IntroductionAseveryenquiry,whichregardsreligion,isoftheutmostimportance,therearetwoquestionsinparticular,whichchallengeourattention,towit,thatconcerningitsfoundationinreason,andthatconcerningitsorigininhumannature。Happily,thefirstquestion,whichisthemostimportant,admitsofthemostobvious,atleast,theclearestsolution。Thewholeframeofnaturebespeaksanintelligentauthor;
andnorationalenquirercan,afterseriousreflection,suspendhisbeliefamomentwithregardtotheprimaryprinciplesofgenuineTheismandReligion。Buttheotherquestion,concerningtheoriginofreligioninhumannature,isexposedtosomemoredifficulty。Thebeliefofinvisible,intelligentpowerhasbeenverygenerallydiffusedoverthehumanrace,inallplacesandinallages;butithasneitherperhapsbeensouniversalastoadmitofnoexception,norhasitbeen,inanydegree,uniformintheideas,whichithassuggested。Somenationshavebeendiscovered,whoentertainednosentimentsofReligion,iftravellersandhistoriansmaybecredited;andnotwonations,andscarceanytwomen,haveeveragreedpreciselyinthesamesentiments。Itwouldappear,therefore,thatthispreconceptionspringsnotfromanoriginalinstinctorprimaryimpressionofnature,suchasgivesrisetoself-love,affectionbetweenthesexes,loveofprogeny,gratitude,resentment;sinceeveryinstinctofthiskindhasbeenfoundabsolutelyuniversalinallnationsandages,andhasalwaysaprecisedeterminateobject,whichitinflexiblypursues。Thefirstreligiousprinciplesmustbesecondary;
suchasmayeasilybepervertedbyvariousaccidentsandcauses,andwhoseoperationtoo,insomecases,may,byanextraordinaryconcurrenceofcircumstances,bealtogetherprevented。
Whatthoseprinciplesare,whichgiverisetotheoriginalbelief,andwhatthoseaccidentsandcausesare,whichdirectitsoperation,isthesubjectofourpresentenquiry。
SECT。I。ThatPolytheismwastheprimaryReligionofMen。
Itappearstome,that,ifweconsidertheimprovementofhumansociety,fromrudebeginningstoastateofgreaterperfection,polytheismoridolatrywas,andnecessarilymusthavebeen,thefirstandmostancientreligionofmankind。ThisopinionIshallendeavourtoconfirmbythefollowingarguments。
Itisamatteroffactincontestable,thatabout1700yearsagoallmankindwerepolytheists。Thedoubtfulandscepticalprinciplesofafewphilosophers,orthetheism,andthattoonotentirelypure,ofoneortwonations,formnoobjectionworthregarding。Beholdthenthecleartestimonyofhistory。
Thefartherwemountupintoantiquity,themoredowefindmankindplungedintopolytheism。Nomarks,nosymptomsofanymoreperfectreligion。Themostancientrecordsofhumanracestillpresentuswiththatsystemasthepopularandestablishedcreed。Thenorth,thesouth,theeast,thewest,givetheirunanimoustestimonytothesamefact。Whatcanbeopposedtosofullanevidence?
