AndnowWilliamthoughtthatthetimehadcomewhenheoughttoexplainhimself。HeaccordinglysentforHalifax,Danby,Shrewsbury,andsomeotherpoliticalleadersofgreatnote,and,withthatairofstoicalapathyunderwhichhehad,fromaboy,beeninthehabitofconcealinghisstrongestemotions,addressedtothemafewdeeplymeditatedandweightywords。
Hehadhitherto,hesaid,remainedsilent;hehadusedneithersolicitationnormenace:hehadnotevensufferedahintofhisopinionsorwishestogetabroad:butacrisishadnowarrivedatwhichitwasnecessaryforhimtodeclarehisintentions。HehadnorightandnowishtodictatetotheConvention。Allthatheclaimedwastheprivilegeofdeclininganyofficewhichhefeltthathecouldnotholdwithhonourtohimselfandwithbenefittothepublic。
AstrongpartywasforaRegency。ItwasfortheHousestodeterminewhethersuchanarrrangementwouldbefortheinterestofthenation。Hehadadecidedopiniononthatpoint;andhethoughtitrighttosaydistinctlythathewouldnotbeRegent。
AnotherpartywasforplacingthePrincessonthethrone,andforgivingtohim,duringherlife,thetitleofKing,andsuchashareintheadministrationasshemightbepleasedtoallowhim。
Hecouldnotstooptosuchapost。HeesteemedthePrincessasmuchasitwaspossibleformantoesteemwoman:butnotevenfromherwouldheacceptasubordinateandaprecariousplaceinthegovernment。Hewassomadethathecouldnotsubmittobetiedtotheapronstringsevenofthebestofwives。HedidnotdesiretotakeanypartinEnglishaffairs;but,ifhedidconsenttotakeapart,therewasonepartonlywhichhecouldusefullyorhonourablytake。IftheEstatesofferedhimthecrownforlife,hewouldacceptit。Ifnot,heshould,withoutrepining,returntohisnativecountry。HeconcludedbysayingthathethoughtitreasonablethattheLadyAnneandherposterityshouldbepreferredinthesuccessiontoanychildrenwhomhemighthavebyanyotherwifethantheLadyMary。662
Themeetingbrokeup;andwhatthePrincehadsaidwasinafewhoursknownalloverLondon。ThathemustbeKingwasnowclear。
TheonlyquestionwaswhetherheshouldholdtheregaldignityaloneorconjointlywiththePrincess。Halifaxandafewotherpoliticians,whosawinastronglightthedangerofdividingthesupremeexecutiveauthority,thoughtitdesirablethat,duringWilliam’slife,MaryshouldbeonlyQueenConsortandasubject。
Butthisarrangement,thoughmuchmightdoubtlessbesaidforitinargument,shockedthegeneralfeelingevenofthoseEnglishmenwhoweremostattachedtothePrince。Hiswifehadgivenanunprecedentedproofofconjugalsubmissionandaffection;andtheveryleastreturnthatcouldbemadetoherwouldbetobestowonherthedignityofQueenRegnant。WilliamHerbert,oneofthemostzealousofthePrince’sadherents,wassomuchexasperatedthathesprangoutofthebedtowhichhewasconfinedbygout,andvehementlydeclaredthatheneverwouldhavedrawnaswordinHisHighness’scauseifhehadforeseenthatsoshamefulanarrangementwouldbemade。NopersontookthematterupsoeagerlyasBurnet。Hisbloodboiledatthewrongdonetohiskindpatroness。HeexpostulatedvehementlywithBentinck,andbeggedtobepermittedtoresignthechaplainship。"WhileIamHisHighness’sservant,"saidthebraveandhonestdivine,"itwouldbeunseemlyinmetoopposeanyplanwhichmayhavehiscountenance。Ithereforedesiretobesetfree,thatImayfightthePrincess’sbattlewitheveryfacultythatGodhasgivenme。"
BentinckprevailedonBurnettodeferanopendeclarationofhostilitiestillWilliam’sresolutionshouldbedistinctlyknown。
Inafewhourstheschemewhichhadexcitedsomuchresentmentwasentirelygivenup;andallthosewhoconsideredJamesasnolongerkingwereagreedastothewayinwhichthethronemustbefilled。WilliamandMarymustbeKingandQueen。Theheadsofbothmustappeartogetheronthecoin:writsmustruninthenamesofboth:bothmustenjoyallthepersonaldignitiesandimmunitiesofroyalty:buttheadministration,whichcouldnotbesafelydivided,mustbelongtoWilliamalone。663
AndnowthetimearrivedforthefreeconferencebetweentheHouses。ThemanagersfortheLords,intheirrobes,tooktheirseatsalongonesideofthetableinthePaintedChamber:butthecrowdofmembersoftheHouseofCommonsontheothersidewassogreatthatthegentlemenwhoweretoarguethequestioninvaintriedtogetthrough。ItwasnotwithoutmuchdifficultyandlongdelaythattheSerjeantatArmswasabletoclearapassage。664
Atlengththediscussionbegan。Afullreportofthespeechesonbothsideshascomedowntous。Therearefewstudentsofhistorywhohavenottakenupthatreportwitheagercuriosityandlaiditdownwithdisappointment。ThequestionbetweentheHouseswasarguedonbothsidesasaquestionoflaw。TheobjectionswhichtheLordsmade,totheresolutionoftheCommonswereverbalandtechnical,andweremetbyverbalandtechnicalanswers。SomersvindicatedtheuseofthewordabdicationbyquotationsfromGrotiusandBrissonius,SpigeliusandBartolus。WhenhewaschallengedtoshowanyauthorityforthepropositionthatEnglandcouldbewithoutasovereign,heproducedtheParliamentrolloftheyear1399,inwhichitwasexpresslysetforththatthekinglyofficewasvacantduringtheintervalbetweentheresignationofRichardtheSecondandtheenthroningofHenrytheFourth。TheLordsrepliedbyproducingtheParliamentrollofthefirstyearofEdwardtheFourth,fromwhichitappearedthattherecordof1399hadbeensolemnlyannulled。TheythereforemaintainedthattheprecedentonwhichSomersreliedwasnolongervalid。TrebythencametoSomers’sassistance,andbroughtforththeParliamentrollofthefirstyearofHenrytheSeventh,whichrepealedtheactofEdwardtheFourth,andconsequentlyrestoredthevalidityoftherecordof1399。Afteracolloquyofseveralhoursthedisputantsseparated。665TheLordsassembledintheirownhouse。Itwaswellunderstoodthattheywereabouttoyield,andthattheconferencehadbeenamereform。ThefriendsofMaryhadfoundthat,bysettingherupasherhusband’srival,theyhaddeeplydispleasedher。SomeofthePeerswhohadformerlyvotedforaRegencyhaddeterminedtoabsentthemselvesortosupporttheresolutionoftheLowerHouse。Theiropinion,theysaid,wasunchanged:butanygovernmentwasbetterthannogovernment,andthecountrycouldnotbearaprolongationofthisagonyofsuspense。EvenNottingham,who,inthePaintedChamber,hadtakentheleadagainsttheCommons,declaredthat,thoughhisownconsciencewouldnotsufferhimtogiveway,hewasgladthattheconsciencesofothermenwerelesssqueamish。SeveralLordswhohadnotyetvotedintheConventionhadbeeninducedtoattend;LordLexington,whohadjusthurriedoverfromtheContinent;theEarlofLincoln,whowashalfmad;theEarlofCarlisle,wholimpedinoncrutches;andtheBishopofDurham,whohadbeeninhidingandhadintendedtoflybeyondsea,buthadreceivedanintimationthat,ifhewouldvoteforthesettlingofthegovernment,hisconductintheEcclesiasticalCommissionshouldnotberememberedagainsthim。Danby,desiroustohealtheschismwhichhehadcaused,exhortedtheHouse,inaspeechdistinguishedbyevenmorethanhisusualability,nottopersevereinacontestwhichmightbefataltothestate。HewasstrenuouslysupportedbyHalifax。Thespiritoftheoppositepartywasquelled。WhenthequestionwasputwhetherKingJameshadabdicatedthegovernmentonlythreelordssaidNotContent。
Onthequestionwhetherthethronewasvacant,adivisionwasdemanded。TheContentsweresixty—two;theNotContentsforty—
seven。Itwasimmediatelyproposedandcarried,withoutadivision,thatthePrinceandPrincessofOrangeshouldbedeclaredKingandQueenofEngland。666
Nottinghamthenmovedthatthewordingoftheoathsofallegianceandsupremacyshouldbealteredinsuchawaythattheymightbeconscientiouslytakenbypersonswho,likehimself,disapprovedofwhattheConventionhaddone,andyetfullypurposedtobeloyalanddutifulsubjectsofthenewsovereigns。Tothispropositionnoobjectionwasmade。IndeedtherecanbelittledoubtthattherewasanunderstandingonthesubjectbetweentheWhigleadersandthoseToryLordswhosevoteshadturnedthescaleonthelastdivision。ThenewoathsweresentdowntotheCommons,togetherwiththeresolutionthatthePrinceandPrincessshouldbedeclaredKingandQueen。667
