首页 >出版文学> Anarchism and Other Essays>第7章
  MaxHalbe’sJUGEND*andWedekind’sFRUHLING’SERWACHEN**aredramaswhichhavedisseminatedradicalthoughtinanaltogetherdifferentdirection。TheytreatofthechildandthedenseignoranceandnarrowPuritanismthatmeettheawakeningofnature。ParticularlythisistrueofFRUHLING’SERWACHEN。Youngboysandgirlssacrificedonthealtaroffalseeducationandofoursickeningmoralitythatprohibitstheenlightenmentofyouthastoquestionssoimperativetothehealthandwell-beingofsociety,——theoriginoflife,anditsfunctions。Itshowshowamother——andatrulygoodmother,atthat——keepsherfourteen-year-olddaughterinabsoluteignoranceastoallmattersofsex,andwhenfinallytheyounggirlfallsavictimtoherownignorance,thesamemotherseesherdaughterkilledbyquackmedicines。Theinscriptiononhergravestatesthatshediedofanaemia,andmoralityissatisfied——
  *YOUTH。
  **THEAWAKENINGOFSPRING——
  ThefatalityofourPuritanichypocrisyinthesemattersisespeciallyilluminedbyWedekindinsofarasourmostpromisingchildrenfallvictimstosexignoranceandtheutterlackofappreciationonthepartoftheteachersofthechild’sawakening。
  Wendla,unusuallydevelopedandalertforherage,pleadswithhermothertoexplainthemysteryoflife:
  "Ihaveasisterwhohasbeenmarriedfortwoandahalfyears。I
  myselfhavebeenmadeanauntforthethirdtime,andIhaven’ttheleastideahowitallcomesabout……Don’tbecross,Mother,dear!WhomintheworldshouldIaskbutyou?Don’tscoldmeforaskingaboutit。Givemeananswer——Howdoesithappen?——YoucannotreallydeceiveyourselfthatI,whoamfourteenyearsold,stillbelieveinthestork。"
  Werehermotherherselfnotavictimoffalsenotionsofmorality,anaffectionateandsensibleexplanationmighthavesavedherdaughter。
  Buttheconventionalmotherseekstohideher"moral"shameandembarrassmentinthisevasivereply:
  "Inordertohaveachild——onemustlove——theman——towhomoneismarried……Onemustlovehim,Wendla,asyouatyouragearestillunabletolove——Nowyouknowit!"
  HowmuchWendla"knew"themotherrealizedtoolate。Thepregnantgirlimaginesherselfillwithdropsy。Andwhenhermothercriesindesperation,"Youhaven’tthedropsy,youhaveachild,girl,"theagonizedWendlaexclaimsinbewilderment:"Butit’snotpossible,Mother,Iamnotmarriedyet……Oh,Mother,whydidn’tyoutellmeeverything?"
  WithequalstupiditytheboyMorrisisdriventosuicidebecausehefailsinhisschoolexaminations。AndMelchior,theyouthfulfatherofWendla’sunbornchild,issenttotheHouseofCorrection,hisearlysexualawakeningstampinghimadegenerateintheeyesofteachersandparents。
  ForyearsthoughtfulmenandwomeninGermanyhadadvocatedthecompellingnecessityofsexenlightenment。MUTTERSCHUTZ,apublicationspeciallydevotedtofrankandintelligentdiscussionofthesexproblem,hasbeencarryingonitsagitationforaconsiderabletime。ButitremainedforthedramaticgeniusofWedekindtoinfluenceradicalthoughttotheextentofforcingtheintroductionofsexphysiologyinmanyschoolsofGermany。
  Scandinavia,likeGermany,wasadvancedthroughthedramamuchmorethanthroughanyotherchannel。LongbeforeIbsenappearedonthescene,Bjornson,thegreatessayist,thunderedagainsttheinequalitiesandinjusticeprevalentinthosecountries。Buthiswasavoiceinthewilderness,reachingbutthefew。NotsowithIbsen。
  HisBRAND,DOLL’SHOUSE,PILLARSOFSOCIETY,GHOSTS,andANENEMYOF
  THEPEOPLEhaveconsiderablyunderminedtheoldconceptions,andreplacedthembyamodernandrealviewoflife。OnehasbuttoreadBRANDtorealizethemodernconception,letussay,ofreligion,——religion,asanidealtobeachievedonearth;religionasaprincipleofhumanbrotherhood,ofsolidarity,andkindness。
  Ibsen,thesupremehaterofallsocialshams,hastorntheveilofhypocrisyfromtheirfaces。Hisgreatestonslaught,however,isonthefourcardinalpointssupportingtheflimsynetworkofsociety。
  First,thelieuponwhichreststhelifeoftoday;second,thefutilityofsacrificeaspreachedbyourmoralcodes;third,pettymaterialconsideration,whichistheonlygodthemajorityworships;
  andfourth,thedeadeninginfluenceofprovincialism。ThesefourrecurastheLEITMOTIFinIbsen’splays,butparticularlyinPILLARS
  OFSOCIETY,DOLL’SHOUSE,GHOSTS,andANENEMYOFTHEPEOPLE。
  PillarsofSociety!Whatatremendousindictmentagainstthesocialstructurethatrestsonrottenanddecayedpillars,——pillarsnicelygildedandapparentlyintact,yetmerelyhidingtheirtruecondition。
  Andwhatarethesepillars?
