NicoloMachiavelli,bornatFlorenceon3rdMay1469。From1494to1512heldanofficialpostatFlorencewhichincludeddiplomaticmissionstovariousEuropeancourts。
ImprisonedinFlorence,1512;laterexiledandreturnedtoSanCasciano。DiedatFlorenceon22ndJune1527。
INTRODUCTION
NicoloMachiavelliwasbornatFlorenceon3rdMay1469。HewasthesecondsonofBernardodiNicoloMachiavelli,alawyerofsomerepute,andofBartolommeadiStefanoNelli,hiswife。BothparentsweremembersoftheoldFlorentinenobility。
Hislifefallsnaturallyintothreeperiods,eachofwhichsingularlyenoughconstitutesadistinctandimportanterainthehistoryofFlorence。HisyouthwasconcurrentwiththegreatnessofFlorenceasanItalianpowerundertheguidanceofLorenzode’Medici,IlMagnifico。ThedownfalloftheMediciinFlorenceoccurredin1494,inwhichyearMachiavellienteredthepublicservice。DuringhisofficialcareerFlorencewasfreeunderthegovernmentofaRepublic,whichlasteduntil1512,whentheMedicireturnedtopower,andMachiavellilosthisoffice。TheMediciagainruledFlorencefrom1512until1527,whentheywereoncemoredrivenout。ThiswastheperiodofMachiavelli’sliteraryactivityandincreasinginfluence;buthedied,withinafewweeksoftheexpulsionoftheMedici,on22ndJune1527,inhisfifty—eighthyear,withouthavingregainedoffice。
YOUTH
Aet。1—25——1469—94
AlthoughthereislittlerecordedoftheyouthofMachiavelli,theFlorenceofthosedaysissowellknownthattheearlyenvironmentofthisrepresentativecitizenmaybeeasilyimagined。Florencehasbeendescribedasacitywithtwooppositecurrentsoflife,onedirectedbytheferventandaustereSavonarola,theotherbythesplendour—
lovingLorenzo。Savonarola’sinfluenceupontheyoungMachiavellimusthavebeenslight,foralthoughatonetimehewieldedimmensepoweroverthefortunesofFlorence,heonlyfurnishedMachiavelliwithasubjectofagibein"ThePrince,"whereheiscitedasanexampleofanunarmedprophetwhocametoabadend。WhereasthemagnificenceoftheMediceanruleduringthelifeofLorenzoappearedtohaveimpressedMachiavellistrongly,forhefrequentlyrecurstoitinhiswritings,anditistoLorenzo’sgrandsonthathededicates"ThePrince。"
Machiavelli,inhis"HistoryofFlorence,"givesusapictureoftheyoungmenamongwhomhisyouthwaspassed。Hewrites:"Theywerefreerthantheirforefathersindressandliving,andspentmoreinotherkindsofexcesses,consumingtheirtimeandmoneyinidleness,gaming,andwomen;theirchiefaimwastoappearwelldressedandtospeakwithwitandacuteness,whilsthewhocouldwoundothersthemostcleverlywasthoughtthewisest。"InalettertohissonGuido,Machiavellishowswhyyouthshouldavailitselfofitsopportunitiesforstudy,andleadsustoinferthathisownyouthhadbeensooccupied。Hewrites:"Ihavereceivedyourletter,whichhasgivenmethegreatestpleasure,especiallybecauseyoutellmeyouarequiterestoredinhealth,thanwhichIcouldhavenobetternews;forifGodgrantlifetoyou,andtome,Ihopetomakeagoodmanofyouifyouarewillingtodoyourshare。"Then,writingofanewpatron,hecontinues:"Thiswillturnoutwellforyou,butitisnecessaryforyoutostudy;since,then,youhavenolongertheexcuseofillness,takepainstostudylettersandmusic,foryouseewhathonourisdonetomeforthelittleskillIhave。Therefore,myson,ifyouwishtopleaseme,andtobringsuccessandhonourtoyourself,dorightandstudy,becauseotherswillhelpyouifyouhelpyourself。"
OFFICE
Aet。25—43——1494—1512
ThesecondperiodofMachiavelli’slifewasspentintheserviceofthefreeRepublicofFlorence,whichflourished,asstatedabove,fromtheexpulsionoftheMediciin1494untiltheirreturnin1512。AfterservingfouryearsinoneofthepublicofficeshewasappointedChancellorandSecretarytotheSecondChancery,theTenofLibertyandPeace。HereweareonfirmgroundwhendealingwiththeeventsofMachiavelli’slife,forduringthistimehetookaleadingpartintheaffairsoftheRepublic,andwehaveitsdecrees,records,anddispatchestoguideus,aswellashisownwritings。Amererecapitulationofafewofhistransactionswiththestatesmenandsoldiersofhistimegivesafairindicationofhisactivities,andsuppliesthesourcesfromwhichhedrewtheexperiencesandcharacterswhichillustrate"ThePrince。"
Hisfirstmissionwasin1499toCatherinaSforza,"myladyofForli"
of"ThePrince,"fromwhoseconductandfatehedrewthemoralthatitisfarbettertoearntheconfidenceofthepeoplethantorelyonfortresses。ThisisaverynoticeableprincipleinMachiavelli,andisurgedbyhiminmanywaysasamatterofvitalimportancetoprinces。
In1500hewassenttoFrancetoobtaintermsfromLouisXIIforcontinuingthewaragainstPisa:thiskingitwaswho,inhisconductofaffairsinItaly,committedthefivecapitalerrorsinstatecraftsummarizedin"ThePrince,"andwasconsequentlydrivenout。He,also,itwaswhomadethedissolutionofhismarriageaconditionofsupporttoPopeAlexanderVI;whichleadsMachiavellitoreferthosewhourgethatsuchpromisesshouldbekepttowhathehaswrittenconcerningthefaithofprinces。
Machiavelli’spubliclifewaslargelyoccupiedwitheventsarisingoutoftheambitionsofPopeAlexanderVIandhisson,CesareBorgia,theDukeValentino,andthesecharactersfillalargespaceof"ThePrince。"Machiavellineverhesitatestocitetheactionsofthedukeforthebenefitofusurperswhowishtokeepthestatestheyhaveseized;hecan,indeed,findnopreceptstooffersogoodasthepatternofCesareBorgia’sconduct,insomuchthatCesareisacclaimedbysomecriticsasthe"hero"of"ThePrince。"Yetin"ThePrince"thedukeisinpointoffactcitedasatypeofthemanwhorisesonthefortuneofothers,andfallswiththem;whotakeseverycoursethatmightbeexpectedfromaprudentmanbutthecoursewhichwillsavehim;whoispreparedforalleventualitiesbuttheonewhichhappens;
andwho,whenallhisabilitiesfailtocarryhimthrough,exclaimsthatitwasnothisfault,butanextraordinaryandunforeseenfatality。
OnthedeathofPiusIII,in1503,MachiavelliwassenttoRometowatchtheelectionofhissuccessor,andtherehesawCesareBorgiacheatedintoallowingthechoiceoftheCollegetofallonGiulianodelleRovere(JuliusII),whowasoneofthecardinalsthathadmostreasontofeartheduke。Machiavelli,whencommentingonthiselection,saysthathewhothinksnewfavourswillcausegreatpersonagestoforgetoldinjuriesdeceiveshimself。JuliusdidnotrestuntilhehadruinedCesare。
