melodramaticatlastpointedtheway。Hewouldresign。Whatanadmirablemodeofrecapturingtheconfidenceofhisdisappointedfriends,carryingouttheiraimtodisrupttheCabinet!ButhecouldnotdoaboldthinglikethisinSeward’sway——atastroke,withouthesitation。WhenhecalledonLincolnthenextdaywiththeresignationinhishand,hewavered。IthappenedthatWelleswasintheroom。
“Chasesaidhehadbeenpainfullyaffected,“isWelles’
account,“bythemeetinglastevening,whichwasasurprise,andaftersomenotveryexplicitremarksastohowhewasaffected,informedthePresidenthehadpreparedhisresignationoftheofficeofSecretaryoftheTreasury。’Whereisit,’saidthePresident,quickly,hiseyelightingupinamoment。’Ibroughtitwithme,’saidChase,takingthepaperfromhispocket。’Iwroteitthismorning。’’Letmehaveit,’
saidthePresident,reachinghislongarmandfingerstowardChase,whoheldonseeminglyreluctanttopartwiththeletterwhichwassealedandwhichheapparentlyhesitatedtosurrender。Somethingfurtherhewishedtosay,butthePresidentwaseageranddidnotperceiveit,buttookandhastilyopenedtheletter。
“’This,’saidhe,lookingtowardsmewithatriumphallaugh,’cutstheGordianknot。’AnairofsatisfactionspreadoverhiscountenancesuchasIhadnotseenforsometime。’Icandisposeofthissubjectnowwithoutdifficulty,’headded,asheturnedinhischair;’Iseemywayclear。’“[12]InLincoln’sdistressduringthisepisode,therewasmuchbesideshisanxietyforthefateofatrustedminister。HefelthemustnotpermithimselftobedrivenintothearmsoftheVindictivesbydisgracingSeward。SewardhadafollowingwhichLincolnneededButtoproclaimtotheworldhisconfidenceinSewardwithoutatthesametimeoffsettingitbysomedisplayofconfidence,equallysignificantintheenemiesofSeward,thiswouldhaveamountedtocommittinghimselftoSeward’sfollowingalone。Andthatwouldnotdo。Shouldeitherfactionappeartodominatehim,Lincolnfeltthat“thewholegovernmentmustcavein。Itcouldnotstand,couldnotholdwater;thebottomwouldbeout。“[13]
Theincrediblestrokeofluck,thesheergoodfortunethatChasewasChaseandnobodyelse,——vain,devious,stageyandhypersensitive,——wassalvation。LincolnpromptlyrejectedbothresignationsandcalleduponbothMinisterstoresumetheirportfolios。Theydidso。Theincidentwasclosed。NeitherfactioncouldsaythatLincolnhadfavoredtheother。Hehadsavedhimself,orrather,Chase’scharacterhadsavedhim,bythemarginofahair。
Forthemoment,arebuildingoftheVindictiveCoalitionwasimpossible。Nevertheless,theJacobins,againbalkedoftheirprey,haditintheirpower,throughtheterribleCommittee,todoimmensemischief。Thehistoryofthewarcontainsnootherinstanceofpartymalicequitesofruitlessandthereforesoinexcusableastheirnextmove。AfterseverelyinterrogatingBurnside,theypublishedanexonerationofhismotivesandrevealedthefactthatLincolnhadforcedhimintocommandagainsthiswill。Theimplicationwasplain。
Januarycamein。TheEmancipationProclamationwasconfirmed。
ThejubilationoftheAbolitionistsbecame,almostatonce,apropagandaforanotherissueuponslavery。NewtroublesweregatheringcloseaboutthePresidentTheoverwhelmingbenefitwhichhadbeenanticipatedfromthenewpolicyhadnotclearlyarrived。Evenarmyenlistmentswerenotsatisfactory。
Conscriptionloomedonthehorizonasaneventualnecessity。A
bankofreturningcloudwascoveringthepoliticalhorizon,enshroudingtheWhiteHouseinanotherdepthofgloom。
However,outofallthisgatheringdarkness,oneclearlightsolacedLincoln’sgaze。Oneofhischiefpurposeshadbeenattained。Incontrasttothedoubtfulandfactionalresponsetohispolicyathome,theresponseabroadwassweepingandunconditional。Hehadmadehimselftheheroofthe“Liberalpartythroughouttheworld。“AmongthefewcheerywordsthatreachedhiminJanuary,1863,wereNewYeargreetingsoftrustandsympathysentbyEnglishworkingmen,who,becauseoftheblockade,wereonthevergeofstarvation。ItwasinresponsetooneoftheselettersfromtheworkingmenofManchesterthatLincolnwrote:
“Ihaveunderstoodwellthatthedutyofself-preservationrestssolelywiththeAmericanpeople;butIhaveatthesametimebeenawarethatthefavorordisfavorofforeignnationsmighthaveamaterialinfluenceinenlargingorprolongingthestrugglewithdisloyalmeninwhichthecountryisengaged。A
