首页 >出版文学> Areopagitica>第5章

第5章

  Whatsomelamentof,werathershouldrejoiceat,shouldratherpraisethispiousforwardnessamongmen,toreassumetheill—
  deputedcareoftheirreligionintotheirownhandsagain。A
  littlegenerousprudence,alittleforbearanceofoneanother,andsomegrainofcharitymightwinallthesediligencestojoin,anduniteinonegeneralandbrotherlysearchaftertruth;couldwebutforgothisprelaticaltraditionofcrowdingfreeconsciencesandChristianlibertiesintocanonsandpreceptsofmen。Idoubtnot,ifsomegreatandworthystrangershouldcomeamongus,wisetodiscernthemouldandtemperofapeople,andhowtogovernit,observingthehighhopesandaims,thediligentalacrityofourextendedthoughtsandreasoningsinthepursuanceoftruthandfreedom,butthathewouldcryoutasPyrrhusdid,admiringtheRomandocilityandcourage:IfsuchweremyEpirots,Iwouldnotdespairthegreatestdesignthatcouldbeattempted,tomakeaChurchorkingdomhappy。
  Yetthesearethemencriedoutagainstforschismaticsandsectaries;asif,whilethetempleoftheLordwasbuilding,somecutting,somesquaringthemarble,othershewingthecedars,thereshouldbeasortofirrationalmenwhocouldnotconsidertheremustbemanyschismsandmanydissectionsmadeinthequarryandinthetimber,erethehouseofGodcanbebuilt。Andwheneverystoneislaidartfullytogether,itcannotbeunitedintoacontinuity,itcanbutbecontiguousinthisworld;neithercaneverypieceofthebuildingbeofoneform;nayrathertheperfectionconsistsinthis,that,outofmanymoderatevarietiesandbrotherlydissimilitudesthatarenotvastlydisproportional,arisesthegoodlyandthegracefulsymmetrythatcommendsthewholepileandstructure。
  Letusthereforebemoreconsideratebuilders,morewiseinspiritualarchitecture,whengreatreformationisexpected。Fornowthetimeseemscome,whereinMosesthegreatprophetmaysitinheavenrejoicingtoseethatmemorableandgloriouswishofhisfulfilled,whennotonlyourseventyelders,butalltheLord’speople,arebecomeprophets。Nomarvelthenthoughsomemen,andsomegoodmentooperhaps,butyoungingoodness,asJoshuathenwas,envythem。Theyfret,andoutoftheirownweaknessareinagony,lestthesedivisionsandsubdivisionswillundous。Theadversaryagainapplauds,andwaitsthehour:whentheyhavebranchedthemselvesout,saithhe,smallenoughintopartiesandpartitions,thenwillbeourtime。Fool!heseesnotthefirmroot,outofwhichweallgrow,thoughintobranches:norwillbewareuntilheseeoursmalldividedmaniplescuttingthroughateveryangleofhisill—unitedandunwieldybrigade。Andthatwearetohopebetterofallthesesupposedsectsandschisms,andthatweshallnotneedthatsolicitude,honestperhaps,thoughover—timorous,ofthemthatvexinthisbehalf,butshalllaughintheendatthosemaliciousapplaudersofourdifferences,Ihavethesereasonstopersuademe。
  First,whenacityshallbeasitwerebesiegedandblockedabout,hernavigableriverinfested,inroadsandincursionsround,defianceandbattleoftrumouredtobemarchingupeventoherwallsandsuburbtrenches,thatthenthepeople,orthegreaterpart,morethanatothertimes,whollytakenupwiththestudyofhighestandmostimportantmatterstobereformed,shouldbedisputing,reasoning,reading,inventing,discoursing,eventoararityandadmiration,thingsnotbeforediscoursedorwrittenof,arguesfirstasingulargoodwill,contentednessandconfidenceinyourprudentforesightandsafegovernment,LordsandCommons;andfromthencederivesitselftoagallantbraveryandwell—groundedcontemptoftheirenemies,asiftherewerenosmallnumberofasgreatspiritsamongus,ashiswas,whowhenRomewasnighbesiegedbyHannibal,beinginthecity,boughtthatpieceofgroundatnocheaprate,whereonHannibalhimselfencampedhisownregiment。
