servativeCreolefamiliesandotherfamilieswhosewomenwereunwillingtovoteinpublic,andshecollectedtheirproxieswhileincidentallysheshowedthemwhatpositiontheyheldunderthelaw。
Witheachproxyitwasnecessarytohavethesigna—
tureofawitness,butaccordingtotheLouisianalawnowomancouldwitnessalegaldocument。MissGordonwasdrivenfromplacetoplacebyhercoloredcoachman,andaftershehadsecuredtheproxyofhertemporaryhostessitwasusuallydiscoveredthattherewasnomanaroundtheplacetoactasawit—
ness。ThiswasMissGordon’sopportunity。Withasmileofgreatsweetnessshewouldsay,``IwillhaveSamcomeinandhelpusout’’;andthecoloredcoachmanwouldgetdownfromhisbox,andbyscrawlinghissignatureontheproxyofthearisto—
craticladyhewouldgiveitthelegalvalueitlacked。
InthiswayMissGordonsecuredthreehundredproxies,andthreehundredveryconservativewomenhadanopportunitytocomparetheirlegalstandingwithSam’s。Thedrainagebillwascarriedandin—
terestinwomansuffragedevelopedsteadily。
ThespecialincidentoftheBuffaloconventionof1908wasthereceiptofanotewhichwaspasseduptomeasIsatontheplatform。WhenIopeneditacheckdroppedout——achecksolargethatIwassureithadbeensentbymistake。However,afteraskingoneortwofriendsontheplatformifIhadreaditcorrectly,IannouncedtotheaudiencethatifacertainamountweresubscribedimmediatelyI
wouldrevealasecret——averyinterestingsecret。
Audiencesareascuriousasindividuals。Theamountwasatoncesubscribed。ThenIheldupacheckfor$10,000,givenforourcampaignworkbyMrs。
GeorgeHowardLewis,inmemoryofSusanB。An—
thony,andIreadtotheaudiencethecharmingletterthataccompaniedit。Themoneywasusedduringthecampaignsofthefollowingyear——partofitinWashington,whereanamendmentwasalreadysubmitted。
InapreviouschapterIhavedescribedtheestab—
lishmentofourNewYorkheadquartersasaresultofthegenerousofferofMrs。O。H。P。BelmontattheSeattleconventionin1909。DuringourfirstyearinthesebeautifulFifthAvenueroomsMrs。
PankhurstmadeherfirstvisittoAmerica,andwegaveherareceptionthere。This,however,wasbeforetheadoptionofthedestructivemethodswhichhavesincemarkedtheactivitiesofthebandofmilitantsuffragistsofwhichMrs。Pankhurstispresident。TherehasneverbeenanysympathyamongAmericansuffragistsforthemilitantsuffragemovementinEngland,andpersonallyIamwhollyopposedtoit。Idonotbelieveinwarinanyform;
andifviolenceonthepartofmenisundesirableinachievingtheirends,itismuchmoresoonthepartofwomen;forwomenneverappeartolessadvan—
tagethaninphysicalcombatswithmen。AsformilitancyinAmerica,nogenerationthatattempteditcouldwin。Novictorycouldcometousinanystatewheremilitantmethodsweretried。Theyareundignified,unworthy——inotherwords,un—Ameri—
can。
TheWashingtonconventionof1910wasgracedbythepresenceofPresidentTaft,who,atthein—
vitationofMrs。RachelFosterAvery,madeanaddress。Itwasunderstood,ofcourse,thathewastocomeoutstronglyforwomansuffrage;but,toourgreatdisappointment,thePresident,amostcharmingandlikablegentleman,seemedunabletograspthesignificanceoftheoccasion。Hebeganhisaddresswithfulsomepraiseofwomen,whichwasacceptedinrespectfulsilence。Thenhegotroundtowomansuffrage,flounderedhelplessly,becameconfused,andendedwiththemostunfortunatelychosenwordshecouldhaveuttered:``Iamop—
posed,’’hesaid,``totheextensionofsuffragetowomennotfittedtovote。Youwouldhardlyexpecttoputtheballotintothehandsofbarbariansorsavagesinthejungle!’’
