andthespiritoftheMaster,Krishna,wasout。HavingspentthegreaterportionofmylifeontheHimalayas,myrighteyehasbecomeinjuredbythesnows。“Thenpointingtohisrighteye,headded,“Myrighteyehasadefectinitwhichyoucannotsee;butonaccountofthat,Icanonlyseeinthedarkwithit。I
immediatelyturnedmyrighteyedownwardandIlooked!I
distinctlysawalady’shandreachedouttowardmyrobeinthedarkness,andthishandtookholdofitandjerkeditlightlyjustlikethis。“The“ReverendSwami“hereillustrated,byslightlyjerkinghiscoatdownward。Itwasveryamusingtohearhim,ingreatseriousness,relatethisinhislowandmeasuredaccentstohisfaithfulfollowers。
Shortlyafterthis,whentheLosAngelesHeraldwasconductingacrusadeagainstthenumerousmediumsofthatcity,andwhenithadanexhibitinitswindowsoftheconfiscatedmaterialofsomeofthem,this“Buddhistpriest“wasarrestedandimprisonedforsomeofhispractices。
HerewardCarringtonMoreTricksof“Spiritualists“
Thereisoneveryclever“test“thatissometimesperformedwhichwouldseemtoshowthatsomethingofthissortISaccomplished。Itis,however,nothingmorethananingenioustrick,andthismightbeagoodtimetoexplainitsmodusoperandi。Thegeneraleffectoftheillusionisthis:Themediumrequestssomeonetoassisthiminanexperimentinwhichheisgoingtoattempttopass“matterthroughmatter。“Asthetestisoneinwhichaconfederatemighteasilybeemployed,heisverycarefultochoosesomepersonwhoiswellknown,orwhosecharacterisaboveallsuspicion。Ifthiswerenotso,theentireeffectofthetestwouldbelostupontheinvestigators。Havingsecuredhisassistant,hehandshim,forexamination,asolidsteelring,justlargeenoughtosliponandoffthehandandarmeasily。Theringisperfectlysolid,andmaybeexaminedbyanyonedesirousofdoingso。Whenthispartoftheperformanceisfinished,themediumandhissitterthenjoinorclasptheirrighthandsasinhandshaking,andthesitterisinstructednottoreleasethehandforasingleinstant。To“makeassurancedoublysure,“however,thehandsarefastenedtogetherinanywaythesittersmaydesire;thehandsbeingtiedtogetherwithtape,e。g。,andtheendsofthistapetiedandtheknotssealed。
Thetapeconnectsthewristsandthehandsofthemediumandhissitter,andthistyingmaybemadeassecureaspossible。Apieceofthickclothisnowthrownoverthetwohandsandthelowerpartofthearms,concealingthemfromview。Withhisdisengagedhandthemediumnowtakestheironringandpassesitupunderthecloth,soastobringitincontactwithhisownarm。Heholdsitthereforsometime,butultimatelysnatchesoffthecoveringcloth,andrevealstotheeyesoftheastonishedaudiencethering——
nowencirclinghisownarm——inspiteofthefactthatthetiesarestillinstatuquo,andthesitterneverletgohisholdforaninstant。Thetiesandtheringmayagainbeexamined,ifdesired,beforethehandsareseparated。
Thisisanexceedinglyeffectivetest,andhaseveryappearanceofbeinggenuine——indeed,itishardtoseewheretrickerycancomein。Thetrickisoneofthesimplestimaginable,however,andisperformedinthefollowingmanner:
ThemediumhasprovidedhimselfwithTWOringsexactlyalike;oneofthesetheaudienceisfreetoexamine,theotherthemediumiswearingonhisrightarm,underhiscoat。Whenthetwohandsareclaspedtogether,therefore,itisasimplethingforthemedium,undercoveroftheenvelopingcloth,tosliptheduplicateringdownhissleeve,andontohisownhand,andthatpartofthe“miracle“isaccomplished!Itremainsonlytoexplainwhatbecomesofthefirstring。Thecloththrownoverthearmsisverythickandstiff,asstated,andtheinnersideofthiscontainsadoublepartition,orsortofbag,intowhichthemediumslipstheduplicatering。Theclothmaynowbeshownonbothsides,withoutdisclosingthering,andthemediummakesawaywithitassoonaspossible,inordertoavoiddetection。
Theobject[ofthispassage]istoenablethereadertosee,moreeasily,howitisthatthewatchfulobserverisdeceivedintobelievingthatathingisso,wheninrealityitisnot,andviceversa;andalsotogiveanideaofthevariousmethodsemployedbythemediuminordertoaccomplishhisresults。
Imustfirstofallcallthereader’sattentiontooneortworuleswhicheveryconjurerlearnsatthecommencementofhisstudy,andwhichhelearnstoapplysoconstantlythatitbecomessecondnaturetohim。Thefirstis:Neverlettheeyesrestonthehandthatisperformingthe“sleight,“butalwaysontheotherhand,oronsomeobjectonthetableorelsewhere,asthiswillhaveatendencytodrawtheeyesoftheaudiencetothatpointalso。Thesittersoraudiencewillalwayslookatthepointcloselywatchedbythemagician——theireyeshaveatendencytofollowhis,andwhereverhelooks,therewilltheonlookerlookalso。Needlesstosay,themagicianmakesuseofthisfact,andmanytricksandillusionsaredependentuponitfortheirsuccessfulac-