Itwasnowknowntowhomthecrownwouldbegiven。Onwhatconditionsitshouldbegiven,stillremainedtobedecided。TheCommonshadappointedacommitteetoconsiderwhatstepsitmightbeadvisabletotake,inordertosecurelawandlibertyagainsttheaggressionsoffuturesovereigns;andthecommitteehadmadeareport。668Thisreportrecommended,first,thatthosegreatprinciplesoftheconstitutionwhichhadbeenviolatedbythedethronedKingshouldbesolemnlyasserted,and,secondly,thatmanynewlawsshouldbeenacted,forthepurposeofcurbingtheprerogativeandpurifyingtheadministrationofjustice。Mostofthesuggestionsofthecommitteewereexcellent;butitwasutterlyimpossiblethattheHousescould,inamonth,oreveninayear,dealproperlywithmatterssonumerous,sovarious,andsoimportant。Itwasproposed,amongotherthings,thatthemilitiashouldberemodelled,thatthepowerwhichthesovereignpossessedofproroguinganddissolvingParliamentsshouldberestricted;thatthedurationofParliamentsshouldbelimited;
thattheroyalpardonshouldnolongerbepleadabletoaparliamentaryimpeachment;thattolerationshouldbegrantedtoProtestantDissenters;thatthecrimeofhightreasonshouldbemorepreciselydefined;thattrialsforhightreasonshouldbeconductedinamannermorefavourabletoinnocence;thatthejudgesshouldholdtheirplacesforlife;thatthemodeofappointingSheriffsshouldbealtered;thatjuriesshouldbenominatedinsuchawayasmightexcludepartialityandcorruption;thatthepracticeoffilingcriminalinformationsintheKing’sBenchshouldbeabolished;thattheCourtofChanceryshouldbereformed;thatthefeesofpublicfunctionariesshouldberegulated;andthatthelawofQuoWarrantoshouldbeamended。
Itwasevidentthatcautiousanddeliberatelegislationonthesesubjectsmustbetheworkofmorethanonelaborioussession;anditwasequallyevidentthathastyandcrudelegislationonsubjectssogravecouldnotbutproducenewgrievances,worsethanthosewhichitmightremove。Ifthecommitteemeanttogivealistofthereformswhichoughttobeaccomplishedbeforethethronewasfilled,thelistwasabsurdlylong。If,ontheotherhand,thecommitteemeanttogivealistofallthereformswhichthelegislaturewoulddowelltomakeinproperseason,thelistwasstrangelyimperfect。Indeed,assoonasthereporthadbeenread,memberaftermemberrosetosuggestsomeaddition。Itwasmovedandcarriedthatthesellingofofficesshouldbeprohibited,thattheHabeasCorpusActshouldbemademoreefficient,andthatthelawofMandamusshouldberevised。Onegentlemanfellonthechimneymen,anotherontheexcisemen;andtheHouseresolvedthatthemalpracticesofbothchimneymenandexcisemenshouldberestrained。Itisamostremarkablecircumstancethat,whilethewholepolitical,military,judicial,andfiscalsystemofthekingdomwasthuspassedinreview,notasinglerepresentativeofthepeopleproposedtherepealofthestatutewhichsubjectedthepresstoacensorship。Itwasnotyetunderstood,evenbythemostenlightenedmen,thatthelibertyofdiscussionisthechiefsafeguardofallotherliberties。669
TheHousewasgreatlyperplexed。Someoratorsvehementlysaidthattoomuchtimehadalreadybeenlost,andthatthegovernmentoughttobesettledwithoutthedelayofaday。Societywasunquiet:tradewaslanguishing:theEnglishcolonyinIrelandwasinimminentdangerofperishing,aforeignwarwasimpending:
theexiledKingmight,inafewweeks,beatDublinwithaFrencharmy,andfromDublinhemightsooncrosstoChester。Wasitnotinsanity,atsuchacrisis,toleavethethroneunfilled,and,whiletheveryexistenceofParliamentswasinjeopardy,towastetimeindebatingwhetherParliamentsshouldbeproroguedbythesovereignorbythemselves?OntheothersideitwasaskedwhethertheConventioncouldthinkthatithadfulfilleditsmissionbymerelypullingdownoneprinceandputtingupanother。
Surelynoworneverwasthetimetosecurepubliclibertybysuchfencesasmighteffectuallypreventtheencroachmentsofprerogative。670Therewasdoubtlessgreatweightinwhatwasurgedonbothsides。TheablechiefsoftheWhigparty,amongwhomSomerswasfastrisingtoascendency,proposedamiddlecourse。TheHousehad,theysaid,twoobjectsinview,whichoughttobekeptdistinct。Oneobjectwastosecuretheoldpolityoftherealmagainstillegalattacks:theotherwastoimprovethatpolitybylegalreforms。Theformerobjectmightbeattainedbysolemnlyputtingonrecord,intheresolutionwhichcalledthenewsovereignstothethrone,theclaimoftheEnglishnationtoitsancientfranchises,sothattheKingmightholdhiscrown,andthepeopletheirprivileges,byoneandthesametitledeed。Thelatterobjectwouldrequireawholevolumeofelaboratestatutes。Theformerobjectmightbeattainedinaday;thelatter,scarcelyinfiveyears。Astotheformerobject,allpartieswereagreed:astothelatter,therewereinnumerablevarietiesofopinion。NomemberofeitherHousewouldhesitateforamomenttovotethattheKingcouldnotlevytaxeswithouttheconsentofParliament:butitwouldbehardlypossibletoframeanynewlawofprocedureincasesofhightreasonwhichwouldnotgiverisetolongdebate,andbecondemnedbysomepersonsasunjusttotheprisoner,andbyothersasunjusttothecrown。ThebusinessofanextraordinaryconventionoftheEstatesoftheRealmwasnottodotheordinaryworkofParliaments,toregulatethefeesofmastersinChancery,andtoprovideagainsttheexactionsofgaugers,buttoputrightthegreatmachineofgovernment。Whenthishadbeendone,itwouldbetimetoinquirewhatimprovementourinstitutionsneeded:norwouldanythingberiskedbydelay;fornosovereignwhoreignedmerelybythechoiceofthenationcouldlongrefusehisassenttoanyimprovementwhichthenation,speakingthroughitsrepresentatives,demanded。
OnthesegroundstheCommonswiselydeterminedtopostponeallreformstilltheancientconstitutionofthekingdomshouldhavebeenrestoredinallitsparts,andforthwithtofillthethronewithoutimposingonWilliamandMaryanyotherobligationthanthatofgoverningaccordingtotheexistinglawsofEngland。InorderthatthequestionswhichhadbeenindisputebetweentheStuartsandthenationmightneveragainbestirred,itwasdeterminedthattheinstrumentbywhichthePrinceandPrincessofOrangewerecalledtothethrone,andbywhichtheorderofsuccessionwassettled,shouldsetforth,inthemostdistinctandsolemnmanner,thefundamentalprinciplesoftheconstitution。Thisinstrument,knownbythenameoftheDeclarationofRight,waspreparedbyacommittee,ofwhichSomerswaschairman。ThefactthatthelowbornyoungbarristerwasappointedtosohonourableandimportantapostinaParliamentfilledwithableandexperiencedmen,onlytendaysafterhehadspokenintheHouseofCommonsforthefirsttime,sufficientlyprovesthesuperiorityofhisabilities。InafewhourstheDeclarationwasframedandapprovedbytheCommons。TheLordsassentedtoitwithsomeamendmentsofnogreatimportance。671
TheDeclarationbeganbyrecapitulatingthecrimesanderrorswhichhadmadearevolutionnecessary。Jameshadinvadedtheprovinceofthelegislature;hadtreatedmodestpetitioningasacrime;hadoppressedtheChurchbymeansofanillegaltribunal;
had,withouttheconsentofParliament,leviedtaxesandmaintainedastandingarmyintimeofpeace;hadviolatedthefreedomofelection,andpervertedthecourseofjustice。
ProceedingswhichcouldlawfullybequestionedonlyinParliamenthadbeenmadethesubjectsofprosecutionintheKing’sBench。
Partialandcorruptjurieshadbeenreturned:excessivebailhadbeenrequiredfromprisoners,excessivefineshadbeenimposed:
barbarousandunusualpunishmentshadbeeninflicted:theestatesofaccusedpersonshadbeengrantedawaybeforeconviction。He,bywhoseauthoritythesethingshadbeendone,hadabdicatedthegovernment。ThePrinceofOrange,whomGodhadmadethegloriousinstrumentofdeliveringthenationfromsuperstitionandtyranny,hadinvitedtheEstatesoftheRealmtomeetandtotakecounseltogetherforthesecuringofreligion,oflaw,andoffreedom。TheLordsandCommons,havingdeliberated,hadresolvedthattheywouldfirst,aftertheexampleoftheirancestors,asserttheancientrightsandlibertiesofEngland。Thereforeitwasdeclaredthatthedispensingpower,latelyassumedandexercised,hadnolegalexistence;that,withoutgrantofParliament,nomoneycouldbeexactedbythesovereignfromthesubject;that,withoutconsentofParliament,nostandingarmycouldbekeptupintimeofpeace。Therightofsubjectstopetition,therightofelectorstochooserepresentativesfreely,therightofParliamentstofreedomofdebate,therightofthenationtoapureandmercifuladministrationofjusticeaccordingtothespiritofitsownmildlaws,weresolemnlyaffirmed。AllthesethingstheConventionclaimed,inthenameofthewholenation,astheundoubtedinheritanceofEnglishmen。Havingthusvindicatedtheprinciplesoftheconstitution,theLordsandCommons,intheentireconfidencethatthedelivererwouldholdsacredthelawsandlibertieswhichhehadsaved,resolvedthatWilliamandMary,PrinceandPrincessofOrange,shouldbedeclaredKingandQueenofEnglandfortheirjointandseparatelives,andthat,duringtheirjointlives,theadministrationofthegovernmentshouldbeinthePrincealone。AfterthemthecrownwassettledontheposterityofMary,thenonAnneandherposterity,andthenontheposterityofWilliam。
