Butsuchisthefrailtyofhumanreason,andsuchtheirresistiblecontagionofopinion,thateventhisdeliberatedoubtcouldscarcelybeupheld;didwenotenlargeourview,andopposingonespeciesofsuperstitiontoanother,setthemaquarrelling;whileweourselves,duringtheirfuryandcontention,happilymakeourescape,intothecalm,thoughobscure,regionsofphilosophy。
Notes2"FRAGILISetlaboriosamortalitasinpartesistadigessit,infirmitatissuaememor,utportionibusquisquiscoleret,quomaximeindigeret。"['Frail,toilingmortality,rememberingitsownweakness,hasdividedsuchdeitiesintogroups,soastoworshipinsections,eachthedeityheismostinneedof。']Pliny,NaturalHistory,Bk。II,Ch。5,Sect。15。SoearlyasHESIOD'Stimetherewere30,000deities。WorksandDays,Bk。I,Line250。Butthetasktobeperformedbytheseseemsstilltoogreatfortheirnumber。Theprovincesofthedeitiesweresosubdivided,thattherewasevenaGodofSneezing。SeeARISTOTLE,Problems,Bk。33,Ch。7and9。Theprovinceofcopulation,suitablytotheimportanceanddignityofit,wasdividedamongseveraldeities。
3RomanAntiquities,Bk。VIII,Ch。2,Sect。
2。
4ThefollowinglinesofEURIPIDESaresomuchtothepresentpurpose,thatIcannotforbearquotingthem:
[GreekQuote]
HUCUBA,Lines956ff。"Thereisnothingsecureintheworld;noglory,noprosperity。Thegodstossalllifeintoconfusion;mixeverythingwithitsreverse;thatallofus,fromourignoranceanduncertainty,maypaythemthemoreworshipandreverence。"
5DiodorusSiculus,LibraryofHistory,Bk。
III,Ch。47,Sect。1。
6Geography,Bk。VII,Ch。4。
7Pere*leComte,MemoiresandObservations……
madeinalateJourneyThroughtheEmpireofChina。
8Jean-FrancoisRegnard,Voiage*deLapponie。
9DiodorusSiculus,LibraryofHistory,Bk。
I,Ch。86,Sect。3。Lucian,"OnSacrifices,"Sect。14。Ovidalludestothesametradition,Metamorphoses,Bk。V,Line321ff。SoalsoManilius,Astronomica,Bk。IV,Lines580and800。
10Herodotus,History,Bk。I,Ch。172。
11Caesar,GallicWar,Bk。IV,Sect。7。
12Homer,Illiad,Bk。V,Line382。
13OntheSublime,Ch。IX,Sect。7。
14PereBrumoy,Theatre*desGrecs,BernarddeFontenelle,HistoiredesOracles。
15Arnobius,SevenBooksAgainsttheHeathen,Bk。VII,Ch。33。
16ConstitutionoftheLacedaemonians,Ch。13,Sect。2-5。
17MoralLetters,letter41。
18QuintusCurtiusRufus,HistoryofAlexander,Bk。IV,Ch。3,Sect。22。DiodorusSiculus,LibraryofHistory,Bk。XVII,Ch。41,Sect。8。
19Suetonius,LivesoftheCaesars,Bk。II,"TheDeifiedAugustus,"Ch。5。
20Suetonius,LivesoftheCaesars,Bk。IV,"GaiusCaligula,"Ch。5。
21Herodotus,History,Bk。II,Ch。53。Lucian,"ZeusCatechized,"Sect。1;"OnFunerals,"Sect。2。
22[Greekquote]['Howfromoneseedspringgodsandmortalmen。']Hesiod,WorksandDays,Line108。
23Hesiod,Theogony,Line570。
24Metamorphoses,Bk。I,Line32。
25LibraryofHistory,Bk。I,Ch。6-7。
26Ibid。,Bk。III,Ch。20。
27Thesameauthor,whocanthusaccountfortheoriginoftheworldwithoutaDeity,esteemsitimpioustoexplainfromphysicalcauses,thecommonaccidentsoflife,earthquakes,inundations,andtempests:anddevoutlyascribesthesetotheangerofJUPITERorNEPTUNE。Aplainproof,whencehederivedhisideasofreligion。DiodorusSiculus,LibraryofHistory,Bk。XV,Ch。48。
