmericanshavedisplayedsingularingenuityincombiningtherestrictionofthepoweroftheUnionwithinthenarrowlimitsofafederalgovernmentwiththesemblanceand,toacertainextent,withtheforceofanationalgovernment。BythismeansthelegislatorsoftheUnionhavesucceededindiminishing,thoughnotincounteractingthenaturaldangerofconfederations。
IthasbeenremarkedthattheAmericanGovernmentdoesnotapplyitselftotheStates,butthatitimmediatelytransmitsitsinjunctionstothecitizens,andcompelsthemasisolatedindividualstocomplywithitsdemands。ButiftheFederallawweretoclashwiththeinterestsandtheprejudicesofaState,itmightbefearedthatallthecitizensofthatStatewouldconceivethemselvestobeinterestedinthecauseofasingleindividualwhoshouldrefusetoobey。IfallthecitizensoftheStatewereaggrievedatthesametimeandinthesamemannerbytheauthorityoftheUnion,theFederalGovernmentwouldvainlyattempttosubduethemindividually;theywouldinstinctivelyuniteinacommondefence,andtheywouldderiveaready—preparedorganizationfromtheshareofsovereigntywhichtheinstitutionoftheirStateallowsthemtoenjoy。Fictionwouldgivewaytoreality,andanorganizedportionoftheterritorymightthencontestthecentralauthority。*tThesameobservationholdsgoodwithregardtotheFederaljurisdiction。IfthecourtsoftheUnionviolatedanimportantlawofaStateinaprivatecase,thereal,ifnottheapparent,contestwouldarisebetweentheaggrievedStaterepresentedbyacitizenandtheUnionrepresentedbyitscourtsofjustice。*u[Footnotet:[Thisispreciselywhatoccurredin1862,andthefollowingparagraphdescribescorrectlythefeelingsandnotionsoftheSouth。GeneralLeeheldthathisprimaryallegiancewasdue,nottotheUnion,buttoVirginia。]]
[Footnoteu:Forinstance,theUnionpossessesbytheConstitutiontherightofsellingunoccupiedlandsforitsownprofit。SupposingthattheStateofOhioshouldclaimthesamerightinbehalfofcertainterritorieslyingwithinitsboundaries,uponthepleathattheConstitutionreferstothoselandsalonewhichdonotbelongtothejurisdictionofanyparticularState,andconsequentlyshouldchoosetodisposeofthemitself,thelitigationwouldbecarriedoninthenamesofthepurchasersfromtheStateofOhioandthepurchasersfromtheUnion,andnotinthenamesofOhioandtheUnion。ButwhatwouldbecomeofthislegalfictioniftheFederalpurchaserwasconfirmedinhisrightbythecourtsoftheUnion,whilsttheothercompetitorwasorderedtoretainpossessionbythetribunalsoftheStateofOhio?]
Hewouldhavebutapartialknowledgeoftheworldwhoshouldimaginethatitispossible,bytheaidoflegalfictions,topreventmenfromfindingoutandemployingthosemeansofgratifyingtheirpassionswhichhavebeenleftopentothem;anditmaybedoubtedwhethertheAmericanlegislators,whentheyrenderedacollisionbetweenthetwosovereignslessprobable,destroyedthecauseofsuchamisfortune。ButitmayevenbeaffirmedthattheywereunabletoensurethepreponderanceoftheFederalelementinacaseofthiskind。TheUnionispossessedofmoneyandoftroops,buttheaffectionsandtheprejudicesofthepeopleareinthebosomoftheStates。ThesovereigntyoftheUnionisanabstractbeing,whichisconnectedwithbutfewexternalobjects;thesovereigntyoftheStatesishourlyperceptible,easilyunderstood,constantlyactive;andiftheformerisofrecentcreation,thelatteriscoevalwiththepeopleitself。ThesovereigntyoftheUnionisfactitious,thatoftheStatesisnatural,andderivesitsexistencefromitsownsimpleinfluence,liketheauthorityofaparent。Thesupremepowerofthenationonlyaffectsafewofthechiefinterestsofsociety;itrepresentsanimmensebutremotecountry,andclaimsafeelingofpatriotismwhichisvagueandilldefined;buttheauthorityoftheStatescontrolseveryindividualcitizenateveryhourandinallcircumstances;itprotectshisproperty,hisfreedom,andhislife;andwhenwerecollectthetraditions,thecustoms,theprejudicesoflocalandfamiliarattachmentwithwhichitisconnected,wecannotdoubtofthesuperiorityofapowerwhichisinterwovenwitheverycircumstancethatrenderstheloveofone’snativecountryinstinctiveinthehumanheart。