Bythistimethewindhadceasedtoblowfromthewest。TheshipinwhichthePrincessofOrangehadembarkedlayoffMargateontheeleventhofFebruary,and,onthefollowingmorning,anchoredatGreenwich。672Shewasreceivedwithmanysignsofjoyandaffection:butherdemeanourshockedtheTories,andwasnotthoughtfaultlessevenbytheWhigs。Ayoungwoman,placed,byadestinyasmournfulandawfulasthatwhichbroodedoverthefabledhousesofLabdacusandPelops,insuchasituationthatshecouldnot,withoutviolatingherdutytoherGod,herhusband,andhercountry,refusetotakeherseatonthethronefromwhichherfatherhadjustbeenhurled,shouldhavebeensad,oratleastserious。Marywasnotmerelyinhigh,butinextravagant,spirits。SheenteredWhitehall,itwasasserted,withagirlishdelightatbeingmistressofsofineahouse,ranabouttherooms,peepedintotheclosets,andexaminedthequiltofthestatebed,withoutseemingtorememberbywhomthosemagnificentapartmentshadlastbeenoccupied。Burnet,whohad,tillthen,thoughtheranangelinhumanform,couldnot,onthisoccasion,refrainfromblamingher。Hewasthemoreastonishedbecause,whenhetookleaveofherattheHague,shehad,thoughfullyconvincedthatshewasinthepathofduty,beendeeplydejected。Tohim,astoherspiritualguide,sheafterwardsexplainedherconduct。Williamhadwrittentoinformherthatsomeofthosewhohadtriedtoseparateherinterestfromhisstillcontinuedtheirmachinations:theygaveitoutthatshethoughtherselfwronged;and,ifsheworeagloomycountenance,thereportwouldbeconfirmed。Hethereforeintreatedhertomakeherfirstappearancewithanairofcheerfulness。Herheart,shesaid,wasfarindeedfromcheerful;butshehaddoneherbest;
and,asshewasafraidofnotsustainingwellapartwhichwasuncongenialtoherfeelings,shehadoveractedit。Herdeportmentwasthesubjectofreamsofscurrilityinproseandverse:itloweredherintheopinionofsomewhoseesteemshevalued;nordidtheworldknow,tillshewasbeyondthereachofpraiseandcensure,thattheconductwhichhadbroughtonherthereproachoflevityandinsensibilitywasreallyasignalinstanceofthatperfectdisinterestednessandselfdevotionofwhichmanseemstobeincapable,butwhichissometimesfoundinwoman。673
OnthemorningofWednesday,thethirteenthofFebruary,thecourtofWhitehallandalltheneighbouringstreetswerefilledwithgazers。ThemagnificentBanquetingHouse,themasterpieceofInigo,embellishedbymasterpiecesofRubens,hadbeenpreparedforagreatceremony。Thewallswerelinedbytheyeomenoftheguard。Nearthenortherndoor,ontherighthand,alargenumberofPeershadassembled。OntheleftweretheCommonswiththeirSpeaker,attendedbythemace。Thesoutherndooropened:andthePrinceandPrincessofOrange,sidebyside,entered,andtooktheirplaceunderthecanopyofstate。
BothHousesapproachedbowinglow。WilliamandMaryadvancedafewsteps。Halifaxontheright,andPowleontheleft,stoodforth;andHalifaxspoke。TheConvention,hesaid,hadagreedtoaresolutionwhichheprayedTheirHighnessestohear。Theysignifiedtheirassent;andtheclerkoftheHouseofLordsread,inaloudvoice,theDeclarationofRight。Whenhehadconcluded,Halifax,inthenameofalltheEstatesoftheRealm,requestedthePrinceandPrincesstoacceptthecrown。
William,inhisownnameandinthatofhiswife,answeredthatthecrownwas,intheirestimation,themorevaluablebecauseitwaspresentedtothemasatokenoftheconfidenceofthenation。
"Wethankfullyaccept,"hesaid,"whatyouhaveofferedus。"
Then,forhimself,heassuredthemthatthelawsofEngland,whichhehadoncealreadyvindicated,shouldbetherulesofhisconduct,thatitshouldbehisstudytopromotethewelfareofthekingdom,andthat,astothemeansofdoingso,heshouldconstantlyrecurtotheadviceoftheHouses,andshouldbedisposedtotrusttheirjudgmentratherthanhisown。674Thesewordswerereceivedwithashoutofjoywhichwasheardinthestreetsbelow,andwasinstantlyansweredbyhuzzasfrommanythousandsofvoices。TheLordsandCommonsthenreverentlyretiredfromtheBanquetingHouseandwentinprocessiontothegreatgateofWhitehall,wheretheheraldsandpursuivantswerewaitingintheirgorgeoustabards。AllthespaceasfarasCharingCrosswasoneseaofheads。Thekettledrumsstruckup;
thetrumpetspealed:andGarterKingatarms,inaloudvoice,proclaimedthePrinceandPrincessofOrangeKingandQueenofEngland,chargedallEnglishmentopay,fromthatmoment,faithandtrueallegiancetothenewsovereigns,andbesoughtGod,whohadalreadywroughtsosignaladeliveranceforourChurchandnation,toblessWilliamandMarywithalongandhappyreign。675
ThuswasconsummatedtheEnglishRevolution。Whenwecompareitwiththoserevolutionswhichhave,duringthelastsixtyyears,overthrownsomanyancientgovernments,wecannotbutbestruckbyitspeculiarcharacter。Whythatcharacterwassopeculiarissufficientlyobvious,andyetseemsnottohavebeenalwaysunderstoodeitherbyeulogistsorbycensors。
Thecontinentalrevolutionsoftheeighteenthandnineteenthcenturiestookplaceincountrieswherealltraceofthelimitedmonarchyofthemiddleageshadlongbeeneffaced。Therightoftheprincetomakelawsandtolevymoneyhad,duringmanygenerations,beenundisputed。Histhronewasguardedbyagreatregulararmy。Hisadministrationcouldnot,withoutextremeperil,beblamedeveninthemildestterms。Hissubjectsheldtheirpersonallibertybynoothertenurethanhispleasure。Notasingleinstitutionwasleftwhichhad,withinthememoryoftheoldestman,affordedefficientprotectiontothesubjectagainsttheutmostexcessoftyranny。Thosegreatcouncilswhichhadoncecurbedtheregalpowerhadsunkintooblivion。Theircompositionandtheirprivilegeswereknownonlytoantiquaries。Wecannotwonder,therefore,that,whenmenwhohadbeenthusruledsucceededinwrestingsupremepowerfromagovernmentwhichtheyhadlonginsecrethated,theyshouldhavebeenimpatienttodemolishandunabletoconstruct,thattheyshouldhavebeenfascinatedbyeveryspeciousnovelty,thattheyshouldhaveproscribedeverytitle,ceremony,andphraseassociatedwiththeoldsystem,andthat,turningawaywithdisgustfromtheirownnationalprecedentsandtraditions,theyshouldhavesoughtforprinciplesofgovernmentinthewritingsoftheorists,oraped,withignorantandungracefulaffectation,thepatriotsofAthensandRome。Aslittlecanwewonderthattheviolentactionoftherevolutionaryspiritshouldhavebeenfollowedbyreactionequallyviolent,andthatconfusionshouldspeedilyhaveengendereddespotismsternerthanthatfromwhichithadsprung。
Hadwebeeninthesamesituation;hadStraffordsucceededinhisfavouriteschemeofThorough;hadheformedanarmyasnumerousandaswelldisciplinedasthatwhich,afewyearslater,wasformedbyCromwell;hadaseriesofjudicialdecisions,similartothatwhichwaspronouncedbytheExchequerChamberinthecaseofshipmoney,transferredtothecrowntherightoftaxingthepeople;hadtheStarChamberandtheHighCommissioncontinuedtofine,mutilate,andimprisoneverymanwhodaredtoraisehisvoiceagainstthegovernment;hadthepressbeenascompletelyenslavedhereasatViennaoratNaples;hadourKingsgraduallydrawntothemselvesthewholelegislativepower;hadsixgenerationsofEnglishmenpassedawaywithoutasinglesessionofparliament;andhadwethenatlengthrisenupinsomemomentofwildexcitementagainstourmasters,whatanoutbreakwouldthathavebeen!Withwhatacrash,heardandfelttothefarthestendsoftheworld,wouldthewholevastfabricofsocietyhavefallen!
