TheverynextyearafterDr。Wells’spaperwaspublishedthereappearedinFrancethethirdvolumeoftheMemoiresdePhysiqueetdeChimiedelaSocieted’Arcueil,andanewepochinmeteorologywasinaugurated。
Thesocietyinquestionwasnumericallyaninconsequentialband,listingonlyadozenmembers;buteverynamewasafamousone:Arago,Berard,Berthollet,Biot,Chaptal,DeCandolle,Dulong,Gay-Lussac,Humboldt,Laplace,Poisson,andThenard——rarespiritseveryone。Littledangerthatthememoirsofsuchabandwouldberelegatedtothedustyshelveswheremostproceedingsofsocietiesbelong——nomilk-for-babesfarewouldbeservedtosuchacompany。
Theparticularpaperwhichhereinterestsusclosesthisthirdandlastvolumeofmemoirs。Itisentitled"DesLignesIsothermesetdelaDistributiondelaChaleursurleGlobe。"TheauthorisAlexanderHumboldt。
Needlesstosay,thetopicishandledinamasterlymanner。Thedistributionofheatonthesurfaceoftheglobe,onthemountain-sides,intheinterioroftheearth;thecausesthatregulatesuchdistribution;theclimaticresults——thesearethetopicsdiscussed。Butwhatgivesepochalcharactertothepaperistheintroductionofthoseisothermallinescirclingtheearthinirregularcourse,joiningtogetherplaceshavingthesamemeanannualtemperature,andthuslayingthefoundationforascienceofcomparativeclimatology。
Itistruetheattempttostudyclimatescomparativelywasnotnew。Mairanhadattempteditinthosepapersinwhichhedevelopedhisbizarreideasastocentralemanationsofheat。Eulerhadbroughthisprofoundmathematicalgeniustobearonthetopic,evolvingthe"extraordinaryconclusionthatundertheequatoratmidnightthecoldoughttobemorerigorousthanatthepolesinwinter。"AndinparticularRichardKirwan,theEnglishchemist,hadcombinedthemathematicalandtheempiricalmethodsandcalculatedtemperaturesforalllatitudes。ButHumboldtdiffersfromallthesepredecessorsinthathegraspstheideathatthebasisofallsuchcomputationsshouldbenottheory,butfact。Hedrewhisisothermallinesnotwheresomeoccultcalculationwouldlocatethemonanidealglobe,butwherepracticaltestswiththethermometerlocatethemonourglobeasitis。London,forexample,liesinthesamelatitudeasthesouthernextremityofHudsonBay;buttheisothermofLondon,asHumboldtoutlinesit,passesthroughCincinnati。
Ofcoursesuchdeviationsofclimaticconditionsbetweenplacesinthesamelatitudehadlongbeenknown。
AsHumboldthimselfobserves,theearliestsettlersofAmericawereastonishedtofindthemselvessubjectedtorigorsofclimateforwhichtheirEuropeanexperiencehadnotatallpreparedthem。Moreover,sagacioustravellers,inparticularCook’scompaniononhissecondvoyage,youngGeorgeForster,hadnotedasageneralprinciplethatthewesternbordersofcontinentsintemperateregionsarealwayswarmerthancorrespondinglatitudesoftheireasternborders;andofcoursethegeneraltruthoftemperaturesbeingmilderinthevicinityoftheseathanintheinteriorofcontinentshadlongbeenfamiliar。ButHumboldt’sisothermallinesforthefirsttimegavetangibilitytotheseideas,andmadepracticableatrulyscientificstudyofcomparativeclimatology。
Instudyingtheselines,particularlyaselaboratedbyfurtherobservations,itbecameclearthattheyarebynomeanshaphazardinarrangement,butaredependentupongeographicalconditionswhichinmostcasesarenotdifficulttodetermine。Humboldthimselfpointedoutveryclearlythemaincausesthattendtoproducedeviationsfromtheaverage——or,asDovelateroncalledit,thenormal——temperatureofanygivenlatitude。Forexample,themeanannualtemperatureofaregionreferringmainlytothenorthernhemisphere
israisedbytheproximityofawesterncoast;
byadividedconfigurationofthecontinentintopeninsulas;
bytheexistenceofopenseastothenorthorofradiatingcontinentalsurfacestothesouth;bymountainrangestoshieldfromcoldwinds;bytheinfrequencyofswampstobecomecongealed;bytheabsenceofwoodsinadry,sandysoil;andbytheserenityofskyinthesummermonthsandthevicinityofanoceancurrentbringingwaterwhichisofahighertemperaturethanthatofthesurroundingsea。
Conditionsoppositetothesetend,ofcourse,correspondinglytolowerthetemperature。Inaword,Humboldtsaystheclimaticdistributionofheatdependsontherelativedistributionoflandandsea,andonthe"hypsometricalconfigurationofthecontinents";
andheurgesthat"greatmeteorologicalphenomenacannotbecomprehendedwhenconsideredindependentlyofgeognosticrelations"——atruthwhich,likemostothergeneralprinciples,seemssimpleenoughonceitispointedout。
Withthatbroadsweepofimaginationwhichcharacterizedhim,Humboldtspeaksoftheatmosphereasthe"aerialocean,inthelowerstrataandontheshoalsofwhichwelive,"andhestudiestheatmosphericphenomenaalwaysinrelationtothoseofthatotheroceanofwater。Ineachoftheseoceanstherearevastpermanentcurrents,flowingalwaysindeterminatedirections,whichenormouslymodifytheclimaticconditionsofeveryzone。Theoceanofairisavastmaelstrom,boilingupalwaysundertheinfluenceofthesun’sheatattheequator,andflowingasanuppercurrenttowardseitherpole,whileanundercurrentfromthepoles,whichbecomesthetrade-winds,flowstowardstheequatortosupplyitsplace。
Butthesuperheatedequatorialair,becomingchilled,descendstothesurfaceintemperatelatitudes,andcontinuesitspolewardjourneyastheanti-trade-winds。
Thetrade-windsaredeflectedtowardsthewest,becauseinapproachingtheequatortheyconstantlypassoversurfacesoftheearthhavingagreaterandgreatervelocityofrotation,andso,asitwere,tendtolagbehind——
anexplanationwhichHadleypointedoutin1735,butwhichwasnotaccepteduntilDaltonindependentlyworkeditoutandpromulgateditin1793。
Fortheoppositereason,theanti-tradesaredeflectedtowardstheeast;henceitisthatthewestern,bordersofcontinentsintemperatezonesarebathedinmoistsea-breezes,whiletheireasternborderslackthiscold-
dispellinginfluence。
Intheoceanofwaterthemaincurrentsrunasmoresharplycircumscribedstreams——veritableriversinthesea。OfthesethebestknownandmostsharplycircumscribedisthefamiliarGulfStream,whichhasitsorigininanequatorialcurrent,impelledwestwardbytrade-winds,whichisdeflectednorthwardinthemainatCapeSt。Roque,enteringtheCaribbeanSeaandGulfofMexico,toemergefinallythroughtheStraitofFlorida,andjourneyoffacrosstheAtlantictowarmtheshoresofEurope。
Such,atleast,istheGulfStreamasHumboldtunderstoodit。Sincehistime,however,oceancurrentsingeneral,andthisoneinparticular,havebeenthesubjectofnoendofcontroversy,itbeinghotlydisputedwhethereithercausesoreffectsoftheGulfStreamarejustwhatHumboldt,incommonwithothersofhistime,conceivedthemtobe。AboutthemiddleofthecenturyLieutenantM。F。Maury,thedistinguishedAmericanhydrographerandmeteorologist,advocatedatheoryofgravitationasthechiefcauseofthecurrents,claimingthatdifferenceindensity,duetodifferenceintemperatureandsaltness,wouldsufficientlyaccountfortheoceaniccirculation。ThistheorygainedgreatpopularitythroughthewidecirculationofMaury’sPhysicalGeographyoftheSea,whichissaidtohavepassedthroughmoreeditionsthananyotherscientificbookoftheperiod;butitwasablyandvigorouslycombatedbyDr。JamesCroll,theScottishgeologist,inhisClimateandTime,andlatterlytheoldtheorythatoceancurrentsareduetothetrade-windshasagaincomeintofavor。Indeed,veryrecentlyamodelhasbeenconstructed,withtheaidofwhichitissaidtohavebeendemonstratedthatprevailingwindsinthedirectionoftheactualtrade-windswouldproducesuchacurrentastheGulfStream。
