Leavingthisdrawer,aswellascupboardNo。1open,MaelzelnowunlocksdoorNo。2,anddoorNo。3,whicharediscoveredtobefoldingdoors,openingintooneandthesamecompartment。Totherightofthiscompartment,however,thatistosaythespectators’
rightasmalldivision,sixincheswide,andfilledwithmachinery,ispartitionedoff。Themaincompartmentitselfinspeakingofthatportionoftheboxvisibleuponopeningdoors2and3,weshallalwayscallitthemaincompartmentislinedwithdarkclothandcontainsnomachinerywhateverbeyondtwopiecesofsteel,quadrant-shaped,andsituatedoneineachofthereartopcornersofthecompartment。Asmallprotuberanceabouteightinchessquare,andalsocoveredwithdarkcloth,liesonthefloorofthecompartmentneartherearcorneronthespectators’lefthand。LeavingdoorsNo。
2andNo。3openaswellasthedrawer,anddoorNo。I,theexhibiternowgoesroundtothebackofthemaincompartment,and,unlockinganotherdoorthere,displaysclearlyalltheinteriorofthemaincompartment,byintroducingacandlebehinditandwithinit。Thewholeboxbeingthusapparentlydisclosedtothescrutinyofthecompany,Maelzel,stillleavingthedoorsanddraweropen,rollstheAutomatonentirelyround,andexposesthebackoftheTurkbyliftingupthedrapery。Adooraboutteninchessquareisthrownopenintheloinsofthefigure,andasmalleronealsointheleftthigh。Theinteriorofthefigure,asseenthroughtheseapertures,appearstobecrowdedwithmachinery。Ingeneral,everyspectatorisnowthoroughlysatisfiedofhavingbeheldandcompletelyscrutinized,atoneandthesametime,everyindividualportionoftheAutomaton,andtheideaofanypersonbeingconcealedintheinterior,duringsocompleteanexhibitionofthatinterior,ifeverentertained,isimmediatelydismissedaspreposterousintheextreme。
M。Maelzel,havingrolledthemachinebackintoitsoriginalposition,nowinformsthecompanythattheAutomatonwillplayagameofchesswithanyonedisposedtoencounterhim。Thischallengebeingaccepted,asmalltableispreparedfortheantagonist,andplacedclosebytherope,butonthespectators’sideofit,andsosituatedasnottopreventthecompanyfromobtainingafullviewoftheAutomaton。Fromadrawerinthistableistakenasetofchess-men,andMaelzelarrangesthemgenerally,butnotalways,withhisownhands,onthechessboard,whichconsistsmerelyoftheusualnumberofsquarespainteduponthetable。Theantagonisthavingtakenhisseat,theexhibiterapproachesthedrawerofthebox,andtakestherefromthecushion,which,afterremovingthepipefromthehandoftheAutomaton,heplacesunderitsleftarmasasupport。ThentakingalsofromthedrawertheAutomaton’ssetofchess-men,hearrangesthemuponthechessboardbeforethefigure。HenowproceedstoclosethedoorsandtolockthemleavingthebunchofkeysindoorNo。1。Healsoclosesthedrawer,and,finally,windsupthemachine,byapplyingakeytoanapertureintheleftendthespectators’leftofthebox。ThegamenowcommencestheAutomatontakingthefirstmove。Thedurationofthecontestisusuallylimitedtohalfanhour,butifitbenotfinishedattheexpirationofthisperiod,andtheantagoniststillcontendthathecanbeattheAutomaton,M。Maelzelhasseldomanyobjectiontocontinueit。Nottowearythecompany,istheostensible,andnodoubttherealobjectofthelimitation。ItWitsofcoursebeunderstoodthatwhenamoveismadeathisowntable,bytheantagonist,thecorrespondingmoveismadeattheboxoftheAutomaton,byMaelzelhimself,whothenactsastherepresentativeoftheantagonist。Ontheotherhand,whentheTurkmoves,thecorrespondingmoveismadeatthetableoftheantagonist,alsobyM。Maelzel,whothenactsastherepresentativeoftheAutomaton。Inthismanneritisnecessarythattheexhibitershouldoftenpassfromonetabletotheother。Healsofrequentlygoesinrearofthefiguretoremovethechess-menwhichithastaken,andwhichitdeposits,whentaken,ontheboxtothelefttoitsownleftoftheboard。WhentheAutomatonhesitatesinrelationtoitsmove,theexhibiterisoccasionallyseentoplacehimselfverynearitsrightside,andtolayhishand,nowandthen,inacarelessmanneruponthebox。Hehasalsoapeculiarshufflewithhisfeet,calculatedtoinducesuspicionofcollusionwiththemachineinmindswhicharemorecunningthansagacious。Thesepeculiaritiesare,nodoubt,meremannerismsofM。Maelzel,or,ifheisawareofthematall,heputstheminpracticewithaviewofexcitinginthespectatorsafalseideaofthepuremechanismintheAutomaton。