ItwastoJuliusIIthatMachiavelliwassentin1506,whenthatpontiffwascommencinghisenterpriseagainstBologna;whichhebroughttoasuccessfulissue,ashedidmanyofhisotheradventures,owingchieflytohisimpetuouscharacter。ItisinreferencetoPopeJuliusthatMachiavellimoralizesontheresemblancebetweenFortuneandwomen,andconcludesthatitistheboldratherthanthecautiousmanthatwillwinandholdthemboth。
ItisimpossibletofollowherethevaryingfortunesoftheItalianstates,whichin1507werecontrolledbyFrance,Spain,andGermany,withresultsthathavelastedtoourday;weareconcernedwiththoseevents,andwiththethreegreatactorsinthem,sofaronlyastheyimpingeonthepersonalityofMachiavelli。HehadseveralmeetingswithLouisXIIofFrance,andhisestimateofthatmonarch’scharacterhasalreadybeenalludedto。MachiavellihaspaintedFerdinandofAragonasthemanwhoaccomplishedgreatthingsunderthecloakofreligion,butwhoinrealityhadnomercy,faith,humanity,orintegrity;andwho,hadheallowedhimselftobeinfluencedbysuchmotives,wouldhavebeenruined。TheEmperorMaximilianwasoneofthemostinterestingmenoftheage,andhischaracterhasbeendrawnbymanyhands;butMachiavelli,whowasanenvoyathiscourtin1507—8,revealsthesecretofhismanyfailureswhenhedescribeshimasasecretiveman,withoutforceofcharacter——ignoringthehumanagenciesnecessarytocarryhisschemesintoeffect,andneverinsistingonthefulfilmentofhiswishes。
TheremainingyearsofMachiavelli’sofficialcareerwerefilledwitheventsarisingoutoftheLeagueofCambrai,madein1508betweenthethreegreatEuropeanpowersalreadymentionedandthepope,withtheobjectofcrushingtheVenetianRepublic。ThisresultwasattainedinthebattleofVaila,whenVenicelostinonedayallthatshehadwonineighthundredyears。Florencehadadifficultparttoplayduringtheseevents,complicatedastheywerebythefeudwhichbrokeoutbetweenthepopeandtheFrench,becausefriendshipwithFrancehaddictatedtheentirepolicyoftheRepublic。When,in1511,JuliusII
finallyformedtheHolyLeagueagainstFrance,andwiththeassistanceoftheSwissdrovetheFrenchoutofItaly,FlorencelayatthemercyofthePope,andhadtosubmittohisterms,oneofwhichwasthattheMedicishouldberestored。ThereturnoftheMedicitoFlorenceon1stSeptember1512,andtheconsequentfalloftheRepublic,wasthesignalforthedismissalofMachiavelliandhisfriends,andthusputanendtohispubliccareer,for,aswehaveseen,hediedwithoutregainingoffice。
LITERATUREANDDEATH
Aet。43—58——1512—27
OnthereturnoftheMedici,Machiavelli,whoforafewweekshadvainlyhopedtoretainhisofficeunderthenewmastersofFlorence,wasdismissedbydecreedated7thNovember1512。ShortlyafterthishewasaccusedofcomplicityinanabortiveconspiracyagainsttheMedici,imprisoned,andputtothequestionbytorture。ThenewMediceanpeople,LeoX,procuredhisrelease,andheretiredtohissmallpropertyatSanCasciano,nearFlorence,wherehedevotedhimselftoliterature。InalettertoFrancescoVettori,dated13thDecember1513,hehasleftaveryinterestingdescriptionofhislifeatthisperiod,whichelucidateshismethodsandhismotivesinwriting"ThePrince。"Afterdescribinghisdailyoccupationswithhisfamilyandneighbours,hewrites:"Theeveningbeingcome,Ireturnhomeandgotomystudy;attheentranceIpulloffmypeasant—
clothes,coveredwithdustanddirt,andputonmynoblecourtdress,andthusbecominglyre—clothedIpassintotheancientcourtsofthemenofold,where,beinglovinglyreceivedbythem,Iamfedwiththatfoodwhichisminealone;whereIdonothesitatetospeakwiththem,andtoaskforthereasonoftheiractions,andtheyintheirbenignityanswerme;andforfourhoursIfeelnoweariness,Iforgeteverytrouble,povertydoesnotdismay,deathdoesnotterrifyme;I
ampossessedentirelybythosegreatmen。AndbecauseDantesays:
Knowledgedothcomeoflearningwellretained,Unfruitfulelse,IhavenoteddownwhatIhavegainedfromtheirconversation,andhavecomposedasmallworkon’Principalities,’whereIpourmyselfoutasfullyasIcaninmeditationonthesubject,discussingwhataprincipalityis,whatkindsthereare,howtheycanbeacquired,howtheycanbekept,whytheyarelost:andifanyofmyfancieseverpleasedyou,thisoughtnottodispleaseyou:andtoaprince,especiallytoanewone,itshouldbewelcome:thereforeIdedicateittohisMagnificenceGiuliano。FilippoCasavecchiohasseenit;hewillbeabletotellyouwhatisinit,andofthediscoursesIhavehadwithhim;nevertheless,Iamstillenrichingandpolishingit。"
The"littlebook"sufferedmanyvicissitudesbeforeattainingtheforminwhichithasreachedus。Variousmentalinfluenceswereatworkduringitscomposition;itstitleandpatronwerechanged;andforsomeunknownreasonitwasfinallydedicatedtoLorenzode’Medici。
AlthoughMachiavellidiscussedwithCasavecchiowhetheritshouldbesentorpresentedinpersontothepatron,thereisnoevidencethatLorenzoeverreceivedorevenreadit:hecertainlynevergaveMachiavellianyemployment。AlthoughitwasplagiarizedduringMachiavelli’slifetime,"ThePrince"wasneverpublishedbyhim,anditstextisstilldisputable。
MachiavelliconcludeshislettertoVettorithus:"Andastothislittlething[hisbook],whenithasbeenreaditwillbeseenthatduringthefifteenyearsIhavegiventothestudyofstatecraftI
haveneithersleptnoridled;andmenoughtevertodesiretobeservedbyonewhohasreapedexperienceattheexpenseofothers。Andofmyloyaltynonecoulddoubt,becausehavingalwayskeptfaithI
couldnotnowlearnhowtobreakit;forhewhohasbeenfaithfulandhonest,asIhave,cannotchangehisnature;andmypovertyisawitnesstomyhonesty。"
BeforeMachiavellihadgot"ThePrince"offhishandshecommencedhis"DiscourseontheFirstDecadeofTitusLivius,"whichshouldbereadconcurrentlywith"ThePrince。"Theseandseveralminorworksoccupiedhimuntiltheyear1518,whenheacceptedasmallcommissiontolookaftertheaffairsofsomeFlorentinemerchantsatGenoa。In1519theMediceanrulersofFlorencegrantedafewpoliticalconcessionstohercitizens,andMachiavelliwithotherswasconsulteduponanewconstitutionunderwhichtheGreatCouncilwastoberestored;butononepretextoranotheritwasnotpromulgated。
