``No,no,’’sheobjected。``Youcannotbethejudgeofthat。Promisemeyouwillremainuntilthefriendsyoumosttrusttellyouitistimetowith—
draw,ormakeyouunderstandthatitistime。
Promisemethat。’’
Imadethepromise。Sheseemedcontent,andagainbegantotalkofthefuture。
``Youwillnothaveaneasypath,’’shewarnedme。``Insomewaysitwillbeharderforyouthanithaseverbeenforme。Iwassomucholderthantherestofyou,andIhadbeenpresidentsolong,thatyougirlshaveallbeenwillingtolistentome。Itwillbedifferentwithyou。Otherwomenofyourownagehavebeenintheworkalmostaslongasyouhavebeen;youdonotstandoutfromthembyageorlengthofservice,asIdid。Therewillbeinevi—
tablejealousiesandmisunderstandings;therewillbeallsortsofcriticismandmisrepresentation。Mylastwordtoyouisthis:Nomatterwhatisdoneorisnotdone,howyouarecriticizedormisunder—
stood,orwhateffortsaremadetoblockyourpath,rememberthattheonlyfearyouneedhaveisthefearofnotstandingbythethingyoubelievetoberight。Takeyourstandandholdit;thenletcomewhatwill,andreceiveblowslikeagoodsoldier。’’
Iwastoomuchovercometoanswerher;andafteramomentofsilenceshe,inherturn,mademeapromise。
``Idonotknowanythingaboutwhatcomestousafterthislifeends,’’shesaid。``Butifthereisacontinuanceoflifebeyondit,andifIhaveanyconsciousknowledgeofthisworldandofwhatyouaredoing,Ishallnotbefarawayfromyou;andintimesofneedIwillhelpyouallIcan。Whoknows?
PerhapsImaybeabletodomorefortheCauseafterIamgonethanwhileIamhere。’’
Nineyearshavepassedsincethen,andineachdayofthemallitseemstome,inlookingback,I
havehadsomeoccasiontorecallherwords。WhentheywereutteredIdidnotfullycomprehendalltheymeant,ortheclearnessofthevisionthathadsuggestedthem。ItseemedtomethatnopositionIcouldholdwouldbeofsufficientimportancetoattractjealousyorpersonalattacks。Theyearshavebroughtmorewisdom;Ihavelearnedthatanyonewhoassumesleadership,orwho,likemyself,hashadleadershipforceduponher,mustexpecttobearmanythingsofwhichtheworldknowsnothing。
Butwiththisknowledge,too,hascomethememoryof``AuntSusan’s’’lastpromise,andagainandyetagaininhoursofdiscouragementanddespairIhavebeenhelpedbytheblessedconvictionthatshewaskeepingit。
Duringthelastforty—eighthoursofherlifeshewasunwillingthatIshouldleaveherside。SodayandnightIkneltbyherbed,holdingherhandandwatchingtheflameofherwonderfulspiritgrowdim。
Attimes,eventhen,itblazedupwithstartlingsud—
denness。Onthelastafternoonofherlife,whenshehadlainquietforhours,shesuddenlybegantoutterthenamesofthewomenwhohadworkedwithher,asifinafinalroll—call。Manyofthemhadprecededherintothenextworld;otherswerestillsplendidlyactiveintheworkshewaslayingdown。Butyoungorold,livingordead,theyallseemedtofilepastherdyingeyesthatdayinanendless,shadowyre—
view,andastheywentbyshespoketoeachofthem。
Notallthenamesshementionedwereknowninsuffrageranks;someofthesewomenlivedonlyintheheartofSusanB。Anthony,andnow,forthelasttime,shewasthankingthemforwhattheyhaddone。Herewasonewho,atamomentofspecialneed,hadgivenhersmallsavings;herewasanotherwhohadwonvaluablerecruitstotheCause;thisonehadwrittenastrongeditorial;thatonehadmadeastirringspeech。Inthesefinalhoursitseemedthatnotasinglesacrificeorservice,howeversmall,hadbeenforgottenbythedyingleader。Lastofall,shespoketothewomenwhohadbeenonherboardandhadstoodbyherloyallysolong——RachelFosterAvery,AliceStoneBlackwell,CarrieChap—
manCatt,Mrs。Upton,LauraClay,andothers。
Then,afterlyinginsilenceforalongtimewithhercheekonmyhand,shemurmured:``Theyarestillpassingbeforeme——faceafterface,hundredsandhundredsofthem,representingalltheeffortsoffiftyyears。IknowhowhardtheyhaveworkedIknowthesacrificestheyhavemade。Butithasallbeenworthwhile!’’
