TheNorthAmericanCivilWarLondon,October20,1861
FormonthstheleadingweeklyanddailypapersoftheLondonpresshavebeenreiteratingthesamelitanyontheAmericanCivilWar。WhiletheyinsultthefreestatesoftheNorth,theyanxiouslydefendthemselvesagainstthesuspicionofsympathisingwiththeslavestatesoftheSouth。Infact,theycontinuallywritetwoarticles:onearticle,inwhichtheyattacktheNorth,andanotherarticle,inwhichtheyexcusetheirattacksontheNorth。
Inessencetheextenuatingargumentsread:ThewarbetweentheNorthandSouthisatariffwar。Thewaris,further,notforanyprinciple,doesnottouchthequestionofslaveryandinfactturnsonNorthernlustforsovereignty。Finally,evenifjusticeisonthesideoftheNorth,doesitnotremainavainendeavourtowanttosubjugateeightmillionAnglo—Saxonsbyforce!WouldnotseparationoftheSouthreleasetheNorthfromallconnectionwithNegroslaveryandensureforit,withitstwentymillioninhabitantsanditsvastterritory,ahigher,hithertoscarcelydreamt—of,development?Accordingly,mustnottheNorthwelcomesecessionasahappyevent,insteadofwantingtooverruleitbyabloodyandfutilecivilwar?
PointbypointwewillprobethepleaoftheEnglishpress。
ThewarbetweenNorthandSouth——sorunsthefirstexcuse——isameretariffwar,awarbetweenaprotectionistsystemandafreetradesystem,andBritainnaturallystandsonthesideoffreetrade。Shalltheslave—ownerenjoythefruitsofslavelabourintheirentiretyorshallhebecheatedofaportionofthesebytheprotectionistsoftheNorth?
Thatisthequestionwhichisatissueinthiswar。ItwasreservedforTheTimestomakethisbrilliantdiscovery。TheEconomist,TheExaminer,TheSaturdayReviewandtuttiquantiexpoundedthethemefurther。Itischaracteristicofthisdiscoverythatitwasmade,notinCharleston,butinLondon。Naturally,inAmericaeveryoneknewthatfrom1846to1861afreetradesystemprevailed,andthatRepresentativeMorrillcarriedhisprotectionisttariffthroughCongressonlyin1861,aftertherebellionhadalreadybrokenout。Secession,therefore,didnottakeplacebecausetheMorrilltariffhadgonethroughCongress,but,atmost,theMorrilltariffwentthroughCongressbecausesecessionhadtakenplace。WhenSouthCarolinahaditsfirstattackofsecessionin1831,theprotectionisttariffof1828servedit,tobesure,asapretext,butonlyasapretext,asisknownfromastatementofGeneralJackson。Thistime,however,theoldpretexthasinfactnotbeenrepeated。IntheSecessionCongressatMontgomeryallreferencetothetariffquestionwasavoided,becausethecultivationofsugarinLouisiana,oneofthemostinfluentialSouthernstates,dependsentirelyonprotection。
But,theLondonpresspleadsfurther,thewaroftheUnitedStatesisnothingbutawarfortheforciblemaintenanceoftheUnion。TheYankeescannotmakeuptheirmindstostrikefifteenstarsfromtheirstandard。
Theywanttocutacolossalfigureontheworldstage。Yes,itwouldbedifferentifthewarwaswagedfortheabolitionofslavery!Thequestionofslavery,however,asTheSaturdayReviewcategoricallydeclaresamongotherthings,hasabsolutelynothingtodowiththiswar。
ItisabovealltoberememberedthatthewardidnotoriginatewiththeNorth,butwiththeSouth。TheNorthfindsitselfonthedefensive。
FormonthsithadquietlylookedonwhilethesecessionistsappropriatedtheUnion’sforts,arsenals,shipyards,customshouses,payoffices,shipsandsuppliesofarms,insulteditsflagandtookprisonerbodiesofitstroops。FinallythesecessionistsresolvedtoforcetheUniongovernmentoutofitspassiveattitudebyablatantactofwar,andsolelyforthisreasonproceededtothebombardmentofFortSumternearCharleston。
