InLincoln’slifetherearetwogreatachievements。
Onehebroughttopassintimeforhimtobeholdhisownvictory。Theotherhesawonlywiththeeyesoffaith。ThefirstwasthedrawingtogetherofalltheelementsofnationalismintheAmericanpeopleandconsolidatingthemintoadrivingforce。ThesecondwaslayingthefoundationofapoliticaltemperthatmadeimpossibleapermanentvictoryfortheVindictives。Itwasthesadfateofthisnation,becauseLincoln’shandwasstruckfromthetillerattheveryinstantofthecrisis,tosufferthetemporarysuccessofthatfactionhestrovesohardtodestroyThetransitorinessoftheireviltriumph,theeventualrallyofthenationagainstthem,wasthefinalvictoryofthespiritofLincoln。
Theimmediatevictoryheappreciatedmorefullyandmeasuredmoreexactly,thandidanyoneelse。Heputitintowordsinthefifthmessage。Whileotherswerecrowingwithexaltationoverapartytriumph,helookeddeepertothepsychologicaltriumph。ScarcelyanothersawthatthemostsignificantdetailofthehourwasintheDemocraticattitude。Eventhebitterestenemiesofnationalism,eventhosewhowerebelievedbyallotherstodesirethebreakingoftheUnion,hadnotthoughtitsafetosayso。Theyhadveiledtheirintentinspeciouswords。McClellaninacceptingtheDemocraticnominationhadrepudiatedtheideaofdisunion。WhethertheDemocraticpoliticianshadagreedwithhimornot,theyhadnotdaredtocontradicthim。ThiswaswhatLincolnputtheemphasisoninhismessage:“ThepurposeofthepeoplewithintheloyalStatestomaintaintheUnionwasnevermorefirmnormorenearlyunanimousthannow……Nocandidateforanyoffice,highorlow,hasventuredtoseekvotesontheavowalthathewasforgivinguptheUnion。TherehavebeenmuchimpugningofmotiveandmuchheatedcontroversyastothepropermeansandbestmodeofadvancingtheUnioncause;butonthedistinctissueofUnionorNoUnionthepoliticianshaveshowntheirinstinctiveknowledgethatthereisnodiversityamongthepeople。Inaffordingthepeoplethefairopportunityofshowingonetoanotherandtotheworld,thisfirmnessandunanimityofpurpose,theelectionhasbeenofvastvaluetothenationalcause。“[1]
ThistemperofthefinalLincoln,hissupremedetachment,thekindimpersonalityofhisintellectualapproach,hasnobetterillustrationinhisstatepapers。Hefurtherrevealeditinamoreintimateway。ThedayhesentthemessagetoCongress,healsosubmittedtotheSenateanominationtothegreatofficeofChiefJustice。WhenTaneydiedinthepreviousSeptember,therewasaneagerstiramongthefriendsofChase。Theyhadhopesbuttheyfeltembarrassed。Couldtheyaskthisgreathonor,thehighestitisinthepoweroftheAmericanPresidenttobe-stow,foramanwhohadbeensolackingincandorasChasehadbeen?Chase’scourseduringthesummerhadmadethingsworse。Hehadplayedthetime-server。NoonewasmoresevereuponLincolninJuly;inAugust,hehesitated,wouldnotquitecommithimselftotheconspiracybutwouldnotdiscourageit;almostgaveithisblessing;inSeptember,butnotuntilitwasquiteplainthattheconspiracywasfailing,hecameoutforLincoln。However,hisfriendsintheSenateovercametheirembarrassment——howelsecoulditbewithSenators?——andpressedhiscase。AndwhenSenatorWilson,alarmedatthePresident’ssilence,triedtoapologizeforChase’sharshremarksaboutthePresident,Lincolncuthimshort。“Oh,astothat,Icarenothing,“saidhe。TheembarrassmentoftheChasepropagandaamusedhim。WhenChasehimselftookahandandwrotehimaletter,Lincolnsaidtohissecretary,“Whatisitabout?“
“Simplyakindandfriendlyletter,“repliedthesecretary。
Lincolnsmiled。“Fileitwiththeotherrecommendations,“saidhe。[2]
HeregardedChaseasagreatlawyer,Taney’slogicalsuccessor。
AlltheslightstheSecretaryhadputuponthePresident,theintriguestosupplanthim,themalicioussayings,wereasiftheyhadneveroccurred。WhenCongressassembled,itwasChase’snamethathesenttotheSenate。ItwasChasewho,asChiefJustice,administeredtheoathatLincoln’ssecondinauguration。
Longsince,Lincolnhadseenthattherehadceasedtoanyhalf-wayhouseinthematterofemancipation。Histhoughtswerechieflyuponthefuture。Andasmerestrategy,hesawthatslaveryhadtobegotoutoftheway。Itwasnolongeraquestion,wholikedthis,whodidnot。Tohim,theultimateissuewastherestorationofharmonyamongtheStates。ThoseStateswhichhadbeendefeatedinthedreadarbitramentofbattle,wouldinanyeventencounterdifficulties,evendeadlyperils,inthenarrowwaywhichmustcomeafterdefeatandwhichmightormightnotleadtorehabilitation。
