IntroductoryNoteThomasCarlylewasbornatEcclefechaninthesouthofScotland,December4,1795。Hisfather,arigorousCalvinistbelongingtotheseceding"BurgherKirk,"wasastone—mason,amanofsternanduprightcharacterwithagiftoffieryspeech。Thomasbeganhiseducationathome,wentnexttothevillageschool,thencetothegrammarschoolatAnnan,andin1809walkedtoEdinburgh,ahundredmilesaway,andenteredtheUniversitywithaviewtopreparingfortheministry。Onfinishinghisartscourse,hewasappointedmathematicalusheratAnnanandtwoyearslateratKirkcaldy,whereheformedanintimatefriendshipwithEdwardIrving。Buthehatedteaching,and,ashehadabandonedhisorthodoxviewsandcouldnolongerthinkofpreaching,hereturnedtoEdinburghtostudyforthebar,supportinghimselfbyprivatetutoringandwritingforencyclopedias。Theseyears,1819—1822,heregardedasthemostmiserableofhislife。Tormentedwithdyspepsia,tornwithreligiousperplexity,withnoprospectsandnoprofession,hefoundcomfortonlyintheaffectionofhisfamily。ItwasaboutthistimethatthestudyofGermanledhimtoGoethe,whoprovedhischiefaidinhisstrugglestogainspiritualpeace。
ThroughIrvingCarlyleobtainedapositionastutortoCharlesandArthurBulleratasalarythatenabledhimtohelphisfamilyinsubstantialways。Thisengagementlastedfortwoyears,duringwhichhetranslatedLegendre's"Geometry"andGoethe's"WilhelmMeister,"andwrotea"LifeofSchiller。"
HisrelationwiththeBullersledhimtoLondon,andforashorttimetoParis;
andinhis"Reminiscences"wehaveagraphicpictureoftheunfavorableimpressionmadeonhimbyfashionableandliterarysociety。
Henowretiredtoafarmnearhisfather'shouse,andspentapeacefulyear,chieflyintranslating。In1826hemarriedJaneBaillieWelsh,thebrilliantandbeautifuldaughterofadoctorinHaddington,whomhehadmetthroughIrving。MissWelshwasdescendedononesidefromJohnKnox,ontheotherfromthegypsies,and,itwasclaimed,WilliamWallace;andhertemperamentdidnotbelieherancestry。Shehadbeenmuchcourted,andherwooingbyCarlylewasasominousasitwasextraordinary。Overtheirsubsequentdomesticrelationstherehasbeenavastamountofunseemlycontroversy,noonecondemningCarlylemoreseverelythanhedidhimself。Yetitmaybearguedthattheyfoundintheirmarriageasmuchsatisfactionaseitherofthemwascapableoffindinginweddedlife。Carlyle'sabsorptioninhisworkandhiscareerundoubtedlyledtomuchneglectandsufferingonthepartofhiswife,butitisclearthattheexpressionsofremorseinhiswritingsafterherdeatharenotfairlytobetakenasjudicialevidenceagainsthim。
Forthefirsteighteenmonthsaftermarriage,theCarlyleslivedinEdinburgh,wheretheysharedinthemostdistinguishedintellectualsocietyofthecity,andwhereCarlyleformedwithFrancisJeffreyapleasantandusefulrelation。
Jeffreyacceptedarticlesforthe"EdinburghReview,"andtheirsuccessthereopenedtoCarlylethepagesofotherperiodicals。ThefirsttworeviewswereonRichterandonGermanLiterature,which,withhistranslationsandlaterwritingsinthesamefield,gainedhimrecognitionasapioneerofGermanliteratureinEngland,andbroughthimgenerouspersonalacknowledgmentsfromGoethe。
Inspiteofthesesuccesses,thefinancialaffairsoftheCarlyleswerestillfarfromsatisfactory,andtoreduceexpensestheyretreatedtothefarmofCraigenputtock,whichbelongedtoMrs。Carlyle。Heretheylivedformorethansixyears,inanisolationbrokenonlybyoccasionalvisitsfromguests,notableamongwhomweretheJeffreysandEmerson。Itwasherethatthequasi—autobiographical"SartorResartus"waswritten,andmoreGermanarticles,themarketforwhich,however,grewdullerandduller。A
