TocallaJapanesecook,forinstance,anartistwouldbebutthebarestacknowledgmentoffact,forJapanesefoodisfarmorebeautifultolookatthanagreeabletoeat;whileTokiotailorsarecertainlymastersofdrapery,iftheyaresublimelyoblivioustothenaturalmodelingsofthemaleorfemaleform。
Ontheotherhand,artissown,liketheuseoftobacco,broadcastamongthepeople。ItisthebirthrightoftheFarEast,thetalentitneverhides。Throughoutthelengthandbreadthoftheland,andfromthehighestprincetothehumblestpeasant,artreignssupreme。
Nowsuchaprevalenceofartisticfeelingimpliesofitselfimpersonalityinthepeople。Atfirstsightitmightseemasifsciencedidthesame,andthatinthisrespecttheonehemisphereoffsettheother,andthatconsequentlybothshouldbeequallyimpersonal。Butinthefirstplace,ourmassesarenotimbuedwiththescientificspirit,astheirsarewithartisticsensibility。
Whowouldexpectofamasonanimpersonalinterestintheprinciplesofthearch,orofaplumberanon—financialdevotiontohydraulics?
CertainlyonewouldbewrongincreditingthemassesingeneralorEuropeanwaitersinparticularwithmuchabstractloveofmathematics,forexample。Inthesecondplace,thereisanessentialdifferenceintheattitudeofthetwosubjectsuponpersonality。Emotionally,scienceappealstonobody,arttoeverybody。Nowtheemotionsconstitutethelargerpartofthatcomplexbundleofideaswhichweknowasself。Athoughtwhichisnottingedtosomeextentwithfeelingisnotonlynotpersonal;properlyspeaking,itisnotevendistinctivelyhuman,butcosmical。Initsloftysuperioritytoman,scienceisunpersonalratherthanimpersonal。Art,ontheotherhand,isafamiliarspirit。Throughthewindowsofthesensesshefindsherwayintotheverysoulofman,andmakesforherselfahomethere。
Butitistohishumanity,nottohisindividuality,thatshewhispers,forshespeaksinthatuniversaltonguewhichallcanunderstand。
Examplesarenotwantingtosubstantiatetheory。ItisnomerecoincidencethatthetwomostimpersonalnationsofEuropeandAsiarespectively,theFrenchandtheJapanese,areatthesametimethemostartistic。Evenpoliteness,which,aswehaveseen,distinguishesboth,isitselfbutaformofart,——thesocialartoflivingagreeablywithone’sfellows。
Thisimpersonalitycomesoutwithallthemoreprominencewhenwepassfromtheconsiderationofartinitselftothespiritwhichactuatesthatart,andespeciallywhenwecomparetheirspiritwithourown。ThemainspringsofFarEasternartmaybesaidtobethree:Nature,Religion,andHumor。Incongruouscollectionthattheyare,allthreewitnesstothesametrait。Forthefirsttypifiesconcreteimpersonality,thesecondabstractimpersonality,whiletheprovinceofthelastistoridiculepersonalitygenerally。
Ofthetriothefirstisaltogetherthemostimportant。Indeed,toaFarOriental,sofundamentalapartofhimselfishisloveofNaturethatbeforeweviewitsmirroredimageitwillbewelltolooktheemotionitselfintheface。TheFarOrientallivesinalongday—dreamofbeauty。Hemusesratherthanreasons,andallmusing,sotheworditselfconfesses,springsfromtheinspirationofaMuse。ButthisMuseappearsnottohim,astotheGreeks,afterthefashionofawoman,norevenmoreprosaicallyafterthelikenessofaman。Unnaturalthoughitseemtous,hisinspirationseeksnohumansymbol。HisMuseisnotkintomankind。Sheistooimpersonalforanypersonification,forsheisNature。
Thatpoetwhosenamecarrieswithitacertainpresumptionofinfallibilityhastoldusthat"theproperstudyofmankindisman;"
andifmaterialadvancementinconsequencebeanycriterionofthefitnessofaparticularmentalpursuit,eventshaveassuredlyjustifiedthesaying。Indeed,theLevanthashelpedantitheticallytopreachthesamelesson,inshowingusbyitsownfatalexamplethattheimproperstudyofmankindiswoman,andthattheywhobutfollowthefairwillinevitablydegenerate。
TheFarOrientalknowsnothingofeitherstudy,andcaresless。
Thedelightofself—exploration,orthepossiblyevengreaterdelightoflosingone’sselfintryingtofathomfemininity,isasensationequallyforeigntohistemperament。Neithertheremarkablepersistenceofone’sowncharacteristics,notinfrequentlymatterofdeepregrettotheirpossessor,northecharminglyunaccountablevariabilityofthefairersex,attimesquiteasannoying,isaphenomenonsufficienttostirhiscuriosity。Accepting,ashedoes,theexistingstateofthingsmoreasamaterialfactthanasaphaseinagradualprocessofdevelopment,heregardshumanityasbutasmallpartofthegreatnaturalworld,insteadofconsideringitthecrowninggloryofthewhole。Herecognizesmanmerelyasafractionoftheuniverse,——onemightalmostsayasavulgarfractionofit,consideringthelowregardinwhichheisheld,——andaccordshimhisproportionateshareofattention,andnomore。
Inhisthought,natureisnotaccessorytoman。WorthyM。Perichon,ofprosaic,nottosayphilistinicfame,had,asweremember,histravelsimmortalizedinapaintingwhereacolossalPerichoninfrontalmostcompletelyeclipsedatinyMontBlancbehind。AFarOrientalthinkspoetry,whichmaypossiblyaccountforthefactthatinhismind—picturestherelativeimportanceofmanandmountainstandsreversed。"ThematchlessFuji,"firstofmotifsinhisart,admitsnopilgrimasitspeer。
Norisittowomanthatturnhisthoughts。MotherEarthisfairer,inhiseyes,thanareanyofherdaughters。Toherisgiventheheartthatshouldbetheirs。TheFarEasternloveofNatureamountsalmosttoapassion。TothestudyofherevervaryingmoodsherJapaneseadmirerbringsanimpersonaladorationthatcombinesoddlytheaestheticismofapoetwiththeasceticismofarecluse。Notthatheworshipsinsecret,however。Hispassionistoogenuineeithertofinddisguiseorseekdisplay。Withus,unfortunately,theloveofNatureisapttobeconsideredamentalextravagancepeculiartopoets,excusableinexactratiototheabilitytogiveitexpression。ForanordinarymortaltofeelafondnessforMotherEarthisakindoffolly,tobecarefullyconcealedfromhisfellows。Asortofshamefacednesspreventshimfromavowingit,asaboyatboarding—schoolhideshishomesickness,oraladhislove。
Heshrinksfromappearinglesspachydermatousthantherest。
Orelsehefliestotheotherextreme,andaffectstheodd;pretends,poses,parades,andatlastsucceedshalfindupinghimself,halfindeceivingotherpeople。ButwithFarOrientalsthecaseisdifferent。Theirlovehasalltheunostentatiousassuranceofwhathasreceivedthesanctionofpublicopinion。Norisitstillatthatdoubtful,hesitatingstagewhen,bytheinstrumentalityofathird,itssoul—harmonycansuddenlybechangedfromthejubilantmajorkeyintothedespairingminor。Notraceofsadnesstingeshisdelight。Hehaslongsincepassedthismelancholyphaseoferoticmisery,ifsobethatthecourseofhistruelovedidnotalwaysrunsmooth,andisnowwelloninmatrimonialbliss。Theverylookofthelandisenoughtobetraythefact。InJapanthelandscapehasanairofdomesticityaboutit,patenteventothemostcasualobserver。WherevertheJapanesehascomeincontactwiththecountryhehasmadeherunmistakablyhisown。Hehastouchedhertocaress,notinjure,anditseemsasifNatureacceptedhisfondnessasamatterofcourse,andyieldedhimawifelysubmissioninreturn。