Meantime,however,itisbynomeanssurethatgravitationdoesnotenterintothecasetotheextentofproducinganinsensiblegeneraloceaniccirculation,independentoftheGulfStreamandsimilarmarkedcurrents,andsimilarinitslargeroutlinestothepolar-
equatorialcirculationoftheair。TheideaofsuchoceaniccirculationwasfirstsuggestedindetailbyProfessorLenz,ofSt。Petersburg,in1845,butitwasnotgenerallyrecognizeduntilDr。Carpenterindependentlyhitupontheideamorethantwentyyearslater。Theplausibilityoftheconceptionisobvious;
yettheallegedfactofsuchcirculationhasbeenhotlydisputed,andthequestionisstillsubjudice。
Butwhetherornotsuchgeneralcirculationofoceanwatertakesplace,itisbeyonddisputethattherecognizedcurrentscarryanenormousquantityofheatfromthetropicstowardsthepoles。Dr。Croll,whohasperhapsgivenmoreattentiontothephysicsofthesubjectthanalmostanyotherperson,computesthattheGulfStreamconveystotheNorthAtlanticone-
fourthasmuchheatasthatbodyreceivesdirectlyfromthesun,andhearguesthatwereitnotforthetransportationofheatbythisandsimilarPacificcurrents,onlyanarrowtropicalregionoftheglobewouldbewarmenoughforhabitationbytheexistingfaunas。
Dr。Crollarguesthataslightchangeintherelativevaluesofnorthernandsoutherntrade-windssuchashebelieveshastakenplaceatvariousperiodsinthepastwouldsufficetosoaltertheequatorialcurrentwhichnowfeedstheGulfStreamthatitsmainbulkwouldbedeflectedsouthwardinsteadofnorthward,bytheangleofCapeSt。Roque。ThustheGulfStreamwouldbenippedinthebud,and,accordingtoDr。
Croll’sestimates,theresultswouldbedisastrousforthenorthernhemisphere。Theanti-trades,whichnowarewarmedbytheGulfStream,wouldthenblowascoldwindsacrosstheshoresofwesternEurope,andinallprobabilityaglacialepochwouldsupervenethroughoutthenorthernhemisphere。
Thesameconsequences,sofarasEuropeisconcernedatleast,wouldapparentlyensueweretheIsthmusofPanamatosettleintothesea,allowingtheCaribbeancurrenttopassintothePacific。Butthegeologisttellsusthatthisisthmusroseatacomparativelyrecentgeologicalperiod,thoughitishintedthattherehadbeensometimepreviouslyatemporarylandconnectionbetweenthetwocontinents。Arewetoinfer,then,thatthetwoAmericasintheirunionsanddisunionshavejuggledwiththeclimateoftheotherhemisphere?Apparentlyso,iftheestimatesmadeoftheinfluenceoftheGulfStreambetenable。ItisafarcryfromPanamatoRussia。YetitseemswithinthepossibilitiesthatthemeteorologistmaylearnfromthegeologistofCentralAmericasomethingthatwillenablehimtoexplaintothepaleontologistofEuropehowitchancedthatatonetimethemammothandrhinocerosroamedacrossnorthernSiberia,whileatanothertimethereindeerandmusk-oxbrowsedalongtheshoresoftheMediterranean。
Possibilities,Isaid,notprobabilities。YeteventhefaintglimmerofsoalluringapossibilitybringshometoonewithvividnessthetruthofHumboldt’sperspicuousobservationthatmeteorologycanbeproperlycomprehendedonlywhenstudiedinconnectionwiththecompanionsciences。Therearenoisolatedphenomenainnature。
CYCLONESANDANTI-CYCLONES
Yet,afterall,itisnottobedeniedthatthechiefconcernofthemeteorologistmustbewiththatothermedium,the"oceanofair,ontheshoalsofwhichwelive。"Forwhatevermaybeaccomplishedbywatercurrentsinthewayofconveyingheat,itisthewindcurrentsthateffectthefinaldistributionofthatheat。
AsDr。Crollhasurged,thewatersoftheGulfStreamdonotwarmtheshoresofEuropebydirectcontact,butbywarmingtheanti-trade-winds,whichsubsequentlyblowacrossthecontinent。Andeverywheretheheataccumulatedbywaterbecomeseffectualinmodifyingclimate,notsomuchbydirectradiationasbydiffusionthroughthemediumoftheair。
Thisveryobviousimportanceofaerialcurrentsledtotheirpracticalstudylongbeforemeteorologyhadanytitletotherankofscience,andDalton’sexplanationofthetrade-windshadlaidthefoundationforascienceofwinddynamicsbeforethebeginningofthenineteenthcentury。Butnosubstantialfurtheradvanceinthisdirectionwaseffecteduntilabout1827,whenHeinrichW。Dove,ofKonigsberg,afterwardstobeknownasperhapstheforemostmeteorologistofhisgeneration,includedthewindsamongthesubjectsofhiselaboratestatisticalstudiesinclimatology。
Doveclassifiedthewindsaspermanent,periodical,andvariable。Hisgreatdiscoverywasthatallwinds,ofwhatevercharacter,andnotmerelythepermanentwinds,comeundertheinfluenceoftheearth’srotationinsuchawayastobedeflectedfromtheircourse,andhencetotakeonagyratorymotion——that,inshort,alllocalwindsareminoreddiesinthegreatpolar-equatorialwhirl,andtendtoreproduceinminiaturethecharacterofthatvastmaelstrom。Forthefirsttime,then,temporaryorvariablewindswereseentoliewithintheprovinceoflaw。
Agenerationlater,ProfessorWilliamFerrel,theAmericanmeteorologist,whohadbeenledtotakeupthesubjectbyaperusalofMaury’sdiscourseonoceanwinds,formulatedageneralmathematicallaw,totheeffectthatanybodymovinginarightlinealongthesurfaceoftheearthinanydirectiontendstohaveitscoursedeflected,owingtotheearth’srotation,totherighthandinthenorthernandtothelefthandinthesouthernhemisphere。Thislawhadindeedbeenstatedasearlyas1835bytheFrenchphysicistPoisson,butnoonethenthoughtofitasotherthanamathematicalcuriosity;itstruesignificancewasonlyunderstoodafterProfessorFerrelhadindependentlyrediscovereditjustasDaltonrediscoveredHadley’sforgottenlawofthetrade-windsandappliedittothemotionofwindcurrents。
Thenitbecameclearthathereisakeytothephenomenaofatmosphericcirculation,fromthegreatpolar-equatorialmaelstromwhichmanifestsitselfinthetrade-windstothemostcircumscribedrifflewhichisannouncedasalocalstorm。Andthemorethephenomenawerestudied,themorestrikingseemedtheparallelbetweenthegreatermaelstromandtheselessereddies。Justastheentireatmosphericmassofeachhemisphereisseen,whenviewedasawhole,tobecarriedinagreatwhirlaboutthepoleofthathemisphere,sothelocaldisturbanceswithinthisgreattidearefoundalwaystotaketheformofwhirlsaboutalocalstorm-centre——whichstorm-centre,meantime,iscarriedalonginthemajorcurrent,asoneoftenseesalittlewhirlpoolinthewatersweptalongwiththemaincurrentofthestream。Sometimes,indeed,thelocaleddy,caughtasitwereinanancillarycurrentofthegreatpolarstream,isdeflectedfromitsnormalcourseandmayseemtotravelagainstthestream;butsuchdeviationsaredeparturesfromtherule。Inthegreatmajorityofcases,forexample,inthenorthtemperatezone,astorm-centrewithitsattendantlocalwhirl
