IntheeveningdinedatMinisterNewel’s。SatbetweenMinisterOkolicsanyioftheAustriandelegation,andCountWelsersheimb,thechairmanofthatdelegation,andhadinterestingtalkswiththem,withtheDukeofTetuan,andothers。ItappearsthattheDuke,whoisaverycharming,kindlyman,has,likemyself,apassionbothforcathedralarchitectureandfororganmusic;hedweltmuchuponBurgos,whichhecalledthegemofSpanishcathedrals。
ThencetothefinalreceptionatthehouseofM。deBeaufort,ministerofforeignaffairs,whoshowedmeacontemporaryportraitofGrotiuswhichdisplaysthetraitsobservableinthecopieswhichBurleighpaintedformetwentyyearsagoatAmsterdamandLeyden。TalkedwithSirJulianPauncefoteregardingtheSwissmatter;hehadabstainedfromvotingforthereasonthathehadnoinstructionsinthepremises。
July2。
InthemorningMajorAllen,militaryattacheofourembassyatBerlin,arrived,bringingtheGrotiuswreath。UnderSecretaryHay’spermission,IhadgiventooneofthebestBerlinsilversmithsvirtuallycarteblanche,andtheresultismostsatisfactory。Thewreathisverylarge,beingmadeup,ononeside,ofalaurelbranchwithleavesoffrostedsilverandberriesofgold,and,ontheother,ofanoakbranchwithsilverleavesandgoldacorns,bothboughsbeingtiedtogetheratthebottombyalargeknotofribboninsilvergilded,bearingthearmsoftheNetherlandsandtheUnitedStatesonenameledshields,andaninscriptionasfollows:
TotheMemoryofHUGOGROTIUS;
InReverenceandGratitude,FromtheUnitedStatesofAmerica;
OntheOccasionoftheInternationalPeaceConferenceofTheHague。
July4th,1899。
Itisasuperbpieceofwork,anditsebonycase,withsilverclasps,andbearingasilvershieldwithsuitableinscription,isalsoperfect:thewholethingattractsmostfavorableattention。
CHAPTERXLIX
ASPRESIDENTOFTHEAMERICANDELEGATIONATTHEPEACECONFERENCE
OFTHEHAGUE:V——1899
July4。
OnthisdaytheAmericandelegationinvitedtheircolleaguestocelebrateournationalanniversaryatthetombofGrotius,firstinthegreatchurch,andafterwardinthetownhallofDelft。
SpeechesweremadebytheministerofforeignaffairsoftheNetherlandsDeBeaufort;bytheirfirstdelegate,VanKarnebeek;
byMr。Asser,oneoftheirleadingjurists;bytheburgomasterofDelft;andbyBarondeBildt,chairmanoftheSwedishdelegationandministeratRome,whoreadatelegramfromtheKingofSwedenreferringtoGrotius’srelationstotheSwedishdiplomaticservice;aswellasbyPresidentLowofColumbiaUniversityandmyself:thedutybeingintrustedtomeoflayingthewreathuponGrotius’stombandmakingtheaddresswithreferencetoit。Asalltheaddressesaretobeprinted,Ishallgivenomoreattentiontothemhere。Averylargeaudiencewaspresent,embracingtheambassadorsandprincipalmembersoftheconference,theNetherlandsministersofstate,professorsfromthevariousuniversitiesoftheNetherlands,andalargebodyofotherinvitedguests。
Themusicofthechimes,oftheorgan,andoftheroyalchoirofonehundredvoiceswasveryfine;and,althoughthedaywasstormy,withahighwindanddrivingrain,everythingwentoffwell。
Aftertheexercisesinthechurch,ourdelegationgaveabreakfast,whichwasverysatisfactory。Aboutthreehundredandfiftypersonssatdowntothetablesatthetownhall,andonehundredotherguests,includingthemusicians,attheleadingrestaurantintheplace。IntheafternoontheAmericansgatheredatthereceptiongivenbyourminister,Mr。Newel,andhiswife,andintheeveningtherewasalargeattendanceatan"Americanconcert"givenbytheorchestraatthegreathallinScheveningen。
July5。
Earlyinthemorningtothesecondcommitteeoftheconference,whereIspokeinbehalfoftheBeldimanresolution,doingjusticetoSwitzerlandasregardsthecontinuanceoftheRedCrossinterestsinSwisshands;andongoingtoavoteweweresuccessful。