Hisgardenismorehuman,even,thanhishouse。Notonlyiseverythingexquisitelyinkeepingwithman,butnaturalfeaturesareactuallychanged,plastictotheimprintoftheirlordandmaster’smind。Bushes,shrubs,trees,forgettofollowtheiroriginalintent,andgrowashewillsthemto;nowexpandinginwantonluxuriance,nowcontractingintodwarfdesignsoftheirformerselves,alltoobeyhiscapriceandpleasehiseye。Evenstubbornrockslosetheirwildness,andcometoseemapartofthealmostsentientlifearoundthem。Ifthedescriptionofsuchdutifulnessseemsfanciful,thethingitselfsurpassesallsupposition。Hedgesandshrubbery,clippedintothemostfantasticshapes,acceptthesuggestionofthepruning—knifeasifman’swishesweretheirownwhims。Manikinmaples,TomThumbtrees,afoothighandthirtyyearsold,withallthegnarlsandknotsandknucklesoftheirfellowsoftheforest,growinhisparterres,theirnativevitalitynotawhitdiminished。
Andtheyarenotregardedasmonstrositiesbutonlyasthemostnaturalofartificialities;fortheyareapartofahorticulturalwhole。TowalkintoaJapanesegardenislikewanderingofasuddenintooneofthosestrangeworldsweseereflectedinthepolishedsurfaceofaconcavemirror,whereallbuttheobserverhimselfistransformedintoafantasticminiatureofthereality。Inthatquaintfairylanddiminutiveriversflowgracefullyundertinytrees,pastmole—hillmountains,tilltheyfallatlastintolilliputianlakes,almostsmotheredfortheflowersthatgrowupontheirbanks;
whileintheextremedistanceofacoupleofrodstheconeofaFujitenfeethighlooksapprovinglydownuponascenewhichwouldbenationallyincompletewithoutit。
ButbesidesthedelightsofdomesticitywhichtheJapaneseenjoysdailyinNature’scompany,hehashisaccesdetendresse,too。
Whenhefeelsthusspeciallystirred,heinvitesachosenfewofhisfriends,equallyinfatuated,andtogethertheyrepairtosomespotnotedforitsscenery。Itmaybeawaterfall,orsomedreamypondoverhungbytrees,orthedistantglimpseofamountainpeakframedinpicture—wisebetweenthenearerhills;or,attheirappropriateseasons,theblossomingofthemanytreeflowers,whichineasternAsiaarebeautifulbeyonddescription。Forheappreciatesnotonlyplaces,buttimes。Onespotistobeseenatsunrise,anotherbymoonlight;onetobevisitedinthespring—time,anotherinthefall。Butwhereverorwheneveritbe,atea—house,placedtocommandthebestviewofthesight,standsreadytoreceivehim。Fornature’sbeautiesaretoowellrecognizedtoremaintheexclusivepropertyofthefirstchancelover。Peopleflocktoviewnatureaswedotoseeaplay,andprivacyisasimpossibleasitisunsought。Indeed,theaversiontopublicityissimplyaresultofthesenseofself,andthereforenecessarilynotafeatureofsoimpersonalacivilization。Aestheticguidebooksarewrittenforthenature—enamoured,descriptiveoftheseviewswhichtheJapanesetranslatorquaintlycalls"Sceneries,"andwhichvisitorscomenotonlyfromnearbutfromfartogazeupon。Infrontofthetea—houseproperarerowsofsummerpavilions,inoneofwhichthepartymakethemselvesathome,whilegentlelittletea—housegirlstoddleforthtoservethemtheinvariablepreliminaryteaandconfections。Eachmanthenproducesfromuphissleeve,orfromouthisgirdle,paper,ink,andbrush,andproceedstocomposeapoemonthebeautyofthespotandthefeelingsitcallsup,whichhesubsequentlyreadstohisadmiringcompanions。
Hotsakeisnextserved,whichistothemwhatbeeristoaGermanorabsinthetoablouse;andtheretheysit,sip,andpoetize,passingtheircouplets,astheydotheircups,inhonortooneanother。Atlast,afterdrinkinginanhourortwoofsceneryandsakecombined,thesymposiumofpoetsbreaksup。
Sometimes,insteadofacompanyoffriends,amanwilltakehisfamily,wife,babies,andall,onsuchanouting,butthedetailsofhisholidayaremuchthesameasbefore。Forthesceneryisstillthecentreofattraction,andintheattendantcreaturecomfortsFarEasternetiquettepermitsanequalenjoymenttoman,woman,andchild。
Thisloveofnatureisquiteirrespectiveofsocialcondition。
Allclassesfeelitsforce,andfreelyindulgethefeeling。Pooraswellasrich,lowaswellashigh,contrivetogratifytheirpoeticinstinctsfornaturalscenery。Asforflowers,especiallytreeflowers,orthoseofthelargerplants,likethelotusortheiris,theJapaneseappreciationoftheirbeautyisasphenomenalasisthatbeautyitself。Thosewhocanaffordtheluxurypossesstheshrubsinprivate;thosewhocannot,feasttheireyesonthepublicspecimens。Fromaspriginavasetoaparkplantedonpurpose,thereisnopartofthemtoosmallortoogreattobeexcludedfromFarOrientalaffection。Andofthetwo"drawing—rooms"oftheMikadoheldeveryyear,inAprilandNovember,botharegarden—parties:
theonegivenatthetimeandwiththetitleof"thecherryblossoms,"
andtheotherof"thechrysanthemum。"
Thesesametreeflowersdeservemorethanapassingnotice,notsimplybecauseoftheiramazingbeauty,whichwouldarrestattentionanywhere,butforthenationalattitudetowardthem。FornobetterexampleoftheJapanesepassionfornaturecouldwellbecited。
Iftheanniversariesofpeopleareslightinglytreatedinthelandofthesunrise,thesamecannotbesaidofplants。Theyearlybirthdaysofthevegetableworldareobservedwithmorethanbotanicenthusiasm。Theregardinwhichtheyareheldistrulyemotional,anditnotactuallyindividualinitsobject,atleastpersonaltothespecies。Eachkindoftreeasitsseasonbringsitintoflowerismadetheoccasionofafestival。Forthebeautyoftheblossomingreceivesthetributeofanationaladmiration。
Frompeerstopopulacemankindturnsouttowitnessit。Noraretheseoccasionsfew。SpringintheFarEastisonelongchainofflowerfetes,andasspringbeginsbytheendofJanuaryandlaststillthemiddleofJune,opportunitiesforappreciatingeachinturnarenothalfspoiledbyacommoncontemporaneousness。Peoplehavenotonlyoccasionbuttimetoadmire。Indeed,springitselfissuitablyrespectedbybeingdatedconformablytofact。FarOrientalsbegintheiryearwhenNaturebeginshers,insteadofstartinganachronouslyaswedointheverymiddleofthedeadseason,muchasourcollegesholdtheircommencements,onthelastinplaceatonthefirstdayoftheacademicterm。SoprevioushasthehasteofWesterncivilizationbecome。Theresultisthatourrejoicingpartakesoftheincongruityofhumor。Thenewyearexistsonlyinname。IntheFarEast,ontheotherband,thecalendarismadetofitthetime。MenbegintoreckontheiryearsomethreeweekslaterthantheWesternworld,justastheplum—treeopensitspinkwhitepetals,asitwere,inrosyreflectionofthesnowthatliesyetupontheground。Butthecoldnessoftheweatherdoesnotintheleastdeterpeoplefromthrongingthespotinwhichthetreesgrow,wheretheyspendhoursinadmiration,andendbypinningappropriatepoemsonthetwigsforlatercomerstoperuse。Fleetingastheflowersareinfact,theyliveforeverinfancy。Fortheyconstituteoneofthecommonestmotifsofbothpaintingandpoetry。
Abranchjustbreakingintobloomseenagainstthesunrisesky,oraboughbendingitsblossomstothebosomofastream,issubjectenoughfortheirgreatestmasters,whothuswed,asitwere,twoartsinone,——thespiritofpoesywithpictorialform。
Thisplum—treeisbutablossom。Precociousharbingerofahostofflowers,itsgayheraldingover,itvanishesnottoberecalled,foritbearsnoediblefruit。
Thenexteventintheseriesmightfairlybecalledphenomenal。
EarlyinApriltakesplacewhatisperhapsassuperbasightasanythinginthisworld,theblossomingofthecherry—trees。Indeed,itisnoteasytodothethingjusticeindescription。Ifthepluminvitedadmiration,thecherrycommandsit;fortoseethesakurainflowerforthefirsttimeistoexperienceanewsensation。
Familiarasamanmaybewithcherryblossomsathome,thesightthereburstsuponhimwiththedazzlingeffectofarevelation。
Suchistheprofusionofflowersthatthetreeseemstohaveturnedintoalivingmassofrosylight。Noleavesbreakthebrilliance。
