首页 >出版文学> Jeremy Bentham>第3章

第3章

  andareconvincedthattheBritishConstitutionrepresentsanunsurpassablethoughunfortunatelyanidealorderofthings,whichmusthaveexistedatsomeindefiniteperiod。Chathaminoneofhismostfamousspeeches,appeals,forexample,tothe’ironbarons’whoresistedKingJohn,andcontraststhemwiththesilkencourtierswhichnowcompeteforplaceandpensions。Thepoliticalreformersofthetime,likereligiousreformersinmosttimes,conceiveofthemselvesonlyasdemandingtherestorationofthesystemtoitsoriginalpurity,notasdemandingitsabrogation。Inotherwords,theyproposetoremedyabusesbutdonotasyetevencontemplateareallyrevolutionarychange。
  Wilkeswasnota’Wilkite,’norwasanyofhisparty,ifWilkitemeantanythinglikeJacobin。
  II。TheRulingClassThus,howeveranomaloustheconstitutionofparliament,therewasnothoughtofanyfar-reachingrevolutionThegreatmassofthepopulationwastooignorant,tooscatteredandtoopoortohaveanyrealpoliticalopinions。Solongascertainprejudiceswerenotaroused,itwascontenttoleavethemanagementofthestatetothedominantclass,whichalonewasintelligentenoughtotakeaninterestinpublicaffairsandstrongenoughtomakeitsinterestfelt。Thisclassconsistedinthefirstplaceofthegreatlandedinterest。
  WhenLordNorthopposedPitt’sreformin1785hesaid4*thattheConstitutionwas’theworkofinfinitewisdom……themostbeautifulfabricthathadeverexistedsincethebeginningoftime。’Headdedthat’thebulkandweight’
  ofthehouseoughttobein’thehandsofthecountry-gentlemen,thebestandmostrespectableobjectsoftheconfidenceofthepeople。’Thespeech,thoughintendedtopleaseanaudienceofcountry-gentlemen,representedagenuinebelief。5*Thecountry-gentlemenformedtheclasstowhichnotonlytheconstitutionallawsbuttheprevailingsentimentofthecountrygavetheleadinpoliticsasinthewholesocialsystem。EvenreformersproposedtoimprovetheHouseofCommonschieflybyincreasingthenumberofcounty-members,andacounty-memberwasalmostnecessarilyacountry-gentlemanofanexaltedkind。Althoughthecountry-gentlemanwasveryfarfromhavingallthingshisownway,hisidealsandprejudiceswereinagreatdegreethemouldtowhichtheotherpoliticallyimportantclassconformed。Therewasindeedagrowingjealousybetweenthelandholdersandthe’monied-men。’Bolingbrokehadexpressedthisdistrustatanearlierpartofthecentury。Butthetruerepresentativeoftheperiodwashissuccessfulrival,Walpole,athoroughcountry-gentlemanwhohadlearnedtounderstandthemysteriesoffinanceandacquiredtheconfidenceofthecity。ThegreatmerchantsofLondonandtherisingmanufacturersinthecountrywererapidlygrowinginwealthandinfluence。Themonied-menrepresentedthemostactive,energetic,andgrowingpartofthebodypolitic。Theirinterestsdeterminedthedirectionofthenationalpolicy。ThegreatwarsofthecenturywereundertakenintheinterestsofBritishtrade。TheextensionoftheempireinIndiawascarriedonthroughagreatcommercialcompany。Thegrowthofcommercesupportedthesea-powerwhichwasthemainfactorinthedevelopmentoftheempire。Thenewindustrialorganisationwhichwasarisingwasinlateryearstorepresentaclassdistinctlyopposedtotheoldaristocraticorder。Atpresentitwasinacomparativelysubordinateposition。Thesquirewasinterestedinthelandandthechurch;