complishment。Wheneverthemagicianormediumlooksintentlyatonehand,therefore,theOTHERhandshouldbewatched,asitisasuresignthatTHATisthehandwhichisperformingthetrick。
Anotherfundamentalrulethatisobservedbyallsleight-of-handperformersis:Nevertoletanaudienceknowbeforehandwhatistobedone;i。e。,thenatureofthetrickthatitisintendedtoperform。Ifthespectatorknewwhatwasforthcoming,hewouldbeonthelookoutformovementsoftheperformeratcertaincriticaltimes——justattheperiodswhencloseobservationisleastwanted——
andwouldquitepossiblydetecttheperformerintheactofexecutingcertainmovementswhichwouldshowhowthetrickwasperformed。Butnotknowingwhatiscoming,thespectatorisunabletowatchcloselyatthecriticalmoment——notknowingwhatthatmomentis——andsoisunabletodetectthetrick,hisattentionbeingdivertedbytheperformer,justbeforethismovementismade,tosomeotherobjectormovement。
Themethodsofdivertingthespectator’sattentionarevarious。
Thereistheuseoftheeyes,asbeforeshown。Thenthereisthespokenword,theperformertellingtheonlookerstoobservesomecertainobjectoraction,andtheeffectistocausethemtowatchit,astheyaretold。Theyfollowthelineofleastresistance。
Thecombinedeffectuponthespectatorofthespokenwordandtheeyestogetherisgenerallyirresistible。
Anotherimportantfactoristhis:Aperformershouldalwaysletanysuggestion,rightorwrong,soakwellintothespectator’smindbeforeattemptingtochangeit。Thisisfortworeasons。Inthefirstplace,ifthesuggestioniscorrect,if,e。g。,theperformerreallyDOESplaceanobjectinhislefthand,anditisshortlyfoundtohavevanishedfromthathand,heisannoyedbyhearingsomeonesaythathewasnotreallysureitwasthereinthefirstplace,as“itwascoveredupsoquickly。“If,ontheotherhand,thesuggestiongivenwasafalseone,if,e。g。,theperformersayshehasplacedanobjectinhislefthand,when,inreality,hehasnotdonesobuthaspalmeditintheright,thenitisstillnecessarytoallowacertaintime-intervaltoelapsebetweentheperformingoftheactionwhichapparentlyplacedtheobjectinthehand,andtheshowingofthehandempty,forthisreason。Ifthehandintowhichtheobjectissupposedlyplacedis
shownempty,thenaturalconclusionofthesitteristhattheobjectwasnotinrealityplacedthereatall,butwasretainedintheotherhand,whichwouldbethefact。If,however,theperformerallowedsometimetoelapse,betweentheactionofplacingtheobjectinthathandsupposedlyandtheshowingofthehandempty,he,meanwhile,keepinghiseyesfixedonthehand,suggestingtothesittersthattheobjectISthere,andineverywayactingasifitWEREthere,theideawillgraduallygainafirmholdonthemindsofthespectatorsthattheobjectisthere,inreality,andtheyarecorrespondinglysurprisedtofinditultimatelyvanished。Itisjustsuchaknowledgeof“thewaypeople’smindswork,“asafriendoncesaidtome,whichenablestheconjurertodeceivethepublic;anditispreciselythesamecastofmindthatthemediumpossesses。Heis,infact,agoodjudgeofhumannature。
Anotherfactthatmustbeborneinmindisthat,whenonceaspectatorhasseenamovementmadetwoorthreetimesinthesamemanner,hefrequently“sees“theperformermakethatmovementonanotheroccasion,whentheperformerhad,inreality,only
tomakethemovement,andsuggestedtherest。Thus,iftheperformerthrowsaballupintotheairtwoorthreetimesinsuccession,andonthefourthoccasionmerelypretendstothrowitup,reallyretainingitintheotherhand,thegreatmajorityofthespectatorswillreally“see“theballascendintotheaironthefourthoccasion,andwillsostate,onbeingasked。Weheredependuponassociationandhabit。[1]
[1]AverysimilarillusionismentionedbyProfessorHyslop,v。
BorderlandofPsychicalResearch,Pp。228-9,inwhichpelletswereapparentlyplacedinabox,reallybeingpalmedinthemedium’shand。
ProfessorJastrowsummedupthisportionofthepsychologyofdeceptionverywellwhenhesaid:[1]
FactandFableinPsychology,pp。
“Hetheconjurermustdissociatethenaturalfactorsofhishabits,actuallyattendingtoonethingwhileseeminglyattendingtoanother;atthesametimehiseyesandhisgesturesandhis’patter’misdirecttheattentiontowhatisapparentlytheessentialfieldofoperation,butreallyonlyablindtodistractattentionawayfromthetruesceneofaction。Theconjurerdirectsyourattentiontowhathedoesnotdo;hedoesnotdowhathepretendstodo;andtowhatheactuallydoes,heiscarefulneithertoappeartodirecthisownattentionnortoarouseyours。“