Thesnowy—pinkpetalsdrapethebranchesentirely,yetsodelicately,onedeemsitallaveildonnedforthetree’snuptialswiththespring。Fornothingcouldmorecompletelypersonifythespiritofthespring—time。Youcanalmostfancyitsomedryaddeckedforherbridal,inmaidenlyday—dreamingtoolovelytolast。
Forliketheplumthecherryfailsinitsfruittofulfilthepromiseofitsflower。
Itwouldbestrangeindeedifsomuchbeautyreceivednorecognition,butitisevenmorestrangethatrecognitionshouldbesocompleteandsouniversalasitis。Appreciationisnotconfinedtothecultivatedfew;itisshownquiteasenthusiasticallybythemasses。
Thepopularityoftheplantsisall—embracing。Thecommonpeopleareassensitivetotheirbeautyasaretheupperclasses。Privategratification,roseateasitis,palesbesidethepublicdelight。
Indeed,notcontentwithwhatrevelationNaturemakesofherselfofherownaccord,manhasmultipliedhermanifestations。Spotssuitabletotheirgrowthhavebeenpeopledbyhimwithtrees。
Sometimestheystandingroupslikestar—clusters,asinOji,crowningahill;sometimes,asatMukojima,theylineanavenueformiles,dividingtheblueriverontheonehandfromtheblue—greenrice—fieldsontheother,——afloralmilkywayoflight。Butwhereverthetreesmaybe,thereattheirfloweringseasonaretobefoundthrongsofadmirers。Forincrowdspeoplegoouttoseethesight,multitudesstreamingincessantlytoandfrobeneaththeirblossomsasthetimeofdaydeterminestheturnofthehumantide。
TotheOccidentalstrangersuchagatheringsuggestssomesocialloadstone;butnoneexists。Inthecherry—treesaloneliestheattraction。
Foroneweekoutofthefifty—twothecherry—treestandsthusglorified,avisionofbeautyprolongedsomewhatbythewantofsynchronousnessofthedifferentkinds。Thenthepetalsfall。
Whatwasanuptialveilbecomesawinding—sheet,coveringthesodaswithwinter’swinding—sheetofsnow,destineditselftodisappear,andthetreeisnothingbutacommoncherry—treeoncemore。
Butflowersarebynomeansoverbecausethecherryblossomsarepast。Abriefspace,andthesamecrowdsthatflockedtothecherryturntothewistaria。Gardensaredevotedtotheplants,andthepopulacegreatlygiventothegardens。Theretheygotositandgazeatthegrape—likeclustersofpalepurpleflowersthathangmorethanacubitlongoverthewoodentrellis,andgrowdailydowntowardtheirownreflectionsinthepondbeneath,vyingwithoneanotherinNarcissus—likeendeavor。Andthepeople,astheysiptheirteaontheverandaopposite,beholdadoubleddelight,thefloweritselfanditsmirroredimagestretchingtokiss。
Afterthewistariacomesthetree—peony,andthentheiris,withitstrefoilflowersbroaderthanamanmayspan,andatallcolorsunderthesky。ToonewhohasseenthegreatJapanesefleur—de—lis,Francelooksludicrouslyinfelicitousinherchoiceofemblem。
Butthelistgrowstoolong,limitedasitisonlybyitsownannualrepetition。WehaveasyetreachedbutthefirstweekinJune;thesummerandautumnarestilltocome,thefirstbringingthelotusforitscrown,andthesecondthechrysanthemum。Andlazilygrandthelotusis,itselftheembodimentofthespiritofthedrowsyAugustair,theveryessenceofBuddha—likerepose。Thecastlemoatsareitsspecialdomain,whichinthisitsfloweringseasonitwrestswhollyfromtheirmoreproperoccupant——thewater。Adensegrowthofleather—likeleaves,abovewhichriseinmajesticisolationthesolitaryflowers,encirclestheouterrampart,shuttingthecastleinasitmightbethepalaceoftheSleepingBeauty。Inthedelightfuldreaminessthatcreepsoveroneashestandsthusbeforesomeolddaimyo’sformerabodeintheheartofJapan,heforgetsallhismetaphysicaldifficultiesaboutNirvana,forhefancieshehasfoundit,onelongLotusafternoon。
Andthenlast,butinsomesortfirst,sinceithasbeentakenfortheimperialinsignia,comesthechrysanthemum。ThesymmetryofitsshapewellfitsittosymbolizethecompletenessofperfectionwhichtheMikado,thesonofheaven,mundanelyrepresents。Ittypifies,too,thefullnessoftheyear;foritmarks,asitwere,thegoldenweddingofthespring,thereminiscenceinNovemberofthenuptialsoftheMay。Itsowncolor,however,isnotconfinedtogold。
Itmaybeofalmostanyhueandwithinthegenerallimitsofacircleofanyform。Nowitisachariotwheelwithpetalsforspokes;nowaballoffirewithlambenttonguesofflame;whileanotherkindseemsthebuttonofsomenaturallegionofhonor,andstillanotherapin—wheelinNature’sownday—fireworks。
Admiredasathingofbeautyforitsownsake,itisalsousedmerelyasamaterialforartisticeffects;foramongthequaintestofsuchconceitsaretheJapaneseJarleychrysanthemumworks。EveryNovemberintheflorists’gardensthatsharethetemplegroundsatAsakusamaybeseengroupsofhistoricalandmythologicalfigurescomposedentirelyofchrysanthemumflowers。TheseeffigiesarequiteworthyofcomparisonwiththeirLondoncousins,beingsufficientlylife—liketoterrifychildrenandstartleanybody。Tocomesuddenly,onturningacorner,uponacolossalwarrior,deterrentlyuncouthandfrightfullybattle—clad,intheactofdispatchingafallenfoe,isasensationnotinstantlydispelledbythefactthatheismadeofflowers。Thepractice,atleast,bearswitnesstoanartisticingenuityofnomeanmerit,andtoahorticultureablycarriedon,ifsomewhateccentricallyapplied。
Fromthepassingofthechrysanthemumdatesthedeadseason。
Butitissuitablyshort—lived。SometimesasearlyasNovember,theplum—treeisalreadyblossomingagain。
EvenfromsoimperfectlygatheredagarlanditwillbeseenthattheJapanesedonotlackforopportunitiestoadmire,nordotheyturncoldlyawayfromwhattheyaregiven。Indeed,theymaybesaidtoliveinachronicstateofflower—fever;butinspiteofthevastamountofadmirationwhichtheybestowonplants,itisnotsomuchthequantityofthatadmirationasthequalityofitwhichisremarkable。TheintenseappreciationshownthesubjectbytheFarOrientalissomethingwhoseverycharacterseemsstrangetous,andwheninadditionweconsiderthatitpermeatestheentirepeoplefromthecommonestcoolietothemostaestheticcourtier,itbecomestoourcomprehensionastateofthingslittleshortofinexplicable。
Tocallitartisticsensibilityistousetoolimitedaterm,foritpervadestheentirepeople;ratherisitasixthsenseofanatural,becausenationaldescription;forthetraitdiffersfromourcorrespondingfeelingindegree,andespeciallyinuniversalityenoughtomeritthedistinction。Theircarefortreeflowersisnotconfinedtoacultivation,itisacult。Itapproachestoasortofnaturalnature—worship,anadorationinwhichnothingispersonified。
FortheemotionarousedintheFarOrientalisjustastrulyanemotionasitwastotheGreek;butwhereastheGreekpersonifieditsobject,theJapaneseadmiresthatobjectforwhatitis。
Tothinkofthecherry—tree,forinstance,asawoman,wouldbetohismindaconceptiontranscendingeventhelimitsoftheludicrous。
Chapter6。Art。
Thatnature,notman,istheirbeauideal,thesourceofinspirationtothem,isevidentagainonlookingattheirart。Thesamespiritthatmakesofthemsuchwonderfullandscapegardenersandsuchwonder—fulllandscapegazersshowsitselfunmistakablyintheirpaintings。
ThecurrentimpressionthatJapanesepictorialambition,andconsequentskill,isconfinedtotherepresentationofbirdsandflowers,thoughentirelyerroneousasitstands,hasagrainoftruthbehindit。Thisideaisduetotheattitudeoftheforeignobservers,andwasinfactatributetoJapanesetechniqueratherthananappreciationofFarEasternartisticfeeling。Thetruthis,theforeignersbroughttothesubjecttheirownWesterncriteriaofmerit,andjudgedeverythingbythesestandards。Suchworksnaturallycommendedthemselvesmostashadleastoccasiontodeviatefromtheircanons。Thesimplestpictures,therefore,werepronouncedthebest。Paintingsofbirdsandflowerswerethusadmittedtobefine,becausetheirrealismspokeforitself。Oftheexquisitepoeticfeelingoftheirlandscapepaintingstheforeigncriticswerenotatfirstconscious,becauseitwasnotexpressedintermswithwhichtheywerefamiliar。
