Thepicturerepresentsafieldwhichisbeingdeeplytilledbyanimplement,andthewholesomeair,theassociatedideaofhardwork,andthebluish-
blackclodsofearthmakeapleasantimpressiononhim。Hethengoesonandseesaworkoneducationlyingopen……andissurprisedthatsomuchattentionisdevotedinittothesexualfeelingsofchildren,whichmakeshimthinkofme。
Hereisaprettywater-dreamofafemalepatient,whichwasturnedtospecialaccountinthecourseoftreatment。
Atherusualholidayresortonthe……Lake,sheflingsherselfintothedarkwaterataplacewherethepalemoonisreflectedinthewater。
Dreamsofthissortareparturitiondreams;theirinterpretationiseffectedbyreversingthefactrecordedinthemanifestdream-content;
thus,insteadofflingingoneselfintothewater,readcomingoutofthewater-thatis,beingborn。*TheplacefromwhichoneisbornmayberecognizedifonethinksofthehumoroussenseoftheFrenchlalune。Thepalemoonthusbecomesthewhitebottom,whichthechildsoonguessestobetheplacefromwhichitcame。Nowwhatcanbethemeaningofthepatient’swishingtobebornataholidayresort?Iaskedthedreamerthis,andsherepliedwithouthesitation:"Hasn’tthetreatmentmademeasthoughIwerebornagain?"Thusthedreambecomesaninvitationtocontinuethetreatmentatthissummerresort-thatis,tovisitherthere;perhapsitalsocontainsaverybashfulallusiontothewishtobecomeamotherherself。*2-
*Forthemythologicalmeaningofwater-birth,seeRank:DerMythusvonderGeburtdesHelden1909。
*2ItwasnotforalongtimethatIlearnedtoappreciatethesignificanceofthephantasiesandunconsciousthoughtsrelatingtolifeinthewomb。Theycontaintheexplanationofthecuriousdread,feltbysomanypeople,ofbeingburiedalive,aswellastheprofoundestunconsciousreasonforthebeliefinalifeafterdeath,whichrepresentsonlytheprojectionintothefutureofthismysteriouslifebeforebirth。Theactofbirth,moreover,isthefirstexperienceattendedbyanxiety,andisthus,thesourceandmodeloftheaffectofanxiety-
Anotherdreamofparturition,withitsinterpretation,ItakefromapaperbyE。Jones。"Shestoodattheseashorewatchingasmallboy,whoseemedtobehers,wadingintothewater。Thishedidtillthewatercoveredhimandshecouldonlyseehisheadbobbingupanddownnearthesurface。Thescenethenchangedtothecrowdedtohallofanhotel。Herhusbandlefther,andshe’enteredintoconversationwith’astranger。
"Thesecondhalfofthedreamwasdiscoveredintheanalysistorepresentflightfromherhusband,andtheenteringintointimaterelationswithathirdperson,behindwhomwasplainlyindicatedMr。X’sbrother,mentionedinaformerdream。Thefirstpartofthedreamwasafairlyevidentbirth-phantasy。Indreams,asinmythology,thedeliveryofachildfromtheuterinewatersiscommonlyrepresented,bywayofdistortion,astheentryofthechildintowater;amongmanyotherinstances,thebirthsofAdonis,Osiris,Moses,andBacchusarewell-knownillustrationsofthis。
Thebobbingupanddownoftheheadinthewateratoncerecalledtothepatientthesensationofquickeningwhichshehadexperiencedinheronlypregnancy。Thinkingoftheboygoingintothewaterinducedareverieinwhichshesawherselftakinghimoutofthewater,carryinghimintothenursery,washinganddressinghim,andinstallinghiminherhousehold。
"Thesecondhalfofthedream,therefore,representsthoughtsconcerningtheelopement,whichbelongedtothefirsthalfoftheunderlyinglatentcontent;thefirsthalfofthedreamcorrespondedwiththesecondhalfofthelatentcontent,thebirthphantasy。Besidesthisinversionintheorder,furtherinversionstookplaceineachhalfofthedream。
Inthefirsthalfthechildenteredthewater,andthenhisheadbobbed;
intheunderlyingdream-thoughtsthequickeningoccurredfirst,andthenthechildleftthewateradoubleinversion。Inthesecondhalfherhusbandlefther;inthedream-thoughtssheleftherhusband。"
AnotherparturitiondreamisrelatedbyAbraham-thedreamofayoungwomanexpectingherfirstconfinement:Frontonepointoftheflooroftheroomasubterraneanchannelleadsdirectlyintothewaterpathofparturition-amnioticfluid。Sheliftsupatrapinthefloor,andthereimmediatelyappearsacreaturedressedinbrownishfur,whichalmostresemblesaseal。Thiscreaturechangesintothedreamer’syoungerbrother,towhomherrelationhasalwaysbeenmaterialincharacter。
Rankhasshownfromanumberofdreamsthatparturition-dreamsemploythesamesymbolsasmicturition-dreams。Theeroticstimulusexpressesitselfinthesedreamsasinurethralstimulus。Thestratificationofmeaninginthesedreamscorrespondswithachanceinthesignificanceofthesymbolsincechildhood。
WemayhereturnbacktotheinterruptedthemeseechapterIII
ofthepartplayedbyorganic,sleep-disturbingstimuliindream-formation。
Dreamswhichhavecomeintoexistenceundertheseinfluencesnotonlyrevealquitefranklythewish-fulfillingtendency,andthecharacterofconvenience-dreams,buttheyveryoftendisplayaquitetransparentsymbolismaswell,sincewakingnotinfrequentlyfollowsastimuluswhosesatisfactioninsymbolicdisguisehasalreadybeenvainlyattemptedinthedream。Thisistrueofemissiondreamsaswellasthoseevokedbytheneedtourinateordefecate。
Thepeculiarcharacterofemissiondreamspermitsusdirectlytounmaskcertainsexualsymbolsalreadyrecognizedastypical,butneverthelessviolentlydisputed,anditalsoconvincesusthatmanyanapparentlyinnocentdream-situationismerelythesymbolicpreludetoacrudelysexualscene。
This,however,findsdirectrepresentation,asarule,onlyinthecomparativelyinfrequentemissiondreams,whileitoftenenoughturnsintoananxiety-dream,whichlikewiseleadstowaking。
Thesymbolismofdreamsduetourethralstimulusisespeciallyobvious,andhasalwaysbeendivined。HippocrateshadalreadyadvancedthetheorythatadisturbanceofthebladderwasindicatedifonedreamtoffountainsandspringsHavelockEllis。Scherner,whohasstudiedthemanifoldsymbolismoftheurethralstimulus,agreesthat"thepowerfulurethralstimulusalwaysturnsintothestimulationofthesexualsphereanditssymbolicimagery……Thedreamduetourethralstimulusisoftenatthesametimetherepresentativeofthesexualdream。"
O。Rank,whoseconclusionsinhispaperonDieSymbolschichtungimWecktraumIhaveherefollowed,arguesveryplausiblythatalargenumberof"dreamsduetourethralstimulus"arereallycausedbysexualstimuli,whichatfirstseektogratifythemselvesbywayofregressiontotheinfantileformofurethralerotism。Thosecasesareespeciallyinstructiveinwhichtheurethralstimulusthusproducedleadstowakingandtheemptyingofthebladder,whereupon,inspiteofthisrelief,thedreamiscontinued,andexpressesitsneedinundisguisedlyeroticimages。*-
*"Thesamesymbolicrepresentationswhichintheinfantilesenseconstitutethebasisofthevesicaldreamappearintherecentsenseinpurelysexualsignificance:water=urine=semen=amnioticfluid;ship=topumpshipurinate=seed-capsule;gettingwet=enuresis=coitus=pregnancy;swimming=fullbladder=dwelling-placeoftheunborn;rain=urination=symboloffertilization:travelingjourneying-alighting
=gettingoutofbed=havingsexualintercoursehoneymoonjourney;urinating=sexualejaculation"Rank,I,c-
Inaquiteanalogousmannerdreamsduetointestinalstimulusdisclosethepertinentsymbolism,andthusconfirmtherelation,whichisalsoamplyverifiedbyethno-psychology,ofgoldandfeces。*"Thus,forexample,awoman,atatimewhensheisunderthecareofaphysicianonaccountofanintestinaldisorder,dreamsofadiggerforhiddentreasurewhoisburyingatreasureinthevicinityofalittlewoodenshedwhichlookslikearuralprivy。Asecondpartofthedreamhasasitscontenthowshewipestheposteriorofherchild,alittlegirl,whohassoiledherself。"-
*Freud,"CharacterandAnalErotism,"CollectedPapers,II;Rank,DieSymbolschictung,etc。;Dattner,Intern。Zeitschr。f。Psych。i1913;
ReikIntern。Zeitschr。,iii1915-
Dreamsofrescueareconnectedwithparturitiondreams。Torescue,especiallytorescuefromthewater,is,whendreamedbyawoman,equivalenttogivingbirth;thissenseis,however,modifiedwhenthedreamerisaman。*-
