首页 >出版文学> War of the Classes>第4章
  whichissocialism。Andheisnotabovefeelinggraveandwell-
  containedsatisfactionwhereverthesocialistdoctrinairehasbeencontradictedbymenattemptingtopractisecooperationinthemidstofthecompetitivesystem,asinBelgium。
  Nevertheless,hecatchesfleetingglimpsesofanextremeandtyrannicallybenevolentfeudalismveryliketoMr。Ghent's,aswitnessthefollowing:
  "IaskedoneofthelargestemployersoflaborintheSouthifhefearedthecomingofthetradeunion。'No,'hesaid,'itisonegoodresultofraceprejudice,thatthenegrowillenableusinthelongruntoweakenthetradeunionsothatitcannotharmus。Wecankeepwagesdownwiththenegroandwecanpreventtoomuchorganization。'
  "Itisinthisspiritthatthelowerstandardsaretobeused。Ifthispurposeshouldsucceed,ithasbutoneissue,——theimmensestrengtheningofaplutocraticadministrationatthetop,servedbyanarmyofhigh-salariedhelpers,withaneliteofskilledandwell-
  paidworkmen,butallrestingonwhatwouldessentiallybeaserfclassoflow-paidlaborandthismasskeptinorderbyanincreaseduseofmilitaryforce。"
  Inbriefsummaryofthesetwonotablebooks,itmaybesaidthatMr。
  Ghentisalarmed,thoughhedoesnotflatlysayso,atthetoogreatsocialrestfulnessinthecommunity,whichispermittingthecapitaliststoformthenewsocietytotheirliking;andthatMr。
  Brooksisalarmed,andheflatlysaysso,atthesocialunrestwhichthreatensthemodifiedindividualismintowhichhewouldliketoseesocietyevolve。Mr。Ghentbeholdsthecapitalistclassrisingtodominatethestateandtheworkingclass;Mr。Brooksbeholdstheworkingclassrisingtodominatethestateandthecapitalistclass。Onefearsthepaternalismofaclass;theother,thetyrannyofthemass。
  WANTED:ANEWLAWOFDEVELOPMENT
  Evolutionisnolongerameretentativehypothesis。Onebyone,stepbystep,eachdivisionandsubdivisionofsciencehascontributeditsevidence,untilnowthecaseiscompleteandtheverdictrendered。Whilethereisstilldiscussionastothemethodofevolution,nonetheless,asaprocesssufficienttoexplainallbiologicalphenomena,alldifferentiationsoflifeintowidelydiversespecies,families,andevenkingdoms,evolutionisflatlyaccepted。Likewisehasbeenaccepteditslawofdevelopment:THAT,INTHESTRUGGLEFOREXISTENCE,THESTRONGANDFITANDTHEPROGENYOF
  THESTRONGANDFITHAVEABETTEROPPORTUNITYFORSURVIVALTHANTHE
  WEAKANDLESSFITANDTHEPROGENYOFTHEWEAKANDLESSFIT。
  Itisinthestruggleofthespecieswithotherspeciesandagainstallotherhostileforcesintheenvironment,thatthislawoperates;
  alsointhestrugglebetweentheindividualsofthesamespecies。
  Inthisstruggle,whichisforfoodandshelter,theweakindividualsmustobviouslywinlessfoodandshelterthanthestrong。Becauseofthis,theirholdonliferelaxesandtheyareeliminated。Andforthesamereasonthattheymaynotwinforthemselvesadequatefoodandshelter,theweakcannotgivetotheirprogenythechanceforsurvivalthatthestronggive。Andthus,sincetheweakarepronetobegetweakness,thespeciesisconstantlypurgedofitsinefficientmembers。
  Becauseofthis,apremiumisplaceduponstrength,andsolongasthestruggleforfoodandshelterobtains,justsolongwilltheaveragestrengthofeachgenerationincrease。Ontheotherhand,shouldconditionssochangethatall,andtheprogenyofall,theweakaswellasthestrong,haveanequalchanceforsurvival,then,atonce,theaveragestrengthofeachgenerationwillbegintodiminish。Neveryet,however,inanimallife,hastherebeensuchastateofaffairs。Naturalselectionhasalwaysobtained。Thestrongandtheirprogeny,attheexpenseoftheweak,havealwayssurvived。Thislawofdevelopmenthasoperateddownallthepastuponalllife;itsooperatestoday,anditisnotrashtosaythatitwillcontinuetooperateinthefuture——atleastuponalllifeexistinginastateofnature。
  Man,preeminentthoughheisintheanimalkingdom,capableofreactinguponandmakingsuitableanunsuitableenvironment,neverthelessremainsthecreatureofthissamelawofdevelopment。
  Thesocialselectiontowhichheissubjectismerelyanotherformofnaturalselection。True,withincertainnarrowlimitshemodifiesthestruggleforexistenceandrenderslessprecariousthetenureoflifefortheweak。Theextremelyweak,diseased,andinefficientarehousedinhospitalsandasylums。Thestrengthoftheviciouslystrong,wheninimicaltosociety,istemperedbypenalinstitutionsandbythegallows。Theshort-sightedareprovidedwithspectacles,andthesicklywhentheycanpayforitwithsanitariums。Pestilentialmarshesaredrained,plaguesarechecked,anddisastersaverted。Yet,forallthat,thestrongandtheprogenyofthestrongsurvive,andtheweakarecrushedout。Themenstrongofbrainaremastersasofyore。Theydominatesocietyandgathertothemselvesthewealthofsociety。Withthiswealththeymaintainthemselvesandequiptheirprogenyforthestruggle。
  Theybuildtheirhomesinhealthfulplaces,purchasethebestfruits,meats,andvegetablesthemarketaffords,andbuythemselvestheministrationsofthemostbrilliantandlearnedoftheprofessionalclasses。Theweakman,asofyore,istheservant,thedoerofthingsatthemaster'scall。Theweakerandlessefficientheis,thepoorerishisreward。Theweakestworkforalivingwage,whentheycangetwork,liveinunsanitaryslums,onvileandinsufficientfood,atthelowestdepthsofhumandegradation。
  Theirgrasponlifeisindeedprecarious,theirmortalityexcessive,theirinfantdeath-rateappalling。