Butfirstimpressions,hereaselsewhere,arevaluable。Oneisveryapttoturntothemagainfromthereasoningofhissecondthoughts。
FloraandfaunaareaconspicuousfeatureofFarAsiaticart,becausetheyenterasdetailsofthesubject—matteroftheartist’sthoughtsandday—dreams。Thesebirdsandflowersarehissujetsdegenre。Whereweshouldselectaphaseofhumanlifeforeffectiveisolation,theychooseinsteadabitofnature。Asprayofgrassoratwigofcherry—blossomsismotifenoughforthem。Totheirthoughtitsbeautyisamplysuggestive。FortotheFarOrientalallnatureissympatheticallysentient。Hisadmiration,insteadofbeingcentredonman,embracestheuniverse。Hisartreflectsit。
Leavingoutofconsideration,forthemoment,minorthoughstillimportantdistinctionsintone,treatment,andtechnique,thegreatfundamentaldifferencebetweenWesternandFarEasternartliesinitsattitudetowardhumanity。
Withus,fromthetimeoftheGreekstothepresentday,manhasbeenthecynosureofartisticeyes;withthemhehasneverbeenvouchsafedmorethanacasual,nottosayacursoryglance,evenwomanfailingtorivethisattention。Oneofourownwritershassaidthat,withoutpassingtheboundsofduerespect,amanispermittedtwolooksatanywomanhemaymeet,onetorecognize,onetoadmire。AJapaneseordinarilyneverdreamsoftakingbutone,——ifindeedhegoessofarasthat,——thefirst。Itistheomittingtotakethatsecondlookthathaslefthimwhatheis。NotthatFortunehasbeenunpropitious;onlyblind。Fatehasofferedhimopportunityenough;toomuch,perhaps。ForinJapantheexposureofthefemaleformiswithoutaparallelinlatitude。Nevernude,itisfrequentlynaked。Theresultartisticallyismuchthesame,thoughthecausebedifferent。ForitisafatalmistaketosupposetheJapaneseanimmodestpeople。Accordingtotheirownstandards,theyareexceedinglymodest。NorespectableJapanesewomanwould,forinstance,everforamomentturnouthertoesinwalking。
Itisconsideredimmodesttodoso。Theircodeis,however,notsowhimsicalasthisbitofetiquettemightsuggest。Theintentiswiththemthetouchstoneofpropriety。Intheireyesastateofnatureisnotastateofindecency。Whateverexposureisrequiredforconvenienceisright;whateverunnecessary,wrong。SuchanEden—likeconditionofsocietywouldseemtobetheveryspotforasomethinglikethemodernFrenchschoolofarttohavedevelopedin。
AndyetitisjustthatstudyofthenudewhichhasfromimmemorialantiquitybeenentirelyneglectedintheFarEast。AnancientGreek,tosaynothingofamodernParisian,wouldhaveshockedaJapanese。Yetweareshockedbythem。Weareastoundedatthesightsweseeintheircountryvillages,whiletheyintheirturnmarvelattheexhibitionstheywitnessinourcitytheatres。Attheirwatering—placesthetwosexesbathepromiscuouslytogetherinallthesimplicityofnature;butforaJapanesewomantoappearonthestageinanycharacter,howeverproper,wouldbedeemedindecent。
Thedifferencebetweenthetwohemispheresmaybesaidtoconsistinanartlesslibertyontheonehand,andartisticlicenseontheother。Theirunwrittencodeofproprietyonthesubjectseemstobe,"Youmustsee,butyoumaynotobserve。"
Thesepeoplelivemoreinaccordancewiththeircodeofproprietythanwedowithours。Allclassesalikeconformtoit。Theadjective"respectable,"usedaboveasadistinctioninspeakingofwoman,wasinrealitysuperfluous,forallwomenthere,asfarasappearancegoes,arerespectable。Eventhemostabandonedcreaturedoesnotbetrayherstatusbyherbehavior。ThereasonofthisuniformityanditspsychologicalimportanceIshalldiscusslater。
Thisformofmodesty,asortofwantofmodestyofform,hasnoconnectionwhateverwithsex。Itapplieswithequalforcetothemalefigure,whichisevenmoreexposedthanthefemale,andoffersanatomicalsuggestionsinvaluablealiketotheartisticandmedicalprofessions,——suggestionsthatareequallyignoredbyboth。
ThecooliesarefrequentlypossessedofphysiqueswhichwouldhavedelightedMichaelAngelo;andasforthephenomenalcorpulencyofthewrestlers,itwouldhavemadeoftheplaceaveryparadiseforRubens。Inregardtothedoctors,——fortocallthemsurgeonswouldbetogiveanametowhatdoesnotexist,——alackofscientificzealhasbeenthecauseoftheirnotinvestigatingwhattemptstooseductively,weshouldimagine,tobeignored。Acupuncture,orthepracticeofstickinglongpinsintoanypartofthepatient’sbodythatmayhappentobepaininghim,prettymuchirrespectiveofanatomicalposition,isthenearestapproachtosurgeryofwhichtheyareguilty,andproclaimsofitselftheincorporevilicharacterofthethingoperatedupon。
Nordoesthepainteroweanythingtoscience。Herepresentshumanitysimplyasheseesitinitsevery—daycostume;anditbetokensthehighestpowersofgeneralizedobservationthatheproducestheresultshedoes。Inhisdrawings,manisshown,notashemightlookintheprimitive,orprivitive,simplicityofhisancestralGardenofEden,butashedoeslookintheordinarywearandtearofhispresentgarments。Civilizationhasfurnishedhimwithclothes,andheprefers,whenhehashispicturetaken,tokeepthemon。
Indealingwithman,theFarOrientalartistisemphaticallyarealist;itiswhenheturnstonaturethathebecomesideal。
Butbyidealisnotmeanthereconventional。Thattermofreproachisamisnomer,foundeduponamistake。Hisidealismissimplytheoutcomeofhislove,which,likeallhumanlove,transfiguresitsobject。TheFarOrientalhasplentyofthis,which,ifsometimesadelusion,seemsalsosecondsight,butitispeculiarlyimpersonal。
Hiscolor—blindnesstothewarm,blood—redendofthespectrumoflifeinnowiseaffectshisperceptionofthecolderbeautyofthegreatbluesandgreensofnature。Totheirpoetryheiseversensitive。Hisappreciationofthemissomethingphenomenal,andhispowerofpresentationworthyhisappreciation。
AJapanesepaintingisapoemratherthanapicture。Itportraysanemotioncalledupbyascene,andnotthesceneitselfinallitselaboratecomplexity。Itundertakestogiveonlysomuchofitasisvitaltothatparticularfeeling,andintentionallyomitsallirrelevantdetails。Itistheexpressioncaughtfromaglimpseofthesoulofnaturebythesoulofman;themirrorofamood,passing,perhaps,infact,butperpetuatedthustofancy。Beinganemotion,itsintensityisdirectlyproportionaltothesinglenesswithwhichitpossessesthethoughts。TheFarOrientalfullyrealizesthepowerofsimplicity。Thisprincipleishisfundamentalcanonofpictorialart。Tounderstandhispaintings,itisfromthisstandpointtheymustberegarded;notassoullessphotographsofscenery,butaspoeticpresentationsofthespiritofthescenes。
Theverycharterofpaintingdependsuponitsnotgivinguscharts。
Andifwithusalongpoembeacontradictioninterms,afullpictureiswiththemasself—condemnatoryaproduction。Fromthecontemplationofsuchworksofartaswecallfinished,oneisapt,afterhehasonceappreciatedFarEasterntaste,torisewithanunpleasantfeelingofsatiety,asifhehaseatentoomuchatthefeast。
Theirpaintings,bycomparison,wecallsketches。Isnotourwould—beslightunwittinglythereverse?Isnotasketch,afterall,fullerofmeaning,toonewhoknowshowtoreadit,thanafinishedaffair,whichisveryapttoendwithitself,barrenoffruit?
