MauriceThompsonspenthiswholeliterarylife,andGeneralLew.WallacestilllivesatCrawfordsville,Indiana;Mr.MadisonCaweinstaysatLouisville,Kentucky;MissMurfreestaysatSt.Louis,Missouri;FrancisR.StocktonspentthegreaterpartoftheyearathisplaceinWestVirginia,andcameonlyforthewintermonthstoNewYork;Mr.EdwardBellamy,untilhisfailinghealthexiledhimtotheFarWest,remainedatChicopee,Massachusetts;andIcannotthinkofoneofthesewriterswhomitwouldhaveadvantagedinanyliterarywisetodwellinNewYork.Hewouldnothavefoundgreaterincentivethanathome;andinsocietyhewouldnothavefoundthatliterarytonewhichallsocietyhad,orwishedtohave,inBostonwhenBostonwasagreattownandnotyetabigtown.
Infact,IdoubtifanywhereintheworldtherewaseversomuchtasteandfeelingforliteratureastherewasinthatBoston.AtEdinburgh(asIimagineit)therewasalargeanddistinguishedliteraryclass,andatWeimartherewasacultivatedcourtcircle;butinBostontherewasnotonlysuchagroupofauthorsasweshallhardlyseehereagainforhundredsofyears,buttherewassuchregardforthemandtheircalling,notonlyingoodsociety,butamongtheextremelywell—readpeopleofthewholeintelligentcity,ashardlyanothercommunityhasshown.NewYork,Iamquitesure,neverwassuchacentre,andIseenosignsthatiteverwillbe.ItdoesnotinfluencetheliteratureofthewholecountryasBostononcedidthroughwriterswhomalltheyoungwriterswishedtoresemble;itdoesnotgivethelaw,anditdoesnotinspirethelovethatliteraryBostoninspired.Thereisnoidealthatitrepresents.
AglanceatthemapoftheUnionwillshowhowverywidelyoursmallerliterarycentresarescattered;andperhapsitwillbeusefulinfollowingmetoothermorepopulousliterarycentres.DroppingsouthwardfromNewYork,now,wefindourselvesinaliterarycentreofimportanceatPhiladelphia,sincethatisthehomeofMr.J.B.McMasters,thehistorianoftheAmericanpeople;ofMr.OwenWister,whosefreshandvigorousworkIhavementioned;andofDr.WeirMitchell,anovelistofpowerlongknowntothebetterpublic,andnowrecognizedbythelargerintheimmensesuccessofhishistoricalromance,HughWynne.
IfIskipBaltimore,Imayignorealiterarycentreofgreatpromise,butwhileIdonotforgettheexcellentworkofJohnsHopkinsUniversityintrainingmenforthesoliderliteratureofthefuture,noBaltimorenamestoconjurewithoccurtomeatthemoment;andwemustreallygetontoWashington.This,tillhebecameambassadorattheCourtofSt.James,wasthehomeofMr.JohnHay,apoetwhosebiographyofLincolnmustrankhimwiththehistorians,andwhosepublicserviceasSecretaryofStateclasseshimhighamongstatesmen.HeblottedoutoneliterarycentreatCleveland,Ohio,whenheremovedtoWashington,andMr.ThomasNelsonPageanotheratRichmond,Virginia,whenhecametothenationalcapital.
Mr.PaulDunbar,thefirstnegropoettodivineandutterhisrace,carriedwithhimtheliterarycentreofDayton,Ohio,whenhecametobeanemployeeintheCongressionalLibrary;andMr.CharlesWarrenStoddard,insettlingatWashingtonasProfessorofLiteratureintheCatholicUniversity,broughtsomewhatindirectlyawaywithhimthelasttracesoftheoldliterarycentreatSanFrancisco.
AmorerecentliterarycentreintheCalifornianmetropoliswenttopieceswhenMr.GelettBurgesscametoNewYorkandsilencedthe'Lark',abirdofasnewandrareanoteasevermadeitselfheardinthisair;
butsincehehasreturnedtoCalifornia,thereishopethattheliterarycentremayformitselfthereagain.IdonotknowwhetherMrs.CharlottePerkinsStetsonwreckedaliterarycentreinleavingLosAngelesornot.
IamsureonlythatshehasenrichedtheliterarycentreofNewYorkbytheadditionofatalentinsociologicalsatirewhichwouldbeextraordinaryevenifitwerenotaltogetherunrivalledamongus.
CouldonesaytoomuchoftheliterarycentreatChicago?Ifancy,yes;
ortoomuch,atleast,forthetasteofthenotablepeoplewhoconstituteit.InMr.HenryB.Fullerwehavereasontohope,fromwhathehasalreadydone,anAmericannovelistofsuchgreatnessthathemaywellleavebeingthegreatAmericannovelisttoanyonewholikestakingthatrole.Mr.HamlinGarlandisanotherwriterofgenuineandoriginalgiftwhocentresatChicago;andMrs.MaryCatherwoodhasmadehernamewellknowninromanticfiction.MissEdithWyattisatalent,newlyknown,ofthefinestqualityinminorfiction;Mr.RobertHerrick,Mr.WillPayneintheirnovels,andMr.GeorgeAdeandMr.PeterDumpintheirsatiresformwiththosenamedagroupnottobematchedelsewhereinthecountry.
Itwouldbehardtomatchamongourcriticaljournalsthe'Dial'ofChicago;andwithafairamountofpublishinginasortofbooksoftenasgoodwithinastheyareuncommonlyprettywithout,Chicagohasaclaimtorankwithourfirstliterarycentres.
ItiscertainlytobereckonednotsoveryfarbelowLondon,which,withMr.HenryJames,Mr.HarryHarland,andMr.BretHarte,seemstomeanAmericanliterarycentreworthytobenamedwithcontemporaryBoston.
Whichisourchiefliterarycentre,however,Iamnot,afterall,readytosay.WhenIrememberMr.G.W.Cable,atNorthampton,Massachusetts,Iamshakeninallmypreoccupations;whenIthinkofMarkTwain,itseemstomethatourgreatestliterarycentreisjustnowatRiverdale—
on—the—Hudson.