Muchlessshouldtheyofferapublicaffronttoanyoftheirsubjects;
kingswereinstitutedtopardonandtopunish,butnevertoinsult。
Whentheyaffronttheirsubjects,theirtreatmentismorecruelthanthatoftheTurkortheMuscovite。Theinsultsoftheseareahumiliation,notadisgrace;butbothmustfollowfromtheinsolentbehaviourofmonarchs。
Suchistheprejudiceoftheeasternnationsthattheylookuponanaffrontfromtheprinceastheeffectofpaternalgoodness;andsuch,onthecontrary,isourwayofthinkingthatbesidesthecruelvexationofbeingaffronted,wedespairofeverbeingabletowipeoffthedisgrace。
Princesoughttobeoverjoyedtohavesubjectstowhomhonourisdearerthanlife,anincitementtofidelityaswellastocourage。
Theyshouldrememberthemisfortunesthathavehappenedtosovereignsforinsultingtheirsubjects:therevengeofCh?rea,oftheeunuchNarses,ofCountJulian,and,infine,oftheDuchessofMontpensier,who,beingenragedagainstHenryIIIforhavingpublishedsomeofherprivatefailings,tormentedhimduringherwholelife。
29。OfthecivilLawsproperformixingsomeportionofLibertyinadespoticGovernment。Thoughdespoticgovernmentsareoftheirownnatureeverywherethesame,yetfromcircumstances——fromareligiousopinion,fromprejudice,fromreceivedexamples,fromaparticularturnofmind,frommannersormorals——itispossibletheymayadmitofaconsiderabledifference。
Itisusefulthatsomeparticularnotionsshouldbeestablishedinthosegovernments。ThusinChinatheprinceisconsideredasthefatherofhispeople;andatthecommencementoftheempireoftheArabs,theprincewastheirpreacher。[76]
Itisproperthereshouldbesomesacredbooktoserveforarule,astheKoranamongtheArabs,thebooksofZoroasteramongthePersians,theVedaamongtheIndians,andtheclassicbooksamongtheChinese。Thereligiouscodesuppliesthecivilandfixestheextentofarbitrarysway。
Itisnotatallamissthatindubiouscasesthejudgesshouldconsulttheministersofreligion。[77]Thus,inTurkey,theCadisconsulttheMollahs。Butifitisacapitalcrime,itmaybeproperfortheparticularjudge,ifsuchtherebe,totakethegovernor’sadvice,totheendthatthecivilandecclesiasticalpowermaybetemperedalsobythepoliticalauthority。
30。ThesameSubjectcontinued。Nothingbuttheveryexcessandrageofdespoticpowerordainedthatthefather’sdisgraceshoulddragafteritthatofhiswifeandchildren。Theyarewretchedenoughalreadywithoutbeingcriminals:besides,theprinceoughttoleavesuppliantsormediatorsbetweenhimselfandtheaccused,toassuagehiswrathortoinformhisjustice。
ItisanexcellentcustomoftheMaldivians[78]thatwhenalordisdisgracedhegoeseverydaytopayhiscourttothekingtillheistakenagainintofavour:hispresencedisarmstheprince’sindignation。
Insomedespoticgovernments[79]theyhaveanotionthatitistrespassingagainsttherespectduetotheirprincetospeaktohiminfavourofapersonindisgrace。Theseprincesseemtousealltheirendeavourstodeprivethemselvesofthevirtueofclemency。
ArcadiusandHonorius,byalaw[80]onwhichwehavealreadydescanted,[81]positivelydeclarethattheywillshownofavourtothosewhoshallpresumetopetitiontheminbehalfoftheguilty。[82]Thiswasaverybadlawindeed,sinceitisbadevenunderadespoticgovernment。
