Perfectconductisarelationbetweenthreeterms:theactor,theobjectsforwhichheacts,andtherecipientsoftheaction。
Inorderthatconductshouldbeabstractlyperfect,allthreeterms,intention,execution,andreception,shouldbesuitedtooneanother。Thebestintentionwillfailifiteitherworkbyfalsemeansoraddressitselftothewrongrecipient。Thusnocriticorestimatorofthevalueofconductcanconfinehimselftotheactor’sanimusalone,apartfromtheotherelementsoftheperformance。Asthereisnoworseliethanatruthmisunderstoodbythosewhohearit,soreasonablearguments,challengestomagnanimity,andappealstosympathyorjustice,arefollywhenwearedealingwithhumancrocodilesandboa-constrictors。Thesaintmaysimplygivetheuniverseintothehandsoftheenemybyhistrustfulness。Hemaybynon-resistancecutoffhisownsurvival。
HerbertSpencertellsusthattheperfectman’sconductwillappearperfectonlywhentheenvironmentisperfect:tonoinferiorenvironmentisitsuitablyadapted。Wemayparaphrasethisbycordiallyadmittingthatsaintlyconductwouldbethemostperfectconductconceivableinanenvironmentwhereallweresaintsalready;butbyaddingthatinanenvironmentwherefewaresaints,andmanytheexactreverseofsaints,itmustbeilladapted。Wemustfranklyconfess,then,usingourempiricalcommonsenseandordinarypracticalprejudices,thatintheworldthatactuallyis,thevirtuesofsympathy,charity,andnon-resistancemaybe,andoftenhavebeen,manifestedinexcess。
Thepowersofdarknesshavesystematicallytakenadvantageofthem。Thewholemodernscientificorganizationofcharityisaconsequenceofthefailureofsimplygivingalms。Thewholehistoryofconstitutionalgovernmentisacommentaryontheexcellenceofresistingevil,andwhenonecheekissmitten,ofsmitingbackandnotturningtheothercheekalso。
Youwillagreetothisingeneral,forinspiteoftheGospel,inspiteofQuakerism,inspiteofTolstoi,youbelieveinfightingfirewithfire,inshootingdownusurpers,lockingupthieves,andfreezingoutvagabondsandswindlers。
Andyetyouaresure,asIamsure,thatweretheworldconfinedtothesehard-headed,hard-hearted,andhard-fistedmethodsexclusively,weretherenooneprompttohelpabrotherfirst,andfindoutafterwardswhetherhewereworthy;noonewillingtodrownhisprivatewrongsinpityforthewronger’sperson;noonereadytobedupedmanyatimeratherthanlivealwaysonsuspicion;noonegladtotreatindividualspassionatelyandimpulsivelyratherthanbygeneralrulesofprudence;theworldwouldbeaninfinitelyworseplacethanitisnowtolivein。
Thetendergrace,notofadaythatisdead,butofadayyettobebornsomehow,withthegoldenrulegrownnatural,wouldbecutoutfromtheperspectiveofourimaginations。
Thesaints,existinginthisway,may,withtheirextravagancesofhumantenderness,beprophetic。Nay,innumerabletimestheyhaveprovedthemselvesprophetic。Treatingthosewhomtheymet,inspiteofthepast,inspiteofallappearances,asworthy,theyhavestimulatedthemtoBEworthy,miraculouslytransformedthembytheirradiantexampleandbythechallengeoftheirexpectation。
Fromthispointofviewwemayadmitthehumancharitywhichwefindinallsaints,andthegreatexcessofitwhichwefindinsomesaints,tobeagenuinelycreativesocialforce,tendingtomakerealadegreeofvirtuewhichitaloneisreadytoassumeaspossible。Thesaintsareauthors,auctores,increasers,ofgoodness。Thepotentialitiesofdevelopmentinhumansoulsareunfathomable。Somanywhoseemedirretrievablyhardenedhaveinpointoffactbeensoftened,converted,regenerated,inwaysthatamazedthesubjectsevenmorethantheysurprisedthespectators,thatwenevercanbesureinadvanceofanymanthathissalvationbythewayofloveishopeless。Wehavenorighttospeakofhumancrocodilesandboa-constrictorsasoffixedlyincurablebeings。Weknownotthecomplexitiesofpersonality,thesmoulderingemotionalfires,theotherfacetsofthecharacter-polyhedron,theresourcesofthesubliminalregion。
St。Paullongagomadeourancestorsfamiliarwiththeideathateverysoulisvirtuallysacred。SinceChristdiedforusallwithoutexception,St。Paulsaid,wemustdespairofnoone。