travelstothenortheast,alongthemaincurrentoftheanti-trade-wind,ofwhichitisapart;andthoughexceptionallyitscoursemaybetothesoutheastinstead,italmostneverdepartssowidelyfromthemainchannelastoprogresstothewestward。ThusitisthatstormssweepingovertheUnitedStatescanbeannounced,asarule,attheseaboardinadvanceoftheircomingbytelegraphiccommunicationfromtheinterior,whilesimilarstormscometoEuropeofftheoceanunannounced。Hencethemorepracticalavailabilityoftheforecastsofweatherbureausintheformercountry。
Buttheselocalwhirls,itmustbeunderstood,arelocalonlyinaverygeneralsenseoftheword,inasmuchasasingleonemaybemorethanathousandmilesindiameter,andasmalloneistwoorthreehundredmilesacross。Butquitewithoutregardtothesizeofthewhirl,theaircomposingitconductsitselfalwaysinoneoftwoways。Itneverwhirlsinconcentriccircles;italwayseitherrushesintowardsthecentreinadescendingspiral,inwhichcaseitiscalledacyclone,oritspreadsoutfromthecentreinawideningspiral,inwhichcaseitiscalledananti-cyclone。Thewordcycloneisassociatedinpopularphraseologywithaterrificstorm,butithasnosuchrestrictionintechnicalusage。Agentlezephyrflowingtowardsa"storm-
centre"isjustasmuchacyclonetothemeteorologistasisthewhirlconstitutingaWest-Indianhurricane。
Indeed,itisnotproperlythewinditselfthatiscalledthecycloneineithercase,buttheentiresystemofwhirls——includingthestorm-centreitself,wheretheremaybenowindatall。
What,then,isthisstorm-centre?Merelyanareaoflowbarometricpressure——anareawheretheairhasbecomelighterthantheairofsurroundingregions。
Underinfluenceofgravitationtheairseeksitsleveljustaswaterdoes;sotheheavyaircomesflowinginfromallsidestowardsthelow-pressurearea,whichthusbecomesa"storm-centre。"Buttheinrushingcurrentsnevercomestraighttotheirmark。InaccordancewithFerrel’slaw,theyaredeflectedtotheright,andtheresult,aswillreadilybeseen,mustbeavortexcurrent,whichwhirlsalwaysinonedirection——namely,fromlefttoright,orinthedirectionoppositetothatofthehandsofawatchheldwithitsfaceupward。Thevelocityofthecycloniccurrentswilldependlargelyuponthedifferenceinbarometricpressurebetweenthestorm-centreandtheconfinesofthecyclonesystem。
Andthevelocityofthecurrentswilldeterminetosomeextentthedegreeofdeflection,andhencetheexactpathofthedescendingspiralinwhichthewindapproachesthecentre。Butineverycaseandineverypartofthecyclonesystemitistrue,asBuysBallot’sfamousrulefirstpointedout,thatapersonstandingwithhisbacktothewindhasthestorm-centreathisleft。
Theprimarycauseofthelowbarometricpressurewhichmarksthestorm-centreandestablishesthecycloneisexpansionoftheairthroughexcessoftemperature。
Theheatedair,risingintocoldupperregions,hasaportionofitsvaporcondensedintoclouds,andnowanewdynamicfactorisadded,foreachparticleofvapor,incondensing,givesupitsmodicumoflatentheat。Eachpoundofvaporthusliberates,accordingtoProfessorTyndall’sestimate,enoughheattomeltfivepoundsofcastiron;sotheamountgivenoutwherelargemassesofcloudareformingmustenormouslyaddtotheconvectioncurrentsoftheair,andhencetothestorm-developingpoweroftheformingcyclone。Indeed,oneschoolofmeteorologists,ofwhomProfessorEspywastheleader,hasheldthat,withoutsuchaddedincrementofenergyconstantlyaugmentingthedynamiceffects,nostormcouldlongcontinueinviolentaction。Anditisdoubtedwhetheranystormcouldeverattain,muchlesscontinue,theterrificforceofthatmostdreadedofwindsoftemperatezones,thetornado——astormwhichobeysallthelawsofcyclones,butdiffersfromordinarycyclonesinhavingavortexcoreonlyafewfeetoryardsindiameter——
withouttheaidofthosegreatmassesofcondensingvaporwhichalwaysaccompanyitintheformofstorm-
clouds。
Theanti-cyclonesimplyreversestheconditionsofthecyclone。Itscentreisanareaofhighpressure,andtheairrushesoutfromitinalldirectionstowardssurroundingregionsoflowpressure。Asbefore,allpartsofthecurrentwillbedeflectedtowardstheright,andtheresult,clearly,isawhirloppositeindirectiontothatofthecyclone。Butherethereisatendencytodissipationratherthantoconcentrationofenergy,hence,consideredasastorm-generator,theanti-
cycloneisofrelativeinsignificance。
Inparticulartheprofessionalmeteorologistwhoconductsa"weatherbureau"——as,forexample,thechiefoftheUnitedStatessignal-servicestationinNewYork——issopreoccupiedwiththeobservationofthisphenomenonthatcyclone-huntingmightbesaidtobehischiefpursuit。Itisforthispurpose,inthemain,thatgovernmentweatherbureausorsignal-
servicedepartmentshavebeenestablishedallovertheworld。Theirchiefworkistofollowupcyclones,withtheaidoftelegraphicreports,mappingtheircourseandrecordingtheattendantmeteorologicalconditions。
Theirso-calledpredictionsorforecastsareessentiallypredications,gaininglocallytheeffectofpredictionsbecausethetelegraphoutstripsthewind。
Atonlyoneplaceontheglobehasitbeenpossibleasyetforthemeteorologisttomakelong-timeforecastsmeritingthetitleofpredictions。ThisisinthemiddleGangesValleyofnorthernIndia。Inthiscountrytheclimaticconditionsarelargelydependentupontheperiodicalwindscalledmonsoons,whichblowsteadilylandwardfromApriltoOctober,andseawardfromOctobertoApril。Thesummermonsoonsbringtheall-essentialrains;iftheyaredelayedorrestrictedinextent,therewillbedroughtandconsequentfamine。
AndsuchrestrictionofthemonsoonislikelytoresultwhentherehasbeenanunusuallydeeporverylatesnowfallontheHimalayas,becauseoftheloweringofspringtemperaturebythemeltingsnow。Thushereitispossible,byobservingthesnowfallinthemountains,topredictwithsomemeasureofsuccesstheaveragerainfallofthefollowingsummer。Thedroughtof1896,withtheconsequentfamineandplaguethatdevastatedIndiathefollowingwinter,wasthuspredictedsomemonthsinadvance。
Thisisthegreatestpresenttriumphofpracticalmeteorology。
Nothinglikeitisyetpossibleanywhereintemperatezones。Butnoonecansaywhatmaynotbepossibleintimestocome,whenthedatanowbeinggatheredallovertheworldshallatlastbeco-ordinated,classified,andmadethebasisofbroadinductions。
Meteorologyispre-eminentlyascienceofthefuture。
VI
MODERNTHEORIESOFHEATANDLIGHT
THEeighteenth-centuryphilosophermadegreatstridesinhisstudiesofthephysicalpropertiesofmatterandtheapplicationofthesepropertiesinmechanics,asthesteam-engine,theballoon,theoptictelegraph,thespinning-jenny,thecotton-gin,thechronometer,theperfectedcompass,theLeydenjar,thelightning-rod,andahostofminorinventionstestify。
Inaspeculativewayhehadthoughtoutmoreorlesstenableconceptionsastotheultimatenatureofmatter,aswitnessthetheoriesofLeibnitzandBoscovichandDavy,towhichwemayrecur。Buthehadnotasyetconceivedthenotionofadistinctionbetweenmatterandenergy,whichissofundamentaltothephysicsofalaterepoch。Hedidnotspeakofheat,light,electricity,asformsofenergyor"force";heconceivedthemassubtileformsofmatter——ashighlyattenuatedyettangiblefluids,subjecttogravitationandchemicalattraction;thoughhehadlearnedtomeasurenoneofthembutheatwithaccuracy,andthisonehecouldtestonlywithinnarrowlimitsuntillateinthecentury,whenJosiahWedgwood,thefamouspotter,taughthimtogaugethehighesttemperatureswiththeclaypyrometer。