ThecustomofPersia,whichpermitseverymanthatpleasestoleavethekingdom,isexcellent;andthoughthecontrarypracticederivesitsoriginfromdespoticpower,whichhaseverconsideredthesubjectsasslaves[83]andthosewhoquitthecountryasfugitives,yetthePersianpracticeisusefuleventoadespoticgovernment,becausetheapprehensionofpeople’swithdrawingfordebtrestrainsormoderatestheoppressionsofpashasandextortioners。
______
1。Politics,ii。8。
2。TarquiniusPriscus。SeeDionysiusHalicarnassus,iv。
3。Asearlyastheyear560。
4。Aristotle,Politics,ii。12。HegavehislawsatThuriuminthe84thOlympiad。
5。SeeAristides,Orat。inMinervam。
6。DionysiusHalicarnassusonthejudgmentofCoriolanus,vii。
7。Minerv?calculus。
8。St。Louismadesuchseverelawsagainstthosewhosworethatthepopethoughthimselfobligedtoadmonishhimforit。Thisprincemoderatedhiszeal,andsoftenedhislaws。SeehisOrdinances。
9。FatherRougerel。
10。Nicetas,LifeofManuelComnenus,iv。
11。Ibid。
12。Theophylactus,HistoryoftheEmperorMaurice,11。
13。SecretHistory。
14。FatherDuHalde,i,p。43。
15。FatherParenninintheEdifyingLetters。
16。Bookxxix。
17。Gratian,Valentinian,andTheodosius。ThisisthesecondintheCod。
decrimin。sacril。
18。Sacrilegiiinstarestdubitareanisdignussitquemelegeritimperator。——Cod。decrimin。sacril。ThislawhasservedasamodeltothatofRogerintheconstitutionofNaples,tit。4。
19。Leg。5,adleg。Jul。Majest。
20。ArcadiusandHonorius。
21。MemoirsofMontresor,i,p。238,Cologne,1723。
22。Namipsiparscorporisnostrisunt——ThesamelawoftheCod。,adleg。Jul。Majest。
23。Itisthe9thoftheCod。Theod。defalsamoneta。
24。Etiamexaliiscausismajestatiscriminacessantmeos?culo——Leg。
1。Cod。,ix,tit。8,adleg。Jul。Majest。
25。Alienamsect?me?solicitudinemconcepisti。——Leg。2,Cod。,iii,tit。4,adleg。Jul。Majest。
26。Leg。4,§1,ff。adleg。,Jul。Majest。,xlviii,tit。4。
27。SeeLeg。5,§2,ff。ibid。
28。Ibid。,§1。
29。Aliudvequidsimileadmiserint——Leg。6,ff。adleg。Jul。Majest。
30。Inthelastlaw,ff。adleg。Jul。deadulteriis。
31。SeeBurnet,HistoryoftheReformation。
32。Plutarch,Dionysius。
33。Thethoughtmustbejoinedwithsomesortofaction。
34。Sinontalesitdelictuminquodvelscripturalegisdescenditveladexemplumlegisvindicandumest,saysModestinusinLeg。7,§3,ff。
adleg。Jul。Majest。
35。In1740。
36。Neclubricumlingu?adpoenamfaciletrahendumest。——Modestinus,inLeg。7,§3,ff。adleg。Jul。Majest。
37。Siidexlevitateprocesserit,contemnendumest;siexinsania,miserationedignissimum;siabinjuria,remittendum。——Leg。unica。Cod。
siquisImperat。maled。
38。Tacitus,Annals,i。72。Thiscontinuedunderthefollowingreigns。
SeethefirstlawintheCod。defamosislibellis。
39。Tacitus,Annals,iv。34。
40。ThelawoftheTwelveTables。
41。Suetonius,LifeofTiberius,61。
42。CollectionofVoyagesthatContributedtotheEstablishmentoftheEastIndiaCompany,v,partII。
43。Ibid。,p。496。
44。Dio,inXiphilin。,lv。5。Tacitus,Annals,ii。30,iii。67,attributesthislaw,nottoAugustus,buttoTiberius。
45。FlaviusVopiscusinhisLife,9。
46。Sullamadealawofmajesty,whichismentionedinCicero’sOrations,ProCluentio,art。3;InPisonem,art。21;andagainstVerres,art。5。FamiliarEpistles,iii,11。C?sarandAugustusinsertedthemintheJulianLaws;othersmadeadditionstothem。
47。Etquoquisdistinctioraccusator,eomagishonoresassequebatur,acvelutisacrosanctuserat。——Tacitus,Annals,iv。36。
48。Deut。,13。6—9。
49。CollectionofVoyagesthatContributedtotheEstablishmentoftheEastIndiaCompany,v,partII,p。423。
50。DionysiusHalicarnassus,RomanAntiquities,viii。