TheTurkplayswithhislefthand。Allthemovementsofthearmareatrightangles。Inthismanner,thehandwhichisglovedandbentinanaturalway,beingbroughtdirectlyabovethepiecetobemoved,descendsfinallyuponit,thefingersreceivingit,inmostcases,withoutdifficulty。Occasionally,however,whenthepieceisnotpreciselyinitspropersituation,theAutomatonfailsinhisattemptatseizingit。Whenthisoccurs,nosecondeffortismade,butthearmcontinuesitsmovementinthedirectionoriginallyintended,preciselyasifthepiecewereinthefingers。Havingthusdesignatedthespotwhitherthemoveshouldhavebeenmade,thearmreturnstoitscushion,andMaelzelperformstheevolutionwhichtheAutomatonpointedout。Ateverymovementofthefiguremachineryisheardinmotion。Duringtheprogressofthegame,thefigurenowandthenrollsitseyes,asifsurveyingtheboard,movesitshead,andpronouncestheword_echec_checkwhennecessary。{*3}Ifafalsemovebemadebyhisantagonist,herapsbrisklyontheboxwiththefingersofhisrighthand,shakeshisheadroughly,andreplacingthepiecefalselymoved,initsformersituation,assumesthenextmovehimself。Uponbeatingthegame,hewaveshisheadwithanairoftriumph,looksroundcomplacentlyuponthespectators,anddrawinghisleftarmfartherbackthanusual,suffershisfingersalonetorestuponthecushion。Ingeneral,theTurkisvictoriousonceortwicehehasbeenbeaten。Thegamebeingended,Maelzelwillagainifdesired,exhibitthemechanismofthebox,inthesamemannerasbefore。Themachineisthenrolledback,andacurtainhidesitfromtheviewofthecompany。
TherehavebeenmanyattemptsatsolvingthemysteryoftheAutomaton。Themostgeneralopinioninrelationtoit,anopiniontoonotunfrequentlyadoptedbymenwhoshouldhaveknownbetter,was,aswehavebeforesaid,thatnoimmediatehumanagencywasemployedinotherwords,thatthemachinewaspurelyamachineandnothingelse。
Many,howevermaintainedthattheexhibiterhimselfregulatedthemovementsofthefigurebymechanicalmeansoperatingthroughthefeetofthebox。Othersagain,spokeconfidentlyofamagnet。Ofthefirstoftheseopinionsweshallsaynothingatpresentmorethanwehavealreadysaid。Inrelationtotheseconditisonlynecessarytorepeatwhatwehavebeforestated,thatthemachineisrolledaboutoncastors,andwill,attherequestofaspectator,bemovedtoandfrotoanyportionoftheroom,evenduringtheprogressofagame。
Thesuppositionofthemagnetisalsountenableforifamagnetweretheagent,anyothermagnetinthepocketofaspectatorwoulddisarrangetheentiremechanism。Theexhibiter,however,willsufferthemostpowerfulloadstonetoremainevenupontheboxduringthewholeoftheexhibition。
Thefirstattemptatawrittenexplanationofthesecret,atleastthefirstattemptofwhichweourselveshaveanyknowledge,wasmadeinalargepamphletprintedatParisin1785。Theauthor’shypothesisamountedtothisthatadwarfactuatedthemachine。Thisdwarfhesupposedtoconcealhimselfduringtheopeningoftheboxbythrustinghislegsintotwohollowcylinders,whichwererepresentedtobebutwhicharenotamongthemachineryinthecupboardNo。I,whilehisbodywasoutoftheboxentirely,andcoveredbythedraperyoftheTurk。Whenthedoorswereshut,thedwarfwasenabledtobringhisbodywithintheboxthenoiseproducedbysomeportionofthemachineryallowinghimtodosounheard,andalsotoclosethedoorbywhichheentered。Theinterioroftheautomatonbeingthenexhibited,andnopersondiscovered,thespectators,saystheauthorofthispamphlet,aresatisfiedthatnooneiswithinanyportionofthemachine。Thiswholehypothesiswastooobviouslyabsurdtorequirecomment,orrefutation,andaccordinglywefindthatitattractedverylittleattention。