Thedroppingoftheseremarkablewordsintoasuffrageconventionwasnaturallyfollowedbyanoppressivesilence,whichMr。Taft,nowwhollybereftofhisself—possession,brokebysayingthatthebestwomenwouldnotvoteandtheworstwomenwould。
Inhisaudienceweremanywomenfromsuffragestates——high—mindedwomen,wivesandmothers,whohadvotedforMr。Taft。Theremarkstowhichtheyhadjustlistenedmusthaveseemedtothemapoorreturn。Someonehissed——someman,somewoman——nooneknowswhichexcepttheculprit——
andademonstrationstartedwhichIimmediatelysilenced。ThenthePresidentfinishedhisaddress。
Hewasverygracioustouswhenheleft,shakinghandswithmanyofus,andbeingespeciallycordialtoSenatorOwens’sagedmother,whohadcometotheconventiontohearhimmakehismaidenspeechonwomansuffrage。IhaveoftenwonderedwhathethoughtofthatspeechashedrovebacktotheWhiteHouse。Probablyheregrettedasearnestlyaswedidthathehadmadeit。
In1912,atanofficialboardmeetingatBrynMawr,Mrs。StanleyMcCormackwasappointedtofillavacancyontheNationalBoard。Sub—
sequentlyshecontributed$6,000towardthepay—
mentofdebtsincidenttoourtemporaryconnec—
tionwiththeWoman’sJournalofBoston,anddidmuchefficientworkforus,Tome,personally,theentranceofMrs。StanleyMcCormackintoourworkhasbeenasourceofthedeepestgrati—
ficationandcomfort。IcantrulysayofherwhatSusanB。Anthonysaidofme,``Sheismyrightbower。’’AtNashville,in1914,shewaselectedfirstvice—president,andtoaremarkabledegreeshehassincerelievedmeoftheburdenofthetechnicalworkofthepresidency,includingtheoversightoftheworkatheadquarters。Tothisshegivesallhertime,aidedbyanexecutivesecretarywhotakeschargeoftheroutineworkoftheassociation。Shehasthusmadeitpossibleformetogivethegreaterpartofmytimetothefieldinwhichsuchinspiringopportunitiesstillconfrontus——campaignworkinthevariousstates。
ToMrs。MedillMcCormackalsoweareindebtedformostadmirableworkandenthusiasticsupport。
AttheWashington(D。C。)conventionin1913shewasmadethechairmanoftheCongressionalCom—
mittee,withMrs。AntoinetteFunk,Mrs。HelenGardnerofWashington,andMrs。BoothofChicagoasherassistants。Theresultstheyachievedweresobrilliantthattheywereunanimouslyre—electedtothesamepositionsthisyear,withtheadditionofMissJeannetteRankin,whoseenergyandservicehadhelpedtowinforusthestateofMontana。
ItwaslargelyduetotheworkofthisCongress—
ionalCommittee,supportedbythelargenumberofstateswhichhadbeenwonforsuffrage,thatwesecuredsuchanexcellentvoteintheLowerHouseofCongressonthebilltoamendthenationalCon—
stitutiongrantingsuffragetothewomenoftheUnitedStates。Thismeasure,knownastheSusanB。Anthonybill,hadbeenintroducedintoeveryCongressforforty—threeyearsbytheNationalWomanSuffrageAssociation。In1914,forthefirsttime,itwasbroughtoutofcommittee,debated,andvoteduponintheLowerHouse。Wereceived174votesinfavorofitto204againstit。Thepreviousspring,inthesameCongress,thesamebillpassedtheSenateby35votesforitto33votesagainstit。
ThemostinterestingfeaturesoftheWashingtonconventionof1913werethelabormass—meetingsledbyJaneAddamsandthehearingbeforetheRulesCommitteeoftheLowerHouseofCon—
gress——thelatterthefirsthearingeverheldbe—
forethisCommitteeforthepurposeofsecuringaCommitteeonSuffrageintheLowerHousetocorrespondwithasimilarcommitteeintheSen—
ate。Formanyyearswehadhadhearingsbe—