visittoLondonin1831,forwhichhehadtoborrowmoneyfromJeffrey,ledtonewrelationswithpublishersandeditors;andfourmonthsinEdinburghbroadenedhisrangeofsubjects。But,finally,solitudeandtheneedofmoneydrovethemtoLondon,wheretheysettledin1834inthehouseinCheyneRow,Chelsea,wheretheylivedfortherestoftheirlives。
ThemostimportanteventoftheearlieryearsoftheLondonperiodwastheripeningofCarlyle'sfriendshipwithJ。S。Mill。Tothisintercoursewasduehisundertakinghis"HistoryoftheFrenchRevolution,"publishedin1837。
Meanwhile,hesucceededingettingsorelyneededfundsbylecturing,givingfourcoursesinsuccessivesprings,thelastofwhichwashiswell—known"HeroesandHero—worship。"Theserelievedhimfrompressingnecessities,andwiththerecognitionofthebrilliantqualitiesofhis"FrenchRevolution"
cametheturninhisfortunes。Hegainedmanyfriends,amongwhomweresuchmenasJohnSterling,whoselifeheafterwardwastowritewithsympathyandcharm;F。D。Maurice,J。G。Lockhart,R。M。Milnes,afterwardsLordHoughton,andtheBarings;andhewasoftensoughtoutbyyounginquirers。EmersonhadintroducedhisworkstoAmerica,withtheresultofbothfameandprofit。HewasalreadybecominganotedfigureinintellectualcirclesinLondon。
Hispoliticalideaswereputintodefiniteshapeinhis"Chartism"(1839),and,ifanyonehadeverdoubtedit,itnowbecameclearthathewasnevertobeclassedwithanyoftheestablishedpoliticalparties。"PastandPresent,"
acontrastbetweenmedievalmonasticlifeandmodernconditions,stillfurtheremphasizedhisseparationfrombothToriesandRadicals。Whiletheseshorterworkswerebeingputforth,hewaslaboringonhisnextgreatbook,the"LifeandLettersofOliverCromwell";andwhenthisappearedin1845hispositionasoneoftheleadingmenoflettersofthedaywasthoroughlyestablished。
Afterayearortwomainlyoccupiedwithpoliticalwriting,mostofitatoncepowerfulinstyleandineffectiveinresult,hesettleddowntoanothergreattask,alifeofFredericktheGreat,whichoccupiedhismainenergiestill1865,andextendedhisreputationbothontheContinentandathome。InthisyearhewaselectedLordRectorofEdinburghUniversity。TheInauguralAddress,whichconstitutesthesoledutyofthishonoraryoffice,hedeliveredthenextyear;andonhisjourneysouthafteratriumphalreceptionhewasmetatDumfriesbythenewsofhiswife'sdeath。ShewasburiedintheAbbeyKirkatHaddington;andtheepitaphwhichherhusbandplaceduponhergravetellswhattheblowmeantforhim。Itrunsthus:"Inherbrightexistenceshehadmoresorrowsthanarecommon,butalsoasoftinvincibility,acapacityofdiscernment,andanobleloyaltyofheartwhicharerare。Forfortyyearsshewasthetrueandlovinghelpmateofherhusband,andbyactandwordunweariedlyforwardedhimasnoneelsecouldinallofworthythathedidorattempted。ShediedatLondon,21stApril,1866,suddenlysnatchedfromhim,andthelightofhislifeasifgoneout。"
And,indeed,thelightofhislifehadgoneout。Hewashenceforthabrokenman。Herevisedhiscollectedworks,wrotehis"Reminiscences,"butundertooknonewtasks。Hewasnowattheheadofhisprofession,andsurroundedbyfriendsandadmirers;honorswereshoweredonhimathomeandabroad;buthelivedinagloomthatdeepenedtotheend。HediedonFebruary4,1881,andwasburiedintheoldkirkyardatEcclefechan。