51。Tyrannooccisoquinqueejusproximoscognationemagistratusnecato。
——Cicero,DeInvent。ii。29。
52。Cookviii,p。547。
53。OftheCivilWars,iv。
54。Itisnotsufficientinthecourtsofjusticeofthatkingdomthattheevidencebeofsuchanatureastosatisfythejudges;theremustbealegalproof;andthelawrequiresthedepositionoftwowitnessesagainsttheaccused。Nootherproofwilldo。Now,ifapersonwhoispresumedguiltyofhightreasonshouldcontrivetosecretethewitnesses,soastorenderitimpossibleforhimtobelegallycondemned,thegovernmentthenmaybringahillofattainderagainsthim;thatis,theymayenactaparticularlawforthatsinglefact。Theyproceedtheninthesamemannerasinallotherbillsbroughtintoparliament;itmustpassthetwohouses,andhavetheking’sconsent,otherwiseitisnotabill:thatis,asentenceofthelegislature。Thepersonaccusedmaypleadagainstthehillbycounsel,andthemembersofthehousemayspeakindefenceofthebill。
55。Legemdesingularialiquorogato,nisisexmillibusitavisum。——
FromAndocidis,DeMysteriis。ThisiswhattheycallOstracism。
56。Deprivishominibuslat?。——Cicero,DeLeg。,iii。19。
57。Scitumestjussuminomnes。——Ibid。
58。SeePhilostratus,i:LivesoftheSophists:?schines。SeelikewisePlutarchandPhocius。
59。BytheRemnianlaw。
60。Plutarch,inatreatiseentitled。HowaPersonMayReapAdvantagefromhisEnemies。
61。"Agreatmanysoldtheirchildrentopaytheirdebts。"——Plutarch,Solon。
62。Ibid。
63。ItappearsfromhistorythatthiscustomwasestablishedamongtheRomansbeforetheLawoftheTwelveTables。——Livy,dec。1,ii。23,24。
64。DionysiusHalicarnassus。RomanAntiquities,vi。
65。Plutarch,FuriusCamillas。
66。Seebelow,xxii。22。
67。OnehundredandtwentyyearsafterthelawoftheTwelveTables:EoannoplebiRoman?,velutaliudinitiumlibertatisfactumest,quodnectidesierunt。——Livy,viii。38。
68。Bonadebitoris,noncorpusobnoxiumesset。——Ibid。
69。TheyearofRome465。
70。ThatofPlautiuswhomadeanattemptuponthebodyofVeturius。——
ValeriusMaximus,vi,1,art。9。Thesetwoeventsoughtnottobeconfounded;theyareneitherthesamepersonsnorthesametimes。
71。SeeafragmentofDionysiusHalicarnassusintheextractofVirtuesandVices[Historica];Livy’sEpitome,ii。,andFreinshemius,ii。
72。Plutarch,ComparisonofsomeRomanandGreekHistories,ii,p。487。
73。Leg。6,Cod。Theod。defamosislibellis。
74。"Nerva,"saysTacitus,"increasedtheeaseofgovernment。"
75。StateofRussia,p。173,Paris,1717。
76。TheCaliphs。
77。HistoryoftheTartars,partIII,p。277,intheremarks。
78。SeeFrancisPirard。
79。AsatpresentinPersia,accordingtoSirJohnChardin,thiscustomisveryancient。"TheyputCavades,"saysProcopius,"intothecastleofoblivion;thereisalawwhichforbidsanyonetospeakofthosewhoareshutup,oreventomentiontheirname。"
80。ThefifthlawintheCod。adleg。Jul。Majest。
81。Inthe8thchapterofthisbook。
82。FrederickcopiedthislawintheConstitutionsofNaples,i。
83。Inmonarchiesthereisgenerallyalawwhichforbidsthosewhoareinvestedwithpublicemploymentstogooutofthekingdomwithouttheprince’sleave。Thislawoughttobeestablishedalsoinrepublics。Butinthosethathaveparticularinstitutionstheprohibitionoughttobegeneral,inordertopreventtheintroductionofforeignmanners。
BookXIII。OftheRelationWhichtheLevyingofTaxesandtheGreatnessofthePublicRevenuesBeartoLiberty1。OfthePublicRevenues。Thepublicrevenuesareaportionthateachsubjectgivesofhisproperty,inordertosecureorenjoytheremainder。