  Thatsomeshouldbeborntoprefermentandotherstoignominyinorderthattheracemayprogress,iscruelandsad;butnonethelesstheyaresoborn。Theweedingoutofhumansouls,someforfatnessandsmiles,someforleannessandtears,issurelyaheartlessselectiveprocess——asheartlessasitisnatural。Andthehumanfamily,forallitswonderfulrecordofadventureandachievement,hasnotyetsucceededinavoidingthisprocess。Thatitisincapableofdoingthisisnottobehazarded。Notonlyisitcapable,butthewholetrendofsocietyisinthatdirection。Allthesocialforcesaredrivingmanontoatimewhentheoldselectivelawwillbeannulled。Thereisnoescapingit,savebytheinterventionofcatastrophesandcataclysmsquiteunthinkable。
  Itisinexorable。Itisinexorablebecausethecommonmandemandsit。Thetwentiethcentury,thecommonmansays,ishisday;thecommonman'sday,or,rather,thedawningofthecommonman'sday。
  Norcanitbedenied。Theevidenceiswithhim。Thepreviouscenturies,andmorenotablythenineteenth,havemarkedtheriseofthecommonman。Fromchattelslaverytoserfdom,andfromserfdomtowhathebitterlyterms"wageslavery,"hehasrisen。Neverwashesostrongasheistoday,andneversomenacing。Hedoestheworkoftheworld,andheisbeginningtoknowit。Theworldcannotgetalongwithouthim,andthisalsoheisbeginningtoknow。Allthehumanknowledgeofthepast,allthescientificdiscovery,governmentalexperiment,andinventionofmachinery,havetendedtohisadvancement。Hisstandardoflivingishigher。Hiscommonschooleducationwouldshameprincestencenturiespast。Hiscivilandreligiouslibertymakeshimafreeman,andhisballotthepeerofhisbetters。Andallthishastendedtomakehimconscious,consciousofhimself,consciousofhisclass。Helooksabouthimandquestionsthatancientlawofdevelopment。Itiscruelandwrong,heisbeginningtodeclare。Itisananachronism。Letitbeabolished。Whyshouldtherebeoneemptybellyinalltheworld,whentheworkoftenmencanfeedahundred?WhatifmybrotherbenotsostrongasI?Hehasnotsinned。Whereforeshouldhehunger——
  heandhissinlesslittleones?Awaywiththeoldlaw。Thereisfoodandshelterforall,thereforeletallreceivefoodandshelter。
  Asfastaslaborhasbecomeconsciousithasorganized。Theambitionoftheseclass-consciousmenisthatthemovementshallbecomegeneral,thatalllaborshallbecomeconsciousofitselfanditsclassinterests。Andthedaythatwitnessesthesolidarityoflabor,theytriumphantlyaffirm,willbeadaywhenlabordominatestheworld。Thisgrowingconsciousnesshasledtotheorganizationoftwomovements,bothseparateanddistinct,butbothconvergingtowardacommongoal——one,thelabormovement,knownasTradeUnionism;theother,thepoliticalmovement,knownasSocialism。
  Botharegrimandsilentforces,unheraldedandvirtuallyunknowntothegeneralpublicsaveinmomentsofstress。Thesleepinglaborgiantreceiveslittlenoticefromthecapitalisticpress,andwhenhestirsuneasily,acolumnofsurprise,indignation,andhorrorsuffices。
  Itisonlynowandthen,afterlongperiodsofsilence,thatthelabormovementputsinitsclaimfornotice。Allisquiet。Thekindoldworldspinson,andthebourgeoismasterscliptheircouponsinsmugcomplacency。Butthegrimandsilentforcesareatwork。
  Suddenly,likeaclapofthunderfromaclearsky,comesadisruptionofindustry。Fromoceantooceanthewheelsofagreatchainofrailroadsceasetorun。Aquarterofamillionminersthrowdownpickandshovelandoutragethesunwiththeirpale,bleachedfaces。Thestreetrailwaysofaswarmingmetropolisstandidle,ortherumbleofmachineryinvastmanufactoriesdiesawaytosilence。Thereisalarmandpanic。Arsonandhomicidestalkforth。
  Thereisacryinthenight,andquickangerandsuddendeath。
  Peacefulcitiesareaffrightedbythecrackofriflesandthesnarlofmachine-guns,andtheheartsoftheshudderingareshakenbytheroarofdynamite。Thereishurryingandskurrying。Thewiresarekepthotbetweenthecentreofgovernmentandtheseatoftrouble。
  Thechiefsofstatepondergravelyandadvise,andgovernorsofstatesimplore。Thereisassemblingofmilitiaandmassingoftroops,andthestreetsresoundtothetrampofarmedmen。Thereareseparateandjointconferencesbetweenthecaptainsofindustryandthecaptainsoflabor。Andthen,finally,allisquietagain,andthememoryofitislikethememoryofabaddream。
  Butthesestrikesbecomeolympiads,thingstodatefrom;andcommononthelipsofmenbecomesuchphrasesas"TheGreatDockStrike,"
  "TheGreatCoalStrike,""TheGreatRailroadStrike。"Neverbeforedidlabordothesethings。AftertheGreatPlagueinEngland,labor,findingitselfindemandandinnocentlyobeyingtheeconomiclaw,askedhigherwages。Butthemasterssetamaximumwage,restrainedworkingmenfrommovingaboutfromplacetoplace,refusedtotolerateidlers,andbymostbarbarouslegalmethodspunishedthosewhodisobeyed。Butlaborisaccordedgreaterrespecttoday。
  Suchapolicy,putintoeffectinthisthefirstdecadeofthetwentiethcentury,wouldsweepthemastersfromtheirseatsinonemightycrash。Andthemastersknowitandarerespectful。
  AfairinstanceofthegrowingsolidarityoflaborisaffordedbyanunimportantrecentstrikeinSanFrancisco。Therestaurantcooksandwaiterswerecompletelyunorganized,workingatanyandallhoursforwhateverwagestheycouldget。ArepresentativeoftheAmericanFederationofLaborwentamongthemandorganizedthem。
  Withinafewweeksnearlytwothousandmenwereenrolled,andtheyhadfivethousanddollarsondeposit。Thentheyputintheirdemandforincreasedwagesandshorterhours。Forthwiththeiremployersorganized。Thedemandwasdenied,andtheCooks'andWaiters'Unionwalkedout。