OftheworksbyCarlylehereprinted,"Characteristics"isacondensedandtellingstatementofsomeofhismostfundamentalideas;theessayon"SirWalterScott"exhibits,bothinitsstrengthandinitsshortcomings,thedominationofethicaloverestheticconsiderationsinhisestimateofliterature,andcontainsbesidesmanycharacteristicsgeneralizationsonhumanlifeandconduct;the"InauguralAddress,"thesubjectofwhichisnominallythe"ReadingofBooks,"summarizesrapidlyhisownintellectualhistory,anddigressesintrueCarlyleanfashionintoreligion,ethics,history,andavarietyofothertopics。Itiswritteninanexceptionallysimpleandstraightforwardstyle,admirablysuitedtotheoccasion;thetwootherpapersrepresentmoretrulyhishabitualmannerofexpression—oftenabrupt,oftenexaggerated,sometimesgrotesque,but,tousehisownwordsofhis"FrenchRevolution,"
coming"directandflaminglyfromtheheartofalivingman。"
Thisstylewas,indeed,highlycharacteristicofitsowner。Theendlesslaborheputintohishistories,thepassionofhispoliticalconvictions,theprofoundearnestnessofhismoralandreligiouspreaching,werecombinedwithathirstforeffectiveexpressionthatledhimtoshatteranyconventionthatstoodinthewayoftruth,andgaveaweightandedgetohisutterancethatmakeitathinguniqueinEnglishliterature。Complexandinconsistenttothepointofparadox,absolutelysincereyetexaggeratedandover—emphatic,violenttobrutalityyettenderofheart,aRadicaltotheToriesandaTorytotheRadicalsCarlyleformednoschool,yetwasoneofthemoststimulatingandpotentinfluencesofhiscentury。Overhischaracterandhismessagethevoicesofcontroversyhavenotyetdieddown,butwhoeverturnstohisworkfindscoursingeverywherethroughittheredbloodofaman。
PartI
Thehealthyknownotoftheirhealth,butonlythesick:thisisthePhysician'sAphorism;andapplicableinafarwidersensethanhegivesit。Wemaysay,itholdsnolessinmoral,intellectual,political,poetical,thaninmerelycorporealtherapeutics;thatwherever,orinwhatshapesoever,powersofthesortwhichcanbenamedvitalareatwork,hereinliesthetestoftheirworkingrightorworkingwrong。
IntheBody,forexample,asalldoctorsareagreed,thefirstconditionofcompletehealthis,thateachorganperformitsfunction,unconsciously,unheeded;letbutanyorganannounceitsseparateexistence,wereitevenboastfully,andforpleasure,notforpain,thenalreadyhasoneofthoseunfortunate'falsecentresofsensibility'establisheditself,alreadyisderangementthere。Theperfectionofbodilywell—beingisthatthecollectivebodilyactivitiesseemone;andbemanifested,moreover,notinthemselves,butintheactiontheyaccomplish。IfaDr。Kitchinerboastthathissystemisinhighorder,DieteticPhilosophymayindeedtakecredit;butthetruePepticianwasthatCountrymanwhoansweredthat,'forhispart,hehadnosystem。'
Infact,unity,agreementisalwayssilent,orsoft—voiced;itisonlydiscordthatloudlyproclaimsitself。SolongastheseveralelementsofLife,allfitlyadjusted,canpourforththeirmovementlikeharmonioustunedstrings,itisamelodyandunison;Life,fromitsmysteriousfountains,flowsoutasincelestialmusicanddiapason,—whichalso,likethatothermusicofthespheres,evenbecauseitisperennialandcomplete,withoutinterruptionandwithoutimperfection,mightbefabledtoescapetheear。Thustoo,insomelanguages,isthestateofhealthwelldenotedbyatermexpressingunity;whenwefeelourselvesaswewishtobe,wesaythatwearewhole。