Tofixtheserevenuesinapropermanner,regardshouldbehadbothtothenecessitiesofthestateandtothoseofthesubject。Therealwantsofthepeopleoughtnevertogivewaytotheimaginarywantsofthestate。
Imaginarywantsarethosewhichflowfromthepassionsandtheweaknessofthegovernors,fromthevainconceitofsomeextraordinaryproject,fromtheinordinatedesireofglory,andfromacertainimpotenceofmindincapableofwithstandingtheimpulseoffancy。Oftenhaveministersofarestlessdispositionimaginedthatthewantsoftheirownmeanandignoblesoulswerethoseofthestate。
Nothingrequiresmorewisdomandprudencethantheregulationofthatportionofwhichthesubjectisdeprived,andthatwhichheissufferedtoretain。
Thepublicrevenuesshouldnotbemeasuredbythepeople’sabilitiestogive,butbywhattheyoughttogive;andiftheyaremeasuredbytheirabilitiestogive,itshouldbeconsideredwhattheyareabletogiveforaconstancy。
2。ThatitisbadReasoningtosaythattheGreatnessofTaxesisgoodinitsownNature。Therehavebeeninstancesinparticularmonarchiesofpettystatesexemptfromtaxesthathavebeenasmiserableasthecircumjacentplaceswhichgroanedundertheweightofexactions。Thechiefreasonofthisis,thatthepettystatecanhardlyhaveanysuchthingasindustry,arts,ormanufactures,becauseofitsbeingsubjecttoathousandrestraintsfromthegreatstatebywhichitisenvironed。
Thegreatstateisblessedwithindustry,manufactures,andarts,andestablisheslawsbywhichthoseseveraladvantagesareprocured。Thepettystatebecomes,therefore,necessarilypoor,letitpayneversofewtaxes。
Andyetsomehaveconcludedfromthepovertyofthosepettystatesthatinordertorenderthepeopleindustrioustheyshouldbeloadedwithtaxes。Butitwouldbeajusterinference,thattheyoughttopaynotaxesatall。Noneliveherebutwretcheswhoretirefromtheneighbouringpartstoavoidworking——wretcheswho,disheartenedbylabour,maketheirwholefelicityconsistinidleness。
Theeffectofwealthinacountryistoinspireeveryheartwithambition:thatofpovertyistogivebirthtodespair。Theformerisexcitedbylabour,thelatterissoothedbyindolence。
Natureisjusttoallmankind,andrepaysthemfortheirindustry:sherendersthemindustriousbyannexingrewardsinproportiontotheirlabour。Butifanarbitraryprinceshouldattempttodeprivethepeopleofnature’sbounty,theywouldfallintoadisrelishofindustry;andthenindolenceandinactionmustbetheironlyhappiness。
3。OfTaxesinCountrieswherePartofthePeopleareVillainsorBondmen。Thestateofvillainageissometimesestablishedafteraconquest。Inthatcase,thebondmanorvillainthattillsthelandoughttohaveakindofpartnershipwithhismaster。Nothingbutacommunicationoflossorprofitcanreconcilethosewhoaredoomedtolabourtosuchasareblessedwithastateofaffluence。
4。OfaRepublicinthelikeCase。Whenarepublichasreducedanationtothedrudgeryofcultivatingherlands,sheoughtnevertosufferthefreesubjecttohavethepowerofincreasingthetributeofthebondman。
ThiswasnotpermittedatSparta。ThosebravepeoplethoughttheHelotes[1]wouldbemoreindustriousincultivatingtheirlands,andknowingthattheirservitudewasnottoincrease;theyimagined,likewise,thatthemasterswouldbebettercitizens,whentheydesirednomorethanwhattheywereaccustomedtoenjoy。