  Allorganizedemployersstoodbackoftherestaurantowners,insympathywiththemandwillingtoaidthemiftheydared。AndatthebackoftheCooks'andWaiters'Unionstoodtheorganizedlaborofthecity,40,000strong。Ifabusinessmanwascaughtpatronizingan"unfair"restaurant,hewasboycotted;ifaunionmanwascaught,hewasfinedheavilybyhisunionorexpelled。Theoystercompaniesandtheslaughterhousesmadeanattempttorefusetoselloystersandmeattounionrestaurants。TheButchersandMeatCutters,andtheTeamsters,inretaliation,refusedtoworkforortodelivertonon-unionrestaurants。Uponthistheoystercompaniesandslaughterhousesacknowledgedthemselvesbeatenandpeacereigned。ButtheRestaurantBakersinnon-unionplaceswereorderedout,andtheBakeryWagonDriversdeclinedtodelivertounfairhouses。
  EveryAmericanFederationofLaborunioninthecitywaspreparedtostrike,andwaitedonlytheword。Andbehindall,ahandfulofmen,knownastheLaborCouncil,directedthefight。Onebyone,blowuponblow,theywereableiftheydeemeditnecessarytocallouttheunions——theLaundryWorkers,whodothewashing;theHackmen,whohaulmentoandfromrestaurants;theButchers,MeatCutters,andTeamsters;andtheMilkers,MilkDrivers,andChickenPickers;
  andafterthat,inpuresympathy,theRetailClerks,theHorseShoers,theGasandElectricalFixtureHangers,theMetalRoofers,theBlacksmiths,theBlacksmiths'Helpers,theStablemen,theMachinists,theBrewers,theCoastSeamen,theVarnishersandPolishers,theConfectioners,theUpholsterers,thePaperHangersandFrescoPainters,theDrugClerks,theFittersandHelpers,theMetalWorkers,theBoilerMakersandIronShipBuilders,theAssistantUndertakers,theCarriageandWagonWorkers,andsoondownthelengthylistoforganizations。
  For,overallthesetrades,overallthesethousandsofmen,istheLaborCouncil。Whenitspeaksitsvoiceisheard,andwhenitordersitisobeyed。Butit,inturn,isdominatedbytheNationalLaborCouncil,withwhichitisconstantlyintouch。Inthiswhollyunimportantlittlelocalstrikeitisofinteresttonotethestandstakenbythedifferentsides。ThelegalrepresentativeandofficialmouthpieceoftheEmployers'Associationsaid:"Thisorganizationisformedfordefensivepurposes,anditmaybedriventotakeoffensivesteps,andifso,willbestrongenoughtofollowthemup。
  Laborcannotbeallowedtodictatetocapitalandsayhowbusinessshallbeconducted。Thereisnoobjectiontotheformationofunionsandtradescouncils,butmembershipmustnotbecompulsory。
  ItisrepugnanttotheAmericanideaoflibertyandcannotbetolerated。"
  Ontheotherhand,thepresidentoftheTeamDrivers'Unionsaid:
  "Theemployersoflaborinthiscityaregenerallyagainstthetrade-unionmovementandthereseemstobeaconcertedeffortontheirparttochecktheprogressoforganizedlabor。Suchactionashasbeentakenbytheminsympathywiththepresentlabortroublesmay,ifcontinued,leadtoaseriousconflict,theoutcomeofwhichmightbemostcalamitousforthebusinessandindustrialinterestsofSanFrancisco。"
  AndthesecretaryoftheUnitedBreweryWorkmen:"Iregardasympatheticstrikeasthelastweaponwhichorganizedlaborshoulduseinitsdefence。When,however,associationsofemployersbandtogethertodefeatorganizedlabor,oroneofitsbranches,thenweshouldnotandwillnothesitateourselvestoemploythesameinstrumentinretaliation。"
  Thus,inalittlecorneroftheworld,isexemplifiedthegrowingsolidarityoflabor。Theorganizationoflaborhasnotonlykeptpacewiththeorganizationofindustry,butithasgaineduponit。
  Inonewinter,intheanthracitecoalregion,$160,000,000inminesand$600,000,000intransportationanddistributionconsolidateditsownershipandcontrol。Andatonce,arrayedassolidlyontheotherside,werethe150,000anthraciteminers。Thebituminousmines,however,werenotconsolidated;yetthe250,000menemployedthereinwerealreadycombined。Andnotonlythat,buttheywerealsocombinedwiththeanthraciteminers,these400,000menbeingunderthecontrolanddirectionofonesupremelaborcouncil。Andinthisandtheothergreatcouncilsaretobefoundcaptainsoflaborofsplendidabilities,who,inunderstandingofeconomicandindustrialconditions,areundeniablytheequalsoftheiropponents,thecaptainsofindustry。
  TheUnitedStatesishoneycombedwithlabororganizations。Andthebigfederationswhichthesegotocomposeaggregatemillionsofmembers,andintheirvariousbrancheshandlemillionsofdollarsyearly。Andnotonlythis;fortheinternationalbrotherhoodsandunionsareforming,andmoneysfortheaidofstrikerspassbackandforthacrosstheseas。TheMachinists,intheirdemandforanine-
  hourday,affected500,000menintheUnitedStates,Mexico,andCanada。InEnglandthemembershipofworking-classorganizationsisapproximatedbyKeirHardieat2,500,000,withreservefundsof$18,000,000。Therethecooperativemovementhasamembershipof1,500,000,andeveryyearturnsoverindistributionmorethan$100,000,000。InFrance,one-eighthofthewholeworkingclassisunionized。InBelgiumtheunionsareveryrichandpowerful,andsoabletodefythemastersthatmanyofthesmallermanufacturers,unabletoresist,"areremovingtheirworkstoothercountrieswheretheworkmen'sorganizationsarenotsopotential。"Andinallothercountries,accordingtothestageoftheireconomicandpoliticaldevelopment,likefiguresobtain。AndEurope,today,confessesthathergreatestsocialproblemisthelaborproblem,andthatitistheonemostcloselyengrossingtheattentionofherstatesmen。
  TheorganizationoflaborisoneofthechiefacknowledgedfactorsintheretrogressionofBritishtrade。Theworkershavebecomeclassconsciousasneverbefore。Thewrongofoneisthewrongofall。Theyhavecometorealize,inashort-sightedway,thattheirmasters'interestsarenottheirinterests。Thehardertheywork,theybelieve,themorewealththeycreatefortheirmasters。
