首页 >出版文学> James Mill>第2章

第2章

  IhavealreadynoticedtheimportanceoftheQuakershareinthevariousphilanthropicmovementsofthetime。TheQuakersharedmanyoftheviewsuponpracticalquestionswhichwerefavouredbythefreethinker,Bothwerehostiletoslavery,infavourofspreadingeducation,opposedtoallreligioustestsandrestrictions,andadvocatesofreforminprisons,andintheharshcriminallaw。ThefundamentaldifferencesoftheologicalbeliefwerenotsoproductiveofdiscordindealingwiththeQuakersaswithothersects;foritwastheveryessenceoftheoldQuakerspirittolookrathertothespiritthantotheletter,Allen,therefore,wasonlyactinginthespiritofhissocietywhenhecouldbeonequallygoodtermswiththeEmperorAlexanderorthedukeofKent,and,ontheotherhand,withJamesMill,thedenouncerofkingsandautocrats。HecouldjoinhandswithMillinassailingslavery,insistinguponprisonreform,preachingtolerationandadvancingcivilisation,althoughheheartilydisapprovedofthedoctrineswithwhichMill’spracticalprincipleswereassociated。Mill,too,practisedeventoaquestionabledegreethemethodofreticence,andtookgoodcarenottooffendhiscoadjutor。
  Theirco-operationwasmanifestedinaquarterlyjournalcalledthePhilanthropist,whichappearedduringthesevenyears,1811-1817,andwaspublishedatAllen’sexpense。
  Millfoundinittheopportunityofadvocatingmanyofhischerishedopinions。
  HedefendedtolerationinthenameofPenn,whoselifehadbeenpublishedbyClarkson。Heattackedtheslave-owners,andsocameintoalliancewithWilberforce,ZacharyMacaulay,andothersoftheevangelicalpersuasion。
  Hefound,atthesametime,opportunitiesforpropagatingthecreedofBenthaminconnectionwithquestionsofprisonreformandthepenalcode。
  Hismostimportantarticle,publishedin1812,wasanothercontributiontotheLancasteriancontroversy。InthisMillhadalliesofaverydifferentschool;andhisactivitybringshimintocloseconnectionwithoneofthemostremarkablemenofthetime。8
  ThiswasFrancisPlace,thefamousRadicaltailor。Place,born3rdNovember1771,hadraisedhimselffromthepositionofaworking-mantobeoccupantofashopatCharingCross,whichbecamethecentreofimportantpoliticalmovements。BetweenPlaceandMilltherewasmuchaffinityofcharacter。Place,likeMill,wasamanofrigidandvigorousintellect。Dogmatic,self-confident,anddecidedlycensorious,notattractivebyanysweetnessorgraceofcharacter,butthoroughlysincereandindependent,heextortsratherthancommandsourrespectbyhisheartydevotiontowhatheatleastbelievedtobethecauseoftruthandprogress。Placewaswhatisnowcalledathorough’individualist。’
  Hebelievedinself-relianceandenergy,andheldthattheclasstowhichhebelongedwastoberaised,ashehadraisedhimself,bytheexerciseofthosequalities,notbyinvokingthedirectinterferenceofthecentralpower,which,indeed,asheknewit,wasonlylikelytointerfereonthewrongside。HehadthemisfortunetobeborninLondoninsteadofScotland,andhadthereforenotMill’seducationaladvantages。Hetriedenergetically,andnotunsuccessfully,toimprovehismind,butheneverquitesurmountedtheweaknessoftheself-educatedman,andhadnospecialliterarytalent。
  Hiswriting,infact,isdullandlong-winded,thoughhehasthemeritofjudgingforhimself,andofsayingwhathethinks。
  PlacehadbeenamemberoftheCorrespondingSociety,andwasatonetimechairmanoftheweeklycommittee。
  Hehad,however,disapprovedoftheirproceedings,andretiredintimetoescapetheimprisonmentwhichfinallycrushedthecommittee。HewasnowoccupiedinbuildinguphisownfortunesatCharingCross。When,duringthesecondwar,thenativeEnglishRadicalismbeganagaintoraiseitshead,Placetookahighlyimportantshareinthepoliticalagitation。Westminster,theconstituencyinwhichhehadavote,hadlongbeenoneofthemostimportantboroughs。Itwasoneofthefewlargepopularconstituencies,andwasaffectedbytheinfluencesnaturallystrongestinthemetropolis。
