Themostimmediateandunequivocalexpressionofthatarchaichumannaturewhichcharacterizesmaninthepredatorystageisthefightingpropensityproper。Incaseswherethepredatoryactivityisacollectiveone,thispropensityisfrequentlycalledthemartialspirit,or,latterly,patriotism。
ItneedsnoinsistencetofindassenttothepropositionthatinthecountriesofcivilizedEuropethehereditaryleisureclassisendowedwiththismartialspiritinahigherdegreethanthemiddleclasses。Indeed,theleisureclassclaimsthedistinctionasamatterofpride,andnodoubtwithsomegrounds。Warishonorable,andwarlikeprowessiseminentlyhonorificintheeyesofthegeneralityofmen;andthisadmirationofwarlikeprowessisitselfthebestvoucherofapredatorytemperamentintheadmirerofwar。Theenthusiasmforwar,andthepredatorytemperofwhichitistheindex,prevailinthelargestmeasureamongtheupperclasses,especiallyamongthehereditaryleisureclass。
Moreover,theostensibleseriousoccupationoftheupperclassisthatofgovernment,which,inpointoforiginanddevelopmentalcontent,isalsoapredatoryoccupation。
Theonlyclasswhichcouldatalldisputewiththehereditaryleisureclassthehonorofanhabitualbellicoseframeofmindisthatofthelower-classdelinquents。Inordinarytimes,thelargebodyoftheindustrialclassesisrelativelyapathetictouchingwarlikeinterests。Whenunexcited,thisbodyofthecommonpeople,whichmakesuptheeffectiveforceoftheindustrialcommunity,isratheraversetoanyotherthanadefensivefight;indeed,itrespondsalittletardilyeventoaprovocationwhichmakesforanattitudeofdefense。Inthemorecivilizedcommunities,orratherinthecommunitieswhichhavereachedanadvancedindustrialdevelopment,thespiritofwarlikeaggressionmaybesaidtobeobsolescentamongthecommonpeople。
Thisdoesnotsaythatthereisnotanappreciablenumberofindividualsamongtheindustrialclassesinwhomthemartialspiritassertsitselfobtrusively。Nordoesitsaythatthebodyofthepeoplemaynotbefiredwithmartialardorforatimeunderthestimulusofsomespecialprovocation,suchasisseeninoperationtodayinmorethanoneofthecountriesofEurope,andforthetimeinAmerica。Butexceptforsuchseasonsoftemporaryexaltation,andexceptforthoseindividualswhoareendowedwithanarchaictemperamentofthepredatorytype,togetherwiththesimilarlyendowedbodyofindividualsamongthehigherandthelowestclasses,theinertnessofthemassofanymoderncivilizedcommunityinthisrespectisprobablysogreataswouldmakewarimpracticable,exceptagainstactualinvasion。
Thehabitsandaptitudesofthecommonrunofmenmakeforanunfoldingofactivityinother,lesspicturesquedirectionsthanthatofwar。
Thisclassdifferenceintemperamentmaybedueinparttoadifferenceintheinheritanceofacquiredtraitsintheseveralclasses,butitseemsalso,insomemeasure,tocorrespondwithadifferenceinethnicderivation。Theclassdifferenceisinthisrespectvisiblylessinthosecountrieswhosepopulationisrelativelyhomogeneous,ethnically,thaninthecountrieswherethereisabroaderdivergencebetweentheethnicelementsthatmakeuptheseveralclassesofthecommunity。Inthesameconnectionitmaybenotedthatthelateraccessionstotheleisureclassinthelattercountries,inageneralway,showlessofthemartialspiritthancontemporaryrepresentativesofthearistocracyoftheancientline。Thesenouveauxarriv閟haverecentlyemergedfromthecommonplacebodyofthepopulationandowetheiremergenceintotheleisureclasstotheexerciseoftraitsandpropensitieswhicharenottobeclassedasprowessintheancientsense。
Apartfromwarlikeactivityproper,theinstitutionoftheduelisalsoanexpressionofthesamesuperiorreadinessforcombat;andtheduelisaleisure-classinstitution。Theduelisinsubstanceamoreorlessdeliberateresorttoafightasafinalsettlementofadifferenceofopinion。Incivilizedcommunitiesitprevailsasanormalphenomenononlywherethereisanhereditaryleisureclass,andalmostexclusivelyamongthatclass。Theexceptionsare1militaryandnavalofficerswhoareordinarilymembersoftheleisureclass,andwhoareatthesametimespeciallytrainedtopredatoryhabitsofmindand2thelower-classdelinquents——whoarebyinheritance,ortraining,orboth,ofasimilarlypredatorydispositionandhabit。Itisonlythehigh-bredgentlemanandtherowdythatnormallyresorttoblowsastheuniversalsolventofdifferencesofopinion。Theplainmanwillordinarilyfightonlywhenexcessivemomentaryirritationoralcoholicexaltationacttoinhibitthemorecomplexhabitsofresponsetothestimulithatmakeforprovocation。Heisthenthrownbackuponthesimpler,lessdifferentiatedformsoftheinstinctofself-assertion;thatistosay,herevertstemporarilyandwithoutreflectiontoanarchaichabitofmind。
