首页 >出版文学> Jeremy Bentham>第14章

第14章

  Therewere5000public-houses,and50,000womensupported,whollyorpartly,byprostitution。Therevenuesraisedbycrimeamounted,ashecalculates,toanannualsumof£;2,000,000。Therewerewholeclassesofprofessionalthieves,moreorlessorganisedingangs,whichactedinsupportofeachother。Thereweregangsontheriver,whoboardedshipsatnight,orlayinwaitroundthewarehouses。Thegovernmentdockyardsweresystematicallyplundered,andthesamearticleoftensoldfourtimesovertotheofficials。
  TheabsenceofpatrolsgaveamplechancetothehighwaymenthenpeculiartoEngland。Theircareers,commemoratedintheNewgateCalendar,hadacertainflavourofRobinHoodromance,andtheirrankswererecruitedfromdissipatedapprenticesandtradesmenindifficulty。ThefieldsroundLondonweresoconstantlyplunderedthattherentwasmateriallylowered。Halfthehackneycoachmen,hesays,29*wereinleaguewiththieves。Thenumberofreceivinghousesforstolengoodshadincreasedintwentyyearsfrom300to3000。30*
  Coiningwasaflourishingtrade,andaccordingtoColquhounemployedseveralthousandpersons。31*Gamblinghadtakenafreshstartabout1777and1778;32*
  andthekeepersoftableshadalwaysmoneyenoughatcommandtomakeconvictionsalmostimpossible。Frenchrefugeesattherevolutionhadintroducedrougeetnoir;andColquhounestimatesthesumsyearlylostingambling-housesatover£;7,000,000。ThegamblersmightperhapsappealnotonlytothepracticesoftheirbettersinthedaysofFox,buttothepubliclotteries。
  Colquhounhadvariouscorrespondents,whodonotventuretoproposetheabolitionofasystemwhichsanctionedthepractice,butwhohopetodiminishthefacilityforsupplementarybettingontheresultsoftheofficialdrawing。
  ThewarhadtendedtoincreasethenumberoflooseanddesperatemarauderswhoswarmedinthevastlabyrinthofLondonstreets。WhenweconsiDerthenatureofthepolicebywhichtheseevilsweretobechecked,andthecriminallawwhichtheyadministered,thewonderislessthatthereweresometimesdesperateriotsasin1780thanthatLondonshouldhavebeeneverabletoresistamob。Colquhoun,thoughapatrioticBriton,hastoadmitthattheFrenchdespotshadatlastcreatedanefficientpolice。33*Theemperor,JosephII,hesays,inquiredforanAustriancriminalsupposedtohaveescapedtoParis。Youwillfindhim,repliedtheheadoftheFrenchpolice,atNo。
  93ofsuchastreetinViennaonthesecond-floorroomlookinguponsuchachurch;andtherehewas。InEnglandacriminalcouldhidehimselfinaherdofhislike,occasionallydisturbedbytheinroadofa’BowStreetrunner,’
  theemissaryofthe’tradingjustices,’formerlyrepresentedbythetwoFieldings。
  Anactof1792createdsevennewoffices,tooneofwhichColquhounhadbeenappointed。Theyhadonehundredandeighty-ninepaidofficersunderthem。34*
  Therewerealsoaboutonethousandconstables。Theseweresmalltradesmenorartisansuponwhomthedutywasimposedwithoutremunerationforayearbytheirparish,thatis,byoneofseventyindependentbodies。A’Tyburnticket,’giveninrewardforobtainingtheconvictionofacriminalexemptedamanfromthedischargeofsuchoffices,andcouldbeboughtforfrom£;15
  to£;25。Therewerealsotwothousandwatchmenreceivingfrom81/2d。
  upto2s。anight。ThesewerethetruesuccessorsofDogberry;ofteninfirmoragedpersonsappointedtokeepthemoutoftheworkhouse。Themanagementofthisdistractedforcethusdependeduponamiscellaneoussetofbodies;
  thepaidmagistrates,theofficialsofthecity,thejusticesofthepeaceforMiddlesex,andtheseventyindependentparishes。