In1520theFlorentinemerchantsagainhadrecoursetoMachiavellitosettletheirdifficultieswithLucca,butthisyearwaschieflyremarkableforhisre—entryintoFlorentineliterarysociety,wherehewasmuchsoughtafter,andalsofortheproductionofhis"ArtofWar。"ItwasinthesameyearthathereceivedacommissionattheinstanceofCardinalde’Medicitowritethe"HistoryofFlorence,"ataskwhichoccupiedhimuntil1525。HisreturntopopularfavourmayhavedeterminedtheMedicitogivehimthisemployment,foranoldwriterobservesthat"anablestatesmanoutofwork,likeahugewhale,willendeavourtooverturntheshipunlesshehasanemptycasktoplaywith。"
Whenthe"HistoryofFlorence"wasfinished,MachiavellitookittoRomeforpresentationtohispatron,Giulianode’Medici,whohadinthemeanwhilebecomepopeunderthetitleofClementVII。Itissomewhatremarkablethat,as,in1513,Machiavellihadwritten"ThePrince"fortheinstructionoftheMediciaftertheyhadjustregainedpowerinFlorence,so,in1525,hededicatedthe"HistoryofFlorence"
totheheadofthefamilywhenitsruinwasnowathand。InthatyearthebattleofPaviadestroyedtheFrenchruleinItaly,andleftFrancisIaprisonerinthehandsofhisgreatrival,CharlesV。ThiswasfollowedbythesackofRome,uponthenewsofwhichthepopularpartyatFlorencethrewofftheyokeoftheMedici,whowereoncemorebanished。
MachiavelliwasabsentfromFlorenceatthistime,buthastenedhisreturn,hopingtosecurehisformerofficeofsecretarytothe"TenofLibertyandPeace。"UnhappilyhewastakenillsoonafterhereachedFlorence,wherehediedon22ndJune1527。
THEMANANDHISWORKS
NoonecansaywherethebonesofMachiavellirest,butmodernFlorencehasdecreedhimastatelycenotaphinSantaCroce,bythesideofhermostfamoussons;recognizingthat,whateverothernationsmayhavefoundinhisworks,ItalyfoundinthemtheideaofherunityandthegermsofherrenaissanceamongthenationsofEurope。Whilstitisidletoprotestagainsttheworld—wideandevilsignificationofhisname,itmaybepointedoutthattheharshconstructionofhisdoctrinewhichthissinisterreputationimplieswasunknowntohisownday,andthattheresearchesofrecenttimeshaveenabledustointerprethimmorereasonably。Itisduetotheseinquiriesthattheshapeofan"unholynecromancer,"whichsolonghauntedmen’svision,hasbeguntofade。
Machiavelliwasundoubtedlyamanofgreatobservation,acuteness,andindustry;notingwithappreciativeeyewhateverpassedbeforehim,andwithhissupremeliterarygiftturningittoaccountinhisenforcedretirementfromaffairs。Hedoesnotpresenthimself,norishedepictedbyhiscontemporaries,asatypeofthatrarecombination,thesuccessfulstatesmanandauthor,forheappearstohavebeenonlymoderatelyprosperousinhisseveralembassiesandpoliticalemployments。HewasmisledbyCatherinaSforza,ignoredbyLouisXII,overawedbyCesareBorgia;severalofhisembassieswerequitebarrenofresults;hisattemptstofortifyFlorencefailed,andthesoldierythatheraisedastonishedeverybodybytheircowardice。Intheconductofhisownaffairshewastimidandtime—serving;hedarednotappearbythesideofSoderini,towhomheowedsomuch,forfearofcompromisinghimself;hisconnectionwiththeMediciwasopentosuspicion,andGiulianoappearstohaverecognizedhisrealfortewhenhesethimtowritethe"HistoryofFlorence,"ratherthanemployhiminthestate。Anditisontheliterarysideofhischaracter,andtherealone,thatwefindnoweaknessandnofailure。
Althoughthelightofalmostfourcenturieshasbeenfocusedon"ThePrince,"itsproblemsarestilldebatableandinteresting,becausetheyaretheeternalproblemsbetweentheruledandtheirrulers。Suchastheyare,itsethicsarethoseofMachiavelli’scontemporaries;yettheycannotbesaidtobeoutofdatesolongasthegovernmentsofEuroperelyonmaterialratherthanonmoralforces。ItshistoricalincidentsandpersonagesbecomeinterestingbyreasonoftheuseswhichMachiavellimakesofthemtoillustratehistheoriesofgovernmentandconduct。
LeavingoutofconsiderationthosemaximsofstatewhichstillfurnishsomeEuropeanandeasternstatesmenwithprinciplesofaction,"ThePrince"isbestrewnwithtruthsthatcanbeprovedateveryturn。Menarestillthedupesoftheirsimplicityandgreed,astheywereinthedaysofAlexanderVI。ThecloakofreligionstillconcealstheviceswhichMachiavellilaidbareinthecharacterofFerdinandofAragon。
Menwillnotlookatthingsastheyreallyare,butastheywishthemtobe——andareruined。Inpoliticstherearenoperfectlysafecourses;prudenceconsistsinchoosingtheleastdangerousones。Then——topasstoahigherplane——Machiavellireiteratesthat,althoughcrimesmaywinanempire,theydonotwinglory。Necessarywarsarejustwars,andthearmsofanationarehallowedwhenithasnootherresourcebuttofight。
ItisthecryofafarlaterdaythanMachiavelli’sthatgovernmentshouldbeelevatedintoalivingmoralforce,capableofinspiringthepeoplewithajustrecognitionofthefundamentalprinciplesofsociety;tothis"highargument""ThePrince"contributesbutlittle。
Machiavellialwaysrefusedtowriteeitherofmenorofgovernmentsotherwisethanashefoundthem,andhewriteswithsuchskillandinsightthathisworkisofabidingvalue。Butwhatinvests"ThePrince"withmorethanamerelyartisticorhistoricalinterestistheincontrovertibletruththatitdealswiththegreatprincipleswhichstillguidenationsandrulersintheirrelationshipwitheachotherandtheirneighbours。
Intranslating"ThePrince"myaimhasbeentoachieveatallcostsanexactliteralrenderingoftheoriginal,ratherthanafluentparaphraseadaptedtothemodernnotionsofstyleandexpression。
Machiavelliwasnofacilephrasemonger;theconditionsunderwhichhewroteobligedhimtoweigheveryword;histhemeswerelofty,hissubstancegrave,hismannernoblyplainandserious。"Quiseofuitunquaminpartiundisrebus,indefiniendis,inexplanandispressior?"