  ConsulBernick,attheveryheightofhissocialandfinancialcareer,thebenefactorofhistownandthestrongestpillarofthecommunity,hasreachedthesummitthroughthechanneloflies,deception,andfraud。Hehasrobbedhisbosomfriend,Johann,ofhisgoodname,andhasbetrayedLonaHessel,thewomanheloved,tomarryherstep-sisterforthesakeofhermoney。Hehasenrichedhimselfbyshadytransactions,undercoverof"thecommunity’sgood,"andfinallyevengoestotheextentofendangeringhumanlifebypreparingtheINDIANGIRL,arottenanddangerousvessel,togotosea。
  ButthereturnofLonabringshimtherealizationoftheemptinessandmeannessofhisnarrowlife。Heseekstoplacatethewakingconsciencebythehopethathehasclearedthegroundforthebetterlifeofhisson,ofthenewgeneration。Buteventhislasthopesoonfallstotheground,asherealizesthattruthcannotbebuiltonalie。Attheverymomentwhenthewholetownispreparedtocelebratethegreatbenefactorofthecommunitywithbanquetpraise,hehimself,nowgrowntofullspiritualmanhood,confessestotheassembledtownspeople:
  "Ihavenorighttothishomage……Myfellow-citizensmustknowmetothecore。Thenleteveryoneexaminehimself,andletusrealizethepredictionthatfromthiseventwebeginanewtime。Theold,withitstinsel,itshypocrisy,itshollowness,itslyingpropriety,anditspitifulcowardice,shallliebehinduslikeamuseum,openforinstruction。"
  WithADOLL’SHOUSEIbsenhaspavedthewayforwoman’semancipation。
  Noraawakensfromherdoll’sroletotherealizationoftheinjusticedoneherbyherfatherandherhusband,HelmerTorvald。
  "WhileIwasathomewithfather,heusedtotellmeallhisopinions,andIheldthesameopinions。IfIhadothersIconcealedthem,becausehewouldnothaveapproved。Heusedtocallmehisdollchild,andplaywithmeasIplayedwithmydolls。ThenIcametoliveinyourhouse。Yousettledeverythingaccordingtoyourtaste,andIgotthesametasteasyou,orIpretendedto。WhenI
  lookbackonitnow,Iseemtohavebeenlivinglikeabeggar,fromhandtomouth。Ilivedbyperformingtricksforyou,Torvald,butyouwouldhaveitso。Youandfatherhavedonemeagreatwrong。"
  InvainHelmerusestheoldphilistineargumentsofwifelydutyandsocialobligations。Norahasgrownoutofherdoll’sdressintofullstatureofconsciouswomanhood。Sheisdeterminedtothinkandjudgeforherself。Shehasrealizedthat,beforeallelse,sheisahumanbeing,owingthefirstdutytoherself。Sheisundauntedevenbythepossibilityofsocialostracism。Shehasbecomescepticalofthejusticeofthelaw,thewisdomoftheconstituted。Herrebellingsoulrisesinprotestagainsttheexisting。Inherownwords:"I
  mustmakeupmymindwhichisright,societyorI。"
  Inherchildlikefaithinherhusbandshehadhopedforthegreatmiracle。Butitwasnotthedisappointedhopethatopenedhervisiontothefalsehoodsofmarriage。ItwasratherthesmugcontentmentofHelmerwithasafelie——onethatwouldremainhiddenandnotendangerhissocialstanding。
  WhenNoraclosedbehindherthedoorofhergildedcageandwentoutintotheworldanew,regeneratedpersonality,sheopenedthegateoffreedomandtruthforherownsexandtheracetocome。
  Morethananyotherplay,GHOSTShasactedlikeabombexplosion,shakingthesocialstructuretoitsveryfoundations。
  InDOLL’SHOUSEthejustificationoftheunionbetweenNoraandHelmerrestedatleastonthehusband’sconceptionofintegrityandrigidadherencetooursocialmorality。Indeed,hewastheconventionalidealhusbandanddevotedfather。NotsoinGHOSTS。
  Mrs。AlvingmarriedCaptainAlvingonlytofindthathewasaphysicalandmentalwreck,andthatlifewithhimwouldmeanutterdegradationandbefataltopossibleoffspring。Inherdespairsheturnedtoheryouth’scompanion,youngPastorManderswho,asthetruesaviorofsoulsforheaven,mustneedsbeindifferenttoearthlynecessities。Hesentherbacktoshameanddegradation,——toherdutiestohusbandandhome。Indeed,happiness——tohim——wasbuttheunholymanifestationofarebelliousspirit,andawife’sdutywasnottojudge,but"tobearwithhumilitythecrosswhichahigherpowerhadforyourowngoodlaiduponyou。"