Doesnotone’sownimaginationeludeone’spowertoportrayit?Isitnotforeverflittingwill—o’—the—wisp—likeaheadofusjustbeyondexactdefinition?Forthesoulofartliesinwhatartcansuggest,andnothingishalfsosuggestiveasthehalfexpressed,notevenadoubleentente。Tohintagreatdealbydisplayingalittleismorevitaltoeffectthanthecleverestrepresentationofthewhole。
Theartofpartiallyrevealingismoretelling,even,thanthearscelareartem。Whohasnotsuspectedthroughaveilafairerfacethanveileverhid?Whohasnotbeendelightedlydupedbythesemi—disclosuresofadress?Theprincipleisjustastrueinanyonebranchofartasitisoftheattempteddevelopmentsbyoneofthesuggestionsofanother。Yetwhobuthasthusfeltitsforce?
Whohasnothadashockofday—dreamdesecrationonchancinguponanillustratededitionofsomebookwhosestoryhehadlaintoheart?
Portraitsofpeople,picturesofplaces,hedoesnotknow,andyetwhichpurporttobehis!AndIventuretobelievethattomorethanoneofustheexquisitepathosoftheBrideofLammermoorisgonewhenLuciawarblesherwoes,beitneversoentrancingly,toanadmiringhouse。ItalmostseemsasifthegarishpublicityofusinghernameforoperatictitlewereaspecialinterventionoftheMuse,thatwemightthelessconnectsongwithstory,——twosensationsthat,liketwolights,destroyoneanotherbymutualinterference。
Againstthispreferenceshownthesketchitmaybeurgedthattoappreciatesuchsuggestionspresupposesasmuchartinthepublicasinthepainter。Buttheabilitytoappreciateathingwhenexpressedisbuthalfthatnecessarytoexpressit。Someunderstandingmustexistintheobserverforanyworktobeintelligible。Itisonlyaquestionofdegree。Thegreatertheart—senseinthepersonaddressed,themorehadbetterbelefttoit。
NowinJapanthepublicissingularlyartistic。Infact,theartisticappreciationofthemassesthereissomethingastonishingtous,accustomedtoourimmenseintellectualdifferencesbetweenmanandman。Sketchesarethuspeculiarlyfittingtosuchaland。
Besides,thereisaquietmodestyaboutthesketchwhichisitselftaking。Toattemptthecompleteeveninafractionalbitofthecosmos,likeapicture,hasinitadifficultyakintothelogicaloneofprovingauniversalnegative。Thepossibilitiesoffailureareenormouslyincreased,andfailureislessforgivenfortheassumption。Artmightperhapsnotunwiselyfollowtheexampleofscienceinsuchmatterswhereanexhaustivework,whichtakesthebetterpartofalifetimetoproduce,isinvariablyentitledbyitseruditeauthoranElementaryTreatiseonthesubjectinhand。
ToaidtheeffectduetosimplicityofconceptionstepsintheFarOriental’swonderfultechnique。Hisbrush—strokesareveryfewinnumber,buteachonetells。Theyarelaidonwithatouchwhichislittleshortofmarvelous,andrequireshereditytoexplainitsskill。Forinhismethodthereisnoemending,nosuper—position,nochangepossible。Whathedoesisdoneonceandforall。
Theforceofitgrowsonyouasyougaze。Eachstrokeexpressessurprisinglymuch,andsuggestsmore。Evenomissionsaremadesignificant。Inhispaintingitisvisiblytruethatobjectscanberenderedconspicuousbytheirveryabsence。Youarequitesureyouseewhatonscrutinyyoudiscovertobeonlytheillusionofinevitableinference。TheFarOrientalartistunderstandsthepowerofsuggestionwell;forimaginationalwaysfillsinthepicturebetterthanthebrush,howeverperfectbeitsskill。
Eventheneglectofcertaingeneralprincipleswhichweconsidervitaltoeffect,suchastheabsenceofshadowsandthelackofperspective,provesnottobeoftheimportanceweimagine。
Wediscoverinthesepaintingshowimmaterial,artistically,wasPeterSchlimmel’ssadloss,andhowperfectlypossibleitistomakebitsofdiscontinuousdistancetaketheplaceeffectivelyofcontinuousspace。
FarEasternpicturesareepigramsratherthandescriptions。
TheypresentabitofnaturewiththetersenessofamaximofLaRochefoucault,andtheydelightasaphorismsdobytheirinsightandthehappyconcisenessofitsexpression。Fewaphorismsareabsolutelytrue,butthenboldnessmorethanmakesupforwhattheylackinverity。Socomplexasubjectislifethattostateatruthwithallitsaccompanyinglimitationsistoweakenitatonce。
Exceptions,whiledemonstratingtherule,donottendtoemphasizeit。
Andthoughthewholetruthisessentialtoscience,suchexhaustivenessisbynomeansacanonofart。
Parallelsarenotwantingathome。Whattheydowithspaceintheirpaintingsdowenotwithtimeinthecaseofourcomedies,thoseactedpicturesoflife?Shouldwenotrefusetotolerateaplaythatinsistedonfurnishinguswithafullperspectiveofitscharacters’past?Andyetofthetwo,itisfarperferable,artistically,tobegiventoomuchinsequencethantoomuchatonce。
TheChinese,whoputmuchlessintoapaintingthanwhatwedeemindispensable,delightindramasthatlastsixweeks。
Togiveaconcludingtouchoflifetomynecessarilyskeleton—likegeneralities,memorypicturesmeacertainpaintingofOkio’swhichIfellinlovewithatfirstsight。ItisofasunriseonthecoastofJapan。Alonglineofsurfisseentumblingintoyoufromoutabankofmist,justpiercingwhichshowstheblood—reddiskoftherisingsun,whileoverthenarrowstripofbreakingrollersthreecranesareslowlysailingnorth。Andthatisallyousee。Youdonotseetheshore;youdonotseethemain;youarelookingbutattheborder—landofthatgreatunknown,theheavingoceanstillslumberingbeneathitschillycoverlidofmist,outofwhichcomethebreakers,andthesun,andthecranes。
SomuchforthemoreserioussideofJapanesefancy;alookatthelighterleadstothesameconclusion。
Handinhandwithhiskeenpoeticsensibilitygoesavividsenseofhumor,——twotraitsthatcommonly,indeed,arefoundMayingtogetheroverthemeadowsofimagination。For,asitmightbeput,"TheheartthatissoonestawaketotheflowersIsalsothefirsttobetouchedbythefun。"
TheFarOrientalwellexemplifiesthisfact。Hisart,whereverfunispossible,fairlybubblesoverwithlaughter。FromtheoldestmastersdowntoHokusai,itisconstantlywellingupinthedrollestconceits。Itisofalldescriptions,too。Nowitlurksinmerryambush,likethefaintsuggestionofasmileonanotherwiseseriousface,sosubtilethattheobserverisleftwonderingwhethertheartistcouldhavemeantwhatseemsmorelikeone’sowningeniousdiscovery;nowitbreaksoutintothebroadestofgrins,absurdjuxtapositionsofsingularlyhappyincongruities。ForHokusai’scaricaturesandHendschel’ssketchesmightbetwins。Ifthereisadifference,itliesnotsomuchintheartist’sworkasinthegreatergeneralityofitsappreciation。Humorflitseasilythereatthesea—levelofthemultitude。FortheJapanesetemperamentiseveronthevergeofasmilewhichbreaksoutwithcatchingnaiveteatthefirstprovocation。Thelanguageaboundsinpunswhicharenotsufferedtolieidle,andevenpoetryoftenhingesoncertainconsecratedplaysonwords。Fromtheveryconstitutionofthepeoplethereisofcoursenothingselfishinthenationalenjoyment。
Amanisquiteasreadytolaughathisownexpenseasathisneighbor’s,acourtesywhichhisneighborcordiallyreturns。
Nowtheludicrousisessentiallyhumaninitsapplication。
Theprincipleofthesynthesisofcontradictories,popularlyknownbythenameofhumor,isnecessarilylimitedinitsfieldtoman。