Hespokeofthematterofheatasbeingthemostuniversallydistributedfluidinnature;asenteringinsomedegreeintothecompositionofnearlyallothersubstances;
asbeingsometimesliquid,sometimescondensedorsolid,andashavingweightthatcouldbedetectedwiththebalance。FollowingNewton,hespokeoflightasa"corpuscularemanation"orfluid,composedofshiningparticleswhichpossiblyaretransmutableintoparticlesofheat,andwhichenterintochemicalcombinationwiththeparticlesofotherformsofmatter。Electricityheconsideredastillmoresubtilekindofmatter-perhapsanattenuatedformoflight。Magnetism,"vitalfluid,"andbysomeevena"gravicfluid,"andafluidofsoundwereplacedinthesamescale;and,takentogether,allthesesupposedsubtileformsofmatterwereclassedas"imponderables。"
Thisviewofthenatureofthe"imponderables"wasinsomemeasurearetrogression,formanyseventeenth-
centuryphilosophers,notablyHookeandHuygensandBoyle,hadheldmorecorrectviews;butthematerialisticconceptionaccordedsowellwiththeeighteenth-
centurytendenciesofthoughtthatonlyhereandthereaphilosopherlikeEulercalleditinquestion,untilwellontowardsthecloseofthecentury。Currentspeechreferredtothematerialityofthe"imponderables"
unquestioningly。Studentsofmeteorology——asciencethatwasjustdawning——explainedatmosphericphenomenaonthesuppositionthatheat,theheaviestimponderable,predominatedintheloweratmosphere,andthatlight,electricity,andmagnetismprevailedinsuccessivelyhigherstrata。AndLavoisier,themostphilosophicalchemistofthecentury,retainedheatandlightonaparwithoxygen,hydrogen,iron,andtherest,inhislistofelementarysubstances。
COUNTRUMFORDANDTHEVIBRATORYTHEORYOFHEAT
ButjustatthecloseofthecenturytheconfidenceinthestatusoftheimponderableswasrudelyshakeninthemindsofphilosophersbytherevivaloftheoldideaofFraPaoloandBaconandBoyle,thatheat,atanyrate,isnotamaterialfluid,butmerelyamodeofmotionorvibrationamongtheparticlesof"ponderable"
matter。Thenewchampionoftheolddoctrineastothenatureofheatwasaverydistinguishedphilosopheranddiplomatistofthetime,who,itmaybeworthrecalling,wasanAmerican。HewasasadlyexpatriatedAmerican,itistrue,ashisname,givenalltheofficialappendages,willamplytestify;buthehadbeenbornandrearedinaMassachusettsvillagenonetheless,andheseemsalwaystohaveretainedakindlyinterestinthelandofhisnativity,eventhoughhelivedabroadintheserviceofotherpowersduringallthelateryearsofhislife,andwasknightedbyEngland,ennobledbyBavaria,andhonoredbythemostdistinguishedscientificbodiesofEurope。TheAmerican,then,whochampionedthevibratorytheoryofheat,inoppositiontoallcurrentopinion,inthisclosingeraoftheeighteenthcentury,wasLieutenant-GeneralSirBenjaminThompson,CountRumford,F。R。S。
Rumfordshowedthatheatmaybeproducedinindefinitequantitiesbyfrictionofbodiesthatdonotthemselvesloseanyappreciablematterintheprocess,andclaimedthatthisprovestheimmaterialityofheat。
Lateronheaddedforcetotheargumentbyproving,inrefutationoftheexperimentsofBowditch,thatnobodyeithergainsorlosesweightinvirtueofbeingheatedorcooled。Hethoughthehadprovedthatheatisonlyaformofmotion。
Hisexperimentforproducingindefinitequantitiesofheatbyfrictionisrecordedbyhiminhispaperentitled,"InquiryConcerningtheSourceofHeatExcitedbyFriction。"
"Beingengaged,lately,insuperintendingtheboringofcannonintheworkshopsofthemilitaryarsenalatMunich,"hesays,"Iwasstruckwiththeveryconsiderabledegreeofheatwhichabrassgunacquiresinashorttimeinbeingbored;andwiththestillmoreintenseheatmuchgreaterthanthatofboilingwater,asIfoundbyexperimentofthemetallicchipsseparatedfromitbytheborer。
"Takingacannonabrasssix-pounder,castsolid,andrough,asitcamefromthefoundry,andfixingithorizontallyinamachineusedforboring,andatthesametimefinishingtheoutsideofthecannonbyturning,Icauseditsextremitytobecutoff;andbyturningdownthemetalinthatpart,asolidcylinderwasformed,73/4inchesindiameterand98/10incheslong;
which,whenfinished,remainedjoinedtotherestofthemetalthatwhich,properlyspeaking,constitutedthecannonbyasmallcylindricalneck,only21/5inchesindiameterand38/10incheslong。
"Thisshortcylinder,whichwassupportedinitshorizontalposition,andturnedrounditsaxisbymeansoftheneckbywhichitremainedunitedtothecannon,wasnowboredwiththehorizontalborerusedinboringcannon。
"Thiscylinderbeingdesignedfortheexpresspurposeofgeneratingheatbyfriction,byhavingabluntborerforcedagainstitssolidbottomatthesametimethatitshouldbeturnedrounditsaxisbytheforceofhorses,inorderthattheheataccumulatedinthecylindermightfromtimetotimebemeasured,asmall,roundhole0。37ofaninchonlyindiameterand4。2
inchesindepth,forthepurposeofintroducingasmallcylindricalmercurialthermometer,wasmadeinit,ononeside,inadirectionperpendiculartotheaxisofthecylinder,andendinginthemiddleofthesolidpartofthemetalwhichformedthebottomofthebore。
"Atthebeginningoftheexperiment,thetemperatureoftheairintheshade,asalsointhecylinder,wasjustsixtydegreesFahrenheit。Attheendofthirtyminutes,whenthecylinderhadmade960revolutionsaboutitsaxis,thehorsesbeingstopped,acylindricalmercurythermometer,whosebulbwas32/100ofaninchindiameterand31/4inchesinlength,wasintroducedintotheholemadetoreceiveitinthesideofthecylinder,whenthemercuryrosealmostinstantlytoonehundredandthirtydegrees。
"Inorder,byonedecisiveexperiment,todeterminewhethertheairoftheatmospherehadanypartornotinthegenerationoftheheat,Icontrivedtorepeattheexperimentundercircumstancesinwhichitwasevidentlyimpossibleforittoproduceanyeffectwhatever。
Bymeansofapistonexactlyfittedtothemouthoftheboreofthecylinder,throughthemiddleofwhichpistonthesquareironbar,totheendofwhichthebluntsteelborerwasfixed,passedinasquareholemadeperfectlyair-tight,theexcessoftheexternalair,totheinsideoftheboreofthecylinder,waseffectuallyprevented。
Ididnotfind,however,bythisexperimentthattheexclusionoftheairdiminishedinthesmallestdegreethequantityofheatexcitedbythefriction。
"Therestillremainedonedoubt,which,thoughitappearedtometobesoslightashardlytodeserveanyattention,Iwas,however,desiroustoremove。Thepistonwhichchokedthemouthoftheboreofthecylinder,inorderthatitmightbeair-tight,wasfittedintoitwithsomuchnicety,bymeansofitscollarsofleather,andpressedagainstitwithsomuchforce,that,notwithstandingitsbeingoiled,itoccasionedaconsiderabledegreeoffrictionwhenthehollowcylinderwasturnedrounditsaxis。Wasnottheheatproduced,oratleastsomepartofit,occasionedbythisfrictionofthepiston?and,astheexternalairhadfreeaccesstotheextremityofthebore,whereitcameintocontactwiththepiston,isitnotpossiblethatthisairmayhavehadsomeshareinthegenerationoftheheatproduced?