Then,thequestionofaproperdealingwithourmemorialregardingtheimmunityofprivatepropertyonthehighseascomingup,Ispokeinfavorofreferringittothegeneralconference,andgavethereasonswhyitshouldnotsimplybedroppedoutasnotcomingwithinthesubjectscontemplatedinthecalltotheconference。ThoughmyspeechwasinFrench,itwentoffbetterthanIexpected。
Intheafternoon,atthefullconference,thesamesubjectcameup;andthen,afteraprefaceinFrench,askingpermissiontospeakinEnglish,Imademyspeech,which,probably,threequartersofallthedelegatesunderstood,but,atmyrequest,asummaryofitwasafterwardgiveninFrenchbyMr。vanKarnebeek。
Theoccasionofthisspeechwasmysecondingthemotion,madeinaveryfriendlymannerbyM。deMartens,toreferthemattertoafutureconference;butIwentintothemeritsofthegeneralsubjecttoshowitsclaimsuponthevariousnations,etc。,etc。,thoughnot,ofcourse,asfullyasIwouldhavedonehadthematterbeenfullyunderdiscussion。Myspeechwasverywellreceived,andwill,Ihope,aidinkeepingthesubjectalive。
IntheafternoondrovetoRyswyck,tothehouseofM。CornetsdeGroot,thelivingrepresentativeoftheGrotiusfamily。Thehouseandgroundswereverypleasant,butthegreatattractionwasacollectionofrelicsofGrotius,includingmanymanuscriptsfromhisownhand,——amongtheseacatechismforhischildren,writtenintheprisonofLoewenstein;withofficialdocuments,signedandsealed,connectedwiththepublictransactionsofhistime;alsoletterswhichpassedbetweenhimandOxenstiern,thegreatSwedishchancellor,someinLatinandsomeinotherlanguages;
besidessundrypoems。Therewerealsoamultitudeofportraits,engravings,anddocumentsrelatingtoOlden—BarneveldandothersofGrotius’scontemporaries。
TheDeGrootfamilygaveusamostheartyreception,introducingtheirlittlegirl,whoisthelatest—borndescendantofGrotius,andshowingusvarioushouseholdrelicsoftheirgreatancestor,includingcups,glasses,andthelike。Mr。DeGrootalsogavemesomecuriousinformationregardinghimwhichIdidnotbeforepossess;and,amongotherthings,toldmethatwhenGrotius’sbodywastransferred,shortlyafterhisdeath,fromRostocktoDelft,thecoffincontainingitwasstonedbyamobatRotterdam;
alsothatattheunveilingofthestatueofGrotiusinfrontofthechurchatDelft,afewyearsago,thehigh—churchCalvinistswouldnotallowthechildrenfromtheirchurchschoolstojointheotherchildreninsinginghymns。TheoldbitternessoftheextremeCalvinisticpartytowardtheirgreatcompatriotwasthusstillexhibited,andtheremarkwasmadeatthetime,byamemberofit,thatthestatuewasperfectlytruetolife,since"itsbackwasturnedtowardthechurch";towhichareplywasmadethat"Grotius’sfaceinthestatue,likehislivingface,wassteadilyturnedtowardjustice。"Thislatterremarkhadreferencetothefactthatacourtisheldinthecityhall,towardwhichthestatueisturned。
IntheeveningtoadinnergivenbyMr。Piersoon,ministeroffinanceandprimeministeroftheNetherlands,toourdelegationandtohiscolleaguesoftheDutchministry。Everythingpassedoffwell,Mr。PiersoonproposingatoasttothehealthofthePresidentoftheUnitedStates,towhichIrepliedinatoasttotheQueenoftheNetherlands。InthecourseofhisspeechMr。
PiersoonthankedusforourtributetoGrotius,andshowedreallydeepfeelingonthesubject。ThereisnodoubtthatwehavestruckaresponsivechordintheheartsofallliberalandthoughtfulmenandwomenoftheNetherlands;fromeveryquartercomeevidencesofthis。
Aremarkofhis,regardingarbitration,especiallypleasedus。Hesaidthatthearbitrationplan,asithadcomefromthegreatcommittee,waslikeababy:——apparentlyhelpless,andofverylittlevalue,unabletodomuch,andrequiringcarefulnursing;