Justbeforeshelapsedintounconsciousnesssheseemedrestlessandanxioustosaysomething,search—
ingmyfacewithherdimmingeyes。
``Doyouwantmetorepeatmypromise?’’I
asked,forshehadalreadymademedososeveraltimes。Shemadeasignofassent,andIgavehertheassuranceshedesired。AsIdidsosheraisedmyhandtoherlipsandkissedit——herlastconsciousaction。FormorethanthirtyhoursafterthatI
kneltbyherside,butthoughsheclungtomyhanduntilherownhandgrewcold,shedidnotspeakagain。
Shehadtoldmeoverandoverhowmuchourlongfriendshipandassociationhadmeanttoher,andthecomfortIhadgivenher。ButwhateverImayhavebeentoher,itwasasnothingcomparedwithwhatshewastome。Kneelingclosetoherasshepassedaway,IknewthatIwouldhavegivenheradozenliveshadIhadthem,andenduredathousandtimesmorehardshipthanwehadbornetogether,fortheinspirationofhercompanionshipandthejoyofheraffection。TheywerethegreatestblessingsIhavehadinallmylife,andIcherishasmydearesttreas—
urethevolumeofherHistoryofWomanSuffrageonthefly—leafofwhichshehadwrittenthisin—
scription:
REVERENDANNAHOWARDSHAW:
ThishugevolumeIVIpresenttoyouwiththelovethatamotherbeareth,andIhopeyouwillfindinitthefactsaboutwomen,foryouwillfindthemnowhereelse。Yourpartwillbetoseethatthefourvolumesaredulyplacedinthelibrariesofthecountry,whereeverystudentofhistorymayhaveaccesstothem。
Withunboundedloveandfaith,SUSANB。ANTHONY。
Thatfinallineisstillmygreatestcomfort。WhenIammisrepresentedormisunderstood,whenIamaccusedofpersonalambitionorofworkingforper—
sonalends,Iturntoitandtosimilarlinespennedbythesamehand,andtellmyselfthatIshouldnotallowanythingtointerferewiththeserenityofmyspiritortodisturbmeinmywork。Attheendofeighteenyearsofthemostintimatecompanionship,theleaderofourCause,thegreatestwomanIhaveeverknown,stillfeltforme``unboundedloveandfaith。’’Havinghadthat,Ihavehadenough。
Fortwodaysafter``AuntSusan’s’’deathshelayinherownhome,asifinrestfulslumber,herfacewearingitsmostexquisitelookofpeacefulserenity;
andhereherspecialfriends,thepoorandtheunfor—
tunateofthecity,camebyhundredstopaytheirlastrespects。Onthethirddaytherewasapublicfuneral,heldintheCongregationalchurch,and,thoughawildblizzardwasraging,everyoneinRochesterseemedincludedinthegreatthrongofmournerswhocametoherbierinreverenceandleftitintears。Thechurchserviceswereconductedbythepastor,theRev。C。C。Albertson,alifelongfriendofMissAnthony’s,assistedbytheRev。Will—
iamC。Gannett。JamesG。Potter,theMayorofthecity,andDr。RushRhees,presidentofRochesterUniversity,occupiedprominentplacesamongthedistinguishedmourners,andMrs。JeromeJeffries,theheadofacoloredschool,spokeinbehalfofthenegroraceanditsrecognitionofMissAnthony’sservices。Collegeclubs,medicalsocieties,andre—
formgroupswererepresentedbydelegatessentfromdifferentstates,andMissAnnaGordonhadcomeonfromIllinoistorepresenttheWoman’sNationalChristianTemperanceUnion。Mrs。CattdeliveredaeulogyinwhichsheexpressedtheloveandrecognitionoftheorganizedsuffragewomenoftheworldforMissAnthony,astheonetowhomtheyhadalllookedastheirleader。WilliamLloydGarrisonspokeofMissAnthony’sworkwithhisfatherandotheranti—
slaveryleaders,andMrs。JeanBrooksGreenleafspokeinbehalfoftheNewYorkStateSuffrageAssociation。Then,as``AuntSusan’’hadrequested,Imadetheclosingaddress。Shehadaskedmetodothisandtopronouncethebenediction,aswellastosaythefinalwordsathergrave。
Itwasestimatedthatmorethantenthousandpersonswereassembledinandaroundthechurch,andafterthebenedictionthosewhohadbeenpa—