  Further,themoreworktheydoinoneday,thefewermenwillbeneededtodothework。Sotheunionsplaceaday'sstintupontheirmembers,beyondwhichtheyarenotpermittedtogo。In"AStudyofTradeUnionism,"byBenjaminTaylorinthe"NineteenthCentury"ofApril,1898,arefurnishedsomeinterestingcorroborations。ThefactsheresetforthwerecollectedbytheExecutiveBoardoftheEmployers'Federation,thedocumentaryproofsofwhichareinthehandsofthesecretaries。Inacertainfirmtheunionworkmenmadeeightammunitionboxesaday。Norcouldtheybepersuadedintomakingmore。AyoungSwiss,whocouldnotspeakEnglish,wassettowork,andinthefirstdayhemadefiftyboxes。Inthesamefirmtheskilledunionhandsfileduptheoutsidehandlesofonemachine-
  gunaday。Thatwastheirstint。Noonewasknownevertodomore。
  Anon-unionfilercameintotheshopanddidtwelveaday。A
  Manchesterfirmfoundthattoplanealargebed-castingtookunionworkmenonehundredandninetyhours,andnon-unionworkmenonehundredandthirty-fivehours。Inanotherinstanceaman,resigningfromhisunion,daybydaydiddoubletheamountofworkhehaddoneformerly。Andtocapitall,anEnglishgentleman,goingouttolookatawallbeingputupforhimbyunionbricklayers,foundoneoftheirnumberwithhisrightarmstrappedtohisbody,doingalltheworkwithhisleftarm-forsooth,becausehewassuchanenergeticfellowthatotherwisehewouldinvoluntarilylaymorebricksthanhisunionpermitted。
  AllEnglandresoundstothecry,"Wakeup,England!"Butthesulkygiantisnotstirred。"LetEngland'stradegotopot,"hesays;
  "whathaveItolose?"AndEnglandispowerless。Thecapacityofherworkmenisrepresentedby1,incomparisonwiththe2。25
  capacityoftheAmericanworkman。Andbecauseofthesolidarityoflaborandthedestructivenessofstrikes,BritishcapitalistsdarenotevenstrivetoemulatetheenterpriseofAmericancapitalists。
  SoEnglandwatchestradeslippingthroughherfingersandwailsunavailingly。Asacorrespondentwrites:"Theenormouspowerofthetradeunionshangs,asullencloud,overthewholeindustrialworldhere,affectingmenandmastersalike。"
  ThepoliticalmovementknownasSocialismis,perhaps,evenlessrealizedbythegeneralpublic。Thegreatstridesithastakenandtheportentousfrontittodayexhibitsarenotcomprehended;and,fastenedthoughitisineveryland,itisgivenlittlespacebythecapitalisticpress。Forallitspleaandpassionandwarmth,itwellsupwardlikeagreat,coldtidalwave,irresistible,inexorable,ingulfingpresent-daysocietylevelbylevel。Byitsownpreachmentitisinexorable。Justassocietieshavesprungintoexistence,fulfilledtheirfunction,andpassedaway,itclaims,justassurelyispresentsocietyhasteningontoitsdissolution。
  Thisisatransitionperiod——anddestinedtobeaveryshortone。
  Barelyacenturyold,capitalismisripeningsorapidlythatitcanneverlivetoseeasecondbirthday。Thereisnohopeforit,theSocialistssay。Itisdoomed。
  ThecardinaltenetofSocialismisthatforbiddingdoctrine,thematerialisticconceptionofhistory。Menarenotthemastersoftheirsouls。Theyarethepuppetsofgreat,blindforces。Thelivestheyliveandthedeathstheydiearecompulsory。Allsocialcodesarebutthereflexesofexistingeconomicconditions,pluscertainsurvivalsofpasteconomicconditions。Theinstitutionsmenbuildtheyarecompelledtobuild。Economiclawsdetermineatanygiventimewhattheseinstitutionsshallbe,howlongtheyshalloperate,andbywhattheyshallbereplaced。Andso,throughtheeconomicprocess,theSocialistpreachestheripeningofthecapitalisticsocietyandthecomingofthenewcooperativesociety。
  ThesecondgreattenetofSocialism,itselfaphaseofthematerialisticconceptionofhistory,istheclassstruggle。Inthesocialstruggleforexistence,menareforcedintoclasses。"Thehistoryofallsocietythusfaristhehistoryofclassstrife。"Inexistingsocietythecapitalistclassexploitstheworkingclass,theproletariat。Theinterestsoftheexploiterarenottheinterestsoftheexploited。"Profitsarelegitimate,"saystheone。
  "Profitsareunpaidwages,"repliestheother,whenhehasbecomeconsciousofhisclass,"thereforeprofitsarerobbery。"Thecapitalistenforceshisprofitsbecauseheisthelegalownerofallthemeansofproduction。Heisthelegalownerbecausehecontrolsthepoliticalmachineryofsociety。TheSocialistsetstoworktocapturethepoliticalmachinery,sothathemaymakeillegalthecapitalist'sownershipofthemeansofproduction,andmakelegalhisownownershipofthemeansofproduction。Anditisthisstruggle,betweenthesetwoclasses,uponwhichtheworldhasatlastentered。
  ScientificSocialismisveryyoung。Onlyyesterdayitwasinswaddlingclothes。Buttodayitisavigorousyounggiant,wellbracedtobattleforwhatitwants,andknowingpreciselywhatitwants。Itholdsitsinternationalconventions,whereworld-policiesareformulatedbytherepresentativesofmillionsofSocialists。InlittleBelgiumtherearethree-quartersofamillionofmenwhoworkforthecause;inGermany,3,000,000;Austria,between1895and1897,raisedhersocialistvotefrom90,000to750,000。Francein1871hadawholegenerationofSocialistswipedout;yetin1885
  therewere30,000,andin1898,1,000,000。
  ErethelastSpaniardhadevacuatedCuba,Socialistgroupswereforming。AndfromfarJapan,inthesefirstdaysofthetwentiethcentury,writesoneTomoyoshiMurai:"TheinterestofourpeopleonSocialismhasbeengreatlyawakenedthesedays,especiallyamongourlaboringpeopleononehandandyoungstudents'circleontheother,asmuchaswecandrawanearnestandenthusiasticaudienceandfillourhall,whichholdstwothousand……Itisgratifyingtosaythatwehaveanumberoffineandwell-trainedpublicoratorsamongourleadersofSocialisminJapan。ThefirstspeakertonightisMr。
  KiyoshiKawakami,editorofoneofourcityTokyodailies,astrong,independent,anddecidedlysocialisticpaper,circulatedfarandwide。Mr。Kawakamiisascholaraswellasapopularwriter。