5。OfaMonarchyinthelikeCase。Whenthenoblesofamonarchicalstatecausethelandstobecultivatedfortheirownusebyaconqueredpeople,theyoughtnevertohavethepowerofincreasingtheserviceortribute。[2]Besides,itisrighttheprinceshouldbesatisfiedwithhisowndemesneandthemilitaryservice。Butifhewantstoraisetaxesonthevassalsofhisnobility,thelordsoftheseveraldistrictsoughttobeanswerableforthetax,[3]andbeobligedtopayitforthevassals,bywhomtheymaybeafterwardsreimbursed。Ifthisrulebenotfollowed,thelordandthecollectorsofthepublictaxeswillharassthepoorvassalbyturnstillheperisheswithmiseryorfliesintothewoods。
6。OfadespoticGovernmentinthelikeCase。Theforegoingruleisstillmoreindispensablynecessaryinadespoticgovernment。Thelordwhoiseverymomentliabletobestrippedofhislandsandhisvassalsisnotsoeagertopreservethem。
WhenPeterIthoughtpropertofollowthecustomofGermany,andtodemandhistaxesinmoney,hemadeaveryprudentregulation,whichisstillfollowedinRussia。Thegentlemanleviesthetaxonthepeasant,andpaysittotheCzar。Ifthenumberofpeasantsdiminishes,hepaysallthesame;ifitincreases,hepaysnomore;sothatitishisinterestnottoworryoroppresshisvassals。
7。OfTaxesinCountrieswhereVillainageisnotestablished。Whentheinhabitantsofastateareallfreesubjects,andeachmanenjoyshispropertywithasmuchrightastheprincehissovereignty,taxesmaythenbelaideitheronpersons,onlands,onmerchandise,ontwoofthese,oronallthreetogether。
Inthetaxingofpersons,itwouldbeanunjustproportiontoconformexactlytothatofproperty。AtAthensthepeopleweredividedintofourclasses。[4]Thosewhodrewfivehundredmeasuresofliquidordriedfruitfromtheirestatespaidatalent[5]tothepublic;thosewhodrewthreehundredmeasurespaidhalfatalent;thosewhohadtwohundredmeasurespaidtenmin?;thoseofthefourthclasspaidnothingatall。
Thetaxwasfair,thoughitwasnotproportionable:ifitdidnotfollowthemeasureofpeople’sproperty,itfollowedthatoftheirwants。Itwasjudgedthateverymanhadanequalshareofwhatwasnecessaryfornature,thatwhatsoeverwasnecessaryfornatureoughtnottobetaxed;
thattothissucceededtheuseful,whichoughttobetaxed,butlessthanthesuperfluous;andthatthelargenessofthetaxesonwhatwassuperfluouspreventedsuperfluity。
Inthetaxingoflandsitiscustomarytomakelistsorregisters,inwhichthedifferentclassesofestatesareranged。Butitisverydifficulttoknowthesedifferences,andstillmoresotofindpeoplethatarenotinterestedinmistakingthem。Here,therefore,aretwosortsofinjustice,thatofthemanandthatofthething。Butifingeneralthetaxbenotexorbitant,andthepeoplecontinuetohaveplentyofnecessaries,theseparticularactsofinjusticewilldonoharm。Onthecontrary,ifthepeoplearepermittedtoenjoyonlyjustwhatisnecessaryforsubsistence,theleastdisproportionwillbeofthegreatestconsequence。
Ifsomesubjectsdonotpayenough,themischiefisnotsogreat;theirconvenienceandeaseturnalwaystothepublicadvantage;ifsomeprivatepeoplepaytoomuch,theirruinredoundstothepublicdetriment。Ifthegovernmentproportionsitsfortunetothatofindividuals,theeaseandconvenienceofthelatterwillsoonmakeitsfortunerise。Thewholedependsuponacriticalmoment:shallthestatebeginwithimpoverishingthesubjectstoenrichitself?Orhaditbetterwaittobeenrichedbyitssubjects?Isitmoreadvisableforittohavetheformerorthelatteradvantage?Whichshallitchoose——tobeginortoendwithopulence?