butthatithadonegreatmerit:——ITWOULDGROW。
ThisIbelievetobeaveryaccuratestatementofthesituation。
Thegeneralfeelingoftheconferencebecomesbetterandbetter。
Moreandmoretheoldskepticismhasdeparted,andinplaceofithascomeastrongambitiontohaveashareinwhatwearebeginningtobelievemaybeamosthonorablecontributiontothepeaceoftheworld。Ihavenevertakenpartinmoreearnestdiscussionsthanthosewhichduringthelasttwoweekshaveoccupiedus,andespeciallythoserelatingtoarbitration。
IthinkImaysay,withoutassumingtoomuch,thatourGrotiuscelebrationhasbeenacontributionofsomevaluetothisgrowthofearnestness。Ithas,ifIamnotgreatlymistaken,revealedtotheconference,stillmoreclearlythanbefore,thefactthatitisahistoricalbodyintrustedwithamatterofvastimportanceanddifficulty,andthatweshallbejudgedinhistorywithreferencetothisfact。
July6。
At5。30P。M。offinspecialtrainwiththeentireconferencetoAmsterdam。Onarriving,wefoundalongtrainofcourtcarriageswhichtookustothepalace,thehousesoneachsidethroughouttheentiredistancebeingdecoratedwithflagsandbanners,andthestreetscrowdedwithmen,women,andchildren。Wewereindeedabraveshow,sinceallofus,exceptthemembersofourAmericandelegation,woregorgeousuniformswithnoendofribbons,stars,andinsigniaofvariousofficesandorders。
Onreachingourdestination,wewerereceivedbytheQueenandQueen—mother,andshortlyafterwardwentintodinner。Withthepossibleexceptionofalordmayor’sfeastattheGuildhall,itwasthemostimposingthingofthekindthatIhaveeverseen。
Thegreatbanqueting—hall,datingfromthegloriousdaysoftheDutchRepublic,isprobablythelargestandmostsumptuousincontinentalEurope,andthetablefurniture,decorations,anddinnerwereworthyofit。Abouttwohundredandfiftypersons,includingallthemembersoftheconferenceandthehigherofficialsofthekingdom,satdown,theQueenandQueen—motherattheheadofthetable,andaboutthemtheambassadorsandpresidentsofdelegations。Myownplace,beingveryneartheMajesties,gavemeanexcellentopportunitytoseeandheareverything。TowardthecloseofthebanquettheyoungQueenaroseandaddressedus,soeasilyandnaturallythatIshouldhavesupposedherspeechextemporaneoushadInotseenherconsultinghermanuscriptjustbeforerising。Hermannerwasperfect,andhervoicesoclearastobeheardbyeveryoneinthehall。
Everythingconsidered,itwasaremarkableeffortforayoungladyofseventeen。Atitscloseanexcellentreplywasmadebyourpresident,M。deStaal;andsoonafterward,whenwehadpassedintothegreatgallery,therecameanevenmorestrikingexhibitionofthepowersofheryouthfulMajesty,forsheconversedwitheverymemberoftheconference,andwiththeutmosteaseandsimplicity。TomeshereturnedthanksfortheGrotiustribute,andinverycordialterms,asdidlateralsotheQueen—mother;andIcannotbutbelievethattheyweresincere,since,threemonthslater,atthefestivalgiventhematPotsdam,theybothrenewedtheiracknowledgmentsinacordialwaywhichshowedthattheirpatrioticheartswerepleased。VariousleadingmenoftheNetherlandsandoftheconferencealsothankedus,andoneofthemsaid,"YouAmericanshavetaughtusalesson;for,insteadofameredisplayoffireworkstotherabbleofasinglecity,oraballorconcerttoafewofficials,youhave,inthissolemnrecognitionofGrotius,paidthehighestcomplimentpossibletotheentirepeopleoftheNetherlands,past,present,andtocome。"
July7。
Inthemorningtothegreathallofthe"HouseintheWood,"
wherethe"editingcommittee"(comitederedaction)reportedtothethirdcommitteeoftheconferencethewholearbitrationplan。