RememberingtheVindictivetemper,rememberingtheforceandcourageoftheVindictiveleaders,itwasimperativetoclearthefieldoftheslaveryissuebeforethereconstructionissuewasfairlylaunched。Itwashighlydesirabletocommittothesupportofthegovernmentsthewholerangeofinfluencesthatwereinearnestaboutemancipation。Furthermore,theSouthitselfwasdriftinginthesamedirection。InhisinterviewwithGilmoreandJaquess,Davishadsaid:“Youhavealreadyemancipatednearlytwomillionsofourslaves;andifyouwilltakecareofthem,youmayemancipatetherest。Ihadafewwhenthewarbegan。Iwasofsomeusetothem;theyneverwereofanytome。“[3]
TheSouthernPresidenthad“felt“hisconstituencyonthesubjectofenrollingslavesassoldierswithapromiseofemancipationastherewardofmilitaryservice。
ThefifthmessageurgedCongresstosubmittotheStatesanamendmenttotheConstitutionabolishingslavery。Suchactionhadbeenconsideredintheprevioussession,butnothinghadbeendone。AtLincoln’ssuggestion,ithadbeenrecommendedintheplatformoftheUnionparty。Now,withthePresident’spowerfulinfluencebehindit,withhisprestigeatfullcircle,theamendmentwasrapidlypushedforward。BeforeJanuaryended,ithadbeenapprovedbybothHouses。LincolnhadusedallhispersonalinfluencetostrengthenitschancesinCongresswhere,untilthelastminute,thevotewasstillindoubt。[4]
WhiletheamendmentwastakingitswaythroughCongress,ashrewdoldpoliticianwhothoughtheknewtheworldbetterthanmostmen,thatMontgomeryBlair,Senior,whowasfatherofthePostmasterGeneral,hadbeentryingonhisownresponsibilitytoopennegotiationsbetweenWashingtonandRichmond。Hisvisionaryideas,whichwerewhollywithouttheresultsheintended,havenoplacehere。Andyetthisfancifulepisodehadasignificanceofitsown。Haditnotoccurred,theConfederategovernmentprobablywouldnothaveappointedcommissionerschargedwiththehopelesstaskofapproachingtheFederalgovernmentforthepurposeofnegotiatingpeacebetween“thetwocountries。“
NowthatLincolnwasentirelyintheascendentathome,andsincetheConfederatearmshadrecentlysufferedterriblereverses,hewasnolongerafraidthatnegotiationmightappeartobethesymptomofweakness。HewentsofarastoconsenttomeettheCommissionershimself。OnasteamerinHamptonRoads,LincolnandSewardhadalongconferencewiththreemembersoftheConfederategovernment,particularlytheVice-President,AlexanderH。Stephens。
ithasbecomeatraditionthatLincolnwroteatthetopofasheetofpapertheoneword“Union“;thathepusheditacrossthetableandsaid,“Stephens,writeunderthatanythingyouwant“Thereappearstobenofoundationforthetaleinthisform。TheamendmenthadcommittedtheNorthtoodefinitelytoemancipation。LincolncouldnothaveproposedUnionwithoutrequiringemancipation,also。Andyet,withthislimitation,thespiritofthetraditionishistoric。TherecanbenodoubtthathepresentedtothecommissionersaboutthetermswhichtheyearbeforehehaddrawnupasamemorandumforGilmoreandJaquess:Union,theacceptanceofemancipation,butalsoinstantaneousrestorationofpoliticalautonomytotheSouthernStates,andalltheinfluenceoftheAdministrationinbehalfofliberalcompensationforthelossofslaveproperty。Butthecommissionershadnoauthoritytoconsidertermsthatdidnotrecognizetheexistenceof“twocountries。“However,thisHamptonRoadsConferencegaveLincolnanewhope。Hedivined,ifhedidnotperceive,thattheConfederateswereonthevergeofdespair。IfhehadbeenaVindictive,thiswouldhavebornefruitinferocioustelegramstohisgeneralstostrikeandsparenot。WhatLincolndidwastolaybeforetheCabinetthisproposal:——thattheyadviseCongresstooffertheConfederategovernmentthesumoffourhundredmilliondollars,providedthewarendandtheStatesinsecessionacknowledgetheauthorityoftheFederalgovernmentprevioustoApril1,1865。ButtheCabinet,completeaswashisdominationinsomerespects,werenotripeforsuchamoveasthis。“’Youareallagainstme,’saidLincolnsadlyandinevidentsurpriseatthewantofstatesmanlikeliberalityonthepartoftheexecutivecouncil,“toquotehisSecretary,“foldedandlaidawaythedraftofhismessage。“[5]Nicolaybelievesthattheideacontinuedvividlyinhismindandthatitmaybelinkedwithhislastpublicutterance——“itmaybemydutytomakesomenewannouncementtothepeopleoftheSouth。Iamconsideringandshallnotfailtoactwhensatisfiedthatactionisproper。“