  themerchantthoughtmoreofcommerceandwasapttobeadissenter。Butthemerchant,inspiteofsomelittlejealousies,admittedtheclaimsofthecountry-gentlemantobehissocialsuperiorandpoliticalleader。Hishighestambitionwastobehimselfadmittedtotheclassortosecuretheadmissionofhisfamily。AshebecamerichheboughtasolidmansionatClaphamorWimbledon,and,ifhemadeafortune,mightbecomelordofmanorsinthecountry。Hecouldnotasyetaspiretobecomehimselfapeer,buthemightbetheancestorofpeers。ThesonofJosiahChild,thegreatmerchantoftheseventeenthcentury,becameEarlTylney,andbuiltatWansteadoneofthenoblestmansionsinEngland。HiscontemporarySirFrancisChild,LordMayor,andafounderoftheBankofEngland,builtOsterleyHouse,andwasancestoroftheearlsofJerseyandWestmoreland。ThedaughterofSirJohnBarnard,thetypicalmerchantofWalpole’stime,marriedthesecondLordPalmerston。Beckford,thefamousLordMayorofChatham’sday,wasfatheroftheauthorofVatheh,whomarriedanearl’sdaughterandbecamethefatherofaduchess。TheBarings,descendantsofaGermanpastor,settledinEnglandearlyinthecenturyandbecamecountry-gentlemen,baronets,andpeers。Cobbett,whosawthemrise,reviledthestockjobberswhowerebuyingouttheoldfamilies。
  Buttheprocesshadbegunlongbeforehisdays,andmeantthattheheadsofthenewindustrialsystemwerebeingabsorbedintotheclassofterritorialmagnates。Thatclassrepresentedtheframeworkuponwhichbothpoliticalandsocialpowerwasmoulded。
  Thisimpliesanessentialcharacteristicofthetime。AfamiliartopicoftheadmirersoftheBritishConstitutionwastheabsenceofthesharplinesofdemarcationbetweenclassesandoftheexclusivearistocraticprivilegeswhich,inFrance,provokedtherevolution。InEnglandtherulingclasswasnota’survival’;ithadnotretainedprivilegeswithoutdischargingcorrespondingfunctions。Theessenceof’self-government,’saysitsmostlearnedcommentator,6*
  istheorganicconnection’betweenStateandsociety。’OntheContinent,thatis,powerswereintrustedtoacentralisedadministrativeandjudicialhierarchy,whichinEnglandwerelefttotheclassindependentlystrongbyitssocialposition。Thelandholderwaspowerfulasaproductofthewholesystemofindustrialandagriculturaldevelopment;andhewasboundinreturntoperformarduousandcomplicatedduties。Howfarheperformedthemwellisanotherquestion。Atleast,hedidwhateverwasdoneinthewayofgoverning,andthereforedidnotsinkintoamereexcrescenceorsuperfluity。ImusttrytopointoutcertainresultswhichhadamaterialeffectuponEnglishopinioningeneraland,inparticular,upontheUtilitarians。
  III。LegislationandAdministrationThecountry-gentlemenformedthebulkofthelawmakingbody,andthelawsgavethefirstpointofassaultoftheUtilitarianmovement。OneexplanationissuggestedbyaphraseattributedtoSirJosiahChild。7*Thelaws,hesaid,wereaheapofnonsense,compiledbyafewignorantcountry-gentlemen,whohardlyknewhowtomakegoodlawsforthegovernmentoftheirownfamilies,muchlessfortheregulationofcompaniesandforeigncommerce。Hemeantthattheparliamentarylegislationofthecenturywastheworkofamateurs,notofspecialists;ofanassemblyofmenmoreinterestedinimmediatequestionsofpolicyorpersonalintriguethaningeneralprinciples,andnotofsuchacentralisedbodyaswouldsetavalueuponsymmetryandscientificprecision。
  Thecountry-gentlemanhadstrongprejudicesandenoughcommonsensetorecognisehisownignorance。Theproductofatraditionalorder,heclungtotraditions,andregardedtheoldmaximsassacredbecausenoobviousreasoncouldbeassignedforthem。Hewassuspiciousofabstracttheories,anditdidnotevenoccurtohimthatanysuchprocessascodificationorradicalalterationofthelawswasconceivable。ForthelawitselfhehadtheprofoundvenerationwhichisexpressedbyBlackstone。Itrepresentedthe’wisdomofourancestors’;
  thesystemoffirstprinciples,Onwhichthewholeorderofthingsreposed,andwhichmustberegardedasanembodimentofrightreason。Thecommonlawwasatradition,notmadebyexpresslegislation,butsomehowexistingapartfromanydefiniteembodiment,andrevealedtocertainlearnedhierophants。
  Anychanges,requiredbythegrowthofnewsocialconditions,hadtobemadeunderpretenceofapplyingtheoldrulessupposedtobealreadyinexistence。
  Thusgrewupthesystemof’judge-madelaw,’whichwastobecomeaspecialobjectofthedenunciationsofBentham。Childhadnoticedtheincompetenceofthecountry-gentlementounderstandtheregulationofcommercialaffairs。