tientlywaitingoutinthestormwerepermittedtopassinsideinsinglefileforalastlookattheirfriend。TheyfoundthecoffincoveredbyalargeAmericanflag,onwhichlayawreathoflaurelandpalms;arounditstoodaguardofhonorcomposedofgirlstudentsofRochesterUniversityintheircollegecapsandgowns。Alldaystudentshadmountedguard,relievingoneanotheratintervals。
Oneverysidetherewereflowersandfloralemblemssentbyvariousorganizations,andjustover``AuntSusan’s’’headfloatedthesilkflaggiventoherbythewomenofColorado。Itcontainedfourgoldstars,representingthefourenfranchisedstates,whiletheotherstarswereinsilver。OnherbreastwaspinnedthejeweledflaggiventoheronhereightiethbirthdaybythewomenofWyoming——thefirstplaceintheworldwhereintheconstitutionofthestatewomenweregivenequalpoliticalrightswithmen。Herethefourstarsrepresentingtheenfranchisedstatesweremadeofdiamonds,theothersofsilverenamel。JustbeforethelidwasfastenedonthecoffinthisflagwasremovedandhandedtoMaryAnthony,whopresentedittome。
FromthatdayIhavewornitoneveryoccasionofimportancetoourCause,andeachtimeastateiswonforwomansuffrageIhaveaddedanewdiamondstar。AtthetimeIwritethis——in1914——therearetwelve。
AsthefuneralprocessionwentthroughthestreetsofRochesteritwasseenthatallthecityflagswereathalf—mast,byorderoftheCityCouncil。Manyhousesweredrapedinblack,andthegriefofthecitizensmanifesteditselfoneveryside。AllthewaytoMountHopeCemeterythesnowwhirledblind—
inglyaroundus,whilethemassesthathadfallencoveredtheearthasfaraswecouldseeafittingwinding—sheetfortheonewhohadgone。Underthefir—treesaroundheropengraveIobeyed``AuntSusan’s’’wishthatIshouldutterthelastwordsspokenoverherbodyasshewaslaidtorest:
``Dearfriend,’’Isaid,``thouhasttarriedwithuslong。Nowthouhastgonetothywell—earnedrest。
WebeseechtheInfiniteSpiritWhohasupheldtheetomakeusworthytofollowinthystepsandtocarryonthywork。Hailandfarewell。’’
XI
THEWIDENINGSUFFRAGESTREAM
InmychaptersonMissAnthonyIbridgedthetwentyyearsbetween1886and1906,omittingmanyofthestirringsuffrageeventsofthatlongperiod,inmydesiretoconcentrateonthosewhichmostvitallyconcernedher。Imustnowretracemystepsalongthewideningsuffragestreamandde—
scribe,consecutivelyatleast,andasfullyastheseincompletereminiscenceswillpermit,otherinci—
dentsthatoccurredonitsbanks。
Ofthesethemostimportantwastheunionin1889ofthetwogreatsuffragesocieties——theAmeri—
canAssociation,ofwhichLucyStonewasthepresi—
dent,andtheNationalAssociation,headedbySusanB。AnthonyandElizabethCadyStanton。AtaconventionheldinWashingtonthesesocietiesweremergedasTheNationalAmericanWomanSuffrageAssociation——thenameourassociationstillbears——
andMrs。Stantonwaselectedpresident。Shewasthennearlyeightyandpastactivework,butshemadeawonderfulpresidingofficeratoursubsequentmeetings,andshewasaspicturesqueasshewasefficient。
MissAnthony,whohadanimmenseadmirationforherandagreatpersonalprideinher,alwaysescortedhertothecapital,and,havingworkedherutmosttomakethemeetingasuccess,invariablygaveMrs。Stantoncreditforallthatwasaccom—
plished。SheoftensaidthatMrs。Stantonwasthebrainsofthenewassociation,whilesheherselfwasmerelyitshandsandfeet;butintruththetwowomenworkedmarvelouslytogether,forMrs。
StantonwasamasterofwordsandcouldwriteandspeaktoperfectionofthethingsSusanB。Anthonysawandfeltbutcouldnotherselfexpress。UsuallyMissAnthonywenttoMrs。Stanton’shouseandtookchargeofitwhileshestimulatedthevenerablepresidenttothewritingofherannualaddress。
Then,atthesubsequentconvention,shewouldlistentothereportwithasmuchdelightandpleasureasifeachwordofithadbeennewtoher。EvenafterMrs。Stanton’sresignationfromthepresidency——