Itstruckmemostfavorably,——indeed,itsurprisedme,thoughI
havekeptwatchofeverystep。Iamconvincedthatitisbetterthananyoftheplansoriginallysubmitted,notexceptingourown。Itwillcertainlybeagaintotheworld。
AtthecloseofthesessionweadjourneduntilMonday,the17th,inorderthatthedelegatesmaygetinstructionsfromtheirvariousgovernmentsregardingthesigningoftheprotocols,agreements,etc。
July8。
IntheeveningdinedwithM。deMier,theMexicanministeratParisanddelegatehere,andhadaveryinterestingtalkwithM。
Raffalovitch,towhomIspokeplainlyregardingtheonlyroadtodisarmament。ItoldhimthathemustknowaswellasanyonethatthereisavaguedreadthroughoutEuropeoftheenormousgrowthofRussia,andthathemustacknowledgethat,whetherjustornot,itisperfectlynatural。Heacquiescedinthis,andIthenwentontosaythattheEmperorNicholashadbeforehimanopportunitytodomoregoodandmakeanoblerreputationthananyotherczarhadeverdone,notexceptingAlexanderIIwithhisemancipationoftheserfs;thatIhadthoughtveryseriouslyofwriting,atthecloseoftheconference,toM。Pobedonostzeff,presentingtohimthereasonswhyRussiamightwellmakeapracticalbeginningofdisarmamentbydismissingtotheirhomes,orplacingonpublicworks,saytwohundredthousandofhersoldiers;thatthiswouldleaveherallthesoldierssheneeds,andmore;thathemustknow,aseverybodyknows,thatnootherpowerdreamsofattackingRussiaordarestodoso;thattherewouldbenodisadvantageinsuchadismissaloftroopstopeacefulavocations,buteveryadvantage;andthatifitweredonetheresultwouldbethat,inlessthanfortyyears,Russiawouldbecome,bythishusbandingofherresources,themostpowerfulnationontheeasterncontinent,andabletocarryoutanyjustpolicywhichshemightdesire。ImighthaveaddedthatoneadvantageofsuchareductionwouldcertainlybelessinclinationbythewarpartyatSt。Petersburgtoplungeintomilitaryadventures。(HadRussiathusreducedherarmyshewouldneverhavesunkintotheconditioninwhichshefindsherselfnow(1905),asIrevisetheselines。InsteadofsendingAlexeiefftomakewar,shewouldhaveallowedDeWittetomakepeace——peaceonabasisofjusticetoJapan,andawinteraccesstothePacific,underpropersafeguards,forherself。)
Raffalovitchseemedtoacquiescefullyinmyview,exceptastothenumberofsoldierstobereleased,sayingthatfiftyorsixtythousandwoulddoperfectlywellasshowingthatRussiaisinearnest。
HeisoneoftheyoungermenofRussia,buthasverydecidedability,andthishehasshownnotonlyinhissecretaryshipoftheconference,butinseveralofhisworksonfinancialandotherpublicquestionspublishedinParis,whichhavesecuredforhimacorrespondingmembershipoftheFrenchInstitute。
Itisabsolutelyclearinmymindthat,ifanythingistobedonetowarddisarmament,apracticalbeginningmustbemadebytheCzar;buttheunfortunatethingisthatwith,nodoubt,fairlygoodintentions,heisweakandillinformed。ThedreadfulmistakeheismakinginviolatingtheoathswornbyhispredecessorsandhimselftoFinlandistheresultofthisweaknessandignorance;andshouldheattempttodiminishhisovergrownarmyhewould,inallprobability,beoverbornebythemilitarypeopleabouthim,andbypettydifficultieswhichtheywouldsuggest,or,ifnecessary,create。Itmustbeconfessedthatthereisonedangerinanyattempteddisarmament,andthisisthatthemilitarycliquemight,topreventit,plungetheempireintoawar。
TheEmperorissurroundedmainlybyinferiormen。Undertheshadeofautocracymenofindependentstrengthrarelyflourish。Indeed,IfindthattheopinionregardingRussianstatesmenwhichI
formedinRussiaisconfirmedbyolddiplomatists,ofthebestjudgment,whomImeethere。Oneofthemsaidtometheotherday:
