thereneitherisnoreverwillbeahigher,orbetter,ormorescientificprinciplethanthisfortheattainmentofsalvationandvictoryinwar。Andweoughtintimeofpeacefromyouthupwardstopractisethishabitofcommandingothers,andofbeingcommandedbyothers;anarchyshouldhavenoplaceinthelifeofmanorofthebeastswhoaresubjecttoman。Imayaddthatalldancesoughttobeperformedwithviewtomilitaryexcellence;andagilityandeaseshouldbecultivatedforthesameobject,andalsoenduranceofthewantofmeatsanddrinks,andofwintercoldandsummerheat,andofhardcouches;and,aboveall,careshouldbetakennottodestroythepeculiarqualitiesoftheheadandthefeetbysurroundingthemwithextraneouscoverings,andsohinderingtheirnaturalgrowthofhairandsoles。Forthesearetheextremities,andofallthepartsofthebody,whethertheyarepreservedornotisofthegreatestconsequence;theoneistheservantofthewholebody,andtheotherthemaster,inwhomalltherulingsensesarebynatureset。Lettheyoungmanimaginethathehearsinwhathasprecededthepraisesofthemilitarylife;thelawshallbeasfollows:-Heshallserveinwarwhoisontherollorappointedtosomespecialservice,andifanyoneisabsentfromcowardice,andwithouttheleaveofthegenerals;heshallbeindictedbeforethemilitarycommandersforfailureofservicewhenthearmycomeshome;andthesoldiersshallbehisjudges;theheavyarmed,andthecavalry,andtheotherarmsoftheserviceshallformseparatecourts;andtheyshallbringtheheavy-armedbeforetheheavy-armed,andthehorsemenbeforethehorsemen,andtheothersinlikemannerbeforetheirpeers;andhewhoisfoundguiltyshallneverbeallowedtocompeteforanyprizeofvalour,orindictanotherfornotservingonanexpedition,orbeanaccuseratallinanymilitarymatters。Moreover,thecourtshallfurtherdeterminewhatpunishmentheshallsuffer,orwhatpenaltyheshallpay。Whenthesuitsforfailureofservicearecompleted,theleadersoftheseveralkindsoftroopsshallagainholdanassembly,andtheyshalladjudgetheprizesofvalour;andhewholikesshallgivejudgmentinhisownbranchoftheservice,sayingnothingaboutanyformerexpedition,norproducinganyprooforwitnessestoconfirmhisstatement,butspeakingonlyofthepresentoccasion。Thecrownofvictoryshallbeanolivewreathwhichthevictorshallofferupthetempleofanywar-godwhomhelikes,addinganinscriptionforatestimonytolastduringlife,thatsuchanonehasreceivedthefirst,thesecond,orprize。Ifanyonegoesonanexpedition,andreturnshomebeforetheappointedtime,whenthegenerals。havenotwithdrawnthearmy,beshallbeindictedfordesertionbeforethesamepersonswhotookcognisanceoffailureofservice,andifhebefoundguilty,thesamepunishmentshallbeinflictedonhim。
Noweverymanwhoisengagedinanysuitoughttobeverycarefulofbringingfalsewitnessagainstanyone,eitherintentionallyorunintentionally,ifhecanhelp;forjusticeistrulysaidtobeanhonourablemaiden,andfalsehoodisnaturallyrepugnanttohonourandjustice。Awitnessoughttobeverycarefulnottosiftagainstjustice,asforexampleinwhatrelatestothethrowingawayofarms-hemustdistinguishthethrowingthemawaywhennecessary,andnotmakethatareproach,orbringinactionagainstsomeinnocentpersononthataccount。Tomakethedistinctionmaybedifficult;butstillthelawmustattempttodefinethedifferentkindsinsomeway。Letmeendeavourtoexplainmymeaningbyanancienttale:-IfPatroclushadbeenbroughttothetentstillalivebutwithouthisarmsandthishashappenedtoinnumerablepersons,theoriginalarms,whichthepoetsayswerepresentedtoPeleusbytheGodsasanuptialgiftwhenhemarried。Thetis,remaininginthehandsofHector,thenthebasespiritsofthatdaymighthavereproachedthesonofMenoetiuswithhavingcastawayhisarms。Again,thereisthecaseofthosewhohavebeenthrowndownprecipicesandlosttheirarms;andofthosewhoatsea,andinstormyplaces,havebeensuddenlyoverwhelmedbyfloodsofwater;andtherearenumberlessthingsofthiskindwhichonemightadducebywayofextenuation,andwiththeviewofjustifyingamisfortunewhichiseasilymisrepresented。