Thisinstitutionoftheduelasamodeoffinallysettlingdisputesandseriousquestionsofprecedenceshadesoffintotheobligatory,unprovokedprivatefight,asasocialobligationduetoone’sgoodrepute。Asaleisure-classusageofthiskindwehave,particularly,thatbizarresurvivalofbellicosechivalry,theGermanstudentduel。Inthelowerorspuriousleisureclassofthedelinquentsthereisinallcountriesasimilar,thoughlessformal,socialobligationincumbentontherowdytoasserthismanhoodinunprovokedcombatwithhisfellows。Andspreadingthroughallgradesofsociety,asimilarusageprevailsamongtheboysofthecommunity。Theboyusuallyknowstonicety,fromdaytoday,howheandhisassociatesgradeinrespectofrelativefightingcapacity;andinthecommunityofboysthereisordinarilynosecurebasisofreputabilityforanyonewho,byexception,willnotorcannotfightoninvitation。
Allthisappliesespeciallytoboysaboveacertainsomewhatvaguelimitofmaturity。Thechild’stemperamentdoesnotcommonlyanswertothisdescriptionduringinfancyandtheyearsofclosetutelage,whenthechildstillhabituallyseekscontactwithitsmotherateveryturnofitsdailylife。Duringthisearlierperiodthereislittleaggressionandlittlepropensityforantagonism。Thetransitionfromthispeaceabletempertothepredaceous,andinextremecasesmalignant,mischievousnessoftheboyisagradualone,anditisaccomplishedwithmorecompleteness,coveringalargerrangeoftheindividual’saptitudes,insomecasesthaninothers。Intheearlierstageofhisgrowth,thechild,whetherboyorgirl,showslessofinitiativeandaggressiveself-assertionandlessofaninclinationtoisolatehimselfandhisinterestsfromthedomesticgroupinwhichhelives,andheshowsmoreofsensitivenesstorebuke,bashfulness,timidity,andtheneedoffriendlyhumancontact。Inthecommonrunofcasesthisearlytemperamentpasses,byagradualbutsomewhatrapidobsolescenceoftheinfantilefeatures,intothetemperamentoftheboyproper;thoughtherearealsocaseswherethepredaceousfuturesofboylifedonotemergeatall,oratthemostemergeinbutaslightandobscuredegree。
Ingirlsthetransitiontothepredaceousstageisseldomaccomplishedwiththesamedegreeofcompletenessasinboys;andinarelativelylargeproportionofcasesitisscarcelyundergoneatall。Insuchcasesthetransitionfrominfancytoadolescenceandmaturityisagradualandunbrokenprocessoftheshiftingofinterestfrominfantilepurposesandaptitudestothepurposes,functions,andrelationsofadultlife。Inthegirlsthereisalessgeneralprevalenceofapredaceousintervalinthedevelopment;andinthecaseswhereitoccurs,thepredaceousandisolatingattitudeduringtheintervaliscommonlylessaccentuated。
Inthemalechildthepredaceousintervalisordinarilyfairlywellmarkedandlastsforsometime,butitiscommonlyterminatedifatallwiththeattainmentofmaturity。Thislaststatementmayneedverymaterialqualification。Thecasesarebynomeansrareinwhichthetransitionfromtheboyishtotheadulttemperamentisnotmade,orismadeonlypartially——
understandingbythe“adult“temperamenttheaveragetemperamentofthoseadultindividualsinmodernindustriallifewhohavesomeserviceabilityforthepurposesofthecollectivelifeprocess,andwhomaythereforebesaidtomakeuptheeffectiveaverageoftheindustrialcommunity。
TheethniccompositionoftheEuropeanpopulationsvaries。
Insomecaseseventhelowerclassesareinlargemeasuremadeupofthepeace-disturbingdolicho-blond;whileinothersthisethnicelementisfoundchieflyamongthehereditaryleisureclass。Thefightinghabitseemstoprevailtoalessextentamongtheworking-classboysinthelatterclassofpopulationsthanamongtheboysoftheupperclassesoramongthoseofthepopulationsfirstnamed。
Ifthisgeneralizationastothetemperamentoftheboyamongtheworkingclassesshouldbefoundtrueonafullerandcloserscrutinyofthefield,itwouldaddforcetotheviewthatthebellicosetemperamentisinsomeappreciabledegreearacecharacteristic;itappearstoentermorelargelyintothemake-upofthedominant,upper-classethnictype——thedolicho-blond——
oftheEuropeancountriesthanintothesubservient,lower-classtypesofmanwhichareconceivedtoconstitutethebodyofthepopulationofthesamecommunities。