*ForsuchadreamseePfister,"EinFallvonpsychoanalytischerSeelensorgeundSeelenheilung,"inEvangelischeFreiheit1909。Concerningthesymbolof"rescuing,"seemypaper,"TheFutureProspectsofPsycho-AnalyticTherapy"p。123above。Also"ContributiontotheTheoryofLove,I:A
SpecialTypeofObjectChoiceinMen"inCollectedPapers,iv。AlsoRank,"BeilegezurRettungs-phantasie,"intheZentralblattfurPsychoanalysei1910,p。331;Reik;"ZurRettungssymbolic,"ibid。,p。299-
Robbers,burglars,andghosts,ofwhichweareafraidbeforegoingtobed,andwhichsometimesevendisturboursleep,originateinoneandthesamechildishreminiscence。Theyarethenightlyvisitorswhohavewakedthechildinordertosetitonthechamber,sothatitmaynotwetthebed,orhaveliftedthecoverletinordertoseeclearlyhowthechildisholdingitshandswhilesleeping。Ihavebeenabletoinduceanexactrecollectionofthenocturnalvisitorintheanalysisofsomeoftheseanxietydreams。Therobberswerealwaysthefather;theghostsmoreprobablycorrespondtofemalepersonsinwhitenight-gowns。
OntoChapter6,SectionF
Freud’s*TheInterpretationofDreams*ChapSix,SectionsFandGBacktoTableofContentsforTheInterpretationofDreamsVI。THEDREAM-WORKcontinuedF。Examples-ArithmeticandSpeechinDreamsBeforeIproceedtoassigntoitsproperplacethefourthofthefactorswhichcontroltheformationofdreams,Ishallciteafewexamplesfrommycollectionofdreams,partlyforthepurposeofillustratingtheco-operationofthethreefactorswithwhichwearealreadyacquainted,andpartlyforthepurposeofadducingevidenceforcertainunsupportedassertionswhichhavebeenmade,orofbringingoutwhatnecessarilyfollowsfromthem。
Ithas,ofcourse,beendifficultintheforegoingaccountofthedream-worktodemonstratemyconclusionsbymeansofexamples。Examplesinsupportofisolatedstatementsareconvincingonlywhenconsideredinthecontextofaninterpretationofadreamasawhole;whentheyarewrestedfromtheircontext,theylosetheirvalue;ontheotherhand,adream-interpretation,evenwhenitisbynomeansprofound,soonbecomessoextensivethatitobscuresthethreadofthediscussionwhichitisintendedtoillustrate。
ThistechnicalconsiderationmustbemyexcuseifInowproceedtomixtogetherallsortsofthingswhichhavenothingincommonexcepttheirreferencetothetextoftheforegoingchapter。
Weshallfirstconsiderafewexamplesofverypeculiarorunusualmethodsofrepresentationindreams。Aladydreamedasfollows:Aservant-girlisstandingonaladderasthoughtocleanthewindows,andhaswithherachimpanzeeandagorillacatlatercorrected,angoracat。Shethrowstheanimalsontothedreamer;thechimpanzeenestlesuptoher,andthisisverydisgusting。Thisdreamhasaccomplisheditspurposebyaverysimplemeans,namely,bytakingamerefigureofspeechliterally,andrepresentingitinaccordancewiththeliteralmeaningofitswords。Monkey,likethenamesofanimalsingeneral,isanopprobriousepithet,andthesituationofthedreammeansmerelytohurlinvectives。Thissamecollectionwillsoonfurnishuswithfurtherexamplesoftheemploymentofthissimpleartificeinthedream-work。
Anotherdreamproceedsinaverysimilarmanner:Awomanwithachildwhichhasaconspicuouslydeformedcranium;thedreamerhasheardthatthechildacquiredthisdeformityowingtoitspositioninitsmother’swomb。Thedoctorsaysthatthecraniummightbegivenabettershapebymeansofcompression,butthatthiswouldinjurethebrain。Shethinksthatbecauseitisaboyitwon’tsuffersomuchfromdeformity。Thisdreamcontainsaplasticrepresentationoftheabstractconcept:Childishimpressions,withwhichthedreamerhasbecomefamiliarinthecourseofthetreatment。
Inthefollowingexamplethedream-workfollowsratheradifferentcourse。ThedreamcontainsarecollectionofanexcursiontotheHilmteich,nearGraz:Thereisaterriblestormoutside;amiserablehotel-thewaterisdrippingfromthewalls,andthebedsaredamp。ThelatterpartofthecontentwaslessdirectlyexpressedthanIgiveit。Thedreamsignifiessuperfluous。Theabstractideaoccurringinthedream-thoughtsisfirstmadeequivocalbyacertainabuseoflanguage;ithasperhapsbeenreplacedbyoverflowing,orbyfluidandsuper-fluid-fluous,andhasthenbeenbroughttorepresentationbyanaccumulationoflikeimpressions。Waterwithin,waterwithout,waterinthebedsintheformofdampness-everythingfluidandsuperfluid。Thatforthepurposesofdream-representationthespellingismuchlessconsideredthanthesoundofwordsoughtnottosurpriseuswhenwerememberthatrhymeexercisesasimilarprivilege。
Thefactthatlanguagehasatitsdisposalagreatnumberofwordswhichwereoriginallyusedinapictorialandconcretesense,butareatpresentusedinacolourlessandabstractfashion,has,incertainothercases,madeitveryeasyforthedreamtorepresentitsthoughts。Thedreamhasonlytorestoretothesewordstheirfullsignificance,ortofollowtheirchangeofmeaningalittlewayback。Forexample,amandreamsthathisfriend,whoisstrugglingtogetoutofaverytightplace,callsuponhimforhelp。Theanalysisshowsthatthetightplaceisahole,andthatthedreamersymbolicallyusestheseverywordstohisfriend:"Becareful,oryou’llgetyourselfintoahole。"*Anotherdreamerclimbsamountainfromwhichheobtainsanextraordinarilyextensiveview。Heidentifieshimselfwithhisbrother,whoiseditingareviewdealingwiththeFarEast。
*EnglishExample-TR。
InadreaminDerGruneHeinrich,aspiritedhorseisplungingaboutinafieldofthefinestoats,everygrainofwhichisreally"asweetalmond,araisinandanewpenny"wrappedinredsilkandtiedwithabitofpig’sbristle。"Thepoetorthedreamerimmediatelyfurnishesthemeaningofthisdream,forthehorsefelthimselfpleasantlytickled,sothatheexclaimed:"Theoatsareprickingme""Ifeelmyoats"。
IntheoldNorsesagasaccordingtoHenzenprolificuseismadeindreamsofcolloquialismsandwittyexpressions;onescarcelyfindsadreamwithoutadoublemeaningoraplayuponwords。
Itwouldbeaspecialundertakingtocollectsuchmethodsofrepresentationandtoarrangetheminaccordancewiththeprinciplesuponwhichtheyarebased。Someoftherepresentationsarealmostwitty。Theygiveonetheimpressionthatonewouldhaveneverguessedtheirmeaningifthedreamerhimselfhadnotsucceededinexplainingit。
1。Amandreamsthatheisaskedforaname,which,however,hecannotrecall。Hehimselfexplainsthatthismeans:"Ishouldn’tdreamofit。"
2。Afemalepatientrelatesadreaminwhichallthepersonsconcernedweresingularlylarge。"Thatmeans,"sheadds,"thatitmustdealwithanepisodeofmyearlychildhood,foratthattimeallgrown-uppeoplenaturallyseemedtomeimmenselylarge。"Sheherselfdidnotappearinthedream。
Thetranspositionintochildhoodisexpresseddifferentlyinotherdreams-bythetranslationoftimeintospace。Oneseespersonsandscenesasthoughatagreatdistance,attheendofalongroad,orasthoughonewerelookingatthemthroughthewrongendofapairofopera-glasses。
3。Amanwhoinwakinglifeshowsaninclinationtoemployabstractandindefiniteexpressions,butwhootherwisehashiswitsabouthim,dreams,inacertainconnection,thathereachesarailwaystationjustasatrainiscomingin。Butthentheplatformmovestowardsthetrain,whichstandsstill;anabsurdinversionoftherealstateofaffairs。Thisdetail,again,isnothingmorethananindicationtotheeffectthatsomethingelseinthedreammustbeinverted。Theanalysisofthesamedreamleadstorecollectionsofpicture-booksinwhichmenwererepresentedstandingontheirheadsandwalkingontheirhands。
4。Thesamedreamer,onanotheroccasion,relatesashortdreamwhichalmostrecallsthetechniqueofarebus。Hisunclegiveshimakissinanautomobile。Heimmediatelyaddstheinterpretation,whichwouldneverhaveoccurredtome:itmeansauto-erotism。Inthewakingstatethismighthavebeensaidinjest。