OnApril11(1861)theirGeneralBeauregardhadlearntinameetingwithMajorAnderson,thecommanderofFortSumter,thatthefortwasonlysuppliedwithprovisionsforthreedaysmoreandaccordinglymustbepeacefullysurrenderedafterthisperiod。Inordertoforestallthispeacefulsurrender,thesecessionistsopenedthebombardmentearlyonthefollowingmorning(April12),whichbroughtaboutthefallofthefortinafewhours。NewsofthishadhardlybeentelegraphedtoMontgomery,theseatoftheSecessionCongress,whenWarMinisterWalkerpubliclydeclaredinthenameofthenewConfederacy:Nomancansaywherethewaropenedtodaywillend。AtthesametimeheprophesiedthatbeforethefirstofMaytheflagoftheSouthernConfederacywillwavefromthedomeoftheoldCapitolinWashingtonandwithinashorttimeperhapsalsofromtheFaneuilHallinBoston。OnlynowensuedtheproclamationinwhichLincolncalledfor75,000mentodefendtheUnion。ThebombardmentofFortSumtercutofftheonlypossibleconstitutionalwayout,namelytheconvocationofageneralconventionoftheAmericanpeople,asLincolnhadproposedinhisinauguraladdress。ForLincolntherenowremainedonlythechoiceoffleeingfromWashington,evacuatingMarylandandDelawareandsurrenderingKentucky,MissouriandVirginia,orofansweringwarwithwar。
ThequestionoftheprincipleoftheAmericanCivilWarisansweredbythebattlesloganwithwhichtheSouthbrokethepeace。Stephens,theVice—PresidentoftheSouthernConfederacy,declaredintheSecessionCongressthatwhatessentiallydistinguishedtheConstitutionnewlyhatchedatMontgomeryfromtheConstitutionofWashingtonandJeffersonwasthatnowforthefirsttimeslaverywasrecognisedasaninstitutiongoodinitself,andasthefoundationofthewholestateedifice,whereastherevolutionaryfathers,mensteepedintheprejudicesoftheeighteenthcentury,hadtreatedslaveryasanevilimportedfromEnglandandtobeeliminatedinthecourseoftime。AnothermatadoroftheSouth,Mr。Spratt,criedout:"Forusitisaquestionoffoundingagreatslaverepublic。"If,therefore,itwasindeedonlyindefenceoftheUnionthattheNorthdrewthesword,hadnottheSouthalreadydeclaredthatthecontinuanceofslaverywasnolongercompatiblewiththecontinuanceoftheUnion?
JustasthebombardmentofFortSumtergavethesignalfortheopeningofthewar,theelectionvictoryoftheRepublicanPartyoftheNorth,theelectionofLincolnasPresident,gavethesignalforsecession。
OnNovember6,1860,Lincolnwaselected。OnNovember8,1860,amessagetelegraphedfromSouthCarolinasaid:Secessionisregardedhereasanaccomplishedfact;onNovember10thelegislatureofGeorgiaoccupieditselfwithsecessionplans,andonNovember13aspecialsessionofthelegislatureofMississippiwasconvenedtoconsidersecession。ButLincoln’selectionwasitselfonlytheresultofasplitintheDemocraticcamp。DuringtheelectionstruggletheDemocratsoftheNorthconcentratedtheirvotesonDouglas,theDemocratsoftheSouthconcentratedtheirvotesonBreckinridge,andtothissplittingoftheDemocraticvotestheRepublicanPartyoweditsvictory。Whencecame,ontheonehand,thepreponderanceoftheRepublicanPartyintheNorth?Whence,ontheother,thedisunionwithintheDemocraticParty,whosemembers,NorthandSouth,hadoperatedinconjunctionformorethanhalfacentury?