  Heisgoingtospeaktonightonthesubject,'TheEssenceofSocialism——theFundamentalPrinciples。'ThenextspeakerisProfessorIsoAbe,presidentofourassociation,whosesubjectofaddressis,'SocialismandtheExistingSocialSystem。'ThethirdspeakerisMr。NaoeKinosita,theeditorofanotherstrongjournalofthecity。Hespeaksonthesubject,'HowtoRealizetheSocialistIdealsandPlans。'NextisMr。ShigeyoshiSugiyama,agraduateofHartfordTheologicalSeminaryandanadvocateofSocialChristianity,whoistospeakon'SocialismandMunicipalProblems。'
  Andthelastspeakeristheeditorofthe'LaborWorld,'theforemostleaderofthelabor-unionmovementinourcountry,Mr。SenKatayama,whospeaksonthesubject,'TheOutlookofSocialisminEuropeandAmerica。'Theseaddressesaregoingtobepublishedinbookformandtobedistributedamongourpeopletoenlightentheirmindsonthesubject。"
  Andinthestruggleforthepoliticalmachineryofsociety,Socialismisnolongerconfinedtomerepropaganda。Italy,Austria,Belgium,England,haveSocialistmembersintheirnationalbodies。
  Outoftheonehundredandthirty-twomembersoftheLondonCountyCouncil,ninety-onearedenouncedbytheconservativeelementasSocialists。TheEmperorofGermanygrowsanxiousandangryattheincreasingnumberswhicharereturnedtotheReichstag。InFrance,manyofthelargecities,suchasMarseilles,areinthehandsoftheSocialists。AlargebodyofthemisintheChamberofDeputies,andMillerand,Socialist,sitsinthecabinet。OfhimM。Leroy-
  Beaulieusayswithhorror:"M。Millerandistheopenenemyofprivateproperty,privatecapital,theresoluteadvocateofthesocializationofproduction……aconstantincitementtoviolence……acollectivist,avowedandmilitant,takingpartinthegovernment,dominatingthedepartmentsofcommerceandindustry,preparingallthelawsandpresidingatthepassageofallmeasureswhichshouldbesubmittedtomerchantsandtradesmen。"
  IntheUnitedStatestherearealreadySocialistmayorsoftownsandmembersofStatelegislatures,avastliterature,andsingleSocialistpaperswithsubscriptionlistsrunningupintothehundredsofthousands。In1896,36,000voteswerecastfortheSocialistcandidateforPresident;in1900,nearly200,000;in1904,450,000。AndtheUnitedStates,youngasitis,isripeningrapidly,andtheSocialistsclaim,accordingtothematerialisticconceptionofhistory,thattheUnitedStateswillbethefirstcountryintheworldwhereinthetoilerswillcapturethepoliticalmachineryandexpropriatethebourgeoisie。
  ButtheSocialistandlabormovementshaverecentlyentereduponanewphase。Therehasbeenaremarkablechangeinattitudeonbothsides。Foralongtimethelaborunionsrefrainedfromgoinginforpoliticalaction。Ontheotherhand,theSocialistsclaimedthatwithoutpoliticalactionlaborwaspowerless。Andbecauseofthistherewasmuchillfeelingbetweenthem,evenopenhostilities,andnoconcertedaction。ButnowtheSocialistsgrantthatthelabormovementhasheldupwagesanddecreasedthehoursoflabor,andthelaborunionsfindthatpoliticalactionisnecessary。Todaybothpartieshavedrawncloselytogetherinthecommonfight。IntheUnitedStatesthisfriendlyfeelinggrows。TheSocialistpapersespousethecauseoflabor,andtheunionshaveopenedtheirearsoncemoretothewilesoftheSocialists。TheyareallleavenedwithSocialistworkmen,"boringfromwithin,"andmanyoftheirleadershavealreadysuccumbed。InEngland,whereclassconsciousnessismoredeveloped,thename"Unionism"hasbeenreplacedby"TheNewUnionism,"themainobjectofwhichis"tocaptureexistingsocialstructuresintheinterestsofthewage-
  earners。"TheretheSocialist,thetrade-union,andotherworking-
  classorganizationsarebeginningtocooperateinsecuringthereturnofrepresentativestotheHouseofCommons。AndinFrance,wherethecitycouncilsandmayorsofMarseillesandMonteaules-
  MinesareSocialistic,thousandsoffrancsofmunicipalmoneywerevotedfortheaidoftheunionsintherecentgreatstrikes。
  Forcenturiestheworldhasbeenpreparingforthecomingofthecommonman。Andtheperiodofpreparationvirtuallypast,labor,consciousofitselfanditsdesires,hasbegunadefinitemovementtowardsolidarity。Itbelievesthetimeisnotfardistantwhenthehistorianwillspeaknotonlyofthedarkagesoffeudalism,butofthedarkagesofcapitalism。Andlaborsincerelybelievesitselfjustifiedinthisbytheterribleindictmentitbringsagainstcapitalisticsociety。Inthefaceofitsenormouswealth,capitalisticsocietyforfeitsitsrighttoexistencewhenitpermitswidespread,bestialpoverty。Thephilosophyofthesurvivalofthefittestdoesnotsoothetheclass-consciousworkerwhenhelearnsthroughhisclassliteraturethatamongtheItalianpants-finishersofChicago{9}theaverageweeklywageis$1。31,andtheaveragenumberofweeksemployedintheyearis27。85。Likewisewhenhereads:{10}"Everyroominthesereekingtenementshousesafamilyortwo。Inoneroomamissionaryfoundamanillwithsmall-pox,hiswifejustrecoveringfromherconfinement,andthechildrenrunningabouthalfnakedandcoveredwithdirt。Herearesevenpeoplelivinginoneundergroundkitchen,andalittledeadchildlyinginthesameroom。Hereliveawidowandhersixchildren,twoofwhomareillwithscarletfever。Inanother,ninebrothersandsisters,fromtwenty-nineyearsofagedownward,live,eat,andsleeptogether。"Andlikewise,whenhereads:{11}"Whenoneman,fiftyyearsold,whohasworkedallhislife,iscompelledtobegalittlemoneytoburyhisdeadbaby,andanotherman,fiftyyearsold,cangivetenmilliondollarstoenablehisdaughtertoliveinluxuryandbolsterupadecayingforeignaristocracy,doyouseenothingamiss?"