ItwasnowobvioustoeveryoneoutsidetheConfederacythatthewarwouldendspeedilyinaNorthernvictory。ToLincoln,therefore,thedutyofthemoment,overshadowingallelse,wasthepreparationforwhatshouldcomeafter。Reconstruction。
MorethaneveritwasoffirstimportancetodecidewhetherthePresidentorCongressshoulddealwiththisgreatmatter。AndnowoccurredaneventwhichborewitnessatoncetothebeginningofLincoln’sfinalstrugglewiththeVindictivesandtothatpersonalascendencywhichwassteadilywidening。OneofthosethreeoriginalJacobinsagreedtobecomehisspokesmanintheSenate。AsthethirdpersonoftheJacobinbrotherhood,LymanTrumbullhadalwaysbeenoutofplace。Hehadgonewrongnotfromperversityofthesoulbutfromamentalfailing,fromthelackofinherentlight,fromintellectualconventionality。
Buthewasagoodman。OnemightapplytohimMrs。Browning’sline:“Justagoodmanmadeagreatman。“Andinhiscase,asinsomanyothers,sheergoodnesshadnotbeensufficientinthemidstofarevolutiontosavehissoul。Toquoteoneofthegreatestoftheobserversofhumanlife:“Morebrains,O
Lord,morebrains。“ThoughTrumbullhadthemakingofanIntellectual,politicshadverynearlyruinedhim。ForallhisgoodintentionsittookhimalongtimetoseewhatHawthornesawatfirstsight-thatLincolnwasbothapowerfulcharacterandanoriginalmind。Still,becauseTrumbullwasreallyagoodman,hefoundawaytorecoverhissoul。Whathisinsightwasnotequaltoperceivingin1861,experienceslowlymadeplaintohiminthecourseofthenextthreeyears。Before1865hehadbrokenwiththeVindictives;hehadcomeovertoLincoln。TrumbullstillheldthepowerfulofficeofChairmanoftheSenateJudiciaryCommittee。HenowundertooktobethePresident’scaptaininabattleontheflooroftheSenatefortherecognitionofLouisiana。
ThenewgovernmentinLouisianahadbeeninactualoperationfornearlyayear。ThoughCongresshaddenouncedit;thoughtheManifestohadheldituptoscornasamonarchialoutrage;
Lincolnhadquietly,steadily,protectedandsupportedit。ItwasdischargingthefunctionofaregularStategovernment。A
governorhadbeenelectedandinaugurated-thatGovernorHahnwhomLincolnhadcongratulatedasLouisiana’sfirstFreeStateGovernor。Hecouldsaythisbecausethenewelectoratewhichhismandatehadcreatedhadassembledaconstitutionalconventionandhadabolishedslavery。AndithadalsocarriedoutthePresident’sviewswithregardtothepoliticalstatusoffreedmen。Lincolnwasnotabelieveringeneralnegrosuffrage。HewasasfaraseverfromthetheorizingoftheAbolitionists。ThemosthewouldapprovewasthebestowalofsuffrageonafewSuperiornegroes,leavingtheresttobegraduallyeducatedintocitizenship。TheLouisianaConventionhadauthorizedtheStateLegislaturetomake,whenitfeltpreparedtodoso,suchalimitedextensionofsuffrage。[6]
Insettingupthisnewgovernment,LincolnhadcreatedapoliticalvesselinwhichpracticallyalltheoldelectorateofLouisianacouldfindtheirplacesthemomenttheygaveupthewarandacceptedthetworequisites,unionandemancipation。
Thatelectoratecouldproceedatoncetorebuildthesocial-politicalorderoftheStatewithoutanyintervalof“expiation。“AllthepoweroftheAdministrationwouldbewiththemintheirlabors。Thatthiswasthewiseaswellasthegenerouswaytoproceed,thebestmindsoftheNorthhadcometosee。WitnesstheconversionofTrumbull。Buttherewerefourgroupsoffanaticswhoweredangerous:extremeAbolitionistswhoclamoredfornegroequality;menlikeWadeandChandler,stillmadwiththelustofconquest,ragingatthePresidentwhohadstoodsoresolutelybetweenthemandtheirdesire;themachinepoliticianswhocouldneverunderstandthePresident’smethods,whoregardedhimasanofficiousamateur;andtheLittleMenwhowouldhavetriedtomakepoliticalcapitaloftheblowingofthelasttrump。Allthese,eachforaseparatemotive,attackedthePresidentbecauseofLouisiana。
ThenewgovernmenthadchosenSenators。HerewasaspecificissueoverwhichtheAdministrationanditsmultiformoppositionmightengageinatrialofstrength。TheSenatehaditinitspowertorefusetoseattheLouisianaSenators。