5。AtaNewYear’sEvedinnerthehost,thepatriarchofthefamily,usheredintheNewYearwithaspeech。Oneofhissons-in-law,alawyer,wasnotinclinedtotaketheoldmanseriously,especiallywheninthecourseofhisspeechheexpressedhimselfasfollows:"WhenIopentheledgerfortheOldYearandglanceatitspagesIseeeverythingontheassetsideandnothing,thanktheLord,onthesideofliability;allyouchildrenhavebeenagreatasset,noneofyoualiability。"OnhearingthistheyounglawyerthoughtofX,hiswife’sbrother,whowasacheatandaliar,andwhomhehadrecentlyextricatedfromtheentanglementsofthelaw。Thatnight,inadream。hesawtheNewYear’scelebrationoncemore,andheardthespeech,orrathersawit。Insteadofspeaking,theoldmanactuallyopenedtheledger,andonthesidemarkedassetshesawhisnameamongstothers,butontheotherside,markedliability,therewasthenameofhisbrother-in-law,X。However,thewordliabilitywaschangedintoLie-Ability,whichheregardedasX’smaincharacteristic。
*
*ReportedbyBrillinhisFundamentalConceptionsofPsychoanalysis。
6。Adreamertreatsanotherpersonforabrokenbone。Theanalysisshowsthatthefracturerepresentsabrokenmarriagevow,etc。
7。Inthedream-contentthetimeofdayoftenrepresentsacertainperiodofthedreamer’schildhood。Thus,forexample,5:15a。m。meanstoonedreamertheageoffiveyearsandthreemonths;whenhewasthatage,ayoungerbrotherwasborn。
8。Anotherrepresentationofageinadream:Awomaniswalkingwithtwolittlegirls;thereisadifferenceoffifteenmonthsintheirages。Thedreamercannotthinkofanyfamilyofheracquaintanceinwhichthisisthecase。Sheherselfinterpretsittomeanthatthetwochildrenrepresentherownperson,andthatthedreamremindsherthatthetwotraumaticeventsofherchildhoodwereseparatedbythisperiodoftime31/2and43/4years。
9。Itisnotastonishingthatpersonswhoareundergoingpsycho-
analytictreatmentfrequentlydreamofit,andarecompelledtogiveexpressionintheirdreamstoallthethoughtsandexpectationsarousedbyit。Theimagechosenforthetreatmentisasarulethatofajourney,usuallyinamotor-car,thisbeingamodernandcomplicatedvehicle;inthereferencetothespeedofthecarthepatient’sironicalhumourisgivenfreeplay。
Iftheunconscious,asanelementofwakingthought,istoberepresentedinthedream,itisreplaced,appropriatelyenough,bysubterraneanlocalities,whichatothertimes,whenthereisnoreferencetoanalytictreatment,haverepresentedthefemalebodyorthewomb。Belowinthedreamveryoftenreferstothegenitals,anditsopposite,above,totheface,mouthorbreast。Bywildbeaststhedream-workusuallysymbolizespassionateimpulses;
thoseofthedreamer,andalsothoseofotherpersonsofwhomthedreamerisafraid;orthus,bymeansofaveryslightdisplacement,thepersonswhoexperiencethesepassions。Fromthisitisnotveryfartothetotemisticrepresentationofthedreadedfatherbymeansofviciousanimals,dogs,wildhorses,etc。Onemightsaythatwildbeastsservetorepresentthelibido,fearedbytheego,andcombatedbyrepression。Eventheneurosisitself,thesickperson,isoftenseparatedfromthedreamerandexhibitedinthedreamasanindependentperson。
Onemaygosofarastosaythatthedream-workmakesuseofallthemeansaccessibletoitforthevisualrepresentationofthedream-thoughts,whethertheseappearadmissibleorinadmissibletowakingcriticism,andthusexposesitselftothedoubtaswellasthederisionofallthosewhohaveonlyhearsayknowledgeofdream-interpretation,buthaveneverthemselvespractisedit。Stekel’sbook,DieSprachedesTraumes,isespeciallyrichinsuchexamples,butIavoidcitingillustrationsfromthisworkastheauthor’slackofcriticaljudgmentandhisarbitrarytechniquewouldmakeeventheunprejudicedobserverfeeldoubtful。
10。FromanessaybyV。Tausk"KleiderundFarbeninDienstederTraumdarstellung,"inInterna。Zeitschr。furPs。A。,ii[1914]:
aAdreamsthatheseeshisformergovernesswearingadressofblacklustre,whichfitscloselyoverherbuttocks。Thatmeanshedeclaresthiswomantobelustful。
bCinadreamseesagirlontheroadtoXbathedinawhitelightandwearingawhiteblouse。
ThedreamerbegananaffairwithaMissWhiteonthisroad。
11。InananalysiswhichIcarriedoutintheFrenchlanguageIhadtointerpretadreaminwhichIappearedasanelephant。InaturallyhadtoaskwhyIwasthusrepresented:"Vousmetrompez,"answeredthedreamerTrompe=trunk。
Thedream-workoftensucceedsinrepresentingveryrefractorymaterial,suchaspropernames,bymeansoftheforcedexploitationofveryremoterelations。InoneofmydreamsoldBruckehassetmeatask。
Imakeapreparation,andpicksomethingoutofitwhichlookslikecrumpledtinfoil。Ishallreturntothisdreamlater。Thecorrespondingassociation,whichisnoteasytofind,isstanniol,andnowIknowthatIhaveinmindthenameoftheauthorStannius,whichappearedonthetitle-pageofatreatiseonthenervoussystemoffishes,whichinmyyouthIregardedwithreverence。Thefirstscientificproblemwhichmyteachersetmedidactuallyrelatetothenervoussystemofafish-theAmmocoetes。Obviously,thisnamecouldnotbeutilizedinthepicture-puzzle。
HereImustnotfailtoincludeadreamwithacuriouscontent,whichisworthnotingalsoasthedreamofachild,andwhichisreadilyexplainedbyanalysis:Aladytellsme:"IcanrememberthatwhenIwasachildIrepeatedlydreamedthatGodworeaconicalpaperhatonHishead。
Theyoftenusedtomakemewearsuchahatattable,sothatIshouldn’tbeabletolookattheplatesoftheotherchildrenandseehowmuchtheyhadreceivedofanyparticulardish。SinceIhadheardthatGodwasomniscient,thedreamsignifiedthatIkneweverythinginspiteofthehatwhichI
wasmadetowear。"
Whatthedream-workconsistsin,anditsunceremonioushandlingofitsmaterial,thedream-thoughts,maybeshowninaninstructivemannerbythenumbersandcalculationswhichoccurindreams。Superstition,bytheway,regardsnumbersashavingaspecialsignificanceindreams。I
shallthereforegiveafewexamplesofthiskindfrommycollection。
1。Fromthedreamofalady,shortlybeforetheendofhertreatment:
Shewantstopayforsomethingorother;herdaughtertakes3
florins65kreuzerfromherpurse;butthemothersays:"Whatareyoudoing?
Itcostsonly21kreuzer。"Thisfragmentofthedreamwasintelligiblewithoutfurtherexplanationowingtomyknowledgeofthedreamer’scircumstances。
Theladywasaforeigner,whohadplacedherdaughteratschoolinVienna,andwasabletocontinuemytreatmentaslongasherdaughterremainedinthecity。Inthreeweeksthedaughter’sscholasticyearwouldend,andthetreatmentwouldthenstop。Onthedaybeforethedreamtheprincipaloftheschoolhadaskedherwhethershecouldnotdecidetoleavethechildatschoolforanotheryear。Shehadthenobviouslyreflectedthatinthiscaseshewouldbeabletocontinuethetreatmentforanotheryear。Now,thisiswhatthedreamrefersto,forayearisequalto365days;thethreeweeksremainingbeforetheendofthescholasticyear,andofthetreatment,areequivalentto21daysthoughnottosomanyhoursoftreatment。
Thenumerals,whichinthedream-thoughtsrefertoperiodsoftime,aregivenmoneyvaluesinthedream,andsimultaneouslyadeepermeaningfindsexpression-fortimeismoney。365kreuzer,ofcourse,are3florins65
kreuzer。Thesmallnessofthesumswhichappearinthedreamisaself-
evidentwish-fulfilment;thewishhasreducedboththecostofthetreatmentandtheyear’sschoolfees。
2。Inanotherdreamthenumeralsareinvolvedinevenmorecomplexrelations。Ayounglady,whohasbeenmarriedforsomeyears,learnsthatanacquaintanceofhers,ofaboutthesameage,EliseL,hasjustbecomeengaged。Thereuponshedreams:Sheissittinginthetheatrewithherhusbandandonesideofthestallsisquiteempty。HerhusbandtellsherthatEliseLandherfiancehadalsowishedtocometothetheatre,butthattheyonlycouldhaveobtainedpoorseats;threefor1florin50kreuzer,andofcoursetheycouldnottakethose。Shethinkstheydidn’tlosemuch,either。
Whatistheoriginofthe1florin50kreuzer?Areallyindifferentincidentofthepreviousday。Thedreamer’ssister-in-lawhadreceived150florinsasapresentfromherhusband,andhastenedtogetridofthembybuyingsomejewellery。Letusnotethat150florinsis100times1florin50kreuzer。Butwhencethe3inconnectionwiththeseatsinthetheatre?