28Itwillbeeasytogiveareason,whyTHALES,ANAXIMANDER,andthoseearlyphilosophers,whoreallywereatheists,mightbeveryorthodoxinthepagancreed;andwhyANAXAGORAS
andSOCRATES,thoughrealtheists,mustnaturally,inancienttimes,beesteemedimpious。Theblind,unguidedpowersofnature,iftheycouldproducemen,mightalsoproducesuchbeingsasJUPITERandNEPTUNE,whobeingthemostpowerful,intelligentexistencesintheworld,wouldbeproperobjectsofworship。Butwhereasupremeintelligence,thefirstcauseofall,isadmitted,thesecapriciousbeings,iftheyexistatall,mustappearverysubordinateanddependent,andconsequentlybeexcludedfromtherankofdeities。PLATO(Laws,Bk。X,886)assignsthisreasonfortheimputationthrownonANAXAGORAS,namelyhisdenyingthedivinityofthestars,planets,andothercreatedobjects。
29AgainstthePhysicists,Bk。II,Sect。18-19。
30DionysiusofHalicarnassus,RomanAntiquities,Bk。VI,Ch。54。
31Pliny,Letters,Bk。VI,Letter20,Sect。
14-15。
32Hesiod,Theogony,Line933ff。
33Ibid。Plutarch,Lives,"Pelopidas,"Ch。19。
34Homer,Illiad,Bk。XIV,Line264ff。
35Herodian,HistoryoftheEmpire,Bk。V,Ch。
3,Sect。3-5。JUPITERAMMONisrepresentedbyCURTIUSasadeityofthesamekind(HistoryofAlexander,Bk。IV,Ch。7,Sect。
23)。TheARABIANSandPERSINUNTIANSadoredalsoshapelessunformedstonesastheirdeity(Arnobius,SevenBooksAgainsttheHeathen,Bk。VI。,Ch。11)。SomuchdidtheirfollyexceedthatoftheEGYPTIANS。
36DiogenesLaertius,LivesofEminentPhilosophers,Bk。II,Ch。11,"Stilpo,"Sect。116。
37SeeCAESARofthereligionoftheGAULS,TheGallicWar,Bk。VI,Sect。17。
38Germany,Ch。40。
39[ThissentenceisasitoriginallyappearedinHume'sFiveDissertationswhichwasprintedbutneverdistributedbecauseofpoliticalpressures。ForprudentialreasonsHumerephrasedthissentencewhich,inthefirstthreedistributededitions,reads,"Thus,notwithstandingthesublimeideassuggestedbyMosesandtheinspiredwriters,manyvulgarJewsseemstilltohaveconceivedthesupremeBeingasameretopicaldeityornationalprotector。"InthesixsucceedingeditionsoftheNaturalHistorythesentenceappearsagainchanged:"Thus,theGodofABRAHAM,ISAAC,andJACOB,becamethesupremedeityofJEHOVAH
oftheJEWS。"]
40CompteHenrideBoulainvilliers,Abrege*
Chronologiquedel'historedeFrance,499。
41[Theprecedingportionofthissentence(beginningwith"sometimesdegraded……")isasitoriginallyappearedinFiveDissertations。AllninedistributededitionsoftheNaturalHistoryreadinitsplace,"sometimesdegradedhimnearlytoalevelwithhumancreaturesinhispowersandfaculties。"]
42ThomasHyde,HistoriareligionisveterumPersarum。
43CalledtheScapulaire。
44Herodotus,History,Bk。IV,Ch。95,96。
45Ibid。,Ch。94。
46[Theword"from"appearshereinthefirstseveneditionsoftheNaturalHistory。]