Prof。MaxDessoir,inaveryfinearticleon“ThePsychologyofConjuring,“writesasfollows:“Byawakeninginterestinsomeunimportantdetail,theconjurerconcentratesthatattentiononsomefalsepoint,ornegatively,divertsitfromthemainobject,andweallknowthesensesofaninattentivepersonareprettydull……Whencausingthedisappearanceofsomeobject,theconjurercountsone,two,three;theobjectmustreallydisappearbeforethree,notatthree,because,theattentionofthepublicbeingdivertedtothree,theydonotnoticewhathappensatoneandtwo……Aspeciallysuccessfulmethodofdiversionisfoundedonthehumancrazeforimitation……Theconjurercountsonthisinmanycases。Healwayslooksinthedirectionwherehewantstheattentionofthepublic,anddoeseverythinghimselfwhichhewantsthepublictodo……Ifthetrickisinthelefthand,theconjurerturnssharplytothepersontohisright,presumingcorrectlythatthespectatorswillmakethesamemovement,andwillnotnoticewhatisgoingoninthelefthand……
Everysharp,shortremarkwill,foramoment,atleast,diverttheeyesfromthehandsanddirectthemtothemouth,accordingtotheabove-mentionedlawofimitation。“
Thesuccessfulconjurerhascarefullystudiedbeforehandeverymovementthatismade——everywordthatisspoken——duringaconjuringperformance,andhasseenthattheseallfitnaturallyintoplace,andhelpconcealtherealworkingsofthetrick。Therightandlefthandsmustbetrainedtooperateindependently,andwithouttheneedoflookingateither。Manyconjurerspracticedoingtwoseparatethingsatthesametime,onewitheitherhand;
andtheabilitytodothisisessential。Aboveall,theperformermustbefullofconsciousself-possession,andfeelhimselftobemasterofthesituation,nolessthantofeeltheabilitytocopewithanyemergenciesthatmayarise。
Turning,now,toaconsiderationoftheseance,wefindthatmanyofthesepsychologicalrulesstillholdgood,andtheiroperationenablesthemediumtoperformmanyactionswhichwouldotherwisebeimpossible。Acertainsuggestionisgiventothesitters,andimaginationandinferencedotherest。“Ourconclusionsastowhatweseeorheararealwaysfoundedonacombinationofobservationandinference;butindailylifeitisseldomnecessarytodistinguishbetweenthetwoelements,since,whentheobjectanditsmodeofpresentationarefamiliar,ourinferencesaregenerallycorrect。Butitisdifferentwhen,owingtocircumstances,suchasabadlight,wehavetoinfermoreinproportiontowhatweperceivethanusual;orwhensomeone,e。g。,aconjureroraventriloquist,istryingtodeceiveusbypresentingoneobjectunderthefamiliaraspectofanother,andsuggestingfalseinferences。Itisnotuncommontofindpeopleatseancesencouragingeachotherinthebeliefthattheysee,say,alivinghumanfigure,whenallthattheyactuallySEEissomethingmovingwhichisaboutthesizeofahumanbeing;therestisinference。“
Howtruetheselastremarksareisdemonstratedbythestatement,madeinTheRevelationsofaSpiritMedium,thatanoldwiremaskfrequentlyusedatmaterializingseanceshadbeenrecognized“bydozensofpersonsasfathers,mothers,sisters,brothers,cousins,sweethearts,wives,husbands,andvariousotherrelativesandfriends。Nonebutthemediumknewthatitwasonlyafifty-centwiremask,hencenonebutthemediumcouldenjoythehumoroftheoccasion。“
OneofthemostinstructiveincidentsIknow,inrelationtothisquestionofthepsychologyofdeception,istheonegivenbyDoctorHodgson[1]——thecaseoftheofficerandtheHindujuggler。Inthiscase,atrickwasperformedbeforeanEnglishofficerandhiswife,andDoctorHodgsonhappenedtooverhearthisofficertellingsometravelersoftheexperienceatdinnerthatevening。“Referringtothemovementsofthecoins,hesaidthathehadtakenacoinfromhisownpocketandplaceditonthegroundhimself,yetthatthiscoinhadindulgedinthesamefreaksastheothercoins。Hiswifeventuredtosuggestthatthejugglerhadtakenthecoinandplaceditontheground,buttheofficerwasemphaticinrepeatinghisstatement,andappealedtomeforconfirmation。Hewas,however,mistaken。Ihadwatchedthetransactionwithspecialcuriosity,asIknewwhatwasnecessaryfortheperformanceofthetrick。Theofficerhadapparentlyintendedtoplacethecoinuponthegroundhimself,butashewasdoingso,thejugglerleanedslightlyforward,dexterouslyandinamostunobtrusivemannerreceivedthecoinfromthefingersoftheofficer,asthelatterwasstoopingdown,andlaiditclosetotheothers。Ifthejugglerhadnotthustakenthecoin,buthadallowedtheofficerhimselftoplaceitontheground,thetrick,asactuallyperformed,wouldhavebeenfrustrated。