  Afterbeinglongundertheinfluenceofthecourtandthedeanandchapter,ithadbeencarriedbyFoxduringthediscontentsof1780,whenthereformmovementtookastartandthecountyassociationsweresymptomsofagrowingagitation。ThegreatWhigleader,thoughnotsounduponthequestionofreform,representedtheconstituencytillhisdeath,andreformdroppedoutofnoticeforthetime。UponFox’sdeath13thSeptember1806LordPercywaselectedwithoutoppositionashissuccessorbyanarrangementamongtherulingfamilies。Placewasdisgustedatthedistributionof’breadandcheeseandbeer,’andresolvedtofindatrulypopularcandidate。
  Inthegeneralelectionwhichsoonfollowedattheendof1806hesupportedPaull,animpecuniousadventurer,whomadeagoodfight,butwasbeatenbySirJ。HoodandSheridan。Placenowproposedamorethoroughorganisationoftheconstituency,andformedacommitteeintendedtocarryanindependentcandidate。SirFrancisBurdett,atypicalcountrygentlemanofnogreatbrainsandofmucharistocraticpride,butamanofhonour,andofasmuchliberalfeelingaswascompatiblewithwealthandstation,hadsatatthefeetoftheoldRadical,HorneTooke。HehadsympathisedwiththeFrenchrevolution;butwasmainly,likehismentor,Tooke,areformeroftheEnglishtype,andabelieverinMagnaChartaandtheBillofRights。Hehadsatinparliament,andin1802hadbeenelectedforMiddlesex。Afteraprolongedlitigation,costingenormoussums,theelectionhadbeenfinallyannulledin1806。Hehadsubscribed£;1000towardsPaull’sexpenses;butwassodisgustedwithhisownelectionexperiencesthatherefusedtocomeforwardasacandidate。Place’scommitteeresolvedthereforetoelecthimandPaullfreeofexpense。DisputesbetweenPaullandBurdettledtoaduel,inwhichbothwerewounded。ThecommitteethrewoverPaull,andattheelectiononthedissolutionofparliamentinthespringof1807,BurdettandCochrane——afterwardsLordDundonald——weretriumphantlyelected,defeatingtheWhigcandidates,SheridanandElliot。Theelectionwasthefirsttriumphofthereformers,andwasduetoPlacemorethananyone。
  BurdettretainedhisseatforWestminsteruntil1837,and,inspiteofmanyquarrelswithhisparty,wasaleadingrepresentativeofthemovement,whichhenceforwardslowlygatheredstrength。Place,indeed,hadapparentlybutscantyrespectforthecandidatewhosesuccesshehadsecured。Burdettandhislikeaimedatpopularity,whilehewascontenttobeignoredsolongashecouldbyanymeanscarrythemeasureswhichheapproved。Place,therefore,actedasamostefficientwirepuller,buthadnoambitiontoleavehisshoptomakespeechesonthehustings。
  ThescandalsaboutthedukeofYorkandtheWalcherenexpeditiongaveachancetotheRadicalsandtotheirleaderintheHouseofCommons。Eventsin1810ledtoapopularexplosion,ofwhichBurdettwasthehero。JohnGaleJones,anoldmemberoftheCorrespondingSocieties,hadputoutaplacarddenouncingtheHouseofCommonsforclosingitsdoorsduringadebateupontheWalcherenexpedition。
  TheHouseproceededagainstJones,whowasmoreorlessadvisedbyPlaceinhisproceedings。BurdetttookthepartofJones,byapaperpublishedinCobbett’sRegister,andwasultimatelycommittedtothetowerinconsequence。ThewholeofLondonwasforatimeinastateofexcitement,anduponthevergeofanoutbreak。Burdettrefusedtosubmittothearrest。
  Mobscollected;soldiersfilledthestreetsandwerepelted。Burdett,whenatlasthewasforcedtoadmittheofficers,appearedinhisdrawing-roomintheactofexpoundingMagnaChartatohisson。That,itwastobesupposed,washisusualoccupationofanafternoon。Meetingswereheld,andresolutionspassed,insupportofthemartyrtoliberty;andwhenhisimprisonmentterminatedontheprorogationofparliament,vastcrowdscollected,andaprocessionwasarrangedtoconvoyhimtohishome。Placehadbeenactiveinarrangingallthedetailsofwhatwastobeagreatpopularmanifestation。
  Tohisinfinitedisgust,Burdettshrankfromtheperformance,andwenthomebywater。Thecrowdwaslefttoexpenditsremainingenthusiasmuponthehackneycarriagewhichcontainedhisfellow-suffererJones。Jones,inthefollowingDecember,wassentencedtotwelvemonths’imprisonmentforalibel。Cobbett,Burdett’sspecialsupporteratthistime,wasalsoimprisonedinJune1810。Foratimethepopularagitationcollapsed。PlaceseemstohavethoughtthatthefailurewasduetoBurdett’swantofcourage,anddroppedallcommunicationwithhimtillalatercontestatWestminster。