In"ThePrince,"itmaybetrulysaid,thereisreasonassignable,notonlyforeveryword,butforthepositionofeveryword。ToanEnglishmanofShakespeare’stimethetranslationofsuchatreatisewasinsomewaysacomparativelyeasytask,forinthosetimesthegeniusoftheEnglishmorenearlyresembledthatoftheItalianlanguage;totheEnglishmanofto—dayitisnotsosimple。Totakeasingleexample:theword"intrattenere,"employedbyMachiavellitoindicatethepolicyadoptedbytheRomanSenatetowardstheweakerstatesofGreece,wouldbyanElizabethanbecorrectlyrendered"entertain,"andeverycontemporaryreaderwouldunderstandwhatwasmeantbysayingthat"RomeentertainedtheAetoliansandtheAchaeanswithoutaugmentingtheirpower。"Butto—daysuchaphrasewouldseemobsoleteandambiguous,ifnotunmeaning:wearecompelledtosaythat"RomemaintainedfriendlyrelationswiththeAetolians,"etc。,usingfourwordstodotheworkofone。IhavetriedtopreservethepithybrevityoftheItaliansofaraswasconsistentwithanabsolutefidelitytothesense。IftheresultbeanoccasionalasperityIcanonlyhopethatthereader,inhiseagernesstoreachtheauthor’smeaning,mayoverlooktheroughnessoftheroadthatleadshimtoit。
ThefollowingisalistoftheworksofMachiavelli:
Principalworks。DiscorsosopralecosediPisa,1499;DelmododitrattareipopolidellaValdichianaribellati,1502;DelmodotenutodalducaValentinonell’ammazzareVitellozzoVitelli,OliverottodaFermo,etc。,1502;Discorsosopralaprovisionedeldanaro,1502;
Decennaleprimo(poeminterzarima),1506;Ritrattidellecosedell’
Alemagna,1508—12;Decennalesecondo,1509;RitrattidellecosediFrancia,1510;DiscorsisopralaprimadecadiT。Livio,3vols。,1512—17;IlPrincipe,1513;Andria,comedytranslatedfromTerence,1513(?);Mandragola,prosecomedyinfiveacts,withprologueinverse,1513;Dellalingua(dialogue),1514;Clizia,comedyinprose,1515(?);Belfagorarcidiavolo(novel),1515;Asinod’oro(poeminterzarima),1517;Dell’artedellaguerra,1519—20;DiscorsosoprailriformarelostatodiFirenze,1520;SommariodellecosedellacittadiLucca,1520;VitadiCastruccioCastracanidaLucca,1520;Istoriefiorentine,8books,1521—5;Frammentistorici,1525。
OtherpoemsincludeSonetti,Canzoni,Ottave,andCanticarnascialeschi。
Editions。Aldo,Venice,1546;dellaTertina,1550;Cambiagi,Florence,6vols。,1782—5;deiClassici,Milan,101813;Silvestri,9vols。,1820—2;Passerini,Fanfani,Milanesi,6vols。onlypublished,1873—7。
Minorworks。Ed。F。L。Polidori,1852;Letterefamiliari,ed。E。
Alvisi,1883,2editions,onewithexcisions;CreditedWritings,ed。
G。Canestrini,1857;LetterstoF。Vettori,seeA。Ridolfi,PensieriintornoalloscopodiN。MachiavellinellibroIlPrincipe,etc。;D。
Ferrara,ThePrivateCorrespondenceofNicoloMachiavelli,1929。
DEDICATION
TotheMagnificentLorenzoDiPieroDe’Medici:
Thosewhostrivetoobtainthegoodgracesofaprinceareaccustomedtocomebeforehimwithsuchthingsastheyholdmostprecious,orinwhichtheyseehimtakemostdelight;whenceoneoftenseeshorses,arms,clothofgold,preciousstones,andsimilarornamentspresentedtoprinces,worthyoftheirgreatness。
DesiringthereforetopresentmyselftoyourMagnificencewithsometestimonyofmydevotiontowardsyou,IhavenotfoundamongmypossessionsanythingwhichIholdmoredearthan,orvaluesomuchas,theknowledgeoftheactionsofgreatmen,acquiredbylongexperienceincontemporaryaffairs,andacontinualstudyofantiquity;which,havingreflecteduponitwithgreatandprolongeddiligence,Inowsend,digestedintoalittlevolume,toyourMagnificence。
AndalthoughImayconsiderthisworkunworthyofyourcountenance,neverthelessItrustmuchtoyourbenignitythatitmaybeacceptable,seeingthatitisnotpossibleformetomakeabettergiftthantoofferyoutheopportunityofunderstandingintheshortesttimeallthatIhavelearntinsomanyyears,andwithsomanytroublesanddangers;whichworkIhavenotembellishedwithswellingormagnificentwords,norstuffedwithroundedperiods,norwithanyextrinsicallurementsoradornmentswhatever,withwhichsomanyareaccustomedtoembellishtheirworks;forIhavewishedeitherthatnohonourshouldbegivenit,orelsethatthetruthofthematterandtheweightinessofthethemeshallmakeitacceptable。
NordoIholdwiththosewhoregarditasapresumptionifamanoflowandhumbleconditiondaretodiscussandsettletheconcernsofprinces;because,justasthosewhodrawlandscapesplacethemselvesbelowintheplaintocontemplatethenatureofthemountainsandofloftyplaces,andinordertocontemplatetheplainsplacethemselvesuponhighmountains,evensotounderstandthenatureofthepeopleitneedstobeaprince,andtounderstandthatifprincesitneedstobeofthepeople。
Takethen,yourMagnificence,thislittlegiftinthespiritinwhichIsendit;wherein,ifitbediligentlyreadandconsideredbyyou,youwilllearnmyextremedesirethatyoushouldattainthatgreatnesswhichfortuneandyourotherattributespromise。
AndifyourMagnificencefromthesummitofyourgreatnesswillsometimesturnyoureyestotheselowerregions,youwillseehowunmeritedlyIsufferagreatandcontinuedmalignityoffortune。
THEPRINCE
CHAPTERI
HOWMANYKINDSOFPRINCIPALITIESTHEREARE,ANDBYWHATMEANSTHEYAREACQUIRED
Allstates,allpowers,thathaveheldandholdruleovermenhavebeenandareeitherrepublicsorprincipalities。
Principalitiesareeitherhereditary,inwhichthefamilyhasbeenlongestablished;ortheyarenew。
Thenewareeitherentirelynew,aswasMilantoFrancescoSforza,ortheyare,asitwere,membersannexedtothehereditarystateoftheprincewhohasacquiredthem,aswasthekingdomofNaplestothatoftheKingofSpain。
Suchdominionsthusacquiredareeitheraccustomedtoliveunderaprince,ortoliveinfreedom;andareacquiredeitherbythearmsoftheprincehimself,orofothers,orelsebyfortuneorbyability。
CHAPTERII
CONCERNINGHEREDITARYPRINCIPALITIES
Iwillleaveoutalldiscussiononrepublics,inasmuchasinanotherplaceIhavewrittenofthematlength,andwilladdressmyselfonlytoprincipalities。IndoingsoIwillkeeptotheorderindicatedabove,anddiscusshowsuchprincipalitiesaretoberuledandpreserved。