  Next,itisalivelyandcheerfulpresageofourhappysuccessandvictory。Forasinabody,whenthebloodisfresh,thespiritspureandvigorous,notonlytovitalbuttorationalfaculties,andthoseintheacutestandthepertestoperationsofwitandsubtlety,itarguesinwhatgoodplightandconstitutionthebodyis;sowhenthecheerfulnessofthepeopleissosprightlyup,asthatithasnotonlywherewithtoguardwellitsownfreedomandsafety,buttospare,andtobestowuponthesolidestandsublimestpointsofcontroversyandnewinvention,itbetokensusnotdegenerated,nordroopingtoafataldecay,butcastingofftheoldandwrinkledskinofcorruptiontooutlivethesepangsandwaxyoungagain,enteringthegloriouswaysoftruthandprosperousvirtue,destinedtobecomegreatandhonourableintheselatterages。MethinksIseeinmymindanobleandpuissantnationrousingherselflikeastrongmanaftersleep,andshakingherinvinciblelocks:methinksIseeherasaneaglemewinghermightyyouth,andkindlingherundazzledeyesatthefullmiddaybeam;
  purgingandunscalingherlong—abusedsightatthefountainitselfofheavenlyradiance;whilethewholenoiseoftimorousandflockingbirds,withthosealsothatlovethetwilight,flutterabout,amazedatwhatshemeans,andintheirenviousgabblewouldprognosticateayearofsectsandschisms。
  Whatwouldyedothen?shouldyesuppressallthisflowerycropofknowledgeandnewlightsprungupandyetspringingdailyinthiscity?Shouldyesetanoligarchyoftwentyengrossersoverit,tobringafamineuponourmindsagain,whenweshallknownothingbutwhatismeasuredtousbytheirbushel?Believeit,LordsandCommons,theywhocounselyetosuchasuppressingdoasgoodasbidyesuppressyourselves;andIwillsoonshowhow。Ifitbedesiredtoknowtheimmediatecauseofallthisfreewritingandfreespeaking,therecannotbeassignedatruerthanyourownmildandfreeandhumanegovernment。Itistheliberty,LordsandCommons,whichyourownvalorousandhappycounselshavepurchasedus,libertywhichisthenurseofallgreatwits;thisisthatwhichhathrarefiedandenlightenedourspiritsliketheinfluenceofheaven;thisisthatwhichhathenfranchised,enlargedandliftedupourapprehensions,degreesabovethemselves。
  Yecannotmakeusnowlesscapable,lessknowing,lesseagerlypursuingofthetruth,unlessyefirstmakeyourselves,thatmadeusso,lessthelovers,lessthefoundersofourtrueliberty。Wecangrowignorantagain,brutish,formalandslavish,asyefoundus;butyouthenmustfirstbecomethatwhichyecannotbe,oppressive,arbitraryandtyrannous,astheywerefromwhomyehavefreedus。Thatourheartsarenowmorecapacious,ourthoughtsmoreerectedtothesearchandexpectationofgreatestandexactestthings,istheissueofyourownvirtuepropagatedinus;yecannotsuppressthat,unlessyereinforceanabrogatedandmercilesslaw,thatfathersmaydispatchatwilltheirownchildren。Andwhoshallthenstickclosesttoye,andexciteothers?nothewhotakesuparmsforcoatandconduct,andhisfournoblesofDanegelt。
  AlthoughIdispraisenotthedefenceofjustimmunities,yetlovemypeacebetter,ifthatwereall。Givemethelibertytoknow,toutter,andtoarguefreelyaccordingtoconscience,aboveallliberties。