Wemust,therefore,endeavourtodividetothebestofourpowerthegreaterandmoreseriousevilfromthelesser。Andadistinctionmaybedrawnintheuseoftermsofreproach。Amandoesnotalwaysdeservetobecalledthethrowerawayofhisshield;hemaybeonlytheloserofhisarms。Forthereisagreatorratherabsolutedifferencebetweenhimwhoisdeprivedofhisarmsbyasufficientforce,andhimwhovoluntarilyletshisshieldgo。Letthelawthenbeasfollows:-Ifapersonhavingarmsisovertakenbytheenemyanddoesnotturnroundanddefendhimself,butletsthemgovoluntarilyorthrowsthemaway,choosingabaselifeandaswiftescaperatherthanacourageousandnobleandblesseddeath-insuchacaseofthethrowingawayofarmsletjusticebedone,butthejudgeneedtakenonoteofthecasejustnowmentioned;forthebadmanoughtalwaystobepunished,inthehopethathemaybeimproved,butnottheunfortunate,forthereisnoadvantageinthat。Andwhatshallbethepunishmentsuitedtohimwhohasthrownawayhisweaponsofdefence?TraditionsaysthatCaeneus,theThessalian,waschangedbyaGodfromawomanintoaman;buttheconversemiraclecannotnowbewrought,ornopunishmentwouldbemoreproperthanthatthemanwhothrowsawayhisshieldshouldbechangedintoawoman。Thishoweverisimpossible,andthereforeletusmakealawasnearlylikethisaswecan-thathewholoveshislifetoowellshallbeinnodangerfortheremainderofhisdays,butshallliveforeverunderthestigmaofcowardice。Andletthelawbeinthefollowingterms:-Whenamanisfoundguiltyofdisgracefullythrowingawayhisarmsinwar,nogeneralormilitaryofficershallallowhimtoserveasasoldier,orgivehimanyplaceatallintheranksofsoldiers;andtheofficerwhogivesthecowardanyplace,shallsufferapenaltywhichthepublicexaminershallexactofhim;andifhebeofthehighestdass,heshallpayathousanddrachmae;orifhebeofthesecondclass,fiveminae;orifhebeofthethird,threeminae;orifhebeofthefourthclass,onemina。Andhewhoisfoundguiltyofcowardice,shallnotonlybedismissedfrommanlydangers,whichisadisgraceappropriatetohisnature,butheshallpayathousanddrachmae,ifhebeofthehighestclass,andfiveminaeifhebeofthesecondclass,andthreeifhebeofthethirdclass,andamina,likethepreceding,ifhebeofthefourthclass。
Whatregulationswillbeproperaboutexaminers,seeingthatsomeofourmagistratesareelectedbylot,andforayear,andsomeforalongertimeandfromselectedpersons?Ofsuchmagistrates,whowillbeasufficientcensororexaminer,ifanyofthem,weigheddownbythepressureofofficeorhisowninabilitytosupportthedignityofhisoffice,beguiltyofanycrookedpractice?Itisbynomeanseasytofindamagistratewhoexcelsothermagistratesinvirtue,butstillwemustendeavourtodiscoversomecensororexaminerwhoismorethanman。Forthetruthis,thattherearemanyelementsofdissolutioninastate,astherearealsoinaship,orinananimal;theyallhavetheircords,andgirders,andsinews-onenaturediffusedinmanyplaces,andcalledbymanynames;andtheofficeofexaminerisamostimportantelementinthepreservationanddissolutionofstates。Foriftheexaminersarebetterthanthemagistrates,andtheirdutyisfulfilledjustlyandwithoutblame,thenthewholestateandcountryflourishesandishappy;butiftheexaminationofthemagistratesiscarriedoninawrongway,then,bytherelaxationofthatjusticewhichistheunitingprincipleofallconstitutions,everypowerinthestateisrentasunderfromeveryother;theynolongerinclineinthesamedirection,butfillthecitywithfaction,andmakemanycitiesoutofone,andsoonbringalltodestruction。Whereforetheexaminersoughttobeadmirableineverysortofvirtue。Letusinventamodeofcreatingthem,whichshallbeasfollows:-Everyyear,afterthesummersolstice,thewholecityshallmeetinthecommonprecinctsofHeliosandApollo,andshallpresenttotheGodthreemenoutoftheirownnumberinthemannerfollowing:-Eachcitizenshallselect,nothimself,butsomeothercitizenwhomhedeemsineverywaythebest,andwhoisnotlessthanfiftyyearsofage。