Sincelegislatorsareunabletoobviatesuchdangerouscollisionsasoccurbetweenthetwosovereigntieswhichcoexistinthefederalsystem,theirfirstobjectmustbe,notonlytodissuadetheconfederateStatesfromwarfare,buttoencouragesuchinstitutionsasmaypromotethemaintenanceofpeace。HenceitresultsthattheFederalcompactcannotbelastingunlessthereexistsinthecommunitieswhichareleaguedtogetheracertainnumberofinducementstounionwhichrendertheircommondependenceagreeable,andthetaskoftheGovernmentlight,andthatsystemcannotsucceedwithoutthepresenceoffavorablecircumstancesaddedtotheinfluenceofgoodlaws。Allthepeopleswhichhaveeverformedaconfederationhavebeenheldtogetherbyacertainnumberofcommoninterests,whichservedastheintellectualtiesofassociation。
Butthesentimentsandtheprinciplesofmanmustbetakenintoconsiderationaswellashisimmediateinterests。AcertainuniformityofcivilizationisnotlessnecessarytothedurabilityofaconfederationthanauniformityofinterestsintheStateswhichcomposeit。InSwitzerlandthedifferencewhichexistsbetweentheCantonofUriandtheCantonofVaudisequaltothatbetweenthefifteenthandthenineteenthcenturies;and,properlyspeaking,Switzerlandhasneverpossessedafederalgovernment。Theunionbetweenthesetwocantonsonlysubsistsuponthemap,andtheirdiscrepancieswouldsoonbeperceivedifanattemptweremadebyacentralauthoritytoprescribethesamelawstothewholeterritory。
OneofthecircumstanceswhichmostpowerfullycontributetosupporttheFederalGovernmentinAmericaisthattheStateshavenotonlysimilarinterests,acommonorigin,andacommontongue,butthattheyarealsoarrivedatthesamestageofcivilization;
whichalmostalwaysrendersaunionfeasible。IdonotknowofanyEuropeannation,howsmallsoeveritmaybe,whichdoesnotpresentlessuniformityinitsdifferentprovincesthantheAmericanpeople,whichoccupiesaterritoryasextensiveasone—halfofEurope。ThedistancefromtheStateofMainetothatofGeorgiaisreckonedataboutonethousandmiles;butthedifferencebetweenthecivilizationofMaineandthatofGeorgiaisslighterthanthedifferencebetweenthehabitsofNormandyandthoseofBrittany。MaineandGeorgia,whichareplacedattheoppositeextremitiesofagreatempire,areconsequentlyinthenaturalpossessionofmorerealinducementstoformaconfederationthanNormandyandBrittany,whichareonlyseparatedbyabridge。
ThegeographicalpositionofthecountrycontributedtoincreasethefacilitieswhichtheAmericanlegislatorsderivedfromthemannersandcustomsoftheinhabitants;anditistothiscircumstancethattheadoptionandthemaintenanceoftheFederalsystemaremainlyattributable。
Themostimportantoccurrencewhichcanmarktheannalsofapeopleisthebreakingoutofawar。Inwarapeoplestruggleswiththeenergyofasinglemanagainstforeignnationsinthedefenceofitsveryexistence。Theskillofagovernment,thegoodsenseofthecommunity,andthenaturalfondnesswhichmenentertainfortheircountry,maysufficetomaintainpeaceintheinteriorofadistrict,andtofavoritsinternalprosperity;butanationcanonlycarryonagreatwaratthecostofmorenumerousandmorepainfulsacrifices;andtosupposethatagreatnumberofmenwilloftheirownaccordcomplywiththeseexigenciesoftheStateistobetrayanignoranceofmankind。