"Thereisnogreatertwaddlethanallthetalkaboutfar—seeingpurposesandmeasuresbyRussianstatesmen。Theyaregenerallyweak,influencedbyminor,andespeciallybypersonal,considerations,andinferiortomostmeninsimilarpositionsintheothergreatgovernmentsofEurope。Thechancellor,PrinceGortchakoff,ofwhomsomuchhasbeensaid,wasaweak,vainman,whomBismarckfounditgenerallyveryeasytodealwith。"
Astomyownexperience,IthinkmanyofthosewhomIsawwerefarfromthebestoftheirkindwithwhomIhavehadtodo。I
haveneverimaginedahumanbeinginthepositionofministeroftheinteriorofagreatnationsoutterlyfutileasthepersonwhoheldthatplaceatSt。Petersburginmytime;andthesamemaybesaidofseveralotherswhomImetthereinhighplaces。
Thereareafewstrongmen,and,unfortunately,Pobedonostzeffisoneofthem。Luckily,DeWitte,theministeroffinance,isanother。
July10。
TheevilwhichIdreaded,asregardstheformationofpublicopinioninrelationtotheworkofourconference,isbecomingrealized。TheLondon"Spectator,"justreceived,containsamostdishearteningarticle,"ThePeaceConferenceaFailure,"withanadditionalarticle,morefullydeveloped,tothesameeffect。
Nothingcouldbemoreunjust;but,onaccountofthe"Spectator’s""moderation,"itwillgreatlyinfluencepublicopinion,anddoubtlessprevent,tosomeextent,thecallingoffutureconferencesneededtodevelopthegoodworkdoneinthis。
Fortunatelythecorrespondentofthe"Times"givesabetterexample,andshows,inhisexcellentletters,whathasbeenaccomplishedhere。The"NewYorkHerald,"also,isthusfartakingtherightview,andmaintainingitwithsomeearnestness。
July17。
Thismorning,atten,tothe"HouseintheWood"tohearMr。vanKarnebeek’sreportondisarmament,checkinginvention,etc。,beforethesessionofcommitteeNo。1。Itwasstronglyattacked,andwasleftinshreds:thewholesubjectisevidentlytooimmatureandcomplicatedtobedealtwithduringthepresentconference。
Intheafternooncameupanespeciallyinterestingmatterinthesessionofthearbitrationcommittee,theoccasionbeingareportofthesubcommittee。AmongthepointswhichmostinterestedusasAmericanswasaprovisionforanappealfromthedecisionofthearbitrationtribunalonthediscoveryofnewfacts。
DeMartensofRussiaspokewithgreatforceagainstsuchrightofappeal,andotherstookgroundwithhim。Hollsreallydistinguishedhimselfbyatellingspeechontheotherside——whichistheAmericanside,thatfeaturehavingbeenpresentinouroriginalinstructions;Messrs。AsserandKarnebeekbothspokeforiteffectively,andthefinaldecisionwasvirtuallyinourfavor,forMr。Asser’scompromisewasadopted,whichreallygivesusthecase。
TheSiameserepresentativesrequestedthatthetimeduringwhichanappealmightbeallowedshouldbesixinsteadofthreemonths,whichwehadnamed;butitwasfinallymadeamatterofadjustmentbetweentheparties。
July18。
TheAmericandelegationmetatten,whenacablemessagefromtheStateDepartmentwasreadauthorizingustosigntheprotocol。
July19。
Fielddayinthearbitrationcommittee。AdecidedsensationwasproducedbyvigorousspeechesbymyBerlincolleague,Beldiman,oftheRoumaniandelegation,andbyServian,Greek,andotherdelegates,againsttheprovisionforcommissionsd’enquete,——DeMartens,Descamps,andothersmakingvigorousspeechesinbehalfofthem。ItlookedasiftheBalkanstateswerelikelytowithdrawfromtheconferenceifthecommissiond’enquetefeaturewasinsistedupon:theyareevidentlyafraidthatsuch"examiningcommissions"maybesentwithintheirboundariesbysomeoftheirbigneighbors——Russia,forexample——tospyoutthelandandstartintrigues。Thewholematterwasputover。