Thereisonlyoneassociationforthis,namely,thatthefianceisthreemonthsyoungerthanherself。Whenwehaveascertainedthesignificanceofthefactthatonesideofthestallsisemptywehavethesolutionofthedream。Thisfeatureisanundisguisedallusiontoalittleincidentwhichhadgivenherhusbandagoodexcuseforteasingher。Shehaddecidedtogotothetheatrethatweek;shehadbeencarefultoobtainticketsafewdaysbeforehand,andhadhadtopaytheadvancebooking-fee。Whentheygottothetheatretheyfoundthatonesideofthehousewasalmostempty;sothatshecertainlyneednothavebeeninsuchahurry。
Ishallnowsubstitutethedream-thoughtsforthedream:"Itsurelywasnonsensetomarrysoearly;therewasnoneedformybeinginsuchahurry。FromEliseL’sexampleIseethatIshouldhavegotahusbandjustthesame-andoneahundredtimesbetter-IfIhadonlywaitedantithesistothehasteofhersister-in-law,Icouldhaveboughtthreesuchmenforthemoneythedowry!"-Ourattentionisdrawntothefactthatthenumeralsinthisdreamhavechangedtheirmeaningsandtheirrelationstoamuchgreaterextentthaninthe。onepreviouslyconsidered。Thetransforminganddistortingactivityofthedreamhasinthiscasebeengreater-afactwhichweinterpretasmeaningthatthesedream-thoughtshadtoovercomeanunusualdegreeofendo-psychicresistancebeforetheyattainedtorepresentation。
Andwemustnotoverlookthefactthatthedreamcontainsanabsurdelement,namely,thattwopersonsareexpectedtotakethreeseats。ItwillthrowsomelightonthequestionoftheinterpretationofabsurdityindreamsifIremarkthatthisabsurddetailofthedream-contentisintendedtorepresentthemoststronglyemphasizedofthedream-thoughts:"Itwasnonsensetomarrysoearly。"Thefigure3,whichoccursinaquitesubordinaterelationbetweenthetwopersonscomparedthreemonths’differenceintheirages,hasthusbeenadroitlyutilizedtoproducetheideaofnonsenserequiredbythedream。Thereductionoftheactual150florinsto1florin50kreuzercorrespondstothedreamer’sdisparagementofherhusbandinhersuppressedthoughts。
3。Anotherexampledisplaysthearithmeticalpowersofdreams,whichhavebroughtthemintosuchdisrepute。Amandreams:HeissittingintheB’shousetheB’sareafamilywithwhichhewasformerlyacquainted,andhesays:"Itwasnonsensethatyoudidn’tgivemeAmyformywife。"
Thereupon,heasksthegirl:"Howoldareyou?"Answer:"Iwasbornin1882。""Ah,thenyouare28yearsold。"
Sincethedreamwasdreamedintheyear1898,thisisobviouslybadarithmetic,andtheinabilityofthedreamertocalculatemay,ifitcannotbeotherwiseexplained,belikenedtothatofageneralparalytic。
Mypatientwasoneofthosemenwhocannothelpthinkingabouteverywomantheysee。Thepatientwhoforsomemonthscamenextafterhiminmyconsulting-roomwasayounglady;hemetthisladyafterhehadconstantlyaskedabouther,andhewasveryanxioustomakeagoodimpressiononher。Thiswastheladywhoseageheestimatedat28。Somuchforexplainingtheresultofhisapparentcalculation。But1882wastheyearinwhichhehadmarried。
Hehadbeenunabletorefrainfromenteringintoconversationwiththetwootherwomenwhomhemetatmyhouse-thetwobynomeansyouthfulmaidswhoalternatelyopenedthedoortohim-andashedidnotfindthemveryresponsive,hehadtoldhimselfthattheyprobablyregardedhimaselderlyandserious。
Bearinginmindtheseexamples,andothersofasimilarnaturetofollow,wemaysay:Thedream-workdoesnotcalculateatall,whethercorrectlyorincorrectly;itonlystringstogether,intheformofasum,numeralswhichoccurinthedream-thoughts,andwhichmayserveasallusionstomaterialwhichisinsusceptibleofrepresentation。Itthusdealswithfigures,asmaterialforexpressingitsintentions,justasitdealswithallotherconcepts,andwithnamesandspeecheswhichareonlyverbalimages。
Forthedream-workcannotcomposeanewspeech。Nomatterhowmanyspeeches;andanswers,whichmayinthemselvesbesensibleorabsurd,mayoccurindreams,analysisshowsusthatthedreamhastakenfromthedream-thoughtsfragmentsofspeecheswhichhavereallybeendeliveredorheard,andhasdealtwiththeminthemostarbitraryfashion。Ithasnotonlytornthemfromtheircontextandmutilatedthem,acceptingonefragmentandrejectinganother,butithasoftenfittedthemtogetherinanovelmanner,sothatthespeechwhichseemscoherentinadreamisdissolvedbyanalysisintothreeorfourcomponents。Inthisnewapplicationofthewordsthedreamhasoftenignoredthemeaningwhichtheyhadinthedream-thoughts,andhasdrawnanentirelynewmeaningfromthem。*Uponcloserinspection,themoredistinctandcompactingredientsofthedream-speechmaybedistinguishedfromothers,whichserveasconnectives,andhaveprobablybeensupplied,justaswesupplyomittedlettersandsyllablesinreading。Thedream-speechthushasthestructureofbreccia,inwhichthelargerpiecesofvariousmaterialareheldtogetherbyasolidifiedcohesivemedium。
*AnalysesofothernumericaldreamshavebeengivenbyJung,Marcinowskiandothers。Suchdreamsofteninvolveverycomplicatedarithmeticaloperations,whicharenonethelesssolvedbythedreamerwithastonishingconfidence。
Cf。alsoErnestJones,"UberunbewussteZahlenbehandlung,"Zentralb。furPsychoanalyse,4,ii,[1912],p。241。
Neurosisbehavesinthesamefashion。Iknowapatientwho-involuntarilyandunwillingly-hearshallucinatessongsorfragmentsofsongswithoutbeingabletounderstandtheirsignificanceforherpsychiclife。Sheiscertainlynotaparanoiac。Analysisshowsthatbyexercisingacertainlicenseshegavethetextofthesesongsafalseapplication。"Oh,thoublissfulone!Oh,thouhappyone!"ThisisthefirstlineofChristmascarol,butbynotcontinuingittotheword,Christmastide,sheturnsitintoabridalsong,etc。Thesamemechanismofdistortionmayoperate,withouthallucination,merelyinassociation。
Strictlyspeaking,ofcourse,thisdescriptioniscorrectonlyforthosedream-speecheswhichhavesomethingofthesensorycharacterofaspeech,andaredescribedasspeeches。Theothers,whichhavenot,asitwere,beenperceivedasheardorspokenwhichhavenoaccompanyingacousticormotoremphasisinthedreamaresimplythoughts,suchasoccurinourwakinglife,andfindtheirwayunchangedintomanyofourdreams。Ourreading,too,seemstoprovideanabundantandnoteasilytraceablesourcefortheindifferentspeech-materialofdreams。Butanythingthatisatallconspicuousasaspeechinadreamcanbereferredtoactualspeecheswhichhavebeenmadeorheardbythedreamer。
Wehavealreadyfoundexamplesofthederivationofsuchdream-
speechesintheanalysesofdreamswhichhavebeencitedforotherpurposes。
Thus,intheinnocentmarket-dreamchapterV。,A。wherethespeech:Thatisnolongertobehadservestoidentifymewiththebutcher,whileafragmentoftheotherspeech:Idon’tknowthat,Idon’ttakethat,preciselyfulfilsthetaskofrenderingthedreaminnocent。Onthepreviousday,thedreamer,replyingtosomeunreasonabledemandonthepartofhercook,hadwavedherasidewiththewords:Idon’tknowthat,behaveyourselfproperly,andsheafterwardstookintothedreamthefirst,indifferent-soundingpartofthespeechinordertoalludetothelatterpart,whichfittedwellintothephantasyunderlyingthedream,butwhichmightalsohavebetrayedit。
Hereisoneofmanyexampleswhichallleadtothesameconclusion:
Alargecourtyardinwhichdeadbodiesarebeingburned。Thedreamersays,"I’mgoing,Ican’tstandthesightofit。"Notadistinctspeech。
Thenhemeetstwobutcherboysandasks,"Well,didittastegood?"Andoneofthemanswers,"No,itwasn’tgood。"Asthoughithadbeenhumanflesh。
Theinnocentoccasionofthisdreamisasfollows:Aftertakingsupperwithhiswife,thedreamerpaysavisittohisworthybutbynomeansappetizingneighbour。Thehospitableoldladyisjustsittingdowntoherownsupper,andpresseshimamongmenacomposite,sexuallysignificantwordisusedjocoselyintheplaceofthiswordtotasteit。Hedeclines,sayingthathehasnoappetite。Shereplies:"Goonwithyou,youcanmanageitallright,"orsomethingofthekind。Thedreameristhusforcedtotasteandpraisewhatisofferedhim。"Butthat’sgood!"Whenheisaloneagainwithhiswife,hecomplainsofhisneighbour’simportunity,andofthequalityofthefoodwhichhehastasted。"Ican’tstandthesightofit,"aphrasethatinthedream,too,doesnotemergeasanactualspeech,isathoughtrelatingtothephysicalcharmsoftheladywhoinviteshim,whichmaybetranslatedbythestatementthathehasnodesiretolookather。
