Ithentoldmyparentsofit,andtoldthemthatIthoughtthattheymustseethatwhenIspoke,thatitwasnotmyownvoice,foritappearedsotome。MyspeechseemedentirelyunderthecontroloftheSpiritwithinme;IdonotmeanthatthewordswhichIspokewerenotmyown,fortheywere。IthoughtthatI
wasinfluencedsimilartotheApostlesonthedayofPentecostwiththeexceptionofhavingpowertogiveittoothers,anddoingwhattheydid。AfterbreakfastIwentroundtoconversewithmyneighborsonreligion,whichIcouldnothavebeenhiredtohavedonebeforethis,andattheirrequestIprayedwiththem,thoughIhadneverprayedinpublicbefore。
“InowfeelasifIhaddischargedmydutybytellingthetruth,andhopebytheblessingofGod,itmaydosomegoodtoallwhoshallreadit。HehasfulfilledhispromiseinsendingtheHolySpiritdownintoourhearts,ormineatleast,andInowdefyalltheDeistsandAtheistsintheworldtoshakemyfaithinChrist。”
SomuchforMr。Bradleyandhisconversion,oftheeffectofwhichuponhislaterlifewegainnoinformation。Nowforaminutersurveyoftheconstituentelementsoftheconversionprocess。
IfyouopenthechapteronAssociation,ofanytreatiseonPsychology,youwillreadthataman’sideas,aims,andobjectsformdiverseinternalgroupsandsystems,relativelyindependentofoneanother。Each’aim’whichhefollowsawakensacertainspecifickindofinterestedexcitement,andgathersacertaingroupofideastogetherinsubordinationtoitasitsassociates;
andiftheaimsandexcitementsaredistinctinkind,theirgroupsofideasmayhavelittleincommon。Whenonegroupispresentandengrossestheinterest,alltheideasconnectedwithothergroupsmaybeexcludedfromthementalfield。ThePresidentoftheUnitedStateswhen,withpaddle,gun,andfishing-rod,hegoescampinginthewildernessforavacation,changeshissystemofideasfromtoptobottom。Thepresidentialanxietieshavelapsedintothebackgroundentirely;theofficialhabitsarereplacedbythehabitsofasonofnature,andthosewhoknewthemanonlyasthestrenuousmagistratewouldnot“knowhimforthesameperson“iftheysawhimasthecamper。
Ifnowheshouldnevergoback,andneveragainsufferpoliticalintereststogaindominionoverhim,hewouldbeforpracticalintentsandpurposesapermanentlytransformedbeing。Ourordinaryalterationsofcharacter,aswepassfromoneofouraimstoanother,arenotcommonlycalledtransformations,becauseeachofthemissorapidlysucceededbyanotherinthereversedirection;butwheneveroneaimgrowssostableastoexpeldefinitivelyitspreviousrivalsfromtheindividual’slife,wetendtospeakofthephenomenon,andperhapstowonderatit,asa“transformation。”
Thesealternationsarethecompletestofthewaysinwhichaselfmaybedivided。Alesscompletewayisthesimultaneouscoexistenceoftwoormoredifferentgroupsofaims,ofwhichonepracticallyholdstherightofwayandinstigatesactivity,whilsttheothersareonlypiouswishes,andneverpracticallycometoanything。SaintAugustine’saspirationstoapurerlife,inourlastlecture,wereforawhileanexample。AnotherwouldbethePresidentinhisfullprideofoffice,wonderingwhetheritwerenotallvanity,andwhetherthelifeofawood-chopperwerenotthewholesomerdestiny。Suchfleetingaspirationsaremerevelleitates,whimsies。Theyexistontheremoteroutskirtsofthemind,andtherealselfoftheman,thecentreofhisenergies,isoccupiedwithanentirelydifferentsystem。Aslifegoeson,thereisaconstantchangeofourinterests,andaconsequentchangeofplaceinoursystemsofideas,frommorecentraltomoreperipheral,andfrommoreperipheraltomorecentralpartsofconsciousness。Iremember,forinstance,thatoneeveningwhenIwasayouth,myfatherreadaloudfromaBostonnewspaperthatpartofLordGifford’swillwhichfoundedthesefourlectureships。AtthattimeIdidnotthinkofbeingateacherofphilosophy,andwhatIlistenedtowasasremotefrommyownlifeasifitrelatedtotheplanetMars。YethereIam,withtheGiffordsystempartandparcelofmyveryself,andallmyenergies,forthetimebeing,devotedtosuccessfullyidentifyingmyselfwithit。Mysoulstandsnowplantedinwhatoncewasforitapracticallyunrealobject,andspeaksfromitasfromitsproperhabitatandcentre。