UnderthepresidencyofBuchanantheswaythattheSouthhadgraduallyusurpedovertheUnionthroughitsalliancewiththeNorthernDemocratsattaineditszenith。ThelastContinentalCongressof1787andthefirstConstitutionalCongressof1789—90hadlegallyexcludedslaveryfromallTerritoriesoftherepublicnorth—westoftheOhio。(Territories,asisknown,isthenamegiventothecolonieslyingwithintheUnitedStatesitselfwhichhavenotyetattainedthelevelofpopulationconstitutionallyprescribedfortheformationofautonomousstates。)Theso—calledMissouriCompromise(1820),inconsequenceofwhichMissouribecameoneoftheStatesoftheUnionasaslavestate,excludedslaveryfromeveryremainingTerritorynorthof36degreeslatitudeandwestoftheMissouri。Bythiscompromisetheareaofslaverywasadvancedseveraldegreesoflongitude,whilst,ontheotherhand,ageographicalboundary—linetoitsfuturespreadseemedquitedefinitelydrawn。Thisgeographicalbarrier,initsturn,wasthrowndownin1854bytheso—calledKansas—NebraskaBill,theinitiatorofwhichwasSt[ephen]A。Douglas,thenleaderoftheNorthernDemocrats。TheBill,whichpassedbothHousesofCongress,repealedtheMissouriCompromise,placedslaveryandfreedomonthesamefooting,commandedtheUniongovernmenttotreatthembothwithequalindifferenceandleftittothesovereigntyofthepeople,thatis,themajorityofthesettlers,todecidewhetherornotslaverywastobeintroducedinaTerritory。Thus,forthefirsttimeinthehistoryoftheUnitedStates,everygeographicalandlegallimittotheextensionofslaveryintheTerritorieswasremoved。UnderthisnewlegislationthehithertofreeTerritoryofNewMexico,aTerritoryfivetimesaslargeastheStateofNewYork,wastransformedintoaslaveTerritory,andtheareaofslaverywasextendedfromtheborderoftheMexicanRepublicto38degreesnorthlatitude。In1859NewMexicoreceivedaslavecodethatvieswiththestatute—booksofTexasandAlabamainbarbarity。
Nevertheless,asthecensusof1860proves,amongsomehundredthousandinhabitantsNewMexicodoesnotyetcounthalfahundredslaves。IthadthereforesufficedfortheSouthtosendsomeadventurerswithafewslavesovertheborder,andthenwiththehelpofthecentralgovernmentinWashingtonandofitsofficialsandcontractorsinNewMexicotodrumtogetherashampopularrepresentationtoimposeslaveryandwithittheruleoftheslaveholdersontheTerritory。
However,thisconvenientmethoddidnotproveapplicableinotherTerritories。
TheSouthaccordinglywentastepfurtherandappealedfromCongresstotheSupremeCourtoftheUnitedStates。ThisCourt,whichnumbersninejudges,fiveofwhombelongtotheSouth,hadlongbeenthemostwillingtooloftheslaveholders。Itdecidedin1857,inthenotoriousDredScottcase,thateveryAmericancitizenpossessestherighttotakewithhimintoanyterritoryanypropertyrecognizedbytheConstitution。TheConstitution,itmaintained,recognisesslavesaspropertyandobligestheUniongovernmenttoprotectthisproperty。Consequently,onthebasisoftheConstitution,slavescouldbeforcedtolabourintheTerritoriesbytheirowners,andsoeveryindividualslaveholderwasentitledtointroduceslaveryintohithertofreeTerritoriesagainstthewillofthemajorityofthesettlers。
TherighttoexcludeslaverywastakenfromtheTerritoriallegislaturesandthedutytoprotectpioneersoftheslavesystemwasimposedonCongressandtheUniongovernment。