47VERRIUSFLACCUS,citedbyPLINY(NaturalHistory,Bk。XXVIII,Ch。4,Sect。18-19),affirmed,thatitwasusualfortheROMANS,beforetheylaidsiegetoanytown,toinvocatethetutelardeityoftheplace,andbypromisinghimgreaterhonoursthanthoseheatpresentenjoyed,bribehimtobetrayhisoldfriendsandvotaries。ThenameofthetutelardeityofROMEwasforthisreasonkeptamostreligiousmystery;lesttheenemiesoftherepublicshouldbeable,inthesamemanner,todrawhimovertotheirservice。Forwithoutthename,theythought,nothingofthatkindcouldbepractised。PLINYsays,thatthecommonformofinvocationwaspreservedtohistimeintheritualofthepontifs。AndMACROBIUShastransmittedacopyofitfromthesecretthingsofSAMMONICUSSERENUS。
48Xenophon,Memorabilia,Bk。I,Ch。3,Sect。
1。
49Plutarch,Moralia,Bk。V,"IsisandOsiris,"
Ch。72。
50Herodotus,History,Bk。II,Ch。180。
51ThomasHyde,HistoriareligionisveterumPersarum。
52Arrian,AnabasisofAlexander,Bk。III,Ch。
16,Sect。3-9,andBk。VII,Ch。17。
53Ibid。,Bk。III,Ch。16,Sect。5。
54Suetonius,LivesoftheCaesars,Bk。II,"TheDeifiedAugustus,"Ch。93。
55Corruptiooptimipessima。
56MOSTnationshavefallenintothisguiltofhumansacrifices;though,perhaps,thatimpioussuperstitionhasneverprevailedverymuchinanycivilizednation,unlessweexcepttheCARTHAGINIANS。FortheTYRIANSsoonabolishedit。Asacrificeisconceivedasapresent;andanypresentisdeliveredtotheirdeitybydestroyingitandrenderingituselesstomen;byburningwhatissolid,pouringouttheliquid,andkillingtheanimate。Forwantofabetterwayofdoinghimservice,wedoourselvesaninjury;andfancythatwetherebyexpress,atleast,theheartinessofourgood-willandadoration。Thusourmercenarydevotiondeceivesourselves,andimaginesitdeceivesthedeity。
57Strabo,Geography,Bk。V,Ch。3,Sect。12;
Suetonius,LivesoftheCaesars,Bk。IV,"GaiusCaligula,"Ch。35,Sect。3。
58Arrian,AnabasisofAlexander,Bk。IV,Ch。
28,Sect。4;Bk。V,Ch。26,Sect。5。
59Thucydides,PeloponnesianWar,Bk。V,Ch。
11。
60Plutarch,Moralia,Bk。III,"SayingsofKingsandCommanders,"Brasidas,Sect。190b。
61PierreBayle,DictionaryHistoricalandCritical,(London:1734-41),articleonBellarmine。
62ItisstrangethattheEGYPTIANreligion,thoughsoabsurd,shouldyethavebornesogreataresemblancetotheJEWISH,thatancientwritersevenofthegreatestgeniuswerenotabletoobserveanydifferencebetweenthem。
ForitisremarkablethatbothTACITUS,andSUETONIUS,whentheymentionthatdecreeofthesenate,underTIBERIUS,bywhichtheEGYPTIANandJEWISHproselyteswerebanishedfromROME,expresslytreatthesereligionsasthesame;anditappears,thateventhedecreeitselfwasfoundedonthatsupposition。"ActumetdesacrisAEGYPTIIS,JUDAICISQUEpellendis;factumquepatrumconsultum,utquatuormillialibertinigeneriseasuperstitioneinfecta,quisidoneaaetas,ininsulamSardiniamveherentur,coercendisilliclatrociniis;etsiobgravitatemcoeliinterissent,viledamnum:CetericederentITALIA,nisicertamantediemprofanosritusexuissent。"['AnotherdebatedealtwiththeproscriptionoftheEgyptianandJewishrites,andasenatorialedictdirectedthatfourthousanddescendantsofenfranchisedslaves,taintedwiththatsuperstitionandsuitableinpointofage,weretobeshippedtoSardiniaandthereemployedinsuppressingbrigandage:iftheysuccumbedtothepestilentialclimate,itwasacheaploss。TheresthadorderstoleaveItaly,unlesstheyhadrenouncedtheirimpiousceremonialbyagivendate。']