Allthepeopleswhichhavebeenobligedtosustainalongandseriouswarfarehaveconsequentlybeenledtoaugmentthepoweroftheirgovernment。Thosewhichhavenotsucceededinthisattempthavebeensubjugated。Alongwaralmostalwaysplacesnationsinthewretchedalternativeofbeingabandonedtoruinbydefeatortodespotismbysuccess。Warthereforerendersthesymptomsoftheweaknessofagovernmentmostpalpableandmostalarming;andIhaveshownthattheinherentdefeatoffederalgovernmentsisthatofbeingweak。
TheFederalsystemisnotonlydeficientineverykindofcentralizedadministration,butthecentralgovernmentitselfisimperfectlyorganized,whichisinvariablyaninfluentialcauseofinferioritywhenthenationisopposedtoothercountrieswhicharethemselvesgovernedbyasingleauthority。IntheFederalConstitutionoftheUnitedStates,bywhichthecentralgovernmentpossessesmorerealforce,thisevilisstillextremelysensible。Anexamplewillillustratethecasetothereader。
TheConstitutionconfersuponCongresstherightofcallingforthmilitiatoexecutethelawsoftheUnion,suppressinsurrections,andrepelinvasions;andanotherarticledeclaresthatthePresidentoftheUnitedStatesisthecommander—in—chiefofthemilitia。Inthewarof1812thePresidentorderedthemilitiaoftheNorthernStatestomarchtothefrontiers;butConnecticutandMassachusetts,whoseinterestswereimpairedbythewar,refusedtoobeythecommand。TheyarguedthattheConstitutionauthorizestheFederalGovernmenttocallforththemilitiaincaseofinsurrectionorinvasion,butthatinthepresentinstancetherewasneitherinvasionnorinsurrection。
Theyadded,thatthesameConstitutionwhichconferredupontheUniontherightofcallingforththemilitiareservedtotheStatesthatofnamingtheofficers;andthatconsequently(astheyunderstoodtheclause)noofficeroftheUnionhadanyrighttocommandthemilitia,evenduringwar,exceptthePresidentinperson;andinthiscasetheywereorderedtojoinanarmycommandedbyanotherindividual。Theseabsurdandperniciousdoctrinesreceivedthesanctionnotonlyofthegovernorsandthelegislativebodies,butalsoofthecourtsofjusticeinbothStates;andtheFederalGovernmentwasconstrainedtoraiseelsewherethetroopswhichitrequired。*v[Footnotev:Kent’s"Commentaries,"vol。i。p。244。IhaveselectedanexamplewhichrelatestoatimeposteriortothepromulgationofthepresentConstitution。IfIhadgonebacktothedaysoftheConfederation,Imighthavegivenstillmorestrikinginstances。Thewholenationwasatthattimeinastateofenthusiasticexcitement;theRevolutionwasrepresentedbyamanwhowastheidolofthepeople;butatthatveryperiodCongresshad,tosaythetruth,noresourcesatallatitsdisposal。Troopsandsupplieswereperpetuallywanting。Thebest—devisedprojectsfailedintheexecution,andtheUnion,whichwasconstantlyonthevergeofdestruction,wassavedbytheweaknessofitsenemiesfarmorethanbyitsownstrength。
[AlldoubtastothepowersoftheFederalExecutivewas,however,removedbyitseffortsintheCivilWar,andthosepowerswerelargelyextended。]]
TheonlysafeguardwhichtheAmericanUnion,withalltherelativeperfectionofitslaws,possessesagainstthedissolutionwhichwouldbeproducedbyagreatwar,liesinitsprobableexemptionfromthatcalamity。Placedinthecentreofanimmensecontinent,whichoffersaboundlessfieldforhumanindustry,theUnionisalmostasmuchinsulatedfromtheworldasifitsfrontiersweregirtbytheocean。Canadacontainsonlyamillionofinhabitants,anditspopulationisdividedintotwoinimicalnations。Therigoroftheclimatelimitstheextensionofitsterritory,andshutsupitsportsduringthesixmonthsofwinter。FromCanadatotheGulfofMexicoafewsavagetribesaretobemetwith,whichretire,perishingintheirretreat,beforesixthousandsoldiers。TotheSouth,theUnionhasapointofcontactwiththeempireofMexico;anditisthencethatserioushostilitiesmayonedaybeexpectedtoarise。ButforalongwhiletocometheuncivilizedstateoftheMexicancommunity,thedepravityofitsmorals,anditsextremepoverty,willpreventthatcountryfromrankinghighamongstnations。*wAsforthePowersofEurope,theyaretoodistanttobeformidable。