  Whatwouldbebestadvised,then,ifitbefoundsohurtfulandsounequaltosuppressopinionsforthenewnessortheunsuitablenesstoacustomaryacceptance,willnotbemytasktosay。IonlyshallrepeatwhatIhavelearnedfromoneofyourownhonourablenumber,arightnobleandpiouslord,who,hadhenotsacrificedhislifeandfortunestotheChurchandCommonwealth,wehadnotnowmissedandbewailedaworthyandundoubtedpatronofthisargument。Yeknowhim,Iamsure;yetIforhonour’ssake,andmayitbeeternaltohim,shallnamehim,theLordBrook。Hewritingofepiscopacy,andbythewaytreatingofsectsandschisms,leftyehisvote,orrathernowthelastwordsofhisdyingcharge,whichIknowwilleverbeofdearandhonouredregardwithye,sofullofmeeknessandbreathingcharity,thatnexttohislasttestament,whobequeathedloveandpeacetohisdisciples,IcannotcalltomindwhereIhavereadorheardwordsmoremildandpeaceful。Hethereexhortsustohearwithpatienceandhumilitythose,howevertheybemiscalled,thatdesiretolivepurely,insuchauseofGod’sordinances,asthebestguidanceoftheirconsciencegivesthem,andtotoleratethem,thoughinsomedisconformitytoourselves。Thebookitselfwilltellusmoreatlarge,beingpublishedtotheworld,anddedicatedtotheParliamentbyhimwho,bothforhislifeandforhisdeath,deservesthatwhatadviceheleftbenotlaidbywithoutperusal。
  Andnowthetimeinspecialis,byprivilegetowriteandspeakwhatmayhelptothefurtherdiscussingofmattersinagitation。
  ThetempleofJanuswithhistwocontroversialfacesmightnownotunsignificantlybesetopen。Andthoughallthewindsofdoctrinewereletloosetoplayupontheearth,soTruthbeinthefield,wedoinjuriously,bylicensingandprohibiting,tomisdoubtherstrength。LetherandFalsehoodgrapple;whoeverknewTruthputtotheworse,inafreeandopenencounter?Herconfutingisthebestandsurestsuppressing。Hewhohearswhatprayingthereisforlightandclearerknowledgetobesentdownamongus,wouldthinkofothermatterstobeconstitutedbeyondthedisciplineofGeneva,framedandfabrickedalreadytoourhands。Yetwhenthenewlightwhichwebegforshinesinuponus,therebewhoenvyandoppose,ifitcomenotfirstinattheircasements。Whatacollusionisthis,whenasweareexhortedbythewisemantousediligence,toseekforwisdomasforhiddentreasuresearlyandlate,thatanotherordershallenjoinustoknownothingbutbystatute?Whenamanhathbeenlabouringthehardestlabourinthedeepminesofknowledge,hathfurnishedouthisfindingsinalltheirequipage:drawnforthhisreasonsasitwereabattleranged:
  scatteredanddefeatedallobjectionsinhisway;callsouthisadversaryintotheplain,offershimtheadvantageofwindandsun,ifheplease,onlythathemaytrythematterbydintofargument:
  forhisopponentsthentoskulk,tolayambushments,tokeepanarrowbridgeoflicensingwherethechallengershouldpass,thoughitbevalourenoughinsoldiership,isbutweaknessandcowardiceinthewarsofTruth。
  ForwhoknowsnotthatTruthisstrong,nexttotheAlmighty?
  Sheneedsnopolicies,norstratagems,norlicensingstomakehervictorious;thosearetheshiftsandthedefencesthaterrorusesagainstherpower。Giveherbutroom,anddonotbindherwhenshesleeps,forthenshespeaksnottrue,astheoldProteusdid,whospakeoraclesonlywhenhewascaughtandbound,butthenrathersheturnsherselfintoallshapes,exceptherown,andperhapstuneshervoiceaccordingtothetime,asMicaiahdidbeforeAhab,untilshebeadjuredintoherownlikeness。Yetisitnotimpossiblethatshemayhavemoreshapesthanone。Whatelseisallthatrankofthingsindifferent,whereinTruthmaybeonthissideorontheother,withoutbeingunlikeherself?Whatbutavainshadowelseistheabolitionofthoseordinances,thathand—writingnailedtothecross?WhatgreatpurchaseisthisChristianlibertywhichPaulsooftenboastsof?Hisdoctrineis,thathewhoeatsoreatsnot,regardsadayorregardsitnot,maydoeithertotheLord。Howmanyotherthingsmightbetoleratedinpeace,andlefttoconscience,hadwebutcharity,andwereitnotthechiefstrongholdofourhypocrisytobeeverjudgingoneanother?