foretheJudiciaryCommitteeoftheLowerHouse,whichwassuchabusycommitteethatithadneithertimenorinteresttogivetoourmeasure。Wethere—
foreconsidereditnecessarytohaveaspecialcom—
mitteeofourown。ThehearingbeganonthemorningofWednesday,thethirdofDecember,andlastedfortwohours。Thentheanti—suffragistsweregiventime,andtheirhearingbeganthefollowingday,continuedthroughoutthatdayandduringthemorningofthenextday,whenourNationalAssociationwasgivenanopportunityforrebuttalargumentintheafternoon。Itwasthelongesthear—
inginthehistoryofthesuffragemovement,andoneofthemostimportant。
DuringthesessionofCongressin1914anotherstrenuouseffortwasmadetosecuretheappoint—
mentofaspecialsuffragecommitteeintheLowerHouse。Butwhensuccessbegantoloomlargebe—
foreustheDemocratswerecalledincaucusbytheminorityleader,Mr。Underwood,ofAlabama,andtheydownedourmeasurebyavoteof127againstitto58forit。ThiswasevidentlydonebytheDemocratsbecauseofthefearthattheunitedvotesofRepublicanandProgressivemembers,withthoseofcertainDemocraticmembers,wouldcarrythemeasure;whereasifthiscaucuswerecalled,andanunfavorablevotetaken,``thegentlemen’sagree—
ment’’whichcontrolsDemocraticpartyactioninCongresswouldforceDemocratsinfavorofsuffragetovoteagainsttheappointmentofthecommittee,whichofcoursewouldinsureitsdefeat。
Thecaucusblockedtheappointmentofthecom—
mittee,butitgavegreatencouragementtothesuf—
fragistsofthecountry,fortheyknewittobeatacitadmissionthatthemeasurewouldreceiveafavor—
ablevoteifitcamebeforeCongressunhampered。
Anotherfeatureofthe1913conventionwasthenewmethodofelectingofficers,bywhichaprimaryvotewastakenonnominations,andafterwardaregularballotwascast;oneofficerwasaddedtothemembersoftheofficialboard,makingnineinsteadofeight,theformernumber。ThenewofficerselectedwereMrs。BreckenridgeofKentucky,thegreat—granddaughterofHenryClay,andMrs。
CatherineRuutz—ReesofGreenwich,Connecticut。
Theoldofficerswerere—elected——MissJaneAddamsasfirstvice—president,Mrs。BreckenridgeandMrs。
Ruutz—Reesassecondandthirdvice—presidents,Mrs。MaryWareDennettascorrespondingsecre—
tary,Mrs。SusanFitzgeraldasrecordingsecretary,Mrs。StanleyMcCormackastreasurer,Mrs。JosephBowenofChicagoandMrs。JamesLeesLaidlawofNewYorkCityasauditors。
Itwouldbedifficulttosecureagroupofwomenofmoremarkedability,orbetter—knownworkersinvariouslinesofphilanthropicandeducationalwork,thanthememberscomposingthisadmirableboard。
Attheconventionof1914,heldinNashville,severalofthemresigned,andatpresent(in1914)the``National’s’’affairsareinthehandsofthisin—
spiringgroup,againheadedbythemuch—criticizedandchastenedwriterofthesereminiscences:
Mrs。StanleyMcCormack,firstvice—president。
Mrs。DeshaBreckenridge,secondvice—president。
Dr。KatharineB。Davis,thirdvice—president。
Mrs。HenryWadeRogers,treasurer。
Mrs。JohnClark,correspondingsecretary。
Mrs。SusanWalkerFitzgerald,recordingsecretary。
Mrs。MedillMcCormack,}
}AuditorsMrs。WalterMcNabbMiller,ofMissouri}
Inabookofthissize,andcoveringthedetailsofmyownlifeaswellasthedevelopmentofthegreatCause,itis,ofcourse,impossibletomentionbynameeachwomanwhohasworkedforus——
though,indeed,Iwouldliketomakearollofhonorandgivethemalltheirdue。InlookingbackIamsur—