In1789abookwaspublishedatDresdenbyM。I。F。Freyhereinwhichanotherendeavorwasmadetounravelthemystery。Mr。Freyhere’sbookwasaprettylargeone,andcopiouslyillustratedbycoloredengravings。Hissuppositionwasthat“awell-taughtboyverythinandtallofhisagesufficientlysothathecouldbeconcealedinadraweralmostimmediatelyunderthechess-board“playedthegameofchessandeffectedalltheevolutionsoftheAutomaton。Thisidea,althoughevenmoresillythanthatoftheParisianauthor,metwithabetterreception,andwasinsomemeasurebelievedtobethetruesolutionofthewonder,untiltheinventorputanendtothediscussionbysufferingacloseexaminationofthetopofthebox。
Thesebizarreattemptsatexplanationwerefollowedbyothersequallybizarre。Oflateyearshowever,ananonymouswriter,byacourseofreasoningexceedinglyunphilosophical,hascontrivedtoblunderuponaplausiblesolutionalthoughwecannotconsideritaltogetherthetrueone。HisEssaywasfirstpublishedinaBaltimoreweeklypaper,wasillustratedbycuts,andwasentitled“AnattempttoanalyzetheAutomatonChess-PlayerofM。Maelzel。”ThisEssaywesupposetohavebeentheoriginalofthe_pamphletto_whichSirDavidBrewsteralludesinhislettersonNaturalMagic,andwhichhehasnohesitationindeclaringathoroughandsatisfactoryexplanation。The_results_oftheanalysisareundoubtedly,inthemain,just;butwecanonlyaccountforBrewster’spronouncingtheEssayathoroughandsatisfactoryexplanation,bysupposinghimtohavebestoweduponitaverycursoryandinattentiveperusal。InthecompendiumoftheEssay,madeuseofintheLettersonNaturalMagic,itisquiteimpossibletoarriveatanydistinctconclusioninregardtotheadequacyorinadequacyoftheanalysis,onaccountofthegrossmisarrangementanddeficiencyofthelettersofreferenceemployed。Thesamefaultistobefoundinthe’`Attempt&c……”asweoriginallysawit。Thesolutionconsistsinaseriesofminuteexplanations,accompaniedbywood-cuts,thewholeoccupyingmanypagesinwhichtheobjectistoshowthe_possibility_of_soshiftingthepartitions_ofthebox,astoallowahumanbeing,concealedintheinterior,tomoveportionsofhisbodyfromonepartoftheboxtoanother,duringtheexhibitionofthemechanismthuseludingthescrutinyofthespectators。Therecanbenodoubt,aswehavebeforeobserved,andaswewillpresentlyendeavortoshow,thattheprinciple,orrathertheresult,ofthissolutionisthetrueone。Somepersonisconcealedintheboxduringthewholetimeofexhibitingtheinterior。Weobject,however,tothewholeverbosedescriptionofthe_manner_inwhichthepartitionsareshifted,toaccommodatethemovementsofthepersonconcealed。Weobjecttoitasameretheoryassumedinthefirstplace,andtowhichcircumstancesareafterwardsmadetoadaptthemselves。Itwasnot,andcouldnothavebeen,arrivedatbyanyinductivereasoning。Inwhateverwaytheshiftingismanaged,itisofcourseconcealedateverystepfromobservation。Toshowthatcertainmovementsmightpossiblybeeffectedinacertainway,isveryfarfromshowingthattheyareactuallysoeffected。Theremaybeaninfinityofothermethodsbywhichthesameresultsmaybeobtained。Theprobabilityoftheoneassumedprovingthecorrectoneisthenasunitytoinfinity。But,inreality,thisparticularpoint,theshiftingofthepartitions,isofnoconsequencewhatever。Itwasaltogetherunnecessarytodevotesevenoreightpagesforthepurposeofprovingwhatnooneinhissenseswoulddenyviz:thatthewonderfulmechanicalgeniusofBaronKempelencouldinventthenecessarymeansforshuttingadoororslippingasideapannel,withahumanagenttooathisserviceinactualcontactwiththepannelorthedoor,andthewholeoperationscarriedon,astheauthoroftheEssayhimselfshows,andasweshallattempttoshowmorefullyhereafter,entirelyoutofreachoftheobservationofthespectators。