Isayatoncetherearefewerdifficultiesinholdinghereditarystates,andthoselongaccustomedtothefamilyoftheirprince,thannewones;foritissufficientonlynottotransgressthecustomsofhisancestors,andtodealprudentlywithcircumstancesastheyarise,foraprinceofaveragepowerstomaintainhimselfinhisstate,unlesshebedeprivedofitbysomeextraordinaryandexcessiveforce;
andifheshouldbesodeprivedofit,wheneveranythingsinisterhappenstotheusurper,hewillregainit。
WehaveinItaly,forexample,theDukeofFerrara,whocouldnothavewithstoodtheattacksoftheVenetiansin’84,northoseofPopeJuliusin’10,unlesshehadbeenlongestablishedinhisdominions。
Forthehereditaryprincehaslesscauseandlessnecessitytooffend;
henceithappensthathewillbemoreloved;andunlessextraordinaryvicescausehimtobehated,itisreasonabletoexpectthathissubjectswillbenaturallywelldisposedtowardshim;andintheantiquityanddurationofhisrulethememoriesandmotivesthatmakeforchangearelost,foronechangealwaysleavesthetoothingforanother。
CHAPTERIII
CONCERNINGMIXEDPRINCIPALITIES
Butthedifficultiesoccurinanewprincipality。Andfirstly,ifitbenotentirelynew,butis,asitwere,amemberofastatewhich,takencollectively,maybecalledcomposite,thechangesarisechieflyfromaninherentdifficultywhichthereisinallnewprincipalities;
formenchangetheirrulerswillingly,hopingtobetterthemselves,andthishopeinducesthemtotakeuparmsagainsthimwhorules:
whereintheyaredeceived,becausetheyafterwardsfindbyexperiencetheyhavegonefrombadtoworse。Thisfollowsalsoonanothernaturalandcommonnecessity,whichalwayscausesanewprincetoburdenthosewhohavesubmittedtohimwithhissoldieryandwithinfiniteotherhardshipswhichhemustputuponhisnewacquisition。
Inthiswayyouhaveenemiesinallthosewhomyouhaveinjuredinseizingthatprincipality,andyouarenotabletokeepthosefriendswhoputyoutherebecauseofyournotbeingabletosatisfytheminthewaytheyexpected,andyoucannottakestrongmeasuresagainstthem,feelingboundtothem。For,althoughonemaybeverystronginarmedforces,yetinenteringaprovinceonehasalwaysneedofthegoodwillofthenatives。
ForthesereasonsLouistheTwelfth,KingofFrance,quicklyoccupiedMilan,andasquicklylostit;andtoturnhimoutthefirsttimeitonlyneededLodovico’sownforces;becausethosewhohadopenedthegatestohim,findingthemselvesdeceivedintheirhopesoffuturebenefit,wouldnotenduretheill—treatmentofthenewprince。Itisverytruethat,afteracquiringrebelliousprovincesasecondtime,theyarenotsolightlylostafterwards,becausetheprince,withlittlereluctance,takestheopportunityoftherebelliontopunishthedelinquents,toclearoutthesuspects,andtostrengthenhimselfintheweakestplaces。ThustocauseFrancetoloseMilanthefirsttimeitwasenoughfortheDukeLodovico[*]toraiseinsurrectionsontheborders;buttocausehimtoloseitasecondtimeitwasnecessarytobringthewholeworldagainsthim,andthathisarmiesshouldbedefeatedanddrivenoutofItaly;whichfollowedfromthecausesabovementioned。
[*]DukeLodovicowasLodovicoMoro,asonofFrancescoSforza,whomarriedBeatriced’Este。HeruledoverMilanfrom1494to1500,anddiedin1510。
NeverthelessMilanwastakenfromFranceboththefirstandthesecondtime。Thegeneralreasonsforthefirsthavebeendiscussed;itremainstonamethoseforthesecond,andtoseewhatresourceshehad,andwhatanyoneinhissituationwouldhavehadformaintaininghimselfmoresecurelyinhisacquisitionthandidtheKingofFrance。
NowIsaythatthosedominionswhich,whenacquired,areaddedtoanancientstatebyhimwhoacquiresthem,areeitherofthesamecountryandlanguage,ortheyarenot。Whentheyare,itiseasiertoholdthem,especiallywhentheyhavenotbeenaccustomedtoself—
government;andtoholdthemsecurelyitisenoughtohavedestroyedthefamilyoftheprincewhowasrulingthem;becausethetwopeoples,preservinginotherthingstheoldconditions,andnotbeingunlikeincustoms,willlivequietlytogether,asonehasseeninBrittany,Burgundy,Gascony,andNormandy,whichhavebeenboundtoFranceforsolongatime:and,althoughtheremaybesomedifferenceinlanguage,neverthelessthecustomsarealike,andthepeoplewilleasilybeabletogetonamongstthemselves。Hewhohasannexedthem,ifhewishestoholdthem,hasonlytobearinmindtwoconsiderations:theone,thatthefamilyoftheirformerlordisextinguished;theother,thatneithertheirlawsnortheirtaxesarealtered,sothatinaveryshorttimetheywillbecomeentirelyonebodywiththeoldprincipality。
Butwhenstatesareacquiredinacountrydifferinginlanguage,customs,orlaws,therearedifficulties,andgoodfortuneandgreatenergyareneededtoholdthem,andoneofthegreatestandmostrealhelpswouldbethathewhohasacquiredthemshouldgoandresidethere。Thiswouldmakehispositionmoresecureanddurable,asithasmadethatoftheTurkinGreece,who,notwithstandingalltheothermeasurestakenbyhimforholdingthatstate,ifhehadnotsettledthere,wouldnothavebeenabletokeepit。Because,ifoneisonthespot,disordersareseenastheyspringup,andonecanquicklyremedythem;butifoneisnotathand,theyareheardofonlywhentheyaregreat,andthenonecannolongerremedythem。Besidesthis,thecountryisnotpillagedbyyourofficials;thesubjectsaresatisfiedbypromptrecoursetotheprince;thus,wishingtobegood,theyhavemorecausetolovehim,andwishingtobeotherwise,tofearhim。Hewhowouldattackthatstatefromtheoutsidemusthavetheutmostcaution;aslongastheprinceresidesthereitcanonlybewrestedfromhimwiththegreatestdifficulty。
Theotherandbettercourseistosendcoloniestooneortwoplaces,whichmaybeaskeystothatstate,foritisnecessaryeithertodothisorelsetokeepthereagreatnumberofcavalryandinfantry。A