prisedtoseehowlittleIhavesaidaboutmanywomenwithwhomIhaveworkedmostclosely——RachelFosterAvery,forexample,withwhomIlivedhappilyforseveralyears;IdaHustedHarper,thehistorianofthesuffragemovementandthebiographerofMissAnthony,withwhomImademanydelightfulvoy—
agestoEurope;AliceStoneBlackwell,Rev。MarySaffard,JaneAddams,KatharineWaughMcCul—
lough,EllaStewart,Mrs。MaryWoodSwift,Mrs。
MaryS。Sperry,MaryCogshall,FlorenceKelly,Mrs。OgdenMillsReidandMrs。NormanWhite—
house(tomentiononlytwooftheyounger``livewires’’inourNewYorkwork),SophonisbaBreck—
enridge,Mrs。ClaraB。Arthur,Rev。CarolineBart—
lettCrane,Mrs。JamesLeesLaidlaw,Mrs。RaymondBrown,thesplendidlyexecutivepresidentofourNewYorkStateSuffrageAssociation,andmybene—
factress,Mrs。GeorgeHowardLewisofBuffalo。Toallofthem,andtothousandsofothers,Imakemygratefulacknowledgmentofindebtednessforfriend—
shipandforhelp。
XVI
COUNCILEPISODES
IhavesaidmuchoftheinterestattendingtheinternationalmeetingsheldinChicago,London,Berlin,andStockholm。ThatIhavesaidlessaboutthoseinCopenhagen,Geneva,TheHague,Budapest,andothercitiesdoesnotmeanthatthesewerelessimportant,andcertainlythewonderfulwomenleadersofEuropewhomadethemsobrilliantmustnotbepassedoverinsilence。
First,however,thedifferencebetweentheSuf—
frageAlliancemeetingsandtheInternationalCoun—
cilmeetingsshouldbeexplained。TheCouncilmeetingsaremadeupofsocietiesfromthevariousnationswhichareauxiliarytotheInternationalCouncil——thesesocietiesrepresentingalllinesofwomen’sactivities,whethereducational,industrial,orsocial,whilethemembership,includingmorethanelevenmillionwomen,representsprobablythelargestorganizationofwomenintheworld。TheInternationalSuffrageAlliancerepresentsthesuf—
frageinterestprimarily,whereastheInternationalCouncilhasonlyasuffragedepartment。Sopopu—
lardidthisInternationalAlliancebecomeafteritsformationinBerlinbyMrs。Catt,in1904,thatattheCopenhagenmeeting,onlythreeyearslater,morethansixteendifferentnationswererepresentedbyregulardelegates。
Itwasunfortunate,therefore,thatIchosethisoccasiontomakeaspectacularpersonalfailureinthepulpit。Ihadbeeninvitedtopreachthecon—
ventionsermon,andforthefirsttimeinmylifeIhadaninterpreter。Fewexperiences,Ibelieve,canbemoreunpleasantthantostandupinapul—
pit,utteraremark,andthenwaitpatientlywhileitisrepeatedinatongueonedoesnotunderstand,byamanwhoisputtingitsgistinhisownwordsandquitepossiblygivingithisowninterpretativetwist。
Iwasveryunhappy,andIfearIshowedit,forI
felt,asIlookedatthefacesofthosefriendswhounderstoodDanish,thattheywerenotgettingwhatIwasgivingthem。Norwerethey,forIafterwardlearnedthattheinterpreter,agoodorthodoxbrother,hadgiventhesermonanultra—orthodoxbiaswhichthosewhoknewmycreedcertainlydidnotrecognize。Thewholeexperiencegreatlydis—
heartenedme,butnodoubtitwasgoodformysoul。
DuringtheCopenhagenmeetingweweregivenabanquetbytheCityCouncil,andinthecourseofhisspeechofwelcomeoneofthecityfathersairilyremarkedthathehopedonournextvisittoCopen—
hagentherewouldbewomenmembersintheCounciltoreceiveus。Atthetimethisseemedmerelyapleasantjest,buttwoyearsfromthatdayabillwasenactedbyParliamentgrantingmunicipalsuf—
fragetothewomenofDenmark,andsevenwomenwereelectedtotheCityCouncilofCopenhagen。
Sorapidlydoesthewomansuffragemovementgrowintheseinspiringdays!