Howmanythousandsofexiles,oncethemostprosperousandthemostrefinedmembersofthisgreatcommunity,wouldhavebeggedtheirbreadincontinentalcities,orhaveshelteredtheirheadsunderhutsofbarkintheunclearedforestsofAmerica!HowoftenshouldwehaveseenthepavementofLondonpiledupinbarricades,thehousesdintedwithbullets,theguttersfoamingwithblood!Howmanytimesshouldwehaverushedwildlyfromextremetoextreme,soughtrefugefromanarchyindespotism,andbeenagaindrivenbydespotismintoanarchy!Howmanyyearsofbloodandconfusionwouldithavecostustolearntheveryrudimentsofpoliticalscience!Howmanychildishtheorieswouldhavedupedus!Howmanyrudeandillpoisedconstitutionsshouldwehavesetup,onlytoseethemtumbledown!Happywouldithavebeenforusifasharpdisciplineofhalfacenturyhadsufficedtoeducateusintoacapacityofenjoyingtruefreedom。
ThesecalamitiesourRevolutionaverted。Itwasarevolutionstrictlydefensive,andhadprescriptionandlegitimacyonitsside。Here,andhereonly,alimitedmonarchyofthethirteenthcenturyhadcomedownunimpairedtotheseventeenthcentury。Ourparliamentaryinstitutionswereinfullvigour。Themainprinciplesofourgovernmentwereexcellent。Theywerenot,indeed,formallyandexactlysetforthinasinglewritteninstrument;buttheyweretobefoundscatteredoverourancientandnoblestatutes;and,whatwasoffargreatermoment,theyhadbeenengravenontheheartsofEnglishmenduringfourhundredyears。That,withouttheconsentoftherepresentativesofthenation,nolegislativeactcouldbepassed,notaximposed,noregularsoldierykeptup,thatnomancouldbeimprisoned,evenforaday,bythearbitrarywillofthesovereign,thatnotoolofpowercouldpleadtheroyalcommandasajustificationforviolatinganyrightofthehumblestsubject,wereheld,bothbyWhigsandTories,tobefundamentallawsoftherealm。Arealmofwhichthesewerethefundamentallawsstoodinnoneedofanewconstitution。
But,thoughanewconstitutionwasnotneeded,itwasplainthatchangeswererequired。ThemisgovernmentoftheStuarts,andthetroubleswhichthatmisgovernmenthadproduced,sufficientlyprovedthattherewassomewhereadefectinourpolity;andthatdefectitwasthedutyoftheConventiontodiscoverandtosupply。
Somequestionsofgreatmomentwerestillopentodispute。Ourconstitutionhadbeguntoexistintimeswhenstatesmenwerenotmuchaccustomedtoframeexactdefinitions。Anomalies,therefore,inconsistentwithitsprinciplesanddangeroustoitsveryexistence,hadsprungupalmostimperceptibly,and,nothaving,duringmanyyears,causedanyseriousinconvenience,hadgraduallyacquiredtheforceofprescription。Theremedyfortheseevilswastoasserttherightsofthepeopleinsuchlanguageasshouldterminateallcontroversy,andtodeclarethatnoprecedentcouldjustifyanyviolationofthoserights。
Whenthishadbeendoneitwouldbeimpossibleforourrulerstomisunderstandthelaw:but,unlesssomethingmoreweredone,itwasbynomeansimprobablethattheymightviolateit。UnhappilytheChurchhadlongtaughtthenationthathereditarymonarchy,aloneamongourinstitutions,wasdivineandinviolable;thattherightoftheHouseofCommonstoashareinthelegislativepowerwasarightmerelyhuman,butthattherightoftheKingtotheobedienceofhispeoplewasfromabove;thattheGreatCharterwasastatutewhichmightberepealedbythosewhohadmadeit,butthattherulewhichcalledtheprincesofthebloodroyaltothethroneinorderofsuccessionwasofcelestialorigin,andthatanyActofParliamentinconsistentwiththatrulewasanullity。Itisevidentthat,inasocietyinwhichsuchsuperstitionsprevail,constitutionalfreedommusteverbeinsecure。ApowerwhichisregardedmerelyastheordinanceofmancannotbeanefficientcheckonapowerwhichisregardedastheordinanceofGod。Itisvaintohopethatlaws,howeverexcellent,willpermanentlyrestrainaKingwho,inhisownopinion,andinthatofagreatpartofhispeople,hasanauthorityinfinitelyhigherinkindthantheauthoritywhichbelongstothoselaws。Todepriveroyaltyofthesemysteriousattributes,andtoestablishtheprinciplethatKingsreignedbyarightinnorespectdifferingfromtherightbywhichfreeholderschoseknightsoftheshire,orfromtherightbywhichjudgesgrantedwritsofHabeasCorpus,wasabsolutelynecessarytothesecurityofourliberties。
ThustheConventionhadtwogreatdutiestoperform。Thefirstwastoclearthefundamentallawsoftherealmfromambiguity。
Thesecondwastoeradicatefromtheminds,bothofthegovernorsandofthegoverned,thefalseandperniciousnotionthattheroyalprerogativewassomethingmoresublimeandholythanthosefundamentallaws。TheformerobjectwasattainedbythesolemnrecitalandclaimwithwhichtheDeclarationofRightcommences;
thelatterbytheresolutionwhichpronouncedthethronevacant,andinvitedWilliamandMarytofillit。
Thechangeseemssmall。Notasingleflowerofthecrownwastouched。Notasinglenewrightwasgiventothepeople。ThewholeEnglishlaw,substantiveandadjective,was,inthejudgmentofallthegreatestlawyers,ofHoltandTreby,ofMaynardandSomers,exactlythesameaftertheRevolutionasbeforeit。Somecontrovertedpointshadbeendecidedaccordingtothesenseofthebestjurists;andtherehadbeenaslightdeviationfromtheordinarycourseofsuccession。Thiswasall;
andthiswasenough。
AsourRevolutionwasavindicationofancientrights,soitwasconductedwithstrictattentiontoancientformalities。Inalmosteverywordandactmaybediscernedaprofoundreverenceforthepast。TheEstatesoftheRealmdeliberatedintheoldhallsandaccordingtotheoldrules。Powlewasconductedtohischairbetweenhismoverandhisseconderwiththeaccustomedforms。TheSerjeantwithhismacebroughtupthemessengersoftheLordstothetableoftheCommons;andthethreeobeisancesweredulymade。Theconferencewasheldwithalltheantiqueceremonial。Ononesideofthetable,inthePaintedChamber,themanagersoftheLordssatecoveredandrobedinermineandgold。ThemanagersoftheCommonsstoodbareheadedontheotherside。Thespeechespresentanalmostludicrouscontrasttotherevolutionaryoratoryofeveryothercountry。BoththeEnglishpartiesagreedintreatingwithsolemnrespecttheancientconstitutionaltraditionsofthestate。Theonlyquestionwas,inwhatsensethosetraditionsweretobeunderstood。Theassertorsoflibertysaidnotawordaboutthenaturalequalityofmenandtheinalienablesovereigntyofthepeople,aboutHarmodiusorTimoleon,BrutustheelderorBrutustheyounger。Whentheyweretoldthat,bytheEnglishlaw,thecrown,atthemomentofademise,mustdescendtothenextheir,theyansweredthat,bytheEnglishlaw,alivingmancouldhavenoheir。Whentheyweretoldthattherewasnoprecedentfordeclaringthethronevacant,theyproducedfromamongtherecordsintheTowerarollofparchment,nearthreehundredyearsold,onwhich,inquaintcharactersandbarbarousLatin,itwasrecordedthattheEstatesoftheRealmhaddeclaredvacantthethroneofaperfidiousandtyrannicalPlantagenet。Whenatlengththedisputehadbeenaccommodated,thenewsovereignswereproclaimedwiththeoldpageantry。Allthefantasticpompofheraldrywasthere,ClarencieuxandNorroy,PortcullisandRougeDragon,thetrumpets,thebanners,thegrotesquecoatsembroideredwithlionsandlilies。ThetitleofKingofFrance,assumedbytheconquerorofCressy,wasnotomittedintheroyalstyle。Tous,whohavelivedintheyear1848,itmayseemalmostanabuseoftermstocallaproceeding,conductedwithsomuchdeliberation,withsomuchsobriety,andwithsuchminuteattentiontoprescriptiveetiquette,bytheterriblenameofRevolution。