  Thelawwasasdefectiveastheadministration。Colqulhounrepresentsthephilanthropicimpulseoftheday,andnotices35*thatin1787JosephIIhadabolishedcapitalpunishment。HischiefauthorityformoremercifulmethodsisBeccaria;anditisworthremarking,forreasonswhichwillappearhereafter,thathedoesnotinthisconnectionrefertoBentham,althoughhespeaksenthusiastically36*ofBentham’smodelprison,thePanopticon。
  Colquhounshowshowstrangelytheseverityofthelawwascombinedwithitsextremecapriciousness。HequotesBacon37*forthestatementthatthelawwasa’heterogeneousmassconcoctedtoooftenonthespurofthemoment,’
  andgivessufficientproofsofitstruth。Hedesires,forexample,alawtopunishreceiversofstolengoods,andsaysthattherewereexcellentlawsinexistence。Unfortunatelyonelawappliedexclusivelytothecaseofpewter-pots,andanotherexclusivelytothepreciousmetals;neithercouldbeusedasagainstreceiversofhorsesorbanknotes。38*Soamanindictedunderanactagainststealingfromshipsonnavigableriversescaped,becausethebargefromwhichhestolehappenedtobeaground。Gangscouldaffordtocorruptwitnessesortopayknavishlawyersskilledinapplyingthesevagariesoflegislation。Juriesalsodislikedconvictingwhenthepenaltyforcoiningsix-pencewasthesameasthepenaltyforkillingamother。Itfollowed,asheshowsbystatistics,thathalfthepersonscommittedfortrialescapedbypettychicaneryorcorruption,orthereluctanceofjuriestoconvictforcapitaloffences。Onlyaboutone-fifthofthecapitalsentenceswereexecuted;andmanywerepardonedonconditionofenlistingtoimprovethemoralsofthearmy。Thecriminals,whowereneitherhangednorallowedtoescape,weresenttoprisons,whichwereschoolsofvice。AftertheindependenceoftheAmericancolonies,thesystemoftransportationtoAustraliahadbegunin1787;buttheexpensewasenormous,andprisonerswerehuddledtogetherinthehulksatWoolwichandPortsmouth,whichhadbeenusedasatemporaryexpedient。Thencetheywereconstantlydischarged,toreturntotheiroldpractices。Aman,saysColquhoun,39*woulddeserveastatuewhoshouldcarryoutaplanforhelpingdischargedprisoners。Tomeettheseevils,Colquhounproposesvariousremedies,suchasametropolitanpolice,apublicprosecutor,orevenacodificationorrevisionoftheCriminalCode,whichheseesislikelytobedelayed。Healsosuggested,inapamphletof1799,akindofcharityorganisationsocietytopreventthewasteoffunds。Manyotherpamphletsofsimilartendenciesshowhisactivezealinpromotingvariousreforms。
  ColquhounwasinclosecorrespondencewithBenthamfromtheyear1798,40*
  andBenthamhelpedhimbydrawingtheThamesPoliceAct,passedin1800,togiveeffecttosomeofthesuggestionsintheTreatise。41*
  AnothersetofabuseshasaspecialconnectionwithBentham’sactivity。
  Benthamhadbeenledin1778toattendtotheprisonquestionbyreadingHoward’sbookonPrisons;andhereferstothe’venerablefriendwhohadlivedanapostleanddiedamartyr。’42*ThecareerofJohnHoward1726-1790
  isfamiliar。ThesonofaLondontradesman,hehadinheritedanestateinBedfordshire。Thereheerectedmodelcottagesandvillageschools;and,onbecomingsheriffofthecountyin1773,wasledtoattendtoabusesintheprisons。Twoactsofparliamentwerepassedin1774toremedysomeoftheevilsexposed,andhepursuedtheinquiryathomeandabroad。HisresultsaregiveninhisStateofthePrisonsinEnglandandWales1779,fourthedition,1792,andhisAccountofthePrincipalLazarettosinEurope1789。
  Theprisoners,hesays,hadlittlefood,sometimesapennyloafaday,andsometimesnothing;nowater,nofreshair,nosewers,andnobedding。Thestenchwasappalling,andgaolfeverkilledmorethandiedonthegallows。
