HadthegoverningclassesinFranceduringthelastcenturypaidasmuchheedtotheirproperbusinessastotheirpleasuresormanners,theguillotineneedneverhaveseveredthatspinalmarrowoforderlyandseculartraditionthroughwhichinanormallyconstitutedstatethebrainsympathizeswiththeextremitiesandsendswillandimpulsionthither。Itisonlywhenthereasonableandpracticablearedeniedthatmendemandtheunreasonableandimpracticable;
onlywhenthepossibleismadedifficultthattheyfancytheimpossibletobeeasy。Fairytalesaremadeoutofthedreamsofthepoor。No;thesentimentwhichliesattherootofdemocracyisnothingnew。Iamspeakingalwaysofasentiment,aspirit,andnotofaformofgovernment;forthiswasbuttheoutgrowthoftheotherandnotitscause。Thissentimentismerelyanexpressionofthenaturalwishofpeopletohaveahand,ifneedbeacontrollinghand,inthemanagementoftheirwonaffairs。Whatisnewisthattheyaremoreandmoregainingthatcontrol,andlearningmoreandmorehowtobeworthyofit。Whatweusedtocallthetendencyordrift-whatwearebeingtaughttocallmorewiselytheevolutionofthings-hasforsometimebeensettingsteadilyinthisdirection。Thereisnogoodinarguingwiththeinevitable。Theonlyargumentavailablewithaneastwindistoputonyourovercoat。Andinthiscase,also,theprudentwillpreparethemselvestoencounterwhattheycannotprevent。Somepeopleadviseustoputonthebrakes,asifthemovementofwhichweareconsciouswerethatofarailwaytrainrunningdownanincline。Butametaphorisnoargument,thoughitbesometimesthegunpowdertodriveonehomeandimbeditinthememory。
Ourdisquietcomesofwhatnursesandotherexperiencedpersonscallgrowingpains,andneednotseriouslyalarmus。Theyarewhateverygenerationbeforeus-certainlyeverygenerationsincetheinventionofprinting-hasgonethroughwithmoreorlessgoodfortune。Tothedoorofeverygenerationtherecomesaknocking,andunlessthehousehold,liketheThaneofCawdorandhiswife,havebeendoingsomedeedwithoutaname,theyneednotshudder。Itturnsoutatworsttobeapoorrelationwhowishestocomeinoutofthecold。Theporteralwaysgrumblesandisslowtoopen。
"Who'sthere,inthenameofBeelzebub?"hemutters。Notachangeforthebetterinourhumanhousekeepinghasevertakenplacethatwiseandgoodmenhavenotopposedit,-havenotprophesiedwiththealdermanthattheworldwouldwakeuptofinditsthroatcutinconsequenceofit。Theworld,onthecontrary,wakesup,rubsitseyes,yawns,stretchesitself,andgoesaboutitsbusinessasifnothinghadhappened。Suppressionoftheslavetrade,abolitionofslavery,tradeunions,atalloftheseexcellentpeopleshooktheirheadsdespondingly,andmurmured"Ichabod。"Butthetradeunionsarenowdebatinginsteadofconspiring,andweallreadtheirdiscussionswithcomfortandhope,surethattheyarelearningthebusinessofcitizenshipandthedifficultiesofpracticallegislation。
OneofthemostcuriousofthesefrenziesofexclusionwasthatagainsttheemancipationoftheJews。Allshareinthegovernmentoftheworldwasdeniedforcenturiestoperhapstheablest,certainlythemosttenacious,racethathadeverlivedinit-theracetowhomweowedourreligionandthepurestspiritualstimulusandconsolationtobefoundinallliterature-araceinwhichabilityseemsasnaturalandhereditaryasthecurveoftheirnoses,andwhoseblood,furtivelyminglingwiththebluestbloodsinEurope,hasquickenedthemwithitsownindomitableimpulsion。Wedrovethemintoacorner,buttheyhadtheirrevenge,asthewrongedarealwayssuretohaveitsoonerorlater。Theymadetheircornerthecounterandbanking-houseoftheworld,andthencetheyruleitanduswiththeignoblersceptreoffinance。