IftheMissouriCompromiseof1820hadextendedthegeographicalboundary—lineofslaveryintheTerritories,iftheKansas—NebraskaBillof1854haderasedeverygeographicalboundary—lineandsetupapoliticalbarrierinstead,thewillofthemajorityofthesettlers,nowtheSupremeCourtoftheUnitedStates,byitsdecisionof1857,toredowneventhispoliticalbarrierandtransformedalltheTerritoriesoftherepublic,presentandfuture,fromnurseriesoffreestatesintonurseriesofslavery。
Atthesametime,underBuchanan’sgovernmentthesevererlawonthesurrenderingoffugitiveslavesenactedin1850wasruthlesslycarriedoutinthestatesoftheNorth。Toplaythepartofslave—catchersfortheSouthernslaveholdersappearedtobetheconstitutionalcallingoftheNorth。Ontheotherhand,inordertohinderasfaraspossiblethecolonisationoftheTerritoriesbyfreesettlers,theslaveholders’partyfrustratedalltheso—calledfree—soilmeasures,i。e。,measureswhichweretosecureforthesettlersadefiniteamountofuncultivatedstatelandfreeofcharge。
Intheforeign,asinthedomestic,policyoftheUnitedStates,theinterestoftheslaveholdersservedastheguidingstar。BuchananhadinfactboughttheofficeofPresidentthroughtheissueoftheOstendManifesto,inwhichtheacquisitionofCuba,whetherbypurchaseorbyforceofarms,wasproclaimedasthegreattaskofnationalpolicy。UnderhisgovernmentnorthernMexicowasalreadydividedamongAmericanlandspeculators,whoimpatientlyawaitedthesignaltofallonChihuahua,CoahuilaandSonora。
TheunceasingpiraticalexpeditionsofthefilibustersagainstthestatesofCentralAmericaweredirectednolessfromtheWhiteHouseatWashington。
Intheclosestconnectionwiththisforeignpolicy,whosemanifestpurposewasconquestofnewterritoryforthespreadofslaveryandoftheslaveholders’
rule,stoodthereopeningoftheslavetrade,secretlysupportedbytheUniongovernment。St[ephen]A。DouglashimselfdeclaredintheAmericanSenateonAugust20,1859:DuringthelastyearmoreNegroeshavebeenimportedfromAfricathaneverbeforeinanysingleyear,evenatthetimewhentheslavetradewasstilllegal。Thenumberofslavesimportedinthelastyeartotalledfifteenthousand。
Armedspreadingofslaveryabroadwastheavowedaimofnationalpolicy;
theUnionhadinfactbecometheslaveofthethreehundredthousandslaveholderswhoheldswayovertheSouth。Aseriesofcompromises,whichtheSouthowedtoitsalliancewiththeNorthernDemocrats,hadledtothisresult。
Onthisalliancealltheattempts,periodicallyrepeatedsince1817,toresisttheeverincreasingencroachmentsoftheslaveholdershadhithertocometogrief。Atlengththerecameaturningpoint。
ForhardlyhadtheKansas—NebraskaBillgonethrough,whichwipedoutthegeographicalboundary—lineofslaveryandmadeitsintroductionintonewTerritoriessubjecttothewillofthemajorityofthesettlers,whenarmedemissariesoftheslaveholders,borderrabblefromMissouriandArkansas,withbowie—knifeinonehandandrevolverintheother,felluponKansasandsoughtbythemostunheard—ofatrocitiestodislodgeitssettlersfromtheTerritorycolonisedbythem。TheseraidsweresupportedbythecentralgovernmentinWashington。Henceatremendousreaction。ThroughouttheNorth,butparticularlyintheNorth—west,arelieforganisationwasformedtosupportKansaswithmen,armsandmoney。OutofthisrelieforganisationarosetheRepublicanParty,whichthereforeowesitsorigintothestruggleforKansas。AftertheattempttotransformKansasintoaslaveTerritorybyforceofarmshadfailed,theSouthsoughttoachievethesameresultbypoliticalintrigues。Buchanan’sgovernment,inparticular,exerteditsutmosteffortstohaveKansasincludedintheStatesoftheUnionasaslavestatewithaslaveconstitutionimposedonit。
Hencerenewedstruggle,thistimemainlyconductedinCongressatWashington。
EvenSt[ephen]A。Douglas,thechiefoftheNorthernDemocrats,now(1857