Andyetthisrevolution,ofallrevolutionstheleastviolent,hasbeenofallrevolutionsthemostbeneficent。Itfinallydecidedthegreatquestionwhetherthepopularelementwhichhad,eversincetheageofFitzwalterandDeMontfort,beenfoundintheEnglishpolity,shouldbedestroyedbythemonarchicalelement,orshouldbesufferedtodevelopeitselffreely,andtobecomedominant。Thestrifebetweenthetwoprincipleshadbeenlong,fierce,anddoubtful。Ithadlastedthroughfourreigns。Ithadproducedseditions,impeachments,rebellions,battles,sieges,proscriptions,judicialmassacres。Sometimesliberty,sometimesroyalty,hadseemedtobeonthepointofperishing。
DuringmanyyearsonehalfoftheenergyofEnglandhadbeenemployedincounteractingtheotherhalf。TheexecutivepowerandthelegislativepowerhadsoeffectuallyimpededeachotherthatthestatehadbeenofnoaccountinEurope。TheKingatArms,whoproclaimedWilliamandMarybeforeWhitehallGate,didintruthannouncethatthisgreatstrugglewasover;thattherewasentireunionbetweenthethroneandtheParliament;thatEngland,longdependentanddegraded,wasagainapowerofthefirstrank;thattheancientlawsbywhichtheprerogativewasboundedwouldhenceforthbeheldassacredastheprerogativeitself,andwouldbefollowedouttoalltheirconsequences;thattheexecutiveadministrationwouldbeconductedinconformitywiththesenseoftherepresentativesofthenation;andthatnoreform,whichthetwoHousesshould,aftermaturedeliberation,propose,wouldbeobstinatelywithstoodbythesovereign。TheDeclarationofRight,thoughitmadenothinglawwhichhadnotbeenlawbefore,containedthegermofthelawwhichgavereligiousfreedomtotheDissenter,ofthelawwhichsecuredtheindependenceofthejudges,ofthelawwhichlimitedthedurationofParliaments,ofthelawwhichplacedthelibertyofthepressundertheprotectionofjuries,ofthelawwhichprohibitedtheslavetrade,ofthelawwhichabolishedthesacramentaltest,ofthelawwhichrelievedtheRomanCatholicsfromcivildisabilities,ofthelawwhichreformedtherepresentativesystem,ofeverygoodlawwhichhasbeenpassedduringahundredandsixtyyears,ofeverygoodlawwhichmayhereafter,inthecourseofages,befoundnecessarytopromotethepublicweal,andtosatisfythedemandsofpublicopinion。
Thehighesteulogywhichcanbepronouncedontherevolutionof1688isthis,thatitwasourlastrevolution。SeveralgenerationshavenowpassedawaysinceanywiseandpatrioticEnglishmanhasmeditatedresistancetotheestablishedgovernment。Inallhonestandreflectingmindsthereisaconviction,dailystrengthenedbyexperience,thatthemeansofeffectingeveryimprovementwhichtheconstitutionrequiresmaybefoundwithintheconstitutionitself。
Now,ifever,weoughttobeabletoappreciatethewholeimportanceofthestandwhichwasmadebyourforefathersagainsttheHouseofStuart。Allaroundustheworldisconvulsedbytheagoniesofgreatnations。Governmentswhichlatelyseemedlikelytostandduringageshavebeenonasuddenshakenandoverthrown。
TheproudestcapitalsofWesternEuropehavestreamedwithcivilblood。Allevilpassions,thethirstofgainandthethirstofvengeance,theantipathyofclasstoclass,theantipathyofracetorace,havebrokenloosefromthecontrolofdivineandhumanlaws。Fearandanxietyhavecloudedthefacesanddepressedtheheartsofmillions。Tradehasbeensuspended,andindustryparalysed。Therichhavebecomepoor;andthepoorhavebecomepoorer。Doctrineshostiletoallsciences,toallarts,toallindustry,toalldomesticcharities,doctrineswhich,ifcarriedintoeffect,would,inthirtyyears,undoallthatthirtycenturieshavedoneformankind,andwouldmakethefairestprovincesofFranceandGermanyassavageasCongoorPatagonia,havebeenavowedfromthetribuneanddefendedbythesword。
Europehasbeenthreatenedwithsubjugationbybarbarians,comparedwithwhomthebarbarianswhomarchedunderAttilaandAlboinwereenlightenedandhumane。Thetruestfriendsofthepeoplehavewithdeepsorrowownedthatinterestsmorepreciousthananypoliticalprivilegeswereinjeopardy,andthatitmightbenecessarytosacrificeevenlibertyinordertosavecivilisation。Meanwhileinourislandtheregularcourseofgovernmenthasneverbeenforadayinterrupted。Thefewbadmenwholongedforlicenseandplunderhavenothadthecouragetoconfrontforonemomentthestrengthofaloyalnation,ralliedinfirmarrayroundaparentalthrone。And,ifitbeaskedwhathasmadeustodifferfromothers,theansweristhatweneverlostwhatothersarewildlyandblindlyseekingtoregain。Itisbecausewehadapreservingrevolutionintheseventeenthcenturythatwehavenothadadestroyingrevolutioninthenineteenth。
Itisbecausewehadfreedominthemidstofservitudethatwehaveorderinthemidstofanarchy。Fortheauthorityoflaw,forthesecurityofproperty,forthepeaceofourstreets,forthehappinessofourhouses,ourgratitudeisdue,underHimwhoraisesandpullsdownnationsathispleasure,totheLongParliament,totheConvention,andtoWilliamofOrange。
FN1AvauxNeg。,Aug。6/161685;DespatchofCittersandhiscolleagues,enclosingthetreaty,Aug。LewistoBarillon,Aug。
14/24。
FN2Instructionsheaded,"FormysonthePrinceofWales,1692,"
intheStuartPapers。
FN3"TheHabeasCorpus,"saidJohnson,themostbigotedofTories,toBoswell,"isthesingleadvantagewhichourgovernmenthasoverthatofothercountries;"andT。B。MacaulayisthemostbigotedofWhigsinhisowncountry,butlefthiswhiggismathomewhenhewenttoIndia。
FN4SeetheHistoricalRecordsofRegiments,publishedunderthesupervisionoftheAdjutantGeneral。
FN5Barillon,Dec。3/131685。Hehadstudiedthesubjectmuch。
"C’estundetail,"hesays,"dontj’aiconnoissance。"itappearsfromtheTreasuryWarrantBookthatthechargeofthearmyfortheyear1687wasfirstofJanuaryat623,104l。9s。11d。
FN6Burnet,i。447。
FN7Tillotson’sSermon,preachedbeforetheHouseofCommons,Nov。5。1678。
FN8Locke,FirstLetteronToleration。
FN9CouncilBook。TheerasureisdatedOct。21。1685。HalifaxtoChesterfield;Barillon,Oct。19/29。
FN10Barillon,Oct。26/Nov。5。1685;LewistoBarillon,Oct。27
/Nov。6。Nov。6/16。
FN11ThereisaremarkableaccountofthefirstappearanceofthesymptomsofdiscontentamongtheToriesinaletterofHalifaxtoChesterfield,writteninOctober,1685。Burnet,i。
684。
FN12Thecontemporarytractsinvariouslanguagesonthesubjectofthispersecutionareinnumerable。Aneminentlyclear,terse,andspiritedsummarywillbefoundinVoltaire’sSiecledeLouisXIV。
FN13"Misionariosembotados,"saysRonquillo。"Apostoliarmati,"
saysInnocent。Thereis,intheMackintoshCollection,aremarkableletteronthissubjectfromRonquillo,datedMarch26。/April5。1686SeeVenier,RelationediFrancia,1689,quotedbyProfessorRankeinhisRomischePapste,bookviii。
FN14"Midiconochetuttiquestiparlamentariinohannovolutocopia,ilcheassolutamenteavracausatepessimeimpressioni。"——
Adda,Nov。9/13。1685。SeeEvelyn’sDiary,Nov。3。
FN15Lords’Journals,Nov。9。1685。"Vengoassicurato,"saysAdda,"cheS。M。stessaabbiacompostoildiscorso。"——DespatchofNov。16/261685。