fairexaminationofhistoryhasservedtoauthorizeabeliefthatthepastactionsandinfluencesoftheUnitedStatesweregenerallyregardedashavingbeenbeneficialtowardmankind。I
havethereforereckonedupontheforbearanceofnations。
Circumstances——tosomeofwhichyoukindlyallude——inducemeespeciallytoexpectthatifjusticeandgoodfaithshouldbepractisedbytheUnitedStatestheywouldencounternohostileinfluenceonthepartofGreatBritain。ItisnowapleasantdutytoacknowledgethedemonstrationyouhavegivenofyourdesirethataspiritofamityandpeacetowardthiscountrymayprevailinthecouncilsofyourQueen,whoisrespectedandesteemedinyourowncountryonlymorethansheis,bythekindrednationwhichhasitshomeonthissideoftheAtlantic。
“IknowanddeeplydeplorethesufferingswhichtheworkingmenatManchester,andinallEurope,arecalledontoendureinthiscrisis。Ithasbeenoftenandstudiouslyrepresentedthattheattempttooverthrowthisgovernmentwhichwasbuiltuponthefoundationofhumanrights,andtosubstituteforitonewhichshouldrestexclusivelyonthebasisofhumanslavery,waslikelytoobtainthefavorofEurope。Throughtheactionofourdisloyalcitizens,theworkingmenofEuropehavebeensubjectedtoseveretrialsforthepurposeofforcingtheirsanctiontothatattempt。Underthecircumstances,IcannotbutregardyourdecisiveutterancesuponthequestionasaninstanceofsublimeChristianheroismwhichhasnotbeensurpassedinanyageorinanycountry。Itisindeedanenergeticandreinspiringassuranceoftheinherentpowerofthetruth,andoftheultimateanduniversaltriumphofjustice,humanityandfreedom。Idonotdoubtthatthesentimentsyouhaveexpressedwillbesustainedbyyourgreatnation;andontheotherhand,Ihavenohesitationinassuringyouthattheywillexciteadmiration,esteem,andthemostreciprocalfeelingsoffriendshipamongtheAmericanpeople。I
hailthisinterchangeofsentiment,therefore,asanaugurythatwhateverelsemayhappen,whatevermisfortunemaybefallyourcountryormyown,thepeaceandfriendshipwhichnowexistbetweenthetwonations,willbe,asitshallhemydesiretomakethem,perpetual。“[14]
XXVI。THEDICTATOR,THEMARPLOTANDTHELITTLEMEN
WhiletheJacobinswereendeavoringtoreorganizetheRepublicanantagonismtothePresident,Lincolnwastakingthoughthowhecouldoffsetstillmoreeffectuallytheirinfluence。intakinguptheemancipationpolicyhehadnotabandonedhisotherpolicyofanall-partiesAdministration,orofsomethingsimilartothat。Bythistimeitwasplainthatacompleteunionofpartieswasimpossible。Intheautumnof1862,amovementofliberalDemocratsinMichiganforthepurposeofaworkingagreementwiththeRepublicanswasfrustratedbytheflintyoppositionofChandler。[1]However,itstillseemedpossibletocombineportionsofpartiesinanAdministrationgroupthatshouldforswearthesavageryoftheextremefactionsandmaintainthewarinamercifultemper。
ThecreationofsuchagroupwasLincoln’saimatthecloseoftheyear。
TheRepublicanswerenotindoubtwhathewasdrivingat。
Smartingovertheirlossesintheelection,therewasangrytalkthatLincolnandSewardhad“slaughteredtheRepublicanparty。“[2]EvenassaneamanasJohnSherman,writingtohisbrotheronthecausesoftheapparentturnofthetidecouldsay“thefirstisthattheRepublicanorganizationwasvoluntarilyabandonedbythePresidentandhisleadingfollowers,andano-partyunionwasformedtorunagainstanold,well-drilledpartyorganization。“[3]WhenJulianreturnedtoWashingtoninDecember,hefoundthatthemenacetotheRepublicanmachinewas“generallyadmittedandhisearnestoppositiontoitfullyjustifiedintheopinionoftheRepublicanmembersofCongress。“[4]HowfullytheyperceivedtheirdangerhadbeenshownintheirattempttodriveLincolnintoacornerontheissueofanewCabinet。
Evenbeforethat,Lincolnhaddecidedonhisnextmove。AsintheemancipationpolicyhehaddrivenawedgebetweenthefactionsoftheRepublicans,sonowhewoulddriveawedgeintotheorganizationoftheDemocrats。Ithadtwopartswhichhadlittletoholdthemtogetherexcepttheirrootedpartisanhabit。[5]Onebranch,soontoreceivethelabel“Copperhead,“
acceptedthesecessionprincipleandsympathizedwiththeConfederacy。Theother,whilerejectingsecessionandsupportingthewar,denouncedtheemancipationpolicyasusurpedauthority,andfeltpersonalhostilitytoLincoln。ItwasthelatterfactionthatLincolnstillhopedtowinover。