Forwhetherithavetodowhollywithactions,orpartlywiththewordsthatexpressthem,whetheritbepresentedintheshapeofapunorapleasantry,itisinincongruouscontraststhatitsvirtuelies。Itistheunexpectedthatprovokesthesmile。Nownosuchincongruityexistsinnature;manenjoysamonopolyofthepowerofmakinghimselfridiculous。Sopleasantispleasantrythatwedoindeedcultivateitbeyonditsproperpale。ButitisonlybypersonifyingNature,andgratuitouslyattributingtohererrorsofwhichsheisincapable,thatwecanmakefunofher;as,forinstance,whenweholdtheweatheruptoridiculebywayofimpotentrevenge。Butsatiresupontheclown—likecharacterofourclimate,which,afterthelamestsortofaspring,somehowmanagesacapitalfall,wouldintheFarEastbeasoutofkeepingwithfancyaswithfact。ToaJapanese,whoneverpersonifiesanything,suchinnocentironyisunmeaning。Besides,itwouldbealsountrue。ForhisMaycarriesnosuggestionofunfulfilmentinitsname。
ThoseFarEasternpaintingswhichhavetodowithmanfallforthemostpartunderoneoftwoheads,thefacetiousandthehistorical。
Thelatterimpliesnoparticularlyintimateconcernformaninhimself,forthepasthasverylittlepersonalityforthepresent。
Asfortheformer,itsattentionis,ifanything,derogatorytohim,forwearealwaysshyofmakingfunofwhatwefeeltobetoocloselyapartofourselves。ButimpersonalityhaspreventedtheFarOrientalfromhavingmuchamourpropre。Hehasnoparticularaversiontocaricaturinghimself。FewEuropeans,perhaps,wouldhavecaredtoperpetrateaself—portraitlikeonepaintedbythepotterKinsei,whichwassoldmeonedayasanamusingtourdeforcebyafacetiouspicture—dealer。Itisacompositepictureofanewkind,aJapanesevarietyoftypeface。Thegreatpotter,whowasalsoapparentlynomeanpainter,hascombinedthreeaspectsofhimselfinasinglerepresentation。Atfirstsighttheportraitappearstobesimplyafullfrontviewofasomewhatmoon—facedcitizen;butasyoucontinuetogaze,itsuddenlydawnsonyouthattherearetwootherindividuals,oneoneitherside,hob—nobbinginprofilewiththefirst,thelinesofthefeaturesbeingingeniouslymadetododoubleduty;andwhenthisaspectofthethinghasoncestruckyou,youcannotlookatthepicturewithoutseeingallthreecitizenssimultaneously。Theresultisdoubtlessmoreeffectiveasacompositionthanflatteringasalikeness。
FarEasternsculpture,byitssecondaryimportanceamongFarEasternarts,witnessesagaintothesecondaryimportanceassignedtomanatourmentalantipodes。Inthisart,owingtoitsnecessarylimitations,therepresentationofnatureinitsbroadersenseisimpossible。Forinthefirstplace,whateverthesubject,itmustbesuchasitispossibletopresentinonecontinuouspiece;
disconnectedadjuncts,as,forinstance,aflockofbirdsflying,whichmightbeintroducedwithgreateffectinpainting,beingherepracticallybeyondtheartist’sreach。Secondly,thematerialbeingofuniformappearance,asarule,color,orevenshading,vitalpointsinlandscapeportrayal,isoutofthequestion,unlessthepieceweresubsequentlypainted,asinGreciansculptures,acustomwhichisnotpractisedinChinaorJapan。Lastly,anotherfactfataltotherepresentationoflandscapeisthesize。Thereducedscaleofthereproductionsuggestsfalsityatonce,afalsitywhosebelittlementthemindcanneitherforgetnorforgive。Plainsculptureisthereforepracticallylimitedtostatuary,eitherofmenoranimals。Theresultisthatintheirart,wherelandscapecountsforsomuch,sculptureplaysaveryminorpart。Inwhatlittlethereis,Nature’splaceistakenbyBuddha。Fortherearetwoclassesofstatues,dividedtheonefromtheotherbythatstepwhichseparatesthesublimefromtheridiculous,namely,thecolossalandthediminutive。Thereisnohappyhumanmean。OfthefirstkindarethebeautifulbronzefiguresoftheBuddha,liketheKamakuraBuddha,fiftyfeethighandninety—sevenfeetround,inwhosefaceallthatisgrandandnobleliessleeping,thelivingrepresentationofNirvana;andofthesecond,thoseoddlittleornamentsknownasnetsuke,comicalcarvingsforthemostpart,grotesquefiguresofmenandmonkeys,saintsandsinners,godsanddevils。Appealingbitsofivory,bone,orwoodtheyare,inwhichthedumbanimalsareasspeakinglikenessesastheirhumanfellows。
Theotherartsshowthesamemotifintheirdecorations。PotteryandlacqueralikewitnesstherespectivepositionsassignedtotheseriousandthecomicinFarEasternfeeling。
TheFarOrientalmakesfunofmanandmakeslovetoNature;anditalmostseemsasifNatureheardhissilentprayer,andsmileduponhiminacceptance;asifthelove—lightlentherfacetheaddedbeautythatitlendsthemaid’s。Fornowhereinthisworld,probably,isshelovelierthaninJapan:aclimateoflong,happymeansandshortextremes,monthsofspringandmonthsofautumn,withbutafewweeksofwinterinbetween;alandofflowers,wherethelotusandthecherry,theplumandwistaria,growwantonlysidebyside;alandwherethebambooembosomsthemaple,wherethepineatlasthasfounditspalm—tree,andthetropicandthetemperatezonesforgettheirseparateidentityinonelongself—obliteratingkiss。
Chapter7。Religion。
Inregardtotheirreligion,nations,likeindividuals,seemsingularlyaversetopractisingwhattheyhavepreached。Whetheritbethathisself—constructedidolsprovetothemakertoosuggestiveofhisownintellectualchiseltodeceivehimforlong,orwhethersacredsoil,likelesshallowedground,becomesafteratimeincapableofrespondingtorepeatedsowingsofthesameseed,certainitisthatinspiritualmattersmostpeopleshavegrownoutofconceitwiththeirownconceptions。Anindividualmayclingwithacertainsentimenttothereligionofhismother,butnationshaveshownanythingbutafoolishfondnessforthesacredsuperstitionsoftheirgreat—grandfathers。Tothecharmofcreationsucceedsinvariablythebitter—sweetafter—tasteofcriticism,andmanwouldnotbetheprogressiveanimalheisifhelongremainedinlovewithhisownproductions。
Whathisfuturewillbeistooengrossingasubject,andonetoodeeplyshroudedinmystery,nottobeconstantlypicturedanew。
Nowonderthattheconsiderationatthatcountrytowardwhichmankindiseverbeinghastenedshouldproveasabsorbingtofancyascontemplatedearthlyjourneysproverbiallyare。Fewpeoplebuthavelaidoutskeletontoursthroughitsidealregions,andperhaps,asinthemappingbeforehandofmerelymundanetravels,oneelementofattractionhasalwaysconsistedinthepossiblerevisionofone’sroutes。
Besides,thereisafascinationabouttheforeignmerelybecauseitissuch。Distancelendsenchantmenttotheviewsofothers,andnevermoresothanwhenthoseviewsarereligiousvisions。
Anenthusiasthascertainlyagreaterchanceofbeingtakenforagodamongapeoplewhodonotknowhimintimatelyasaman。Sowithhisdoctrines。Theimportedisapttoseemmoreimportantthanthehome—made;asthefar—offbewitchesmoreeasilythanthenear。Butjustascastlesintheairdonotcommonlybecomethepropertyoftheirbuilders,somansionsintheskiesalmostasfrequentlyhavefailedofdirectinheritance。Ratherstrikinglyhasthisprovedthecasewithwhatareto—daythetwomostpowerfulreligionsoftheworld,——BuddhismandChristianity。Neitherisnowthebeliefofitsfounder’speople。WhatwasAryan—bornhasbecomeTuranian—bred,andwhatwasSemiticbyconceptionisatpresentAryanbyadoption。
Thepossibilitiesofanother’shereafterlooksomuchrosierthanthelimitationsofone’sownpresent!