  Mrs。Alvingborethecrossfortwenty-sixlongyears。Notforthesakeofthehigherpower,butforherlittlesonOswald,whomshelongedtosavefromthepoisonousatmosphereofherhusband’shome。
  Itwasalsoforthesakeofthebelovedsonthatshesupportedthelieofhisfather’sgoodness,insuperstitiousaweof"dutyanddecency。"Shelearned,alas!toolate,thatthesacrificeofherentirelifehadbeeninvain,andthathersonOswaldwasvisitedbythesinsofhisfather,thathewasirrevocablydoomed。This,too,shelearned,that"weareallofusghosts。Itisnotonlywhatwehaveinheritedfromourfatherandmotherthatwalksinus。Itisallsortsofdeadideasandlifelessoldbeliefs。Theyhavenovitality,buttheyclingtousallthesameandwecan’tgetridofthem……Andthenweare,oneandall,sopitifullyafraidoflight。WhenyouforcedmeundertheyokeyoucalledDutyandObligation;whenyoupraisedasrightandproperwhatmywholesoulrebelledagainstassomethingloathsome;itwasthenthatIbegantolookintotheseamsofyourdoctrine。Ionlywishedtopickatasingleknot,butwhenIhadgotthatundone,thewholethingravelledout。AndthenIunderstoodthatitwasallmachine-sewn。"
  Howcouldasocietymachine-sewn,fathomtheseethingdepthswhenceissuedthegreatmasterpieceofHenrikIbsen?Itcouldnotunderstand,andthereforeitpouredthevialsofabuseandvenomuponitsgreatestbenefactor。ThatIbsenwasnotdauntedhehasprovedbyhisreplyinANENEMYOFTHEPEOPLE。
  InthatgreatdramaIbsenperformsthelastfuneralritesoveradecayinganddyingsocialsystem。Outofitsashesrisestheregeneratedindividual,theboldanddaringrebel。Dr。Stockman,anidealist,fullofsocialsympathyandsolidarity,iscalledtohisnativetownasthephysicianofthebaths。Hesoondiscoversthatthelatterarebuiltonaswamp,andthatinsteadoffindingreliefthepatients,whoflocktotheplace,arebeingpoisoned。
  Anhonestman,ofstrongconvictions,thedoctorconsidersithisdutytomakehisdiscoveryknown。Buthesoonlearnsthatdividendsandprofitsareconcernedneitherwithhealthnorprinciples。Eventhereformersofthetown,representedinthePEOPLE’SMESSENGER,alwaysreadytoprateoftheirdevotiontothepeople,withdrawtheirsupportfromthe"reckless"idealist,themomenttheylearnthatthedoctor’sdiscoverymaybringthetownintodisrepute,andthusinjuretheirpockets。
  ButDoctorStockmancontinuesinthefaithheentertainsforhastownsmen。Theywouldhearhim。Buthere,too,hesoonfindshimselfalone。Hecannotevensecureaplacetoproclaimhisgreattruth。
  Andwhenhefinallysucceeds,heisoverwhelmedbyabuseandridiculeastheenemyofthepeople。Thedoctor,soenthusiasticofhistownspeople’sassistancetoeradicatetheevil,issoondriventoasolitaryposition。Theannouncementofhisdiscoverywouldresultinapecuniarylosstothetown,andthatconsiderationinducestheofficials,thegoodcitizens,andsoulreformers,tostiflethevoiceoftruth。Hefindsthemallacompactmajority,unscrupulousenoughtobewillingtobuilduptheprosperityofthetownonaquagmireofliesandfraud。Heisaccusedoftryingtoruinthecommunity。Buttohismind"itdoesnotmatterifalyingcommunityisruined。Itmustbelevelledtotheground。Allmenwholiveuponliesmustbeexterminatedlikevermin。You’llbringittosuchapassthatthewholecountrywilldeservetoperish。"
  DoctorStockmanisnotapracticalpolitician。Afreeman,hethinks,mustnotbehavelikeablackguard。"Hemustnotsoactthathewouldspitinhisownface。"Foronlycowardspermit"considerations"ofpretendedgeneralwelfareorofpartytooverridetruthandideals。"Partyprogrammeswringthenecksofallyoung,livingtruths;andconsiderationsofexpediencyturnmoralityandrighteousnessupsidedown,untillifeissimplyhideous。"