Asfaraswritingorhistoryreaches,mankind,inancienttimes,appearuniversallytohavebeenpolytheists。
Shallweassert,that,inmoreancienttimes,beforetheknowledgeofletters,orthediscoveryofanyartorscience,menentertainedtheprinciplesofpuretheism?Thatis,whiletheywereignorantandbarbarous,theydiscoveredtruth:Butfellintoerror,assoonastheyacquiredlearningandpoliteness。
Butinthisassertionyounotonlycontradictallappearanceofprobability,butalsoourpresentexperienceconcerningtheprinciplesandopinionsofbarbarousnations。ThesavagetribesofAMERICA,AFRICA,andASIAareallidolaters。Notasingleexceptiontothisrule。Insomuch,that,wereatravellertotransporthimselfintoanyunknownregion;ifhefoundinhabitantscultivatedwithartsandscience,thoughevenuponthatsuppositionthereareoddsagainsttheirbeingtheists,yetcouldhenotsafely,tillfartherinquiry,pronounceanythingonthathead:Butifhefoundthemignorantandbarbarous,hemightbeforehanddeclarethemidolaters;andtherescarcelyisapossibilityofhisbeingmistaken。
Itseemscertain,that,accordingtothenaturalprogressofhumanthought,theignorantmultitudemustfirstentertainsomegrovelingandfamiliarnotionofsuperiorpowers,beforetheystretchtheirconceptiontothatperfectBeing,whobestowedorderonthewholeframeofnature。Wemayasreasonablyimagine,thatmeninhabitedpalacesbeforehutsandcottages,orstudiedgeometrybeforeagriculture;asassertthattheDeityappearedtothemapurespirit,omniscient,omnipotent,andomnipresent,beforehewasapprehendedtobeapowerful,thoughlimitedbeing,withhumanpassionsandappetites,limbsandorgans。Themindrisesgradually,frominferiortosuperior:Byabstractingfromwhatisimperfect,itformsanideaofperfection:
Andslowlydistinguishingthenoblerpartsofitsownframefromthegrosser,itlearnstotransferonlytheformer,muchelevatedandrefined,toitsdivinity。Nothingcoulddisturbthisnaturalprogressofthought,butsomeobviousandinvincibleargument,whichmightimmediatelyleadthemindintothepureprinciplesoftheism,andmakeitoverleap,atonebound,thevastintervalwhichisinterposedbetweenthehumanandthedivinenature。ButthoughIallow,thattheorderandframeoftheuniverse,whenaccuratelyexamined,affordssuchanargument;yetIcanneverthink,thatthisconsiderationcouldhaveaninfluenceonmankind,whentheyformedtheirfirstrudenotionsofreligion。
Thecausesofsuchobjects,asarequitefamiliartous,neverstrikeourattentionorcuriosity;andhoweverextraordinaryorsurprisingtheseobjectsinthemselves,theyarepassedover,bytherawandignorantmultitude,withoutmuchexaminationorenquiry。ADAM,risingatonce,inparadise,andinthefullperfectionofhisfaculties,wouldnaturally,asrepresentedbyMILTON,beastonishedatthegloriousappearancesofnature,theheavens,theair,theearth,hisownorgansandmembers;andwouldbeledtoask,whencethiswonderfulscenearose。Butabarbarous,necessitousanimal(suchasamanisonthefirstoriginofsociety),pressedbysuchnumerouswantsandpassions,hasnoleisuretoadmiretheregularfaceofnature,ormakeenquiriesconcerningthecauseofthoseobjects,towhichfromhisinfancyhehasbeengraduallyaccustomed。
Onthecontrary,themoreregularanduniform,thatis,themoreperfectnatureappears,themoreishefamiliarizedtoit,andthelessinclinedtoscrutinizeandexamineit。Amonstrousbirthexciteshiscuriosity,andisdeemedaprodigy。Italarmshimfromitsnovelty;andimmediatelysetshimatrembling,andsacrificing,andpraying。Butananimal,compleatinallitslimbsandorgans,istohimanordinaryspectacle,andproducesnoreligiousopinionoraffection。Askhim,whencethatanimalarose;hewilltellyou,fromthecopulationofitsparents。Andthese,whence?