  Andontheotherhand,theclass-consciousworkerreadsthestatisticsofthewealthyclasses,knowswhattheirincomesare,andhowtheygetthem。True,downallthepasthehasknownhisownmaterialmiseryandthematerialcomfortofthedominantclasses,andoftenhasthisknowledgeledhimtointemperateactsandunwiserebellion。Buttoday,andforthefirsttime,becausebothsocietyandhehaveevolved,heisbeginningtoseeapossiblewayout。HisearsareopeningtothepropagandaofSocialism,thepassionategospelofthedispossessed。Butitdoesnotinculcateaturningback。Thewaythroughisthewayout,heunderstands,andwiththisinmindhedrawsuptheprogramme。
  Itisquitesimple,thisprogramme。Everythingismovinginhisdirection,towardthedaywhenhewilltakecharge。Thetrust?Ah,no。Unlikethetremblingmiddle-classmanandthesmallcapitalist,heseesnothingatwhichtobefrightened。Helikesthetrust。Heexultsinthetrust,foritislargelydoingthetaskforhim。Itsocializesproduction;thisdone,thereremainsnothingforhimtodobutsocializedistribution,andallisaccomplished。Thetrust?
  "Itorganizesindustryonanenormous,labor-savingscale,andabolisheschildish,wastefulcompetition。"Itisagiganticobjectlesson,anditpreacheshispoliticaleconomyfarmorepotentlythanhecanpreachit。Hepointstothetrust,laughingscornfullyinthefaceoftheorthodoxeconomists。"Youtoldmethisthingcouldnotbe,"{12}hethunders。"Behold,thethingis!"
  Heseescompetitionintherealmofproductionpassingaway。Whenthecaptainsofindustryhavethoroughlyorganizedproduction,andgoteverythingrunningsmoothly,itwillbeveryeasyforhimtoeliminatetheprofitsbysteppinginandhavingthethingrunforhimself。Andthecaptainofindustry,ifhebegood,maybegiventheprivilegeofcontinuingthemanagementonafairsalary。ThesixtymillionsofdividendswhichtheStandardOilCompanyannuallydeclareswillbedistributedamongtheworkers。ThesamewiththegreatUnitedStatesSteelCorporation。Thepresidentofthatcorporationknowshisbusiness。Verygood。LethimbecomeSecretaryoftheDepartmentofIronandSteeloftheUnitedStates。
  But,sincethechiefexecutiveofanationofseventy-oddmillionsworksfor$50,000ayear,theSecretaryoftheDepartmentofIronandSteelmustexpecttohavehissalarycutaccordingly。Andnotonlywilltheworkerstaketothemselvestheprofitsofnationalandmunicipalmonopolies,butalsotheimmenserevenueswhichthedominantclassestodaydrawfromrents,andmines,andfactories,andallmannerofenterprises。
  Allthiswouldseemverylikeadream,eventotheworker,ifitwerenotforthefactthatlikethingshavebeendonebefore。Hepointstriumphantlytothearistocratoftheeighteenthcentury,whofought,legislated,governed,anddominatedsociety,butwhowasshornofpoweranddisplacedbytherisingbourgeoisie。Ay,thethingwasdone,heholds。Anditshallbedoneagain,butthistimeitistheproletariatwhodoestheshearing。Sociologyhastaughthimthatm-i-g-h-tspells"right。"Everysocietyhasbeenruledbyclasses,andtheclasseshaveruledbysheerstrength,andhavebeenoverthrownbysheerstrength。Thebourgeoisie,becauseitwasthestronger,draggeddownthenobilityofthesword;andtheproletariat,becauseitisthestrongestofall,canandwilldragdownthebourgeoisie。
  Andinthatday,forbetterorworse,thecommonmanbecomesthemaster——forbetter,hebelieves。Itishisintentiontomakethesumofhumanhappinessfargreater。Nomanshallworkforabarelivingwage,whichisdegradation。Everymanshallhaveworktodo,andshallbepaidexceedinglywellfordoingit。Thereshallbenoslumclasses,nobeggars。Norshalltherebehundredsofthousandsofmenandwomencondemned,foreconomicreasons,tolivesofcelibacyorsexualinfertility。Everymanshallbeabletomarry,toliveinhealthy,comfortablequarters,andtohaveallhewantstoeatasmanytimesadayashewishes。Thereshallnolongerbealife-and-deathstruggleforfoodandshelter。Theoldheartlesslawofdevelopmentshallbeannulled。
  Allofwhichisverygoodandveryfine。Andwhenthesethingshavecometopass,whatthen?Ofold,byvirtueoftheirweaknessandinefficiencyinthestruggleforfoodandshelter,theracewaspurgedofitsweakandinefficientmembers。Butthiswillnolongerobtain。Underthenewordertheweakandtheprogenyoftheweakwillhaveachanceforsurvivalequaltothatofthestrongandtheprogenyofthestrong。Thisbeingso,thepremiumuponstrengthwillhavebeenwithdrawn,andonthefaceofittheaveragestrengthofeachgeneration,insteadofcontinuingtorise,willbegintodecline。
  Whenthecommonman'sdayshallhavearrived,thenewsocialinstitutionsofthatdaywillpreventtheweedingoutofweaknessandinefficiency。All,theweakandthestrong,willhaveanequalchanceforprocreation。Andtheprogenyofall,oftheweakaswellasthestrong,willhaveanequalchanceforsurvival。Thisbeingso,andifnoneweffectivelawofdevelopmentbeputintooperation,thenprogressmustcease。Andnotonlyprogress,fordeteriorationwouldatoncesetin。Itisapregnantproblem。Whatwillbethenatureofthisnewandmostnecessarylawofdevelopment?Canthecommonmanpauselongenoughfromhisundermininglaborstoanswer?Sinceheisbentupondraggingdownthebourgeoisieandreconstructingsociety,canhesoreconstructthatapremium,insomeunguessedwayorother,willstillbelaiduponthestrongandefficientsothatthehumantypewillcontinuetodevelop?Canthecommonman,ortheuncommonmenwhoarealliedwithhim,devisesuchalaw?Orhavetheyalreadydevisedone?Andifso,whatisit?