princedoesnotspendmuchoncolonies,forwithlittleornoexpensehecansendthemoutandkeepthemthere,andheoffendsaminorityonlyofthecitizensfromwhomhetakeslandsandhousestogivethemtothenewinhabitants;andthosewhomheoffends,remainingpoorandscattered,areneverabletoinjurehim;whilsttherestbeinguninjuredareeasilykeptquiet,andatthesametimeareanxiousnottoerrforfearitshouldhappentothemasithastothosewhohavebeendespoiled。Inconclusion,Isaythatthesecoloniesarenotcostly,theyaremorefaithful,theyinjureless,andtheinjured,ashasbeensaid,beingpoorandscattered,cannothurt。Uponthis,onehastoremarkthatmenoughteithertobewelltreatedorcrushed,becausetheycanavengethemselvesoflighterinjuries,ofmoreseriousonestheycannot;thereforetheinjurythatistobedonetoamanoughttobeofsuchakindthatonedoesnotstandinfearofrevenge。
Butinmaintainingarmedmenthereinplaceofcoloniesonespendsmuchmore,havingtoconsumeonthegarrisonalltheincomefromthestate,sothattheacquisitionturnsintoaloss,andmanymoreareexasperated,becausethewholestateisinjured;throughtheshiftingofthegarrisonupanddownallbecomeacquaintedwithhardship,andallbecomehostile,andtheyareenemieswho,whilstbeatenontheirownground,areyetabletodohurt。Foreveryreason,therefore,suchguardsareasuselessasacolonyisuseful。
Again,theprincewhoholdsacountrydifferingintheaboverespectsoughttomakehimselftheheadanddefenderofhislesspowerfulneighbours,andtoweakenthemorepowerfulamongstthem,takingcarethatnoforeigneraspowerfulashimselfshall,byanyaccident,getafootingthere;foritwillalwayshappenthatsuchaonewillbeintroducedbythosewhoarediscontented,eitherthroughexcessofambitionorthroughfear,asonehasseenalready。TheRomanswerebroughtintoGreecebytheAetolians;andineveryothercountrywheretheyobtainedafootingtheywerebroughtinbytheinhabitants。Andtheusualcourseofaffairsisthat,assoonasapowerfulforeignerentersacountry,allthesubjectstatesaredrawntohim,movedbythehatredwhichtheyfeelagainsttherulingpower。Sothatinrespecttothosesubjectstateshehasnottotakeanytroubletogainthemovertohimself,forthewholeofthemquicklyrallytothestatewhichhehasacquiredthere。Hehasonlytotakecarethattheydonotgetholdoftoomuchpowerandtoomuchauthority,andthenwithhisownforces,andwiththeirgoodwill,hecaneasilykeepdownthemorepowerfulofthem,soastoremainentirelymasterinthecountry。Andhewhodoesnotproperlymanagethisbusinesswillsoonlosewhathehasacquired,andwhilsthedoesholdithewillhaveendlessdifficultiesandtroubles。
TheRomans,inthecountrieswhichtheyannexed,observedcloselythesemeasures;theysentcoloniesandmaintainedfriendlyrelationswith[*]theminorpowers,withoutincreasingtheirstrength;theykeptdownthegreater,anddidnotallowanystrongforeignpowerstogainauthority。Greeceappearstomesufficientforanexample。TheAchaeansandAetolianswerekeptfriendlybythem,thekingdomofMacedoniawashumbled,Antiochuswasdrivenout;yetthemeritsoftheAchaeansandAetoliansneversecuredforthempermissiontoincreasetheirpower,nordidthepersuasionsofPhilipeverinducetheRomanstobehisfriendswithoutfirsthumblinghim,nordidtheinfluenceofAntiochusmakethemagreethatheshouldretainanylordshipoverthecountry。BecausetheRomansdidintheseinstanceswhatallprudentprincesoughttodo,whohavetoregardnotonlypresenttroubles,butalsofutureones,forwhichtheymustpreparewitheveryenergy,because,whenforeseen,itiseasytoremedythem;butifyouwaituntiltheyapproach,themedicineisnolongerintimebecausethemaladyhasbecomeincurable;forithappensinthis,asthephysicianssayithappensinhecticfever,thatinthebeginningofthemaladyitiseasytocurebutdifficulttodetect,butinthecourseoftime,nothavingbeeneitherdetectedortreatedinthebeginning,itbecomeseasytodetectbutdifficulttocure。Thisithappensinaffairsofstate,forwhentheevilsthatarisehavebeenforeseen(whichitisonlygiventoawisemantosee),theycanbequicklyredressed,butwhen,throughnothavingbeenforeseen,theyhavebeenpermittedtogrowinawaythateveryonecanseethem,thereisnolongeraremedy。Therefore,theRomans,foreseeingtroubles,dealtwiththematonce,and,eventoavoidawar,wouldnotletthemcometoahead,fortheyknewthatwarisnottobeavoided,butisonlytobeputofftotheadvantageofothers;moreovertheywishedtofightwithPhilipandAntiochusinGreecesoasnottohavetodoitinItaly;theycouldhaveavoidedboth,butthistheydidnotwish;nordidthateverpleasethemwhichisforeverinthemouthsofthewiseonesofourtime:——Letusenjoythebenefitsofthetime——butratherthebenefitsoftheirownvalourandprudence,fortimedriveseverythingbeforeit,andisabletobringwithitgoodaswellasevil,andevilaswellasgood。
[*]Seeremarkintheintroductionontheword"intrattenere。"
ButletusturntoFranceandinquirewhethershehasdoneanyofthethingsmentioned。IwillspeakofLouis[*](andnotofCharles[])astheonewhoseconductisthebettertobeobserved,hehavingheldpossessionofItalyforthelongestperiod;andyouwillseethathehasdonetheoppositetothosethingswhichoughttobedonetoretainastatecomposedofdiverselements。
[*]LouisXII,KingofFrance,"TheFatherofthePeople,"born1462,died1515。
[]CharlesVIII,KingofFrance,born1470,died1498。
KingLouiswasbroughtintoItalybytheambitionoftheVenetians,whodesiredtoobtainhalfthestateofLombardybyhisintervention。
Iwillnotblamethecoursetakenbytheking,because,wishingtogetafootholdinItaly,andhavingnofriendsthere——seeingratherthateverydoorwasshuttohimowingtotheconductofCharles——hewasforcedtoacceptthosefriendshipswhichhecouldget,andhewouldhavesucceededveryquicklyinhisdesignifinothermattershehadnotmadesomemistakes。Theking,however,havingacquiredLombardy,regainedatoncetheauthoritywhichCharleshadlost:Genoayielded;
theFlorentinesbecamehisfriends;theMarquessofMantua,theDukeofFerrara,theBentivogli,myladyofForli,theLordsofFaenza,ofPesaro,ofRimini,ofCamerino,ofPiombino,theLucchese,thePisans,theSienese——everybodymadeadvancestohimtobecomehisfriend。ThencouldtheVenetiansrealizetherashnessofthecoursetakenbythem,which,inorderthattheymightsecuretwotownsinLombardy,hadmadethekingmasteroftwo—thirdsofItaly。