Theanalysisofanotherdream-whichIwillciteatthisstageforthesakeofaverydistinctspeech,whichconstitutesitsnucleus,butwhichwillbeexplainedonlywhenwecometoevaluatetheaffectsindreams-ismoreinstructive。Idreamveryvividly:IhavegonetoBrucke’slaboratoryatnight,andonhearingagentleknockingatthedoor,IopenittothedeceasedProfessorFleischl,whoentersinthecompanyofseveralstrangers,andaftersayingafewwordssitsdownathistable。Thenfollowsaseconddream:MyfriendFlhascometoVienna,unobtrusively,inJuly;
Imeethiminthestreet,inconversationwithmydeceasedfriendP,andIgowiththemsomewhere,andtheysitdownfacingeachotherasthoughatasmalltable,whileIsitfacingthematthenarrowendofthetable。
Flspeaksofhissister,andsays:"Inthree-quartersofanhourshewasdead,"andthensomethinglike"Thatisthethreshold。"AsPdoesnotunderstandhim,Flturnstome,andasksmehowmuchIhavetoldPofhisaffairs。
Atthis,overcomebystrangeemotions,ItrytotellFlthatPcannotpossiblyknowanything,ofcourse,becauseheisnotalive。Butnoticingthemistakemyself,Isay:"Nonvixit。"ThenIlooksearchinglyatP,andundermygazehebecomespaleandblurred,andhiseyesturnasicklyblue-
andatlasthedissolves。Irejoicegreatlyatthis;InowunderstandthatErnstFleischl,too,isonlyanapparition,arevenant,andIfindthatitisquitepossiblethatsuchapersonshouldexistonlysolongasonewisheshimto,andthathecanbemadetodisappearbythewishofanotherperson。
Thisveryprettydreamunitessomanyoftheenigmaticalcharacteristicsofthedream-content-thecriticismmadeinthedreamitself,inasmuchasImyselfnoticemymistakeinsayingNonvixitinsteadofNonvivit,theunconstrainedintercoursewithdeceasedpersons,whomthedreamitselfdeclarestobedead,theabsurdityofmyconclusion,andtheintensesatisfactionwhichitgivesme-that"Iwouldgivemylife"toexpoundthecompletesolutionoftheproblem。ButinrealityIamincapableofdoingwhatI
dointhedream,i。e。,ofsacrificingsuchintimatefriendstomyambition。
AndifIattemptedtodisguisethefacts,thetruemeaningofthedream,withwhichIamperfectlyfamiliar,wouldbespoiled。Imustthereforebecontenttoselectafewoftheelementsofthedreamforinterpretation,somehere,andsomeatalaterstage。
ThesceneinwhichIannihilatePwithaglanceformsthecentreofthedream。Hiseyesbecomestrangeandweirdlyblue,andthenhedissolves。
Thissceneisanunmistakableimitationofascenethatwasactuallyexperienced。
IwasademonstratoratthePhysiologicalInstitute;Iwasondutyinthemorning,andBruckelearnedthatonseveraloccasionsIhadbeenunpunctualinmyattendanceatthestudents’laboratory。Onemorning,therefore,hearrivedatthehourofopening,andwaitedforme。Whathesaidtomewasbriefandtothepoint;butitwasnotwhathesaidthatmattered。Whatoverwhelmedmewastheterriblegazeofhisblueeyes,beforewhichImeltedaway-asPdoesinthedream,forPhasexchangedroleswithme,muchtomyrelief。Anyonewhorememberstheeyesofthegreatmaster,whichwerewonderfullybeautifuleveninhisoldage,andhaseverseenhimangered,willreadilyimaginetheemotionsoftheyoungtransgressoronthatoccasion。
ButforalongwhileIwasunabletoaccountfortheNonvixitwithwhichIpasssentenceinthedream。Finally,Irememberedthatthereasonwhythesetwowordsweresodistinctinthedreamwasnotbecausetheywereheardorspoken,butbecausetheywereseen。ThenIknewatoncewheretheycamefrom。OnthepedestalofthestatueoftheEmperorjosephintheViennaHofburgareinscribedthefollowingbeautifulwords:
Salutipatriaevixitnondiusedtotus。*
*Theinscriptioninfactreads:
Salutipublicaevixitnondiusedtotus。
[Helivedforthesafetyofthepublic,notforalongtime,butalways。]Themotiveofthemistake:patriae[fatherland]forpublicae,hasprobablybeencorrectlydivinedbyWittels。
FromthisinscriptionIhadtakenwhatfittedoneinimicaltrainofthoughtinmydream-thoughts,andwhichwasintendedtomean:"Thatfellowhasnothingtosayinthematter,heisnotreallyalive。"AndInowrecalledthatthedreamwasdreamedafewdaysaftertheunveilingofthememorialtoFleischl,inthecloistersoftheUniversity,uponwhichoccasionI
hadoncemoreseenthememorialtoBrucke,andmusthavethoughtwithregretintheunconscioushowmygiftedfriendP,withallhisdevotiontoscience,hadbyhisprematuredeathforfeitedhisjustclaimtoamemorialinthesehalls。SoIsetupthismemorialtohiminthedream;JosefismyfriendP’sbaptismalname。*
*Asanexampleofover-determination:Myexcuseforcominglatewasthatafterworkinglateintothenight,inthemorningIhadtomakethelongjourneyfromKaiser-Josef-StrassetoWahringerStrasse。
Accordingtotherulesofdream-interpretation,Ishouldstillnotbejustifiedinreplacingnonvivit,whichIneed,bynonvixit,whichisplacedatmydisposalbytherecollectionoftheKaiserJosefmemorial。
Someotherelementofthedream-thoughtsmusthavecontributedtomakethispossible。SomethingnowcallsmyattentiontothefactthatinthedreamscenetwotrainsofthoughtrelatingtomyfriendPmeet,onehostile,theotheraffectionate-theformeronthesurface,thelattercoveredup-
andbotharegivenrepresentationinthesamewords:nonvixit。AsmyfriendPhasdeservedwellofscience,Ierectamemorialtohim;ashehasbeenguiltyofamaliciouswishexpressedattheendofthedream,Iannihilatehim。Ihavehereconstructedasentencewithaspecialcadence,andindoingsoImusthavebeeninfluencedbysomeexistingmodel。ButwherecanIfindasimilarantithesis,asimilarparallelbetweentwooppositereactionstothesameperson,bothofwhichcanclaimtobewhollyjustified,andwhichneverthelessdonotattempttoaffectoneanother?Onlyinonepassagewhich,however,makesaprofoundimpressionuponthereader-Brutus’sspeechofjustificationinShakespeare’sJuliusCaesar:"AsCaesarlovedme,Iweepforhim;ashewasfortunate,Irejoiceatit;ashewasvaliant。
Ihonourhim;butashewasambitious,Islewhim。"Havewenotherethesameverbalstructure,andthesameantithesisofthought,asinthedream-thoughts?
SoIamplayingBrutusinmydream。IfonlyIcouldfindinmydream-thoughtsanothercollateralconnectiontoconfirmthis!Ithinkitmightbethefollowing:MyfriendFlcomestoViennainJuly。Thisdetailisnotthecaseinreality。Tomyknowledge,myfriendhasneverbeeninViennainJuly。ButthemonthofJulyisnamedafterJuliusCaesar,andmightthereforeverywellfurnishtherequiredallusiontotheintermediatethought-thatIamplayingthepartofBrutus。*-
*Andalso,Caesar=Kaiser。
Strangelyenough,IoncedidactuallyplaythepartofBrutus。WhenIwasaboyoffourteen,IpresentedthescenebetweenBrutusandCaesarinSchiller’spoemtoanaudienceofchildren:withtheassistanceofmynephew,whowasayearolderthanI,andwhohadcometousfromEngland-
andwasthusarevenant-forinhimIrecognizedtheplaymateofmyearlychildhood。Untiltheendofmythirdyearwehadbeeninseparable;wehadlovedeachotherandfoughteachotherand,asIhavealreadyhinted,thischildishrelationhasdeterminedallmylaterfeelingsinmyintercoursewithpersonsofmyownage。MynephewJohnhassincethenhadmanyincarnations,whichhaverevivifiedfirstoneandthenanotheraspectofacharacterthatisineradicablyfixedinmyunconsciousmemory。Attimeshemusthavetreatedmeverybadly,andImusthaveopposedmytyrantcourageously,forinlateryearsIwasoftentoldofashortspeechinwhichIdefendedmyselfwhenmyfather-hisgrandfather-calledmetoaccount:"WhydidyouhitJohn?""Ihithimbecausehehitme。"Itmustbethischildishscenewhichcausesnonvivittobecomenonvixit,forinthelanguageoflaterchildhoodstrikingisknownaswichsenGerman:wichsen=topolish,towax,i。e。,tothrash;andthedream-workdoesnotdisdaintotakeadvantageofsuchassociations。MyhostilitytowardsmyfriendP,whichhassolittlefoundationinreality-hewasgreatlymysuperior,andmightthereforehavebeenaneweditionofmyoldplaymate-maycertainlybetracedtomycomplicatedrelationswithJohnduringourchildhood。Ishall,asI
havesaid,returntothisdreamlateron。