attheend,Ithink,ofthreeyears——andMissAn—
thony’selectionashersuccessor,``AuntSusan’’stillwenttoheroldfriendwheneveranimportantreso—
lutionwastobewritten,andMrs。Stantonloyallydrafteditforher。
Mrs。Stantonwasthemostbrilliantconversa—
tionalistIhaveeverknown;andthebesttalkI
haveheardanywherewasthattowhichIusedtolisteninthehomeofMrs。ElizaWrightOsborne,inAuburn,NewYork,whenMrs。Stanton,SusanB。Anthony,EmilyHowland,ElizabethSmithMiller,IdaHustedHarper,MissMills,andIweregatheredthereforouroccasionalweek—endvisits。
Mrs。Osborneinheritedhersuffragesympathies,forshewasthedaughterofMarthaWright,who,withMrs。StantonandLucretiaMott,calledthefirstsuffrageconventioninSenecaFalls,NewYork。I
mustaddinpassingthatherson,ThomasMottOsborne,whoisdoingsuchadmirableworkinprisonreformatSingSing,hasshownhimselfworthyofthegiftedandhigh—mindedmotherwhogavehimtotheworld。
MostoftheconversationinMrs。Osborne’shomewascontributedbyMrs。StantonandMissAnthony,whiletherestofussat,asitwere,attheirfeet。
Manyhumanandfemininetouchesbrightenedtheloftydiscussionsthatwereconstantlygoingon,andthevariedcharacteristicsofourleaderscroppedupinamusingfashion。Mrs。Stanton,forexample,wasrarelyaccurateingivingfiguresordates,whileMissAnthonywasalwaysveryexactinsuchmatters。
ShefrequentlycorrectedMrs。Stanton’sstatements,andMrs。Stantonusuallytooktheinterruptioninthebestpossiblespirit,promptlyadmittingthat``AuntSusan’’knewbest。OnoneoccasionIre—
call,however,sheheldfasttoheropinionthatshewasrightastothemonthinwhichacertaininci—
denthadoccurred。
``No,Susan,’’sheinsisted,``you’rewrongforonce。Irememberperfectlywhenthathappened,foritwasatthetimeIwasbeginningtoweanHarriet。’’
AuntSusan,thoughsomewhatstaggeredbytheforceofthistestimony,stillmaintainedthatMrs。
Stantonmustbemistaken,whereuponthelatterrepeated,inexasperation,``ItellyouithappenedwhenIwasweaningHarriet。’’Andsheadded,scornfully,``Whateventhaveyougottoreckonfrom?’’
MissAnthonymeeklysubsided。
Mrs。Stantonhadwonderfulblueeyes,whichheldtotheendofherlifeanexpressionofeternalyouth。Duringourconventionssheusuallytookalittlenapintheafternoon,andwhensheawokeherblueeyesalwayshadanexpressionofpleasedandinnocentsurprise,asifsheweregazingontheworldforthefirsttime——theround,unwinking,interestedlookababy’seyeshavewhensomethingattractiveisheldupbeforethem。
Letmegiveinaparagraph,beforeIswingoffintothebypathsthatalwaysallureme,theconsecutivesuffrageeventsofthepastquarterofacentury。
Havingdonethis,IcandwelloneachascasuallyasIchoose,foritispossibletodescribeonlyafewincidentshereandthere;andIshallnotbedepart—
ingfromthestoryofmylife,formylifehadbecomemergedinthesuffragecause。
OfthepreliminarysuffragecampaignsinKansas,madeincompanywith``AuntSusan,’’Ihaveal—
readywritten,anditremainsonlytosaythatdur—
ingthesecondKansascampaignyellowwasadoptedasthesuffragecolor。In1890,’92,and’93weagainworkedinKansasandinSouthDakota,withsuchindefatigableandbrilliantspeakersasMrs。Catt(towhoseeffortsalsowerelargelyduethewinningofColoradoin’93),Mrs。LauraJohnsofKansas,Mrs。JuliaNelson,HenryB。Blackwell,Dr。HelenV。PutnamofDakota,Mrs。EmmaSmithDeVoe,Rev。OlympiaBrowneofWisconsin,andDr。MarySeymourHowellofNewYork。In’94,’95,and’96
specialeffortsweredevotedtoIdaho,Utah,Cali—
fornia,andWashington,andfromthenonourcampaignswerewagedsteadilyintheWesternstates。
TheColoradovictorygaveustwofullsuffragestates,forin1869theTerritoryofWyominghaden—