RecallingtheInternationalCouncilof1899inLondon,oneofmymostvividpictureshasQueenVictoriaforitscentralfigure。TheEnglishcourtwasinmourningatthetimeandnopublicaudienceswerebeingheld;butwewereinvitedtoWindsorwiththeunderstandingthat,althoughtheQueencouldnotformallyreceiveus,shewouldpassthroughourlines,receivingLadyAberdeenandgivingtherestofusanopportunitytocourtesyandobtainHerMajesty’srecognitionoftheCause。
TheQueenarrangedwithherchamberlainthatweshouldbegiventeaandacollation;butbeforethisrefreshmentwasserved,indeedimmediatelyafterourarrival,sheenteredherfamiliarlittlepony—cartandwasdrivenslowlyalonglinesofbowingwomenwhomusthavelookedlikeawheat—fieldinahighwind。
AmonguswasagroupofIndianwomen,andthese,dressedintheirnativecostumes,contributedapicturesquebitofbrilliantcolortothesceneastheydeeplysalaamed。TheyarrestedtheeyeoftheQueen,whostoppedandspokeafewcordialwordstothem。Thisgavetherestofusanexcellentopportunitytoobserveherclosely,andIadmitthatmyEnglishbloodstirredinmesuddenlyandloyallyasIstudiedtheplumplittlefigure。Shewasdressedentirelyandverysimplyinblack,withaquaintflatblackhatandablackcape。Theonlybitofcoloraboutherwasablack—and—whiteparasolwithagoldhandle。Itwas,however,herfacewhichheldme,foritgavemeawhollydifferentimpressionoftheQueenfromthoseIhadreceivedfromherphotographs。Herpicturedeyeswerealwaysrathercold,andherpicturedfaceratherhaughty;buttherewasaverysweetandwinningsoftnessintheeyessheturnedupontheIndianwomen,andherwholeexpressionwasunexpectedlygentleandbenignant。
Behindher,asapersonalattendant,strodeanenormousEast—Indianinfullnativecostume,andcloselysurroundingherweregentlemenofherhouse—
hold,eachinuniform。
Bythistimemythoughtswereonmycourtesy,whichIdesiredtomakeconventionalifnotgrace—
ful;butnaturehasnotmadeiteasyformetodoubletotheearthasLadyAberdeenandtheIn—
dianwomenweredoing,andIfearIaccomplishedlittlesaveanexhibitionofgoodintentions。TheQueen,however,wasgettingintothespiritoftheoccasion。ShestoppedtospeaktoaCanadianrepresentative,andshewould,Ithink,haveendedbytalkingtomanyothers;but,justatthepsycho—
logicalmoment,awomanrushedoutoftheline,seizedHerMajesty’shandandkissedit——andVic—
toria,startledandpossiblyfearingageneralon—
slaught,hurriedlypassedon。
AnotherpictureIrecallwasmadebytheDuchessofSutherland,theCountessofAberdeen,andtheCountessofWarwickstandingtogethertoreceiveusatthefootofthemarblestairwayinSutherlandHouse。Allofthemliterallyblazedwithjewels,andtheCountessofAberdeenworethefamousAber—
deenemerald。AtLadyBattersea’sreceptionIhadmyfirstmemorialmeetingwithMaryAndersonNavarro,andwasabletothankherforthepleasureshehadgivenmeinBostonsolongago。ThenI
reproachedhermildlyfortakingherselfawayfromus,pointingoutthatagreatgifthadbeengivenherwhichsheshouldhavecontinuedtosharewiththeworld。
``Comeandseemybaby,’’laughedMadameNavarro。``That’sthebestargumentIcanoffertorefuteyours。’’
AtthesamereceptionIhadaninterestingtalkwithJamesBryce。HehadrecentlywrittenhisAmericanCommonwealth,andIhadjustreadit。
Itwas,therefore,thefirstsubjectIintroducedinourconversation。Mr。Bryce’scommentamusedme。Hetoldmehehadquitechangedhisopiniontowardthesuffrageaspirationsofwomen,becausesomanywomenhadreadhisbookthathereallybelievedtheywereintelligent,andhehadcometofeelmuchmorekindlytowardthem。Thesewerenothisexactwords,buthismeaningwasunmistak—