"Aquadrangularoblongdealbox,water-tight,beingprovidedwithholesorslitsinthemiddleofeachofitsends,justlargeenoughtoreceive,theonethesquareironrodtotheendofwhichthebluntsteelborerwasfastened,theotherthesmallcylindricalneckwhichjoinedthehollowcylindertothecannon;whenthisboxwhichwasoccasionallyclosedabovebyawoodencoverorlidmovingonhingeswasputintoitsplace——
thatistosay,when,bymeansofthetwoverticalopeningorslitsinitstwoends,theboxwasfixedtothemachineryinsuchamannerthatitsbottombeingintheplaneofthehorizon,itsaxiscoincidedwiththeaxisofthehollowmetalliccylinder,itisevident,fromthedescription,thatthehollow,metalliccylinderwouldoccupythemiddleofthebox,withouttouchingitoneitherside;andthat,onpouringwaterintotheboxandfillingittothebrim,thecylinderwouldbecompletelycoveredandsurroundedoneverysidebythatfluid。And,further,astheboxwasheldfastbythestrong,squareironrodwhichpassedinasquareholeinthecentreofoneofitsends,whiletheroundorcylindricalneckwhichjoinedthehollowcylindertotheendofthecannoncouldturnroundfreelyonitsaxisintheroundholeinthecentreoftheotherendofit,itisevidentthatthemachinerycouldbeputinmotionwithouttheleastdangerofforcingtheboxoutofitsplace,throwingthewateroutofit,orderanginganypartoftheapparatus。"
Everythingbeingthusready,theboxwasfilledwithcoldwater,havingbeenmadewater-tightbymeansofleathercollars,andthemachineryputinmotion。
"Theresultofthisbeautifulexperiment,"saysRumford,"wasverystriking,andthepleasureitaffordedmeamplyrepaidmeforallthetroubleIhadhadincontrivingandarrangingthecomplicatedmachineryusedinmakingit。Thecylinder,revolvingattherateofthirty-twotimesinaminute,hadbeeninmotionbutashorttimewhenIperceived,byputtingmyhandintothewaterandtouchingtheoutsideofthecylinder,thatheatwasgenerated,anditwasnotlongbeforethewaterwhichsurroundedthecylinderbegantobesensiblywarm。
"AttheendofonehourIfound,byplungingathermometerintothebox,……thatitstemperaturehadbeenraisednolessthanforty-sevendegreesFahrenheit,beingnowonehundredandsevendegreesFahrenheit……Onehourandthirtyminutesafterthemachineryhadbeenputinmotiontheheatofthewaterintheboxwasonehundredandforty-twodegrees。Attheendoftwohours……itwasraisedtoonehundredandseventy-eightdegrees;andattwohoursandthirtyminutesitACTUALLYBOILED!
"Itwouldbedifficulttodescribethesurpriseandastonishmentexpressedinthecountenancesofthebystandersonseeingsolargeaquantityofcoldwaterheated,andactuallymadetoboil,withoutanyfire。
Thoughtherewas,infact,nothingthatcouldjustlybeconsideredasasurpriseinthisevent,yetIacknowledgefairlythatitaffordedmeadegreeofchildishpleasurewhich,wereIambitiousofthereputationofaGRAVEPHILOSOPHER,Ioughtmostcertainlyrathertohidethantodiscover……"
Havingthusdweltindetailontheseexperiments,Rumfordcomesnowtotheall-importantdiscussionastothesignificanceofthem——thesubjectthathadbeenthesourceofsomuchspeculationamongthephilosophers——
thequestionastowhatheatreallyis,andiftherereallyisanysuchthingasmanybelievedasanigneousfluid,orasomethingcalledcaloric。
"Fromwhencecamethisheatwhichwascontinuallygivenoffinthismanner,intheforegoingexperiments?"
asksRumford。"Wasitfurnishedbythesmallparticlesofmetaldetachedfromthelargersolidmassesontheirbeingrubbedtogether?This,aswehavealreadyseen,couldnotpossiblyhavebeenthecase。
"Wasitfurnishedbytheair?Thiscouldnothavebeenthecase;for,inthreeoftheexperiments,themachinerybeingkeptimmersedinwater,theaccessoftheairoftheatmospherewascompletelyprevented。
"Wasitfurnishedbythewaterwhichsurroundedthemachinery?Thatthiscouldnothavebeenthecaseisevident:first,becausethiswaterwascontinuallyRECEIVINGheatfromthemachinery,andcouldnot,atthesametime,beGIVINGTOandRECEIVINGHEATFROMthesamebody;and,secondly,becausetherewasnochemicaldecompositionofanypartofthiswater。Hadanysuchdecompositiontakenplacewhich,indeed,couldnotreasonablyhavebeenexpected,oneofitscomponentelasticfluidsmostprobablyhydrogenmust,atthesametime,havebeensetatliberty,and,inmakingitsescapeintotheatmosphere,wouldhavebeendetected;
but,thoughIfrequentlyexaminedthewatertoseeifanyair-bubblesroseupthroughit,andhadevenmadepreparationsforcatchingthemiftheyshouldappear,Icouldperceivenone;norwasthereanysignofdecompositionofanykindwhatever,orotherchemicalprocess,goingoninthewater。
"Isitpossiblethattheheatcouldhavebeensuppliedbymeansoftheironbartotheendofwhichthebluntsteelborerwasfixed?Orbythesmallneckofgun-metalbywhichthehollowcylinderwasunitedtothecannon?Thesesuppositionsseemmoreimprobableeventhaneitherofthebefore-mentioned;forheatwascontinuallygoingoff,orOUTOFTHEMACHINERY,byboththesepassagesduringthewholetimetheexperimentlasted。
"Andinreasoningonthissubjectwemustnotforgettoconsiderthatmostremarkablecircumstance,thatthesourceoftheheatgeneratedbyfrictionintheseexperimentsappearedevidentlytobeINEXHAUSTIBLE。
"ItishardlynecessarytoaddthatanythingwhichanyINSULATEDbody,orsystemofbodies,cancontinuetofurnishWITHOUTLIMITATIONcannotpossiblybeaMATERIAL
substance;anditappearstometobeextremelydifficult,ifnotquiteimpossible,toformanydistinctideaofanythingcapableofbeingexcitedandcommunicated,inthemannertheheatwasexcitedandcommunicatedintheseexperiments,exceptinMOTION。"[1]
THOMASYOUNGANDTHEWAVETHEORYOFLIGHT
Butcontemporaryjudgment,whileitlistenedrespectfullytoRumford,waslittlemindedtoaccepthisverdict。Thecherishedbeliefsofagenerationarenottobeputdownwithasingleblow。Wheremanymindshaveasimilardrift,however,thefirstblowmayprecipitateageneralconflict;andsoitwashere。YoungHumphryDavyhadduplicatedRumford’sexperiments,andreachedsimilarconclusions;andsoonothersfellintoline。Then,in1800,Dr。ThomasYoung——
"PhenomenonYoung"theycalledhimatCambridge,becausehewasreputedtoknoweverything——tookupthecudgelsforthevibratorytheoryoflight,anditbegantobeclearthatthetwo"imponderables,"heatandlight,muststandorfalltogether;butnooneasyetmadeaclaimagainstthefluidityofelectricity。
BeforewetakeupthedetailsoftheassaultmadebyYoungupontheolddoctrineofthematerialityoflight,wemustpausetoconsiderthepersonalityofYounghimself。ForitchancedthatthisQuakerphysicianwasoneofthoseprodigieswhocomebutfewtimesinacentury,andthefulllistofwhomintherecordsofhistorycouldbetoldonone’sthumbsandfingers。Hisbiographerstellusthingsabouthimthatreadlikethemostpatentfairy-tales。Asamereinfantinarmshehadbeenabletoreadfluently。BeforehisfourthbirthdaycamehehadreadtheBibletwicethrough,aswellasWatts’sHymns——poorchild!——andwhensevenoreighthehadshownapropensitytoabsorblanguagesmuchasotherchildrenabsorbnurserytattleandMotherGooserhymes。Whenhewasfourteen,ayoungladyvisitingthehouseholdofhistutorpatronizedtheprettyboybyaskingtoseeaspecimenofhispenmanship。
Theprettyboycompliedreadilyenough,andmildlyrebukedhisinterrogatorbyrapidlywritingsomesentencesforherinfourteenlanguages,includingsuchas,Arabian,Persian,andEthiopic。