G。AbsurdDreams-IntellectualPerformancesinDreamsI。Hitherto,inourinterpretationofdreams,wehavecomeupontheelementofabsurdityinthedream-contentsofrequentlythatwemustnolongerpostponetheinvestigationofitscauseanditsmeaning。Weremember,ofcourse,thattheabsurdityofdreamshasfurnishedtheopponentsofdream-interpretationwiththeirchiefargumentforregardingthedreamasmerelythemeaninglessproductofanattenuatedandfragmentaryactivityofthepsyche。
Iwillbeginwithafewexamplesinwhichtheabsurdityofthedream-contentisapparentonly,disappearingwhenthedreamismorethoroughlyexamined。Thesearecertaindreamswhich-accidently,onebeginsbythinking-
areconcernedwiththedreamer’sdeadfather。
1。Hereisthedreamofapatientwhohadlosthisfathersixyearsbeforethedateofthedream:
Hisfatherhadbeeninvolvedinaterribleaccident。Hewastravellingbythenightexpresswhenthetrainwasderailed,theseatsweretelescoped,andhisheadwascrushedfromsidetoside。Thedreamerseeshimlyingonhisbed;fromhislefteyebrowawoundrunsverticallyupwards。Thedreamerissurprisedthathisfathershouldhavemetwithanaccidentsinceheisdeadalready,asthedreameraddsinrelatinghisdream。Hisfather’seyesaresoclear。
Accordingtotheprevailingstandardsofdream-criticism,thisdream-contentwouldbeexplainedasfollows:Atfirst,whilethedreamerispicturinghisfather’saccident,hehasforgottenthathisfatherhasalreadybeenmanyyearsinhisgrave;inthecourseofthedreamthismemoryawakens,sothatheissurprisedathisowndreamevenwhileheisdreamingit。Analysis,however,tellsusthatitisquitesuperfluoustoseekforsuchexplanations。Thedreamerhadcommissionedasculptortomakeabustofhisfather,andhehadinspectedthebusttwodaysbeforethedream。
ItisthiswhichseemstohimtohavecometogrieftheGermanwordmeansgonewrongormetwithanaccident。Thesculptorhasneverseenhisfather,andhashadtoworkfromphotographs。Ontheverydaybeforethedreamthesonhadsentanoldfamilyservanttothestudioinordertoseewhetherhe,too,wouldpassthesomejudgmentuponthemarblebust-namely,thatitwastoonarrowbetweenthetemples。Andnowfollowsthememory-materialwhichhascontributedtotheformationofthedream:Thedreamer’sfatherhadahabit,wheneverhewasharassedbybusinesscaresordomesticdifficulties,ofpressinghistemplesbetweenhishands,asthoughhisheadwasgrowingtoolargeandbewastryingtocompressit。Whenthedreamerwasfouryearsold,hewaspresentwhenapistolwasaccidentallydischarged,andhisfather’seyeswereblackenedhiseyesaresoclear。Whenhisfatherwasthoughtfulordepressed,hehadadeepfurrowinhisforeheadjustwherethedreamshowshiswound。Thefactthatinthedreamthiswrinkleisreplacedbyawoundpointstothesecondoccasionforthedream。Thedreamerhadtakenaphotographofhislittledaughter;theplatehadfallenfromhishand,andwhenhepickeditupitrevealedacrackwhichranlikeaverticalfurrowacrossthechild’sforehead,extendingasfarastheeyebrow。Hecouldnothelpfeelingasuperstitiousforeboding,foronthedaybeforehismother’sdeaththenegativeofherportraithadbeencracked。
Thus,theabsurdityofthisdreamissimplytheresultofacarelessnessofverbalexpression,whichdoesnotdistinguishbetweenthebustorthephotographandtheoriginal。Weareallaccustomedtomakingremarkslike:
"Don’tyouthinkit’sexactlyyourfather?"Theappearanceofabsurdityinthisdreammight,ofcourse,havebeeneasilyavoided。Ifitwerepermissibletoformanopiniononthestrengthofasinglecase,onemightbetemptedtosaythatthissemblanceofabsurdityisadmittedorevendesired。II。HereisanotherexampleofthesamekindfrommyowndreamsIlostmyfatherintheyear1896:
Afterhisdeath,myfatherhasplayedapartinthepoliticallifeoftheMagyars,andhasunitedthemintoapoliticalwhole;andhereIsee,indistinctly,alittlepicture:anumberofmen,asthoughintheReichstag;amanisstandingononeortwochairs;thereareothersroundabouthim。IrememberthatonhisdeathbedhelookedsolikeGaribaldi,andIamgladthatthispromisehasreallycometrue。
Certainlythisisabsurdenough。ItwasdreamedatthetimewhentheHungarianswereinastateofanarchy,owingtoParliamentaryobstruction,andwerepassingthroughthecrisisfromwhichKolomanSzellsubsequentlydeliveredthem。Thetrivialcircumstancethatthescenesbeheldindreamsconsistofsuchlittlepicturesisnotwithoutsignificancefortheelucidationofthiselement。Thecustomaryvisualdream-representationsofourthoughtspresentimagesthatimpressusasbeinglife-size;mydream-picture,however,isthereproductionofawood-cutinsertedinthetextofanillustratedhistoryofAustria,representingMariaTheresaintheReichstagofPressburg-
thefamoussceneofMoriamurproregenostro。*LikeMariaTheresa,myfather,inmydream,issurroundedbythemultitude;butheisstandingononeortwochairsStuhlen,andisthus,likeaStuhlrichterpresidingjudge。Hehasunitedthem;heretheintermediaryisthephrase:"Weshallneednojudge。"Thoseofuswhostoodaboutmyfather’sdeath-beddidactuallynoticethathelookedverylikeGaribaldi。Hehadapost-mortemriseoftemperature;hischeeksshoneredderandredder……involuntarilywecontinue:"Andbehindhim,inunsubstantialradiance,laythatwhichsubduesusall-thecommonfate。"
*[Wedieforourking。]IhaveforgotteninwhatauthorIfoundareferencetoadreamwhichwasoverrunwithunusuallysmallfigures,thesourceofwhichprovedtobeoneoftheengravingsofJacquesCallot,whichthedreamerhadexaminedduringtheday。Theseengravingscontainanenormousnumberofverysmallfigures;awholeseriesofthemdealswiththehorrorsoftheThirtyYearsWar。
Thisupliftingofourthoughtspreparesusforthefactthatweshallhavetodealwiththiscommonfate。Thepost-mortemriseintemperaturecorrespondstothewordsafterhisdeathinthedream-content。Themostagonizingofhisafflictionshadbeenacompleteparalysisoftheintestinesobstructionduringthelastfewweeksofhislife。Allsortsofdisrespectfulthoughtsassociatethemselveswiththis。Oneofmycontemporaries,wholosthisfatherwhilestillattheGymnasium-uponwhichoccasionIwasprofoundlymoved,andtenderedhimmyfriendship-oncetoldme,derisively,ofthedistressofarelativewhosefatherhaddiedinthestreet,andhadbeenbroughthome,whenitappeared,uponundressingthecorpse,thatatthemomentofdeath,orpost-mortem,anevacuationofthebowelsStuhlentleerung
hadtakenplace。Thedaughterwasdeeplydistressedbythiscircumstance,becausethisuglydetailwouldinevitablyspoilhermemoryofherfather。
Wehavenowpenetratedtothewishthatisembodiedinthisdream。Tostandafterone’sdeathbeforeone’schildrengreatandundefiled:whowouldnotwishthat?Whatnowhasbecomeoftheabsurdityofthisdream?Theappearanceofabsurditywasdueonlytothefactthataperfectlypermissiblefigureofspeech,inwhichweareaccustomedtoignoreanyabsurditythatmayexistasbetweenitscomponents,hasbeenfaithfullyrepresentedinthedream。Hereagainwecanhardlydenythattheappearanceofabsurdityisdesiredandhasbeenpurposelyproduced。
Thefrequencywithwhichdeadpersonsappearinourdreamsaslivingandactiveandassociatingwithushasevokedundueastonishment,andsomecuriousexplanations,whichaffordconspicuousproofofourmisunderstandingofdreams。Andyettheexplanationofthesedreamsiscloseathand。Howoftenithappensthatwesaytoourselves:"Ifmyfatherwerestillalive,whatwouldhesaytothis?"Thedreamcanexpressthisifinnootherwaythanbyhispresenceinadefinitesituation。Thus,forinstance,ayoungmanwhosegrandfatherhaslefthimagreatinheritancedreamsthattheoldmanisalive,andcallshisgrandsontoaccount,reproachinghimforhislavishexpenditure。Whatweregardasanobjectiontothedreamonaccountofourbetterknowledgethatthemanisalreadydead,isinrealitytheconsolingthoughtthatthedeadmandoesnotneedtolearnthetruth,orsatisfactionoverthefactthathecannolongerhaveasayinthematter。