  TheseplaysofIbsen——THEPILLARSOFSOCIETY,ADOLL’SHOUSE,GHOSTS,andANENEMYOFTHEPEOPLE——constituteadynamicforcewhichisgraduallydissipatingtheghostswalkingthesocialburyinggroundcalledcivilization。Nay,more;Ibsen’sdestructiveeffectsareatthesametimesupremelyconstructive,forhenotmerelyunderminesexistingpillars;indeed,hebuildswithsurestrokesthefoundationofahealthier,idealfuture,basedonthesovereigntyoftheindividualwithinasympatheticsocialenvironment。
  Englandwithhergreatpioneersofradicalthought,theintellectualpilgrimslikeGodwin,RobertOwen,Darwin,Spencer,WilliamMorris,andscoresofothers;withherwonderfullarksofliberty——Shelley,Byron,Keats——isanotherexampleoftheinfluenceofdramaticart。
  Withincomparativelyafewyears,thedramaticworksofShaw,Pinero,Galsworthy,RannKennedy,havecarriedradicalthoughttotheearsformerlydeafeventoGreatBritain’swondrouspoets。ThusapublicwhichwillremainindifferentreadinganessaybyRobertOwen,onPoverty,orignoreBernardShaw’sSocialistictracts,wasmadetothinkbyMAJORBARBARA,whereinpovertyisdescribedasthegreatestcrimeofChristiancivilization。"Povertymakespeopleweak,slavish,puny;povertycreatesdisease,crime,prostitution;infine,povertyisresponsibleforalltheillsandevilsoftheworld。"
  Povertyalsonecessitatesdependency,charitableorganizations,institutionsthatthriveofftheverythingtheyaretryingtodestroy。TheSalvationArmy,forinstance,asshowninMAJOR
  BARBARA,fightsdrunkenness;yetoneofitsgreatestcontributorsisBadger,awhiskeydistiller,whofurnishesyearlythousandsofpoundstodoawaywiththeverysourceofhiswealth。BernardShaw,therefore,concludesthattheonlyrealbenefactorofsocietyisamanlikeUndershaft,Barbara’sfather,acannonmanufacturer,whosetheoryoflifeisthatpowderisstrongerthanwords。
  "Theworstofcrimes,"saysUndershaft,"ispoverty。Alltheothercrimesarevirtuesbesideit;alltheotherdishonorsarechivalryitselfbycomparison。Povertyblightswholecities;spreadshorriblepestilences;strikesdeadtheverysoulofallwhocomewithinsight,sound,orsmellofit。Whatyoucallcrimeisnothing;amurderhere,atheftthere,ablownowandacursethere:whatdotheymatter?Theyareonlytheaccidentsandillnessesoflife;therearenotfiftygenuineprofessionalcriminalsinLondon。Buttherearemillionsofpoorpeople,abjectpeople,dirtypeople,ill-fed,ill-clothedpeople。Theypoisonusmorallyandphysically;theykillthehappinessofsociety;theyforceustodoawaywithourownlibertiesandtoorganizeunnaturalcrueltiesforfeartheyshouldriseagainstusanddragusdownintotheirabyss……Povertyandslaveryhavestoodupforcenturiestoyoursermonsandleadingarticles;theywillnotstanduptomymachineguns。Don’tpreachatthem;don’treasonwiththem。Killthem……Itisthefinaltestofconviction,theonlyleverstrongenoughtooverturnasocialsystem……Vote!Bah!Whenyouvote,youonlychangethenameofthecabinet。Whenyoushoot,youpulldowngovernments,inauguratenewepochs,abolisholdorders,andsetupnew。"
  NowonderpeoplecaredlittletoreadMr。Shaw’sSocialistictracts。
  Innootherwaybutinthedramacouldhedeliversuchforcible,historictruths。AndthereforeitisonlythroughthedramathatMr。
  Shawisarevolutionaryfactorinthedisseminationofradicalideas。
  AfterHauptmann’sDIEWEBER,STRIFE,byGalsworthy,isthemostimportantlabordrama。
  ThethemeofSTRIFEisastrikewithtwodominantfactors:Anthony,thepresidentofthecompany,rigid,uncompromising,unwillingtomaketheslightestconcession,althoughthemenheldoutformonthsandareinaconditionofsemi-starvation;andDavidRoberts,anuncompromisingrevolutionist,whosedevotiontotheworkingmanandthecauseoffreedomisatwhiteheat。Betweenthemthestrikersarewornandwearywiththeterriblestruggle,andareharassedanddrivenbytheawfulsightofpovertyandwantintheirfamilies。