IntheeveningtoCountMunster’sdinneratScheveningen,andhadaveryinterestingtalkonconferencematterswithSirJulianPauncefote,findingthatinmostthingsweshallbeabletostandtogetherasthecrisisapproaches。
July20。
ForseveraldayspastIhavebeenpreparingapossiblespeechtobemadeinsigningtheprotocol,etc。,which,ifnotusedforthatpurpose,maybepublished,and,perhaps,aidinkeepingpublicopinionintherightlineasregardstheworkoftheconferenceafterithasclosed。
Intheafternoontothe"HouseintheWood,"thecommitteeonarbitrationmeetingagain。MorespeechesweremadebytheBulgariansandServians,whoarestillupinarms,fearingthatthecommissionnd’enquetemeansinterventionbythegreatstatesintheiraffairs。SpeechestoallaytheirfearsweremadebyCountNigra,Dr。Zorn,Holls,andLeonBourgeois。ZornspokeinGermanwithexcellenteffect,asdidHollsinEnglish;Nigrawasreallyimpressive;andBourgeois,fromthechair,gaveusaspecimenoffirst—rateFrenchoratory。HemadeamostearnestappealtothedelegatesoftheBalkanstates,showingthemthatbysuchasystemofarbitrationasisnowproposedthelesserpowerswouldbetheveryfirsttoprofit,andheappealedtotheirloyaltytohumanity。Thespeechwasgreatlyandjustlyapplauded。
TheBalkandelegatesaregraduallyandgracefullyyielding。
July21。
Inthemorningtothe"HouseintheWood,"whereaplenarysessionoftheconferencewasheld。Itwasafielddayonexplosive,flatteningandexpandingbullets,etc。OurCaptainCrozier,whoevidentlyknowsmoreaboutthesubjectthananybodyelsehere,urgedadeclarationoftheprinciplethatballsshouldbenotmoredeadlyorcruelthanisabsolutelynecessarytoputsoldiershorsdecombat;butthecommitteehadreportedaresolutionwhich,Crozierinsists,opensthedoortoworsemissilesthanthoseatpresentused。Manyandearnestspeechesweremade。Imadeashortspeech,movingtoreferthematterbacktothecommittee,withinstructionstoharmonizeandcombinethetwoideasinonearticle——thatis,theideawhichthearticlenowexpresses,andCrozier’sideaofstatingthegeneralprincipletowhichthebulletsshouldconform——namely,thatofnotmakingawoundmorecruelthannecessary;buttheamendmentwaslost。
July22。
SirJulianPauncefotecalledtodiscusswithusthesigningoftheActeFinal。Thereseemstobegeneraldoubtastowhatisthebestmannerofsigningtheconventions,declarations,etc。,andallremainsintheair。
InthemorningtheAmericandelegationmetandCaptainMahanthrewinabombregardingarticle27,whichrequiresthatwhenanytwopartiestotheconferencearedriftingintowar,theotherpowersshouldconsideritaduty(devoir)toremindthemofthearbitrationtribunal,etc。HethinksthatthisinfringestheAmericandoctrineofnotentanglingourselvesintheaffairsofforeignstates,andwillpreventtheratificationoftheconventionbytheUnitedStatesSenate。Thisarousedearnestdebate,CaptainMahaninsistingupontheomissionoftheword"devoir,"andDr。Hollsdefendingthearticleasreportedbythesubcommittee,ofwhichheisamember,andcontendingthatthepeculiarinterestsofAmericacouldbeprotectedbyareservation。Finally,thedelegationvotedtoinsistupontheinsertionofthequalifyingwords,"autantquelescirconstancespermettent,"butthisdecisionwasafterwardabandoned。
July23。
MetatourMinisterNewel’ssupperSirHenryHoward,whotoldmethatthepresentDutchministry,withPiersoonatitsheadandDeBeaufortasministerofforeignaffairs,isinaverybadway;
thatits"subserviencytoItaly,"inoppositiontothedemandsoftheVaticanforadmittanceintotheconference,anditsdifficultieswiththesocialistsandothers,arisingfromthepolicemeasurestakenagainstArmenian,Finnish,NewTurkish,andotheroratorswhohavewishedtocomehereandmaketheconferenceandthecityabear—garden,haveledboththeextremeparties——thatis,thesolidRomanCatholicpartyononeside,andthepretendedvotariesoflibertyontheother——tohatetheministryequally。Hethinksthattheywilljoinhandsandousttheministryjustassoonastheconferenceisover。