Anotherformofabsurdityfoundindreamsofdeceasedrelativesdoesnotexpressscornandderision;itservestoexpresstheextremestrepudiation,therepresentationofasuppressedthoughtwhichonewouldliketobelievetheverylastthingonewouldthinkof。Dreamsofthiskindappeartobecapableofsolutiononlyifwerememberthatadreammakesnodistinctionbetweendesireandreality。Forexample,amanwhonursedhisfatherduringhislastillness,andwhofelthisdeathverykeenly,dreamedsometimeafterwardsthefollowingsenselessdream:Hisfatherwasagainliving,andconversingwithhimasusual,butandthiswastheremarkablethinghehadneverthelessdied,thoughhedidnotknowit。Thisdreamisintelligibleif,afterhehadneverthelessdied,weinsertinconsequenceofthedreamer’swish,andifafterbuthedidnotknowit,weaddthatthedreamerhadentertainedthiswish。Whilenursinghim,thesonhadoftenwishedthathisfatherwasdead;thatis,hehadhadthereallycompassionatethoughtthatitwouldbeagoodthingifdeathwouldatlastputanendtohissufferings。Whilehewasmourninghisfather’sdeath,eventhiscompassionatewishbecameanunconsciousreproach,asthoughithadreallycontributedtoshortenthesickman’slife。Bytheawakeningoftheearliestinfantilefeelingsagainsthisfather,itbecamepossibletoexpressthisreproachasadream;anditwaspreciselybecauseoftheextremeantithesisbetweenthedream-instigatorandtheday-thoughtsthatthisdreamhadtoassumesoabsurdaform。*
*Cf。"FormulationsregardingtheTwoPrinciplesinMentalFunctioning,"
CollectedPapers,IV。
Asageneralthing,thedreamsofadeceasedpersonofwhomthedreamerhasbeenfondconfronttheinterpreterwithdifficultproblems,thesolutionofwhichisnotalwayssatisfying。Thereasonforthismaybesoughtintheespeciallypronouncedambivalenceoffeelingwhichcontrolstherelationofthedreamertothedeadperson。Insuchdreamsitisquiteusualforthedeceasedpersontobetreatedatfirstasliving;thenitsuddenlyappearsthatheisdead;andinthecontinuationofthedreamheisoncemoreliving。Thishasaconfusingeffect。Iatlastdivinedthatthisalternationofdeathandlifeisintendedtorepresenttheindifferenceofthedreamer"Itisallonetomewhetherheisaliveordead"。Thisindifference,ofcourse,isnotreal,butwished;itspurposeistohelpthedreamertodenyhisveryintenseandoftencontradictoryemotionalattitudes,andsoitbecomesthedream-representationofhisambivalence。Forotherdreamsinwhichonemeetswithdeceasedpersonsthefollowingrulewilloftenbeaguide:Ifinthedreamthedreamerisnotremindedthatthedeadpersonisdead,hesetshimselfonaparwiththedead;hedreamsofhisowndeath。
Thesuddenrealizationorastonishmentinthedream"buthehaslongbeendead!"isaprotestagainstthisidentification,andrejectsthemeaningthatthedreamerisdead。ButIwilladmitthatIfeelthatdream-interpretationisfarfromhavingelicitedallthesecretsofdreamshavingthiscontent。III。IntheexamplewhichIshallnowcite,Icandetectthedream-workintheactofpurposelymanufacturinganabsurdityforwhichthereisnooccasionwhateverinthedream-material。ItistakenfromthedreamwhichIhadasaresultofmeetingCountThunjustbeforegoingawayonaholiday。
Iamdrivinginacab,andItellthedrivertodrivetoarailwaystation。
"Ofcourse,Ican’tdrivewithyouontherailwaytrackitself,"Isay,afterthedriverhadreproachedme,asthoughIhadwornhimout;atthesametime,itseemsasthoughIhadalreadymadewithhimajourneythatoneusuallymakesbytrain。Ofthisconfusedandsenselessstoryanalysisgivesthefollowingexplanation:DuringthedayIhadhiredacabtotakemetoaremotestreetinDornbach。Thedriver,however,didnotknowtheway,andsimplykeptondriving,inthemannerofsuchworthypeople,untilIbecameawareofthefactandshowedhimtheway,indulginginafewderisiveremarks。FromthisdriveratrainofthoughtledtothearistocraticpersonagewhomIwastomeetlateron。Forthepresent,Iwillonlyremarkthatonethingthatstrikesusmiddle-classplebeiansaboutthearistocracyisthattheyliketoputthemselvesinthedriver’sseat。DoesnotCountThunguidetheAustriancarofState?Thenextsentenceinthedream,however,referstomybrother,whomIthusalsoidentifywiththecab-driver。I
hadrefusedtogotoItalywithhimthisyearOfcourse,Ican’tdrivewithyouontherailwaytrackitself,andthisrefusalwasasortofpunishmentforhisaccustomedcomplaintthatIusuallywearhimoutonthistourthisfindsitswayintothedreamunchangedbyrushinghimtooquicklyfromplacetoplace,andmakinghimseetoomanybeautifulthingsinasingleday。Thateveningmybrotherhadaccompaniedmetotherailwaystation,butshortlybeforethecarriagehadreachedtheWesternstationoftheMetropolitanRailwayhehadjumpedoutinordertotakethetraintoPurkersdorf。
Isuggestedtohimthathemightremainwithmealittlelonger,ashedidnottraveltoPurkersdorfbytheMetropolitanbutbytheWesternRailway。
Thisiswhy,inmydream,Imadeinthecabajourneywhichoneusuallymakesbytrain。Inreality,however,itwastheotherwayabout:whatI
toldmybrotherwas:"ThedistancewhichyoutravelontheMetropolitanRailwayyoucouldtravelinmycompanyontheWesternRailway"ThewholeconfusionofthedreamisthereforeduetothefactthatinmydreamI
replace"MetropolitanRailway"bycab,which,tobesure,doesgoodserviceinbringingthedriverandmybrotherintoconjunction。Ithenelicitfromthedreamsomenonsensewhichishardlydisentangledbyelucidation,andwhichalmostconstitutesacontradictionofmyearlierspeechofcourse,Icannotdrivewithyouontherailwaytrackitself。ButasIhavenoexcusewhateverforconfrontingtheMetropolitanRailwaywiththecab,Imustintentionallyhavegiventhewholeenigmaticalstorythispeculiarforminmydream。
Butwithwhatintention?Weshallnowlearnwhattheabsurdityinthedreamsignifies,andthemotiveswhichadmitteditorcreatedit。
Inthiscasethesolutionofthemysteryisasfollows:InthedreamI
needanabsurdity,andsomethingincomprehensible,inconnectionwithdrivingFahren=riding,drivingbecauseinthedream-thoughtsIhaveacertainopinionthatdemandsrepresentation。Oneevening,atthehouseofthewittyandhospitableladywhoappears,inanothersceneofthesamedream,asthehousekeeper,IheardtworiddleswhichIcouldnotsolve:Astheywereknowntotheothermembersoftheparty,Ipresentedasomewhatludicrousfigureinmyunsuccessfulattemptstofindthesolutions。TheyweretwopunsturningonthewordsNachkommentoobeyorders-offspringandVorfahrentodrive-forefathers,ancestry。Theyran,Ibelieve,asfollows:
ThecoachmandoesitAtthemaster’sbehests;
Everyonehasit;
Inthegraveitrests。
Vorfahren
Aconfusingdetailwasthatthefirsthalvesofthetworiddleswereidentical:
ThecoachmandoesitAtthemaster’sbehests;
Noteveryonehasit,Inthecradleitrests。
Nachkommen
WhenIsawCountThundriveupvorfahreninstate,andfellintotheFigaro-likemood,inwhichonefindsthatthesolemeritofsucharistocraticgentlemenisthattheyhavetakenthetroubletobeborntobecomeNachkommen,thesetworiddlesbecameintermediarythoughtsforthedream-work。Asaristocratsmayreadilybereplacedbycoachmen,andsinceitwasoncethecustomtocallacoachmanHerrSchwagerbrother-in-law,theworkofcondensationcouldinvolvemybrotherinthesamerepresentation。Butthedream-thoughtatworkinthebackgroundisasfollows:Itisnonsensetobeproudofone’sancestorsVorfahren。IwouldratherbeanancestorVorfahrmyself。
Onaccountofthisopinion,itisnonsense,wehavethenonsenseinthedream。Andnowthelastriddleinthisobscurepassageofthedreamissolved-namelythatIhavedrivenbeforevorhergefahren,vorgefaltren
withthisdriver。
Thus,adreamismadeabsurdifthereoccursinthedream-thoughts,asoneoftheelementsofthecontents,theopinion:"Thatisnonsense";
and,ingeneral,ifcriticismandderisionarethemotivesofoneofthedreamer’sunconscioustrainsofthought。Hence,absurdityisoneofthemeansbywhichthedream-workrepresentscontradiction;anothermeansistheinversionofmaterialrelationbetweenthedream-thoughtsandthedream-content;anotheristheemploymentofthefeelingofmotorinhibition。
Buttheabsurdityofadreamisnottobetranslatedbyasimpleno;itisintendedtoreproducethetendencyofthedream-thoughtstoexpresslaughterorderisionsimultaneouslywiththecontradiction。Onlywiththisintentiondoesthedream-workproduceanythingridiculous。Hereagainittransformsapartofthelatentcontentintoamanifestform。*
*Herethedream-workparodiesthethoughtwhichitqualifiesasridiculous,inthatitcreatessomethingridiculousinrelationtoit。HeinedoesthesamethingwhenhewishestoderidethebadrhymesoftheKingofBavaria。
Hedoesitbyusingevenworserhymes:
HerrLudwigisteingrosserPoetUndsingter,sosturztApolloVorihmaufdieKnieundbittetundfleht,Haltein,ichwerdesonsttoll,oh!