[Footnotew:[WarbrokeoutbetweentheUnitedStatesandMexicoin1846,andendedintheconquestofanimmenseterritory,includingCalifornia。]]
ThegreatadvantageoftheUnitedStatesdoesnot,then,consistinaFederalConstitutionwhichallowsthemtocarryongreatwars,butinageographicalpositionwhichrenderssuchenterprisesextremelyimprobable。
NoonecanbemoreinclinedthanIammyselftoappreciatetheadvantagesofthefederalsystem,whichIholdtobeoneofthecombinationsmostfavorabletotheprosperityandfreedomofman。Ienvythelotofthosenationswhichhavebeenenabledtoadoptit;butIcannotbelievethatanyconfederatepeoplescouldmaintainalongoranequalcontestwithanationofsimilarstrengthinwhichthegovernmentshouldbecentralized。Apeoplewhichshoulddivideitssovereigntyintofractionalpowers,inthepresenceofthegreatmilitarymonarchiesofEurope,would,inmyopinion,bythatveryact,abdicateitspower,andperhapsitsexistenceanditsname。ButsuchistheadmirablepositionoftheNewWorldthatmanhasnootherenemythanhimself;andthat,inordertobehappyandtobefree,itsufficestoseekthegiftsofprosperityandtheknowledgeoffreedom。
ChapterXI:WhyThePeopleMayStrictlyBeSaidToGovernInTheUnitedStatesIhavehithertoexaminedtheinstitutionsoftheUnitedStates;Ihavepassedtheirlegislationinreview,andIhavedepictedthepresentcharacteristicsofpoliticalsocietyinthatcountry。Butasovereignpowerexistsabovetheseinstitutionsandbeyondthesecharacteristicfeatureswhichmaydestroyormodifythematitspleasure—Imeanthatofthepeople。Itremainstobeshowninwhatmannerthispower,whichregulatesthelaws,acts:itspropensitiesanditspassionsremaintobepointedout,aswellasthesecretspringswhichretard,accelerate,ordirectitsirresistiblecourse;andtheeffectsofitsunboundedauthority,withthedestinywhichisprobablyreservedforit。
ChapterX:WhyThePeopleMayStrictlyBeSaidToGovernInTheUnitedStatesInAmericathepeopleappointsthelegislativeandtheexecutivepower,andfurnishesthejurorswhopunishalloffencesagainstthelaws。TheAmericaninstitutionsaredemocratic,notonlyintheirprinciplebutinalltheirconsequences;andthepeopleelectsitsrepresentativesdirectly,andforthemostpartannually,inordertoensuretheirdependence。Thepeopleisthereforetherealdirectingpower;andalthoughtheformofgovernmentisrepresentative,itisevidentthattheopinions,theprejudices,theinterests,andeventhepassionsofthecommunityarehinderedbynodurableobstaclesfromexercisingaperpetualinfluenceonsociety。IntheUnitedStatesthemajoritygovernsinthenameofthepeople,asisthecaseinallthecountriesinwhichthepeopleissupreme。Themajorityisprincipallycomposedofpeacefulcitizenswho,eitherbyinclinationorbyinterest,aresincerelydesirousofthewelfareoftheircountry。Buttheyaresurroundedbytheincessantagitationofparties,whichattempttogaintheirco—operationandtoavailthemselvesoftheirsupport。
ChapterX:PartiesInTheUnitedStatesChapterSummaryGreatdistinctiontobemadebetweenparties—Partieswhicharetoeachotherasrivalnations—Partiesproperlysocalled—
Differencebetweengreatandsmallparties—Epochswhichproducethem—Theircharacteristics—Americahashadgreatparties—
Theyareextinct—Federalists—Republicans—DefeatoftheFederalists—DifficultyofcreatingpartiesintheUnitedStates—Whatisdonewiththisintention—Aristocraticordemocraticcharactertobemetwithinallparties—StruggleofGeneralJacksonagainsttheBank。