Thedutiesfeltleastbythepeoplearethoseonmerchandise,becausetheyarenotdemandedoftheminform。Theymaybesoprudentlymanagedthatthepeoplethemselvesshallhardlyknowtheypaythem。Forthispurposeitisoftheutmostconsequencethatthepersonwhosellsthemerchandiseshouldpaytheduty。Heisverysensiblethathedoesnotpayitforhimself;andtheconsumer,whopaysitinthemain,confoundsitwiththeprice。SomeauthorshaveobservedthatNerohadabolishedthedutyofthefive—and—twentiethpartarisingfromthesaleofslaves;[6]andyethehadonlyordainedthatitshouldbepaidbythesellerinsteadofthepurchaser;thisregulation,whichlefttheimpostentire,seemedneverthelesstosuppressit。
TherearetwostatesinEuropewheretheimpostsareveryheavyuponliquors:inonethebreweralonepaystheduty,intheotheritisleviedindiscriminatelyuponalltheconsumers;inthefirstnobodyfeelstherigouroftheimpost,intheseconditislookeduponasagrievance;intheformerthesubjectissensibleonlyofthelibertyhehasofnotpaying,inthelatterhefeelsonlythenecessitythatcompelshimtopay。
Further,theobligingtheconsumerstopayrequiresaperpetualrummagingandsearchingintotheirhouses。Nownothingismorecontrarythanthistoliberty;andthosewhoestablishthesesortsofdutieshavenotsurelybeensohappyastohituponthebestmethodofcollectingtherevenue。
8。InwhatMannertheDeceptionispreserved。Inordertomakethepurchaserconfoundthepriceofthecommoditywiththeimpost,theremustbesomeproportionbetweentheimpostandthevalueofthecommodity:forwhichreasonthereoughtnottobeanexcessivedutyuponmerchandiseoflittlevalue。Therearecountriesinwhichthedutyexceedsseventeenoreighteentimesthevalueofthecommodity。Inthiscasetheprinceremovesthedisguise:hissubjectsplainlyseetheyaredealtwithinanunreasonablemanner,whichrendersthemmostexquisitelysensibleoftheirservilecondition。
Besides,theprince,tobeabletolevyadutysodisproportionedtothevalueofthecommodity,mustbehimselfthevendor,andthepeoplemustnothaveitintheirpowertopurchaseitelsewhere:apracticesubjecttoathousandinconveniences。
Smugglingbeinginthiscaseextremelylucrative,thenaturalandmostreasonablepenalty,namely,theconfiscationofthemerchandise,becomesincapableofputtingastoptoit;especiallyasthisverymerchandiseisintrinsicallyofinconsiderablevalue。Recoursemustthereforebehadtoextravagantpunishments,suchasthoseinflictedforcapitalcrimes。
Allproportionthenofpenaltiesisatanend。Personsthatcannotreallybeconsideredasviciousarepunishedlikethemostinfamouscriminals;whichofallthingsintheworldisthemostcontrarytothespiritofamoderategovernment。
Again,inproportionaspeoplearetemptedtocheatthefarmeroftherevenues,themorethelatterisenriched,andtheformerimpoverished。
Toputastoptosmuggling,thefarmermustbeinvestedwithextraordinarymeansofoppressing,andthenthecountryisruined。
9。OfabadKindofImpost。Weshallhere,bytheway,takenoticeofanimpostlaidinparticularcountriesonthedifferentarticlesofcivilcontracts。Asthesearethingssubjecttoverynicedisquisitions,avastdealofknowledgeisnecessarytomakeanytolerabledefenceagainstthefarmeroftherevenues,whointerprets,inthatcase,theregulationsoftheprince,andexercisesanarbitrarypoweroverpeople’sfortunes。Experiencehasdemonstratedthatadutyonthepaperonwhichthedeedsaredrawnwouldbeoffargreaterservice。
10。ThattheGreatnessofTaxesdependsontheNatureoftheGovernment。
Taxesoughttobeverylightindespoticgovernments:otherwisewhowouldbeatthetroubleoftillingtheland?Besides,howisitpossibletopayheavydutiesinagovernmentthatmakesnomannerofreturntothedifferentcontributionsofthesubject?
Theexorbitantpoweroftheprince,andtheextremedepressionofthepeople,requirethatthereshouldnotbeevenapossibilityoftheleastmistakebetweenthem。Thetaxesoughttobesoeasytocollect,andsoclearlysettled,astoleavenoopportunityforthecollectorstoincreaseordiminishthem。Aportionofthefruitsoftheearth,acapitation,adutyofsomuchpercentonmerchandise,aretheonlytaxessuitabletothatgovernment。
Merchantsindespoticcountriesoughttohaveapersonalsafeguard,towhichallduerespectshouldbepaid。Withoutthistheywouldbetooweaktodisputewiththecustom—houseofficers。
第21章