Meantimelanguageshadbeenbutanincidentintheeducationofthelad。Heseemstohaveenteredeveryavailablefieldofthought——mathematics,physics,botany,literature,music,painting,languages,philosophy,archaeology,andsoontotiresomelengths——andoncehehadenteredanyfieldheseldomturnedasideuntilhehadreachedtheconfinesofthesubjectasthenknownandaddedsomethingnewfromtherecessesofhisowngenius。HewasasversatileasPriestley,asprofoundasNewtonhimself。Hehadtherangeofameredilettante,buteverywherethefullgraspofthemaster。Hetookearlyforhismottothesayingthatwhatonemanhasdone,anothermanmaydo。GrantingthattheothermanhasthebrainofaThomasYoung,itisatruemotto。
Such,then,wastheyoungQuakerwhocametoLondontofollowoutthehumdrumlifeofapractitionerofmedicineintheyear1801。ButincidentallytheyoungphysicianwasprevailedupontooccupytheinterimsofearlypracticebyfulfillingthedutiesofthechairofNaturalPhilosophyattheRoyalInstitution,whichCountRumfordhadfounded,andofwhichDavywasthenProfessorofChemistry——theinstitutionwhoseglorieshavebeenperpetuatedbysuchnamesasFaradayandTyndall,andwhichtheBritonofto-dayspeaksofasthe"PantheonofScience。"HereitwasthatThomasYoungmadethosestudieswhichhaveinsuredhimanicheinthetempleoffamenotfarremovedfromthatofIsaacNewton。
Asearlyas1793,whenhewasonlytwenty,YounghadbeguntoCommunicatepaperstotheRoyalSocietyofLondon,whichwereadjudgedworthytobeprintedinfullinthePhilosophicalTransactions;soitisnotstrangethatheshouldhavebeenaskedtodelivertheBakerianlecturebeforethatlearnedbodytheveryfirstyearafterhecametoLondon。ThelecturewasdeliveredNovember12,1801。Itssubjectwas"TheTheoryofLightandColors,"anditsreadingmarksanepochinphysicalscience;forherewasbroughtforwardforthefirsttimeconvincingproofofthatundulatorytheoryoflightwithwhicheverystudentofmodernphysicsisfamiliar——thetheorywhichholdsthatlightisnotacorporealentity,butamerepulsationinthesubstanceofanall-pervadingether,justassoundisapulsationintheair,orinliquidsorsolids。
Younghad,indeed,advocatedthistheoryatanearlierdate,butitwasnotuntil1801thathehitupontheideawhichenabledhimtobringittoanythingapproachingademonstration。Itwaswhileponderingoverthefamiliarbutpuzzlingphenomenaofcoloredringsintowhichwhitelightisbrokenwhenreflectedfromthinfilms——Newton’srings,socalled——thatanexplanationoccurredtohimwhichatonceputtheentireundulatorytheoryonanewfooting。Withthatsagacityofinsightwhichwecallgenius,hesawofasuddenthatthephenomenacouldbeexplainedbysupposingthatwhenraysoflightfallonathinglass,partoftheraysbeingreflectedfromtheuppersurface,otherrays,reflectedfromthelowersurface,mightbesoretardedintheircoursethroughtheglassthatthetwosetswouldinterferewithoneanother,theforwardpulsationofoneraycorrespondingtothebackwardpulsationofanother,thusquiteneutralizingtheeffect。
Someofthecomponentpulsationsofthelightbeingthuseffacedbymutualinterference,theremainingrayswouldnolongergivetheopticaleffectofwhitelight;hencethepuzzlingcolors。
HereisYoung’sexpositionofthesubject:
OftheColorsofThinPlates"Whenabeamoflightfallsupontworefractingsurfaces,thepartialreflectionscoincideperfectlyindirection;andinthiscasetheintervalofretardationtakenbetweenthesurfacesistotheirradiusastwicethecosineoftheangleofrefractiontotheradius。
"Letthemediumbetweenthesurfacesberarerthanthesurroundingmediums;thentheimpulsereflectedatthesecondsurface,meetingasubsequentundulationatthefirst,willrendertheparticlesoftherarermediumcapableofwhollystoppingthemotionofthedenseranddestroyingthereflection,whiletheythemselveswillbemorestronglypropelledthaniftheyhadbeenatrest,andthetransmittedlightwillbeincreased。
Sothatthecolorsbyreflectionwillbedestroyed,andthosebytransmissionrenderedmorevivid,whenthedoublethicknessorintervalsofretardationareanymultiplesofthewholebreadthoftheundulations;andatintermediatethicknessestheeffectswillbereversedaccordingtotheNewtonianobservation。
"Ifthesameproportionsbefoundtoholdgoodwithrespecttothinplatesofadensermedium,whichis,indeed,notimprobable,itwillbenecessarytoadopttheconnecteddemonstrationsofProp。IV。,but,atanyrate,ifathinplatebeinterposedbetweenararerandadensermedium,thecolorsbyreflectionandtransmissionmaybeexpectedtochangeplaces。
OftheColorsofThickPlates"Whenabeamoflightpassesthrougharefractingsurface,especiallyifimperfectlypolished,aportionofitisirregularlyscattered,andmakesthesurfacevisibleinalldirections,butmostconspicuouslyindirectionsnotfardistantfromthatofthelightitself;andifareflectingsurfacebeplacedparalleltotherefractingsurface,thisscatteredlight,aswellastheprincipalbeam,willbereflected,andtherewillbealsoanewdissipationoflight,atthereturnofthebeamthroughtherefractingsurface。Thesetwoportionsofscatteredlightwillcoincideindirection;andifthesurfacesbeofsuchaformastocollectthesimilareffects,willexhibitringsofcolors。Theintervalofretardationisherethedifferencebetweenthepathsoftheprincipalbeamandofthescatteredlightbetweenthetwosurfaces;
ofcourse,wherevertheinclinationofthescatteredlightisequaltothatofthebeam,althoughindifferentplanes,theintervalwillvanishandalltheundulationswillconspire。Atotherinclinations,theintervalwillbethedifferenceofthesecantsfromthesecantoftheinclination,orangleofrefractionoftheprincipalbeam。Fromthesecauses,allthecolorsofconcavemirrorsobservedbyNewtonandothersarenecessaryconsequences;anditappearsthattheirproduction,thoughsomewhatsimilar,isbynomeansasNewtonimagined,identicalwiththeproductionofthinplates。"[2]
Byfollowingupthisclewwithmathematicalprecision,measuringtheexactthicknessoftheplateandthespacebetweenthedifferentringsofcolor,Youngwasabletoshowmathematicallywhatmustbethelengthofpulsationforeachofthedifferentcolorsofthespectrum。Heestimatedthattheundulationsofredlight,attheextremelowerendofthevisiblespectrum,mustnumberaboutthirty-seventhousandsixhundredandfortytotheinch,andpassanygivenspotatarateoffourhundredandsixty-threemillionsofmillionsofundulationsinasecond,whiletheextremevioletnumbersfifty-ninethousandsevenhundredandfiftyundulationstotheinch,orsevenhundredandthirty-fivemillionsofmillionstothesecond。
TheColorsofStriatedSurfacesYoungsimilarlyexaminedthecolorsthatareproducedbyscratchesonasmoothsurface,inparticulartestingthelightfrom"Mr。Coventry’sexquisitemicrometers,"
whichconsistoflinesscratchedonglassatmeasuredintervals。Thesemicroscopictestsbroughtthesameresultsastheotherexperiments。Thecolorswereproducedatcertaindefiniteandmeasurableangles,andthetheoryofinterferenceofundulationsexplainedthemperfectly,while,asYoungaffirmedwithconfidence,nootherhypothesishithertoadvancedwouldexplainthematall。Herearehiswords:
"Lettherebeinagivenplanetworeflectingpointsveryneareachother,andlettheplanebesosituatedthatthereflectedimageofaluminousobjectseeninitmayappeartocoincidewiththepoints;thenitisobviousthatthelengthoftheincidentandreflectedray,takentogether,isequalwithrespecttobothpoints,consideringthemascapableofreflectinginalldirections。
Letoneofthepointsbenowdepressedbelowthegivenplane;thenthewholepathofthelightreflectedfromitwillbelengthenedbyalinewhichistothedepressionofthepointastwicethecosineofincidencetotheradius。