PartiesInTheUnitedStatesAgreatdistinctionmustbemadebetweenparties。Somecountriesaresolargethatthedifferentpopulationswhichinhabitthemhavecontradictoryinterests,althoughtheyarethesubjectsofthesameGovernment,andtheymaythencebeinaperpetualstateofopposition。Inthiscasethedifferentfractionsofthepeoplemaymoreproperlybeconsideredasdistinctnationsthanasmereparties;andifacivilwarbreaksout,thestruggleiscarriedonbyrivalpeoplesratherthanbyfactionsintheState。
Butwhenthecitizensentertaindifferentopinionsuponsubjectswhichaffectthewholecountryalike,such,forinstance,astheprinciplesuponwhichthegovernmentistobeconducted,thendistinctionsarisewhichmaycorrectlybestyledparties。Partiesareanecessaryevilinfreegovernments;buttheyhavenotatalltimesthesamecharacterandthesamepropensities。
Atcertainperiodsanationmaybeoppressedbysuchinsupportableevilsastoconceivethedesignofeffectingatotalchangeinitspoliticalconstitution;atothertimesthemischiefliesstilldeeper,andtheexistenceofsocietyitselfisendangered。Sucharethetimesofgreatrevolutionsandofgreatparties。Butbetweentheseepochsofmiseryandofconfusionthereareperiodsduringwhichhumansocietyseemstorest,andmankindtomakeapause。Thispauseis,indeed,onlyapparent,fortimedoesnotstopitscoursefornationsanymorethanformen;theyarealladvancingtowardsagoalwithwhichtheyareunacquainted;andweonlyimaginethemtobestationarywhentheirprogressescapesourobservation,asmenwhoaregoingatafoot—paceseemtobestandingstilltothosewhorun。
Buthoweverthismaybe,therearecertainepochsatwhichthechangesthattakeplaceinthesocialandpoliticalconstitutionofnationsaresoslowandsoinsensiblethatmenimaginetheirpresentconditiontobeafinalstate;andthehumanmind,believingitselftobefirmlybaseduponcertainfoundations,doesnotextenditsresearchesbeyondthehorizonwhichitdescries。Thesearethetimesofsmallpartiesandofintrigue。
ThepoliticalpartieswhichIstylegreatarethosewhichclingtoprinciplesmorethantotheirconsequences;togeneral,andnottoespecialcases;toideas,andnottomen。Thesepartiesareusuallydistinguishedbyanoblercharacter,bymoregenerouspassions,moregenuineconvictions,andamoreboldandopenconductthantheothers。Inthemprivateinterest,whichalwaysplaysthechiefpartinpoliticalpassions,ismorestudiouslyveiledunderthepretextofthepublicgood;anditmayevenbesometimesconcealedfromtheeyesoftheverypersonswhomitexcitesandimpels。
Minorpartiesare,ontheotherhand,generallydeficientinpoliticalfaith。Astheyarenotsustainedordignifiedbyaloftypurpose,theyostensiblydisplaytheegotismoftheircharacterintheiractions。Theyglowwithafactitiouszeal;
theirlanguageisvehement,buttheirconductistimidandirresolute。Themeanstheyemployareaswretchedastheendatwhichtheyaim。Henceitarisesthatwhenacalmstateofthingssucceedsaviolentrevolution,theleadersofsocietyseemsuddenlytodisappear,andthepowersofthehumanmindtolieconcealed。Societyisconvulsedbygreatparties,byminoronesitisagitated;itistornbytheformer,bythelatteritisdegraded;andifthesesometimessaveitbyasalutaryperturbation,thoseinvariablydisturbittonogoodend。
Americahasalreadylostthegreatpartieswhichoncedividedthenation;andifherhappinessisconsiderablyincreased,hermoralityhassufferedbytheirextinction。WhentheWarofIndependencewasterminated,andthefoundationsofthenewGovernmentweretobelaiddown,thenationwasdividedbetweentwoopinions—twoopinionswhichareasoldastheworld,andwhichareperpetuallytobemetwithunderalltheformsandallthenameswhichhaveeverobtainedinfreecommunities—theonetendingtolimit,theothertoextendindefinitely,thepowerofthepeople。TheconflictofthesetwoopinionsneverassumedthatdegreeofviolenceinAmericawhichithasfrequentlydisplayedelsewhere。BothpartiesoftheAmericanswere,infact,agreeduponthemostessentialpoints;