Fewpastimesaremoredelightfulthantossingpebblesintosomestill,darkpool,andwatchingtheripplesthatriseresponsive,astheyrunineverwideningcirclestotheshore。Mostofushavefeltitsfascinationsecondonlytothatofthedottedspiraloftheskipping—stone,afascinationnotoutgrownwithyears。Thereissomethingsingularlyattractiveinthesubtleforcethatforamomentswayseachparticleonlytopassontothenext,amotionmysteriousinitsimmateriality。Somesuchpleasuremustbetheirswhohavethrowntheirthoughtsintotheheartsofmen,andseenthemspreadinwavesoffeeling,whosespheretimewidensthroughtheworld。Forlikethemobilewateristhemindofman,——quicktocatchemotions,quicktotransmitthem。Ofallwavesoffeeling,thisisnottheleasttrueofreligiousones,that,startingfromtheirbirthplace,passouttostirothers,whohavebuthumanityincommonwiththosewhoprofessedthemfirst。Liketheripplesinthepool,theyleavetheirinitialconvertstosinkbackagainintocomparativequiescence,astheyadvancetothrowintosuddentremorshordesofouterbarbarians。Inbothofthegreatreligionsinquestionthiswavepropagationhasbeenmostmarked,onlythedirectionittookdiffered。Christianitywentwestward;Buddhismtravelledeast。ProselytesinAsiaMinor,Greece,andItalyfindcounterpartsinEasternIndia,Burmah,andThibet。Eventuallythetaughtsurpassedtheirteachersbothinzealandnumbers。JerusalemandBenaresatlastgaveplacetoRomeandLassaassacerdotalcentres。Stillthemovementjourneyedon。PopesandLhamasremainedwheretheirpredecessorshadfoundedsees,butthetideofbeliefsurgedpasttheminitsirresistibleadvance。Fartheryetfromwhereeachfaithbeganaretobefoundto—daythegreaterpartofitsadherents。ThehomethattheWesternhemisphereseemstopromisetotheone,theextremeOrientaffordstheother。AsRomanCatholicismnowlookstoAmericaforitsstrength,soBuddhismto—dayfindsitsworshipperschieflyinChinaandJapan。
ButthoughtheJapanesemaybesaidtobeallBuddhists,Buddhistisbynomeansallthattheyare。AtthetimeoftheiradoptionofthegreatIndianfaith,theJapanesewerealreadyinpossessionofasystemofsuperstitionwhichhashelditsowntothisday。Infact,asthestatereligionoftheland,ithasjustexperiencedarevival,aregalvanizingofitsold—timeenergy,atthehandsofsomeofthenativearchaeologists。Itssacredmirror,helduptoNature,hasbeenburnishedanew。Formerlythisbodyofbeliefwasthenationalfaith,theMikado,thedirectdescendantoftheearlygods,beingitsheadonearth。Hisreinstatementtotemporalpowerformedaveryfittingfirststeptowardreinvestingthecultwithitsformerprestige;acuriousinstance,indeed,ofareligiousrevivalduetoarchaeological,nottoreligiouszeal。
ThiscultisthemythologicalinheritanceofthewholeeasternseaboardofAsia,fromSiamtoKamtchatka。InJapanitiscalledShintoism。Theword"Shinto"meansliterally"thewayofthegods,"
andtheletterofitsnameisatrueexponentofthespiritofthebelief。Foritsscripturesareratheranitineraryofthegods’
livesthanaguidetothatroadbywhichmanhimselfmayattaintoimmortality。Thuswithacertainfitnesspilgrimagesareitsmostnoticeablerites。OnecannotjourneyanywhereintheheartofJapanwithoutmeetingmultitudesofthesepilgrims,withtheirneatwhiteleggingsandtheirmushroom—likehats,norrestatnightatanyinnthatisnothungwithcountlesslittlebannersofthepilgrimassociations,ofwhichtheyallaremembers。Beingapilgrimthereisequivalenttobeingatouristhere,onlythattotheexcitementofdoingthecountryisaddedasustainingsenseofthemeritoriousnessofthedeed。Oftenerthannottheobjectivepointofthedevoutisthesummitofsomenotedmountain。ForpeaksarepeculiarlysacredspotsintheShintofaith。Thefactisperhapsanexpressionofman’sinstinctivedesiretorise,asifthebodilyactinsomewisebetokenedthementalaction。Theshrineinsoexaltedapositionisofthesimplest:arudehut,withorwithouttheonlydistinctiveemblemsofthecult,amirrortypicalofthegodandthependentgohei,orzigzagstripsofpaper,permanentvotiveofferingsofman。Asforthebeliefitself,itisbutthedeificationofthosenaturalelementswhichaboriginalmaninstinctivelywondersatorfears,thesun,themoon,thethunder,thelightning,andthewind;all,inshort,thathesees,hears,andfeels,yetcannotcomprehend。Heclotheshisterrorswithformswhichresemblethehuman,becausehecanconceiveofnothingelsethatcouldcausetheunexpected。Buttheawfulshapesheconjuresuphavenaughtincommonwithhimself。Theyarefartoofearfultobefollowed。
Theirwayisthe"highwayofthegods,"butnoJacob’sladderforwaywardman。
InthisexternalitytothehumanliesthereasonthatShintoismandBuddhismcanagreesowell,andcanbothjoinwithConfucianisminhelpingtoformthathappyfamilyoffaithwhichissosingularafeatureofFarEasternreligiouscapability。Itisnotsimplythatthetwocontrivetolivepeaceablytogether;theyareactuallybothofthemimplicitlybelievedbythesameindividual。MillionsofJapanesearegoodBuddhistsandgoodShintoistsatthesametime。
Thatsuchacombinationshouldbepossibleisduetotheessentialdifferenceinthecharacterofthetwobeliefs。Theoneisextrinsic,theotherintrinsic,initsrelationstothehumansoul。
Shintoismtellsmanbutlittleabouthimselfandhishereafter;
Buddhism,littlebutabouthimselfandwhathemaybecome。InexaminingFarEasternreligion,therefore,forpersonality,orthereverse,wemaydismissShintoismashavingnoparticularbearinguponthesubject。Theonlyeffectithasisindirectinfurtheringthenaturalpropensityofthesepeopletoanadorationofnature。
InKoreaandinChina,again,Confucianismisthegreatmorallaw,asbyreflectionitistoacertainextentinJapan。Butthatinitsturnmaybeomittedinthepresentargument;inasmuchasConfuciustaughtconfessedlyanddesignedlyonlyasystemofmorals,andreligiouslyabstainedfrompronouncinganyopinionwhateveruponthecharacterorthecareerofthehumansoul。
Taouism,thethirdgreatreligionofChina,resemblesShintoismtothisextent,thatitisabodyofsuperstition,andnotaformofphilosophy。Itundertakestoprovidenostrumsforspiritualills,butisdumbastotheconstitutionofthesoulforwhichitprofessestoprescribe。Itspillsaretobeswallowedunquestioninglybythepatient,andarewarrantedtocure;andowingtothetwogreathumanfrailties,fearandcredulity,itspracticeisverylarge。
Possessing,however,nophilosophicdiploma,itiswithoutthepaleofthepresentdiscussion。
Thedemon—worshipofKoreaisamildformofthesamethingwiththehierarchyleftout,everymantherebeinghisownspiritualadviser。
AnordinaryKoreanisbornwithaninnatebeliefinmalevolentspirits,whomheaccordinglypropitiatesfromtimetotime。Oneofnoblerbirthpropitiatesonlythespiritsofhisownancestors。
Wecome,then,byaprocessofeliminationtoaconsiderationofBuddhism,thegreatphilosophicfaithofthewholeFarEast。