FN16Commons’Journals;Bramston’sMemoirs;JamesvonLeeuwentotheStatesGeneral,Nov。10/201685。LeeuwenwassecretaryoftheDutchembassy,andconductedthecorrespondenceintheabsenceofCitters。AstoClarges,seeBurnet,i。98。
FN17Barillon,Nov。16/26。1685。
FN18Dodd’sChurchHistory,Leeuwen,Nov。17/271685;Barillon,Dec。24。1685。BarillonsaysofAdda,"Onl’avoitfaitprevenirquelasureteetl’avantagedesCatholiquesconsistoientdansunereunionentieredesaMajesteBritanniqueetdesonparlement。"
LettersofInnocenttoJames,datedJuly27/Aug。8andSept。23/
Oct。3。1685;DespatchesofAdda,Nov。9/19。andNov。1685。TheveryinterestingcorrespondenceofAdda,copiedfromthePapalarchives,isintheBritishMuseum;AdditionalMSS。No。15395。
FN19Themostremarkabledespatchbearsdatethe9/19thofNovember1685,andwillbefoundintheAppendixtoMr。Fox’sHistory。
FN20Commons’Journals,Nov。12。1685;Leeuwen,Nov。;Barillon,Nov。16/26。;SirJohnBramston’sMemoirs。ThebestreportofthedebatesoftheCommonsinNovember,1685,isoneofwhichthehistoryissomewhatcurious。TherearetwomanuscriptcopiesofitintheBritishMuseum,Harl。7187。;Lans。253。Inthesecopiesthenamesofthespeakersaregivenatlength。TheauthoroftheLifeofJamespublishedin1702transcribedthisreport,butgaveonlytheinitials,ofthespeakers。TheeditorsofChandler’sDebatesandoftheParliamentaryHistoryguessedfromtheseinitialsatthenames,andsometimesguessedwrong。TheyascribetoWaileraveryremarkablespeech,whichwillhereafterbementioned,andwhichwasreallymadebyWindham,memberforSalisbury。ItwaswithsomeconcernthatIfoundmyselfforcedtogiveupthebeliefthatthelastwordsutteredinpublicbyWallerweresohonourabletohim。
FN21Commons’Journals,Nov。13。1685;Bramston’sMemoirs;
Reresby’sMemoirs;Barillon,Nov。16/26。;Leeuwen,Nov。13/23。;
MemoirsofSirStephenFox,1717;TheCaseoftheChurchofEnglandfairlystated;Burnet,i。666。andSpeakerOnslow’snote。
FN22Commons’Journals,Nov。1685;Harl。MS。7187。;Lans。MS。
FN23Theconflictoftestimonyonthissubjectismostextraordinary;and,afterlongconsideration,Imustownthatthebalanceseemstometobeexactlypoised。IntheLifeofJames(1702),themotionisrepresentedasacourtmotion。ThisaccountisconfirmedbyaremarkablepassageintheStuartPapers,whichwascorrectedbythePretenderhimself。(Clarke’sLifeofJamestheSecond,ii。55。)Ontheotherhand,Reresby,whowaspresent,andBarillon,whooughttohavebeenwellinformed,representthemotionasanoppositionmotion。TheHarleianandLansdownemanuscriptsdifferinthesinglewordonwhichthewholedepends。
UnfortunatelyBramstonwasnotattheHousethatday。JamesVanLeeuwenmentionsthemotionandthedivision,butdoesnotaddawordwhichcanthrowthesmallestlightonthestateofparties。
Imustownmyselfunabletodrawwithconfidenceanyinferencefromthenamesofthetellers,SirJosephWilliamsonandSirFrancisRussellforthemajority,andLordAncramandSirHenryGoodrickefortheminority。IshouldhavethoughtLordAncramlikelytogowiththecourt,andSirHenryGoodrickelikelytogowiththeopposition。
FN24Commons’Journals,Nov。16。1685Harl。MS。7187。;Lans。MS。
235。
FN25Commons’Journals,Nov。17,18。1685。
FN26Commons’Journals,Nov。18。1685;Harl。MS。7187。;Lans。
MS。253。;Burnet,i。667。
FN27Lonsdale’sMemoirs。Burnettellsus(i。667。)thatasharpdebateaboutelectionstookplaceintheHouseofCommonsafterCoke’scommittal。Itmustthereforehavebeenonthe19thofNovember;forCokewascommittedlateonthe18th,andtheParliamentwasproroguedonthe20th。Burnet’snarrativeisconfirmedbytheJournals,fromwhichitappearsthatseveralelectionswereunderdiscussiononthe19th。
FN28Burnet,i。560。;FuneralSermonoftheDukeofDevonshire,preachedbyKennet,1708;TravelsofCosmoIII。inEngland。
FN29Bramston’sMemoirs。Burnetisincorrectbothastothetimewhentheremarkwasmadeandastothepersonwhomadeit。InHalifax’sLettertoaDissenterwillbefoundaremarkableallusiontothisdiscussion。
FN30Wood,Ath。Ox。;Gooch’sFuneralSermononBishopCompton。
FN31Teonge’sDiary。
FN32Barillonhasgiventhebestaccountofthisdebate。IwillextracthisreportofMordaunt’sspeech。"MilordMordaunt,quoiquejeune,parlaaveceloquenceetforce。Ilditquelaquestionn’etoitpasreduite,commelaChambredesCommuneslepretendoit,aguerirdesjalousiesetdefiances,quiavoientlieudansleschosesincertaines;maisquecequicepassoitnel’etoitpas,qu’ilyavoitunearmeesurpiedquisubsistoit,etquietoitremplied’officiersCatholiques,quinepouvoitetreconserveequepourlerenversementdesloix,etquelasubsistancedel’armee,quandiln’yaaucuneguerreniaudedansniaudehors,etoitl’etablissementdugouvernementarbitraire,pourlequellesAngloisontuneaversionsibienfondee。"
FN33Hewasveryeasilymovedtotears。"Hecouldnot,"saystheauthorofthePanegyric,"refrainfromweepingonboldaffronts。"
Andagain"Theytalkofhishectoringandproudcarriage;whatcouldbemorehumblethanforamaninhisgreatposttocryandsob?"IntheanswertothePanegyricitissaidthat"hishavingnocommandofhistearsspoiledhimforahypocrite。"
FN34Lords’Journals,Nov。19。1685;Barillon,Nov。23/Dec。3。
DutchDespatch,Nov。20/30。;Luttrell’sDiary,Nov。19。;Burnet,i。665。TheclosingspeedsofHalifaxismentionedbytheNuncioinhisdespatchofNov。16/26。Adda,aboutamonthlater,hearsstrongtestimonytoHalifax’spowers,"Daquestouomochehagrancreditonelparlamento,egrandeeloquenza,nonsipossonoattenderechefierecontradizioni,enelparlitoRegiononvieunuomodacontrapporsi。"Dec。21/31。
FN35Lords’andCommons’Journals,Nov。20。1685。
FN36Lords’Journals,Nov。11。17,18。1685。
FN37Burneti,646。
FN38Bramston’sMemoirs;Luttrell’sDiary。
FN39ThetrialintheCollectionofStateTrials;Bramston’sMemoirsBurnet,1。647。;Lords’Journals,Dec。20。1689。
FN40Lords’Journals,Nov。9,to。16。1685。
FN41SpeechontheCorruptionoftheJudgesinLordDelamere’sworks,1694。
FN42Fuunafunzionepienadigravita,diordine,edigranspeciosita。Adda,Jan。15/25。1686。
FN43TheTrialisintheCollectionofStateTrials。Leeuwen,Jan。15/25。19/29。1686。
FN44LadyRusselltoDr。Fitzwilliam,Jan。15。1686。
FN45LewistoBarillon,Feb。10/201685/6。
FN46Evelyn’sDiary,Oct。2。1685。
FN47Clarke’sLifeofJamestheSecond,ii。9。,Orig。Mem。
FN48Leeuwen,Jan。1/11and12/221686。Herletter,thoughverylongandveryabsurd,wasthoughtworthsendingtotheStatesGeneralasasignofthetimes。
FN49SeehistrialintheCollectionofStateTrials,andhiscuriousmanifesto,printedin1681。
FN50MemoiresdeGrammont;Pepys’sDiary,Aug。19。1662。
BonrepauxtoSeignelay,Feb。1/111686。
FN51BonrepauxtoSeignelay,Feb。1/11。1686。
FN52MemoiresdeGrammont;LifeofEdward,EarlofClarendon;
CorrespondenceofHenry,EarlofClarendon,passim,particularlytheletterdatedDec。29。1685;SheridanMS。amongtheStuartPapers;EllisCorrespondence,Jan。12。1686。
FN53Seehislatercorrespondence,passim;St。Evremond,passim;
MadamedeSevigne’sLettersinthebeginningof1689。SeealsotheinstructionstoTallardafterthepeaceofRyswick,intheFrenchArchives。
FN54St。Simon,Memoires,1697,1719;St。Evremond;LaFontaine;
BonrepauxtoSeignelay,Jan。28/Feb。6,Feb。8/18。1686。