andneitherofthemhadtodestroyatraditionaryconstitution,ortooverthrowthestructureofsociety,inordertoensureitsowntriumph。Inneitherofthem,consequently,wereagreatnumberofprivateinterestsaffectedbysuccessorbydefeat;butmoralprinciplesofahighorder,suchastheloveofequalityandofindependence,wereconcernedinthestruggle,andtheysufficedtokindleviolentpassions。
ThepartywhichdesiredtolimitthepowerofthepeopleendeavoredtoapplyitsdoctrinesmoreespeciallytotheConstitutionoftheUnion,whenceitderiveditsnameofFederal。
Theotherparty,whichaffectedtobemoreexclusivelyattachedtothecauseofliberty,tookthatofRepublican。Americaisalandofdemocracy,andtheFederalistswerealwaysinaminority;
buttheyreckonedontheirsidealmostallthegreatmenwhohadbeencalledforthbytheWarofIndependence,andtheirmoralinfluencewasveryconsiderable。Theircausewas,moreover,favoredbycircumstances。TheruinoftheConfederationhadimpressedthepeoplewithadreadofanarchy,andtheFederalistsdidnotfailtoprofitbythistransientdispositionofthemultitude。Fortenortwelveyearstheywereattheheadofaffairs,andtheywereabletoapplysome,thoughnotall,oftheirprinciples;forthehostilecurrentwasbecomingfromdaytodaytooviolenttobecheckedorstemmed。In1801theRepublicansgotpossessionoftheGovernment;ThomasJeffersonwasnamedPresident;andheincreasedtheinfluenceoftheirpartybytheweightofhiscelebrity,thegreatnessofhistalents,andtheimmenseextentofhispopularity。
ThemeansbywhichtheFederalistshadmaintainedtheirpositionwereartificial,andtheirresourcesweretemporary;itwasbythevirtuesorthetalentsoftheirleadersthattheyhadrisentopower。WhentheRepublicansattainedtothatloftystation,theiropponentswereoverwhelmedbyutterdefeat。Animmensemajoritydeclareditselfagainsttheretiringparty,andtheFederalistsfoundthemselvesinsosmallaminoritythattheyatoncedespairedoftheirfuturesuccess。FromthatmomenttheRepublicanorDemocraticparty*ahasproceededfromconquesttoconquest,untilithasacquiredabsolutesupremacyinthecountry。TheFederalists,perceivingthattheywerevanquishedwithoutresource,andisolatedinthemidstofthenation,fellintotwodivisions,ofwhichonejoinedthevictoriousRepublicans,andtheotherabandoneditsrallying—pointanditsname。Manyyearshavealreadyelapsedsincetheyceasedtoexistasaparty。
[Footnotea:[Itisscarcelynecessarytoremarkthatinmorerecenttimesthesignificationofthesetermshaschanged。TheRepublicansaretherepresentativesoftheoldFederalists,andtheDemocratsoftheoldRepublicans。—Trans。Note(1861)。]]TheaccessionoftheFederaliststopowerwas,inmyopinion,oneofthemostfortunateincidentswhichaccompaniedtheformationofthegreatAmericanUnion;theyresistedtheinevitablepropensitiesoftheirageandofthecountry。Butwhethertheirtheoriesweregoodorbad,theyhadtheeffectofbeinginapplicable,asasystem,tothesocietywhichtheyprofessedtogovern,andthatwhichoccurredundertheauspicesofJeffersonmustthereforehavetakenplacesoonerorlater。ButtheirGovernmentgavethenewrepublictimetoacquireacertainstability,andafterwardstosupporttherapidgrowthoftheverydoctrineswhichtheyhadcombated。Aconsiderablenumberoftheirprincipleswereinpointoffactembodiedinthepoliticalcreedoftheiropponents;andtheFederalConstitutionwhichsubsistsatthepresentdayisalastingmonumentoftheirpatriotismandtheirwisdom。