  Debtorsandfelons,men,womenandchildren,werehuddledtogether;oftenwithlunatics,whowereshownbythegaolersformoney。’Garnish’wasextorted;
  thegaolerskeptdrinking-taps;gamblingflourished:andprisonerswereoftencruellyironed,andkeptforlongperiodsbeforetrial。AtHulltheassizeshadonlybeenheldonceinsevenyears,andafterwardsonceinthree。ItisacomforttofindthatthewholenumberofprisonersinEnglandandWalesamounted,in1780,toabout4400,1078ofwhomweredebtors,798felons,and917pettyoffenders。Anactpassedin1779providedfortheerectionoftwopenitentiaries。Howardwastobeasupervisor。Thefailuretocarryoutthisactled,asweshallsee,tooneofBentham’smostcharacteristicundertakings。Onepeculiaritymustbenoted。Howardfoundprisonsonthecontinentwherethetreatmentwasbadandtorturestilloccasionallypractised;
  buthenowherefoundthingssobadasinEngland。InHollandtheprisonsweresoneatandcleanastomakeitdifficulttobelievethattheywereprisons:andtheywereusedasmodelsforthelegislationof1779。OnecauseofthisunenviabledistinctionofEnglishprisonshadbeenindicatedbyanearlierinvestigation。GeneralOglethorpe1696-1785hadbeenstartedinhisphilanthropiccareerbyobtainingacommitteeoftheHouseofCommonsin1729toinquireintothestateofthegaols。ThefoundationofthecolonyofGeorgiaasanoutletforthepopulationwasoneresultoftheinquiry。
  Itled,inthefirstplace,however,toatrialofpersonsaccusedofatrociouscrueltiesattheFleetprison。43*Thetrialwasabortive。ItappearedinthecourseoftheproceedingsthattheFleetprisonwasa’freehold。’ApatentforrebuildingithadbeengrantedtoSirJeremyWhichcotunderCharlesII,andhadbeensoldtooneHiggins,whoresoldittootherpersonsfor£;5000。
  Theproprietorsmadetheirinvestmentpaybycruelill-treatmentoftheprisoners,oppressingthepoorandlettingoffpartsoftheprisontodealersindrink。
  ThiswasthegeneralplanintheprisonsexaminedbyHoward,andhelpstoaccountforthegrossabuses。Itisonemoreapplicationofthegeneralsystem。
  Asthepatronwasownerofaliving,andtheofficerofhiscommission,thekeeperofaprisonwasownerofhisestablishment。Theparalysisofadministrationwhichprevailedthroughoutthecountrymadeitnaturaltofarmoutpauperstothemasterofaworkhouse,andprisonerstotheproprietorofagaol。
  ThestateofprisonersmaybeinferrednotonlyfromHoward’sauthenticrecordbutfromthefictionsofFielding,SmollettandGoldsmith;andthelastechoesofthesamecomplaintsmaybefoundinPickwickandLittleDorrit。TheMarshalseadescribedinthelastwasalsoaproprietaryconcern。WeshallhereafterseehowBenthamproposedtotreattheevilsrevealedbyOglethorpeandHoward,III。EDUCATION
  AnothertopictreatedbyColquhounmarkstheinitialstageofcontroversieswhichweresoontogrowwarm。ColquhounboastsofthenumberofcharitiesforwhichLondonwasalreadyconspicuous。Agrowingfacilityforformingassociationsofallkinds,political,religious,scientific,andcharitable,isanobviouscharacteristicofmodernprogress。Whereinearliertimesacollegeorahospitalhadtobeendowedbyafounderandinvestedbycharterwithcorporatepersonality,itisnownecessaryonlytocallameeting,formacommittee,andappealforsubscriptions。Societiesofvariouskindshadsprungupduringthecentury。Artists,menofscience,agriculturists,andmenofliterarytastes,hadfoundedinnumerableacademiesand’philosophicalinstitutes。’ThegreatLondonhospitals,dependentuponvoluntarysubscriptions,hadbeenfoundedduringthefirsthalfofthecentury。Colquhouncountstheannualrevenueofvariouscharitableinstitutionsat£;445,000,besideswhichtheendowmentsproduced£;150,000,andthepoor-rates£;255,000。44*