Fewmortals,itistobefeared,arepermanentlyblessedwiththatfelicityof'havingnosystem';nevertheless,mostofus,lookingbackonyoungyears,mayrememberseasonsofalight,aerialtranslucencyandelasticityandperfectfreedom;thebodyhadnotyetbecometheprison—houseofthesoul,butwasitsvehicleandimplement,likeacreatureofthethought,andaltogetherplianttoitsbidding。Weknewnotthatwehadlimbs,weonlylifted,hurledandleapt;througheyeandear,andallavenuesofsense,cameclearunimpededtidingsfromwithout,andfromwithinissuedclearvictoriousforce;
westoodasinthecentreofNature,givingandreceiving,inharmonywithitall;unlikeVirgil'sHusbandmen,'toohappybecausewedidnotknowourblessedness。'
Inthosedays,healthandsicknesswereforeigntraditionsthatdidnotconcernus;ourwholebeingwasasyetOne,thewholemanlikeanincorporatedWill。
Such,wereRestorever—successfulLabourthehumanlot,mightourlifecontinuetobe:apure,perpetual,unregardedmusic;abeamofperfectwhitelight,renderingallthingsvisible,butitselfunseen,evenbecauseitwasofthatperfectwhiteness,andnoirregularobstructionhadyetbrokenitintocolours。
ThebeginningofInquiryisDisease:allScience,ifweconsiderwell,asitmusthaveoriginatedinthefeelingofsomethingbeingwrong,soitisandcontinuestobebutDivision,Dismemberment,andpartialhealingofthewrong。
Thus,aswasofoldwritten,theTreeofKnowledgespringsfromarootofevil,andbearsfruitsofgoodandevil。HadAdamremainedinParadise,therehadbeennoAnatomyandnoMetaphysics。
But,alas,asthePhilosopherdeclares,'Lifeitselfisadisease;aworkingincitedbysuffering';actionfrompassion!ThememoryofthatfirststateofFreedomandparadisaicUnconsciousnesshasfadedawayintoanidealpoeticdream。Westandheretooconsciousofmanythings:withKnowledge,thesymptomofDerangement,wemustevendoourbesttorestorealittleOrder。
Lifeis,infewinstances,andatrareintervals,thediapasonofaheavenlymelody;oftenestthefiercejarofdisruptionsandconvulsions,which,dowhatwewill,thereisnodisregarding。Nevertheless,suchisstillthewishofNatureonourbehalf;inallvitalaction,hermanifestpurposeandeffortis,thatweshouldbeunconsciousofit,andlikethepepticCountryman,neverknowthatwe'haveasystem。'For,indeedvitalactioneverywhereisemphaticallyameans,notanend;LifeisnotgivenusforthemeresakeofLiving,butalwayswithanulteriorexternalAim:neitherisitontheprocess,onthemeans,butratherontheresult,thatNature,isanyofherdoings,iswonttointrustuswithinsightandvolition。Boundlessasisthedomainofman,itisbutasmallfractionalproportionofitthatheruleswithConsciousnessandbyForethought:whathecancontrive,nay,whathecanaltogetherknowandcomprehend,isessentiallythemechanical,small;thegreatisever,inonesenseorother,thevital;itisessentiallythemysterious,andonlythesurfaceofitcanbeunderstood。ButNature,itmightseem,strives,likeakindmother,tohidefromuseventhis,thatsheisamystery:shewillhaveusrestonherbeautifulandawfulbosomasifitwereoursecurehome;onthebottomlessboundlessDeep,whereonallhumanthingsfearfullyandwonderfullyswim,shewillhaveuswalkandbuild,asifthefilmwhichsupportedusthere(whichanyscratchofabarebodkinwillrendasunder,anysputterofapistol—shotinstantaneouslyburnup)werenofilm,butasolidrock—foundation。