Asamatteroffact,wehavealreadycitedaconvincingexampleofthissignificanceofanabsurddream。Thedreaminterpretedwithoutanalysis
oftheWagnerianperformancewhichlasteduntil7。45a。m。,andinwhichtheorchestraisconductedfromatower,etc。seethischapter,D。,isobviouslysaving:Itisacrazyworldandaninsanesociety。Hewhodeservesathingdoesn’tgetit,andhewhodoesn’tcareforitdoesgetit。Inthiswaythedreamercomparesherfatewiththatofhercousin。Thefactthatdreamsofadeadfatherwerethefirsttofurnishuswithexamplesofabsurdityindreamsisbynomeansaccidental。Theconditionsforthecreationofabsurddreamsareheregroupedtogetherinatypicalfashion。
Theauthoritypropertothefatherhasatanearlyageevokedthecriticismofthechild,andthestrictdemandswhichhehasmadehavecausedthechild,inself-defence,topayparticularlycloseattentiontoeveryweaknessofhisfather’s;butthepietywithwhichthefather’spersonalityissurroundedinourthoughts,especiallyafterhisdeath,intensifiesthecensorshipwhichpreventstheexpressionofthiscriticismfrombecomingconscious。IV。Hereisanotherabsurddreamofadeceasedfather:
Ireceiveacommunicationfromthetowncouncilofmynativecityconcerningthecostofaccommodationinthehospitalintheyear1851。
ThiswasnecessitatedbyaseizurefromwhichIwassuffering。Imakefunofthematterfor,inthefirstplace,Iwasnotyetbornin1851,andinthesecondplace,myfather,towhomthecommunicationmightrefer,isalreadydead。Igotohimintheadjoiningroom,whereheislyinginbed,andtellhimaboutit。Tomysurpriseheremembersthatintheyear1851hewasoncedrinkandhadtobelockeduporconfined。ItwaswhenhewasworkingforthefirmofT。"Thenyou,too,usedtodrink?"Iask。
"Youmarriedsoonafter?"IreckonthatIwasbornin1856,whichseemstometobeimmediatelyafterwards。
Inthelightoftheforegoingexposition,weshalltranslatetheinsistencewithwhichthisdreamexhibitsitsabsurditiesasasuresignofaparticularlyembitteredandpassionatepolemicinthedream-thoughts。
Allthegreater,then,isourastonishmentwhenweperceivethatinthisdreamthepolemiciswagedopenly,andthatmyfatherisdenotedasthepersonwhoismadealaughing-stock。Suchfranknessseemstocontradictourassumptionofacensorshipcontrollingthedream-work。Theexplanationisthatherethefatherisonlyaninterposedfigure,whilethequarrelisreallywithanotherperson,whoappearsinthedreamonlyinasingleallusion。Whereasadreamusuallytreatsofrevoltagainstotherpersons,behindwhomthefatherisconcealed,hereitistheotherwayabout:thefatherservesasthemanofstrawtorepresentanother,andhencethedreamdarestoconcernitselfopenlywithapersonwhoisusuallyhallowed,becausethereispresentthecertainknowledgethatheisnotinrealityintended。
Welearnofthisconditionofaffairsbyconsideringtheoccasionofthedream。ItwasdreamedafterIhadheardthatanoldercolleague,whosejudgmentwasconsideredinfallible,hadexpresseddisapprovalandastonishmentonhearingthatoneofmypatientshadalreadybeenundergoingpsychoanalytictreatmentatmyhandsforfiveyears。Theintroductorysentencesofthedreamalludeinatransparentlydisguisedmannertothefactthatthiscolleaguehadforatimetakenoverthedutieswhichmyfathercouldnolongerperformstatementofexpenses,accommodationinthehospital;
andwhenourfriendlyrelationsbegantoalterfortheworseIwasthrownintothesameemotionalconflictasthatwhicharisesinthecaseofamisunderstandingbetweenfatherandsonbyreasonofthepartplayedbythefather,andhisearlierfunctions。Thedream-thoughtsnowbitterlyresentthereproachthatIamnotmakingbetterprogress,whichextendsitselffromthetreatmentofthispatienttootherthings。Doesmycolleagueknowanyonewhocangetonanyfaster?Doeshenotknowthatconditionsofthissortareusuallyincurableandlastforlife?Whatarefourorfiveyearsincomparisontoawholelifetime,especiallywhenlifehasbeenmadesomucheasierforthepatientduringthetreatment?
Theimpressionofabsurdityinthisdreamisbroughtaboutlargelybythefactthatsentencesfromdifferentdivisionsofthedream-thoughtsarestrungtogetherwithoutanyreconcilingtransition。Thus,thesentence,Igotohimittheadjoiningroom,etc。,leavesthesubjectfromwhichtheprecedingsentencesaretaken,andfaithfullyreproducesthecircumstancesunderwhichItoldmyfatherthatIwasengagedtobemarried。Thusthedreamistryingtoremindmeofthenobledisinterestednesswhichtheoldmanshowedatthattime,andtocontrastthiswiththeconductofanothernewly-introducedperson。Inowperceivethatthedreamisallowedtomakefunofmyfatherbecauseinthedream-thoughts,inthefullrecognitionofhismerits,heisheldupasanexampletoothers。Itisinthenatureofeverycensorshipthatoneispermittedtotelluntruthsaboutforbiddenthingsratherthanthetruth。Thenextsentence,totheeffectthatmyfatherremembersthathewasoncedrink,andwaslockedupinconsequence,containsnothingthatreallyrelatestomyfatheranymore。ThepersonwhoisscreenedbyhimishereanolessimportantpersonagethanthegreatMeynert,inwhosefootstepsIfollowedwithsuchveneration,andwhoseattitudetowardsme,afterashortperiodoffavouritism,changedintooneofundisguisedhostility。Thedreamrecallstomehisownstatementthatinhisyouthhehadatonetimeformedthehabitofintoxicatinghimselfwithchloroform,withtheresultthathehadtoenterasanatorium;andalsomysecondexperiencewithhim,shortlybeforehisdeath。Ihadanembitteredliterarycontroversywithhiminreferencetomasculinehysteria,theexistenceofwhichhedenied,andwhenIvisitedhimduringhislastillness,andaskedhimhowhefelt,hedescribedhisconditionatsomelength,andconcludedwiththewords:"Youknow,Ihavealwaysbeenoneoftheprettiestcasesofmasculinehysteria。"Thus,tomysatisfaction,andtomyastonishment,headmittedwhathesolongandsostubbornlydenied。
ButthefactthatinthissceneofmydreamIcanusemyfathertoscreenMeynertisexplainednotbyanydiscoveredanalogybetweenthetwopersons,butbythefactthatitisthebriefyetperfectlyadequaterepresentationofaconditionalsentenceinthedream-thoughtswhich,iffullyexpanded,wouldreadasfollows:"Ofcourse,ifIbelongedtothesecondgeneration,ifIwerethesonofaprofessororaprivycouncillor,Ishouldhaveprogressedmorerapidly。"InmydreamImakemyfatheraprofessorandaprivycouncillor。
Themostobviousandmostannoyingabsurdityofthedreamliesinthetreatmentofthedate1851,whichseemstometobeindistinguishablefrom1856,asthoughadifferenceoffiveyearsmeantnothingwhatever。Butitisjustthisoneofthedream-thoughtsthatrequiresexpression。Fourorfiveyears-thatispreciselythelengthoftimeduringwhichIenjoyedthesupportofthecolleaguementionedattheoutset;butitisalsothedurationoftimeIkeptmyfiancewaitingbeforeImarriedher;andbyacoincidencethatiseagerlyexploitedbythedream-thoughts,itisalsothetimeI
havekeptmyoldestpatientwaitingforacompletecure。"Whatarefiveyears?"askthedream-thoughts。"Thatisnotimeatalltome,thatisn’tworthconsideration。Ihavetimeenoughaheadofme,andjustaswhatyouwouldn’tbelievecametrueatlast,soIshallaccomplishthisalso。"Moreover,thenumber51,whenconsideredapartfromthenumberofthecentury,isdeterminedinyetanothermannerandinanoppositesense;forwhichreasonitoccursseveraltimesoverinthedream。Itistheageatwhichmanseemsparticularlyexposedtodanger;theageatwhichIhaveseencolleaguesdiesuddenly,amongthemonewhohadbeenappointedafewdaysearliertoaprofessorshipforwhichhehadlongbeenwaiting。V。Anotherabsurddreamwhichplayswithfigures:
Anacquaintanceofmine,HerrM,hasbeenattackedinanessaybynolessapersonthanGoetheand,asweallthink,withunjustifiablevehemence。HerrMis,ofcourse,crushedbythisattack。Hecomplainsofitbitterlyatadinner-party;buthisvenerationforGoethehasnotsufferedasaresultofthispersonalexperience。Itrytoelucidatethetemporalrelationsalittle,astheyseemimprobabletome。Goethediedin1832;
sincehisattackuponMmust,ofcourse,havetakenplaceearlier,Mwasatthetimequiteayoungman。Itseemsplausibletomethathewas18
yearsold。ButIdonotknowexactlywhatthedateofthepresentyearis,andsothewholecalculationlapsesintoobscurity。Theattack,bytheway,iscontainedinGoethe’swell-knownessayon"Nature。"
Weshallsoonfindthemeansofjustifyingthenonsenseofthisdream。HerrM,withwhomIbecameacquaintedatadinner-party,hadrecentlyaskedmetoexaminehisbrother,whoshowedsignsofgeneralparalysis。