franchisedwomenunderveryinterestingconditions,notnowgenerallyremembered。Theachievementwasduetotheinfluenceofonewoman,EstherMorris,apioneerwhowasasgoodaneighborasshewasasuffragist。Inthoseearlydays,inhomesfarfromphysiciansandsurgeons,thewomencaredforoneanotherinsickness,andEstherMorris,asithappened,oncetookfullandskilfulchargeofaneighborduringthedifficultbirthofthelatter’schild。Shehaddonethesamethingformanyotherwomen,butthiswoman’shusbandwasespeciallygrateful。HewasalsoamemberoftheLegislature,andhetoldMrs。Morristhatiftherewasanymeasureshewishedputthroughforthewomenoftheterritoryhewouldbegladtointroduceit。
Sheimmediatelytookhimathiswordbyaskinghimtointroduceabillenfranchisingwomen,andhepromptlydidso。
TheLegislaturewasDemocratic,anditpounceduponthemeasureasahugejoke。WiththeamiablepurposeofembarrassingtheGovernoroftheter—
ritory,whowasaRepublicanandhadbeenappointedbythePresident,thememberspassedthebillandputituptohimtoveto。Totheircombinedhorrorandamazement,theyoungGovernordidnothingofthekind。Hehadcome,asithappened,fromSalem,Ohio,oneofthefirsttownsintheUnitedStatesinwhichasuffrageconventionwasheld。
There,asaboy,hehadheardSusanB。Anthonymakeaspeech,andhehadcarriedintotheyearstheimpressionitmadeuponhim。Hesignedthatbill;and,astheLegislaturecouldnotgetatwo—
thirdsvotetokillit,thedisgustedmembershadtomakethebestofthematter。ThefollowingyearaDemocratintroducedabilltorepealthemeasure,butalreadypublicsentimenthadchangedandhewaslaugheddown。AfterthatnofurthereffortwasevermadetotaketheballotawayfromthewomenofWyoming。
Whentheterritoryappliedforstatehood,itwasfearedthatthewoman—suffrageclauseinthecon—
stitutionmightinjureitschanceofadmission,andthewomensentthistelegramtoJosephM。Carey:
``Dropusifyoumust。WecantrustthemenofWyomingtoenfranchiseusafterourterritorybe—
comesastate。’’
Mr。CareydiscussedthistelegramwiththeothermenwhowereurginguponCongresstheadmissionoftheirterritory,andthefollowingreplywentback:
``WemaystayoutoftheUnionahundredyears,butwewillcomeinwithourwomen。’’
Thereisgreatinspirationinthosetwomessages——
andagreatlesson,aswell。
In1894weconductedacampaigninNewYork,whenaneffortwasmadetosecureaclausetoen—
franchisewomeninthenewstateconstitution;andforthefirsttimeinthehistoryofthewoman—suf—
fragemovementmanyoftheinfluentialwomeninthestateandcityofNewYorktookanactivepartinthework。MissAnthonywas,asalways,ourleaderandgreatestinspiration。Mrs。JohnBrooksGreenleafwasstatepresident,andMissMaryAnthonywasthemostactiveworkerintheRoches—
terheadquarters。Mrs。LilyDevereauxBlakehadchargeofthecampaigninNewYorkCity,andMrs。
MariannaChapmanlookedaftertheBrooklynsec—
tion,whileamoststimulatingsignofthetimeswastheorganizationofacommitteeofNewYorkwomenofwealthandsocialinfluence,whoestab—
lishedtheirheadquartersatSherry’s。AmongthesewereMrs。JosephineShawLowell,Mrs。JosephH。
Choate,Dr。MaryPutnamJacobi,Mrs。J。WarrenGoddard,andMrs。RobertAbbe。MissAnthony,theninherseventy—fifthyear,spokeineverycountyofthestatesixtyinall。Ispokeinforty,andMrs。
Catt,asalways,madeasuperbrecord。MissHar—
rietMayMills,agraduateofCornell,andMissMaryG。Hay,didadmirableorganizationworkinthedif—
ferentcounties。Ourdisappointmentoverthere—
sultwasgreatlysoothedbythefactthatonlytwoyearslaterbothIdahoandUtahswungintolineasfullsuffragestates,thoughCalifornia,inwhichwehadlaboredwithequalzeal,waitedfifteenyearslonger。
Amongthesecampaigns,andoverlappingthem,wereourannualconventions——eachofwhichIat—
tendedfrom1888on——andthenationalandinter—
nationalcouncils,toanumberofwhich,also,Ihavegivenpreliminarymention。WhenSusanB。An—