Andoutoftheselectedpersonswhohavethegreatestnumberofvotes,theyshallmakeafurtherselectionuntiltheyreducethemtoone-half,iftheyareanevennumber;butiftheyarenotanevennumber,theyshallsubtracttheonewhohasthesmallestnumberofvotes,andmakethemanevennumber,andthenleavethehalfwhichhavethegreatnumberofvotes。Andiftwopersonshaveanequalnumberofvotes,andthusincreasethenumberbeyondone-half,theyshallwithdrawtheyoungerofthetwoanddoawaywiththeexcess;andthenincludingalltheresttheyshallagainvote,untilthereareleftthreehavinganunequalnumberofvotes。
Butifallthethree,ortwooutofthethree,haveequalvotes,letthemcommittheelectiontogoodfateandfortune,andseparateoffbylotthefirst,andthesecond,andthethird;thesetheyshallcrownwithanolivewreathandgivethemtheprizeofexcellence,atthesametimeproclaimingtoalltheworldthatthecityoftheMagnetes,byprovidenceoftheGods,isagainpreserved,andpresentstotheSunandtoApolloherthreebestmenasfirst-fruits,tobeacommonofferingtothem,accordingtotheancientlaw,aslongastheirlivesanswertothejudgmentformedofthem。Andtheseshallappointintheirfirstyeartwelveexaminers,tocontinueuntileachhascompletedseventy-fiveyears,towhomthreeshallafterwardsbeaddedyearly;andletthesedivideallthemagistraciesintotwelveparts,andprovetheholdersofthembyeverysortoftesttowhichafreemanmaybesubjected;andletthemlivewhiletheyholdofficeintheprecinctofHeliosandApollo,inwhichtheywerechosen,andleteachoneformajudgmentofsomethingsindividually,andofothersincompanywithhiscolleagues;andlethimplaceawritingintheagoraabouteachmagistracy,andwhatthemagistrateoughttosufferorpay,accordingtothedecisionoftheexaminers。Andifamagistratedoesnotadmitthathehasbeenjustlyjudged,lethimbringtheexaminersbeforetheselectjudges,andifhebeacquittedbytheirdecision,lethim,ifhewill,accusetheexaminersthemselves;if,however,hebeconvicted,andhavebeencondemnedtodeathbytheexaminers,lethimdieandofcoursehecanonlydieonce:-butanyotherpenaltieswhichadmitofbeingdoubledlethimsuffertwiceover。
Andnowletuspassunderreviewtheexaminersthemselves;whatwilltheirexaminationbe,andhowconducted?Duringthelifeofthesemen,whomthewholestatecountsworthyoftherewardsofvirtue,theyshallhavethefirstseatatallpublicassemblies,andatallHellenicsacrificesandsacredmissions,andotherpublicandholyceremoniesinwhichtheyshare。Thechiefsofeachsacredmissionshallbeselectedfromthem,andtheyonlyofallthecitizensshallbeadornedwithacrownoflaurel;theyshallallbepriestsofApolloandHelios;andoneofthem,whoisjudgedfirstofthepriestscreatedinthatyear,shallbehighpriest;andtheyshallwriteuphisnameineachyeartobeameasureoftimeaslongasthecitylasts;andaftertheirdeaththeyshallbelaidoutandcarriedtothegraveandentombedinamannerdifferentfromtheothercitizens。Theyshallbedeckedinarobeallofwhite,andthereshallbenocryingorlamentationoverthem;butachorusoffifteenmaidens,andanotherofboys,shallstandaroundthebieroneitherside,hymningthepraisesofthedepartedpriestsinalternateresponses,declaringtheirblessednessinsongalldaylong;andatdawnahundredoftheyouthswhopractisegymnasticandwhomtherelationsofthedepartedshallchoose,shallcarrythebiertothesepulchre,theyoungmenmarchingfirst,dressedinthegarbofwarriors-thecavalrywiththeirhorses,theheavy-armedwiththeirarms,andtheothersinlikemanner。Andboysneatthebierandinfrontofitshallsingtheirnationalhymn,andmaidensshallfollowbehind,andwiththemthewomenwhohavepassedtheageofchildbearing;next,althoughtheyareinterdictedfromotherburials,letpriestsandpriestessesfollow,unlessthePythianoracleforbidthem;forthisburialisfreefrompollution。Theplaceofburialshallbeanoblongvaultedchamberunderground,constructedoftufa,whichwilllastforever,havingstonecouchesplacedsidebyside。Andheretheywilllaytheblessedperson,andcoverthesepulchrewithacircularmoundofearthandplantagroveoftreesaroundoneverysidebutone;andonthatsidethesepulchreshallbeallowedtoextendforever,andanewmoundwillnotberequired。Everyyeartheyshallhavecontestsinmusicandgymnastics,andinhorsemanship,inhonourofthedead。