WhenIsay“Soul。”youneednottakemeintheontologicalsenseunlessyoupreferto;foralthoughontologicallanguageisinstinctiveinsuchmatters,yetBuddhistsorHumianscanperfectlywelldescribethefactsinthephenomenaltermswhicharetheirfavorites。Forthemthesoulisonlyasuccessionoffieldsofconsciousness:yetthereisfoundineachfieldapart,orsub-field,whichfiguresasfocalandcontainstheexcitement,andfromwhich,asfromacentre,theaimseemstobetaken。Talkingofthispart,weinvoluntarilyapplywordsofperspectivetodistinguishitfromtherest,wordslike“here。”
“this。”“now。”“mine。”or“me“;andweascribetotheotherpartsthepositions“there。”“then。”“that。”“his“or“thine。”“it。”
“notme。”Buta“here“canchangetoa“there。”anda“there“
becomea“here。”andwhatwas“mine“andwhatwas“notmine“
changetheirplaces。
Whatbringssuchchangesaboutisthewayinwhichemotionalexcitementalters。Thingshotandvitaltousto-dayarecoldto-morrow。Itisasifseenfromthehotpartsofthefieldthattheotherpartsappeartous,andfromthesehotpartspersonaldesireandvolitionmaketheirsallies。Theyareinshortthecentresofourdynamicenergy,whereasthecoldpartsleaveusindifferentandpassiveinproportiontotheircoldness。
Whethersuchlanguageberigorouslyexactisforthepresentofnoimportance。Itisexactenough,ifyourecognizefromyourownexperiencethefactswhichIseektodesignatebyit。
Nowtheremaybegreatoscillationintheemotionalinterest,andthehotplacesmayshiftbeforeonealmostasrapidlyasthesparksthatrunthroughburnt-uppaper。Thenwehavethewaveringanddividedselfweheardsomuchofinthepreviouslecture。Orthefocusofexcitementandheat,thepointofviewfromwhichtheaimistaken,maycometoliepermanentlywithinacertainsystem;andthen,ifthechangebeareligiousone,wecallitaCONVERSION,especiallyifitbebycrisis,orsudden。
Letushereafter,inspeakingofthehotplaceinaman’sconsciousness,thegroupofideastowhichhedevoteshimself,andfromwhichheworks,callitTHEHABITUALCENTREOFHIS
PERSONALENERGY。Itmakesagreatdifferencetoamanwhetheronesetofhisideas,oranother,bethecentreofhisenergy;
anditmakesagreatdifference,asregardsanysetofideaswhichhemaypossess,whethertheybecomecentralorremainperipheralinhim。Tosaythatamanis“converted“means,intheseterms,thatreligiousideas,previouslyperipheralinhisconsciousness,nowtakeacentralplace,andthatreligiousaimsformthehabitualcentreofhisenergy。
NowifyouaskofpsychologyjustHOWtheexcitementshiftsinaman’smentalsystem,andWHYaimsthatwereperipheralbecomeatacertainmomentcentral,psychologyhastoreplythatalthoughshecangiveageneraldescriptionofwhathappens,sheisunableinagivencasetoaccountaccuratelyforallthesingleforcesatwork。NeitheranoutsideobservernortheSubjectwhoundergoestheprocesscanexplainfullyhowparticularexperiencesareabletochangeone’scentreofenergysodecisively,orwhytheysooftenhavetobidetheirhourtodoso。Wehaveathought,orweperformanact,repeatedly,butonacertaindaytherealmeaningofthethoughtpealsthroughusforthefirsttime,ortheacthassuddenlyturnedintoamoralimpossibility。Allweknowisthattherearedeadfeelings,deadideas,andcoldbeliefs,andtherearehotandliveones;andwhenonegrowshotandalivewithinus,everythinghastore-crystallizeaboutit。Wemaysaythattheheatandlivelinessmeanonlythe“motorefficacy。”longdeferredbutnowoperative,oftheidea;butsuchtalkitselfisonlycircumlocution,forwhencethesuddenmotorefficacy?Andourexplanationsthengetsovagueandgeneralthatonerealizesallthemoretheintenseindividualityofthewholephenomenon。
Intheendwefallbackonthehackneyedsymbolismofamechanicalequilibrium。Amindisasystemofideas,eachwiththeexcitementitarouses,andwithtendenciesimpulsiveandinhibitive,whichmutuallycheckorreinforceoneanother。Thecollectionofideasaltersbysubtractionorbyadditioninthecourseofexperience,andthetendenciesalterastheorganismgetsmoreaged。Amentalsystemmaybeunderminedorweakenedbythisinterstitialalterationjustasabuildingis,andyetforatimekeepuprightbydeadhabit。Butanewperception,asuddenemotionalshock,oranoccasionwhichlaysbaretheorganicalteration,willmakethewholefabricfalltogether;andthenthecentreofgravitysinksintoanattitudemorestable,forthenewideasthatreachthecentreintherearrangementseemnowtobelockedthere,andthenewstructureremainspermanent。