  Ifearyetthisironyokeofoutwardconformityhathleftaslavishprintuponournecks;theghostofalinendecencyyethauntsus。Westumbleandareimpatientattheleastdividingofonevisiblecongregationfromanother,thoughitbenotinfundamentals;andthroughourforwardnesstosuppress,andourbackwardnesstorecoveranyenthralledpieceoftruthoutofthegripeofcustom,wecarenottokeeptruthseparatedfromtruth,whichisthefiercestrentanddisunionofall。Wedonotseethat,whilewestillaffectbyallmeansarigidexternalformality,wemayassoonfallagainintoagrossconformingstupidity,astarkanddeadcongealmentofwoodandhayandstubble,forcedandfrozentogether,whichismoretothesuddendegeneratingofaChurchthanmanysubdichotomiesofpettyschisms。
  NotthatIcanthinkwellofeverylightseparation,orthatallinaChurchistobeexpectedgoldandsilverandpreciousstones:itisnotpossibleformantoseverthewheatfromthetares,thegoodfishfromtheotherfry;thatmustbetheAngels’
  ministryattheendofmortalthings。Yetifallcannotbeofonemind——aswholookstheyshouldbe?——thisdoubtlessismorewholesome,moreprudent,andmoreChristian,thatmanybetolerated,ratherthanallcompelled。Imeannottoleratedpopery,andopensuperstition,which,asitextirpatesallreligionsandcivilsupremacies,soitselfshouldbeextirpate,providedfirstthatallcharitableandcompassionatemeansbeusedtowinandregaintheweakandthemisled:thatalsowhichisimpiousorevilabsolutelyeitheragainstfaithormannersnolawcanpossiblypermit,thatintendsnottounlawitself:butthoseneighbouringdifferences,orratherindifferences,arewhatIspeakof,whetherinsomepointofdoctrineorofdiscipline,which,thoughtheymaybemany,yetneednotinterruptTHEUNITYOFSPIRIT,ifwecouldbutfindamongusTHEBONDOFPEACE。
  Inthemeanwhileifanyonewouldwrite,andbringhishelpfulhandtotheslow—movingReformationwhichwelabourunder,ifTruthhavespokentohimbeforeothers,orbutseemedatleasttospeak,whohathsobejesuitedusthatweshouldtroublethatmanwithaskinglicensetodosoworthyadeed?andnotconsiderthis,thatifitcometoprohibiting,thereisnotaughtmorelikelytobeprohibitedthantruthitself;whosefirstappearancetooureyes,blearedanddimmedwithprejudiceandcustom,ismoreunsightlyandunplausiblethanmanyerrors,evenasthepersonisofmanyagreatmanslightandcontemptuoustoseeto。Andwhatdotheytellusvainlyofnewopinions,whenthisveryopinionoftheirs,thatnonemustbeheardbutwhomtheylike,istheworstandnewestopinionofallothers;andisthechiefcausewhysectsandschismsdosomuchabound,andtrueknowledgeiskeptatdistancefromus;
  besidesyetagreaterdangerwhichisinit。
  ForwhenGodshakesakingdomwithstrongandhealthfulcommotionstoageneralreforming,’tisnotuntruethatmanysectariesandfalseteachersarethenbusiestinseducing;butyetmoretrueitis,thatGodthenraisestohisownworkmenofrareabilities,andmorethancommonindustry,notonlytolookbackandrevisewhathathbeentaughtheretofore,buttogainfurtherandgoonsomenewenlightenedstepsinthediscoveryoftruth。ForsuchistheorderofGod’senlighteninghisChurch,todispenseanddealoutbydegreeshisbeam,soasourearthlyeyesmaybestsustainit。
  NeitherisGodappointedandconfined,whereandoutofwhatplacethesehischosenshallbefirstheardtospeak;forheseesnotasmansees,choosesnotasmanchooses,lestweshoulddevoteourselvesagaintosetplaces,andassemblies,andoutwardcallingsofmen;plantingourfaithonewhileintheoldConvocationhouse,andanotherwhileintheChapelatWestminster;whenallthefaithandreligionthatshallbetherecanonizedisnotsufficientwithoutplainconvincement,andthecharityofpatientinstructiontosuppletheleastbruiseofconscience,toedifythemeanestChristian,whodesirestowalkintheSpirit,andnotintheletterofhumantrust,forallthenumberofvoicesthatcanbetheremade;no,thoughHarryVIIhimselfthere,withallhisliegetombsabouthim,shouldlendthemvoicesfromthedead,toswelltheirnumber。