FN55Adda,Nov。16/26,Dec。7/17。andDec。21/31。1685。InthesedespatchesAddagivesstrongreasonsforcompromisingmattersbyabolishingthepenallawsandleavingthetest。HecallsthequarrelwiththeParliamenta"grandisgrazia。"HerepeatedlyhintsthattheKingmight,byaconstitutionalpolicy,haveobtainedmuchfortheRomanCatholics,andthattheattempttorelievethemillegallyislikelytobringgreatcalamitiesonthem。
FN56FraPaulo,tib。vii。;Pallavicino,lib。xviii。cap。15。
FN57ThiswasthepracticeofhisdaughterAnne;andMarlboroughsaidthatshehadlearneditfromherfather——VindicationoftheDuchessofMarlborough。
FN58DowntothetimeofthetrialoftheBishops,JameswentontellingAddathatallthecalamitiesofCharlestheFirstwere"perlatroppaindulgenza。"——Despatchof1688。
FN59Barillon,Nov。16/26。1685;LewistoBarillon,Nov。28/Dec。
6。26。Inahighlycuriouspaperwhichwaswrittenin1687,almostcertainlybyBonrepaux,andwhichisnowintheFrencharchives,Sunderlandisdescribedthus—"Lapassionqu’ilapourlejeu,etlespertesconsiderablesquilyfait,incommodentfortsesaffaires。Iln’aimepaslevin;etilhaitlesfemmes。"
FN60ItappearsfromtheCouncilBookthathetookhisplaceaspresidentonthe4thofDecember,1685。
FN61BonrepauxwasnotsoeasilydeceivedasJames。"Ensonparticulieril(Sunderland)n’enprofesseaucune(religion),etenparlefortlibrement。CessortesdediscoursseroientenexecrationenFrance。Iciilssontordinairesparmiuncertainnombredegensdupais。"——BonrepauxtoSeignelay,May25/June4
1687。
FN62Clarke’sLifeofJamestheSecond,ii,74。77。Orig。Mem。;
SheridanMS。;Barillon,March19/291686。
FN63Reresby’sMemoirs;Luttrell’sDiary,Feb。2。1685/6
Barillon,Feb。Jan。25/Feb4。
FN64Dartmouth’snoteonBurnet,i。621。InacontemporarysatireitisremarkedthatGodolphin"Beatstimewithpolitichead,andallapproves,PleasedwiththechargeoftheQueen’smuffandgloves。"
FN65Pepys,Oct。4。1664。
FN66Pepys,July1。1663。
FN67SeeDorset’ssatiricallinesonher。
FN68ThechiefmaterialsforthehistoryofthisintriguearethedespatchesofBarillonandBonrepauxatthebeginningoftheyear1686。SeeBarillon,Jan25。/Feb4。Feb。1/11。Feb。8/18。
Feb。19/29。andBonrepauxunderthefirstfourDates;Evelyn’sDiary,Jan。29。;Reresby’sMemoirs;Burnet,i。682。;SheridanMS。;ChaillotMS。;Adda’sDespatches,Jan22/Feb1。andJan29/Feb81686。Addawriteslikeapious,butweakandignorantman。HeappearstohaveknownnothingofJames’spastlife。
FN69Themeditationhearsdate1685/6。Bonrepaux,inhisdespatchofthesameday,says,"L’intrigueavoiteteconduiteparMilordRochesteretsafemme……LeurprojetetoitdefairegouvernerleRoyd’Angleterreparlanouvellecomtesse。Ilss’etoientassuresd’elle。"WhileBonrepauxwaswritingthus,Rochesterwaswritingasfollows:"OhGod,teachmesotonumbermydaysthatImayapplymyheartuntowisdom。TeachmetonumberthedaysthatIhavespentinvanityandidleness,andteachmetonumberthosethatIhavespentinsinandwickedness。OhGod,teachmetonumberthedaysofmyafflictiontoo,andtogivethanksforallthatiscometomefromthyhand。Teachmelikewisetonumberthedaysofthisworld’sgreatness,ofwhichI
havesogreatashare;andteachmetolookuponthemasvanityandvexationofspirit。"
FN70"JevisMilordRochestercommeilsortoitdeconseilfortchagrin;et,surlafindusouper,illuienechappequelquechose。"Bonrepaux,Feb。18/28。1656。SeealsoBarillon,March1/11,4/14。
FN71BarillonMarch22/April1,April12。221686。
FN72LondonGazette,Feb。11。1685/6;Luttrell’sDiary,Feb。8;
Leeuwen,Feb。9/19。;Clarke’sLifeofJamestheSecond,ii。75。
Orig。Mem。
FN73Leeuwen,Feb23/Mar5。1686。
FN74Barillon,April26/May6。May3/13。i686;Citters,May7/17;Evelyn’sDiary,May5。;Luttrell’sDiaryofthesamedate;
PrivyCouncilBook,May2。
FN75LadyRusselltoDr。Fitzwilliam,Jan。22。1686;Barillon,Feb22/Mar41686。"Ceprincetemoigne,"saysBarillon,"unegrandeaversionpoureux,etauraitbienvoulusedispenserdelacollecte,quiestordonneeenleurfaveur:maisiln’apascruquecelafutpossible。"
FN76Barillon,Feb22/Mar4。1686。
FN77Accountofthecommissioners,datedMarch15。1688。
FN78"LeRoid’Angleterreconnaitbienquelesgensmalintentionnespourluisontlespluspromptsetlesplusdisposesadonnerconsiderablement……SaMajesteBritanniqueconnoitbienqu’ilauroitaproposdenepointordonnerdecollecte,etquelesgensmalintentionnescontrelareligionCatholiqueetcontreluiseserventdecetteoccasionpourtemoignerleurzele。"——Barillon,April19/291686。
FN79Barillon,Feb15/25Feb22/Mar4。April19/29,LewistoBarillonMar5/15。
FN80Barillon,April19/29。1686;LadyRusselltoDr。
Fitzwilliam,April14。"Hesentawaymany,"shesays"withsadhearts。"
FN81LondonGazetteofMay13。1686。
FN82Reresby’sMemoirs;Eachard,iii。797。;Kennet,iii。451。
FN83LondonGazette,April22。and29。i686;Barillon,April19/29。;Evelyn’sDiary,June2。;Luttrell,June8。;Dodd’sChurchHistory。
FN84North’sLifeofGuildford,288。
FN85Reresby’sMemoirs。
FN86SeetheaccountofthecaseintheCollectionofStateTrials;Citters,May4/14。,June22/July21686;Evelyn’sDiary,June27。;Luttrell’sDiary,June25。AstoStreet,seeClarendon’sDiary,Dec。27。1688。
FN87LondonGazette,July19。1686。
FN88SeetheletterspatentinGutch’sCollectancaCuriosa。Thedateisthe3dofMay,1686。Sclater’sConsensusVeterum;Gee’sreply,entitledVeteresVindicati;Dr。AnthonyHorneck’saccountofMr。Sclater’srecantationoftheerrorsofPoperyonthe5thofMay,1689;Dodd’sChurchHistory,partviii。bookii。art。3。
FN89Gutch’sCollectaneaCuriosa;Dodd,viii。ii。3。;Wood,Ath。
Ox。;EllisCorrespondence,Feb。27。1686;Commons’Journals,Oct。
26。1689。
FN90Gutch’sCollectaneaCuriosa;Wood’sAthenaeOxonienses;
DialoguebetweenaChurchmanandaDissenter,1689。
FN91Adda,July9/191686。
FN92Adda,July30/Aug91686。
FN93"Ceprincem’aditqueDieuavoitpermiequetouteslesloixquiontetefaitespouretablirlareligionProtestante,etdetruirelareligionCatholique,serventpresentementdefondementcequ’ilveutfairepourl’etablissementdelavraiereligion,etlemettentendroitd’exercerunpouvoirencoreplusgrandqueceluiqu’ontlesroleCatholiquessurlesaffairesecclesiastiquesdanslesautrespays。"——Barillon,July12/22。
1686。ToAddaHisMajestysaid,afewdayslater,"Chel’autoritaconcessaledalparlamentosopral’Ecclesiasticosenzaalcunlimiteconfinecontrariofosseadessoperservirealvantaggiode’medesimiCattolici。"July23/Aug2。
FN94Thewholequestionislucidlyandunanswerablyarguedinalittlecontemporarytract,entitled"TheKing’sPowerinMattersEcclesiasticalfairlystated。"SeealsoaconcisebutforcibleargumentbyArchbishopSancroft。Doyly’sLifeofSancroft,i。
229。
FN95LetterfromJamestoClarendon,Feb。18。1685/6。
FN96ThebestaccountofthesetransactionsisintheLifeofSharp,byhisson。Citters,June29/July91686。
FN97Barillon,July21/Aug11686。Citters,July16/26;PrivyCouncilBook,July17。;EllisCorrespondence,July17。;Evelyn’sDiary,July14。;Luttrell’sDiary,Aug。5,6。
FN98Thedevicewasaroseandcrown。BeforethedevicewastheinitialletteroftheSovereign’sname;afterittheletterR。
Roundthesealwasthisinscription,"Sigillumcommissariorumregiaemajestatisadcausasecclesiasticas。"
FN99AppendixtoClarendon’sDiary;Citters,Oct。8/181686;
Barillon,Oct。11/21;Doyly’sLifeofSancroft。
FN100Burnet,i。676。
FN101Burnet,i。675。ii。629。;Sprat’sLetterstoDorset。
FN102Burnet,i。677。;Barillon,Sept。6/16。1686。ThepublicproceedingsareintheCollectionofStateTrials。