NotuncommonlyinthecourtyardofaJapanesetemple,inthesolemnhalf—lightofthesombrefirs,therestandsalargestonebasin,cutfromasingleblock,andfilledtothebrimwithwater。Thetrees,thebasin,andafewstonelanterns——socalledfromtheirform,andnottheirfunction,fortheyhavevotivepebbleswhereweshouldlookforwicks——arethesoleoccupantsoftheplace。Shelteredfromthewind,withdrawnfromsound,andonlypiouslyapproachedbyman,thisantechamberofthegodseemstheveryabodeofsilenceandrest。
ItmightbeNirvanaitself,humanentrancetoanimmortalitylikethegod’swithin,sopeaceful,sopervasiveisitscalm;andinitsmidstisthemoss—coveredmonolith,holdinginitsembracethelittleimprisonedpoolofwater。Sostillisthespotandsocleartheliquidthatyouknowtheoneonlyasthereflectionoftheother。
Mirroredinitsglassysurfaceappearseverythingaroundit。
Asyoupeerin,fardownyouseeatinybitofsky,asdeepastheblueishighabove,acrosswhichslowlysailthepassingclouds;
thennearerstandthetrees,archingoverhead,asifbendingtocatchglimpsesofthemselvesinthatotherworldbelow;andthen,neareryet——yourself。
EmblemofthespiritofmanisthislittlepooltoFarOrientaleyes。
Subtileasthesoulistheincomprehensiblewater;soresponsivetolightthatitremainsitselfinvisible;soclearthatitseemsillusion!Thoughportrayersoperfectofformsaboutit,allweknowofthethingitselfisthatitis。Throughnoneofthefivesensesdoweperceiveit。Neithersight,norhearing,nortaste,norsmell,nortouchcantellusitexists;wefeelittobebythemuscularsensealone,thatblindanddumbanalogueforthebodyofwhatconsciousnessisforthesoul。Onlywhendisturbed,troubled,doesthewateritselfbecomevisible,andthenitisbutthesurfacethatwesee。SototheFarOrientalthisstilllittlelaketypifiesthesoul,theeventualpurificationofhisown;asomethinglostinreflection,self—effaced,onlythealteregooftheouterworld。
Forcontemplation,notaction,istheFarOriental’sidealoflife。
Thereposeofself—adjustmentlikethattowhichourwholesolarsystemisslowlytendingasitsdeath,——thistohimappears,thoughfromnoscientificdeduction,theendofallexistence。Sohesitsandponders,abstractly,vaguely,uponeverythingingeneral,——synonym,alas,toman’sfinitemind,fornothinginparticular,——
tilleventhesenseofselfseemstovanish,andthroughthemist—likeportalofunconsciousnesshefloatsoutintothevastindistinguishablesamenessofNirvana’ssea。
AtfirstsightBuddhismismuchmorelikeChristianitythanthoseofuswhostayathomeandspeculateuponitcommonlyappreciate。Asasystemofphilosophyitsoundsexceedinglyforeign,butitlooksunexpectedlyfamiliarasafaith。Indeed,theonereligionmightwellpassforthecounterfeitpresentmentoftheother。TheresemblancesostrucktheearlyCatholicmissionariesthattheyfeltobligedtoexplaintheremarkablesimilaritybetweenthetwo。
Withthemingenuoussurpriseinstantlybegotingenioussophistry。
Externally,thelikenesswassoexactthatatfirsttheycouldnotbringthemselvestobelievethattheBuddhistceremonialshadnotbeenfilchedbodilyfromthepracticesofthetruefaith。Finding,however,thatnoknownhumanagencyhadactedinthematter,theybethoughtthemofintroducing,toaccountforthings,adeusexmachinaintheshapeofthedevil。Theyweresopleasedwiththissolutionofthedifficultythattheyimparteditatoncewithmuchpridetothenatives。Youhaveindeedgot,theygraciouslyifsomewhatgratuitouslyinformedthem,theoutwardsemblanceofthetruefaith,butyouareinfactthemiserablevictimsofanimpiousfraud。Satanhasstolentheinsigniaofdivinity,andisnowmasqueradingbeforeyouasthedeity;yourgodisreallyourdevil,——arecognitionofantipodalinversiontrulyworthytheJesuiticalmind!
Perhapsitisnotmatterforgreatsurprisethattheyconvertedbutfewoftheirhearers。Thesuggestionwashardlysodiplomaticasmighthavebeenexpectedfromsogenerallyastuteabody;foritcouldnotmakemuchdifferencewhattheall—presidingdeitywascalled,ifhisactionswerethesame,sincehismotiveswerebeyondhumanobservation。Besides,thebareideaofaforeignboguswasnotveryterrifying。TheChinesepossessedtoomanyfamiliardevilsoftheirown。Buttherewasanotherandamuchdeeperreason,whichweshallcometolater,whyChristianitymadebutlittleheadwayintheFarEast。
Butitisbynomeansinexternalsonlythatthetworeligionsarealike。Ifthefirstglanceatthemawakensthatpeculiarsensationwhichmostofushavefeltatsometimeorother,asenseofhavingseenallthisbefore,furtherscrutinyrevealsadeeperagreementthanmerelyinappearances。
Inpassingfromthesurfaceintothesubstance,itmaybementionedincidentallythatthecodesofmoralityofthetwoareaboutonalevel。Isayincidentally,forsofarasitspractice,certainly,isconcerned,itnotitspreaching,moralityhasnomoreintimateconnectionwithreligionthanithaswithartorpolitics。Ifwedoubtthis,wehavebuttoexaminethefacts。Arethemostreligiouspeoplesthemostmoral?Itneedsnoprolongedinvestigationtoconvinceusthattheyarenot。Ifproofofthewantofabondwererequired,thematteroftruth—tellingmightbeadducedinpoint。
Asthisisasubjectuponwhichaslightmisconceptionexistsinthemindsofsomeevangelicallypersuadedpersons,andbecause,whatismoregenerallyrelevant,thepresenceofthisquality,honestyinwordanddeed,hasmorethanalmostanyotheronecharacteristichelpedtoputusinthevanoftheworld’sadvanceto—day,itmaynotunfittinglybecitedhere。
Theargumentinthecasemaybeputthus。Havespeciallyreligionsracesbeenproportionallytruth—tellingones?Ifnot,hastherebeenanyothercauseatworkinthedevelopmentofmankindtendingtoincreaseveracity?Theanswertothefirstquestionhasallthesimplicityofaplainnegative。Nosuchpleasingconcomitanceofcharacteristicsisobservableto—day,orhasbeenpresentedinthepast。Permitting,however,thedeadpasttoburyitsshortcomingsinoblivion,letuslookattheworldaswefindit。Weobserve,then,thatthereligiousspiritisquiteasstronginAsiaasitisinEurope;ifanything,thatatthepresenttimeitisratherstronger。TheaverageBrahman,Mahometan,orBuddhistisquiteasdevoutastheordinaryRomanCatholicorPresbyterian。Ifheissomewhatlessgiventopropagandism,heisnotawhitlessregardfulofhisownsalvation。YetthroughouttheOrienttruthisathingunknown,liesofcourtesybeingderigueurandliesofconveniencederaison;whilewithus,fortunately,mendacityisgenerallydiscredited。Butweneednottravelsofarforproof。Thesameisevidentinlessantipodalrelations。HavetheleastreligiousnationsofEuropebeenanylesstruthfulthanthemostbigoted?WasfanaticSpainremarkableforveracity?WasLoyolaagentlemanwhoseassertionscarriedconvictionotherthantothestake?Weretheeminentlymundaneburgherswhomhepersecutednotedforapioussuperioritytofact?Or,tonarrowthefieldstillfurther,andscanthecircleofone’sownacquaintance,arethemostbelievingindividualsamongthemworthyofthemostbelief?Assuredlynot。