Fromthecopulationoftheirs。Afewremovessatisfyhiscuriosity,andsettheobjectsatsuchadistance,thatheentirelylosessightofthem。Imaginenot,thathewillsomuchasstartthequestion,whencethefirstanimal;muchless,whencethewholesystemorunitedfabricoftheuniversearose。Or,ifyoustartsuchaquestiontohim,expectnot,thathewillemployhismindwithanyanxietyaboutasubject,soremote,souninteresting,andwhichsomuchexceedstheboundsofhiscapacity。
Butfarther,ifmenwereatfirstledintothebeliefofoneSupremeBeing,byreasoningfromtheframeofnature,theycouldneverpossiblyleavethatbelief,inordertoembracepolytheism;butthesameprinciplesofreason,whichatfirstproducedanddiffusedovermankind,somagnificentanopinion,mustbeable,withgreaterfacility,topreserveit。Thefirstinventionandproofofanydoctrineismuchmoredifficultthanthesupportingandretainingofit。
Thereisagreatdifferencebetweenhistoricalfactsandspeculativeopinions;noristheknowledgeoftheonepropagatedinthesamemannerwiththatoftheother。Anhistoricalfact,whileitpassesbyoraltraditionfromeye-witnessesandcontemporaries,isdisguisedineverysuccessivenarration,andmayatlastretainbutverysmall,ifany,resemblanceoftheoriginaltruth,onwhichitwasfounded。
Thefrailmemoriesofmen,theirloveofexaggeration,theirsupinecarelessness;theseprinciples,ifnotcorrectedbybooksandwriting,soonperverttheaccountofhistoricalevents;whereargumentorreasoninghaslittleornoplace,norcaneverrecalthetruth,whichhasonceescapedthosenarrations。ItisthusthefablesofHERCULES,THESEUS,BACCHUSaresupposedtohavebeenoriginallyfoundedintruehistory,corruptedbytradition。Butwithregardtospeculativeopinions,thecaseisfarotherwise。Iftheseopinionsbefoundedonargumentssoclearandobviousastocarryconvictionwiththegeneralityofmankind,thesamearguments,whichatfirstdiffusedtheopinions,willstillpreservethemintheiroriginalpurity。
Iftheargumentsbemoreabstruse,andmoreremotefromvulgarapprehension,theopinionswillalwaysbeconfinedtoafewpersons;andassoonasmenleavethecontemplationofthearguments,theopinionswillimmediatelybelostandbeburiedinoblivion。Whicheversideofthisdilemmawetake,itmustappearimpossible,thattheismcould,fromreasoning,havebeentheprimaryreligionofhumanrace,andhaveafterwards,byitscorruption,givenbirthtopolytheismandtoallthevarioussuperstitionsoftheheathenworld。
Reason,whenobvious,preventsthesecorruptions:Whenabstruse,itkeepstheprinciplesentirelyfromtheknowledgeofthevulgar,whoarealoneliabletocorruptanyprincipleoropinion。
SECT。II。OriginofPolytheism。
Ifwewould,therefore,indulgeourcuriosity,inenquiringconcerningtheoriginofreligion,wemustturnourthoughtstowardspolytheism,theprimitivereligionofuninstructedmankind。
Weremenledintotheapprehensionofinvisible,intelligentpowerbyacontemplationoftheworksofnature,theycouldneverpossiblyentertainanyconceptionbutofonesinglebeing,whobestowedexistenceandorderonthisvastmachine,andadjustedallitsparts,accordingtooneregularplanorconnectedsystem。Forthough,topersonsofacertainturnofmind,itmaynotappearaltogetherabsurd,thatseveralindependentbeings,endowedwithsuperiorwisdom,mightconspireinthecontrivanceandexecutionofoneregularplan;yetisthisamerelyarbitrarysupposition,which,evenifallowedpossible,mustbeconfessedneithertobesupportedbyprobabilitynornecessity。Allthingsintheuniverseareevidentlyofapiece。Everythingisadjustedtoeverything。Onedesignprevailsthroughoutthewhole。Andthisuniformityleadsthemindtoacknowledgeoneauthor;becausetheconceptionofdifferentauthors,withoutanydistinctionofattributesoroperations,servesonlytogiveperplexitytotheimagination,withoutbestowinganysatisfactionontheunderstanding。