SomeallowanceistobemadeforthefactthatSirHenryisaRomanCatholic:whilegenerallyliberal,heevidentlylooksatmanyquestionsfromthepointofviewofhischurch。[9]
[9]Asitturnedout,hewasright:theministrywasousted,butnotsosoonasheexpected,forthecatastrophedidnotarriveuntilabouttwoyearslater。ThencameinacoalitionofhighCalvinistsandRomanCatholicswhichbroughtintheKuyperministry。
July24。
Forsomedays——infact,eversinceCaptainMahanonthe22dcalledattentiontoarticle27ofthearbitrationconventionaslikelytobeconsideredaninfringementoftheMonroeDoctrine——ourAmericandelegationhasbeengreatlyperplexed。WehavebeentryingtoinducetheFrench,whoproposedarticle27,andwhoareasmuchattachedtoitasisahentoheronechick,togiveitup,or,atleast,toallowalimitingorexplanatoryclausetobeplacedwithit。Variousclausesofthissorthavebeenproposed。Thearticleitselfmakesitthedutyoftheothersignatorypowers,whenanytwonationsareevidentlydriftingtowardwar,toremindthesetwonationsthatthearbitrationtribunalisopentothem。Nothingcanbemoresimpleandnatural;
butwefearlest,whentheconventioncomesupforratificationintheUnitedStatesSenate,someover—sensitivepatriotmayseektodefeatitbyinsistingthatitisreallyaviolationoftime—honoredAmericanpolicyathomeandabroad——thepolicyofnotentanglingourselvesintheaffairsofforeignnations,ononeside,andofnotallowingthemtointerfereinouraffairs,ontheother。
AttwelvethisdayourdelegationgavealargeluncheonattheOudeDoelen——amongthosepresentbeingAmbassadorsDeStaal,CountNigra,andSirJulianPauncefote,Bourgeois,Karnebeek,Basily,Barond’Estournelles,BarondeBildt,andothers——todiscussmeansofgettingoutoftheabove—mentioneddifficulty。A
mostearnesteffortwasmadetoinducetheFrenchtoallowsomesuchmodificationashasbeenputintootherarticles——namely,thewords,"autantquepossible,"orsomelimitingclausetothesameeffect;butneitherBourgeoisnorD’Estournelles,representingFrance,wouldthinkofitforamoment。Bourgeois,astheheadoftheFrenchdelegation,spokeagainandagain,atgreatlength。Amongotherthings,hegaveusaverylongdisquisitiononthemeaningof"devoir"asitstandsinthearticle——adisquisitionwhichshowedthattheJesuitsarenottheonlyskilfulcasuistsintheworld。
IthenpresentedmyprojectofadeclarationoftheAmericandoctrinetobemadebyusonsigning。Ithadbeenscratchedoffwithapencilinthemorning,hastily;butitwaswellreceivedbyBourgeois,D’Estournelles,andalltheothers。
Laterweheldameetingofourowndelegation,when,tomyprojectofadeclarationstatingthatnothingcontainedinanypartoftheconventionsignedhereshouldbeconsideredasrequiringustointrude,mingle,orentangleourselvesinEuropeanpoliticsorinternalaffairs,LowmadeanexcellentadditiontotheeffectthatnothingshouldbeconsideredtorequireanyabandonmentofthetraditionalattitudeoftheUnitedStatestowardquestionspurelyAmerican;and,withslightverbalchanges,thiscombinationwasadopted。
July25。
AllnightlongIhavebeentossingaboutinmybedandthinkingofourdeclarationoftheMonroeDoctrinetobebroughtbeforetheconferenceto—day。Weallfearthattheconferencewillnotreceiveit,orwillinsistonoursigningwithoutitornotsigningatall。