FN10327Eliz。c。2。;2Jac。I。c。4;3Jac。I。c。5。
FN104Clarke’sLifeofJamestheSecond,ii。79,80。Orig。Mem,FN105DeAugmentisi。vi。4。
FN106Citters,May14/241686。
FN107Citters。May18/281686。Adda,May19/29
FN108EllisCorrespondence,April27。1686;Barillon,April19/29Citters,April20/30;PrivyCouncilBook,March26;
Luttrell’sDiary;AddaFeb26/Mar8March26/April5,April2/12
April23/May3
FN109Burnet’sTravels。
FN110Barillon,May27/June61686。
FN111Citters,May23/June11686。
FN112EllisCorrespondence,June26。1686;Citters,July2/12
Luttrell’sDiary,July19。
FN113Seethecontemporarypoems,entitledHounslowHeathandCaesar’sGhost;Evelyn’sDiary,June2。1686。AballadinthePepysiancollectioncontainsthefollowinglines"Ilikedtheplacebeyondexpressing,Ine’ersawacampsofine,Notamaidinaplaindressing,Butmighttasteaglassofwine。"
FN114Luttrell’sDiary,June18。1686。
FN115SeethememoirsofJohnson,prefixedtothefolioeditionofhislife,hisJulian,andhisanswerstohisopponents。SeealsoHickes’sJovian。
FN116LifeofJohnson,prefixedtohisworks;SecretHistoryofthehappyRevolution,byHughSpeke;StateTrials;Citters,Nov23/Dec31686。Cittersgivesthebestaccountofthetrial。I
haveseenabroadsidewhichconfirmshisnarrative。
FN117SeetheprefacetoHenryWharton’sPosthumousSermons。
FN118ThisIcanattestfrommyownresearches。ThereisanexcellentcollectionintheBritishMuseum。Birchtellsus,inhisLifeofTillotson,thatArchbishopWakehadnotbeenabletoformevenaperfectcatalogueofallthetractspublishedinthiscontroversy。
FN119CardinalHowardspokestronglytoBurnetatRomeonthissubjectBurnet,i。662。ThereisacuriouspassagetothesameeffectinadespatchofBarillonbutIhavemislaidthereference。
OneoftheRomanCatholicdivineswhoengagedinthiscontroversy,aJesuitnamedAndrewPatton,whomMr。Oliver,inhisbiographyoftheOrder,pronouncestohavebeenamanofdistinguishedability,veryfranklyownshisdeficiencies。"A。P。
havingbeeneighteenyearsoutofhisowncountry,pretendsnotyettoanyperfectionoftheEnglishexpressionororthography。"
Hisorthographyisindeeddeplorable。Inoneofhisletterswrightisputforwrite,woedforwould。HechallengedTenisontodisputewithhiminLatin,thattheymightbeonequalterms。Inacontemporarysatire,entitledTheAdvice,isthefollowingcouplet"SendPultontobelashedatBushy’sschool,Thatheinprintnolongerplaythefool。"
AnotherRomanCatholic,namedWilliamClench,wroteatreatiseonthePope’ssupremacy,anddedicatedittotheQueeninItalian。
Thefollowingspecimenofhisstylemaysuffice。"Odelsagromaritofortunataconsorte!Odolcealleviamentod’affarialti!O
gratoristorodipensierinoiosi,nelcuipettolatteo,lucentespecchiod’illibatamatronalpudicizia,nelcuisenoodorato,comeinportodamor,siritirailGiacomo!Obeataregiacoppia!
Ofeliceinsertotral’invincibilleonielecandideaquile!"
Clench’sEnglishisofapiecewithhisTuscan。Forexample,"Petersignifiesaninexpugnablerock,abletoevacuatealltheplotsofhell’sdivan,andnaufragatealltheluriddesignsofempoisonedheretics。"
AnotherRomanCatholictreatise,entitled"TheChurchofEnglandtrulyrepresented,"beginsbyinformingusthat"theignisfatuusofreformation,whichhadgrowntoacometbymanyactsofspoilandrapine,hadbeenusheredintoEngland,purifiedofthefilthwhichithadcontractedamongthelakesoftheAlps。"
FN120Barillon,July19/291686。
FN121ActParl。Aug。24。1560;Dec。15。1567。
FN122ActParl。May8。1685。
FN123ActParl。Aug。311681。
FN124Burnet,i。584。
FN125Ibid。i。652,653。
FN126Ibid。i。678。
FN127Burnet,i。653。
FN128Fountainhall,Jan。28。1685/6。
FN129Ibid。Jan。111685/6。
FN130Fountainhall,Jan。31。andFeb。1。1685/6。;Burnet,i。
678,;TrialsofDavidMowbrayandAlexanderKeith,intheCollectionofStateTrials;Bonrepaux,Feb。11/21
FN131LewistoBarillon,Feb。18/281686。
FN132Fountainhall,Feb。16。;Wodrow,bookiii。chap。x。sec。3。
"Werequire,"HisMajestygraciouslywrote,"thatyousparenolegaltrialbytortureorotherwise。"
FN133Bonrepaux,Feb。18/281686。
FN134Fountainhall,March11。1686;Adda,March1/11
FN135ThisletterisdatedMarch4。1686。
FN136Barillon,April19/291686;Burnet,i。370。
FN137ThewordsareinaletterofJohnstoneofWaristoun。
FN138SomewordsofBarillondeservetobetranscribed。Theywouldalonesufficetodecideaquestionwhichignoranceandpartyspirithavedonemuchtoperplex。"Cetteliberteaccordeeauxnonconformistesafaiteunegrandedifficulte,etaetedebattuependantplusieursjours。LeRoyd’AngleterreavoitfortenviequelesCatholiqueseussentseulslalibertedel’exercicedeleurreligion。"April19/291686。
FN139Barillon,April19/291686Citters,April18/2820/30May9/19
FN140Fountainhall,May6。1686。
FN141Ibid。June15。1686。
FN142Citters,May11/211686。CittersinformedtheStatesthathehadhisintelligencefromasurehand。Iwilltranscribepartofhisnarrative。ItisanamusingspecimenofthepyebalddialectinwhichtheDutchdiplomatistsofthatagecorresponded。
"Deskonigsmissive,bovenenbehalvendenHoogCommissarisaensprake,aenhetparlementafgesonden,gelyckdataltoosgebruyckelyckis,waerbySyneMajesteytnyingenereversochthieftdemitigatiederrigoureuseoftesanglantewettenvonhetRyckjegenshetPausdom,inhetGeneraleComiteedesArticles(soomenhetdaernaemt)naordregesteltengelesensynde,in’tvoteren,denHertogvanHamiltononderanderenklaeruytseydedathydaertoenietsoudeverstaen,datbyandersgenegenwasdenkoniginallenvoorvalgetrouwtedienenvolgenshetdictamensynerconscientie:’tgeneredengafaendeLordCancelierdeGravePertsteseggendathetwoortconscientienietsenbeduyde,enalleeneenindividuumvagumwas,waeropderChevalierLocqnarddanverdergingh;wilmannietverstaendebetyckenisvanhetwoordtconscientie,soosalikinfortioribusseggendatwymeynenvolgensdefondamentalewettenvanhetryck。"
Thereis,intheHindLetLoose,acuriouspassagetowhichI
shouldhavegivennocredit,butforthisdespatchofCitters。
"Theycannotenduresomuchastohearofthenameofconscience。
OnethatwaswellacquaintwiththeCouncil’shumourinthispointtoldagentlemanthatwasgoingbeforethem,`Ibeseechyou,whateveryoudo,speaknothingofconsciencebeforetheLords,fortheycannotabidetohearthatword。’"
FN143Fountainhall,May17。1686。
FN144Wodrow,III。x。3。
FN145Citters,May28/June7,June1/11June4/141686
FountainhallJune15;
FNLuttrell’sDiary,June2。16
FN146Fountainhall,June211686。
FN147Ibid。September16。1686。
FN148Fountainhall,Sept。16;Wodrow,III。x。3。
FN149TheprovisionsoftheIrishActofSupremacy,2Eliz。
chap。I。,aresubstantiallythesamewiththoseoftheEnglishActofSupremacy,IEliz。chap。I。huttheEnglishactwassoonfoundtohedefectiveandthedefectwassuppliedbyamorestringentact,5Eliz。chap。INosuchsupplementarylawwasmadeinIreland。ThattheconstructionmentionedinthetextwasputontheIrishActofSupremacy,wearetoldbyArchbishopKing:
StateofIreland,chap。ii。sec。9。HecallsthisconstructionJesuiticalbutIcannotseeitinthatlight。
FN150PoliticalAnatomyofIreland。
FN151PoliticalAnatomyofIreland,1672;IrishHudibras,1689;
JohnDunton’sAccountofIreland,1699。
FN152ClarendontoRochester,May4。1686。
FN153BishopMalony’sLettertoBishopTyrrel,March5。1689。