  HOWIBECAMEASOCIALIST
  ItisquitefairtosaythatIbecameaSocialistinafashionsomewhatsimilartothewayinwhichtheTeutonicpagansbecameChristians——itwashammeredintome。NotonlywasInotlookingforSocialismatthetimeofmyconversion,butIwasfightingit。I
  wasveryyoungandcallow,didnotknowmuchofanything,andthoughIhadneverevenheardofaschoolcalled"Individualism,"Isangthepaeanofthestrongwithallmyheart。
  ThiswasbecauseIwasstrongmyself。BystrongImeanthatIhadgoodhealthandhardmuscles,bothofwhichpossessionsareeasilyaccountedfor。IhadlivedmychildhoodonCaliforniaranches,myboyhoodhustlingnewspapersonthestreetsofahealthyWesterncity,andmyyouthontheozone-ladenwatersofSanFranciscoBayandthePacificOcean。Ilovedlifeintheopen,andItoiledintheopen,atthehardestkindsofwork。Learningnotrade,butdriftingalongfromjobtojob,Ilookedontheworldandcalleditgood,everybitofit。Letmerepeat,thisoptimismwasbecauseI
  washealthyandstrong,botheredwithneitherachesnorweaknesses,neverturneddownbythebossbecauseIdidnotlookfit,ablealwaystogetajobatshovellingcoal,sailorizing,ormanuallaborofsomesort。
  Andbecauseofallthis,exultinginmyyounglife,abletoholdmyownatworkorfight,Iwasarampantindividualist。Itwasverynatural。Iwasawinner。WhereforeIcalledthegame,asIsawitplayed,orthoughtIsawitplayed,averypropergameforMEN。TobeaMANwastowritemaninlargecapitalsonmyheart。Toadventurelikeaman,andfightlikeaman,anddoaman'sworkevenforaboy'spay——thesewerethingsthatreachedrightinandgrippedholdofmeasnootherthingcould。AndIlookedaheadintolongvistasofahazyandinterminablefuture,intowhich,playingwhatIconceivedtobeMAN'Sgame,Ishouldcontinuetotravelwithunfailinghealth,withoutaccidents,andwithmusclesevervigorous。
  AsIsay,thisfuturewasinterminable。IcouldseemyselfonlyragingthroughlifewithoutendlikeoneofNietzsche'sBLOND-
  BEASTS,lustfullyrovingandconqueringbysheersuperiorityandstrength。
  Asfortheunfortunates,thesick,andailing,andold,andmaimed,ImustconfessIhardlythoughtofthematall,savethatIvaguelyfeltthatthey,barringaccidents,couldbeasgoodasIiftheywantedtorealhard,andcouldworkjustaswell。Accidents?Well,theyrepresentedFATE,alsospelledoutincapitals,andtherewasnogettingaroundFATE。NapoleonhadhadanaccidentatWaterloo,butthatdidnotdampenmydesiretobeanotherandlaterNapoleon。
  Further,theoptimismbredofastomachwhichcoulddigestscrapironandabodywhichflourishedonhardshipsdidnotpermitmetoconsideraccidentsasevenremotelyrelatedtomygloriouspersonality。
  IhopeIhavemadeitclearthatIwasproudtobeoneofNature'sstrong-armednoblemen。Thedignityoflaborwastomethemostimpressivethingintheworld。WithouthavingreadCarlyle,orKipling,Iformulatedagospelofworkwhichputtheirsintheshade。Workwaseverything。Itwassanctificationandsalvation。
  TheprideItookinahardday'sworkwelldonewouldbeinconceivabletoyou。ItisalmostinconceivabletomeasIlookbackuponit。Iwasasfaithfulawageslaveasevercapitalistexploited。Toshirkormalingeronthemanwhopaidmemywageswasasin,first,againstmyself,andsecond,againsthim。Iconsidereditacrimesecondonlytotreasonandjustaboutasbad。
  Inshort,myjoyousindividualismwasdominatedbytheorthodoxbourgeoisethics。Ireadthebourgeoispapers,listenedtothebourgeoispreachers,andshoutedatthesonorousplatitudesofthebourgeoispoliticians。AndIdoubtnot,ifothereventshadnotchangedmycareer,thatIshouldhaveevolvedintoaprofessionalstrike-breaker,oneofPresidentEliot'sAmericanheroes,andhadmyheadandmyearningpowerirrevocablysmashedbyaclubinthehandsofsomemilitanttrades-unionist。
  Justaboutthistime,returningfromasevenmonths'voyagebeforethemast,andjustturnedeighteen,Itookitintomyheadtogotramping。OnrodsandblindbaggagesIfoughtmywayfromtheopenWestwheremenbuckedbigandthejobhuntedtheman,tothecongestedlaborcentresoftheEast,wheremenweresmallpotatoesandhuntedthejobforalltheywereworth。AndonthisnewBLOND-
  BEASTadventureIfoundmyselflookinguponlifefromanewandtotallydifferentangle。Ihaddroppeddownfromtheproletariatintowhatsociologistslovetocallthe"submergedtenth,"andIwasstartledtodiscoverthewayinwhichthatsubmergedtenthwasrecruited。
  Ifoundthereallsortsofmen,manyofwhomhadoncebeenasgoodasmyselfandjustasBLOND-BEAST;sailor-men,soldier-men,labor-
  men,allwrenchedanddistortedandtwistedoutofshapebytoilandhardshipandaccident,andcastadriftbytheirmasterslikesomanyoldhorses。Ibatteredonthedragandslammedbackgateswiththem,orshiveredwiththeminboxcarsandcityparks,listeningthewhiletolife-historieswhichbeganunderauspicesasfairasmine,withdigestionsandbodiesequaltoandbetterthanmine,andwhichendedtherebeforemyeyesintheshamblesatthebottomoftheSocialPit。
  AndasIlistenedmybrainbegantowork。Thewomanofthestreetsandthemanofthegutterdrewveryclosetome。IsawthepictureoftheSocialPitasvividlyasthoughitwereaconcretething,andatthebottomofthePitIsawthem,myselfabovethem,notfar,andhangingontotheslipperywallbymainstrengthandsweat。AndI
  confessaterrorseizedme。Whatwhenmystrengthfailed?whenI
  shouldbeunabletoworkshouldertoshoulderwiththestrongmenwhowereasyetbabesunborn?AndthereandthenIsworeagreatoath。Itransomethinglikethis:ALLMYDAYSIHAVEWORKEDHARD
  WITHMYBODY,ANDACCORDINGTOTHENUMBEROFDAYSIHAVEWORKED,BY