Tacitus,Annals,Bk。II,Ch。85。"Externascaeremonias,AEGYPTIOS,JUDAICOSQUErituscompescuit;coactusquisuperstitioneeatenebantur,religiosasvestescuminstrumentoomnicomburere,etc。"['Heabolishedforeigncults,especiallytheEgyptianandtheJewishrites,compellingallwhowereaddictedtosuchsuperstitionstoburntheirreligiousvestmentsandalltheirparaphernalia。']Suetonius,LivesoftheCaesars,Bk。III,"Tiberius,"Ch。36。Thesewiseheathens,observingsomethinginthegeneralair,andgenius,andspiritofthetworeligionstobethesame,esteemedthedifferencesoftheirdogmastoofrivoloustodeserveanyattention。
63DiodorusSiculus,LibraryofHistory,Bk。
I,Ch。83,Sect。8-9。
64WhenLOUIStheXIVthtookonhimselftheprotectionoftheJesuits'CollegeofCLERMONT,thesocietyorderedtheking'sarmstobeputupoverthegate,andtookdownthecross,inordertomakewayforit:Whichgaveoccasiontothefollowingepigram:SustulithincChristi,posuitqueinsigniaRegis:Impiagens,aliumnescithabereDeum。
65OntheNatureoftheGods,Bk。I,Ch。29,Sect。82。
66Cicero,TusculanDisputations,Bk。V,Ch。
27,Sect。78。
67Augustine,CityofGod,Bk。VII,Ch。17。
68ClaudiusRutiliusNamatianus,AVoyageHometoGaul,Bk。I,Lines387-398。
69AeliusSpartianus,"LifeofHadrian,"Bk。
XIV,Sect。2。
70Cicero,LetterstohisFriends,Bk。XIV,Letter7,Sect。1。
71Cicero,"OnDivination,"Bk。II,Ch。24。
72Suetonius,LivesoftheCaesars,Bk。II,"TheDeifiedAugustus,"Ch。90-92。Pliny,NaturalHistory,Bk。II,Ch。5,Sect。24-25。
73WitnessthisremarkablepassageofTACITUS:
"Praetermultiplicesrerumhumanarumcasus,coeloterraqueprodigia,etfulminummonitusetfuturorumpraesagia,laeta,tristia,ambigua,manifesta。NecenimunquamatrocioribuspopuliRomanicladibus,magiquejustisJudiciisapprobatumest,nonessecuraeDiissecuritatemnostram,esseultionem。"History,Bk。I,Ch。3。AUGUSTUS'SquarrelwithNEPTUNEisaninstanceofthesamekind。
HadnottheemperorbelievedNEPTUNEtobearealbeing,andtohavedominionoverthesea,wherehadbeenthefoundationofhisanger?Andifhebelievedit,whatmadnesstoprovokestillfartherthatdeity?ThesameobservationmaybemadeuponQUINTILIAN'Sexclamation,onaccountofthedeathofhischildren。InstitutioOratoria,Bk。VI,Preface,Sect。10。
74"TheLoverofLies,"Sect。3。
75FromtheFoundingoftheCity,Bk。X,Ch。
40。
76Cicero,"OnDivination,"Bk。I,Ch。3,7。
77MarcusAureliusAntonius,Meditations,Bk。
I,Ch。17,Sect。8。
78Enchiridion,Sect。18。
79TheStoics,Iown,werenotquiteorthodoxintheestablishedreligion;butonemaysee,fromtheseinstances,thattheywentagreatway:Andthepeopleundoubtedlywenteverylength。
80Plato,Euthyphro,5d-6b。
81Plato,Phaedo,80d-e。
82XENOPHON'Sconduct,asrelatedbyhimself,is,atonce,anincontestableproofofthegeneralcredulityofmankindinthoseages,andtheincoherencies,inallages,ofmen'sopinionsinreligiousmatters。Thatgreatcaptainandphilosopher,thediscipleofSOCRATES,andonewhohasdeliveredsomeofthemostrefinedsentimentswithregardtoadeity,gaveallthefollowingmarksofvulgar,pagansuperstition。