Thecaseoftheboymayseemnottobearseriouslyonthequestionoftherelativeendowmentofprowesswithwhichtheseveralclassesofsocietyaregifted;butitisatleastofsomevalueasgoingtoshowthatthisfightingimpulsebelongstoamorearchaictemperamentthanthatpossessedbytheaverageadultmanoftheindustriousclasses。Inthis,asinmanyotherfeaturesofchildlife,thechildreproduces,temporarilyandinminiature,someoftheearlierphasesofthedevelopmentofadultman。Underthisinterpretation,theboy’spredilectionforexploitandforisolationofhisowninterestistobetakenasatransientreversiontothehumannaturethatisnormaltotheearlybarbarianculture——thepredatorycultureproper。Inthisrespect,asinmuchelse,theleisure-classandthedelinquent-classcharactershowsapersistenceintoadultlifeoftraitsthatarenormaltochildhoodandyouth,andthatarelikewisenormalorhabitualtotheearlierstagesofculture。
Unlessthedifferenceistraceableentirelytoafundamentaldifferencebetweenpersistentethnictypes,thetraitsthatdistinguishtheswaggeringdelinquentandthepunctiliousgentlemanofleisurefromthecommoncrowdare,insomemeasure,marksofanarrestedspiritualdevelopment。Theymarkanimmaturephase,ascomparedwiththestageofdevelopmentattainedbytheaverageoftheadultsinthemodernindustrialcommunity。Anditwillappearpresentlythatthepuerilespiritualmake-upoftheserepresentativesoftheupperandthelowestsocialstratashowsitselfalsointhepresenceofotherarchaictraitsthanthisproclivitytoferociousexploitandisolation。
Asiftoleavenodoubtabouttheessentialimmaturityofthefightingtemperament,wehave,bridgingtheintervalbetweenlegitimateboyhoodandadultmanhood,theaimlessandplayful,butmoreorlesssystematicandelaborate,disturbancesofthepeaceinvogueamongschoolboysofaslightlyhigherage。Inthecommonrunofcases,thesedisturbancesareconfinedtotheperiodofadolescence。Theyrecurwithdecreasingfrequencyandacutenessasyouthmergesintoadultlife,andsotheyreproduce,inageneralway,inthelifeoftheindividual,thesequencebywhichthegrouphaspassedfromthepredatorytoamoresettledhabitoflife。Inanappreciablenumberofcasesthespiritualgrowthoftheindividualcomestoaclosebeforeheemergesfromthispuerilephase;inthesecasesthefightingtemperpersiststhroughlife。Thoseindividualswhoinspiritualdevelopmenteventuallyreachman’sestate,therefore,ordinarilypassthroughatemporaryarchaicphasecorrespondingtothepermanentspirituallevelofthefightingandsportingmen。Differentindividualswill,ofcourse,achievespiritualmaturityandsobrietyinthisrespectindifferentdegrees;andthosewhofailoftheaverageremainasanundissolvedresidueofcrudehumanityinthemodernindustrialcommunityandasafoilforthatselectiveprocessofadaptationwhichmakesforaheightenedindustrialefficiencyandthefullnessoflifeofthecollectivity。Thisarrestedspiritualdevelopmentmayexpressitselfnotonlyinadirectparticipationbyadultsinyouthfulexploitsofferocity,butalsoindirectlyinaidingandabettingdisturbancesofthiskindonthepartofyoungerpersons。Ittherebyfurtherstheformationofhabitsofferocitywhichmaypersistinthelaterlifeofthegrowinggeneration,andsoretardanymovementinthedirectionofamorepeaceableeffectivetemperamentonthepartofthecommunity。Ifapersonsoendowedwithaproclivityforexploitsisinapositiontoguidethedevelopmentofhabitsintheadolescentmembersofthecommunity,theinfluencewhichheexertsinthedirectionofconservationandreversiontoprowessmaybeveryconsiderable。
Thisisthesignificance,forinstance,ofthefosteringcarelatterlybestowedbymanyclergymenandotherpillarsofsocietyupon“boys’brigades“andsimilarpseudo-militaryorganizations。
Thesameistrueoftheencouragementgiventothegrowthof“collegespirit,“collegeathletics,andthelike,inthehigherinstitutionsoflearning。
Thesemanifestationsofthepredatorytemperamentarealltobeclassedundertheheadofexploit。Theyarepartlysimpleandunreflectedexpressionsofanattitudeofemulativeferocity,partlyactivitiesdeliberatelyentereduponwithaviewtogainingreputeforprowess。Sportsofallkindsareofthesamegeneralcharacter,includingprize-fights,bull-fights,athletics,shooting,angling,yachting,andgamesofskill,evenwheretheelementofdestructivephysicalefficiencyisnotanobtrusivefeature。Sportsshadeofffromthebasisofhostilecombat,throughskill,tocunningandchicanery,withoutitsbeingpossibletodrawalineatanypoint。Thegroundofanaddictiontosportsisanarchaicspiritualconstitution——thepossessionofthepredatoryemulativepropensityinarelativelyhighpotency,Astrongproclivitytoadventuresomeexploitandtotheinflictionofdamageisespeciallypronouncedinthoseemploymentswhichareincolloquialusagespecificallycalledsportsmanship。