  ThemostmarvellousandbrilliantpieceofworkinSTRIFEisGalsworthy’sportrayalofthemob,itsfickleness,andlackofbackbone。OnemomenttheyapplaudoldThomas,whospeaksofthepowerofGodandreligionandadmonishesthemenagainstrebellion;
  thenextinstanttheyarecarriedawaybyawalkingdelegate,whopleadsthecauseoftheunion,——theunionthatalwaysstandsforcompromise,andwhichforsakestheworkingmenwhenevertheydaretostrikeforindependentdemands;againtheyareaglowwiththeearnestness,thespirit,andtheintensityofDavidRoberts——allthesepeoplewillingtogoinwhateverdirectionthewindblows。Itisthecurseoftheworkingclassthattheyalwaysfollowlikesheepledtoslaughter。
  Consistencyisthegreatestcrimeofourcommercialage。Nomatterhowintensethespiritorhowimportanttheman,themomenthewillnotallowhimselftobeusedorsellhisprinciples,heisthrownonthedustheap。Suchwasthefateofthepresidentofthecompany,Anthony,andofDavidRoberts。Tobesuretheyrepresentedoppositepoles——polesantagonistictoeachother,polesdividedbyaterriblegapthatcanneverbebridgedover。Yettheysharedacommonfate。
  Anthonyistheembodimentofconservatism,ofoldideas,ofironmethods:
  "Ihavebeenchairmanofthiscompanythirty-twoyears。Ihavefoughtthemenfourtimes。Ihaveneverbeendefeated。Ithasbeensaidthattimeshavechanged。Iftheyhave,Ihavenotchangedwiththem。Ithasbeensaidthatmastersandmenareequal。Cant。Therecanbeonlyonemasterinahouse。IthasbeensaidthatCapitalandLaborhavethesameinterests。Cant。Theirinterestsareaswideasunderasthepoles。Thereisonlyonewayoftreatingmen——withtheironrod。Mastersaremasters。Menaremen。"
  Wemaynotlikethisadherencetoold,reactionarynotions,andyetthereissomethingadmirableinthecourageandconsistencyofthisman,norishehalfasdangeroustotheinterestsoftheoppressed,asoursentimentalandsoftreformerswhorobwithninefingers,andgivelibrarieswiththetenth;whogrindhumanbeingslikeRussellSage,andthenspendmillionsofdollarsinsocialresearchwork;whoturnbeautifulyoungplantsintofadedoldwomen,andthengivethemafewpaltrydollarsorfoundaHomeforWorkingGirls。Anthonyisaworthyfoe;andtofightsuchafoe,onemustlearntomeethiminopenbattle。
  DavidRobertshasallthementalandmoralattributesofhisadversary,coupledwiththespiritofrevolt,andthedepthofmodernideas。He,too,isconsistent,andwantsnothingforhisclassshortofcompletevictory。
  "Itisnotforthislittlemomentoftimewearefighting,notforourownlittlebodiesandtheirwarmth;itisforallthosewhocomeafter,foralltimes。Oh,men,fortheloveofthemdon’tturnupanotherstoneontheirheads,don’thelptoblackenthesky。Ifwecanshakethatwhite-facedmonsterwiththebloodylipsthathassuckedthelivesoutofourselves,ourwives,andchildren,sincetheworldbegan,ifwehavenottheheartsofmentostandagainstit,breasttobreastandeyetoeye,andforceitbackwardtillitcryformercy,itwillgoonsuckinglife,andweshallstayforeverwhereweare,lessthantheverydogs。"
  Itisinevitablethatcompromiseandpettyinterestshouldpassonandleavetwosuchgiantsbehind。Inevitable,untilthemasswillreachthestatureofaDavidRoberts。Willitever?Prophecyisnotthevocationofthedramatist,yetthemorallessonisevident。Onecannothelprealizingthattheworkingmenwillhavetousemethodshithertounfamiliartothem;thattheywillhavetodiscardallthoseelementsintheirmidstthatareforeverreadytoreconciletheirreconcilable,namelyCapitalandLabor。TheywillhavetolearnthatcharacterslikeDavidRobertsaretheveryforcesthathaverevolutionizedtheworldandthuspavedthewayforemancipationoutoftheclutchesofthat"white-facedmonsterwithbloodylips,"
  towardsabrighterhorizon,afreerlife,andadeeperrecognitionofhumanvalues。
  Nosubjectofequalsocialimporthasreceivedsuchextensiveconsiderationwithinthelastfewyearsasthequestionofprisonandpunishment。