  JUSTTHATMUCHAMINEARERTHEBOTTOMOFTHEPIT。ISHALLCLIMBOUT
  OFTHEPIT,BUTNOTBYTHEMUSCLESOFMYBODYSHALLICLIMBOUT。I
  SHALLDONOMOREHARDWORK,ANDMAYGODSTRIKEMEDEADIFIDO
  ANOTHERDAY'SHARDWORKWITHMYBODYMORETHANIABSOLUTELYHAVETO
  DO。AndIhavebeenbusyeversincerunningawayfromhardwork。
  Incidentally,whiletrampingsometenthousandmilesthroughtheUnitedStatesandCanada,IstrayedintoNiagaraFalls,wasnabbedbyafee-huntingconstable,deniedtherighttopleadguiltyornotguilty,sentencedoutofhandtothirtydays'imprisonmentforhavingnofixedabodeandnovisiblemeansofsupport,handcuffedandchainedtoabunchofmensimilarlycircumstanced,carteddowncountrytoBuffalo,registeredattheErieCountyPenitentiary,hadmyheadclippedandmybuddingmustacheshaved,wasdressedinconvictstripes,compulsorilyvaccinatedbyamedicalstudentwhopractisedonsuchaswe,madetomarchthelock-step,andputtoworkundertheeyesofguardsarmedwithWinchesterrifles——allforadventuringinBLOND-BEASTLYfashion。Concerningfurtherdetailsdeponentsayethnot,thoughhemayhintthatsomeofhisplethoricnationalpatriotismsimmereddownandleakedoutofthebottomofhissoulsomewhere——atleast,sincethatexperiencehefindsthathecaresmoreformenandwomenandlittlechildrenthanforimaginarygeographicallines。
  Toreturntomyconversion。Ithinkitisapparentthatmyrampantindividualismwasprettyeffectivelyhammeredoutofme,andsomethingelseaseffectivelyhammeredin。But,justasIhadbeenanindividualistwithoutknowingit,IwasnowaSocialistwithoutknowingit,withal,anunscientificone。Ihadbeenreborn,butnotrenamed,andIwasrunningaroundtofindoutwhatmannerofthingI
  was。IranbacktoCaliforniaandopenedthebooks。IdonotrememberwhichonesIopenedfirst。Itisanunimportantdetailanyway。IwasalreadyIt,whateverItwas,andbyaidofthebooksIdiscoveredthatItwasaSocialist。SincethatdayIhaveopenedmanybooks,butnoeconomicargument,noluciddemonstrationofthelogicandinevitablenessofSocialismaffectsmeasprofoundlyandconvincinglyasIwasaffectedonthedaywhenIfirstsawthewallsoftheSocialPitrisearoundmeandfeltmyselfslippingdown,down,intotheshamblesatthebottom。
  Footnotes:
  {1}"From43to52percentofallapplicantsneedworkratherthanrelief。"——ReportoftheCharityOrganizationSocietyofNewYorkCity。
  {2}Mr。Leiter,whoownsacoalmineatthetownofZeigler,Illinois,inaninterviewprintedintheChicagoRecord-HeraldofDecember6,1904,said:"WhenIgointothemarkettopurchaselabor,Iproposetoretainjustasmuchfreedomasdoesapurchaserinanyotherkindofamarket……Thereisnodifficultywhateverinobtaininglabor,FORTHECOUNTRYISFULLOFUNEMPLOYEDMEN。"
  {3}"Despondentandwearywithvainattemptstostruggleagainstanunsympatheticworld,twooldmenwerebroughtbeforePoliceJudgeMcHughthisafternoontoseewhethersomemeanscouldnotbeprovidedfortheirsupport,atleastuntilspringtime。
  "GeorgeWestlakewasthefirstonetoreceivetheconsiderationofthecourt。Westlakeisseventy-twoyearsold。Achargeofhabitualdrunkennesswasplacedagainsthim,andhewassentencedtoaterminthecountyjail,thoughitismorethanprobablethathewasneverundertheinfluenceofintoxicatingliquorinhislife。Theactonthepartoftheauthoritieswasoneofkindnessforhim,asinthecountyjailhewillbeprovidedwithagoodplacetosleepandplentytoeat。
  "JoeCoat,agedsixty-nineyears,willserveninetydaysinthecountyjailformuchthesamereasonasWestlake。Hestatesthat,ifgivenachancetodoso,hewillgoouttoawood-campandcuttimberduringthewinter,butthepoliceauthoritiesrealizethathecouldnotlongsurvivesuchatask。"——FromtheButteMontana
  Miner,December7th,1904。
  "'IendmylifebecauseIhavereachedtheagelimit,andthereisnoplaceformeinthisworld。Pleasenotifymywife,No。222West129thStreet,NewYork。'Havingsummedupthecauseofhisdespondencyinthisfinalmessage,JamesHollander,fifty-sixyearsold,shothimselfthroughthelefttemple,inhisroomattheStaffordHoteltoday。"——NewYorkHerald。
  {4}IntheSanFranciscoExaminerofNovember16,1904,thereisanaccountoftheuseoffire-hosetodriveawaythreehundredmenwhowantedworkatunloadingavesselintheharbor。Soanxiouswerethementogetthetwoorthreehours'jobthattheymadeaveritablemobandhadtobedrivenoff。
  {5}"Itwasnouncommonthinginthesesweatshopsformentositbentoverasewing-machinecontinuouslyfromeleventofifteenhoursadayinJulyweather,operatingasewing-machinebyfoot-power,andoftensodriventhattheycouldnotstopforlunch。Theseasonalcharacteroftheworkmeantdemoralizingtoilforafewmonthsintheyear,andanotlessdemoralizingidlenessfortheremainderofthetime。Consumption,theplagueofthetenementsandtheespecialplagueofthegarmentindustry,carriedoffmanyoftheseworkers;
  poornutritionandexhaustion,manymore。"——FromMcClure'sMagazine。
  {6}TheSocialUnrest。MacmillanCompany。
  {7}"OurBenevolentFeudalism。"ByW。J。Ghent。TheMacmillanCompany。
  {8}"TheSocialUnrest。"ByJohnGrahamBrooks。TheMacmillanCompany。
  {9}FromfigurespresentedbyMissNellieMasonAutenintheAmericanJournalofSociology,andcopiedextensivelybythetrade-
  unionandSocialistpress。
  {10}"TheBitterCryofOutcastLondon。"
  {11}AnitemfromtheSocialDemocraticHerald。Hundredsoftheseitems,culledfromcurrenthappenings,arepublishedweeklyinthepapersoftheworkers。
  {12}KarlMarx,thegreatSocialist,workedoutthetrustdevelopmentfortyyearsago,forwhichhewaslaughedatbytheorthodoxeconomists。