Greatpoliticalpartiesarenot,then,tobemetwithintheUnitedStatesatthepresenttime。Parties,indeed,maybefoundwhichthreatenthefuturetranquillityoftheUnion;buttherearenonewhichseemtocontestthepresentformofGovernmentorthepresentcourseofsociety。ThepartiesbywhichtheUnionismenaceddonotrestuponabstractprinciples,butupontemporalinterests。Theseinterests,disseminatedintheprovincesofsovastanempire,maybesaidtoconstituterivalnationsratherthanparties。Thus,uponarecentoccasion,theNorthcontendedforthesystemofcommercialprohibition,andtheSouthtookuparmsinfavoroffreetrade,simplybecausetheNorthisamanufacturingandtheSouthanagriculturaldistrict;andthattherestrictivesystemwhichwasprofitabletotheonewasprejudicialtotheother。*b[Footnoteb:[ThedivisionsofNorthandSouthhavesinceacquiredafargreaterdegreeofintensity,andtheSouth,thoughconquered,stillpresentsaformidablespiritofoppositiontoNortherngovernment。—Translator’sNote,1875。]]
Intheabsenceofgreatparties,theUnitedStatesaboundwithlessercontroversies;andpublicopinionisdividedintoathousandminuteshadesofdifferenceuponquestionsofverylittlemoment。Thepainswhicharetakentocreatepartiesareinconceivable,andatthepresentdayitisnoeasytask。IntheUnitedStatesthereisnoreligiousanimosity,becauseallreligionisrespected,andnosectispredominant;thereisnojealousyofrank,becausethepeopleiseverything,andnonecancontestitsauthority;lastly,thereisnopublicindigencetosupplythemeansofagitation,becausethephysicalpositionofthecountryopenssowideafieldtoindustrythatmanisabletoaccomplishthemostsurprisingundertakingswithhisownnativeresources。Nevertheless,ambitiousmenareinterbstedinthecreationofparties,sinceitisdifficulttoejectapersonfromauthorityuponthemeregroundthathisplaceiscovetedbyothers。Theskilloftheactorsinthepoliticalworldliesthereforeintheartofcreatingparties。ApoliticalaspirantintheUnitedStatesbeginsbydiscriminatinghisowninterest,andbycalculatinguponthoseinterestswhichmaybecollectedaroundandamalgamatedwithit;hethencontrivestodiscoversomedoctrineorsomeprinciplewhichmaysuitthepurposesofthisnewassociation,andwhichheadoptsinordertobringforwardhispartyandtosecurehispopularity;justastheimprimaturofaKingwasinformerdaysincorporatedwiththevolumewhichitauthorized,buttowhichitnowisebelonged。Whenthesepreliminariesareterminated,thenewpartyisusheredintothepoliticalworld。
AllthedomesticcontroversiesoftheAmericansatfirstappeartoastrangertobesoincomprehensibleandsopuerilethatheisatalosswhethertopityapeoplewhichtakessucharranttriflesingoodearnest,ortoenvythehappinesswhichenablesittodiscussthem。ButwhenhecomestostudythesecretpropensitieswhichgovernthefactionsofAmerica,heeasilyperceivesthatthegreaterpartofthemaremoreorlessconnectedwithoneortheotherofthosetwodivisionswhichhavealwaysexistedinfreecommunities。Thedeeperwepenetrateintotheworkingoftheseparties,themoredoweperceivethattheobjectoftheoneistolimit,andthatoftheothertoextend,thepopularauthority。Idonotassertthattheostensibleend,oreventhatthesecretaim,ofAmericanpartiesistopromotetheruleofaristocracyordemocracyinthecountry;butIaffirmthataristocraticordemocraticpassionsmayeasilybedetectedatthebottomofallparties,andthat,althoughtheyescapeasuperficialobservation,theyarethemainpointandtheverysoulofeveryfactionintheUnitedStates。
Toquotearecentexample。WhenthePresidentattackedtheBank,thecountrywasexcitedandpartieswereformed;thewell—