ForeverintheneighbourhoodofaninevitableDeath,mancanforgetthatheisborntodie;ofhisLife,which,strictlymeditated,containsinitanImmensityandanEternity,hecanconceivelightly,asofasimpleimplementwherewithtododay—labourandearnwages。SocunninglydoesNature,themotherofallhighestArt,whichonlyapesherfromafar,'bodyforththeFinitefromtheInfinite';andguidemansafeonhiswondrouspath,notmorebyendowinghimwithvision,than,attherightplace,withblindness!Underallherworks,chieflyunderhernoblestwork,Life,liesabasisofDarkness,whichshebenignantlyconceals;inLifetoo,therootsandinwardcirculationswhichstretchdownfearfullytotheregionsofDeathandNight,shallnothintoftheirexistence,andonlythefairstemwithitsleavesandflowers,shoneonbythefairsun,shalldiscloseitself,andjoyfullygrow。
However,withoutventuringintotheabstruse,ortooeagerlyaskingWhyandHow,inthingswhereouranswermustneedsprove,ingreatpart,anechoofthequestion,letusbecontenttoremarkfarther,inthemerelyhistoricalway,howthatAphorismofthebodilyPhysicianholdsgoodinquiteotherdepartments。OftheSoul,withheractivities,weshallfinditnolesstruethanoftheBody:nay,crytheSpiritualists,isnotthatverydivisionoftheunity,Man,intoadualismofSoulandBody,itselfthesymptomofdisease;
as,perhaps,yourfrightfultheoryofMaterialism,ofhisbeingbutaBody,andtherefore,atleast,oncemoreaunity,maybetheparoxysmwhichwascritical,andthebeginningofcure!Butomittingthis,weobserve,withconfidenceenough,thatthetrulystrongmind,viewitasIntellect,asMorality,orunderanyotheraspect,isnowisethemindacquaintedwithitsstrength;
thathereasbeforethesignofhealthisUnconsciousness。Inourinward,asinouroutwardworld,whatismechanicalliesopentous:notwhatisdynamicalandhasvitality。OfourThinking,wemightsay,itisbutthemereuppersurfacethatweshapeintoarticulateThoughts;—underneaththeregionofargumentandconsciousdiscourse,liestheregionofmeditation;here,initsquietmysteriousdepths,dwellswhatvitalforceisinus;here,ifaughtistobecreated,andnotmerelymanufacturedandcommunicated,musttheworkgoon。Manufactureisintelligible,buttrivial:Creationisgreat,andcannotbeunderstood。ThusiftheDebaterandDemonstrator,whomwemayrankasthelowestoftruethinkers,knowswhathehasdone,andhowhedidit,theArtist,whomwerankasthehighest,knowsnot;mustspeakofInspiration,andinoneortheotherdialect,callhisworkthegiftofadivinity。
Butonthewhole,'geniusiseverasecrettoitself';ofthisoldtruthwehave,onallsides,dailyevidence。TheShakspearetakesnoairsforwritingHamletandtheTempest,understandsnotthatitisanythingsurprising:Milton,again,ismoreconsciousofhisfaculty,whichaccordinglyisaninferiorone。Ontheotherhand,whatcacklingandstruttingmustwenotoftenhearandsee,when,insomeshapeofacademicalprolusion,maidenspeech,reviewarticle,thisortheotherwell—fledgedgoosehasproduceditsgoose—egg,ofquitemeasurablevalue,wereitthepinkofitswholekind;andwonderswhyallmortalsdonotwonder!
Foolishenough,too,wastheCollegeTutor'ssurpriseatWalterShandy:
how,thoughunreadinAristotle,hecouldneverthelessargue;andnotknowingthenameofanydialectictool,handledthemalltoperfection。IsittheskilfulestanatomistthatcutsthebestfigureatSadler'sWells?ordoestheboxerhitbetterforknowingthathehasaflexorlongusandaflexorbrevis?
Butindeed,asinthehighercaseofthePoet,sohereinthatoftheSpeakerandInquirer,thetrueforceisanunconsciousone。ThehealthyUnderstanding,weshouldsay,isnottheLogical,argumentative,buttheIntuitive;fortheendofUnderstandingisnottoproveandfindreasons,buttoknowandbelieve。
第1章