YourgrandfathersmobbedPriestleyonlythatyoumightsetuphisstatueandmakeBirminghamtheheadquartersofEnglishUnitarianism。Wehearitsaidsometimesthatthisisanageoftransition,asifthatmademattersclearer;butcananyonepointustoanagethatwasnot?Ifhecould,hewouldshowusanageofstagnation。Thequestionforus,asithasbeenforallbeforeus,istomakethetransitiongradualandeasy,toseethatourpointsarerightsothatthetrainmaynotcometogrief。Forweshouldrememberthatnothingismorenaturalforpeoplewhoseeducationhasbeenneglectedthantospellevolutionwithaninitial"r。"Agreatmanstrugglingwiththestormsoffatehasbeencalledasublimespectacle;butsurelyagreatmanwrestlingwiththesenewforcesthathavecomeintotheworld,masteringthemandcontrollingthemtobeneficentends,wouldbeayetsublimer。Hereisnotadanger,andiftherewereitwouldbeonlyabetterschoolofmanhood,anoblerscopeforambition。Ihavehintedthatwhatpeopleareafraidofindemocracyislessthethingitselfthanwhattheyconceivetobeitsnecessaryadjunctsandconsequences。Itissupposedtoreduceallmankindtoadeadlevelofmediocrityincharacterandculture,tovulgarizemen'sconceptionsoflife,andthereforetheircodeofmorals,manners,andconduct-toendangertherightsofpropertyandpossession。ButIbelievethattherealgravamenofthechargesliesinthehabitithasofmakingitselfgenerallydisagreeablebyaskingthePowersthatBeatthemostinconvenientmomentwhethertheyarethepowersthatoughttobe。Ifthepowersthatbeareinaconditiontogiveasatisfactoryanswertothisinevitablequestion,theyneedfeelinnowaydiscomfitedbyit。
Fewpeopletakethetroubleoftryingtofindoutwhatdemocracyreallyis。
Yetthiswouldbeagreathelp,foritisourlawlessanduncertainthoughts,itistheindefinitenessofourimpressions,thatfilldarkness,whethermentalorphysical,withspectresandhobgoblins。Democracyisnothingmorethananexperimentingovernment,morelikelytosucceedinanewsoil,butlikelytobetriedinallsoils,whichmuststandorfallonitsownmeritsasothershavedonebeforeit。Forthereisnotrickofperpetualmotioninpoliticsanymorethaninmechanics。PresidentLincolndefineddemocracytobe"thegovernmentofthepeoplebythepeopleforthepeople。"Thisisasufficientlycompactstatementofitasapoliticalarrangement。TheodoreParkersaidthat"Democracymeantnot'I'masgoodasyouare,'but'You'reasgoodasI
am。'"Andthisistheethicalconceptionofit,necessaryasacomplementoftheother;aconceptionwhich,coulditbemadeactualandpractical,wouldeasilysolvealltheriddlesthattheoldsphinxofpoliticalandsocialeconomywhositsbytheroadsidehasbeenproposingtomankindfromthebeginning,andwhichmankindhaveshownsuchasingulartalentforansweringwrongly。
InthissenseChristwasthefirsttruedemocratthateverbreathed,astheolddramatistDekkersaidhewasthefirsttruegentleman。Thecharactersmaybeeasilydoubled,sostrongisthelikenessbetweenthem。AbeautifulandprofoundparableofthePersianpoetJellaladeentellsusthat"OneknockedattheBeloved'sdoor,andavoiceaskedfromwithin'Whoisthere?'andheanswered'ItisI。'Thenthevoicesaid,'Thishousewillnotholdmeandthee';
andthedoorwasnotopened。Thenwenttheloverintothedesertandfastedandprayedinsolitude,andafterayearhereturnedandknockedagainatthedoor;andagainthevoiceasked'Whoisthere?'andhesaid'Itisthyself;'andthedoorwasopenedtohim。"Butthatisidealism,youwillsay,andthisisanonlytoopracticalworld。Igrantit;butIamoneofthosewhobelievethattherealwillneverfindanirremovablebasistillitrestsontheideal。
Itusedtobethoughtthatademocracywaspossibleonlyinasmallterritory,andthisisdoubtlesstrueofademocracystrictlydefined,forinsuchallthecitizensdecidedirectlyuponeveryquestionofpublicconcerninageneralassembly。
AnexamplestillsurvivesinthetinySwisscantonofAppenzell。Butthisimmediateinterventionofthepeopleintheirownaffairsisnotoftheessenceofdemocracy;itisnotnecessary,norindeed,inmostcases,practicable。
DemocraciestowhichMr。Lincoln'sdefinitionwouldfairlyenoughapplyhaveexisted,andnowexist,inwhich,thoughthesupremeauthorityresideinthepeople,yettheycanactonlyindirectlyonthenationalpolicy。Thisgenerationhasseenademocracywithanimperialfigurehead,andinallthathaveeverexistedthebodypolitichasneverembracedalltheinhabitantsincludedwithinitsterritory,therighttoshareinthedirectionofaffairshasbeenconfinedtocitizens,andcitizenshiphasbeenfurtherrestrictedbyvariouslimitations,sometimesofproperty,sometimesofnativity,andalwaysofageandsex。
第3章