Thisbeliefintheessentialsacrednessofeveryoneexpressesitselfto-dayinallsortsofhumanecustomsandreformatoryinstitutions,andinagrowingaversiontothedeathpenaltyandtobrutalityinpunishment。Thesaints,withtheirextravaganceofhumantenderness,arethegreattorch-bearersofthisbelief,thetipofthewedge,theclearersofthedarkness。Likethesingledropswhichsparkleinthesunastheyareflungfaraheadoftheadvancingedgeofawave-crestorofaflood,theyshowthewayandareforerunners。Theworldisnotyetwiththem,sotheyoftenseeminthemidstoftheworld’saffairstobepreposterous。Yettheyareimpregnatorsoftheworld,vivifiersandanimatersofpotentialitiesofgoodnesswhichbutforthemwouldlieforeverdormant。Itisnotpossibletobequiteasmeanaswenaturallyare,whentheyhavepassedbeforeus。Onefirekindlesanother;andwithoutthatover-trustinhumanworthwhichtheyshow,therestofuswouldlieinspiritualstagnancy。
Momentarilyconsidered,then,thesaintmaywastehistendernessandbethedupeandvictimofhischaritablefever,butthegeneralfunctionofhischarityinsocialevolutionisvitalandessential。Ifthingsareevertomoveupward,someonemustbereadytotakethefirststep,andassumetheriskofit。Noonewhoisnotwillingtotrycharity,totrynon-resistanceasthesaintisalwayswilling,cantellwhetherthesemethodswillorwillnotsucceed。Whentheydosucceed,theyarefarmorepowerfullysuccessfulthanforceorworldlyprudence。Forcedestroysenemies;andthebestthatcanbesaidofprudenceisthatitkeepswhatwealreadyhaveinsafety。Butnon-resistance,whensuccessful,turnsenemiesintofriends;andcharityregeneratesitsobjects。Thesesaintlymethodsare,asI
said,creativeenergies;andgenuinesaintsfindintheelevatedexcitementwithwhichtheirfaithendowsthemanauthorityandimpressivenesswhichmakesthemirresistibleinsituationswheremenofshallowernaturecannotgetonatallwithouttheuseofworldlyprudence。Thispracticalproofthatworldlywisdommaybesafelytranscendedisthesaint’smagicgifttomankind。[215]
Notonlydoeshisvisionofabetterworldconsoleusforthegenerallyprevailingproseandbarrenness;butevenwhenonthewholewehavetoconfesshimilladapted,hemakessomeconverts,andtheenvironmentgetsbetterforhisministry。Heisaneffectivefermentofgoodness,aslowtransmuteroftheearthlyintoamoreheavenlyorder。
[215]Thebestmissionarylivesaboundinthevictoriouscombinationofnon-resistancewithpersonalauthority。JohnG。
Paton,forexample,intheNewHebrides,amongbrutishMelanesiancannibals,preservesacharmedlifebydintofit。Whenitcomestothepoint,nooneeverdaresactuallytostrikehim。Nativeconverts,inspiredbyhim,showedanalogousvirtue。“Oneofourchiefs,fulloftheChrist-kindleddesiretoseekandtosave,sentamessagetoaninlandchief,thatheandfourattendantswouldcomeonSabbathandtellthemthegospelofJehovahGod。
Thereplycamebacksternlyforbiddingtheirvisit,andthreateningwithdeathanyChristianthatapproachedtheirvillage。Ourchiefsentinresponsealovingmessage,tellingthemthatJehovahhadtaughttheChristianstoreturngoodforevil,andthattheywouldcomeunarmedtotellthemthestoryofhowtheSonofGodcameintotheworldanddiedinordertoblessandsavehisenemies。Theheathenchiefsentbackasternandpromptreplyoncemore:’Ifyoucome,youwillbekilled。’OnSabbathmorntheChristianchiefandhisfourcompanionsweremetoutsidethevillagebytheheathenchief,whoimploredandthreatenedthemoncemore。Buttheformersaid:——
“’Wecometoyouwithoutweaponsofwar!WecomeonlytotellyouaboutJesus。WebelievethatHewillprotectusto-day。’
“Astheypressedsteadilyforwardtowardsthevillage,spearsbegantobethrownatthem。Sometheyevaded,beingallexceptonedexterouswarriors;andotherstheyliterallyreceivedwiththeirbarehands,andturnedthemasideinanincrediblemanner。
Theheathen,apparentlythunderstruckatthesementhusapproachingthemwithoutweaponsofwar,andnotevenflingingbacktheirownspearswhichtheyhadcaught,afterhavingthrownwhattheoldchiefcalled’ashowerofspears,’desistedfrommeresurprise。OurChristianchiefcalledout,asheandhiscompanionsdrewupinthemidstofthemonthevillagepublicground:——
“’Jehovahthusprotectsus。Hehasgivenusallyourspears!