"If,therefore,equalundulationsofgivendimensionsbereflectedfromtwopoints,situatednearenoughtoappeartotheeyebutasone,wheneverthislineisequaltohalfthebreadthofawholeundulationthereflectionfromthedepressedpointwillsointerferewiththereflectionfromthefixedpointthattheprogressivemotionoftheonewillcoincidewiththeretrogrademotionoftheother,andtheywillbothbedestroyed;butwhenthislineisequaltothewholebreadthofanundulation,theeffectwillbedoubled,andwhentoabreadthandahalf,againdestroyed;andthusforaconsiderablenumberofalternations,andifthereflectedundulationsbeofadifferentkind,theywillbevariouslyaffected,accordingtotheirproportionstothevariouslengthofthelinewhichisthedifferencebetweenthelengthsoftheirtwopaths,andwhichmaybedenominatedtheintervalofaretardation。
"Inorderthattheeffectmaybethemoreperceptible,anumberofpairsofpointsmustbeunitedintotwoparallellines;andifseveralsuchpairsoflinesbeplacedneareachother,theywillfacilitatetheobservation。Ifoneofthelinesbemadetorevolveroundtheotherasanaxis,thedepressionbelowthegivenplanewillbeasthesineoftheinclination;andwhiletheeyeandtheluminousobjectremainfixedthedifferenceofthelengthofthepathswillvaryasthissine。
"ThebestsubjectsfortheexperimentareMr。Coventry’sexquisitemicrometers;suchofthemasconsistofparallellinesdrawnonglass,atadistanceofone-
five-hundredthofaninch,arethemostconvenient。
Eachoftheselinesappearsunderamicroscopetoconsistoftwoormorefinerlines,exactlyparallel,andatadistanceofsomewhatmorethanatwentiethmorethantheadjacentlines。Iplacedoneofthesesoastoreflectthesun’slightatanangleofforty-fivedegrees,andfixeditinsuchamannerthatwhileitrevolvedroundoneofthelinesasanaxis,Icouldmeasureitsangularmotion;Ifoundthatthelongestredcoloroccurredattheinclination101/4degrees,203/4degrees,32
degrees,and45degrees;ofwhichthesinesareasthenumbers1,2,3,and4。Atallotheranglesalso,whenthesun’slightwasreflectedfromthesurface,thecolorvanishedwiththeinclination,andwasequalatequalinclinationsoneitherside。
Thisexperimentaffordsaverystrongconfirmationofthetheory。Itisimpossibletodeduceanyexplanationofitfromanyhypothesishithertoadvanced;
andIbelieveitwouldbedifficulttoinventanyotherthatwouldaccountforit。Thereisastrikinganalogybetweenthisseparationofcolorsandtheproductionofamusicalnotebysuccessiveechoesfromequidistantironpalisades,whichIhavefoundtocorrespondprettyaccuratelywiththeknownvelocityofsoundandthedistancesofthesurfaces。
"Itisnotimprobablethatthecolorsoftheintegumentsofsomeinsects,andofsomeothernaturalbodies,exhibitingindifferentlightsthemostbeautifulversatility,maybefoundtobeofthisdescription,andnottobederivedfromthinplates。Insomecasesasinglescratchorfurrowmayproducesimilareffects,bythereflectionofitsoppositeedges。"[3]
ThisdoctrineofinterferenceofundulationswastheabsolutelynovelpartofYoung’stheory。Theall-
compassinggeniusofRobertHookehad,indeed,verynearlyapprehendeditmorethanacenturybefore,asYounghimselfpointsout,butnooneelsebadsomuchasvaguelyconceivedit;andevenwiththesagaciousHookeitwasonlyahappyguess,neverdistinctlyoutlinedinhisownmind,andutterlyignoredbyallothers。
YoungdidnotknowofHooke’sguessuntilhehimselfhadfullyformulatedthetheory,buthehastenedthentogivehispredecessorallthecreditthatcouldpossiblybeadjudgedhisduebythemostdisinterestedobserver。
ToHooke’scontemporary,Huygens,whowastheoriginatorofthegeneraldoctrineofundulationastheexplanationoflight,Youngrendersfulljusticealso。
Forhimselfheclaimsonlythemeritofhavingdemonstratedthetheorywhichtheseandafewothersofhispredecessorshadadvocatedwithoutfullproof。
ThefollowingyearDr。YoungdetailedbeforetheRoyalSocietyotherexperiments,whichthrewadditionallightonthedoctrineofinterference;andin1803
hecitedstillothers,which,heaffirmed,broughtthedoctrinetocompletedemonstration。Inapplyingthisdemonstrationtothegeneraltheoryoflight,hemadethestrikingsuggestionthat"theluminiferousetherpervadesthesubstanceofallmaterialbodieswithlittleornoresistance,asfreely,perhaps,asthewindpassesthroughagroveoftrees。"HeassertedhisbeliefalsothatthechemicalrayswhichRitterhaddiscoveredbeyondthevioletendofthevisiblespectrumarebutstillmorerapidundulationsofthesamecharacterasthosewhichproducelight。InhisearlierlecturehehadaffirmedalikeaffinitybetweenthelightraysandtheraysofradiantheatwhichHerscheldetectedbelowtheredendofthespectrum,suggestingthat"lightdiffersfromheatonlyinthefrequencyofitsundulationsorvibrations——thoseundulationswhicharewithincertainlimitswithrespecttofrequencyaffectingtheopticnerveandconstitutinglight,andthosewhichareslowerandprobablystrongerconstitutingheatonly。"Fromtheveryoutsethehadrecognizedtheaffinitybetweensoundandlight;indeed,ithadbeenthisaffinitythatledhimontoanappreciationoftheundulatorytheoryoflight。
Butwhilealltheseaffinitiesseemedsocleartothegreatco-ordinatingbrainofYoung,theymadenosuchimpressiononthemindsofhiscontemporaries。Theimmaterialityoflighthadbeensubstantiallydemonstrated,butpracticallynoonesaveitsauthoracceptedthedemonstration。Newton’sdoctrineoftheemissionofcorpuscleswastoofirmlyrootedtobereadilydislodged,andDr。Younghadtoomanyotherintereststocontinuetheassaultunceasingly。Heoccasionallywrotesomethingtouchingonhistheory,mostlypaperscontributedtotheQuarterlyReviewandsimilarperiodicals,anonymouslyorunderpseudonym,forhehadconceivedthenotionthattoogreatconspicuousnessinfieldsoutsideofmedicinewouldinjurehispracticeasaphysician。HisviewsregardinglightincludingtheoriginalpapersfromthePhilosophicalTransactionsoftheRoyalSocietywereagaingivenpublicityinfullinhiscelebratedvolumeonnaturalphilosophy,consistinginpartofhislecturesbeforetheRoyalInstitution,publishedin1807;buteventhentheyfailedtobringconvictiontothephilosophicworld。Indeed,theydidnotevenarouseacontroversialspirit,ashisfirstpapershaddone。
ARAGOANDFRESNELCHAMPIONTHEWAVETHEORY
Soitchancedthatwhen,in1815,ayoungFrenchmilitaryengineer,namedAugustinJeanFresnel,returningfromtheNapoleonicwars,becameinterestedinthephenomenaoflight,andmadesomeexperimentsconcerningdiffractionwhichseemedtohimtocontroverttheacceptednotionsofthematerialityoflight,hewasquiteunawarethathisexperimentshadbeenanticipatedbyaphilosopheracrosstheChannel。HecommunicatedhisexperimentsandresultstotheFrenchInstitute,supposingthemtobeabsolutelynovel。Thatbodyreferredthemtoacommittee,ofwhich,asgoodfortunewouldhaveit,thedominatingmemberwasDominiqueFrancoisArago,amanasversatileasYounghimself,andhardlylessprofound,ifperhapsnotquitesooriginal。AragoatoncerecognizedthemeritofFresnel’swork,andsoonbecameaconverttothetheory。HetoldFresnelthatYounghadanticipatedhimasregardsthegeneraltheory,butthatmuchremainedtobedone,andheofferedtoassociatehimselfwithFresnelinprosecutingtheinvestigation。
Fresnelwasnotalittledashedtolearnthathisoriginalideashadbeenworkedoutbyanotherwhilehewasalad,buthebowedgracefullytothesituationandwentaheadwithunabatedzeal。
ThechampionshipofAragoinsuredtheundulatorytheoryahearingbeforetheFrenchInstitute,butbynomeanssufficedtobringaboutitsgeneralacceptance。
Onthecontrary,abitterfeudensued,inwhichAragowasopposedbythe"JupiterOlympusoftheAcademy,"