LetanyonenowconsiderwiththatlittledifficultythekingcouldhavemaintainedhispositioninItalyhadheobservedtherulesabovelaiddown,andkeptallhisfriendssecureandprotected;foralthoughtheywerenumeroustheywerebothweakandtimid,someafraidoftheChurch,someoftheVenetians,andthustheywouldalwayshavebeenforcedtostandinwithhim,andbytheirmeanshecouldeasilyhavemadehimselfsecureagainstthosewhoremainedpowerful。ButhewasnosoonerinMilanthanhedidthecontrarybyassistingPopeAlexandertooccupytheRomagna。Itneveroccurredtohimthatbythisactionhewasweakeninghimself,deprivinghimselfoffriendsandofthosewhohadthrownthemselvesintohislap,whilstheaggrandizedtheChurchbyaddingmuchtemporalpowertothespiritual,thusgivingitgreaterauthority。Andhavingcommittedthisprimeerror,hewasobligedtofollowitup,somuchsothat,toputanendtotheambitionofAlexander,andtopreventhisbecomingthemasterofTuscany,hewashimselfforcedtocomeintoItaly。
AndasifitwerenotenoughtohaveaggrandizedtheChurch,anddeprivedhimselfoffriends,he,wishingtohavethekingdomofNaples,dividesitwiththeKingofSpain,andwherehewastheprimearbiterinItalyhetakesanassociate,sothattheambitiousofthatcountryandthemalcontentsofhisownshouldhavesomewheretoshelter;andwhereashecouldhaveleftinthekingdomhisownpensionerasking,hedrovehimout,toputonetherewhowasabletodrivehim,Louis,outinturn。
Thewishtoacquireisintruthverynaturalandcommon,andmenalwaysdosowhentheycan,andforthistheywillbepraisednotblamed;butwhentheycannotdoso,yetwishtodosobyanymeans,thenthereisfollyandblame。Therefore,ifFrancecouldhaveattackedNapleswithherownforcessheoughttohavedoneso;ifshecouldnot,thensheoughtnottohavedividedit。AndifthepartitionwhichshemadewiththeVenetiansinLombardywasjustifiedbytheexcusethatbyitshegotafootholdinItaly,thisotherpartitionmeritedblame,forithadnottheexcuseofthatnecessity。
ThereforeLouismadethesefiveerrors:hedestroyedtheminorpowers,heincreasedthestrengthofoneofthegreaterpowersinItaly,hebroughtinaforeignpower,hedidnotsettleinthecountry,hedidnotsendcolonies。Whicherrors,hadhelived,werenotenoughtoinjurehimhadhenotmadeasixthbytakingawaytheirdominionsfromtheVenetians;because,hadhenotaggrandizedtheChurch,norbroughtSpainintoItaly,itwouldhavebeenveryreasonableandnecessarytohumblethem;buthavingfirsttakenthesesteps,heoughtnevertohaveconsentedtotheirruin,forthey,beingpowerful,wouldalwayshavekeptoffothersfromdesignsonLombardy,towhichtheVenetianswouldneverhaveconsentedexcepttobecomemastersthemselvesthere;
alsobecausetheotherswouldnotwishtotakeLombardyfromFranceinordertogiveittotheVenetians,andtoruncountertoboththeywouldnothavehadthecourage。
Andifanyoneshouldsay:"KingLouisyieldedtheRomagnatoAlexanderandthekingdomtoSpaintoavoidwar,Ianswerforthereasonsgivenabovethatablunderoughtnevertobeperpetratedtoavoidwar,becauseitisnottobeavoided,butisonlydeferredtoyourdisadvantage。AndifanothershouldallegethepledgewhichthekinghadgiventothePopethathewouldassisthimintheenterprise,inexchangeforthedissolutionofhismarriage[*]andforthecaptoRouen,[]tothatIreplywhatIshallwritelateronconcerningthefaithofprinces,andhowitoughttobekept。
[*]LouisXIIdivorcedhiswife,Jeanne,daughterofLouisXI,andmarriedin1499AnneofBrittany,widowofCharlesVIII,inordertoretaintheDuchyofBrittanyforthecrown。
[]TheArchbishopofRouen。HewasGeorgesd’Amboise,createdacardinalbyAlexanderVI。Born1460,died1510。
ThusKingLouislostLombardybynothavingfollowedanyoftheconditionsobservedbythosewhohavetakenpossessionofcountriesandwishedtoretainthem。Noristhereanymiracleinthis,butmuchthatisreasonableandquitenatural。AndonthesemattersIspokeatNanteswithRouen,whenValentino,asCesareBorgia,thesonofPopeAlexander,wasusuallycalled,occupiedtheRomagna,andonCardinalRouenobservingtomethattheItaliansdidnotunderstandwar,I
repliedtohimthattheFrenchdidnotunderstandstatecraft,meaningthatotherwisetheywouldnothaveallowedtheChurchtoreachsuchgreatness。AndinfactishasbeenseenthatthegreatnessoftheChurchandofSpaininItalyhasbeencausedbyFrance,andherruinmaybeattributedtothem。Fromthisageneralruleisdrawnwhichneverorrarelyfails:thathewhoisthecauseofanotherbecomingpowerfulisruined;becausethatpredominancyhasbeenbroughtabouteitherbyastutenessorelsebyforce,andbotharedistrustedbyhimwhohasbeenraisedtopower。
CHAPTERIV
WHYTHEKINGDOMOFDARIUS,CONQUEREDBYALEXANDER,DIDNOTREBEL
AGAINSTTHESUCCESSORSOFALEXANDERATHISDEATH
Consideringthedifficultieswhichmenhavehadtoholdtoanewlyacquiredstate,somemightwonderhow,seeingthatAlexandertheGreatbecamethemasterofAsiainafewyears,anddiedwhilstitwasscarcelysettled(whenceitmightappearreasonablethatthewholeempirewouldhaverebelled),neverthelesshissuccessorsmaintainedthemselves,andhadtomeetnootherdifficultythanthatwhicharoseamongthemselvesfromtheirownambitions。
Ianswerthattheprincipalitiesofwhichonehasrecordarefoundtobegovernedintwodifferentways;eitherbyaprince,withabodyofservants,whoassisthimtogovernthekingdomasministersbyhisfavourandpermission;orbyaprinceandbarons,whoholdthatdignitybyantiquityofbloodandnotbythegraceoftheprince。Suchbaronshavestatesandtheirownsubjects,whorecognizethemaslordsandholdtheminnaturalaffection。Thosestatesthataregovernedbyaprinceandhisservantsholdtheirprinceinmoreconsideration,becauseinallthecountrythereisnoonewhoisrecognizedassuperiortohim,andiftheyyieldobediencetoanothertheydoitastoaministerandofficial,andtheydonotbearhimanyparticularaffection。