BySOCRATES'Sadvice,heconsultedtheoracleofDELPHI,beforehewouldengageintheexpeditionofCYRUS
(Anabasis,Bk。III,Ch。I,Sect。5)。Seesadreamthenightafterthegeneralswereseized;whichhepaysgreatregardto,butthinksambiguous(ibid。,Sect。11-14)。Heandthewholearmyregardsneezingasaveryluckyomen(ibid。,Ch。
2,Sect。9)。Hasanotherdream,whenhecomestotheriverCENTRITES,whichhisfellow-general,CHIROSOPHUS,alsopaysgreatregardto(ibid。,Bk。IV,Ch。3,Sect。
9)。TheGREEKS,sufferingfromacoldnorthwind,sacrificetoit;
andthehistorianobserves,thatitimmediatelyabated(ibid。,Ch。5,Sect。3,4)。XENOPHONconsultsthesacrificesinsecret,beforehewouldformanyresolutionwithhimselfaboutsettlingacolony(ibid。,Bk。V,Ch。6,Sect。17)。Hewashimselfaveryskilfulaugur(ibid。,Sect。29)。Isdeterminedbythevictimstorefusethesolecommandofthearmywhichwasofferedhim(ibid。,Bk。VI,Ch。1,Sect。
22-24)。CLEANDER,theSPARTAN,thoughverydesirousofit,refusesitforthesamereason(ibid。,Ch。6,Sect。36)。
XENOPHONmentionsanolddreamwiththeinterpretationgivenhim,whenhefirstjoinedCYRUS(ibid。,Ch。1,Sect。
22-23)。MentionsalsotheplaceofHERCULES'Sdescentintohellasbelievingit,andsaysthemarksofitarestillremaining(ibid。,Ch。2,Sect。2)。Hadalmoststarvedthearmy,ratherthanleadthemtothefieldagainsttheauspices(ibid。,Ch。4,Sect。12-23)。Hisfriend,EUCLIDES,theaugur,wouldnotbelievethathehadbroughtnomoneyfromtheexpedition;tillhe(EUCLIDES)sacrificed,andthenhesawthematterclearlyintheExta(ibid。,Bk。7,Ch。8,Sect。1-3)。
Thesamephilosopher,proposingaprojectofminesfortheencreaseoftheATHENIANrevenues,advisesthemfirsttoconsulttheoracle("WaysandMeans,"Ch。6,Sect。2)。Thatallthisdevotionwasnotafarce,inordertoserveapoliticalpurpose,appearsbothfromthefactsthemselves,andfromthegeniusofthatage,whenlittleornothingcouldbegainedbyhypocrisy。Besides,XENOPHON,asappearsfromhisMemorabilia,wasakindofhereticinthosetimes,whichnopoliticaldevoteeeveris。Itisforthesamereason,Imaintain,thatNEWTON,LOCKE,CLARKE,etc。
beingAriansorSocinians,wereverysincereinthecreedtheyprofessed:
AndIalwaysopposethisargumenttosomelibertines,whowillneedshaveit,thatitwasimpossiblebutthatthesephilosophersmusthavebeenhypocrites。
83Cicero,"InDefenseofCluentius,"Ch。61,Sect。171。
84TheWarwithCatiline,Ch。51,Sect。16-20。
85CICERO(TusculanDisputations,Bk。I,Ch。
5-6)andSENECA(Letter24),asalsoJuvenal(Satire2,Line149
ff。),maintainthatthereisnoboyoroldwomansoridiculousastobelievethepoetsintheiraccountsofafuturestate。
WhythendoesLUCRETIUSsohighlyexalthismasterforfreeingusfromtheseterrors?PerhapsthegeneralityofmankindweretheninthedispositionofCEPHALUSinPLATO(Republic,Bk。I,330d-e)whowhilehewasyoungandhealthfulcouldridiculethesestories;butassoonashebecameoldandinfirm,begantoentertainapprehensionsoftheirtruth。Thiswemayobservenottobeunusualevenatpresent。
86SextusEmpiricus,AgainstthePhysicists,Bk。I,Sect。182-90。
87Xenophon,Memorabilia,Bk。I,Ch。1,Sect。
19。