  Hardlyanymagazineofconsequencethathasnotdevoteditscolumnstothediscussionofthisvitaltheme。Anumberofbooksbyablewriters,bothinAmericaandabroad,havediscussedthistopicfromthehistoric,psychologic,andsocialstandpoint,allagreeingthatpresentpenalinstitutionsandourmodeofcopingwithcrimehaveineveryrespectprovedinadequateaswellaswasteful。Onewouldexpectthatsomethingveryradicalshouldresultfromthecumulativeliteraryindictmentofthesocialcrimesperpetratedupontheprisoner。Yetwiththeexceptionofafewminorandcomparativelyinsignificantreformsinsomeofourprisons,absolutelynothinghasbeenaccomplished。ButatlastthisgravesocialwronghasfounddramaticinterpretationinGalworthy’sJUSTICE。
  TheplayopensintheofficeofJamesHowandSons,Solicitors。Theseniorclerk,RobertCokeson,discoversthatacheckhehadissuedforninepoundshasbeenforgedtoninety。Byelimination,suspicionfallsuponWilliamFalder,thejuniorofficeclerk。Thelatterisinlovewithamarriedwoman,theabused,ill-treatedwifeofabrutaldrunkard。Pressedbyhisemployer,asevereyetnotunkindlyman,Falderconfessestheforgery,pleadingthedirenecessityofhissweetheart,RuthHoneywill,withwhomhehadplannedtoescapetosaveherfromtheunbearablebrutalityofherhusband。
  NotwithstandingtheentreatiesofyoungWalter,whoistouchedbymodernideas,hisfather,amoralandlaw-respectingcitizen,turnsFalderovertothepolice。
  Thesecondact,inthecourt-room,showsJusticeintheveryprocessofmanufacture。ThesceneequalsindramaticpowerandpsychologicveritythegreatcourtsceneinRESURRECTION。YoungFalder,anervousandratherweaklyyouthoftwenty-three,standsbeforethebar。Ruth,hismarriedsweetheart,fullofloveanddevotion,burnswithanxietytosavetheyoungmanwhoseaffectionbroughtabouthispresentpredicament。TheyoungmanisdefendedbyLawyerFrome,whosespeechtothejuryisamasterpieceofdeepsocialphilosophywreathedwiththetendrilsofhumanunderstandingandsympathy。HedoesnotattempttodisputethemerefactofFalderhavingalteredthecheck;andthoughhepleadstemporaryaberrationindefenseofhisclient,thatpleaisbaseduponasocialconsciousnessasdeepandall-embracingastherootsofoursocialills——"thebackgroundoflife,thatpalpitatinglifewhichalwaysliesbehindthecommissionofacrime。"HeshowsFaldertohavefacedthealternativeofseeingthebelovedwomanmurderedbyherbrutalhusband,whomshecannotdivorce;oroftakingthelawintohisownhands。Thedefencepleadswiththejurynottoturntheweakyoungmanintoacriminalbycondemninghimtoprison,for"justiceisamachinethat,whensomeonehasgivenitastartingpush,rollsonofitself……Isthisyoungmantobegroundtopiecesunderthismachineforanactwhich,attheworst,wasoneofweakness?Ishetobecomeamemberofthelucklesscrewsthatmanthosedark,ill-starredshipscalledprisons?……Iurgeyou,gentlemen,donotruinthisyoungman。
  Forasaresultofthosefourminutes,ruin,utterandirretrievable,stareshimintheface……TherollingofthechariotwheelsofJusticeoverthisboybeganwhenitwasdecidedtoprosecutehim。"
  ButthechariotofJusticerollsmercilesslyon,for——asthelearnedJudgesays——"thelawiswhatitis——amajesticedifice,shelteringallofus,eachstoneofwhichrestsonanother。"
  Falderissentencedtothreeyears’penalservitude。
  Inprison,theyoung,inexperiencedconvictsoonfindshimselfthevictimoftheterrible"system。"TheauthoritiesadmitthatyoungFalderismentallyandphysically"inbadshape,"butnothingcanbedoneinthematter:manyothersareinasimilarposition,and"thequartersareinadequate。"
  Thethirdsceneofthethirdactisheart-grippinginitssilentforce。Thewholesceneisapantomime,takingplaceinFalder’sprisoncell。