ableandhismentalattitudeartlesslysincere。And,onreflection,IagreewithhimthattheAmericanCommonwealthissomethingofanintellectualhurdlefortheaveragehumanmind。
In1908theInternationalCouncilwasheldinGeneva,andhere,forthefirsttime,wewereshown,asentertainment,thedancesofacountry——thescenebeinganespeciallybrilliantone,asallthedancersworetheirnativecostumes。Also,forthefirsttimeinthehistoryofGeneva,thebuildingsofParliamentwereopenedtowomenandawoman’sorganizationwasgiventhekeytothecity。AtthattimetheSwisswomenweremakingtheirfightforavoteinchurchmatters,andwehelpedtheircauseasmuchaswecould。To—daymanySwisswomenarepermittedtoexercisethisright——thefirstpoliticalprivilegefreeSwitzerlandhasgiventhem。
TheInternationalAlliancemeetinginAmster—
damin1909wasthelargesthelduptothattime,andmuchofitssuccesswasduetoDr。AlettaJacobs,thepresidentoftheNationalSuffrageAssociationofHolland。Dr。Jacobshadsomewonderfulhelpersamongthewomenofhercountry,andsheherselfwasanidealleader——patient,enthusiastic,andtire—
less。ThatyearthegovernmentsofAustralia,Nor—
way,andFinlandpaidtheexpensesofthedelegatesfromthosecountries——ahearteninginnovation。OneoftheinterestingfeaturesofthemeetingwasacantatacomposedfortheoccasionandgivenbytheQueen’sRoyalBand,underthedirectionofawoman——CatharinevanRennes,oneofthemostdistinguishedcomposersandteachersinHolland。
Shewrotebothwordsandmusicofhercantataanddirecteditadmirably;andthemusiciansoftheQueen’sBandenteredfullyintoitsspiritandplayedlikemeninspired。Thatnightwehadmoremusic,aswellasanever—to—be—forgottenexhibitionoffolk—
dancing。
Thesameyear,inJune,weheldthemeetingoftheInternationalCouncilinToronto,and,asCanadahasneverbeeneagerlyinterestedinsuffrage,anun—
successfuleffortwasmadetoexcludethissubjectfromtheprogramme。IwasaskedtopresideatthesuffragemeetingsontheartlessandobvioustheorythatIwouldthusbekepttoobusytosaymuch。
IhadhopedthattheCountessofAberdeen,whowasthepresidentoftheInternationalCouncil,wouldtakethechair;butshedeclinedtodothis,oreventospeak,astheEarlofAberdeenhadrecentlybeenappointedViceroyofIreland,andshedesiredtosparehimanyembarrassmentwhichmightbecausedbyherpublicactivities。Werecognizedthewisdomofherdecision,but,ofcourse,regrettedit;andIwasthereforeespeciallypleasedwhen,onsuffragenight,thecountess,accompaniedbyheraidesintheirbrilliantuniforms,enteredthehall。
Wehadnotbeensurethatshewouldbewithus,butsheenteredinherusualcharmingandgra—
ciousmanner,tookaseatbesidemeontheplatform,andshowedadeepinterestintheprogrammeandthegreatgatheringbeforeus。
AsthemeetingwentonIsawthatshewasgrow—
ingmoreandmoreenthusiastic,andtowardtheendoftheeveningIquietlyaskedherifshedidnotwishtosayafewwords。Shesaidshewouldsayaveryfew。Ihadputmyselfattheendoftheprogramme,intendingtotalkabouttwentyminutes;
butbeforebeginningmyspeechIintroducedthecountess,andbythistimeshewassoenthusiasticthat,tomygreatdelight,sheusedupmytwentyminutesinacapitalspeechinwhichshecameoutvigorouslyforwomansuffrage。Itgaveusthebestandtimeliesthelpwecouldhavehad,andwasagreatimpetustothemovement。