  Thegapwasbeingfilledup,withoutexpresslegislation,byjudicialinterpretationsofMansfieldandhisfellows。This,indeed,marksacharacteristicofthewholesystem。’Ourconstitution,’saysProfessorDicey,8*’isajudge-madeconstitution,anditbearsonitsfaceallthefeatures,goodandbad,ofjudge-madelaw。’Thelawoflandedproperty,meanwhile,wasofvitalandimmediateinteresttothecountry-gentleman。But,feelinghisownincompetence,hehadcalledintheaidoftheexpert。Thelawhadbeendevelopedinmedievaltimes,andboreinallitsdetailsthemarksofthelongseriesofstrugglesbetweenkingandnoblesandparliaments。Oneresulthadbeentheelaborateseriesoflegalfictionsworkedoutintheconflictbetweenprivateinterestsandpublicpolicy,bywhichlawyershadbeenabletoadapttherulesfittedforanancientstateofsocietytoanotherinwhichtheveryfundamentalconceptionswerealtered。Amysterioussystemhadthusgrownup,whichdeterredanybutthemostresolutestudents。OfFearne’sessayupon’Contingentremainders’
  publishedin1772itwassaidthatnowork’inanybranchofsciencecouldaffordamorebeautifulinstanceofanalysis。’Fearnehadshowntheacutenessof’aNewtonoraPascal。’Othercriticsdisputethisproposition;butinanycasethelawwassoperplexingthatitcouldonlybefullyunderstoodbyonewhounitedantiquarianknowledgetothesubtletyofagreatlogician。
  The’vastandintricatemachine,’asBlackstonecallsit,’ofavoluminousfamilysettlement’requiredforitsexplanationthedialecticalskillofanaccomplishedschoolman。Thepoorcountry-gentlemancouldnotunderstandthetermsonwhichheheldhisownestatewithoutcallinginanexpertequaltosuchatask。Themanwhohasacquiredskillsoessentialtohisemployer’sinterestsisnotlikelytoundervalueitortobeoveranxioustosimplifythelabyrinthinwhichheshoneasacompetentguide。
  Thelawyerswhoplayedsoimportantapartbytheirfamiliaritywiththemysteriesofcommerciallawandlandedproperty,naturallyenjoyedtherespectoftheirclients,andwererewardedbyadoptionintotheclass。TheEnglishbarristeraspiredtosuccessbyhimselftakingpartinpoliticsandlegislation。
  Theonlypathtothehighestpositionsreallyopentoamanofability,notconnectedbybloodwiththegreatfamilies,wasthepathwhichledtothewoolsackortothejudge’sbench。Agreatmerchantmightbethefatherorfather-in-lawofpeers;asuccessfulsoldierorsailormighthimselfbecomeapeer,butgenerallyhebeganlifeasamemberoftherulingclasses,andhispromotionwasaffectedbyparliamentaryinfluence。ButasuccessfullawyermightfighthiswayfromahumblepositiontotheHouseofLords。Thurlow,sonofacountry-gentleman;Dunning,sonofacountryattorney;Ellenborough,sonofabishopanddefendantofalonglineofNorth-country’statesmen’;
  Kenyon,sonofafarmer;Eldon,sonofaNewcastlecoalmerchant,representtheaveragecareerofasuccessfulbarrister。Someofthemrosetobemenofpoliticalimportance,andThurlowandEldonhadtheadvantageofkeepingGeorgeIII’sconscience——anunrulyfacultywhichhadanunfortunatelystronginfluenceuponaffairs。Theleadersofthelegalprofession,therefore,andthosewhohopedtobeleaders,sharedtheprejudices,tookapartinthestruggles,andwererewardedbythehonoursofthedominantclass。
  Thecriminallawbecameamaintopicofreformers。There,aselsewhere,wehaveastrikingexampleoftraditionalmodesofthoughtsurvivingwithsingularpersistence。Theroughclassificationofcrimesintofelonyandmisdemeanour,andthestrangetechnicalrulesabout’benefitofclergy’datingbacktothestrugglesofHenryIIandBecket,remainedlikeultimatecategoriesofthought。Whenthegrowthofsocialconditionsledtonewtemptationsortheappearanceofanewcriminalclass,andparticularvarietiesofcrimebecameconspicuous,theonlyremedywastodeclarethatsomeoffenceshouldbe’felonywithoutbenefitofclergy,’andthereforepunishablebydeath。