TheexamplesofthesetwogovernmentsinourtimearetheTurkandtheKingofFrance。TheentiremonarchyoftheTurkisgovernedbyonelord,theothersarehisservants;and,dividinghiskingdomintosanjaks,hesendstheredifferentadministrators,andshiftsandchangesthemashechooses。ButtheKingofFranceisplacedinthemidstofanancientbodyoflords,acknowledgedbytheirownsubjects,andbelovedbythem;theyhavetheirownprerogatives,norcanthekingtaketheseawayexceptathisperil。Therefore,hewhoconsidersbothofthesestateswillrecognizegreatdifficultiesinseizingthestateoftheTurk,but,onceitisconquered,greateaseinholdingit。ThecausesofthedifficultiesinseizingthekingdomoftheTurkarethattheusurpercannotbecalledinbytheprincesofthekingdom,norcanhehopetobeassistedinhisdesignsbytherevoltofthosewhomthelordhasaroundhim。Thisarisesfromthereasonsgivenabove;forhisministers,beingallslavesandbondmen,canonlybecorruptedwithgreatdifficulty,andonecanexpectlittleadvantagefromthemwhentheyhavebeencorrupted,astheycannotcarrythepeoplewiththem,forthereasonsassigned。Hence,hewhoattackstheTurkmustbearinmindthathewillfindhimunited,andhewillhavetorelymoreonhisownstrengththanontherevoltofothers;but,ifoncetheTurkhasbeenconquered,androutedinthefieldinsuchawaythathecannotreplacehisarmies,thereisnothingtofearbutthefamilyofthisprince,and,thisbeingexterminated,thereremainsnoonetofear,theothershavingnocreditwiththepeople;andastheconquerordidnotrelyonthembeforehisvictory,soheoughtnottofearthemafterit。
ThecontraryhappensinkingdomsgovernedlikethatofFrance,becauseonecaneasilyentertherebygainingoversomebaronofthekingdom,foronealwaysfindsmalcontentsandsuchasdesireachange。Suchmen,forthereasonsgiven,canopenthewayintothestateandrenderthevictoryeasy;butifyouwishtoholditafterwards,youmeetwithinfinitedifficulties,bothfromthosewhohaveassistedyouandfromthoseyouhavecrushed。Norisitenoughforyoutohaveexterminatedthefamilyoftheprince,becausethelordsthatremainmakethemselvestheheadsoffreshmovementsagainstyou,andasyouareunableeithertosatisfyorexterminatethem,thatstateislostwhenevertimebringstheopportunity。
NowifyouwillconsiderwhatwasthenatureofthegovernmentofDarius,youwillfinditsimilartothekingdomoftheTurk,andthereforeitwasonlynecessaryforAlexander,firsttooverthrowhiminthefield,andthentotakethecountryfromhim。Afterwhichvictory,Dariusbeingkilled,thestateremainedsecuretoAlexander,fortheabovereasons。Andifhissuccessorshadbeenunitedtheywouldhaveenjoyeditsecurelyandattheirease,fortherewerenotumultsraisedinthekingdomexceptthosetheyprovokedthemselves。
ButitisimpossibletoholdwithsuchtranquillitystatesconstitutedlikethatofFrance。HencearosethosefrequentrebellionsagainsttheRomansinSpain,France,andGreece,owingtothemanyprincipalitiestherewereinthesestates,ofwhich,aslongasthememoryofthemendured,theRomansalwaysheldaninsecurepossession;butwiththepowerandlongcontinuanceoftheempirethememoryofthempassedaway,andtheRomansthenbecamesecurepossessors。Andwhenfightingafterwardsamongstthemselves,eachonewasabletoattachtohimselfhisownpartsofthecountry,accordingtotheauthorityhehadassumedthere;andthefamilyoftheformerlordbeingexterminated,noneotherthantheRomanswereacknowledged。
WhenthesethingsarerememberednoonewillmarvelattheeasewithwhichAlexanderheldtheEmpireofAsia,oratthedifficultieswhichothershavehadtokeepanacquisition,suchasPyrrhusandmanymore;
thisisnotoccasionedbythelittleorabundanceofabilityintheconqueror,butbythewantofuniformityinthesubjectstate。
CHAPTERV
CONCERNINGTHEWAYTOGOVERNCITIESORPRINCIPALITIESWHICH
LIVEDUNDERTHEIROWNLAWSBEFORETHEYWEREANNEXED
Wheneverthosestateswhichhavebeenacquiredasstatedhavebeenaccustomedtoliveundertheirownlawsandinfreedom,therearethreecoursesforthosewhowishtoholdthem:thefirstistoruinthem,thenextistoresidethereinperson,thethirdistopermitthemtoliveundertheirownlaws,drawingatribute,andestablishingwithinitanoligarchywhichwillkeepitfriendlytoyou。Becausesuchagovernment,beingcreatedbytheprince,knowsthatitcannotstandwithouthisfriendshipandinterest,anddoesitutmosttosupporthim;andthereforehewhowouldkeepacityaccustomedtofreedomwillholditmoreeasilybythemeansofitsowncitizensthaninanyotherway。
Thereare,forexample,theSpartansandtheRomans。TheSpartansheldAthensandThebes,establishingthereanoligarchy,neverthelesstheylostthem。TheRomans,inordertoholdCapua,Carthage,andNumantia,dismantledthem,anddidnotlosethem。TheywishedtoholdGreeceastheSpartansheldit,makingitfreeandpermittingitslaws,anddidnotsucceed。Sotoholdittheywerecompelledtodismantlemanycitiesinthecountry,forintruththereisnosafewaytoretainthemotherwisethanbyruiningthem。Andhewhobecomesmasterofacityaccustomedtofreedomanddoesnotdestroyit,mayexpecttobedestroyedbyit,forinrebellionithasalwaysthewatchwordoflibertyanditsancientprivilegesasarallyingpoint,whichneithertimenorbenefitswillevercauseittoforget。Andwhateveryoumaydoorprovideagainst,theyneverforgetthatnameortheirprivilegesunlesstheyaredisunitedordispersed,butateverychancetheyimmediatelyrallytothem,asPisaafterthehundredyearsshehadbeenheldinbondagebytheFlorentines。
Butwhencitiesorcountriesareaccustomedtoliveunderaprince,andhisfamilyisexterminated,they,beingontheonehandaccustomedtoobeyandontheotherhandnothavingtheoldprince,cannotagreeinmakingonefromamongstthemselves,andtheydonotknowhowtogovernthemselves。Forthisreasontheyareveryslowtotakeuparms,andaprincecangainthemtohimselfandsecurethemmuchmoreeasily。Butinrepublicsthereismorevitality,greaterhatred,andmoredesireforvengeance,whichwillneverpermitthemtoallowthememoryoftheirformerlibertytorest;sothatthesafestwayistodestroythemortoresidethere。
第1章