88Itwasconsideredamongtheancients,asaveryextraordinary,philosophicalparadox,thatthepresenceofthegodswasnotconfinedtotheheavens,butwereextendedeverywhere;
aswelearnfromLUCIAN("Hirmotimus,"
Sect。81)。
89Plutarch,Moralia,Bk。II,"Superstition,"
Ch。10,170a-b。
90Lucian,"Menippus,"Sect。3。
91BACCHUS,adivinebeing,isrepresentedbytheheathenmythologyastheinventorofdancingandthetheatre。Playswereancientlyevenapartofpublicworshiponthemostsolemnoccasions,andoftenemployedintimesofpestilence,toappeasetheoffendeddeities。Buttheyhavebeenzealouslyproscribedbythegodlyinlaterages;andtheplayhouse,accordingtoalearneddivine,istheporchofhell。
Butinordertoshowmoreevidently,thatitispossibleforareligiontorepresentthedivinityinstillamoreimmoralandunamiablelightthanhewaspicturedbytheancients,weshallcitealongpassagefromanauthoroftasteandimagination,whowassurelynoenemytoChristianity。ItistheChevalierRAMSAY,awriter,whohadsolaudableaninclinationtobeorthodox,thathisreasonneverfoundanydifficulty,eveninthedoctrineswhichfree-thinkersscruplethemost,thetrinity,incarnation,andsatisfaction:Hishumanityalone,ofwhichheseemstohavehadagreatstock,rebelledagainstthedoctrinesofeternalreprobationandpredestination。
Heexpresseshimselfthus:"Whatstrangeideas,"sayshe,wouldanIndianoraChinesephilosopherhaveofourholyreligion,iftheyjudgedbytheschemesgivenofitbyourmodernfreethinkers,andpharisaicaldoctorsofallsects?Accordingtotheodiousandtoovulgarsystemoftheseincredulousscoffersandcredulousscribblers,"TheGodoftheJewsisamostcruel,unjust,partial,andfantasticalbeing。Hecreated,about6000yearsago,amanandawoman,andplacedtheminafinegardenofASIA,ofwhichtherearenoremains。Thisgardenwasfurnishedwithallsortsoftrees,fountains,andflowers。Heallowedthemtheuseofallthefruitsofthisbeautifulgarden,exceptone,thatwasplantedinthemidstthereof,andthathadinitasecretvirtueofpreservingthemincontinualhealthandvigourofbodyandmind,ofexaltingtheirnaturalpowersandmakingthemwise。Thedevilenteredintothebodyofaserpent,andsolicitedthefirstwomantoeatofthisforbiddenfruit;sheengagedherhusbandtodothesame。
Topunishthisslightcuriosityandnaturaldesireoflifeandknowledge,Godnotonlythrewourfirstparentsoutofparadise,buthecondemnedalltheirposteritytotemporalmisery,andthegreatestpartofthemtoeternalpains,thoughthesoulsoftheseinnocentchildrenhavenomorerelationtothatofADAMthantothoseofNEROandMAHOMET;since,accordingtothescholasticdrivellers,fabulists,andmythologists,allsoulsarecreatedpure,andinfusedimmediatelyintomortalbodies,sosoonasthefoetusisformed。Toaccomplishthebarbarous,partialdecreeofpredestinationandreprobation,Godabandonedallnationstodarkness,idolatry,andsuperstition,withoutanysavingknowledgeorsalutarygraces;unlessitwasoneparticularnation,whomhechoseashispeculiarpeople。Thischosennationwas,however,themoststupid,ungrateful,rebelliousandpersidiousofallnations。AfterGodhadthuskeptthefargreaterpartofallthehumanspecies,duringnear4000years,inareprobatestate,hechangedallofasudden,andtookafancyforothernationsbesidetheJEWS。