  Placewasthusatthecentreofthepoliticalagitationwhich,forthetime,representedthemostenergeticreformingmovement。Itwasin1811or1812thathebecameacquaintedwithMill。9InMillherecognisedacongenialspirit,andamanabletodefendanddevelopprinciples。Heperhaps,asProfessorBainthinks,madeadvancestoMilluponthestrengthofthehistoryofIndia;andin1814hewascertainlyendeavouringtoraisemoneytoputMillabovetheneedofprecarioushack-work。10TheanticipateddifficultyofpersuadingMillsofartosacrificehisindependencewasapparentlyfataltothescheme。PlacewasinoccasionalcommunicationwithBentham,andvisitedhimatFordAbbeyin1817。Hebecameintimatewiththegreatman;
  helpedhiminbusinessaffairs;andwasoneofthedisciplesemployedtopreparehisbooksforpublication。11Benthamwasthesourceofphilosophy,andMillonlyhisprophet。ButMill,whowascapableofactivityinpracticalaffairs,wasmoreusefultoamanoftheworld。ThefirstbusinesswhichbroughtthemintocloseconnectionwastheLancasteriancontroversy。Thestronginterestrousedbythisagitationwassignificantofmanydifficultiestocome。Theaveragemindhadbeengraduallycomingtotheconclusionthatthepoorshouldbetaughttoreadandwrite。SundayschoolsandHannahMore’sschoolsinSomersetshirehaddrawntheattentionofthereligiousworldtothesubject。Duringtheearlyyearsofthecenturytheeducationquestionhadsteadilybecomemoreprominent,andthegrowinginterestwasshownbyasingularlybitterandcomplicatedcontroversy。
  TheoppositepartiesfoughtunderthebannersofBellandLancaster。AndrewBell,bornatSt。Andrews,27thMarch1753,wasbothacannyScotandanAnglicanclergyman。Hecombinedphilanthropywithbusinessfaculties。HesailedtoIndiain1787with£;128,10sinhispockettobeanarmychaplain;hereturnedin1796with£;25,000andanewsystemofeducationwhichhehaddevisedassuperintendentofanorphanasylum。HesettledinEngland,publishedanaccountofhisplan,anddidsomethingtobringitintooperation。MeanwhileJosephLancaster1770-1838,ayoungQuaker,hadsetupaschoolinLondon;hedevisedaplansimilartothatofBell,andin1803publishedanaccountofhisimprovementsineducationwithacknowledgmentstoBell。Foratimethetwowereonfriendlyterms。Lancastersetaboutpropagatinghisnewsystemwithmoreenthusiasmthandiscretion。
  Hisfamerapidlyspreadtillitreachedthethrone。In1805GeorgeIII
  sentforhim;theroyalfamilysubscribedtohisschools;andthekingdeclaredhiswishthateverychildinhisdominionsshouldbetaughttoreadtheBible。Theking’sgraciouswishunconsciouslyindicatedadifficulty。
  WasitsafetoteachtheBiblewithoutthesafeguardofauthorisedinterpretation?
  Orthodoxopponentsfearedthealliancewithamanwhosefirstprinciplewastoleration,andfirstamongthemwastheexcellentMrs。Trimmer,whohadbeenalreadyengagedintheSunday-schoolmovement。ShepointedoutinapamphletthattheschismaticLancasterwasweakeningtheEstablishedChurch。TheEdinburghReviewcametohissupportin1806and1807;
  fortheWhig,especiallyifhewasalsoaScot,wasprejudicedagainsttheChurchofEngland。Lancasterwentonhisway,butsoongotintodifficulties,forhewasimpetuous,carelessofmoney,andautocratic。WilliamAllen,withanotherQuaker,cametohissupportin1808,andfoundedtheRoyalLancasterianSocietytomaintainhisschoolintheBoroughRoad,andpropagateitslikeelsewhere。Lancastertravelledthroughthecountry,andtheagitationprospered,andspreadeventoAmerica。Thechurch,however,wasnowfairlyaroused。BishopMarshpreachedasermoninSt。Paul’s,andfolloweditupbypamphlets;thecausewastakenupbytheQuarterlyReviewin1811,andinthesameyeartheNationalSocietywasfoundedto’educatethepoorintheprinciplesoftheEstablishedChurch。’Bellhadsuggestedanationalsystem,butthetimeswerenotripe。Meanwhilethecontroversybecamefurious。TheEdinburghandtheQuarterlythunderedonoppositesides,immenseimportancewasattachedbybothpartiestotheschemedevisedbyBell,andpartlyadoptedbyLancaster。