  "Infast-fallingdaylight,Falder,inhisstockings,isseenstandingmotionless,withhisheadinclinedtowardsthedoor,listening。Hemovesalittleclosertothedoor,hisstockingedfeetmakingnonoise。Hestopsatthedoor。Heistryingharderandhardertohearsomething,anylittlethingthatisgoingonoutside。Hespringssuddenlyupright——asifatasound——andremainsperfectlymotionless。
  Then,withaheavysigh,hemovestohiswork,andstandslookingatit,withhisheaddown;hedoesastitchortwo,havingtheairofamansolostinsadnessthateachstitchis,asitwere,acomingtolife。Then,turningabruptly,hebeginspacinghiscell,movinghishead,likeananimalpacingitscage。Hestopsagainatthedoor,listens,and,placingthepalmsofhishandsagainstitwithhisfingersspreadout,leanshisforeheadagainsttheiron。Turningfromit,presently,hemovesslowlybacktowardsthewindow,holdinghishead,asifhefeltthatitweregoingtoburst,andstopsunderthewindow。Butsincehecannotseeoutofitheleavesofflooking,and,pickingupthelidofoneofthetins,peersintoit,asiftryingtomakeacompanionofhisownface。Ithasgrownverynearlydark。Suddenlythelidfallsoutofhishandwithaclatter——theonlysoundthathasbrokenthesilence——andhestandsstaringintentlyatthewallwherethestuffoftheshirtishangingratherwhiteinthedarkness——heseemstobeseeingsomebodyorsomethingthere。Thereisasharptapandclick;thecelllightbehindtheglassscreenhasbeenturnedup。Thecellisbrightlylighted。
  Falderisseengaspingforbreath。
  Asoundfromfaraway,asofdistant,dullbeatingonthickmetal,issuddenlyaudible。Faldershrinksback,notabletobearthissuddenclamor。Butthesoundgrows,asthoughsomegreattumbrilwererollingtowardsthecell。Andgraduallyitseemstohypnotizehim。
  Hebeginscreepinginchbyinchnearertothedoor。Thebangingsound,travelingfromcelltocell,drawscloserandcloser;Falder’shandsareseenmovingasifhisspirithadalreadyjoinedinthisbeating,andthesoundswellstillitseemstohaveenteredtheverycell。Hesuddenlyraiseshisclenchedfists。Pantingviolently,heflingshimselfathisdoor,andbeatsonit。"
  FinallyFalderleavestheprison,abrokenticket-of-leaveman,thestampoftheconvictuponhisbrow,theironofmiseryinhissoul。
  ThankstoRuth’spleading,thefirmofJamesHowandSoniswillingtotakeFalderbackintheiremploy,onconditionthathegiveupRuth。ItisthenthatFalderlearnstheawfulnewsthatthewomanheloveshadbeendrivenbythemercilesseconomicMolochtosellherself。She"triedmakingskirts……cheapthings……Inevermademorethantenshillingsaweek,buyingmyowncotton,andworkingallday。Ihardlyevergottobedtillpasttwelve……
  Andthen……myemployerhappened——he’shappenedeversince。"Atthisterriblepsychologicmomentthepoliceappeartodraghimbacktoprisonforfailingtoreporthimselfasticket-of-leaveman。
  Completelyoverwhelmedbytheinexorabilityofhisenvironment,youngFalderseeksandfindspeace,greaterthanhumanjustice,bythrowinghimselfdowntodeath,asthedetectivesaretakinghimbacktoprison。
  Itwouldbeimpossibletoestimatetheeffectproducedbythisplay。
  PerhapssomeconceptioncanbegainedfromtheveryunusualcircumstancethatithadprovedsopowerfulastoinducetheHomeSecretaryofGreatBritaintoundertakeextensiveprisonreformsinEngland。Averyencouragingsignthis,oftheinfluenceexertedbythemoderndrama。ItistobehopedthatthethunderingindictmentofMr。GalsworthywillnotremainwithoutsimilareffectuponthepublicsentimentandprisonconditionsofAmerica。Atanyrate,itiscertainthatnoothermodernplayhasbornesuchdirectandimmediatefruitinwakeningthesocialconscience。
  Anothermodernplay,THESERVANTINTHEHOUSE,strikesavitalkeyinoursociallife。TheheroofMr。Kennedy’smasterpieceisRobert,acoarse,filthydrunkard,whomrespectablesocietyhasrepudiated。
  Robert,thesewercleaner,istherealherooftheplay;nay,itstrueandonlysavior。Itishewhovolunteerstogodownintothedangeroussewer,sothathiscomrades"can’avelightandair。"
  Afterall,hashenotsacrificedhislifealways,sothatothersmayhavelightandair?