Thesearethehonourswhichshallbegiventothosewhoattheexaminationarefoundblameless;butifanyofthem,trustingtothescrutinybeingover,should,afterthejudgmenthasbeengiven,manifestthewickednessofhumannature,letthelawordainthathewhopleasesshallindicthim,andletthecausebetriedinthefollowingmanner。Inthefirstplace,thecourtshallbecomposedoftheguardiansofthelaw,andtothemthesurvivingexaminersshallbeadded,aswellasthecourtofselectjudges;andletthepursuerlayhisindictmentinthisform-heshallsaythatso-and-soisunworthyoftheprizeofvirtueandofhisoffice;andifthedefendantbeconvictedlethimbedeprivedofhisoffice,andoftheburial,andoftheotherhonoursgivenhim。Butiftheprosecutordonotobtainthefifthpartofthevotes,lethim,ifhebeofthefirstdass,paytwelveminae,andeightifhebeofthesecondclass,andsixifhebeofthethirddass,andtwominaeifhebeofthefourthclass。
Theso-calleddecisionofRhadamanthusisworthyofalladmiration。HeknewthatthemenofhisowntimebelievedandhadnodoubtthattherewereGods,whichwasareasonablebeliefinthosedays,becausemostmenwerethesonsofGods,andaccordingtotraditionhewasonehimself。Heappearstohavethoughtthatheoughttocommitjudgmenttonoman,buttotheGodsonly,andinthiswaysuitsweresimplyandspeedilydecidedbyhim。Forhemadethetwopartiestakeanoathrespectingthepointsindispute,andsogotridofthematterspeedilyandsafely。ButnowthatacertainportionofmankinddonotbelieveatallintheexistenceoftheGods,andothersimaginethattheyhavenocareofus,andtheopinionofmostmen,andofthemen,isthatinreturnforsmallsacrificeandafewflatteringwordstheywillbetheiraccomplicesinpurloininglargesumsandsavethemfrommanyterriblepunishments,thewayofRhadamanthusisnolongersuitedtotheneedsofjustice;forastheneedsofmenabouttheGodsarechanged,thelawsshouldalsobechanged;-inthegrantingofsuitsarationallegislationoughttodoawaywiththeoathsofthepartiesoneitherside-hewhoobtainsleavetobringanactionshouldwrite,downthecharges,butshouldnotaddanoath;andthedefendantinlikemannershouldgivehisdenialtothemagistratesinwriting,andnotswear;foritisadreadfulthingtoknow,whenmanylawsuitsaregoingoninastatethatalmosthalfthepeoplewhomeetoneanotherquiteunconcernedlyatthepublicmealsandinothercompaniesandrelationsofprivatelifeareperjured。Letthelaw,then,beasfollows:-Ajudgewhoisabouttogivejudgmentshalltakeanoath,andhewhoischoosingmagistratesforthestateshalleithervoteonoathorwithavotingtabletwhichhebringsfromatemple;sotoothejudgeofdancesandofallmusic,andthesuperintendentsandumpiresofgymnasticandequestriancontests,andanymattersinwhich,asfarasmencanjudge,thereisnothingtobegainedbyafalseoath;butallcasesinwhichadenialconfirmedbyanoathclearlyresultsinagreatadvantagetothetakeroftheoath,shallbedecidedwithouttheoathofthepartiestothesuit,andthepresidingjudgesshallnotpermiteitherofthem。touseanoathforthesakeofpersuading,nortocalldowncursesonhimselfandhisrace,nortouseunseemlysupplicationsorwomanishlaments。Buttheyshalleverbeteachingandlearningwhatisjustinauspiciouswords;andhewhodoesotherwiseshallbesupposedtospeakbesidethepoint,andthejudgesshallagainbringhimbacktothequestionatissue。Ontheotherhand,strangersintheirdealingswithstrangersshallasatpresenthavepowertogiveandreceiveoaths,fortheywillnotoftengrowoldinthecityorleaveafryofyoungoneslikethemselvestobethesonsandheirsoftheland。
第56章