Oncewewouldhavethrownthembackatyouandkilledyou。Butnowwecome,nottofightbuttotellyouaboutJesus。Hehaschangedourdarkhearts。Heasksyounowtolaydownalltheseyourotherweaponsofwar,andtohearwhatwecantellyouabouttheloveofGod,ourgreatFather,theonlylivingGod。’
“Theheathenwereperfectlyoverawed。TheymanifestlylookedontheseChristiansasprotectedbysomeInvisibleOne。TheylistenedforthefirsttimetothestoryoftheGospelandoftheCross。WelivedtoseethatchiefandallhistribesittingintheschoolofChrist。Andthereisperhapsnotanislandinthesesouthernseas,amongstallthosewonforChrist,wheresimilaractsofheroismonthepartofconvertscannotberecited。”JohnG。Paton,MissionarytotheNewHebrides,AnAutobiography,secondpart,London,1890,p。243。
InthisrespecttheUtopiandreamsofsocialjusticeinwhichmanycontemporarysocialistsandanarchistsindulgeare,inspiteoftheirimpracticabilityandnon-adaptationtopresentenvironmentalconditions,analogoustothesaint’sbeliefinanexistentkingdomofheaven。Theyhelptobreaktheedgeofthegeneralreignofhardnessandareslowleavensofabetterorder。
ThenexttopicinorderisAsceticism,whichIfancyyouareallreadytoconsiderwithoutargumentavirtueliabletoextravaganceandexcess。Theoptimismandrefinementofthemodernimaginationhas,asIhavealreadysaidelsewhere,changedtheattitudeofthechurchtowardscorporealmortification,andaSusooraSaintPeterofAlcantara[216]appeartousto-dayratherinthelightoftragicmountebanksthanofsanemeninspiringuswithrespect。Iftheinnerdispositionsareright,weask,whatneedofallthistorment,thisviolationoftheouternature?Itkeepstheouternaturetooimportant。Anyonewhoisgenuinelyemancipatedfromthefleshwilllookonpleasuresandpains,abundanceandprivation,asalikeirrelevantandindifferent。Hecanengageinactionsandexperienceenjoymentswithoutfearofcorruptionorenslavement。AstheBhagavad-Gitasays,onlythoseneedrenounceworldlyactionswhoarestillinwardlyattachedthereto。Ifonebereallyunattachedtothefruitsofaction,onemaymixintheworldwithequanimity。IquotedinaformerlectureSaintAugustine’santinomiansaying:IfyouonlyloveGodenough,youmaysafelyfollowallyourinclinations。“Heneedsnodevotionalpractices。”isoneofRamakrishna’smaxims,“whoseheartismovedtotearsatthemerementionofthenameofHari。”[217]
AndtheBuddha,inpointingoutwhathecalled“themiddleway“
tohisdisciples,toldthemtoabstainfrombothextremes,excessivemortificationbeingasunrealandunworthyasmeredesireandpleasure。Theonlyperfectlife,hesaid,isthatofinnerwisdom,whichmakesonethingasindifferenttousasanother,andthusleadstorest,topeace,andtoNirvana。[218]
[216]SaintPeter,SaintTeresatellsusinherautobiographyFrenchtranslation,p。333,“hadpassedfortyyearswithouteversleepingmorethananhourandahalfaday。Ofallhismortifications,thiswastheonethathadcosthimthemost。Tocompassit,hekeptalwaysonhiskneesoronhisfeet。Thelittlesleepheallowednaturetotakewassnatchedinasittingposture,hisheadleaningagainstapieceofwoodfixedinthewall。Evenhadhewishedtoliedown,itwouldhavebeenimpossible,becausehiscellwasonlyfourfeetandahalflong。