OnmywaytoTheHaguefromScheveningenImetM。Descamps,theeminentprofessorofinternationallawintheUniversityofLouvain,andtheleadingdelegateintheconferenceasregardsintricatelegalquestionsconnectedwiththearbitrationplan。Hethoughtthatourbestwayoutofthedifficultywasabsolutelytoinsistonaclauselimitingthedevoirimposedbyarticle27,andtoforceittoavote。Hedeclaredthat,inspiteoftheFrench,itwouldcertainlybecarried。ThisIdoubt。M。Descampsknows,perhaps,moreofinternationallawthanofthetemperofhisassociates。
Intheafternoontothe"HouseintheWood,"wherethe"FinalAct"wasread。Thisisastatementofwhathasbeendone,summedupintheformofthreeconventions,withsundrydeclarations,voeux,etc。Wehadtakenpainstoseeanumberoftheleadingdelegates,andall,intheiranxietytosavethemainfeaturesofthearbitrationplan,agreedthattheywouldnotopposeourdeclaration。ItwasthereforeplacedinthehandsofRaffalovitch,theRussiansecretary,whostoodclosebesidethepresident,andassoonasthe"FinalAct"hadbeenrecitedhereadthisdeclarationofours。ThiswasthenbroughtbeforetheconferenceinplenarysessionbyM。deStaal,andtheconferencewasaskedwhetheranyonebadanyobjection,oranythingtosayregardingit。Therewasapauseofaboutaminute,whichseemedtomeaboutanhour。Notawordwassaid,——infact,therewasdeadsilence,——andsoourdeclarationembodyingareservationinfavoroftheMonroeDoctrinewasdulyrecordedandbecamepartoftheproceedings。
RarelyinmylifehaveIhadsuchafeelingofdeeprelief;for,duringsomedayspast,ithaslookedasifthearbitrationproject,sofarastheUnitedStatesisconcerned,wouldbewreckedonthatwretchedlittlearticle27。
Ihadbeforemenotesofaspeechcarefullyprepared,statingourreasonsandreplyingtoobjections,tobeusedincasewewereattacked,butitwasnotneeded。IntheeveningIwasaskedbyMr。Lavino,thecorrespondentoftheLondon"Times,"toputthegistofitintoan"interview"forthegreatnewspaperwhichheserves,andtothisIconsented;for,duringtheproceedingsthisafternoonintheconference,SirJulianPauncefoteshowedgreatuneasiness。Hewasveryanxiousthatweshouldwithdrawthedeclarationaltogether,andsaid,"Itwillbechargedagainstyouthatyouproposetoevadeyourdutieswhileusingthetreatytopromoteyourinterests";butIheldfirmandpressedthematter,withtheresultabovestated。Ifearedthathewouldobjectinopenconference;buthisloyaltytoarbitrationevidentlydeterredhim。However,hereturnedtothechargeprivately,andI
thenpromisedtomakeapublicstatementofourreasonsforthedeclaration,andthisseemedtoeasehismind。Theresultwasarecastingofmyproposedspeech,andthisMr。Lavinothrewintotheformofalongtelegramtothe"Times。"
July26。
AttentoameetingofourAmericandelegation,whenanotherbombshellwasthrownamongus——nothinglessthanthequestionwhetherthePopeistobeallowedtobecomeoneofthesignatorypowers;andthisquestionhasnowtakenaveryacuteform。Italyis,ofcourse,utterlyopposedtoit,andGreatBritainwillnotsignifanybesidesthoseagreeduponbythesignatorypowersareallowedtocomeinhereafter,hermotivebeing,nodoubt,toavoidtroubleinregardtotheTransvaal。
Mr。Lowstatedthatinthegreatcommitteetheprevailingopinionseemedtobethatthesignatorypowershadmadeasortofpartnership,andthatnonewpartnerscouldbeaddedwithouttheconsentofall。Thisisthenaturalground,andentirelytenable。
Iwouldhavebeengladtoaddtheadditionalrequirementthatnopowershouldbeadmittedwhichwouldnotmakearbitrationreciprocal——thatis,nopowerwhich,whileaidingtoarbitrateforothers,wouldnotacceptarbitrationbetweenitselfandanotherpower。Thiswould,ofcourse,excludetheVatican;for,whileitdesirestojudgeothers,itwillallownointerestsofitsown,noteventhemostworldlyandtrivial,tobesubmittedtoanyearthlytribunal。