ThenhesenthisonlybegottenSontotheworld,underahumanform,toappeasehiswrath,satisfyhisvindictivejustice,anddieforthepardonofsin。Veryfewnations,however,haveheardofthisgospel;andalltherest,thoughleftininvincibleignorance,aredamnedwithoutexception,oranypossibilityofremission。Thegreatestpartofthosewhohaveheardofit,havechangedonlysomespeculativenotionsaboutGod,andsomeexternalformsinworship:For,inotherrespects,thebulkofChristianshavecontinuedascorruptastherestofmankindintheirmorals;yea,somuchthemoreperverseandcriminal,thattheirlightsweregreater。Unlessitbeaverysmallselectnumber,allotherChristians,likethepagans,willbeforeverdamned;
thegreatsacrificeofferedupforthemwillbecomevoidandofnoeffect;Godwilltakedelightforever,intheirtormentsandblasphemies;andthoughhecan,byonefiatchangetheirhearts,yettheywillremainforeverunconvertedandunconvertible,becausehewillbeforeverunappeasableandirreconcileable。Itistrue,thatallthismakesGododious,ahaterofsouls,ratherthanaloverofthem;acruel,vindictivetyrant,animpotentorawrathfuldaemon,ratherthananall-powerful,beneficentfatherofspirits:Yetallthisisamystery。Hehassecretreasonsforhisconduct,thatareimpenetrable;andthoughheappearsunjustandbarbarous,yetwemustbelievethecontrary,becausewhatisinjustice,crime,cruelty,andtheblackestmaliceinus,isinhimjustice,mercy,andsovereigngoodness。"Thustheincredulousfree-thinkers,thejudaizingChristians,andthefatalisticdoctorshavedisfiguredanddishonouredthesublimemysteriesofourholyfaith;thustheyhaveconfoundedthenatureofgoodandevil;transformedthemostmonstrouspassionsintodivineattributes,andsurpassedthepagansinblasphemy,byascribingtotheeternalnature,asperfections,whatmakesthemosthorridcrimesamongstmen。Thegrosserpaganscontentedthemselveswithdivinizinglust,incest,andadultery;butthepredestinariandoctorshavedivinizedcruelty,wrath,fury,vengeance,andalltheblackestvices。SeetheChevalierRAMSAY'SPhilosophicalprinciplesofnaturalandrevealedreligion,PartII,p。401。
Thesameauthorasserts,inotherplaces,thattheArminianandMolinistschemesserveverylittletomendthematter:AndhavingthusthrownhimselfoutofallreceivedsectsofChristianity,heisobligedtoadvanceasystemofhisown,whichisakindofOrigenism,andsupposesthepre-existenceofthesoulsbothofmenandbeasts,andtheeternalsalvationandconversionofallmen,beasts,anddevils。Butthisnotion,beingquitepeculiartohimself,weneednottreatof。Ithoughttheopinionsofthisingeniousauthorverycurious;butIpretendnottowarrantthejustnessofthem。
92Ovid,Metamorphoses,Bk。IX,Line500。
93CalledDictatorclavisfigendaecausa。Livy,FromtheFoundingoftheCity,Bk。VII,Ch。3,Sect。3。
94Herodotus,History,Bk。VI,Ch。91。
95TobefoundinDiodorusSiculus,LibraryofHistory,Bk。XII,Ch。20-21。
96DiodorusSiculus,LibraryofHistory,Bk。
XX,Ch。43。
97Cicero,"FirstSpeechAgainstCatiline;"
Sallust,TheWarwithCatiline,Ch。22。