informedclassesralliedroundtheBank,thecommonpeopleroundthePresident。Butitmustnotbeimaginedthatthepeoplehadformedarationalopinionuponaquestionwhichofferssomanydifficultiestothemostexperiencedstatesmen。TheBankisagreatestablishmentwhichenjoysanindependentexistence,andthepeople,accustomedtomakeandunmakewhatsoeveritpleases,isstartledtomeetwiththisobstacletoitsauthority。Inthemidstoftheperpetualfluctuationofsocietythecommunityisirritatedbysopermanentaninstitution,andisledtoattackitinordertoseewhetheritcanbeshakenandcontrolled,likealltheotherinstitutionsofthecountry。
RemainsOfTheAristocraticPartyInTheUnitedStatesSecretoppositionofwealthyindividualstodemocracy—Theirretirement—Theirtasteforexclusivepleasuresandforluxuryathome—Theirsimplicityabroad—Theiraffectedcondescensiontowardsthepeople。
Itsometimeshappensinapeopleamongstwhichvariousopinionsprevailthatthebalanceoftheseveralpartiesislost,andoneofthemobtainsanirresistiblepreponderance,overpowersallobstacles,harassesitsopponents,andappropriatesalltheresourcesofsocietytoitsownpurposes。Thevanquishedcitizensdespairofsuccessandtheyconcealtheirdissatisfactioninsilenceandingeneralapathy。Thenationseemstobegovernedbyasingleprinciple,andtheprevailingpartyassumesthecreditofhavingrestoredpeaceandunanimitytothecountry。Butthisapparentunanimityismerelyacloaktoalarmingdissensionsandperpetualopposition。
ThisispreciselywhatoccurredinAmerica;whenthedemocraticpartygottheupperhand,ittookexclusivepossessionoftheconductofaffairs,andfromthattimethelawsandthecustomsofsocietyhavebeenadaptedtoitscaprices。AtthepresentdaythemoreaffluentclassesofsocietyaresoentirelyremovedfromthedirectionofpoliticalaffairsintheUnitedStatesthatwealth,farfromconferringarighttotheexerciseofpower,isratheranobstaclethanameansofattainingtoit。
Thewealthymembersofthecommunityabandonthelists,throughunwillingnesstocontend,andfrequentlytocontendinvain,againstthepoorestclassesoftheirfellowcitizens。Theyconcentratealltheirenjoymentsintheprivacyoftheirhomes,wheretheyoccupyarankwhichcannotbeassumedinpublic;andtheyconstituteaprivatesocietyintheState,whichhasitsowntastesanditsownpleasures。Theysubmittothisstateofthingsasanirremediableevil,buttheyarecarefulnottoshowthattheyaregalledbyitscontinuance;itisevennotuncommontohearthemlaudthedelightsofarepublicangovernment,andtheadvantagesofdemocraticinstitutionswhentheyareinpublic。
Nexttohatingtheirenemies,menaremostinclinedtoflatterthem。
Mark,forinstance,thatopulentcitizen,whoisasanxiousasaJewoftheMiddleAgestoconcealhiswealth。Hisdressisplain,hisdemeanorunassuming;buttheinteriorofhisdwellingglitterswithluxury,andnonebutafewchosenguestswhomhehaughtilystyleshisequalsareallowedtopenetrateintothissanctuary。NoEuropeannobleismoreexclusiveinhispleasures,ormorejealousofthesmallestadvantageswhichhisprivilegedstationconfersuponhim。Buttheverysameindividualcrossesthecitytoreachadarkcounting—houseinthecentreoftraffic,whereeveryonemayaccosthimwhopleases。Ifhemeetshiscobblerupontheway,theystopandconverse;thetwocitizensdiscusstheaffairsoftheStateinwhichtheyhaveanequalinterest,andtheyshakehandsbeforetheypart。
Butbeneaththisartificialenthusiasm,andtheseobsequiousattentionstothepreponderatingpower,itiseasytoperceivethatthewealthymembersofthecommunityentertainaheartydistastetothedemocraticinstitutionsoftheircountry。Thepopulaceisatoncetheobjectoftheirscornandoftheirfears。
Ifthemaladministrationofthedemocracyeverbringsaboutarevolutionarycrisis,andifmonarchicalinstitutionseverbecomepracticableintheUnitedStates,thetruthofwhatIadvancewillbecomeobvious。
Thetwochiefweaponswhichpartiesuseinordertoensuresuccessarethepublicpressandtheformationofassociations。
第15章