  Andifthemenbeerroneouswhoappeartobetheleadingschismatics,whatwithholdsusbutoursloth,ourself—will,anddistrustintherightcause,thatwedonotgivethemgentlemeetingsandgentledismissions,thatwedebatenotandexaminethematterthoroughlywithliberalandfrequentaudience;ifnotfortheirsakes,yetforourown?seeingnomanwhohathtastedlearning,butwillconfessthemanywaysofprofitingbythosewho,notcontentedwithstalereceipts,areabletomanageandsetforthnewpositionstotheworld。Andweretheybutasthedustandcindersofourfeet,solongasinthatnotiontheymayyetservetopolishandbrightenthearmouryofTruth,evenforthatrespecttheywerenotutterlytobecastaway。ButiftheybeofthosewhomGodhathfittedforthespecialuseofthesetimeswitheminentandamplegifts,andthoseperhapsneitheramongthepriestsnoramongthePharisees,andweinthehasteofaprecipitantzealshallmakenodistinction,butresolvetostoptheirmouths,becausewefeartheycomewithnewanddangerousopinions,aswecommonlyforejudgethemereweunderstandthem;nolessthanwoetous,while,thinkingthustodefendtheGospel,wearefoundthepersecutors。
  TherehavebeennotafewsincethebeginningofthisParliament,bothofthepresbyteryandothers,whobytheirunlicensedbooks,tothecontemptofanImprimatur,firstbrokethattripleiceclungaboutourhearts,andtaughtthepeopletoseeday:Ihopethatnoneofthosewerethepersuaderstorenewuponusthisbondagewhichtheythemselveshavewroughtsomuchgoodbycontemning。ButifneitherthecheckthatMosesgavetoyoungJoshua,northecountermandwhichourSaviourgavetoyoungJohn,whowassoreadytoprohibitthosewhomhethoughtunlicensed,benotenoughtoadmonishoureldershowunacceptabletoGodtheirtestymoodofprohibitingis;ifneithertheirownremembrancewhatevilhathaboundedintheChurchbythissetoflicensing,andwhatgoodtheythemselveshavebegunbytransgressingit,benotenough,butthattheywillpersuadeandexecutethemostDominicanpartoftheInquisitionoverus,andarealreadywithonefootinthestirrupsoactiveatsuppressing,itwouldbenounequaldistributioninthefirstplacetosuppressthesuppressorsthemselves:whomthechangeoftheirconditionhathpuffedup,morethantheirlateexperienceofhardertimeshathmadewise。
  Andasforregulatingthepress,letnomanthinktohavethehonourofadvisingyebetterthanyourselveshavedoneinthatOrderpublishednextbeforethis,"thatnobookbeprinted,unlesstheprinter’sandtheauthor’sname,oratleasttheprinter’s,beregistered。"Thosewhichotherwisecomeforth,iftheybefoundmischievousandlibellous,thefireandtheexecutionerwillbethetimeliestandthemosteffectualremedythatman’spreventioncanuse。ForthisauthenticSpanishpolicyoflicensingbooks,ifI
  havesaidaught,willprovethemostunlicensedbookitselfwithinashortwhile;andwastheimmediateimageofaStarChamberdecreetothatpurposemadeinthoseverytimeswhenthatCourtdidtherestofthoseherpiousworks,forwhichsheisnowfallenfromthestarswithLucifer。Wherebyyemayguesswhatkindofstateprudence,whatloveofthepeople,whatcareofreligionorgoodmannerstherewasatthecontriving,althoughwithsingularhypocrisyitpretendedtobindbookstotheirgoodbehaviour。AndhowitgottheupperhandofyourprecedentOrdersowellconstitutedbefore,ifwemaybelievethosemenwhoseprofessiongivesthemcausetoinquiremost,itmaybedoubtedtherewasinitthefraudofsomeoldpatenteesandmonopolizersinthetradeofbookselling;whounderpretenceofthepoorintheirCompanynottobedefrauded,andthejustretainingofeachmanhisseveralcopy,whichGodforbidshouldbegainsaid,broughtdiversglossingcolourstotheHouse,whichwereindeedbutcolours,andservingtonoendexceptitbetoexerciseasuperiorityovertheirneighbours;menwhodonotthereforelabourinanhonestprofessiontowhichlearningisindebted,thattheyshouldbemadeothermen’svassals。AnotherendisthoughtwasaimedatbysomeoftheminprocuringbypetitionthisOrder,that,havingpowerintheirhands,malignantbooksmighttheeasierscapeabroad,astheeventshows。
  ButofthesesophismsandelenchsofmerchandiseIskillnot。
  ThisIknow,thaterrorsinagoodgovernmentandinabadareequallyalmostincident;forwhatmagistratemaynotbemisinformed,andmuchthesooner,iflibertyofprintingbereducedintothepowerofafew?Buttoredresswillinglyandspeedilywhathathbeenerred,andinhighestauthoritytoesteemaplainadvertisementmorethanothershavedoneasumptuousbride,isavirtue(honouredLordsandCommons)answerabletoyourhighestactions,andwhereofnonecanparticipatebutgreatestandwisestmen。