ThestatueofLAOCOON,aswelearnfromPLINY,wastheworkofthreeartists:Butitiscertain,that,werewenottoldso,weshouldneverhaveimagined,thatagroupeoffigures,cutfromonestone,andunitedinoneplan,wasnottheworkandcontrivanceofonestatuary。Toascribeanysingleeffecttothecombinationofseveralcauses,isnotsurelyanaturalandobvioussupposition。
Ontheotherhand,if,leavingtheworksofnature,wetracethefootstepsofinvisiblepowerinthevariousandcontraryeventsofhumanlife,wearenecessarilyledintopolytheismandtotheacknowledgmentofseverallimitedandimperfectdeities。Stormsandtempestsruinwhatisnourishedbythesun。Thesundestroyswhatisfosteredbythemoistureofdewsandrains。Warmaybefavourabletoanation,whomtheinclemencyoftheseasonsafflictswithfamine。Sicknessandpestilencemaydepopulateakingdom,amidstthemostprofuseplenty。Thesamenationisnot,atthesametime,equallysuccessfulbyseaandbyland。Andanation,whichnowtriumphsoveritsenemies,mayanonsubmittotheirmoreprosperousarms。Inshort,theconductofevents,orwhatwecalltheplanofaparticularprovidence,issofullofvarietyanduncertainty,that,ifwesupposeitimmediatelyorderedbyanyintelligentbeings,wemustacknowledgeacontrarietyintheirdesignsandintentions,aconstantcombatofoppositepowers,andarepentanceorchangeofintentioninthesamepower,fromimpotenceorlevity。Eachnationhasitstutelardeity。
Eachelementissubjectedtoitsinvisiblepoweroragent。Theprovinceofeachgodisseparatefromthatofanother。
Noraretheoperationsofthesamegodalwayscertainandinvariable。
To-dayheprotects:To-morrowheabandonsus。Prayersandsacrifices,ritesandceremonies,wellorillperformed,arethesourcesofhisfavourorenmity,andproduceallthegoodorillfortune,whicharetobefoundamongstmankind。
Wemayconclude,therefore,that,inallnations,whichhaveembracedpolytheism,thefirstideasofreligionarosenotfromacontemplationoftheworksofnature,butfromaconcernwithregardtotheeventsoflife,andfromtheincessanthopesandfears,whichactuatethehumanmind。Accordingly,wefind,thatallidolaters,havingseparatedtheprovincesoftheirdeities,haverecoursetothatinvisibleagent,towhoseauthoritytheyareimmediatelysubjected,andwhoseprovinceitistosuperintendthatcourseofactions,inwhichtheyare,atanytime,engaged。JUNOisinvokedatmarriages;LUCINAatbirths。NEPTUNEreceivestheprayersofseamen;andMARSofwarriors。ThehusbandmancultivateshisfieldundertheprotectionofCERES;andthemerchantacknowledgestheauthorityofMERCURY。Eachnaturaleventissupposedtobegovernedbysomeintelligentagent;andnothingprosperousoradversecanhappeninlife,whichmaynotbethesubjectofpeculiarprayersorthanksgivings。2
Itmustnecessarily,indeed,beallowed,that,inordertocarrymen'sattentionbeyondthepresentcourseofthings,orleadthemintoanyinferenceconcerninginvisibleintelligentpower,theymustbeactuatedbysomepassion,whichpromptstheirthoughtandreflection;somemotive,whichurgestheirfirstenquiry。Butwhatpassionshallweherehaverecourseto,forexplaininganeffectofsuchmightyconsequence?Notspeculativecuriositysurely,orthepureloveoftruth。Thatmotiveistoorefinedforsuchgrossapprehensions;andwouldleadmenintoenquiriesconcerningtheframeofnature,asubjecttoolargeandcomprehensivefortheirnarrowcapacities。Nopassions,therefore,canbesupposedtoworkuponsuchbarbarians,buttheordinaryaffectionsofhumanlife;theanxiousconcernforhappiness,thedreadoffuturemisery,theterrorofdeath,thethirstofrevenge,theappetiteforfoodandothernecessaries。Agitatedbyhopesandfearsofthisnature,especiallythelatter,menscrutinize,withatremblingcuriosity,thecourseoffuturecauses,andexaminethevariousandcontraryeventsofhumanlife。Andinthisdisorderedscene,witheyesstillmoredisorderedandastonished,theyseethefirstobscuretracesofdivinity。
SECT。III。Thesamesubjectcontinued。