  Thethoughtthatlaboristheredeemerofsocialwell-beinghasbeencriedfromthehousetopsineverytongueandeveryclime。YetthesimplewordsofRobertexpressthesignificanceoflaboranditsmissionwithfargreaterpotency。
  Americaisstillinitsdramaticinfancy。Mostoftheattemptsalongthislinetomirrorlife,havebeenwretchedfailures。Still,therearehopefulsignsintheattitudeoftheintelligentpublictowardmodernplays,eveniftheybefromforeignsoil。
  TheonlyrealdramaAmericahassofarproducedisTHEEASIESTWAY,byEugeneWalter。
  Itissupposedtorepresenta"peculiarphase"ofNewYorklife。Ifthatwereall,itwouldbeofminorsignificance。Thatwhichgivestheplayitsrealimportanceandvalueliesmuchdeeper。Itlies,first,inthefundamentalcurrentofoursocialfabricwhichdrivesusall,evenstrongercharactersthanLaura,intotheeasiestway——awaysoverydestructiveofintegrity,truth,andjustice。Secondly,thecruel,senselessfatalismconditionedinLaura’ssex。Thesetwofeaturesputtheuniversalstampupontheplay,andcharacterizeitasoneofthestrongestdramaticindictmentsagainstsociety。
  Thecriminalwasteofhumanenergy,ineconomicandsocialconditions,drivesLauraasitdrivestheaveragegirltomarryanymanfora"home";orasitdrivesmentoenduretheworstindignitiesforamiserablepittance。
  Thenthereisthatotherrespectableinstitution,thefatalismofLaura’ssex。Theinevitabilityofthatforceissummedupinthefollowingwords:"Don’tyouknowthatwecountnomoreinthelifeofthesementhantamedanimals?It’sagame,andifwedon’tplayourcardswell,welose。"Womaninthebattlewithlifehasbutoneweapon,onecommodity——sex。Thataloneservesasatrumpcardinthegameoflife。
  Thisblindfatalismhasmadeofwomanaparasite,aninertthing。
  WhythenexpectperseveranceorenergyofLaura?Theeasiestwayisthepathmappedoutforherfromtimeimmemorial。Shecouldfollownoother。
  Anumberofotherplayscouldbequotedascharacteristicofthegrowingroleofthedramaasadisseminatorofradicalthought。
  SufficetomentionTHETHIRDDEGREE,byCharlesKlein;THEFOURTH
  ESTATE,byMedillPatterson;AMAN’SWORLD,byIdaCroutchers,——allpointingtothedawnofdramaticartinAmerica,anartwhichisdiscoveringtothepeopletheterriblediseasesofoursocialbody。
  Ithasbeensaidofold,allroadsleadtoRome。Inparaphrasedapplicationtothetendenciesofourday,itmaytrulybesaidthatallroadsleadtothegreatsocialreconstruction。Theeconomicawakeningoftheworkingman,andhisrealizationofthenecessityforconcertedindustrialaction;thetendenciesofmoderneducation,especiallyintheirapplicationtothefreedevelopmentofthechild;
  thespiritofgrowingunrestexpressedthrough,andcultivatedby,artandliterature,allpavethewaytotheOpenRoad。Aboveall,themoderndrama,operatingthroughthedoublechannelofdramatistandinterpreter,affectingasitdoesbothmindandheart,isthestrongestforceindevelopingsocialdiscontent,swellingthepowerfultideofunrestthatsweepsonwardandoverthedamofignorance,prejudice,andsuperstition。
  End