Formedassociationsofideasandhabitsareusuallyfactorsofretardationinsuchchangesofequilibrium。Newinformation,howeveracquired,playsanacceleratingpartinthechanges;andtheslowmutationofourinstinctsandpropensities,underthe“unimaginabletouchoftime“hasanenormousinfluence。
Moreover,alltheseinfluencesmayworksubconsciouslyorhalfunconsciously。[99]AndwhenyougetaSubjectinwhomthesubconsciouslife——ofwhichImustspeakmorefullysoon——islargelydeveloped,andinwhommotiveshabituallyripeninsilence,yougetacaseofwhichyoucannevergiveafullaccount,andinwhich,bothtotheSubjectandtheonlookers,theremayappearanelementofmarvel。Emotionaloccasions,especiallyviolentones,areextremelypotentinprecipitatingmentalrearrangements。Thesuddenandexplosivewaysinwhichlove,jealousy,guilt,fear,remorse,orangercanseizeupononeareknowntoeverybody。[100]Hope,happiness,security,resolve,emotionscharacteristicofconversion,canbeequallyexplosive。
Andemotionsthatcomeinthisexplosivewayseldomleavethingsastheyfoundthem。
[99]Jouffroyisanexample:“Downthisslopeitwasthatmyintelligencehadglided,andlittlebylittleithadgotfarfromitsfirstfaith。Butthismelancholyrevolutionhadnottakenplaceinthebroaddaylightofmyconsciousness;toomanyscruples,toomanyguidesandsacredaffectionshadmadeitdreadfultome,sothatIwasfarfromavowingtomyselftheprogressithadmade。Ithadgoneoninsilence,byaninvoluntaryelaborationofwhichIwasnottheaccomplice;andalthoughIhadinrealitylongceasedtobeaChristian,yet,intheinnocenceofmyintention,Ishouldhaveshudderedtosuspectit,andthoughtitcalumnyhadIbeenaccusedofsuchafallingaway。”ThenfollowsJouffroy’saccountofhiscounter-conversion,quotedaboveonp。173。
[100]Onehardlyneedsexamples;butforlove,seep。176,note,forfear,p。161;forremorse,seeOthelloafterthemurder;
forangerseeLearafterCordelia’sfirstspeechtohim;forresolve,seep。175J。Fostercase。HereisapathologicalcaseinwhichGUILTwasthefeelingthatsuddenlyexploded:“OnenightIwasseizedonenteringbedwitharigor,suchasSwedenborgdescribesascomingoverhimwithasenseofholiness,butovermewithasenseofGUILT。DuringthatwholenightIlayundertheinfluenceoftherigor,andfromitsinceptionIfeltthatIwasunderthecurseofGod。Ihaveneverdoneoneactofdutyinmylife——sinsagainstGodandmanbeginningasfarasmymemorygoesback——awildcatinhumanshape。”
InhisrecentworkonthePsychologyofReligion,ProfessorStarbuckofCaliforniahasshownbyastatisticalinquiryhowcloselyparallelinitsmanifestationstheordinary“conversion“
whichoccursinyoungpeoplebroughtupinevangelicalcirclesistothatgrowthintoalargerspirituallifewhichisanormalphaseofadolescenceineveryclassofhumanbeings。Theageisthesame,fallingusuallybetweenfourteenandseventeen。Thesymptomsarethesame,——senseofincompletenessandimperfection;
brooding,depression,morbidintrospection,andsenseofsin;
anxietyaboutthehereafter;distressoverdoubts,andthelike。
Andtheresultisthesame——ahappyreliefandobjectivity,astheconfidenceinselfgetsgreaterthroughtheadjustmentofthefacultiestothewideroutlook。Inspontaneousreligiousawakening,apartfromrevivalisticexamples,andintheordinarystormandstressandmoulting-timeofadolescence,wealsomaymeetwithmysticalexperiences,astonishingthesubjectsbytheirsuddenness,justasinrevivalisticconversion。Theanalogy,infact,iscomplete;andStarbuck’sconclusionastotheseordinaryyouthfulconversionswouldseemtobetheonlysoundone:
Conversionisinitsessenceanormaladolescentphenomenon,incidentaltothepassagefromthechild’ssmalluniversetothewiderintellectualandspirituallifeofmaturity。