Weareplacedinthisworld,asinagreattheatre,wherethetruespringsandcausesofeveryeventareentirelyconcealedfromus;norhaveweeithersufficientwisdomtoforesee,orpowertopreventthoseills,withwhichwearecontinuallythreatened。Wehanginperpetualsuspencebetweenlifeanddeath,healthandsickness,plentyandwant;whicharedistributedamongstthehumanspeciesbysecretandunknowncauses,whoseoperationisoftunexpected,andalwaysunaccountable。Theseunknowncauses,then,becometheconstantobjectofourhopeandfear;andwhilethepassionsarekeptinperpetualalarmbyananxiousexpectationoftheevents,theimaginationisequallyemployedinformingideasofthosepowers,onwhichwehavesoentireadependance。Couldmenanatomizenature,accordingtothemostprobable,atleastthemostintelligiblephilosophy,theywouldfind,thatthesecausesarenothingbuttheparticularfabricandstructureoftheminutepartsoftheirownbodiesandofexternalobjects;andthat,byaregularandconstantmachinery,alltheeventsareproduced,aboutwhichtheyaresomuchconcerned。Butthisphilosophyexceedsthecomprehensionoftheignorantmultitude,whocanonlyconceivetheunknowncausesinageneralandconfusedmanner;thoughtheirimagination,perpetuallyemployedonthesamesubject,mustlabourtoformsomeparticularanddistinctideaofthem。
Themoretheyconsiderthesecausesthemselves,andtheuncertaintyoftheiroperation,thelesssatisfactiondotheymeetwithintheirresearches;and,howeverunwilling,theymustatlasthaveabandonedsoarduousanattempt,wereitnotforapropensityinhumannature,whichleadsintoasystem,thatgivesthemsomesatisfaction。
Thereisanuniversaltendencyamongmankindtoconceiveallbeingslikethemselves,andtotransfertoeveryobject,thosequalities,withwhichtheyarefamiliarlyacquainted,andofwhichtheyareintimatelyconscious。Wefindhumanfacesinthemoon,armiesintheclouds;andbyanaturalpropensity,ifnotcorrectedbyexperienceandreflection,ascribemaliceorgood-willtoeverything,thathurtsorpleasesus。Hencethefrequencyandbeautyoftheprosopopoeiainpoetry;wheretrees,mountainsandstreamsarepersonified,andtheinanimatepartsofnatureacquiresentimentandpassion。Andthoughthesepoeticalfiguresandexpressionsgainnotonthebelief,theymayserve,atleast,toproveacertaintendencyintheimagination,withoutwhichtheycouldneitherbebeautifulnornatural。Norisariver-godorhamadryadalwaystakenforamerepoeticalorimaginarypersonage;butmaysometimesenterintotherealcreedoftheignorantvulgar;whileeachgroveorfieldisrepresentedaspossessedofaparticulargeniusorinvisiblepower,whichinhabitsandprotectsit。Nay,philosopherscannotentirelyexemptthemselvesfromthisnaturalfrailty;buthaveoftascribedtoinanimatematterthehorrorofavacuum,sympathies,antipathies,andotheraffectionsofhumannature。Theabsurdityisnotless,whilewecastoureyesupwards;andtransferring,asistoousual,humanpassionsandinfirmitiestothedeity,representhimasjealousandrevengeful,capriciousandpartial,and,inshort,awickedandfoolishman,ineveryrespectbuthissuperiorpowerandauthority。
Nowonder,then,thatmankind,beingplacedinsuchanabsoluteignoranceofcauses,andbeingatthesametimesoanxiousconcerningtheirfuturefortune,shouldimmediatelyacknowledgeadependenceoninvisiblepowers,possessedofsentimentandintelligence。Theunknowncauses,whichcontinuallyemploytheirthought,appearingalwaysinthesameaspect,areallapprehendedtobeofthesamekindorspecies。Norisitlongbeforeweascribetothemthoughtandreasonandpassion,andsometimeseventhelimbsandfiguresofmen,inordertobringthemnearertoaresemblancewithourselves。
Inproportionasanyman'scourseoflifeisgovernedbyaccident,wealwaysfind,thatheencreasesinsuperstition;asmayparticularlybeobservedofgamestersandsailors,who,though,ofallmankind,theleastcapableofseriousreflection,aboundmostinfrivolousandsuperstitiousapprehensions。
Thegods,saysCORIOLANUSinDIONYSIUS,3haveaninfluenceineveryaffair;butaboveall,inwar;