Laplace,bytheonlylessfamousPoisson,andbytheyoungerbuthardlylessableBiot。Sobitterlyragedthefeudthatalife-longfriendshipbetweenAragoandBiotwasrupturedforever。TheoppositionmanagedtodelaythepublicationofFresnel’spapers,butAragocontinuedtofightwithhiscustomaryenthusiasmandpertinacity,andatlast,in1823,theAcademyyielded,andvotedFresnelintoitsranks,thusimplicitlyadmittingthevalueofhiswork。
Itisahumiliatingthoughtthatsuchcontroversiesasthismustmartheprogressofscientifictruth;butfortunatelythestoryoftheintroductionoftheundulatorytheoryhasamorepleasantside。Threemen,greatbothincharacterandinintellect,wereconcernedinpressingitsclaims——Young,Fresnel,andArago——andtherelationsofthesemenformapictureunmarredbyanyofthosepettyjealousiesthatsooftendimthelustreofgreatnames。FresnelfreelyacknowledgedYoung’sprioritysosoonashisattentionwascalledtoit;andYoungapplaudedtheworkoftheFrenchman,andaidedwithhiscounselintheapplicationoftheundulatorytheorytotheproblemsofpolarizationoflight,whichstilldemandedexplanation,andwhichFresnel’sfertilityofexperimentalresourceandprofundityofmathematicalinsightsufficedintheendtoconquer。
AfterFresnel’sadmissiontotheInstitutein1823
theoppositionweakened,andgraduallythephilosopherscametorealizethemeritsofatheorywhichYounghadvainlycalledtotheirattentionafullquarter-
centurybefore。Now,thankslargelytoArago,bothYoungandFresnelreceivedtheirfullmeedofappreciation。
FresnelwasgiventheRumfordmedaloftheRoyalSocietyofEnglandin1825,andchosenoneoftheforeignmembersofthesocietytwoyearslater,whileYounginturnwaselectedoneoftheeightforeignmembersoftheFrenchAcademy。Asafittingculminationofthechapteroffelicitiesbetweenthethreefriends,itfelltothelotofYoung,asForeignSecretaryoftheRoyalSociety,tonotifyFresnelofthehonorsshownhimbyEngland’srepresentativebodyofscientists;
whileArago,asPerpetualSecretaryoftheFrenchInstitute,conveyedtoYounginthesameyearthenotificationthathehadbeensimilarlyhonoredbythesavantsofFrance。
AfewmonthslaterFresnelwasdead,andYoungsurvivedhimonlytwoyears。Bothdiedprematurely,buttheirgreatworkwasdone,andtheworldwillrememberalwaysandlinktogetherthesetwonamesinconnectionwithatheorywhichinitsimplicationsandimportancerankslittlebelowthetheoryofuniversalgravitation。
VII。THEMODERNDEVELOPMENTOFELECTRICITYANDMAGNETISM
GALVANIANDVOLTA
ThefullimportanceofYoung’sstudiesoflightmightperhapshavegainedearlierrecognitionhaditnotchancedthat,atthetimewhentheyweremade,theattentionofthephilosophicworldwasturnedwiththefixityandfascinationofahypnoticstareuponanotherfield,whichforatimebrookednorival。
Howcouldtheold,familiarphenomenon,light,interestanyonewhenthenewagent,galvanism,wasinview?
Aswellaskonetofixattentiononastarwhileameteoriteblazesacrossthesky。
GalvanismwassocalledpreciselyastheRoentgenraywaschristenedatalaterday——asasafemeansofbeggingthequestionastothenatureofthephenomenainvolved。TheinitialfactingalvanismwasthediscoveryofLuigiGalvani1737-1798,aphysicianofBologna,in1791,thatbybringingmetalsincontactwiththenervesofafrog’slegviolentmuscularcontractionsareproduced。Asthissimplelittleexperimentledeventuallytothediscoveryofgalvanicelectricityandtheinventionofthegalvanicbattery,itmayberegardedasthebeginningofmodernelectricity。
ThestoryistoldthatGalvaniwasledtohisdiscoverywhilepreparingfrogs’legstomakeabrothforhisinvalidwife。Asthestoryruns,hehadremovedtheskinsfromseveralfrogs’legs,when,happeningtotouchtheexposedmuscleswithascalpelwhichhadlainincloseproximitytoanelectricalmachine,violentmuscularactionwasproduced。Impressedwiththisphenomenon,hebeganaseriesofexperimentswhichfinallyresultedinhisgreatdiscovery。Butbethisstoryauthenticornot,itiscertainthatGalvaniexperimentedforseveralyearsuponfrogs’legssuspendeduponwiresandhooks,untilhefinallyconstructedhisarcoftwodifferentmetals,which,whenarrangedsothatonewasplacedincontactwithanerveandtheotherwithamuscle,producedviolentcontractions。
Thesetwopiecesofmetalformthebasicprincipleofthemoderngalvanicbattery,andleddirectlytoAlessandroVolta’sinventionofhis"voltaicpile,"theimmediateancestorofthemoderngalvanicbattery。
Volta’sexperimentswerecarriedonatthesametimeasthoseofGalvani,andhisinventionofhispilefollowedcloseuponGalvani’sdiscoveryofthenewformofelectricity。Fromthesefactsthenewformofelectricitywassometimescalled"galvanic"andsometimes"voltaic"electricity,butinrecentyearstheterm"galvanism"and"galvaniccurrent"havealmostentirelysupplantedtheuseofthetermvoltaic。
ItwasVoltawhomadethereportofGalvani’swonderfuldiscoverytotheRoyalSocietyofLondon,readonJanuary31,1793。InthisletterhedescribesGalvani’sexperimentsindetailandreferstotheminglowingtermsofpraise。Hecallsitoneofthe"mostbeautifulandimportantdiscoveries,"andregardeditasthegermorfoundationuponwhichotherdiscoveriesweretobemade。Thepredictionprovedentirelycorrect,Voltahimselfbeingthechiefdiscoverer。
WorkingalonglinessuggestedbyGalvani’sdiscovery,Voltaconstructedanapparatusmadeupofanumberofdisksoftwodifferentkindsofmetal,suchastinandsilver,arrangedalternately,apieceofsomemoist,poroussubstance,likepaperorfelt,beinginterposedbetweeneachpairofdisks。Withthis"pile,"
asitwascalled,electricitywasgenerated,andbylinkingtogetherseveralsuchpilesanelectricbatterycouldbeformed。
Thisinventiontooktheworldbystorm。NothingliketheenthusiasmitcreatedinthephilosophicworldhadbeenknownsincetheinventionoftheLeydenjar,morethanhalfacenturybefore。WithinafewweeksafterVolta’sannouncement,batteriesmadeaccordingtohisplanwerebeingexperimentedwithineveryimportantlaboratoryinEurope。
Asthecenturyclosed,halfthephilosophicworldwasspeculatingastowhether"galvanicinfluence"
wereanewimponderable,oronlyaformofelectricity;
andtheotherhalfwaseagerlyseekingtodiscoverwhatnewmarvelsthebatterymightreveal。Theleastimaginativemancouldseethatherewasaninventionthatwouldbeepoch-making,butthemostvisionarydreamercouldnotevenvaguelyadumbratetherealmeasureofitsimportance。
Itwasevidentatoncethatalmostanyformofgalvanicbattery,despiteimperfections,wasamoresatisfactoryinstrumentforgeneratingelectricitythanthefrictionalmachinehithertoinuse,theadvantagelyinginthefactthatthecurrentfromthegalvanicbatterycouldbecontrolledpracticallyatwill,andthattheapparatusitselfwasinexpensiveandrequiredcomparativelylittleattention。Theseadvantagesweresoonmadeapparentbythepracticalapplicationoftheelectriccurrentinseveralfields。
ItwillberecalledthatdespitetheenergeticendeavorsofsuchphilosophersasWatson,Franklin,Galvani,andmanyothers,thefieldofpracticalapplicationofelectricitywasverylimitedatthecloseoftheeighteenthcentury。Thelightning-rodhadcomeintogeneraluse,tobesure,anditsvalueasaninventioncanhardlybeoverestimated。Butwhileitwastheresultofextensiveelectricaldiscoveries,andisamostpracticalinstrument,itcanhardlybecalledonethatputselectricitytopracticaluse,butsimplyactsasameansofwardingofftheevileffectsofanaturalmanifestationofelectricity。Theinvention,however,hadalltheeffectsofamechanismwhichturnedelectricitytopracticalaccount。Butwiththeadventofthenewkindofelectricitytheageofpracticalapplicationbegan。
第19章