—58)enteredthelistsagainstthegovernmentandhisalliesoftheSouth,becauseimpositionofaslaveconstitutionwouldhavebeencontrarytotheprincipleofsovereigntyofthesettlerspassedintheNebraskaBillof1854。Douglas,SenatorforIllinois,aNorth—westernstate,wouldnaturallyhavelostallhisinfluenceifhehadwantedtoconcedetotheSouththerighttostealbyforceofarmsorthroughactsofCongressTerritoriescolonisedbytheNorth。AsthestruggleforKansas,therefore,calledtheRepublicanPartyintobeing,itatthesametimeoccasionedthefirstsplitwithintheDemocraticPartyitself。
TheRepublicanPartyputforwarditsfirstplatformforthepresidentialelectionin1856。Althoughitscandidate,JohnFremont,wasnotvictorious,thehugenumberofvotescastforhimatanyrateprovedtherapidgrowthoftheParty,particularlyintheNorth—west。AttheirsecondNationalConventionforthepresidentialelection(May17,1860),theRepublicansagainputforwardtheirplatformof1856,onlyenrichedbysomeadditions。
Itsprincipalcontentswerethefollowing:Notafootoffreshterritoryisfurtherconcededtoslavery。Thefilibusteringpolicyabroadmustcease。
Thereopeningoftheslavetradeisstigmatised。Finally,free—soillawsaretobeenactedforthefurtheranceoffreecolonisation。
Thevitallyimportantpointinthisplatformwasthatnotafootoffreshterrainwasconcededtoslavery;ratheritwastoremainonceandforallconfinedwiththeboundariesofthestateswhereitalreadylegallyexisted。Slaverywasthustobeformallyinterned;butcontinualexpansionofterritoryandcontinualspreadofslaverybeyonditsoldlimitsisalawoflifefortheslavestatesoftheUnion。
Thecultivationofthesouthernexportarticles,cotton,tobacco,sugar,etc。,carriedonbyslaves,isonlyremunerativeaslongasitisconductedwithlargegangsofslaves,onamassscaleandonwideexpansesofanaturallyfertilesoil,whichrequiresonlysimplelabour。Intensivecultivation,whichdependslessonfertilityofthesoilthanoninvestmentofcapital,intelligenceandenergyoflabour,iscontrarytothenatureofslavery。
HencetherapidtransformationofstateslikeMarylandandVirginia,whichformerlyemployedslavesontheproductionofexportarticles,intostateswhichraiseslavestoexportthemintothedeepSouth。EveninSouthCarolina,wheretheslavesformfour—seventhsofthepopulation,thecultivationofcottonhasbeenalmostcompletelystationaryforyearsduetotheexhaustionofthesoil。Indeed,byforceofcircumstancesSouthCarolinahasalreadybeentransformedinpartintoaslave—raisingstate,sinceitalreadysellsslavestothesumoffourmilliondollarsyearlytothestatesoftheextremeSouthandSouth—west。Assoonasthispointisreached,theacquisitionofnewTerritoriesbecomesnecessary,sothatonesectionoftheslaveholderswiththeirslavesmayoccupynewfertilelandsandthatanewmarketforslave—raising,thereforeforthesaleofslaves,maybecreatedfortheremainingsection。Itis,forexample,indubitablethatwithouttheacquisitionofLouisiana,MissouriandArkansasbytheUnitedStates,slaveryinVirginiaandMarylandwouldhavebeenwipedoutlongago。IntheSecessionistCongressatMontgomery,SenatorToombs,oneofthespokesmenoftheSouth,strikinglyformulatedtheeconomiclawthatcommandstheconstantexpansionoftheterritoryofslavery。"Infifteenyears,"saidhe,"withoutagreatincreaseinslaveterritory,eithertheslavesmustbepermittedtofleefromthewhites,orthewhitesmustfleefromtheslaves。"
Asisknown,therepresentationoftheindividualstatesintheCongressHouseofRepresentativesdependsonthesizeoftheirrespectivepopulations。