ItsmostimportantmemberwasHoratioSeymour,whointheautumnof1862waselectedgovernorofNewYork。Lincolndecidedtooperateonhimbyoneofthoseastoundingmoveswhichtotheselflessmanseemednaturalenough,bywhichtheordinarypoliticianwasalwayshopelesslymystified。HecalledinThurlowWeedandauthorizedhimtomakethisproposal:ifSeymourwouldbringhisfollowingintoacompositeUnionpartywithnoplatformbutthevigorousprosecutionofthewar,LincolnwouldpledgeallhisinfluencetosecuringforSeymourthepresidentialnominationin1864。Weeddeliveredhismessage。SeymourwasnoncommittalandLincolnhadtowaitforhisansweruntilthenewGovernorshouldshowhishandbyhisofficialacts。Meanwhileanewcrisishaddevelopedinthearmy。Burnside’scharacterappearstohavebeenshatteredbyhisdefeat。PrevioustoFredericksburg,hehadseemedtobeagenerous,high-mindedman。FromFredericksburgonward,hebecamemoreandmoreanimpossible。AreflectionofMcClellaninhisearlierstage,hewassomehowtransformedeventuallyintoareflectionofvindictivism。HislatercharacterbegantoappearinhisfirstconferencewiththeCommitteesubsequenttohisdisaster。Theyvisitedhimonthefieldand“hisconversationdisarmedallcriticism。“Thiswasbecausehestrucktheirownnotetoperfection。“Oursoldiers,“hesaid,“werenotsufficientlyfiredbyresentment,andheexhortedme[Julian]ifIcould,tobreatheintoourpeopleathomethesamespirittowardourenemieswhichinspiredthemtowardus。“[6]
WhatatransformationinMcClellan’sdisciple!
ButthecountrywasnotwonoversoeasilyastheCommittee。
Therewasloudandgeneraldisapprovalandofcourse,thehabitualquestion,“Whonext?“ThepublicationbytheCommitteeofitsinsinuationthatoncemorethestubbornPresidentwastherealculpritdidnotstemthetide。Burnsidehimselfmadehiscasesteadilyworse。Hisjudgment,suchasitwas,hadcollapsed。Heseemedtobestubbornlybentonavirtualrepetitionofhispreviousfolly。LincolnfeltitnecessarytocommandhimtomakenoforwardmovewithoutconsultingthePresident。[7]
Burnside’ssubordinatesfreelycriticizedtheircommander。
GeneralHookerwasthemostoutspoken。Itwasknownthatamovementwasafoot——anintrigue,ifyouwill-todisgraceBurnsideandelevateHooker。Chafingundercriticismandrestraint,Burnsidecompletelylosthissenseofpropriety。Onthetwenty-fourthofJanuary,1863,whenHenryW。Raymond,thepowerfuleditoroftheNewYorkTimes,wasonavisittothecamp,BurnsidetookhimintohistentandreadhimanorderremovingHookerbecauseofhisunfitness“toholdacommandinacausewheresomuchmoderation,forbearance,andunselfishpatriotismwererequired。“Raymond,aghast,inquiredwhathewoulddoifHookerresisted,ifheraisedhistroopsinmutiny?
“HesaidhewouldSwinghimbeforesundownifheattemptedsuchathing。“
Raymond,thoughmorethanhalfinsympathywithBurnside,feltthatthesituationwasstartling。HehurriedofftoWashington。“Iimmediately,“hewrites,“calleduponSecretaryChaseandtoldhimthewholestory。HewasgreatlysurprisedtohearsuchreportsofHooker,andsaidhehadlookeduponhimasthemanbestfittedtocommandthearmyofthePotomac。Butnomancapableofsomuchandsuchunprincipledambitionwasfitforsogreatatrust,andhegaveupallthoughtofhimhenceforth。HewishedmetogowithhimtohishouseandaccompanyhimandhisdaughtertothePresident’slevee。IdidsoandfoundagreatcrowdsurroundingPresidentLincoln。I
managed,however,totellhiminbrieftermsthatIhadbeenwiththearmyandthatmanythingswereoccurringtherewhichheoughttoknow。ItoldhimoftheobstaclesthrowninBurnside’swaybyhissubordinatesandespeciallyGeneralHooker’shabitualconversation。Heputhishandonmyshoulderandsaidinmyearasifdesirousofnotbeingoverheard,’Thatisalltrue;Hookertalksbadly;butthetroubleis,heisstrongerwiththecountrytodaythananyotherman。’Iventuredtoaskhowlonghewouldretainthatstrengthifhisrealconductandcharactershouldbeunderstood。’Thecountry,’
saidhe,’wouldnotbelieveit;theywouldsayitwasallalie。’“[8]
WhetherChasedidwhathesaidhewoulddoandceasedtobeHooker’sadvocate,maybequestioned。TraditionpreservesadealbetweentheSecretaryandtheGeneral——theSecretarytourgehisadvancement,theGeneral,ifhereachedhisgoal,tocontenthimselfwithmilitaryhonorsandtoassisttheSecretaryinsucceedingtothePresidency。Hookerwasapublicfavorite。Thedashing,handsomefigureof“FightingJoe“